Background and Need for Legislation
Following U.S. acquisition, American Samoa was placed under the U.S. Navy's administrative authority until 1951 when the authority was transferred to the Department of the Interior (DOI) in 1956 through Executive Order 10264.\1\ The Department of the Interior's Office of Insular Affairs (OIA) coordinates political relations with American Samoa and other U.S. territories (except Puerto Rico, which falls under the Executive Office of the President).\2\ American Samoa has a local (territorial) constitution; however, Congress has not enacted an Organic Act for the territory. American Samoa's constitution is unique in that it seeks to preserve Samoan cultural identity and way of life, particularly on land ownership, Samoa's ``Maitai'' social hierarchy, and immigration.\3\ Furthermore, American Samoa does not have an Organic Act due to concerns within American Samoa that it would erode the Samoan way of life.\4\ The Secretary of the Interior retains broad administrative authority over American Samoa, including over its constitutional amendment process. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\E.O. 10264. https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/ codification/executive-order/10264.html. \2\Memorandum for the Heads of Executive Departments and Agencies. 57 Fed. Reg. 57093. \3\For more information on American Samoa's culture and relationship with the U.S. Constitution, refer to Defining Status--A Comprehensive Analysis of U.S. Territorial Policy. Arnold H. Leibowitz. 2013. \4\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In 1983, Congress passed, and the President signed into law Public Law 98-213. Section 12 of the law stated that any changes to the Constitution of American Samoa may be made only by an Act of Congress.\5\ Prior to 1983, only the approval of the Secretary of the Interior was required for constitutional amendments.\6\ The legislative history concerning Section 12 suggests that a personnel dispute embodying self-government concerns motivated Congress to enact the provision. There were concerns within American Samoa about the then-Assistant Secretary of the Interior, acting on behalf of the Secretary of the Interior, making a unilateral decision to remove the incumbent Attorney General of American Samoa.\7\ Changing federal law ensured that the Secretary of the Interior could not make unilateral appointments of American Samoa's cabinet and removed the possibility of unilateral amendment to the Constitution by the Secretary of the Interior.\8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\Office of Rep. Eni Faleomavaega, ``Faleomavaega Announces a Draft Bill to Repeal Congressional Approval for Amendments to the American Samoa Constitution,'' press release, February 10, 2012, https://www.webharvest.gov/congress112th/20121215060831/http:/ www.house.gov/list/press/as00_faleomavaega/appealfofolaw.html. \6\48 U.S.C. Sec. 1662a. \7\U.S. Congress, Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Subcommittee on Energy Conservation and Supply, Revised Constitution of American Samoa, hearing, 98th Cong., 2nd sess., May 8, 1984, S. Hrg. 98-997 (Washington: GPO, 1984), pp. 3-4. Rep. Sunia's written statement appears in all capital letters. The quoted material is reformatted to comport with CRS style. \8\Legal Authority Supporting DOI and Congressional Approval or Disapproval of Amendments to the Constitution of American Samoa. Jon Van Dyke. University of Hawaii School of Law Library. Jon Van Dyke Archives Collection. https://scholarspace.manoa.hawaii.edu/server/api/ core/bitstreams/159c73b2-1b50-407a-b59e-8e757fb03ba4/content. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Debate over Section 12 continued in 1984, both in Congress and in American Samoa, even though the provision became law in late 1983. In May 1984, the same Senate subcommittee that had overseen Section 12's development again received testimony about the provision. On that occasion, Section 12 discussions arose amid consideration of constitutional amendments proposed in 1984, after a territorial convention.\9\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\U.S. Congress, Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Subcommittee on Energy Conservation and Supply, Revised Constitution of American Samoa, hearing, 98th Cong., 2nd sess., May 8, 1984, S. Hrg. 98-997 (Washington: GPO, 1984). https://republicans- naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/ Hearing_Revised_Constitution_of_American_ Samoa.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Since 1984, American Samoa has made attempts to return to the pre-1983 policy where the Secretary of the Interior has the sole authority to approve changes to the American Samoan Constitution as there were no longer concerns about unilateral actions by the Department of the Interior. Concerns have been raised within American Samoa and personnel at the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) about whether Section 12 could adversely affect American Samoan culture. In a May 8, 1984, Senate Energy and Natural Resources hearing, the DOJ witness stated: I feel constrained to bring to your attention a case now pending in the Supreme Court of the United States on petition for a writ of certiorari. This case raises the seemingly paradoxical possibility that the very Congressional approval of the Samoan Constitution, in particular of those provisions which might be inconsistent with the Constitution of the United States, could facilitate scrutiny and possible invalidation of Samoan institutions by the federal courts under our own Constitution.\10\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \10\U.S. Congress, Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Subcommittee on Energy Conservation and Supply, Revised Constitution of American Samoa, hearing, 98th Cong., 2nd sess., May 8, 1984, S. Hrg. 98-997 (Washington: GPO, 1984). See ``Statement of Robert B. Shanks, Deputy Assistant Attorney General, Office of Legal Counsel, Department of Justice.'' https://republicans- naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/ Hearing_Revised_Constitution_of_ American_Samoa.pdf. Furthermore, concerns have been raised within American Samoa that Section 12 has stalled the approval of all amendments to the Constitution of American Samoa and has created an inequitable amendment process for American Samoa when compared to the other U.S. territories. Of the other U.S. territories with a local constitution, American Samoa is the only territory that must go through Congress to institute changes voted by their own citizens.\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \11\Commonwealth of Northern Mariana Islands. Constitution. https:/ /cnmilaw.org/cons.php#gsc.tab=0 and Puerto Rico Law. https:// law.justia.com/puerto-rico/ #::text=Article%20Seven%20provides%20the%20process,abolish%20the%20Bill %20of%20Rights. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- H.R. 6062 would repeal Section 12 of Public Law 98-213, granting the President of the United States, and subsequently the Secretary of the Interior, the power to approve amendments to the Constitution of American Samoa without Congressional approval. Congress would still retain its authority to regulate the territories, including the authority to make any changes to the Constitution of American Samoa, provided under the Territories Clause of the U.S. Constitution. The Territorial Clause of the U.S. Constitution grants Congress broad authority over U.S. territories. Specifically, Article IV, Section 3 of the Constitution states, in part, that ``The Congress shall have Power to dispose of and make all needful Rules and Regulations respecting the Territory or other Property belonging to the United States.''\12\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\``Article 4 Section 3 Clause 2.'' U.S. Constitution Annotated. https://constitution. congress.gov/browse/article-4/section-3/clause-2/. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------