Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 8649]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and the Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 8649) to ensure that parents are aware
of foreign influence in their child's public school, and for
other purposes, having considered the same, reports favorably
thereon with an amendment and recommends that the bill as
amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Transparency in Reporting of
Adversarial Contributions to Education Act''.
SEC. 2. PARENTS' RIGHT TO KNOW ABOUT FOREIGN INFLUENCE.
(a) In General.--Subpart 2 of part F of title VIII of the Elementary
and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 7901 et seq.) is amended
by adding at the end the following:
``SEC. 8549D. PARENTS' RIGHT TO KNOW ABOUT FOREIGN INFLUENCE.
``(a) In General.--As a condition of receiving funds under this Act,
a local educational agency shall ensure that each elementary school and
each secondary school served by such agency provides to each parent of
a child attending the school, at a minimum--
``(1) the right (in a manner consistent with copyright law)
to review, and make copies of free of cost, at least every four
weeks and not later than 30 days after submission of a written
request by the parent, any curricular material or professional
development material used at the school that was purchased, or
otherwise obtained, using funds received from the government of
a foreign country or a foreign entity of concern;
``(2) the right to know, by written response provided not
later than 30 days after submission of a written request by the
parent, how many personnel of the school are compensated, in
whole or in part, using funds received from the government of a
foreign country or a foreign entity of concern; and
``(3) the right to know, by written response provided not
later than 30 days after submission of a written request by the
parent, of--
``(A) any donation received by the school or local
educational agency from a foreign country or a foreign
entity of concern;
``(B) any agreement in writing (such as a contract or
memorandum of understanding) between the school or
local educational agency and a foreign country or a
foreign entity of concern; and
``(C) any financial transaction between the school or
local educational agency and a foreign country or a
foreign entity of concern.
``(b) Donations, Agreements, and Financial Transactions.--The
information described in subsection (a)(3) shall include, at minimum,
the following:
``(1) The name of the foreign country or foreign entity of
concern.
``(2) In any case in which funds were received by the school
or local educational agency from a foreign country or a foreign
entity of concern--
``(A) the amount of such funds; and
``(B) any terms or conditions applicable to the
receipt of such funds.
``(c) Notice of Rights.--At the beginning of each school year, a
local educational agency receiving funds under this Act shall ensure
that each elementary school and each secondary school served by such
agency posts on a publicly accessible website of the school or, if the
school does not operate a website, widely disseminates to the public, a
summary notice of the rights of parents described in subsections (a)
and (b).
``(d) Notification of Requirements.--At the beginning of each school
year, the Secretary shall notify State educational agencies about the
requirements of this section. As a condition of receiving funds under
this Act, State educational agencies shall, at the beginning of each
school year, notify local educational agencies of the requirements of
this section.
``(e) Definitions.--In this section:
``(1) The term `foreign country' means a foreign country or a
dependent territory or possession of a foreign country. Such
term does not include any of the outlying areas.
``(2) The term `foreign entity of concern' has the meaning
given such term in section 10612(a) of the Research and
Development, Competition, and Innovation Act (42 U.S.C.
19221(a)).''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents in section 2 of the
Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 is amended by inserting
after the item relating to section 8549C the following:
``Sec. 8549D. Parents' right to know about foreign influence.''.
Purpose
The purpose of H.R. 8649, the Transparency in Reporting of
Adversarial Contributions to Education (TRACE) Act, is to help
ensure that parents are aware of any foreign government's
influence in their child's school and that parents can review
any curriculum provided by a foreign government.
Committee Action
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On September 19, 2023, the Committee's Subcommittee on
Early Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education held a
hearing on ``Academic Freedom Under Attack: Loosening the CCP's
Grip on America's Classrooms.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to examine the covert influence of foreign governments and
organizations, particularly the Chinese Communist Party, on
U.S. K-12 schools. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Mr.
Michael Gonzalez, Senior Fellow, Heritage Foundation,
Washington, DC; Ms. Gisela Perez Kusakawa, Executive Director,
Asian American Scholar Forum, New York, NY; Mrs. Nicole Neily,
President, Parents Defending Education, Arlington, VA; Mr. Ryan
Walters, State Superintendent of Public Instruction, Oklahoma
State Department of Education, Oklahoma City, OK.
Second Session--Hearings
On May 8, 2024, the Committee's Subcommittee on Early
Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education held a hearing
on ``Confronting Pervasive Antisemitism in K-12 Schools.'' The
purpose of the hearing was to discuss the proliferation of
antisemitism in K-12 schools. During the hearing, Committee
Chairwoman Virginia Foxx (R-NC) asked New York City Chancellor
David Banks if foreign governments donate significant funding
to NYC Public Schools. Chancellor Banks stated that the Qatar
Foundation did, and he followed up after the hearing and
confirmed that the Italian government and the Consulate General
of the Republic of Korea contributed funding to NYC K-12
schools. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Mr. David
Banks, Chancellor, New York City Public Schools, New York City,
NY; Ms. Karla Silvestre, President, Montgomery County Board of
Education, Montgomery County Public Schools, Rockville, MD; Mr.
Emerson Sykes, Senior Staff Attorney, American Civil Liberties
Union, New York, NY; Ms. Enikia Ford Morthel, Superintendent,
Berkeley Unified School District, Berkeley, CA.
Legislative Action
On June 7, 2024, Representative Aaron Bean (R-FL)
introduced H.R. 8649, the Transparency in Reporting of
Adversarial Contributions to Education (TRACE) Act. The bill
was referred solely to the Committee on Education and the
Workforce. On June 13, 2024, the Committee considered H.R. 8649
in legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended,
to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 23-16.
The Committee considered the following amendments to H.R. 8649:
1. Representative Bean offered an amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute that clarifies LEAs must respond
to parent inquires in writing within 30 days. The
amendment was adopted by a recorded vote of 23-16.
2. Representative Bobby Scott (D-VA) offered an
amendment that authorizes $300 million per year
starting in fiscal year 2025. The amendment failed by a
recorded vote of 16-23.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
Over the last decade, the Chinese Communist Party has
infiltrated American K-12 schools through grants, sister school
partnerships, and other programming through an unassuming
program called Confucius Classrooms, a trojan horse for China's
propaganda.
CHINA'S ACTIVITY IN U.S. K-12 SCHOOLS
The Chinese government's effort to forge ties with American
schools is one facet of the Chinese Communist Party's (CCP)
broader soft-power strategy to influence policy in nations
throughout the world. The United States Senate Permanent
Subcommittee on Investigations found that expanding Confucius
Classrooms in the United States has been a top priority for the
Chinese government.\1\ Many K-12 schools eagerly accepted CCP-
linked grants, which came with perks including fully funded
teacher exchanges, Chinese language programs, and opportunities
for American students to learn in China.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\China's Impact on the U.S. Education System--Permanent
Subcommittee on Investigations.
\2\Little Red Classrooms--Parents Defending Education.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Confucius Classrooms are smaller-scale, K-12 versions of
Confucius Institutes which the CCP has pushed for on U.S.
college campuses. Confucius Institutes are established as
partnerships between a host institution, a Chinese partner
(usually a Chinese university), and a Chinese government
agency. China's Ministry of Education Office of Chinese
Language Council International funds each Confucius Institute,
often at around $100,000 per year, and asks host institutions
to match those funds with their own contributions.
Confucius Institute funding comes with strings attached
that compromise academic freedom. The Chinese government
approves teachers, events, and speakers and requires teachers
to sign contracts pledging they will not damage the national
interests of China. The contracts make clear a Chinese director
or teacher will be terminated if they ``violate Chinese laws''
or ``engage in activities detrimental to national interests''
and states that they must ``conscientiously safeguard national
interests.''\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Microsoft Word--20190227 Chinas Impact on the US Education
System (senate.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many K-12 Confucius Classrooms developed as offshoots of
university-based Confucius Institutes. China strategically
deployed and rapidly expanded their Confucius Classrooms, going
from very few in 2008 to more than a thousand worldwide by
2017. More than 500 American K-12 schools have hosted Confucius
Classrooms, aided in part by the Asia Society, an American
nonprofit that previously ran a network of 100 Confucius
Classrooms before they ended the partnership in 2021.\4\ A
Parents Defending Education report tracked Chinese affiliation
in 143 schools across 34 states--with at least seven still
active today.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Schools: Confucius Classrooms Network Online (asiasociety.org).
\5\Little Red Classrooms--Parents Defending Education.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
OTHER COUNTRIES' INFLUENCE IN U.S. K-12 SCHOOLS
While it appears that no other country has a program
similar in scope and size to the CCP's propaganda campaign in
American schools, other countries have also invested in
language and cultural educational programs in American K-12
schools.
One notable example is Qatar. The Qatar Foundation, along
with its subsidiaries like Qatar Foundation International and
the Qatar National Research Fund, have been actively involved
in influencing American K-12 education through financial
partnerships with individual schools.\6\ From 2009 to 2017, the
Qatar Foundation allocated $30.6 million to various schools
across 12 U.S. states. The funds are predominantly directed
towards facilitating Arabic language programs, and they cover
expenses for teacher education, materials, and salaries. These
contributions have taken various forms, from direct funds to
professional development initiatives, such as teacher councils
and language conferences. Additionally, there are instances of
school districts, like the Tucson Unified School District and
New Haven Public Schools, receiving substantial grants over
multiple years.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\FARA_Memo_with_Exhibits_R-1.pdf (freebeacon.com).
\7\FARA_Memo_with_Exhibits_R-1.pdf (freebeacon.com).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other countries have also made notable donations to U.S. K-
12 schools. After the May 8 subcommittee hearing on
antisemitism in K-12 schools, New York City Public Schools
Chancellor David Banks informed Committee staff that the
Italian-American Committee on Education, which is connected to
the Italian government, contributed $257,000 to New York City
Public Schools in 2021-24. Chancellor Banks also reported that
the Consulate General of the Republic of Korea in New York
contributed $16,000 to support Korean instruction and
programming in New York City Public Schools. It is unclear the
extent to which these foreign ties had been publicized prior to
the Committee's request for information.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Documentation emailed from New York City Public Schools to
Committee staff on May 22, 2024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONCLUSION
It is unacceptable that foreign adversaries such as the CCP
is attempting to influence U.S. K-12 schools. Congress should
take immediate action to ensure that students are not being
indoctrinated with communist propaganda. Congress should also
take action to ensure that parents have the right to review and
know of all curricula purchased or provided by a foreign
country. This bill will help ensure that the Chinese government
does not take advantage of local school districts and that
parents have the right to be fully informed of what is
happening in their child's schools.
Summary
On June 7, 2024, Representative Bean introduced H.R. 8649,
the Transparency in Reporting of Adversarial Contributions to
Education (TRACE) Act. The bill requires that, as a condition
of receiving funds under the Elementary and Secondary Education
Act, a local educational agency must ensure that public schools
provide each parent the right to review any curricular material
provided or purchased with funds from a foreign government or
foreign entity of concern. The bill also guarantees parents the
right to know how many personnel at their child's school are
compensated by foreign sources and about any donations or
financial transactions between the school and a foreign
government or foreign entity of concern.
H.R. 8649 SECTION-BY-SECTION SUMMARY
Section 1--Short title
Names the bill the Transparency in Reporting of
Adversarial Contributions to Education Act.
Section 2--Parents' right to know about foreign influence
The bill requires that, as a condition of
receiving federal financial assistance under any program under
the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, a local educational
agency shall ensure that each elementary and secondary school
served by the district provides each parent of a child
attending the schools the following rights:
The right to review any curricular
material or professional development material purchased
using funds from a foreign government or foreign entity
of concern.
The right to know how many personnel of
the school are compensated by a foreign government or
foreign entity of concern.
The right to know of any donation or
agreement in writing between the school or local
educational agency and a foreign country or foreign
entity of concern.
Explanation of Amendments
The amendments, including the amendment in the nature of a
substitute, are explained in the body of this report.
Application of Law to the Legislative Branch
Section 102(b)(3) of Public Law 104-1 requires a
description of the application of this bill to the legislative
branch. H.R. 8649 ensures that parents are notified of foreign
influence in their child's public school. H.R. 8649 is
applicable to federally funded elementary and secondary
schools, and therefore does not apply to the Legislative
Branch.
Unfunded Mandate Statement
Pursuant to Section 423 of the Congressional Budget and
Impoundment Control Act of 1974, Pub. L. No. 93-344 (as amended
by Section 101(a)(2) of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of
1995, Pub. L. No. 104-4), the Committee adopts as its own the
estimate of mandates prepared by the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office (CBO).
Earmark Statement
H.R. 8649 does not contain any congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in
clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the House of
Representatives.
Roll Call Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee Report to include for
each record vote on a motion to report the measure or matter
and on any amendments offered to the measure or matter the
total number of votes for and against and the names of the
Members voting for and against.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
In accordance with clause (3)(c) of House rule XIII, the
goal of H.R. 8649 is to give parents the right to know about
foreign influences in their child's public school.
Duplication of Federal Programs
No provision of H.R. 8649 establishes or reauthorizes a
program of the Federal Government known to be duplicative of
another Federal program, a program that was included in any
report from the Government Accountability Office to Congress
pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139, or a program
related to a program identified in the most recent Catalog of
Federal Domestic Assistance.
Statement of Oversight Findings and Recommendations of
the Committee
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII and clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
the committee's oversight findings and recommendations are
reflected in the body of this report.
Required Committee Hearing and Related Hearings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII the
following hearing held during the 118th Congress was used to
develop or consider H.R. 8649: On September 19, 2023, the
Committee's Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and
Secondary Education held a hearing on ``Academic Freedom Under
Attack: Loosening the CCP's Grip on America's Classrooms.''
New Budget Authority and CBO Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and with respect
to requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives and section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee adopts as its
own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Legislation Summary: On June 13, 2024, the House Committee
on Education and the Workforce ordered to be reported eight
bills and one joint resolution. This document provides
estimates for seven of those bills and the resolution.
Generally, the legislation would:
Repeal a rule submitted by the Department of
Education relating to ``Nondiscrimination on the Basis
of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving
Federal Financial Assistance;''
Allow nurse practitioners and physician
assistants to diagnose, treat, and certify an injury
and extent of disability for the purposes of federal
workers' compensation;
Require elementary and secondary schools and
institutions of higher education to meet new
requirements in order to maintain eligibility for
funding from the Department of Education;
Prevent student athletes from being
considered the employees of an institution of higher
education; and
Authorize appropriations for the educational
activities of the United States Holocaust Memorial
Museum.
Estimated Federal cost: The estimated costs of the
legislation fall within budget function 500 (education,
training, employment, and social services).
Basis of estimate: For this estimate, CBO assumes that the
legislation will be enacted near the end of fiscal year 2024.
The estimated costs do not include any interaction effects
among the pieces of legislation. If all seven bills and the
resolution were combined and enacted as a single piece of
legislation, the estimated costs could be different than the
sum of the separate estimates, although CBO expects that any
difference would be small.
CBO estimates that implementing H.R. 8606 would cost $8
million over the 2024-2029 period. Implementing the remaining
bills and the joint resolution would each cost less than
$500,000 over the same period. Any related spending would be
subject to the availability of appropriated funds.
H.J. Res. 165, a joint resolution providing for
Congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United
States Code, of the rule submitted by the Department of
Education relating to ``Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex
in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial
Assistance'': H.J. Res 165 would disapprove the rule submitted
by the Department of Education relating to ``Nondiscrimination
on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities
Receiving Federal Financial Assistance,'' as published in the
Federal Register on April 29, 2024.
The rule amends title IX of the Education Amendments of
1972 (title IX), which prohibits discrimination on the basis of
sex in any education program or activity receiving federal
financial assistance. The rule clarifies definitions related to
sex-based discrimination and harassment and specifies the
requirements for grievance procedures, and requirements for
preventing sexual discrimination and remedying its effects.
Institutions that fail to comply with title IX, as amended
by the rule, could lose federal funding. However, CBO expects
that institutions will comply with the regulations to avoid
doing so. On that basis, CBO estimates that disapproving the
rule would not affect institutions' eligibility for federal
student aid.
Based on the costs of similar activities, CBO estimates
that implementing the resolution would cost less than $500,000
over the 2024-2029 period. Any related spending would be
subject to the availability of appropriated funds.
H.R. 618, Improving Access to Workers' Compensation for
Injured Federal Workers Act: H.R. 618 would allow nurse
practitioners and physician assistants to diagnose, prescribe
treatment, and certify an injury and the extent of disability
for the purpose of compensating federal workers under the
Federal Employees' Compensation Act (FECA). Using information
from the Department of Labor, CBO expects that nonphysician
providers would be compensated at the same rate as physicians
and that total benefits provided to injured federal workers
would not significantly change. Some people may receive
treatment more quickly under the bill, which could increase
costs over the 10-year period because some payments to medical
providers that would have occurred in 2035 under current law
could be paid in 2034. On the other hand, if injured workers
receive treatment faster, some may return to work more quickly,
which could reduce costs. CBO has no basis to estimate which
effect would predominate, but we expect that t
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 8649, the Transparency in Reporting of Adversarial
Contributions to Education Act, requires local educational
agencies (LEAs) and individual schools to provide parents with
the opportunity to: (1) access curriculum and staff
professional development materials provided by a government of
a foreign country (foreign government) or foreign entity of
concern; (2) know how many school staff have been paid, in
whole or part, by a foreign government or foreign entity of
concern; and (3) know of any donation to, written agreement
with, or financial transaction between the school or LEA and a
foreign government or foreign entity of concern and related
details.\1\ The Majority claims the bill ``solidifies the
rights of parents to know how foreign funding is impacting
their child's classroom and adds a layer of deterrence to keep
foreign nations from reaching America's youth.''\2\ Yet, the
Majority has not proven any local school system has allowed
foreign influence to exist in elementary and secondary public
schools. Instead, the bill would feed into baseless claims
encompassed in the Majority's self-created culture wars and
raises a number of administrative questions and concerns for
public schools.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Transparency in Reporting of Adversarial Contributions to
Education Act, H.R. 8649, 118th Cong. (2024).
\2\Press Release, Rep. Aaron Bean, Congressman Bean Safeguards K-12
Schools from Foreign Adversaries (June 10, 2024), https://
bean.house.gov/media/press-releases/icymi-congressman-bean-safeguards-
k-12-schools-foreign-adversaries.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY OF CONCERNS
H.R. 8649 Claims to Provide Parents with Rights, But in Reality
Feeds into Culture Wars
While the Majority claims a desire to provide parents with
information on foreign governments and foreign entities of
concern allegedly impacting their students' education, H.R.
8649 is another attempt to feed into culture wars. Earlier this
Congress, the House passed H.R. 5, the Parents Bill of Rights
Act, which the Majority claimed would ``put in place concrete
legal protections that will ensure parents always have a seat
at the table when it comes to their child's education.''\3\
But, as pointed out in the Minority Views accompanying that
bill to the House floor, the Majority ignored the fact that the
bill was ``largely duplicative of current law, lacks clarity in
how its provisions will actually address students well-being,
and stands as an example of the type federal overreach
Congressional Republicans have long claimed would harm
children, teachers and schools.''\4\ It is worth noting that
pursuant to a law that already applies to entities that receive
U.S. Department of Education funding and awards, parents
currently have the right to inspect instructional materials
pertaining to their child's classes.\5\ But H.R. 8649 permits
parents to inspect and copy--at unlimited cost to the school--
any instructional materials or professional development
materials that the school purchased or obtained using funds
from a foreign government or foreign entity of concern.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Press Release, Rep. Julia Letlow, Letlow Introduces Parents Bill
of Rights (Mar. 1, 2023), https://letlow.house.gov/media/press-
releases/letlow-reintroduces-parents-bill-rights.
\4\H.R. Rep. No. 118-9, at 48 (2023), https://www.congress.gov/
congressional-report/118th-
congress/house-report/9/1?s=5&r=1&q=%7B%22search%22%3A%22hr+5%22%7D.
\5\20 U.S.C. Sec. 1232h.
\6\This significantly broadens the information that parents may
access beyond information pertaining to their own child under GEPA. In
addition, even with that expansion, as written, the bill does not
include the right to inspect and copy donated materials for which funds
were not used.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Foreign influence has not posed a threat to K-12 classrooms
The Majority claims H.R. 8649 is necessary because
``foreign adversaries . . . are systematically and aggressively
attempting to influence our nation's elementary and secondary
schools''\7\. But the most common example of foreign influence
in schools that the Majority cites are Confucius Classrooms.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Press Release, Rep. Aaron Bean, supra note 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chinese influence has not posed a threat to Elementary and Secondary
classrooms
Confucius Classrooms, which are affiliated with Confucious
Institutes, are centers for Chinese culture and language
established at public and private elementary and secondary
schools--either to bolster a Chinese program already at the
school or to start a new one.\8\ Over nearly five years, the
number of Classrooms has dropped from more than 500 to
currently no more than 16.\9\ Many countries around the world
lack quality Chinese language and culture resources and
Confucious Institutes and Classrooms provide those resources
for free.\10\ Experts have summed up the current state of these
programs, saying ``[t]he harsh reality is that Confucius
Institutes/Confucius Classrooms stepped up to fulfill a need
that governments were not--and they were happy to accept a
`freebie,' . . . Now that Confucius Institutes have been
tainted by wider distaste and suspicion of the Chinese
government, this `freebie' now has a cost.''\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\China's Impact on the U.S. Education System: Hearing Before the
Subcomm. on Investigations of the S. Comm. on Homeland Security &
Governmental Affairs, 116th Cong., 90,147 (2019).
\9\Confucius Institutes Around the World--2024, Dig Mandarin (Mar.
20, 2024) https://www.digmandarin.com/confucius-institutes-around-the-
world.html; Beth Wallis, Tulsa Public Schools ended Chinese language
program weeks before Oklahoma Superintendent's Congressional testimony,
National Public Radio KOSU (Sept. 29, 2023) https://www.kosu.org/
education/2023-
09-29/tulsa-public-schools-ended-chinese-language-program-weeks-before-
oklahoma-superintendents-congressional-testimony; Little Red Classrooms
China's Infiltration of American K-12 Schools, Defending Ed. (Jul. 26 ,
2023). https://defendinged.org/investigations/little-red-classrooms-
china-infiltration-of-american-K-12-schools/.
\10\Lin Yang, Controversial Confucius Institutes Returning to U.S.
Schools Under New Name, VOA News, (June 27, 2022). https://
www.voanews.com/a/controversial-confucius-institutes-
returning-to-u-s-schools-under-new-name/6635906.html.
\11\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Parents Defending Education (PDE), a right-wing non-profit
organization, published a report in July 2023 entitled,
``Little Red Classrooms: China's Infiltration of American K-12
Schools.'' The report alleges undue Chinese influence in
America through the existence of Confucius Institutes,
Classrooms, and related ``programming'' that currently exists
or previously existed in public schools across the United
States, including in areas near U.S. military bases.\12\
Despite the claims in the report, Committee Democratic staff
have been unable to locate credible evidence to support either
the claims made by the Majority's and PDE's that there is
inappropriate and undue foreign influence in our nation's K-12
public schools. In 2019, the Senate Committee on Homeland
Security and Governmental Affairs' Permanent Subcommittee on
Investigations held a hearing entitled ``China's Impact on the
U.S. Education System''. The hearing was held the day after the
Committee released a bipartisan staff report with the same
title.\13\ While the staff report made recommendations that
schools should ensure that Chinese partnership organization's
``vetting, screening and interview processes are aligned with
their own hiring protocols and procedures''\14\ and that ``the
State Department should demand reciprocal and fair treatments
of its diplomats and employees in China.''\15\ the Committee
did not find security risks or curriculum vulnerability, as
claimed by the Majority.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Little Red Classrooms China's Infiltration of American K-12
Schools, Defending Ed. (Jul. 26, 2023) https://defendinged.org/
investigations/little-red-classrooms-china-infiltration-of-
american-K-12-schools/.
\13\China's Impact on the U.S. Education System, supra note 8.
\14\Id. at 91.
\15\Id. at 92.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 8649 Includes Severe Penalties for Public School Systems
Failure to comply with the requirements of H.R. 8649 could
cause public school systems and states to lose their funding
from the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA),
including the Title I-A program. Specifically, the bill
conditions receipt of ESEA program funds on meeting the
requirements of the bill. Each LEA is responsible for making
sure that each school in the LEA posts or disseminates
information about these rights at the beginning of every school
year. It also requires state educational agencies (SEAs) to
notify LEAs of these requirements at the beginning of every
school year. By conditioning ESEA funds to LEAs and SEAs on
meeting the requirements in the bill, H.R. 8649 contains severe
penalties for districts and states that fail to implement the
requirements of the bill correctly, whether intentional or
accidental.
H.R. 8649 Raises Significant Administrative Concerns for Public
Schools
As written, H.R. 8649 will cause confusion for public
schools as they seek to follow the law. With respect to staff
compensation, it is unclear whether the bill only applies to
staff compensation that is provided by the school using funds
the school received from a foreign government or foreign entity
of concern or if it applies, for instance, to a volunteer
compensated directly by a foreign government or foreign entity
of concern without a school's knowledge. Further, while the
obligation to provide information about donations, agreements,
or financial transactions rests with the school, schools are
often not aware of donations, agreements, or financial
transactions made at the LEA level, and the bill does not
require LEAs to share that information with schools.
Additionally, the bill does not provide a clear definition
for ``foreign country.'' This sets a dangerous precedent by
leaving it to LEAs and schools to decide what constitutes a
foreign country and inviting them to engage in international
diplomacy. It is also unclear in what instances an LEA or
school will need to determine whether there is any involvement
by a foreign government or a ``foreign entity of concern''. The
bill is also silent as to how to make such a determination, or
how to assess whether any entity the LEA or school works with--
U.S. or otherwise--has substantial operations in another
country. Learning how to assess and make these determinations
and ensure that anyone authorized to spend money is aware of
the requirements in the bill will require significant training,
professional development, and cost. Moreover, it is unclear
whether every contract (new and existing) for food, tutoring,
textbooks, janitorial services, trash collection, recycling,
etc. would need to undergo such examination. The bill is also
not specific about whether such an examination to ensure
compliance would need to focus on each individual employee or
only key decision-makers at the entity providing services.
Finally, it is worth pointing out that H.R. 8649 could have
a chilling effect on SEAs, LEAs, and schools engaging in
international and cultural exchange opportunities because they
often require some coordination with foreign governments
(through U.S. consulates).
DEMOCRATIC AMENDMENT OFFERED DURING MARKUP OF H.R. 8649
Ranking Member Bobby Scott (D-VA) put forward an amendment
to provide funds to assist with the administrative burden of
complying with the bill. Significant effort may need to be
expended to investigate existing and new contracts, to
determine whether existing or potential business partners are
foreign governments or ``foreign entities of concern'', to
create and maintain systems to keep track of all the new
information and respond to inquiries and to train staff in each
school on the ways to report to be in compliance with the bill.
This amendment authorizes $300 million for fiscal year 2025 and
each subsequent fiscal year to carry out the requirements in
the bill.\16\ Committee Republicans rejected this amendment on
a party-line vote.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\According to the National Center for Education Statistics in
the Institute of Education Sciences at the U.S. Department of
Education, there were 99,388 public elementary and secondary schools
for the 2022-2023 school year. NCES, Digest of Education Statistics
tbl. 216.10 (2023), https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d23/tables/
dt23_216.10.asp. Three hundred million dollars would provide $3000 per
year to each of those schools to offset the costs of compliance. In
reality, the administrative burden this bill poses could easily require
a full time administrative staff person at each school. Providing a
modest salary of $50,000 to each of those schools for such a position
would cost approximately 5 billion dollars.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONCLUSION
H.R. 8649 is a solution in search of a problem. While the
Majority claims that some foreign countries seek to influence
our nation's students, there is no credible evidence proving
such a claim. Yet, they use the bill to feed into baseless
arguments that parents do not have rights. Additionally, the
bill raises a number of administrative questions and concerns
for public schools. For the reasons stated above, we urge the
House of Representatives to oppose H.R. 8649.
Robert C. ``Bobby'' Scott,
Ranking Member.
Gregorio Kilili Camacho Sablan,
Suzanne Bonamici,
Mark Takano,
Mark DeSaulnier,
Pramila Jayapal,
Members of Congress.
[all]