Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 8998] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for the Department of the Interior, the Environmental Protection Agency, and Related Agencies for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2025. INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT Page number Bill Report Title I--Department of the Interior........................ 2 16 Title II--Environmental Protection Agency.................. 86 63 Title III--Related Agencies................................ 112 80 Department of Agriculture.......................... 112 80 Department of Health and Human Services............ 132 92 Council on Environmental Quality and Office of Environmental Quality.......................... 144 99 Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board..... 144 100 Office of Navajo and Hopi Indian Relocation........ 145 100 Institute of American Indian and Alaska Native Culture and Arts Development................... 146 101 Smithsonian Institution............................ 147 101 National Gallery of Art............................ 149 102 John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts..... 151 102 Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars... 152 103 National Endowment for the Arts.................... 152 103 National Endowment for the Humanities.............. 152 104 Commission of Fine Arts............................ 154 106 National Capital Arts and Cultural Affairs......... 155 106 Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.......... 155 107 National Capital Planning Commission............... 155 107 United States Holocaust Memorial Museum............ 155 107 United States Semiquincentennial Commission........ 156 108 Title IV--General Provisions............................... 157 109 House of Representatives Reporting Requirements.... 122 HIGHLIGHTS OF THE BILL The Interior, Environment, and Related Agencies Subcommittee has jurisdiction over a diverse group of agencies responsible for managing Federal lands and national parks, protecting the environment, reinforcing the Federal commitments to honor our trust and treaty responsibilities to American Indians and Alaska Natives, and supporting the arts and humanities. The activities of these agencies are integral to the operations of our government. The bill provides a total of $38,478,000,000 in discretionary budget authority for fiscal year 2025 which is $72,000,000 below the fiscal year 2024 level and $4,407,332,000 below the President's budget request. The bill also rescinds $55,000,000 of Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) funds for the National Park Service that have been designated for the Presidio Trust. Within the level of funding provided, the bill fully funds the Payments in Lieu of Taxes (PILT) program and prioritizes funding for Tribes and Wildland Fire Management, including permanently addressing wildland firefighter pay. The bill provides $2,812,709,000 for the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), which is $356,074,000 or nearly 15 percent above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level. Within this funding, the bill prioritizes Public Safety and Justice activities by providing an additional $190,477,000--or 34 percent increase-- above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level. The bill also provides $1,469,083,000 for the Bureau of Indian Education (BIE) and $8,561,647,000 for the Indian Health Service (IHS) in funding available in fiscal year 2025. In addition, the bill provides a fiscal year 2026 advance appropriations of $5,975,175,000 for the Indian Health Service. The bill provides a $176,696,000 discretionary increase for the Wildland Fire Management accounts at the Department of the Interior and the U.S. Forest Service, which includes over $330,000,000 to support a permanent pay fix and job series for Federal wildland firefighters. The bill funds base fire suppression resources consistent with the Stephen Sepp Wildfire Suppression Funding and Forest Management Activities Act instead of as an emergency, as was proposed in the President's budget request. In order to fund these priorities at necessary levels, the Committee has reduced funding for the majority of accounts in the bill. This includes a $1,788,779,000 or 20 percent reduction to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) below the fiscal year 2024 level. In addition to limiting spending, the bill includes several provisions to rein in the activities of the Administration. For example, the bill continues language from previous years to: Prohibit funds for EPA to impose mandatory reporting of greenhouse gas emissions from manure management systems. Prohibit funds to regulate the lead content of ammunition or fishing tackle under the Toxic Substances Control Act or any other act. Prohibit funds for EPA to implement permitting requirements for livestock emissions under the Clean Air Act. Require the Administration to implement policies that reflect the carbon neutrality of forest biomass. Restrict funding for acquisition of lands or interests in lands from being used for declarations of taking or complaints in condemnation. Prohibit funds for computer networks unless it blocks access to pornography. Require the use of American iron and steel in EPA safe drinking water projects. And the bill adds new provisions to: Block restrictions on hunting, fishing, and recreational shooting on Federal lands. Require the Secretary of the Interior to issue 5-year offshore oil and gas leasing programs on time; conduct lease sales in the Central Gulf of Mexico Planning Area, the Western Gulf of Mexico Planning Area, and in the Alaska region; and conduct Lease Sale 262. Reinstate leases for critical minerals. Block EPA's car regulations on light, medium, and heavy-duty vehicles. Provide continued access to our public lands by blocking the Bureau of Land Management's ``Conservation and Landscape Health'' rule and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's ``National Wildlife Refuge System; Biological Integrity, Diversity, and Environmental Health'' (BIDEH) rule. Ensure that ancillary mining activities, including exploration operations and construction of a mine access road, are permitted with or without the discovery of a valuable mineral deposit (Rosemont decision). Improve forest management by addressing the Cottonwood Environmental Law Center v. United States Forest Service decision. Prohibit funds to consider the social cost of carbon. Clarify pesticide labeling. REPROGRAMMING GUIDELINES The following are the procedures governing reprogramming actions for programs and activities funded in the Department of the Interior, Environment, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act. The agencies funded in this Act are reminded that these reprogramming guidelines are in effect, and must be complied with. Definitions.--``Reprogramming'' as defined in these procedures, includes the reallocation of funds from one budget activity, budget line-item, or program area to another within any appropriation funded in this Act. For construction, land acquisition, and forest legacy accounts, a reprogramming constitutes the reallocation of funds, including unobligated balances, from one construction, land acquisition, or forest legacy project to another such project. A reprogramming shall also consist of any significant departure from the program described in the agency's budget justifications. This includes all proposed reorganizations or other workforce actions detailed below which affect a total of 10 staff members or 10 percent of the staffing of an affected program or office, whichever is less, even without a change in funding. Any change to the organization table presented in the budget justification shall also be subject to this requirement. Agencies are reminded that this bill continues longstanding General Guidelines for Reprogramming that require agencies funded by this Act to submit reorganization proposals for the Committees' review prior to their implementation. It is noted that such reprogramming guidelines apply to proposed reorganizations, workforce restructure, reshaping, transfer of functions, or bureau-wide downsizing and include closures, consolidations, and relocations of offices, facilities, and laboratories. In addition, no agency shall implement any part of a reorganization that modifies regional or State boundaries for agencies or bureaus that were in effect as of the date of enactment of this Act unless approved, consistent with the General Guidelines for Reprogramming procedures specified herein. Any such reprogramming request submitted to the Committee shall include a description of anticipated benefits, including anticipated efficiencies and cost-savings, as well as a description of anticipated personnel impacts and funding changes anticipated to implement the proposal. General Guidelines for Reprogramming.-- (a) A reprogramming should be made only when an unforeseen situation arises, and then only if postponement of the project or the activity until the next appropriation year would result in actual loss or damage. (b) Any project or activity, which may be deferred through reprogramming, shall not later be accomplished by means of further reprogramming, but instead, funds should again be sought for the deferred project or activity through the regular appropriations process. (c) Except under the most urgent situations, reprogramming should not be employed to initiate new programs or increase allocations specifically denied or limited by Congress, or to decrease allocations specifically increased by the Congress. (d) Reprogramming proposals submitted to the Committee for approval will be considered as expeditiously as possible, and the Committee remind the agencies that in order to process reprogramming requests, adequate and timely information must be provided. Criteria and Exceptions.--A reprogramming must be submitted to the Committee in writing prior to implementation if it exceeds $1,000,000 annually or results in an increase or decrease of more than 10 percent annually in affected programs or projects, whichever amount is less, with the following exceptions: (a) With regard to the Tribal priority allocations of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) and Bureau of Indian Education (BIE), there is no restriction on reprogrammings among these programs. However, the Bureaus shall report on all reprogrammings made during a given fiscal year no later than 60 days after the end of the fiscal year. (b) With regard to the EPA, the Committee does not require reprogramming requests associated with the States and Tribes Partnership Grants or up to a cumulative total of $5,000,000 from carryover balances among the individual program areas delineated in the Environmental Programs and Management account, with no more than $1,000,000 coming from any individual program area. No funds, however, shall be reallocated from individual Geographic Programs. (c) With regard to the National Park Service (NPS), the Committee does not require reprogramming requests associated with the park base within the Park Management activity in the Operation of the National Park System Account. The NPS is required to brief the Committee on spending trends for the park base not later than 60 days following the enactment of this Act. Assessments.--``Assessment'' as defined in these procedures shall refer to any charges, reserves, or holdbacks applied to a budget activity or budget line-item for costs associated with general agency administrative costs, overhead costs, working capital expenses, or contingencies. (a) No assessment shall be levied against any program, budget activity, subactivity, budget line- item, or project funded by the Interior, Environment, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act unless such assessment and the basis therefore are presented to the Committee in the budget justifications and are subsequently approved by the Committee. The explanation for any assessment in the budget justification shall show the amount of the assessment, the activities assessed, and the purpose of the funds. (b) Proposed changes to estimated assessments, as such estimates were presented in annual budget justifications, shall be submitted through the reprogramming process and shall be subject to the same dollar and reporting criteria as any other reprogramming. (c) Each agency or bureau which utilizes assessments shall submit an annual report to the Committee, which provides details on the use of all funds assessed from any other budget activity, line-item, subactivity, or project. (d) In no case shall contingency funds or assessments be used to finance projects and activities disapproved or limited by Congress or to finance programs or activities that could be foreseen and included in the normal budget review process. (e) New programs requested in the budget should not be initiated before enactment of the bill without notification to, and the approval of, the Committee. This restriction applies to all such actions regardless of whether a formal reprogramming of funds is required to begin the program. Quarterly Reports.--All reprogrammings between budget activities, budget line-items, program areas, or the more detailed activity levels shown in this bill, including those below the monetary thresholds established above, shall be reported to the Committee within 60 days of the end of each quarter and shall include cumulative totals for each budget activity or budget line-item, or construction, land acquisition, or forest legacy project. Legacy.--Lands shall not be acquired for more than the approved appraised value, as addressed in section 301(3) of Public Law 91- 646, unless such acquisitions are submitted to the Committee for approval in compliance with these procedures. Land Exchanges.--Land exchanges, wherein the estimated value of the Federal lands to be exchanged is greater than $1,000,000, shall not be consummated until the Committee has had 30 days in which to examine the proposed exchange. In addition, the Committee shall be provided advance notification of exchanges valued between $500,000 and $1,000,000. Budget Structure.--The budget activity or line-item structure for any agency appropriation account shall not be altered without advance approval of the Committee. OTHER COMMITTEE DIRECTION Access to Hardrock Minerals.--The United States is increasingly reliant upon foreign sources for many of the raw materials needed for our economic and national security. Additionally, the share of global investments in U.S. mining projects has dropped precipitously in the last two decades. Misguided goals by this Administration to conserve 30 percent of the nation's land and waters by 2030 adds to regulatory uncertainty for new mining claims and discoveries. Therefore, the Committee supports continued access to our nation's public lands to obtain important raw materials, especially in areas of moderate-to-high mineral potential that will yield resources that are increasingly essential to our U.S. manufacturers and critical to our energy and national security sectors. Additionally, the Committee emphasizes that any recommendations made by the Interagency Working Group on Mining Regulations, Laws, and Permitting (87 Fed. Reg. 18811) report, entitled ``Recommendations to Improve Mining on Public Lands,'' released September 2023, will not impede the development of domestic mineral resources in a timely, safe, and environmentally sustainable manner. Acreage Treated.--The Committee recognizes the Department of the Interior and the Forest Service's intention to moving beyond acreage treated as a performance metric towards outcome- focused measurements that accurately reflect the impact of the agencies' forest restoration work on wildfire risk reduction and ecosystem resilience. The Committee believes that utilizing proven, existing, commercially available advanced decision support tools and analytics are important for accomplishing this task and evaluating the real-world outcomes of forest treatments and ensuring Federal investments yield the highest returns in terms of risk mitigation and ecosystem health. The Committee directs the Forest Service, in coordination with the Department of the Interior, to provide the Committee an update not later than 45 days following the enactment of this Act regarding how the agencies will report on outcomes beyond acres treated and what decision support tools, especially those that are already commercially available, are needed to accomplish this task. Advertising.--The Committee directs all agencies to include advertising contracting information in its fiscal year 2026 budget justification, including total obligations in fiscal year 2024 and expected obligations for fiscal years 2025 and 2026 for advertising services, and contracts for the advertising services with small businesses. For small businesses, both prime contracts and subcontracts, the agency shall identify obligations associated with small businesses, small disadvantaged businesses, service-disabled veteran-owned small businesses, women owned small businesses, and HUBZone small businesses. The agency shall also report if it has met its small business goals in each of these categories in fiscal year 2024. Bighorn Sheep.--The Committee is aware that the Forest Service and the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) use the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies' occupied bighorn habitat maps, telemetry data, and recent bighorn observations in conducting Risk of Contact analyses and that risk of contact models are currently being run on a State-wide basis where sufficient data exists. The Committee directs the agencies to complete Risk of Contact analyses using the Western Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies' data. The Committee expects the agencies to continue to share findings transparently and promptly with other Federal land management agencies, State and local governments, State wildlife agencies, and State and Federal animal healt