Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 9026] INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT Page number Bill Report Title I--Department of Commerce............................ 2 9 Title II--Department of Justice............................ 27 43 Title III--Science......................................... 79 92 Office of Science and Technology Policy............ 79 92 National Space Council............................. 79 93 National Aeronautics and Space Administration...... 80 93 National Science Foundation........................ 89 109 Title IV--Related Agencies................................. 94 117 Commission on Civil Rights......................... 94 117 Equal Employment Opportunity Commission............ 94 117 International Trade Commission..................... 96 117 Legal Services Corporation......................... 96 118 Marine Mammal Commission........................... 98 118 Office of the United States Trade Representative... 98 118 State Justice Institute............................ 99 120 Title V--General Provisions................................ 100 120 Title VI--Other Matters.................................... 150 127 House of Representatives Reporting Requirements.... 129 Minority Views..................................... 252 Highlights of the Bill The Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Subcommittee has jurisdiction over a wide variety of agencies responsible for enforcing trade laws; promoting U.S. economic interests; bolstering innovation and manufacturing; forecasting the weather; managing fisheries; combating drug trafficking, violent crime, financial fraud, terrorism, espionage, and cybercrime; exploring space; and advancing science. The activities of these agencies impact nearly every American and are integral to the operations of our Government. The Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2025, provides a total of $78,288,000,000 in discretionary budget authority for fiscal year 2025. Within this amount, non-defense spending totals $71,932,000,000 and defense spending totals $6,356,000,000. To reduce the size of the Federal Government and ensure that agencies funded herein are focused on missions that serve the American people without wasting and abusing hard-earned tax dollars, this bill prioritizes funding for critical agencies, including the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, National Science Foundation, Bureau of Prisons and Drug Enforcement Administration, while freezing, reducing, or eliminating funding for non-essential activities. FUNDING PRIORITY AGENCIES AT FISCALLY RESPONSIBLE LEVELS To support investments in Federal priorities such as national security, law enforcement in our communities, and administering just detention and correctional systems, the bill right-sizes agencies and programs by scaling back unsustainable spending levels to fiscal year 2022 levels, or lower, and cutting programs that have become agency slush funds and social justice initiatives. In addition, the bill continues funding, at fiscally responsible levels, for trade enforcement, economic development, innovation and manufacturing initiatives, efforts to protect the security and rights of all Americans, fundamental scientific research, and space exploration. Many agencies with important missions are subject to reductions, because Congress must act immediately to reverse the unsustainable growth of the Federal Government. Limited funding increases in the bill are focused on key national interests, including combating the scourge of fentanyl, safeguarding national security, and ensuring strong American leadership in research and technology advancement to counter China's growing influence. In addition to countering the unchecked and reckless growth of the Federal Government, the Committee is determined to reduce the negative impact of the Federal Government on Americans' lives. Therefore, the bill increases restrictions on agency spending to restore accountability, constrain rogue Federal agencies, and protect the fundamental liberties of the American people. In doing so, the bill addresses the weaponization of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) against the American people and the overreach by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) that undermines the Second Amendment. Trade Agencies.--The bill scales back funding for the International Trade Administration to fiscal year 2022 levels and sustains funding for the Bureau of Industry and Security, Office of the United States Trade Representative, and International Trade Commission at fiscal year 2023 levels. Such funding will maintain priority efforts focused on countering unfair trade practices and economic coercion by the People's Republic of China, enhancing U.S. economic engagement in the Indo-Pacific region, and preventing adversaries from leveraging U.S. advanced technologies to facilitate their destabilizing military modernization activities. Economic Development Assistance.--The bill reduces the size of the Economic Development Administration (EDA) by $143,500,000, or 31 percent, below the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and $198,364,000 below the request in response to growing calls to reduce or eliminate the EDA. As a result, EDA funding levels reflect dwindling congressional and public interest in many legacy EDA programs. The bill provides funding for programs that assist Coal and Indigenous Communities and the Regional Technology Hubs program, which aims to spur economic growth by increasing distressed regions' capacity to manufacture, commercialize, and deploy critical technologies. Finally, the bill reduces the Minority Business Development Agency (MBDA) by $13,250,000, or 19 percent, to $55,000,000, which is equal to the fiscal year 2022 enacted level. National Institute of Standards and Technology.--To responsibly support programs that bolster U.S. innovation and manufacturing, the bill reduces overall funding for the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) by $45,000,000 below the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and $83,500,000 below the request, but increases funding for Scientific and Technical Research and Services by $28,000,000 above the request, and sustains the fiscal year 2024 enacted level funding for Industrial Technology Services (ITS). The bill includes $175,000,000 for the Manufacturing Extension Partnership (MEP) and $37,000,000 for Manufacturing USA, both of which match the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and the request. INVESTING IN SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY TO MAINTAIN DOMINANCE OVER CHINA AND ADVANCE AMERICAN LEADERSHIP IN SPACE Notable exceptions to the Committee's effort to roll back Federal spending include targeted investments to ensure the United States remains the international leader in space, research, and technology development. The bill includes an increase for the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), to support the critical Artemis program and continued American leadership in space. The bill also includes an increase for the National Science Foundation (NSF), in recognition of increased authorization levels and support for advancements in technology development and safeguarding American research from Chinese theft. National Aeronautics and Space Administration.--The bill increases topline funding for NASA by $303,640,000 above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level, an amount that is $204,100,000 below the request. To continue advancing U.S. leadership in space, the bill: Provides for the continued development of the Space Launch System, the Orion crew vehicle, and the Exploration Ground Systems that will soon send the Artemis II crew beyond Low Earth Orbit; Continues funding for critical science missions that advance the understanding of the solar system; Supports critical investments in aeronautics research programs to improve aircraft efficiencies and innovation; and Increases funds for Space Operations to maintain current services at the International Space Station and Human Space Flight Operations. National Science Foundation.--Recognizing the importance of maintaining America's competitive research advantage over China, the bill increases funding for NSF by $198,640,000 above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level, which is $924,360,000 below the request. Although funding is below the authorized level, the bill: Supports the development of innovation across the country through the Established Program to Stimulate Competitive Research (EPSCoR) and Regional Innovation Engines program; Safeguards the American research enterprise from China's malign influence, by supporting the work NSF is doing to create a whole-of-government research strategy and increasing oversight of grant funding; and Sustains funds to grow the STEM workforce, while preventing these funds from being used for the administration's activist equity initiatives. RESTORING CONSTITUTIONAL PRINCIPLES BY REINING IN THE FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION AND THE BUREAU OF ALCOHOL, TOBACCO, FIREARMS AND EXPLOSIVES The Committee is committed to appropriately funding and thoroughly overseeing Federal law enforcement. As such, the Committee carefully scrutinized the budget submissions of the Department of Justice's law enforcement components. In response to concerns that the FBI has been weaponized against conservatives, the Committee reduces the FBI's topline funding level by $367,713,000, or 3.5 percent, below the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and $1,028,839,000 below the request. The bill: Cuts FBI Salaries and Expenses by $367,713,000, or 3.5 percent, below the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and $996,944,000 below the request. Reforms the FBI by prohibiting funds from being used to-- Pay the salary of any employee who is found to have retaliated against a whistleblower or suppressed an employee's First Amendment rights. Conduct an interview unless that interview is recorded. Classify any communication as misinformation or censor lawful speech. Pay the salary of any Federal employee who fails to comply with a congressional subpoena. Ensures the FBI is not rewarded with a new headquarters building in the National Capital Region by limiting its use of existing construction balances to sustainment of the J. Edgar Hoover Building. Similarly, the bill addresses out-of-control regulatory overreach by the ATF by: Significantly cutting ATF Salaries and Expenses by $188,500,000 below the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and $515,500,000 below the request. Prohibiting the use of funds to enforce the ATF's rules on pistol braces and privately made firearms. Conditioning ATF funding on meaningful reductions in National Firearms Act processing times. Incorporating new restrictions to address ATF overreach and eliminate wasteful and potentially unlawful programs and activities at the agency. Addressing the ATF's harassment of Federal firearms licensees (FFLs) while ensuring it stays focused on its mission of serving the industries it regulates. COUNTERING CHINA In February of 2022, the Department of Justice announced it was ending its China Initiative--a national security program established by the Trump administration to counter China's intelligence activities in the United States, including the theft of emerging technology and research from American universities. This decision is an example of weakness from a Justice Department more concerned with being politically correct than protecting Americans and stands in stark contrast to the actions of other Federal agencies that have taken steps in recognition of the extraordinary long-term threat China poses to the United States. Since 2018, according to the Department of Justice, upwards of 80 percent of all economic espionage prosecutions brought by the Justice Department allege conduct that would benefit the Chinese state, and there is at least some nexus to China in around 60 percent of all trade secret theft cases. As the U.S. engages with China in a geopolitical struggle unseen since the Cold War, it is vital that our agencies are laser focused on the threat at hand. This bill takes steps to counter China, including by challenging China's space ambitions by providing the resources necessary to return American astronauts to the Moon. NASA's Artemis program will keep the United States on the leading edge of technological development and prevent China from gaining an advantage in space exploration and utilization. The bill also makes significant investments in the American research enterprise through NSF to counter China's increasing investments in basic research and technology development, and support efforts to prevent research and intellectual property theft. RESOURCES TO COMBAT FENTANYL The fentanyl crisis is unlike any other drug problem in U.S. history. It is plaguing our towns, cities, States, and country. Practically speaking, fentanyl deaths are more akin to mass poisonings than drug overdoses. Addressing the fentanyl crisis and the role of transnational criminal organizations in drug trafficking is a top priority for both the Committee and this Congress. Therefore, the Committee provides funding above the President's inadequate request for the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA). The bill increases funding for the DEA to address fentanyl trafficking by including $193,924,000 above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and $73,924,000 above the President's request. The bill includes $547,000,000 for Organized Crime and Drug Enforcement Task Forces, which matches the fiscal year 2024 enacted level to enhance multi-agency efforts to combat transnational organized crime and reduce the availability of illicit drugs by identifying, dismantling, and prosecuting drug trafficking and money laundering operations. For State and local assistance to address fentanyl, the bill includes $420,000,000 for Comprehensive Addiction and Recovery Act grants, of which: $20,000,000 will be dedicated to local and regional efforts to prevent substance use and misuse in support of organizations doing the hard work of countering opioid use at the local level; and $35,000,000 is for the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program (PDMP), an amount equal to the fiscal year 2024 enacted level. SUPPORTING THE BUREAU OF PRISONS AND THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE To support incarceration and the correctional workers responsible for the Nation's inmate population, the bill provides funding for Bureau of Prisons (BOP) Salaries and Expenses by matching the fiscal year 2024 enacted level, an amount that is $164,751,000 below the request, and increases BOP Construction by $93,238,000 above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level. It also rejects the President's request to rescind funding for a new Federal Correctional Institute in Letcher, Kentucky. The bill increases funding for the United States Marshals Service (USMS) by $48,700,000 above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level, an amount that is $168,627,000 below the request. ENSURING LIMITED STATE AND LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT FUNDING IS USED AS INTENDED RATHER THAN DIVERTED FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE'S ACTIVIST PRIORITIES To reduce unsustainable and reckless spending on progressive Department of Justice grant programs and reverse the effects of the Department's social justice agenda that is undercutting the Nation's police, the bill sharply reduces or prohibits funding for numerous grant programs. The bill makes targeted investments in programs that support State and local law enforcement efforts including the Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant program and the Community Oriented Policing Services (COPS) Hiring program. ADDRESSING A DYSFUNCTIONAL IMMIGRATION COURT SYSTEM In recent years, this administration assured the Committee that funding hundreds of new immigration judges would have a dramatic impact on the immigration case backlog. Instead, the opposite has happened. The Immigration Court case backlog has now surpassed 3,000,000 cases, a more than 55 percent increase from late 2023. It is an undeniable fact that years of continued investments in additional judges have abjectly failed to make any discernable impact on the immigration case backlog. Our Nation's failing immigration court system is a direct result of the administration's failure to control the border, not a lack of immigration judges. Since President Biden took office in 2021, border officials have encountered more than 7,000,000 illegal aliens along the southwest border, and the Biden administration has released into American communities over 2,000,000 illegal aliens. The lesson is clear: No amount of funding for new immigration judges can outpace the effects of an open border. Similarly, an immigration court system with no appreciable case completion goals does not adequately incentivize judges to quickly process cases and effectively rewards aliens who have no lawful right to remain in the United States with years of continued illegal presence. Thus, the bill directs the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) to reinstate case completion performance metrics to enable an objective, quantifiable measurement of each immigration judge's performance. Finally, the bill also rejects the administration's request to cut off reimbursements to law enforcement for the costs of incarcerating unauthorized criminal aliens. Oversight and Budget Review In furtherance of the Committee's oversight responsibilities and to protect hard-earned taxpayer dollars, the Committee has included language that: Requires reporting on Immigration Judge performance. Requires quarterly reporting of unobligated balances. Requires agencies procuring sensitive information technology systems to conduct supply chain risk assessments. Requires contractors and grantees receiving more than $5,000,000 to certify that they are not delinquent on their Federal taxes. Prohibits funds from being used to purchase first class and premium airline travel. Limits the number of agency staff who can attend overseas conferences. Requires agencies to track undisbursed grant