Skip to content

house · Committee report

H. Rept. 118-583

AGRICULTURE, RURAL DEVELOPMENT, FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION, AND RELATED AGENCIES APPROPRIATIONS BILL, 2025

2024-07-12

Committees

Associated legislation

Text

Dissenting Views

[To accompany H.R. 9027] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies for fiscal year 2025. CONTENTS Page Title I--Agricultural Programs................................... 2 Title II--Farm Production and Conservation Programs.............. 47 Title III--Rural Development Programs............................ 58 Title IV--Domestic Food Programs................................. 70 Title V--Foreign Assistance and Related Programs................. 76 Title VI--Related Agencies and Food and Drug Administration...... 79 Title VII--General Provisions.................................... 97 OVERVIEW The Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies Subcommittee has jurisdiction over the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) except for the Forest Service, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and the Farm Credit Administration (FCA). The Subcommittee's responsibility covers matters of importance to Americans every day of the year. The fiscal year 2025 allocation is $25,873,000,000 which is $355,000,000 below the fiscal year 2024 enacted level and $2,688,497,000 below the President's budget request for fiscal year 2025. The funding levels provided in this appropriations bill continue to demonstrate how seriously this Committee takes its responsibility to fund the highest priority programs and activities while helping to address the nation's debt, deficit, and economic challenges and rein in regulatory overreach at USDA, FDA, and CFTC. The Committee does not include funding to begin new programs and, except where specifically noted, does not provide additional funding for pay increases. In this report, ``the Committees'' refers to the Committees on Appropriations of the House of Representatives and the Senate. The Subcommittee held five hearings related to the agencies it funds. Those hearings were: The FY 2025 Budget Request for the Department of Agriculture--March 21, 2024 Member Day--April 11, 2024 The FY 2025 Budget Request for the Food and Drug Administration--April 18, 2024 The FY 2025 Budget Request for the Department of Agriculture's Farm Production and Conservation Mission Area--May 1, 2024 Oversight Hearing on Nutritious Foods in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program--May 22, 2024 TITLE I AGRICULTURAL PROGRAMS Processing, Research and Marketing Office of the Secretary (INCLUDING TRANSFERS OF FUNDS) 2024 appropriation.................................... $58,292,000 2025 budget estimate.................................. 103,025,000 Provided in the bill.................................. 40,457,000 Comparison: 2024 appropriation.................................. -17,835,000 2025 budget estimate................................ -62,568,000 The following table reflects the amount provided by the Committee for each office and activity: [Dollars in thousands] ------------------------------------------------------------------------ FY 2024 FY 2025 Committee enacted estimate provision ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Office of the Secretary.......... $7,000 $20,669 $5,051 Office of Homeland Security...... 1,896 3,174 2,146 Office of Tribal Relations....... 5,190 6,613 5,190 Office of Partnerships and Public 7,500 9,339 4,711 Engagement...................... Office of the Assistant Secretary 1,706 1,737 875 for Administration.............. Departmental Administration...... 23,500 45,207 15,984 Office of the Assistant Secretary 4,500 4,709 3,000 for Congressional Relations and Intergovernmental Affairs....... Office of Communications......... 7,000 11,577 3,500 -------------------------------------- Total, Office of the 58,292 103,025 40,457 Secretary................... ------------------------------------------------------------------------ COMMITTEE PROVISIONS For the Office of the Secretary, the Committee provides an appropriation of $40,457,000. Similar to prior years, the Committee does not include direct funding for activities that are currently funded through other resources, such as the Working Capital Fund, or that have historically been funded through other means. Agritourism Resources.--The Committee looks forward to seeing the publication of an updated agritourism resource manual as requested within a year of enactment of the fiscal year 2022 bill. The Committee additionally looks forward to seeing the results of the agritourism follow-on study, also requested in the fiscal year 2022 bill, now that the 2022 Census of Agriculture has been released. Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) Report.--The Committee directs the Secretary to provide a report on November 15, 2024, and May 15, 2025, on planned uses of funding under the authorities of Section 4 and Section 11 of the CCC Charter Act. CCC Obligations and Commitments.--The Secretary is directed to notify the Committees in writing 15 days prior to any announcement on the use of funds from the CCC or the obligation or commitment of any emergency funds from the CCC. Communication from USDA.--A collaborative working relationship between the Committee and USDA is necessary to ensure efficient and effective implementation of Congress' funding decisions. USDA is directed to ensure that the Committee is notified of major changes to existing policies and any significant developments in its operations before providing non-governmental stakeholders such information, before making the changes public, and before implementing them. Communication Services for Limited English Proficient Communities.--The Committee is supportive of efforts the Department is taking to improve communications to reach limited English proficient (LEP) communities. The Committee encourages the Department to review the communication practices and create uniform applications across all Department agencies to strengthen communication practices to include digital, television and radio advertising when working with limited English proficient communities. The Committee further directs each agency funded by this Act with annual advertising budgets to include a report on expenditures related to local media advertising to include digital, television and radio no more than 60 days after the enaction of this Act. Critical Inputs.--The Committee directs the Secretary to provide a report within 180 days of enactment on the dependency on the People's Republic of China on critical agricultural inputs such as animal feed, including vitamins, minerals, and amino acids, crop protection chemicals, and veterinary drugs and vaccines, and recommend legislative or regulatory actions to reduce barriers to onshore production and mitigate potential supply chain disruptions that could be exploited by the People's Republic of China. Customer Service.--The Committee continues to support the Department's efforts to improve customer service. The Committee directs the Secretary to develop standards to improve customer service, incorporate the standards into the performance plans required under 31 U.S.C. 1115, and submit a report on these efforts within 60 days of enactment of this Act. Explanatory Notes.--The Committee appreciates the Department's work to restore the Explanatory Notes to the same format as they had been presented in prior to fiscal year 2021 and directs that this format be maintained for fiscal year 2026 and beyond. Feral Hogs.--The Committee is concerned about the growing threat posed by feral hogs and the mounting damages this invasive species is causing in Louisiana and other states. The damages nationwide are well over $1 billion and climbing, causing environmental and water resources destruction, natural plant species and crop destruction, and disruption to food production. The Committee encourages the Secretary to work with the EPA to find an expedited solution to arrive at a field trial testing regimen for a feral hog toxicant based on currently available knowledge. Fruit Fly Quarantine Areas.--The Committee is aware of quarantines in California as a result of detections of Oriental fruit fly and Queensland fruit fly. The Committee recognizes the importance of Animal Plant and Health Inspection Service Plant Protection and Quarantine in safeguarding crops and forests against the entry, establishment, and spread of pests. However, with very few treatment options available for crops located within the California quarantine areas, farmers have faced devastating losses. The Committee urges APHIS to take the necessary steps to resolve the infestation so that the quarantine may be lifted. Further, the Department is directed through all agencies, including within Farm Production and Conservation, to evaluate available financial assistance for producers impacted by the quarantines and provide a report of its findings to the Committee within 120 days of enactment of this Act. Within the report, the Department is encouraged to provide recommendations of program changes that would make them more accessible and beneficial to producers negatively impacted by quarantines. Improving Tribal Consultation.--The Committee continues to encourage the Office of Tribal Relations and the Office of Budget and Program Analysis (OBPA) to establish a regular tribal consultation process when formulating budget requests and multi-year program reauthorizations that have budgetary impacts. Intermediate Crops.--The Committee is aware of a burgeoning industry of nonfood crops, such as camelina, that can be grown on existing farmland between primary crops to produce feedstock for renewable biofuels and chemicals. The Committee encourages USDA to consider opportunities to utilize existing programs and resources to support intermediate crop production in the United States. Further, the Committee encourages USDA to establish a standard definition for the term ``intermediate crop'' as an oilseed crop of renewable biomass, such as camelina, carinata, and domesticated pennycress, or any other crop as determined by the Secretary, that otherwise meets the definition of a cover crop and is planted and harvested on land that would otherwise be idle in a rotation pattern between main crops or in a fallow rotation and is primarily intended to provide feedstocks for the production of renewable biofuels and chemicals. Liability Protections for Food Donation.--The Committee directs USDA to update the guidance documents related to liability protections provided through the Bill Emerson Act and the Food Donation Improvement Act to clarify how food companies can donate excess food. Loan and Grant Programs.--The Committee directs that if an estimate of loan activity for any program funded in Titles II and III of this bill indicates that a limitation on authority to make commitments for a fiscal year will be reached before the end of that fiscal year, or in any event when 75 percent of the authority to make commitments has been utilized, the Secretary shall promptly notify the Committees through OBPA. The Committee directs the Department, through OBPA, to provide quarterly reports to the Committees on the status of obligations and funds availability for the loan and grant programs provided in this bill. National Finance Center.--The National Finance Center (NFC) is the largest designated Federal Government Payroll Shared Service Provider, and it provides integrated payroll and personnel services for over 640,000 Federal employees. To ensure that thousands of Federal employees' pay and human resources services are not interrupted or adversely impacted by major organizational changes, the Committee continues requirements under current law relating to NFC payroll and shared services operations, missions, personnel, and functions. The Committee also directs USDA to provide quarterly reports on full-time equivalent (FTE) levels for each of the current NFC divisions, operations, and functions, as well as each of the Office of the Chief Financial Officer (OCFO) and Office of the Chief Information Officer (OCIO) divisions, operations, and functions currently co-located with the NFC. The reports also are to include a detailed breakdown of the FTEs for each and any of these same divisions, functions, or operations for the NFC and the co-located OCFO and OCIO functions compared to those during FY 2017 and 2018. Natural Capital Accounting.--The Committee notes that no funding is provided to implement Executive Order 14072 (87 Fed. Reg. 24851). New Initiatives.--The Committee directs USDA, no later than 120 days after enactment, to submit an execution plan for each new initiative funded in this Act. This strategy should include, but is not limited to, the steps necessary to make funding available, the timeline thereof, targeted beneficiaries, and expected results. The Committee requests quarterly reports on these initiatives until the initiative has been fully implemented. Notification Requirements.--The Committee reminds the Department that the Committee uses the definitions for transfer, reprogramming, and program, project, and activity as defined by the Government Accountability Office (GAO). As noted in the fiscal year 2024 Joint Explanatory Statement, a program, project, or activity (PPA) is an element within a budget account. PPAs are identified by reference to include the most specific level of budget items identified in the Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies Act, 2024, accompanying Committee reports, explanatory statements, and budget justifications. The Committee notes that the most specific level of budget items in USDA budget justifications is not limited to tables titled ``Project Statement''. Persistent Poverty Areas.--The Committee supports targeted investments in impoverished areas. The Committee directs the Department to develop and implement measures to increase the share of investments in persistent poverty counties, distressed communities, and other impoverished areas. The Committee directs the Department to submit a report to the Committee that includes the total amount of Federal investments targeted toward such areas; a list of the programs under which the amount of Federal investments to such areas were increased in fiscal year 2025; the percent change in the amount of funds that were targeted to such areas from fiscal year 2024; and to the extent practicable, an assessment of the economic impact of departmental programs in these areas. Spending Plans.--The bill continues a provision in Title VII that requires USDA to submit spending plans to the Committee within 30 days of enactment. Previous versions of these plans have not included adequate details that would be useful for Committee oversight. The Committee requests that USDA spending plans include for each program, project, or activity: (1) a comparison between the budget justification funding levels, the most recent Congressional directives or approved funding levels, and the funding levels proposed by the department or agency; and (2) a clear, concise, and informative description/justification. The Committee reminds USDA of notification requirements, also included in Title VII, for all applicable changes. Status of House and Senate Report Language.--The Department is directed to include in its fiscal year 2026 Congressional Justification, as a single exhibit, a table listing all deliverables, with a column for due dates if applicable. OBPA is directed to provide updates on the status of House and Senate reports upon request from the Committees. USDA BioPreferred Program.--The Committee recognizes the importance of work to expand biobased manufacturing. The Committee directs the Secretary to submit a report detailing the status of the USDA BioPreferred Program, including a list of biobased products that have been certified; a list of BioPreferred products that are currently included in the federal procurement catalogues; a list of BioPreferred products that are receiving support from USDA at any phase of development, including research, development, piloting, or the build out of manufacturing facilities; and any other matters the Secretary determines appropriate. USDA Domestic and International Commodity Procurement Review.--The COVID-19 pandemic and resulting supply chain disruptions revealed fragilities in America's food supply, to the detriment of farmers, producers, and consumers across America. The Committee directs Agricultural Marketing Service and Economic Research Service to review USDA's application and enrollment procedures, required commodity quality, best and most available commodities for purchase regionally, and outreach practices to small and local farmers for all available domestic and international USDA procurement programs. This will help increase understanding of programs and purchasing to elevate fair participation of America's small and local farmers. Within 180 days of enactment of this Act, AMS and ERS shall report back on their findings and efforts on improving small and local farmer procurement for relevant USDA programs. USDA Farm Delivery Systems Modernization.--The Committee directs the Secretary within 60 days of enactment of this Act to provide an IT modernization plan that accelerates the continued implementation and expansion of the Farmers.gov system using the Enterprise Data Analytics Platform and Toolset (EDAPT) to enable USDA customers to: (1) view their information, complete transactions, quickly review the status, and update tabular customer information; (2) submit applications for Farm Production and Conservation (FPAC) programs and receive program payments for all USDA farm programs; (3) to complete their own applications, including electronic signatures and submissions, for all farm programs that require direct application; (4) enable electronic income reporting between USDA and the Internal Revenue Service; and (5) access and manage acreage reporting, farm records mapping, and farm records information within Farmers.gov. The agreement further directs the FPAC Business Center to provide a roadmap for systems to make customer information available within Farmers.gov and EDAPT including, but not limited to, the Agriculture Risk Coverage and Price Loss Coverage programs, the Dairy Margin Coverage program, and the Farm Service Agency Emergency Relief Program. USDA Office of Homeland Security.--The Committee provides $225,000 for the Office of Homeland Security to fulfill its co- Sector Risk Management Agency (SRMA) responsibilities. As demonstrated by

Dissenting Views

This is a bad bill that we very strongly oppose. However, we first want to make sure Members know of two enormous improvements in the bill from full committee markup. First, in response to the outcry from the disability community and many members of the Committee, in the Manager's Amendment, Rep. Harris removed his own bill language that would have effectively stopped FDA from banning the use of electric shock devices on youths with behavioral issues and developmental disabilities. FDA is now free to continue towards a final rule to at last end this barbarous practice. Second, Mr. Bishop offered an amendment to eliminate language that would create a controversial pilot program within SNAP that was adopted by the Committee. The proposed pilot would ``restrict the purchase of ``non-nutritious'' food or beverage items based upon nutrient content rather than calories.'' As several Democratic committee members, especially Rep. Lee (D-CA), explained, the meager daily SNAP allowance ($6.20 a day) forces recipients to buy whatever foods their benefits allow, sometimes unhealthy foods, because healthier options are too often simply unaffordable. This provision would also burden 262,000 small and rural grocers and is impractical to implement even as a pilot. All grocers would be forced to monitor customers' purchases and to undergo expensive technology overhauls to implement this SNAP choice pilot program. We hope this is the last time we see this proposal. The bill provides discretionary funding of $25.9 billion, about 3.6 percent below the comparable level for fiscal year 2024. Over 80 percent of the of the Members of the Committee voted for the final 2024 appropriations Acts, which not only rejected the partisan riders, but provided a nondefense funding level of $778 billion--a one percent increase over the 2023 nondefense topline and almost $6 billion more than was originally envisioned by the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 (FRA). Throughout this year's process, the majority has shown that despite damaging cuts in all of the bills, the majority has been unable to write bills that adhere to their own promise of sticking to the statutory caps. Nevertheless, the allocations for fiscal year 2025--adopted by a party-line vote--would cut nondefense funding by more than $52 billion compared to the laws enacted just four months before this bill was marked up in Committee. We need a starting point for 2025 that both recognizes the reality of what was enacted into law, and that provides at least a one percent increase in both defense and nondefense funding, consistent with the Fiscal Responsibility Act framework that House Republicans demanded as the price for averting a catastrophic default last year. Democrats will accept nothing less than a one percent increase over 2024 in nondefense and defense funding. That means that the starting point for 2025 for nondefense funding must be at least $786 billion. Instead, the Chair's allocations walk away from that commitment and take off the table at least $60 billion in investments in American families, which is why they were opposed by every Democratic Member in attendance. Among the worst funding decisions in the bill is the slashing of the Food for Peace program from about $1.6 billion to $1 billion. During a global hunger crisis, the bill callously cuts the Food for Peace program by over 40 percent, its lowest level in over 20 years. This decision reflects the Republicans' failure to understand the difference between the Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) fund and Food for Peace. Despite the apparently strongly held views of the Republicans last year that the Secretary ``over-used'' CCC for unauthorized purposes, this year they cite his use of CCC funds for international food assistance as a justification for cutting discretionary funds for the Food for Peace program. They also cited unobligated balances, which is routine in the program at this time of the fiscal year and does not reflect a lack of need for additional funds. Domestic nutrition programs are not well-funded, either. We will need to keep a close eye on WIC funding as we get closer to 2025 and we regret the failure to provide the budget request for the Commodity Supplemental Food Program and the WIC farmers market program. The budget request for the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Island is inexplicably slashed. Another major area of concern is the large cut to the mandatory administrative funding for SNAP, despite the fact that these funds do not count against the bill's 302(b) allocation. Those funds cover things like benefit and retailer redemption, certification of Supplemental Security Income recipients for SNAP, payment accuracy, and retailer integrity and trafficking. The last item is particularly ironic since the Republicans opposed an amendment to continue assisting recipients whose benefits are stolen. Other cuts of concern that will negatively affect rural businesses and farmers include: the research title is 3 percent below 2024 and 5 percent below the budget at a time when maintaining global U.S. agricultural competitiveness is of paramount importance; within the research title, funding for the National Agricultural Statistics Service continues to be a major issue for producers. NASS was unable to complete several important surveys for 2024, including the July Cattle, Cotton Objective Yield, and County- Level Estimates surveys because of insufficient funding, yet this bill would continue down that same path, effectively cutting the agency by approximately $3.5 million. Once again, we set ourselves up to shortchange American producers. the farm production and conservation title is 2 percent below 2024 and 8 percent below the request when farmers desperately need support; rural development is 5 percent below the request, leaving housing loans, broadband and water and waste funding at unacceptably low levels; freezing FDA at the 2024 level; the Commodity Futures Trading Commissions' ability to operate and to protect itself and its data from international predatory cyber criminals is severely hampered by being funded at 5 percent below fiscal year 2024 and 8 percent below the request. A data breach at the CFTC would be nothing less than catastrophic, and it cannot be understated how shortsighted it is to underfund this agency that plays an outsized role in the global financial system; the failure to include funds to cover increased pay costs, which is effectively a 2 percent cut across the board. Finally, for the second year, it contains a laundry list of petty, mean-spirited provisions that are aimed at LGBTQI+ Americans, persons of color, disabled persons, and underserved communities, which includes an enormous swath of rural America. These riders were dropped in conference for fiscal year 2024 and their inclusion in the fiscal year 2025 bill does nothing to bring the committee closer to bipartisan agreement. We oppose the bill and will work to produce a bipartisan bill in conference with an appropriate 302(b) level. Rosa DeLauro. Sanford D. Bishop, Jr. [all]

Source: https://api.congress.gov/v3/committee-report/118/hrpt/583