Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 9029]
The Committee on Appropriations submits the following
report in explanation of the accompanying bill making
appropriations for the Departments of Labor, Health and Human
Services (except the Food and Drug Administration, the Agency
for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, and the Indian
Health Service), and Education, and the Committee for Purchase
from People Who Are Blind or Severely Disabled, Corporation for
National and Community Service, Corporation for Public
Broadcasting, Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service,
Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission, Institute of
Museum and Library Services, Medicaid and CHIP Payment and
Access Commission, Medicare Payment Advisory Commission,
National Council on Disability, National Labor Relations Board,
National Mediation Board, Occupational Safety and Health Review
Commission, Railroad Retirement Board, and Social Security
Administration for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2025,
and for other purposes.
INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT
Page number
Bill Report
Summary of Estimates and Appropriation..................... 4
General Summary of the Bill................................ 4
Bill Wide Requirements..................................... 5
Title I--Department of Labor:
Employment and Training Administration............. 2 8
Training and Employment Services........... 2 9
Job Corps.................................. 9 13
Community Service Employment for Older
Americans.............................. 14
Federal Unemployment Benefits and
Allowances............................. 10 14
State Unemployment Insurance and Employment
Service Operations..................... 11 14
Advances to the Unemployment Trust Fund and
Other Funds............................ 18 16
Program Administration..................... 18 16
Veterans' Employment and Training.................. 18 17
Employee Benefits Security Administration.......... 22 18
Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation............... 22 19
Office of Workers' Compensation Programs........... 24 19
Special Benefits........................... 24 20
Energy Employees Occupational Illness
Compensation Fund...................... 26 20
Special Benefits for Disabled Coal Miners.. 27 20
Black Lung Disability Trust Fund........... 27 21
Wage and Hour Division............................. 28 21
Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs..... 28 22
Office of Labor-Management Standards............... 28 22
Occupational Safety and Health Administration...... 29 22
Mine Safety and Health Administration.............. 31 23
Bureau of Labor Statistics......................... 33 24
Departmental Management............................ 33 25
Office of Disability Employment Policy............. 35 28
General Provisions................................. 35 28
Title II--Department of Health and Human Services:
Health Resources and Services Administration....... 53 30
Primary Health Care........................ 53 31
Health Workforce........................... 53 34
Maternal and Child Health.................. 57 43
Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program................ 58 49
Health Systems............................. 58 49
Rural Health............................... 58 51
HRSA-Wide Activities and Program Support... 59 55
Vaccine Injury Compensation Program........ 60 57
Covered Countermeasures Process Fund....... 60 58
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention......... 60 58
Immunization and Respiratory Diseases...... 60 58
HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis, Sexually
Transmitted Disease, and Tuberculosis
Prevention............................. 61 59
Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases.. 61 60
Chronic Disease Prevention and Health
Promotion.............................. 61 63
Birth Defects, Developmental Disabilities,
Disabilities and Health................ 62 68
Public Health Scientific Services.......... 62 69
Environmental Health....................... 62 71
Injury Prevention and Control.............. 72
National Institute for Occupational Safety
and Health............................. 62 73
Energy Employees Occupational Illness
Compensation Program................... 63 74
Global Health.............................. 63 75
Public Health Preparedness and Response.... 63 75
CDC-Wide Activities and Program Support.... 64 76
Buildings and Facilities................... 66 80
National Institutes of Health...................... 67 81
National Cancer Institute.................. 67 82
National Institute on Body Systems Research 67 87
National Institute on Neuroscience and
Brain Research......................... 68 91
National Institute on Infectious Diseases.. 68 95
National Institute on the Immune System and
Arthritis.............................. 68 97
National Institute of General Medical
Sciences............................... 68 98
National Institute for Disability Related
Research............................... 69 99
National Institute on Dementia............. 69 103
National Institute on Substance Use........ 69 104
National Institute of Mental Health........ 69 106
National Institute on Health Sciences
Research............................... 70 108
National Institute on Innovation and
Advanced Research...................... 70 111
Office of the Director..................... 70 113
Buildings and Facilities................... 72 125
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services
Administration................................. 73 125
Mental Health.............................. 73 128
Substance Abuse Treatment.................. 74 135
Substance Abuse Prevention................. 75 140
Health Surveillance and Program Support.... 75 142
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality......... 142
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services........... 76 143
Grants to States for Medicaid.............. 76 143
Payments to the Health Care Trust Funds.... 77 143
Program Management......................... 77 143
Health Care Fraud and Abuse Control Account 79 159
Administration for Children and Families........... 80 159
Payments to States for Child Support
Enforcement and Family Support Programs 80 159
Low Income Home Energy Assistance.......... 81 160
Refugee and Entrant Assistance............. 82 160
Promoting Safe and Stable Families......... 83 164
Child Care and Development Block Grant..... 84 164
Social Services Block Grant................ 85 164
Children and Families Services Programs.... 85 165
Payments for Foster Care and Permanency.... 88 170
Administration for Community Living................ 89 170
Administration for Strategic Preparedness and
Response....................................... 92 176
Research, Development, and Procurement..... 92 180
Operations, Preparedness, and Emergency
Response............................... 94 185
Office of the Secretary............................ 94 187
General Departmental Management............ 94 187
Office for Civil Rights.................... 96 202
Office of the National Coordinator for
Health Information Technology.......... 97 202
Medicare Hearings and Appeals.............. 97 204
Office of Inspector General................ 98 204
General Provisions................................. 98 205
Title III--Department of Education:
Office of Elementary and Secondary Education....... 126 209
Education for the Disadvantaged............ 126 209
Impact Aid................................. 127 213
School Improvement Programs................ 128 214
Safe Schools and Citizenship Education..... 130 216
Indian Education........................... 130 219
Innovation and Improvement................. 131 220
Office of English Language Acquisition............. 223
Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative
Services....................................... 132 224
Special Education.......................... 132 224
Rehabilitation Services.................... 136 226
Special Institutions for Persons with
Disabilities........................... 137 227
American Printing House for the Blind.... 137 227
National Technical Institute for the Deaf 137 228
Gallaudet University..................... 137 228
Office of Career, Technical, and Adult Education... 138 229
Office of Postsecondary Education.................. 138 230
Higher Education........................... 138 230
Howard University.......................... 140 236
College Housing and Academic Facilities
Loans.................................. 140 237
Historically Black College and University
Capital Financing Program Account...... 141 237
Office of Federal Student Aid.............. 141 237
Student Financial Assistance............... 141 239
Student Aid Administration................. 142 240
Institute of Education Sciences.................... 143 243
Departmental Management............................ 144 244
General Provisions................................. 145 249
Title IV--Related Agencies:
Committee for Purchase from People Who Are Blind or
Severely Disabled.............................. 154 251
Corporation for National and Community Service..... 155 251
Corporation for Public Broadcasting................ 253
Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service......... 159 254
Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission... 160 254
Institute of Museum and Library Services........... 160 254
Medicaid and CHIP Payment and Access Commission.... 160 255
Medicare Payment Advisory Commission............... 161 256
National Council on Disability..................... 161 256
National Labor Relations Board..................... 161 257
National Mediation Board........................... 162 257
Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission... 163 258
Railroad Retirement Board.......................... 163 258
Social Security Administration..................... 165 259
Title V--General Provisions................................ 170 263
House of Representatives Report Requirements............... 265
Summary of Estimates and Appropriations
The following table compares on a summary basis the
appropriations, including trust funds for fiscal year 2025, the
budget request for fiscal year 2025, and the Committee
recommendation for fiscal year 2025 in the accompanying bill.
2025 LABOR, HHS, EDUCATION BILL
[Discretionary funding in thousands of dollars]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fiscal Year-- 2025 Committee compared to--
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Budget Activity 2025
2024 Enacted 2025 Budget Committee 2024 Enacted 2025 Budget
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Department of Labor............. $13,695,849 $14,174,234 $10,529,223 -3,166,626 -3,645,011
Department of Health and Human 116,122,958 121,558,671 107,640,959 -8,481,999 -13,917,712
Services.......................
Department of Education......... 79,052,238 82,491,976 67,948,452 -11,103,786 -14,543,524
Related Agencies................ 17,071,955 18,421,516 14,962,530 -2,119,425 -3,458,986
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
General Summary of the Bill
For fiscal year 2025, the Committee recommends a total of
$185,797,000,000 in current year discretionary funding--the
302(b) allocation--and $201,081,164,000 in overall programmatic
funding, including offsets and adjustments. The fiscal year
2025 recommendation is a decrease of $8,637,000,000 below the
fiscal year 2024 enacted level. This amount represents 26
percent of total nondefense spending and 12 percent of total
discretionary spending.
The Labor-HHS-Education bill supports some of the nation's
most critical programs that touch individuals and families
throughout their lifespan, from Early Head Start to Social
Security.
Federal government discretionary spending of approximately
$1.7 trillion represents less than half of mandatory
entitlement spending of $3.8 trillion. Mandatory entitlement
spending, like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid,
commands a significant portion of the budget due to automatic
funding mechanisms and eligibility criteria set by law.
Mandatory spending accounts for more than 70 percent of total
Federal outlays. Discretionary spending, on the other hand,
accounts for just 28 percent of total Federal outlays.
Discretionary spending covers a far broader spectrum of
government activities, including the nation's defense,
education, roads and bridges, and research infrastructure.
Over the past decade, Federal mandatory spending has
exhibited a notable upward trajectory, driven primarily by
factors such as demographic shifts, economic conditions, and
policy decisions. The rising costs of Federal health care and
social insurance programs have shaped the growth of mandatory
spending. Just ten years ago, mandatory spending was
approximately 12 percent of the U.S. gross domestic product
(GDP), and discretionary spending was approximately 8 percent.
In one decade, the mandatory amount jumped to nearly 14 percent
of GDP and discretionary shrunk to a corresponding 6 percent of
GDP. Over the long term, projections suggest that if current
policies remain unchanged, the Federal government could face
major fiscal imbalances, primarily due to automatic entitlement
spending.
Bill Wide Requirements
In cases where this report directs the submission of a
report, that report is to be submitted to the Committee on
Appropriations of the House of Representatives. Where this
report refers to the Committee or the Committee on
Appropriations, unless otherwise noted, this reference is to
the House of Representatives Subcommittee on Labor, Health and
Human Services, Education, and Related Agencies.
Each department and agency funded in this Act shall follow
the directives set forth in this Act and the accompanying
report and shall not reallocate resources or reorganize
activities except as provided herein. Funds for individual
programs and activities are displayed in the detailed table at
the end of report accompanying this Act. Funding levels that
are not displayed in the detailed table are identified within
this report. Any action to eliminate or consolidate programs,
projects, and activities should be pursued through a proposal
in the President's Budget so it can be considered by the
Committee.
Budget Submission.--As part of the President's Budget
Request, each Department is directed to provide the Committee
in electronic format a table that corresponds with every
program line found in the detailed table at the end of this
report. Such a table shall include a column for the most
recently enacted appropriation, the current year, and the
budget year, assuming current law. In addition, the Committee
continues to expect delivery of all congressional
justifications and budget summary documents no later than the
day of the President's Budget Appendix publication online. The
Department is directed to notify the Committee 24 hours in
advance of any anticipated delay.
Congressional Reports.--Each department or agency is
directed to provide the Committee, within 30 days from the date
of enactment of this Act and quarterly thereafter, a summary
describing each requested report to the Committee along with
related actions completed in the current and prior quarters and
planned actions to be completed in future quarters. Such a
summary shall be cumulative for all fiscal years for which any
report remains outstanding.
Customer Experience.--The Committee continues to support
efforts to improve agency customer experience. The Committee
urges all agencies funded by this Act to develop standards to
improve customer experience and incorporate the standards into
the performance plans required under 31 U.S.C. 1115. The
Committee requests an update from all agencies funded by this
Act to report on their implementation plans regarding this
subject in the fiscal year 2026 congressional justification.
Federal Agenc
Minority Views
This bill continues the Republican Party's full-scale
assault on public education, abandons ongoing health crises,
and eliminates funding for reproductive health. The Republican
majority's Fiscal Year 2025 appropriations bill for the
Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human Services, Education,
and Related Agencies cuts discretionary spending by $24.6
billion, or 11 percent, below the fiscal year 2024 level.
For the second year in a row, the majority's bill
prophesies the complete destruction of public education. Last
year, the Republican majority put forth a Labor-HHS-Education
bill that would have taken 224,000 teachers out of classrooms;
eliminated job opportunities for young adults, seniors, and
working families; and jeopardized maternal, pediatric, and
public health.
This year, the bill once again decimates support for K-12
education--including cuts that would take at least 72,000
teachers out of low-income classrooms--and it abandons college
students and lower-income workers trying to gain an education
or advance their career for their chance at the American Dream.
The Republican majority's bill would harm women's health,
children's health, and public health. The bill would surrender
the safety and wellbeing of the American people to multiple
ongoing health crises.
And the majority's cuts to the Social Security
Administration would mean closures and shorter operating hours
at Social Security field offices, and longer processing and
wait times for seniors and those with disabilities.
This bill will never become law. But the Republican
majority once again demonstrates beyond any doubt where it
seeks to take public education in this country. American
families deserve to know not only how the Republican majority's
bill decimates support for K-12 education--they deserve to know
how it would abandon students, young adults, workers and
seniors through all stages of their education and careers.
In this bill, the Republican majority cuts funding for the
Department of Education by $11 billion, including a cut of $5
billion to Title I Grants to Local Educational Agencies, which
would take at least 72,000 teachers out of low-income
classrooms, in the midst of a teacher shortage.
More than 600 teachers in Connecticut would be shown the
door. Pink slips would be handed out to over 8,800 teachers in
California, 4,000 teachers in Florida, and 7,300 teachers in
Texas.
This bill eliminates funding for English language
acquisition--disadvantaging and discriminating against five
million English learners nationwide who primarily speak another
language, hurting their future ability to compete and succeed
in the American economy. Funding for Supporting Effective
Instruction State grants--which provide professional
development opportunities for educators--is eliminated as well.
This bill cuts funding for Federal Work Study by 50
percent--limiting the potential earnings and future success of
330,000 students who need work-based financial aid to help
finance their post-secondary education. The bill also cuts
funding Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grants--which is
need-based financial aid--by 50 percent for more than 800,000
low-income students who use it to finance their education.
This bill eliminates funding for Workforce Innovation and
Opportunity Act Youth Job Training grants--denying job training
opportunities for 135,000 youth.
And beyond education and job training, this bill would
endanger the health of women, children, and families around the
country. This bill eliminates funding for Title X Family
Planning, which would be the end of support for preventive
health care services, including contraception and cancer
screenings, for 2.6 million low-income women and men.
This bill launches a full-blown assault on HIV/AIDS
programs, with total eliminations of funding for the Ending HIV
Epidemic initiative and Minority AIDS prevention.
The Republican majority also eliminates funding for Gun
Violence Prevention Research, Tobacco Prevention, and Suicide
Prevention. The bill cuts funding for SAMHSA's mental health
programs by $150 million, and funding for programs that were
created following the tragedy at Sandy Hook elementary school
in Newtown, Connecticut, is completely eliminated.
In addition, the majority includes a short-sighted proposal
to reorganize the National Institutes of Health (NIH) in a
partisan appropriations bill.
The House needs to hold public hearings and engage in a
thoughtful process to incorporate the best ideas to advance NIH
as the crown jewel of biomedical research. Any discussion to
reauthorize the NIH needs to be bipartisan and bicameral--
unfortunately, the proposed reorganization in today's partisan
bill falls short.
Moreover, the bill cuts funding for the Advanced Research
Projects Agency for Health (ARPH-H) by $1 billion below the
2024 enacted level, and proposes to consolidate ARPA-H into the
NIH, which would destroy ARPA-H as an independent research
agency less than three years after Congress established it.
In keeping with the majority's other partisan bills, this
bill includes dozens of policy riders, including multiple
provisions that attack women's freedom and block abortion and
reproductive health care services. Policy riders in this bill
would create an open season for discrimination against LGBTQI+
people, and they would prohibit policies and programs intended
to promote diversity in the federal government.
Like last year, these new policy riders will need to be
removed from the bill before it can be enacted.
Full Committee Markup
During full committee markup, House Democrats offered an
amendment to restore funding to the Department of Education's
Title I Grants to Local Educational Agencies, but it was
rejected by the majority.
House Democrats offered an amendment to restore funding for
the Social Security Administration's operating budget, but it
was rejected by the majority.
House Democrats offered an amendment to strike six new
policy riders that would block access to abortion and
reproductive health services, but it was rejected by the
majority.
House Democrats offered an amendment to strike 32 new
policy riders that would harm workers, patients, students, and
families, but it was rejected by the majority.
Conclusion
This bill would abandon and endanger Americans--from the
classroom, to the examination room, to the workplace--so I
cannot support it.
This bill, like the 11 other appropriations bills, will
need support from Republicans and Democrats in the House and
Senate in order to become law.
The law provides for--and Democrats will accept nothing
less than--a one percent increase in fiscal year 2025 for
Labor-HHS-Education and each of the other appropriations bills,
including parity with any additional funding increases for
defense programs.
Democrats are at the table and ready to pass legislation
that protects Americans' schools, health, and economic
opportunity. We implore the majority to join us. It is time to
govern.
Rosa DeLauro.
[all]