Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 8648]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and the Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 8648) to increase the transparency of
colleges and universities in carrying out their civil rights
responsibilities, and for other purposes, having considered the
same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Civil Rights Protection Act of 2024''.
SEC. 2. COMPLIANCE AND TRANSPARENCY RELATED TO TITLE VI OF THE CIVIL
RIGHTS ACT OF 1964.
(a) Program Participation Agreement Requirement.--Section 487 of the
Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1094) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by adding at the end the following new
paragraph:
``(30) The institution will comply with the provisions of
subsection (i) and provide to the Secretary an annual
attestation of such compliance.''.
(2) by redesignating subsections (i) and (j) as subsections
(j) and (k), respectively; and
(3) by inserting after subsection (h) the following new
subsection:
``(i) Compliance and Transparency Related to Complaints Under Title
VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.--
``(1) Compliance and transparency.--With respect to
complaints received by an institution related to alleged
violations of title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (42
U.S.C. 2000d et seq.), the institution will--
``(A) have in effect, make publicly available
(including on the website of the institution), and
widely distribute to students and their families
(including in student orientation materials) a
description of the investigative processes of the
institution related to such complaints;
``(B) include in the description of investigative
processes described in subparagraph (A) at least the
following:
``(i) The processes and factors used to
determine whether such a complaint will be
investigated and how the outcome of an
investigation will be determined.
``(ii) A designation of at least one employee
to coordinate its efforts to comply with title
VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C.
2000d et seq.), including any investigation of
any complaint alleging the noncompliance of the
institution with requirements under the Act.
``(iii) The contact information and necessary
steps for reporting such a complaint to the
institution.
``(iv) A procedure to ensure that, for each
such complaint received by the institution, the
complainant will receive from the institution
timely notification of each of the following:
``(I) Confirmation of receipt of the
complaint.
``(II) Notification of whether or not
an investigation has been opened in
response to the complaint.
``(III) In the case that an
investigation was not opened in
response to the complaint, an
explanation of why an investigation was
not opened including a summary of the
information that was used to determine
that an investigation should not be
opened.
``(IV) In the case that an
investigation was opened--
``(aa) notification that an
investigation of the complaint
will be carried out, and that
the complainant will be
notified of the outcome of the
investigation; and
``(bb) notification of the
outcome of the investigation,
including an explanation of how
the outcome was reached, and
any remedial actions taken in
response to the complaint.
``(v) A system for keeping and maintaining
records of such complaints, including the
determination and reasoning for whether or not
an investigation into a complaint was opened,
notifications to and communications with the
complainant and, if applicable, the respondent,
a record of the investigation (including the
outcome thereof), and a record of any remedial
actions taken in response to the complaint.
``(vi) The contact information and necessary
steps for reporting a complaint related to an
alleged violation of title VI of the Civil
Rights Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000d et seq.) to
the Office for Civil Rights of the Department
of Education, including the hyperlink to the
electronic complaint form of the Office for
Civil Rights for an alleged violation of such
title VI; and
``(C) with respect to public awareness campaign
materials created and distributed by the Office for
Civil Rights of the Department relating to protections
for individuals under title VI of the Civil Rights Act
of 1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000d et seq.), display and publish
such materials, as applicable--
``(i) not later than 30 days after such
materials are distributed;
``(ii) for not less than 1 year or until new
such materials are distributed, whichever is
later;
``(iii) in high traffic, public places on the
campus of the institution; and
``(iv) on publicly available websites of the
institution.
``(2) Enforcement.--An institution of higher education that
fails to comply with any provision of subsection (a)(30) for
two consecutive award years shall be ineligible to participate
in the programs authorized by this title for a period of not
less than two years. To regain eligibility to participate in
the programs authorized by this title, an institution of higher
education shall demonstrate compliance with paragraph (1) prior
to the completion of the period during which the institution is
ineligible due to failure to comply with such paragraph.''.
(b) Effective Date.--The amendments made by subsection (a) shall take
effect on the first day of the first award year beginning after the
date of enactment of this Act.
SEC. 3. OFFICE FOR CIVIL RIGHTS REQUIREMENTS.
(a) Congressional Briefings.--
(1) In general.--Beginning not later than 30 days after the
date of the enactment of this Act and ending 2 years after such
date of enactment, the Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights of
the Department of Education shall give a monthly briefing to
the Committee on Education and the Workforce of the House of
Representatives and the Committee on Health, Education, Labor,
and Pensions of the Senate regarding discrimination on the
basis of race, color, or national origin in violation of title
VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000d et seq.),
disaggregated by the basis of discrimination, including shared
ancestry, that--
(A) explains the number of complaints alleging such
discrimination that the Office for Civil Rights of the
Department of Education (referred to in this section as
the ``Office'')--
(i) is investigating; and
(ii) has received in the preceding month;
(B) describes--
(i) how the Office plans to address those
complaints; and
(ii) the investigations being carried out in
response to those complaints, as applicable;
and
(C) provides data about the length of time that those
complaints are pending after being received by the
Office.
(2) Report.--Not later than 48 hours prior to each briefing
required under paragraph (1), the Assistant Secretary for Civil
Rights of the Department of Education shall provide a written
report to the Committee on Education and the Workforce of the
House of Representatives and the Committee on Health,
Education, Labor, and Pensions of the Senate that contains the
information that will be presented at such briefing, in a
manner that protects personally identifiable information in
accordance with applicable privacy laws.
(b) OCR Process Reforms.--
(1) Dismissals.--The Office shall not close or dismiss any
complaint regarding discrimination on the basis of race, color,
or national origin in violation of title VI of the Civil Rights
Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000d et seq.) due to the filing of a
complaint involving the same allegations against the same
recipient--
(A) by an individual other than the complainant with
another Federal, State, or local agency, a court, or
the recipient, unless the Office determines that--
(i) a court has certified a class action with
respect to the alleged violation of such other
individual's complaint;
(ii) such other individual is a member of
such class; and
(iii) the complainant is a member of such
class; or
(B) by the complainant with another Federal, State,
or local agency, a court, or the recipient.
(2) Investigations.--The Office shall not delay an
investigation of a complaint due to the filing of a complaint
involving the same allegations against the same recipient with
another Federal, State, or local agency or the recipient.
(3) Recipient defined.--For purposes of this subsection, the
term ``recipient'' means an institution of higher education (as
such term is defined in section 102 of the Higher Education Act
of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1002)) that receives funds under an
applicable program (as such term is defined in section 400 of
the General Education Provisions Act (20 U.S.C. 1221)).
Purpose
The purpose of H.R. 8648, the Civil Rights Protection Act
of 2024, is to increase the transparency of colleges and
universities in carrying out their civil rights
responsibilities and to codify certain investigative procedures
at the Office for Civil Rights at the U.S. Department of
Education (OCR).
Committee Action
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On November 14, 2023, the Subcommittee on Higher Education
and Workforce Development held a hearing on ``Confronting the
Scourge of Antisemitism on Campus.'' The purpose of the hearing
was to discuss the proliferation of antisemitism on college
campuses. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Rabbi Moshe
Hauer, Executive Vice President, Orthodox Union, NY, NY;
Kenneth L. Marcus, Esq., Founder and Chairman, Brandeis Center,
Washington, DC; Ms. Stacy Burdett, Independent Consultant in
Antisemitism Prevention and Response, Washington, DC; and Sahar
Tartak, Jewish student, Yale University, New Haven, CT.
On December 5, 2023, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Holding Campus Leaders
Accountable and Confronting Antisemitism.'' The purpose of the
hearing was to discuss the proliferation of antisemitism on
college campuses with key college presidents. Testifying before
the Committee were Dr. Claudine Gay, President, Harvard
University, Boston, MA; Ms. Liz Magill, President, University
of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA; Dr. Pamela Nadell, Professor
of History and Jewish Studies, American University, Washington,
DC; and Dr. Sally Kornbluth, President, Massachusetts Institute
of Technology, Boston, MA.
Second Session--Hearings
On April 17, 2024, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Columbia in Crisis: Columbia
University's Response to Antisemitism.'' The purpose of the
hearing was to learn more about the pervasive environment of
antisemitism on Columbia's campus. Testifying before the
Committee were Dr. Nemat ``Minouche'' Shafik, President,
Columbia University, New York, NY; Professor David Schizer,
Dean Emeritus and Harvey R. Miller Professor of Law &
Economics, Columbia Law School, New York, NY; Ms. Claire
Shipman, Board of Trustees Co-Chair, Columbia University, New
York, NY; and Mr. David Greenwald, Board of Trustees Co-Chair,
Columbia University, New York, NY.
On May 8, 2024, the Subcommittee on Early Childhood,
Elementary, and Secondary Education held a hearing on
``Confronting Pervasive Antisemitism In K-12 Schools.'' The
purpose of the hearing was to discuss the proliferation of
antisemitism in K-12 schools. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Mr. David Banks, Chancellor, New York City
Public Schools, New York City Department of Education, New
York, NY; Ms. Karla Silvestre, President, Montgomery County
Board of Education, Montgomery County Public Schools,
Rockville, MD; Mr. Emerson Sykes, Senior Staff Attorney,
American Civil Liberties Union, New York, NY; and Ms. Enikia
Ford Morthel, Superintendent, Berkeley Unified School District,
Berkely, CA.
On May 23, 2024, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing ``Calling for Accountability: Stopping
Antisemitic College Chaos.'' The purpose of the hearing was to
examine pervasive antisemitism and encampments on college
campuses. Testifying before the Committee were Mr. Michael
Schill, President of Northwestern University, Evanston, IL; Dr.
Jonathan Holloway, President of Rutgers University, New
Brunswick, NJ; Mr. Frederick M. Lawrence, Secretary and CEO,
Phi Beta Kappa Society, Washington, DC; and Dr. Gene Block,
Chancellor, University of California--Los Angeles, Los Angeles,
CA.
Legislative Action
On June 7, 2024, Rep. Lori Chavez-DeRemer (R-OR) introduced
H.R. 8648, the Civil Rights Protection Act of 2024. The bill
was referred solely to the Committee on Education and the
Workforce. On June 13, 2024, the Committee considered H.R. 8648
in legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended,
to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 25-15.
The Committee adopted the following amendments to H.R. 8648:
1. Rep. Lori Chavez-DeRemer (R-OR) offered an
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute (ANS) that
requires communications with complainants and
respondents to be part of the IHE's record keeping and
makes other technical changes. The amendment also
clarifies that courts certify class actions.
2. Representative Bobby Scott (D-VA) offered an
amendment that would authorize $280 million annually
for the Office for Civil Rights for five years starting
in FY 2025. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of
16-24.
3. Representative Kathy Manning (D-NC) offered an
amendment that would authorize ``such sums'' for
funding for fiscal years 2024 through 2028 to implement
the Act. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 16-
23.
4. Representative Kathy Manning (D-NC) offered an
amendment that requires institutions to display and
publish public awareness materials created and
distributed by OCR relating to title VI of the Civil
Rights Act. The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
Title VI of the Civil Rights Act (title VI) prohibits
discrimination in federal taxpayer funded programs based on
race, color, or national origin. Administrations of both
parties have affirmed that discrimination against religious
groups is prohibited by title VI when that discrimination is
based on an individual's actual or perceived shared ancestry or
ethnic characteristics.\1\ Over the last several months, there
has been an explosion of antisemitism on college campuses. This
has raised questions about how institutions of higher education
(IHEs) investigate claims of discrimination and harassment
under Title VI and created calls for codifying certain
investigative processes at OCR.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/presidential-actions/
executive-order-combating-anti-semitism/; https://www.ed.gov/news/
press-releases/us-department-education-reminds-schools-their-legal-
obligation-address-discrimination-including-harassment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Increasing Transparence at Institutions of Higher Education
H.R. 8648 amends the program participation agreement under
the Higher Education Act to require IHEs to be transparent
about their procedures for investigating complaints of alleged
violations of title VI. The bill also establishes minimum
requirements for those procedures to ensure that institutions
are communicating regularly and clearly with complainants and
being transparent about decisions made over the course of an
investigation. The bill also requires institutions to
disseminate these procedures widely to their campuses so that
students and other members of their communities know how to
file a complaint and understand how complaints will be
investigated. These changes are important because neither the
title VI statute nor the title VI regulations provide
significant direction to campuses regarding how allegations of
discrimination based on race, color, or national origin should
be investigated.
Office for Civil Rights Investigative Procedures
H.R. 8648 also requires OCR to brief the Committee on
Education and the Workforce and the Senate Health, Education,
Labor, and Pensions Committee monthly for two years on the
progress the office is making investigating title VI
complaints. There is a significant backlog of title VI cases at
OCR, and this provision will provide Congress an opportunity to
hear directly from OCR about the progress being made on those
complaints.
The bill ensures that investigations of title VI complaints
will continue at OCR. The bill places restrictions on OCR for
when it can dismiss a complaint because of the existence of a
class action in a court. This is already current policy at OCR
under its case processing manual, but this provision will
codify that practice in law to ensure it is followed. The bill
also ensures that OCR will not dismiss or delay an
investigation because a complaint involving the same
allegations and the same institution has been made with another
entity.
CONCLUSION
H.R. 8648 will strengthen title VI compliance processes at
colleges and universities and OCR. These are important steps
forward as Congress seeks to stamp out the resurgence of
antisemitism on college campuses and ensure that all students
have equal access to educational opportunities.
Summary
H.R. 8648 amends the program participation agreement under
the Higher Education Act to require institutions of higher
education to be transparent about their procedures for
investigating complaints of alleged violations of Title VI,
establishes minimum requirements for those procedures to ensure
that institutions are communicating regularly and clearly with
complainants and being transparent about decisions made over
the course of an investigation, requires transparency from OCR
with Congress about progress being made on title VI
investigations, and ensures that investigations of title VI
complaints at ED will continue.
H.R. 8648 SECTION-BY-SECTION SUMMARY
Section 1--Short title
Names the bill the Civil Rights Protection Act of
2024
Section 2--Compliance and transparency related to Title VI of the Civil
Rights Act of 1964
The bill amends the program participation
agreement under the Higher Education Act to require
institutions of higher education receiving Title IV aid to:
Have in place and widely distribute
investigative processes to investigate claims filed
with the institution under title VI.
Include within those processes at least
the following minimum elements:
D A description of the investigative
processes, including how the institution
determines whether a complaint will be
investigated, and if so, how the outcome of the
investigation is determined.
D Designation of at least one employee to
coordinate the institution's title VI
compliance, including any investigations of
complaints alleging noncompliance.
D The contact information and necessary steps
for reporting a complaint to the institution.
D Timely delivery to each complainant a
confirmation the complaint was received;
notification of whether or not an investigation
has been opened; in the case that an
investigation was not opened, an explanation of
why the investigation was not opened; in the
case that an investigation is opened,
notification that an investigation will be
carried out, notification of the outcome of the
investigation, and notification of the remedial
actions taken.
Have in place a system for keeping and
maintaining records of complaints and investigations
that result from such complaints.
The contact information and necessary
steps for reporting a complaint under title VI to OCR.
Require the Department of Education to
withhold title IV aid from the institution for two
years if the institution violates these requirements
for two consecutive years and requires institutions to
demonstrate compliance with the requirements before
regaining eligibility.
The bill establishes an effective date for these
amendments of the first day of the first award year beginning
after the date of enactment of the bill.
Section 3--Office for Civil Rights requirements
Beginning 30 days after enactment of the bill and
lasting for two years, the bill requires OCR to brief the
Congressional education committees monthly on its title VI
investigations.
The bill lays out information the
briefing must cover.
The bill requires OCR to submit a report
on the information to be covered in the briefing to the
Committees 48 hours prior to each briefing.
The bill prohibits OCR from dismissing title VI
complaints filed with OCR under certain conditions.
The bill prohibits OCR from dismissing a
complaint using its ``class action'' authority based on
a complaint filed by a second complainant unless OCR
determines that the second complaint is part of a class
action that the first complainant is part of.
The bill prohibits OCR from dismissing a
complaint if a complaint involving the same allegation
against the same recipient is filed with another
federal, state, or local agency, a court, or the
recipient.
The bill prohibits OCR from delaying the
investigation of a complaint due to the filing of a complaint
involving the same allegations against the same recipient with
another federal, state, or local agency or the recipient.
The bill defines ``recipient'' to mean an
institution of higher education that receives funds from the
Department of Education.
Explanation of Amendments
The amendments, including the amendment in the nature of a
substitute, are explained in the body of this report.
Application of Law to the Legislative Branch
Section 102(b)(3) of Public Law 104-1 requires a
description of the application of this bill to the legislative
branch. H.R. 8648 amends the program participation agreement
under the Higher Education Act to require institutions of
higher education to have procedures in place to investigate
claims filed with the institution under Title VI. H.R. 8648 is
applicable to institutions of higher education and therefore
does not apply to the Legislative Branch.
Unfunded Mandate Statement
Pursuant to Section 423 of the Congressional Budget and
Impoundment Control Act of 1974, Pub.L. No. 93-344 (as amended
by Section 101(a)(2) of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of
1995, Pub. L. No. 104-4), the Committee adopts as its own the
cost estimate prepared by the Director of the Congressional
Budget Office (CBO) pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974.
Earmark Statement
H.R. 8648 does not contain any congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in
clause 9 of House rule XXI.
Roll Call Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee Report to include for
each record vote on a motion to report the measure or matter
and on any amendments offered to the measure or matter the
total number of votes for and against and the names of the
Members voting for and against.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
In accordance with clause (3)(c) of House rule XIII, the
goal of H.R. 8648, is to increase the transparency of colleges
and universities in carrying out their civil rights
responsibilities by requiring institutions of higher education
receiving Title IV aid to establish and implement processes to
investigate claims filed under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act
of 1964.
Duplication of Federal Programs
No provision of H.R. 8648 establishes or reauthorizes a
program of the Federal Government known to be duplicative of
another Federal program, a program that was included in any
report from the Government Accountability Office to Congress
pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139, or a program
related to a program identified in the most recent Catalog of
Federal Domestic Assistance.
Statement of Oversight Findings and Recommendations of the Committee
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII and clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
the committee's oversight findings and recommendations are
reflected in the body of this report.
Required Committee Hearing
In compliance with clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII the
following hearing held during the 118th Congress was used to
develop or consider H.R. 8648: On November 14, 2023, the
Committee on Education and the Workforce held a hearing on
``Confronting the Scourge of Antisemitism on Campus.''
New Budget Authority and CBO Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and with respect
to requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives and section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has received
the following estimate for H.R. 8648 from the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Legislation summary: On June 13, 2024, the House Committee
on Education and the Workforce ordered to be reported eight
bills and one joint resolution. This document provides
estimates for seven of those bills and the resolution.
Generally, the legislation would:
Repeal a rule submitted by the Department of
Education relating to ``Nondiscrimination on the Basis
of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving
Federal Financial Assistance;''
Allow nurse practitioners and physician
assistants to diagnose, treat, and certify an injury
and extent of disability for the purposes of federal
workers' compensation;
Require elementary and secondary schools and
institutions of higher education to meet new
requirements in order to maintain eligibility for
funding from the Department of Education;
Prevent student athletes from being
considered the employees of an institution of higher
education; and
Authorize appropriations for the educational
activities of the United States Holocaust Memorial
Museum.
Estimated Federal Cost: The estimated costs of the
legislation fall within budget function 500 (education,
training, employment, and social services).
Basis of estimate: For this estimate, CBO assumes that the
legislation will be enacted near the end of fiscal year 2024.
The estimated costs do not include any interaction effects
among the pieces of legislation. If all seven bills and the
resolution were combined and enacted as a single piece of
legislation, the estimated costs could be different than the
sum of the separate estimates, although CBO expects that any
difference would be small.
CBO estimates that implementing H.R. 8606 would cost $8
million over the 2024-2029 period. Implementing the remaining
bills and the joint resolution would each cost less than
$500,000 over the same period. Any related spending would be
subject to the availability of appropriated funds.
H.J. Res. 165, a joint resolution providing for
Congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United
States Code, of the rule submitted by the Department of
Education relating to ``Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex
in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial
Assistance'': H.J. Res 165 would disapprove the rule submitted
by
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 8648, the Civil Rights Protection Act of 2024, amends
the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA) to place requirements
related to compliance with title VI of the Civil Rights Act of
1964 (Title VI) in the Provisional Participation Agreement
(PPA) institutions of higher education (IHEs) enter into in
order to receive access to Federal Student Aid. The bill also
makes changes to the process by which the U.S. Department of
Education's (Department) Office for Civil Rights (OCR) handles
Title VI claims. While we appreciate the spirit in which the
bill is offered, we have concerns about specific provisions in
the bill that may increase the backlog of cases at OCR and
could result in inequitable outcomes between complaints based
in Title VI and other education civil rights cases. Sadly,
these concerns must be considered along with the Committee's
recent Title VI ``oversight''.
SUMMARY OF CONCERNS
The Committee's Title VI ``Oversight'', or Lack Thereof
By the Chair's own words, H.R. 8648 has its genesis in the
Committee's ``ongoing effort to stamp out antisemitism.''\1\ We
have serious concerns about how the Committee has undertaken
this effort. These concerns are difficult to set aside when
considering the merits of and motivations behind H.R. 8648.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Press Release, H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, Chairwoman
Foxx Delivers Opening Remarks at Markup to Enhance Safety, Security,
and Rights of Students, Parents, and Workers (June 13, 2024), https://
edworkforce.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=410701.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
From the beginning, the Committee has undertaken a partisan
investigation into antisemitic events that have occurred on
college campuses in the wake of the heinous Oct. 7 terrorist
attack by Hamas on innocent civilians in the state of Israel.
This is of course the Majority's prerogative.\2\ But this
partisan approach has been reflected in both the tone of the
hearings the Committee has held and the ``targets'' of the
Committee's investigation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\See Ben Wilhelm, et al., Cong. Rsch. Serv., RL30240,
Congressional Oversight Manual 39, https://crs.gov/reports/pdf/RL30240/
RL30240.pdf (``There, a committee rule required that all `major
investigations' be initiated only with the majority approval of the
committee.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
From all outward appearances, the Committee's efforts to
``stamp out antisemitism'' have had less to do with identifying
and addressing the root causes of antisemitism in educational
settings than with pillorying college administrators generally,
elite colleges specifically.\3\ The proceedings have taken on
the air of show trials, where college Presidents are forced to
distill complex questions or decisions they have made to one
word answers, designed to portray them in the most unfavorable
light. This is obvious when press statements and tweets after
the hearings celebrate instances when Presidents misspoke, were
rebuked by their faculty, or forced to resign as a result of
something that transpired during the hearing.\4\ While these
efforts may garner acclaim for Members, they do little to
nothing to address the underlying problem, addressing the
responsibilities schools have to provide learning environments
free from hostility based on race, national origin, or shared
ancestry.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\E.g., Franciska Coleman, Opinion, In battles over offensive
speech, the `cure' is usually worse than the disease, The Hill, Jan.
16, 2024; Bianca Quilantan, Lawmakers, Jewish groups brace for
Columbia's Capitol Hill antisemitism showdown, Politico, Apr. 17, 2024
(``Some higher education groups and faculty who hoped to get help in
dealing with thorny issues of free speech are resigning themselves to a
show trial.'').
\4\E.g., @RepStefanik, X.com (formerly Twitter.com) (Dec. 9, 2023,
5:03 PM), https://x.com/RepStefanik/status/1733608373990343015?lang=en.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the wake of the October 7th attack there have been many
documented incidents of racist, antisemitic, and Islamophobic
activity on U.S. college campuses. However, in every official
oversight action this Committee has taken on the issue of
hostile learning environments on college campuses in the wake
of October 7th, the Committee has ignored issues of hate and
animus on college campuses that did not involve antisemitism.
For example, on Tuesday November 14, the Higher Education
and Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing titled
``Confronting the Scourge of Antisemitism on Campus''. This was
timely as incidents of antisemitism on college campuses
proliferated horribly in the aftermath of the October 7th
attack.\5\ However, two weeks before the hearing, the Council
on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) reported that they had
received 774 anti-Islamic ``complaints, including reported bias
incidents'' since October 7, including incidents that took
place at schools.\6\ At the time the hearing was held, the U.S.
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) was already investigating
a death threat made against a Palestinian American employee of
American University.\7\ At Harvard University, there was
reporting that efforts to ``dox'' leaders of student groups
supporting the Palestine Solidarity Coalition (PSC), included
students who were not even on campus that semester and had no
part in the PSC's response to the October 7th attack.\8\ Muslim
students who had been doxed had reported receiving death
threats in the wake of the doxing.\9\ To our knowledge there
has been no Committee oversight of these events or either
campus' response to them.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Press Release, Anti-Defamation League, ADL Records Dramatic
Increase in U.S. Antisemitic Incidents Following Oct. 7 Hamas Massacre,
Oct. 24, 2023, https://www.adl.org/resources/press-release/adl-records-
dramatic-increase-us-antisemitic-incidents-following-oct-7.
\6\Press Release, Council on Am.-Islamic Relations, CAIR Reports
Sharp Increase in Complaints, Reported Bias Incidents Since 10/7, Oct.
25, 2023, https://www.cair.com/press_releases/cair-reports-sharp-
increase-in-complaints-reported-bias-incidents-since-107/.
\7\Susan H. Greenberg, FBI Investigates Anti-Palestinian Message at
American University, Inside Higher Ed, Oct. 31, 2023, https://
www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2023/10/31/fbi-investigates-
anti-palestinian-message-american-u.
\8\Eren Orbey, The Anguished Fallout from A Pro-Palestinian Letter
at Harvard, The New Yorker, Oct. 20, 2023, https://www.newyorker.com/
news/dispatch/the-anguished-fallout-from-a-pro-palestinian-letter-at-
harvard.
\9\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On Tuesday, December 5, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Holding Campus Leaders Accountable and Confronting
Antisemitism''. On that same day, FBI director Christopher Wray
testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee, reiterating
concerns CAIR and ADL had raised earlier. His prepared
testimony stated clearly that both Jewish and Muslim
communities are threatened by violence as a result of the
October 7th Hamas attack and its aftermath.\10\ It is such
violent extremism that likely drove a gunman to shoot three
Palestinian-American college students walking down the street
in Burlington, Vermont ten days prior to our Dec. 5
hearing.\11\ In the aftermath of that shooting, which left one
student paralyzed, one of the victims wondered if such violence
would deter Muslim families from sending their children to
college in America, if they could not guarantee their safety
just walking down the street.\12\ Even with the direct
implication of Muslim-American student safety on college
campuses, there has been no Committee oversight of this
shooting, and based on the Chair's public interpretation of our
Committee's jurisdiction, we do not anticipate such oversight
from this Committee while she leads it.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Oversight of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Hearing
Before the S. Comm. on the Judic., 118th Cong. (2023) (statement of The
Hon. Christopher Wray, Director) (``Anti-Semitism and anti-Islamic
sentiment permeate many violent extremist ideologies and serves as a
primary driver for attacks by a diverse set of violent extremists who
pose a persistent threat to Jewish and Muslim communities and
institutions in the United States and abroad . . . . Some violent
extremists have used times of heightened tensions to incite violence
against religious minorities, targeting both Jewish and Muslim
Americans.'').
\11\Anna Betts & Jenna Russell, For Palestinian Student Shot in
Vermont, A Collision of Two Worlds, N.Y. Times, Nov. 29, 2023, https://
nytimes.com/2023/11/29/us/vermont-shooting-burlington-palestinian-
american.html.
\12\See id.
\13\Valerie Strauss, What Republicans Really Want from Colleges,
Wash. Post, Dec. 14, 2023, https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/
2023/12/14/what-republicans-really-want-colleges/ (``Asked about
Scott's accusation, a committee spokesman said in an email: `What
happened on UVA's campus in 2017 wasn't led by UVA students, didn't
represent the campus environment, and had nothing to do with the
institution we have jurisdiction over.''').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On January 9th, Chair Foxx sent a letter to the Senior
Fellow of the Harvard Corporation and the Interim President of
Harvard University, ``kicking off'' the Committee's
investigation of incidents of antisemitism at the
university.\14\ This was over a month after the U.S. Department
of Education's Office for Civil Rights (OCR), the executive
branch agency actually empowered under law to determine if a
school has violated student rights under Title VI of the Civil
Rights Act of 1964, announced it was opening an investigation
into antisemitism at Harvard.\15\ The letter included a litany
of antisemitic events that demands investigation. But that
letter does not cite any of the widely reported accusations of
harassment and intimidation against Palestinian, Arab, or
Muslim students at Harvard, accusations so serious that OCR
opened an investigation based on a complaint alleging such
discrimination at Harvard less than a month after the Committee
sent its letter.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Press Release, @EdWorkfrceCmte Kicks Off antisemitism
Investigation with Letter to Harvard, Jan. 9, 2024, https://
edworkforce.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=409936;
Letter from Rep. Virginia Foxx to Mrs. Penny Prtizker & Mr. Alan
Garber, (Jan. 9, 2024), https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
1.9.24_foxx_letter_to_pritzker_and_garber.pdf.
\15\E.g., Miles J. Herszenhorn & Claire Yuan, U.S. Education
Department Opens Investigation into Harvard Following Antisemitism
Complaint, Harvard Crimson, Nov. 20, 2023, https://www.thecrimson.com/
article/2023/11/30/ed-department-investigation-antisemitism/.
\16\E.g., Vimal Patel, Education Dept. Investigates Claims of
Discrimination Against Palestinian Students at Harvard, N.Y. Times, Feb
7, 2024, https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/07/us/harvard-palestinian-
discrimination-complaint.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On January 24th, the Chair sent a letter to Chairman of the
Board of Trustees and Interim President of the University of
Pennsylvania highlighting multiple antisemitic incidents on the
campus.\17\ A portion of that letter accused the school of
demonstrating a ``clear double standard by tolerating
antisemitic vandalism, harassment, and intimidation, but
suppressing and penalizing other expression it deemed
problematic.''\18\ The letter failed to mention concerns of
double standards in the policing of speech have also been
raised by students espousing pro-Palestinian beliefs on campus,
with reported claims that peaceful protesting students are
being punished ``extralegally'' and that students and alumni
have been able to dox and harass pro-Palestinian demonstrators
online ``to zero consequences.''\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Letter from Rep. Virginia Foxx to Mr. Ramanan Raghavendran and
Dr. Larry Jameson, (Jan. 24, 2024), https://edworkforce.house.gov/
uploadedfiles/penn_letter_final_v2.pdf.
\18\Id. at 7.
\19\Jin Kwon, Penn Students Voice Concerns About Free Speech,
Admin. Disciplinary Responses at U. Council Open Forum, Daily
Pennsylvanian, Feb 22, 2024, https://www.thedp.com/article/2024/02/
penn-university-council-open-forum-antisemitism-islamophobia.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On Feb. 12th, the Chair sent a letter to the Presidents and
Chairs of the Board of Trustees of Columbia University and
Barnard College (Columbia).\20\ Included in a shameful list of
antisemitic events on campus was a poster that appeared on
campus Jan. 31 that included ``an image of a blue and white
skunk with a Star of David on its back and the captions
`Beware! Skunk on Campus' and `brought to you in collaboration
by Columbia University and the IOF [Israeli Occupation
Forces].'''\21\ A reader of the letter might believe that
Jewish students at Columbia were being targeted with some new
horrid antisemitic term. That would be unless the reader was
unaware of the Jan. 19 protest on Columbia's campus where it
was alleged that two students sprayed over 20 pro-Palestinian
protesting students with a chemical agent with the brand name
Skunk, developed by a company in Israel and used by the Israeli
Defense Forces as a less-lethal crowd control weapon.\22\ While
the chemical in question was later determined to be a novelty
stink bomb, at the time the Committee began its hearing
featuring Columbia's President and Board of Trustees co-Chairs,
the allegation was still under investigation by the New York
Police Department as a hate crime.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Letter from Rep. Virginia Foxx to Dr. Minouche Shafik et al.,
(Feb. 12, 2024), https://edworkforce.house.gov/uploadedfiles/2-12-
24_foxx_letter_to_columbia_university.pdf.
\21\Id. at 5.
\22\E.g., Chris Mendell, Protesters Allegedly Sprayed with
Hazardous Chemical at Pro-Palestinian rally, nearly two dozen report,
Columbia Spectator, Jan. 22, 2024, https://www.columbiaspectator.com/
news/2024/01/22/protesters-allegedly-sprayed-with-hazardous-chemical-
at-pro-palestinian-rally-nearly-two-dozen-report/.
\23\E.g., Gaya Gupta, At Columbia, Student Protesters Say They Were
Attacked with Chemicals, N.Y. Times, Jan. 22, 2024, https://
www.nytimes.com/2024/01/22/nyregion/palestinian-protest-columbia-
university.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the time the Majority convened the May 23, 2024, hearing
with the Presidents of Rutgers University, Northwestern
University, and University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA),
there were already prominent reports of hostile environments
against Muslim or Palestinian students on all three of those
campuses, reports ignored by the Majority. At Rutgers, there
was an attack on the Rutgers Islamic Center on April 10,
2024.\24\ During the attack, windows were broken and
televisions and Islamic art with Quranic scripture were
destroyed.\25\ At Northwestern, four Palestinian Northwestern
students brought a Title VI complaint to OCR against the
Pritzker School of Law on April 17, claiming that the school
was ignoring a ``hostile anti-Palestinian environment.''\26\
Their allegations include discriminatory practices from fellow
students and administrators, and anti-Palestinian comments from
professors.\27\ Late into the night of April 30, the day UCLA
declared a student encampment was unlawful, Pro-Israel counter
protesting mobs began tearing down encampment barriers and
screaming ``Second Nakba!'' referring to the mass displacement
and dispossession of Palestinians during the 1948 Arab-Israeli
war.\28\ Video footage from the incident shows protesters being
attacked, objects being thrown into the camp, and at least one
firework being set off.\29\ Security guards were present at the
scene but did not intervene, with reports suggesting that
academic faculty participating in the encampment called 911 and
their calls were not responded to. It is important to note that
many of the Pro-Israel counter-protesters were not UCLA
students.\30\ Several injured in the protest went to the
hospital and experienced several medical injuries following
attacks with sticks, metal rods, mace, hammers, and more.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\Celina Tebor, Rutgers University Center for Islamic Life
vandalized during Eid al-Fitr, officials say, CNN, Apr. 10, 2024,
https://www.cnn.com/2024/04/10/us/rutgers-university-center-for-
islamic-life-vandalized-eid-reaj/index.html.
\25\Id.
\26\Beatrice Villaflor, Palestine Legal files Title VI complaint
against Pritzker for `hostile anti-Palestinian environment', The Daily
Northwestern, Apr. 19, 2024, https://dailynorthwestern.com/2024/04/19/
campus/palestine-legal-files-title-vi-complaint-against-pritzker-for-
hostile-anti-palestinian-environment/.
\27\Id.
\28\Jacob Gurvis, As police clear encampments at UCLA, Jewish
students say pro-Israel violence undercuts them, The Jerusalem Post,
May 3, 2024, https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/antisemitism/article-
799691.
\29\Id.
\30\Blake Ellis, et al., Unmasking counterprotesters who attacked
UCLA's pro-Palestine encampment, CNN, May 16, 2024, https://
www.cnn.com/2024/05/16/us/ucla-student-protests-counterprotesters-invs/
index.html.
\31\Will Carless, How pro-Palestinian camp, and an extremist attack
roiled the protest at UCLA, USA Today, May 3, 2024, https://
www.usatoday.com/story/news/investigations/2024/05/03/inside-ucla-
protest/73560767007/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We fervently hope that the Committee is able to get answers
from schools to the allegations of antisemitism on their
campuses that it has requested. There is no justification for
threats, violence, harassment, or intimidation against any
student on campus, especially if such threats are the result of
their shared ancestry, national origin, or ethnic
characteristics. The Committee's failure to address any such
accusation of threats, violence, harassment, or intimidation
against any Muslim student on any campus in America in the wake
of October 7th does not change this hope, but it does raise
significant concern.
We fear this oversight failure on the Committee's part will
solidify the impression that this Committee is not interested
in ensuring that al