Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.J. Res. 148]
The Committee on Ways and Means, to whom was referred the
joint resolution (H.J. Res. 148) providing for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the Department of the Treasury relating
to ``Clean Vehicle Credits Under Sections 25E and 30D; Transfer
of Credits; Critical Minerals and Battery Components; Foreign
Entities of Concern'', having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon without amendment and recommends that the
joint resolution do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND...........................................2
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 2
B. Background and Need for Legislation................. 2
C. Legislative History................................. 4
D. Legislative History................................. 4
II. EXPLANATION OF THE RESOLUTION....................................4
A. Joint Resolution of Disapproval (secs. 30D and 25E
of the Internal Revenue Code and secs. 801-808 of
title 5 of the United States Code)................. 4
1. The clean vehicle credit (sec. 30D)............. 4
2. Previously-owned clean vehicles (sec. 25E)...... 8
3. Clean vehicle regulations....................... 10
4. The Congressional Review Act.................... 10
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE...........................................11
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE RESOLUTION................................12
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects............. 12
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax
Expenditures Budget Authority...................... 12
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office............................................. 12
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE......12
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations.... 12
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and
Objectives......................................... 12
C. Applicability of House Rule XXI, Clause 5(b)........ 12
D. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates........... 13
E. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and
Limited Tariff Benefits............................ 13
F. Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 13
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE RESOLUTION, AS REPORTED.....13
VII. DISSENTING VIEWS................................................14
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
The purpose of H.J. Res. 148 is to provide for
Congressional disapproval of the rule submitted by the
Department of the Treasury relating to ``Clean Vehicle Credits
Under Sections 25E and 30D; Transfer of Credits; Critical
Minerals and Battery Components; Foreign Entities of Concern.''
Under H.J. Res. 148, the Biden Administration's China
favorable electric vehicle (EV) regulations from the Inflation
Reduction Act (IRA) would be voided, including the new rules
promulgated in the final regulations as well as previously
proposed regulations that have been addressed by the
legislation marked-up in the Ways and Means Committee.
If the Joint Resolution is approved by both houses of
Congress and signed by the President the rule at issue cannot
go into effect or continue in effect and the Administration
would have to re-write regulations in a substantially different
manner.
B. Background and Need for Legislation
The Inflation Reduction Act created generous new tax
subsidies for the manufacturing and purchase of EVs at an
enormous cost to taxpayers.
Bipartisan lawmakers have called on the Biden
Administration to craft implementing regulations that prevent
those subsidies from going to foreign entities of concern
(FEOC), like those with ties to China or other adversaries, as
originally called for in the IRA.
In April and December of 2023, the Treasury Department
issued proposed regulations for the IRA EV Credits. Pushed by
radical environmentalists and some EV producers, the Biden
Administration wrote lenient FEOC rules for the IRA EV tax
provisions which allow American tax dollars to flow to China.
Under the IRA, EVs are ineligible for a tax subsidy if they
contain battery components or critical minerals sourced from an
FEOC. This follows a similar restriction on semiconductor
grants included in the Creating Helpful Incentives to Produce
Semiconductors (CHIPS) and Science Act signed by President
Biden.
In September 2023, the Commerce Department issued rules
under the CHIPS Act that defined an FEOC as follows: 25 percent
or more of the entity's voting interest, or board seats, or
equity interest is held directly or indirectly by the
government of a country of concern (China, Russia, North Korea,
or Iran) or its officials, or by any person that is a citizen,
national, or resident of such country.
In December 2023, Treasury issued similar FEOC rules for
the EV tax subsidies but opted to make their version more
China-favorable than the Commerce Department rule. Treasury
excluded ``any person that is a citizen, national, or
resident''--so an entity owned by a wealthy foreign national
could benefit from the EV subsidies as long as his or her ties
to the Chinese Communist Party or other hostile government were
unofficial.
Treasury also defined ``battery component'' very favorably
to Chinese manufacturers, who can produce all materials and
parts upstream of the battery component and still remain
eligible to benefit from the EV tax subsidies.
The IRA requires that critical minerals in electric vehicle
batteries be sourced domestically or from a Free Trade
Agreement (FTA) partner to receive half of the $7,500 tax
credit. ``Free Trade Agreement'' is a well understood term that
refers to comprehensive trade agreements such as the U.S.-
Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), the U.S.-Australia FTA, the
U.S.-Chile FTA, and others that Congress has approved. Finding
their own law requirements too constraining, and unwilling to
allow for critical mineral production here in the U.S., the
Biden administration in these regulations is usurping Congress
by pretending a ``Critical Minerals Agreement'' with Japan was
an FTA to qualify under the IRA. Unlike FTAs approved by
Congress, Critical Mineral Agreements are superficial executive
agreements that do not substantively enhance trade with the
partner country or reduce U.S. dependency on China for critical
minerals.
On May 6, 2024, the Biden Treasury Department finalized the
full EV regulation package with an additional rule that is
supposed to honor the language of the law by making EVs
ineligible for a tax subsidy if they contain battery components
or critical minerals sourced from an FEOC, including the
Chinese Communist Party (CCP). Unfortunately, as crafted, the
rule will allow certain EV and battery component inputs
directly sourced from the CCP to skirt this restriction and
still be eligible to receive U.S. taxpayer funded subsidies
from the IRA.
The final IRA EV rule claims that if an input (e.g. battery
or critical mineral used in EVs) is currently hard to trace, it
is considered ``non-traceable'' and is not subject to the FEOC
restriction. Specifically, the Biden Administration classified
graphite as ``non-traceable,'' despite North American graphite
producers asserting that tracing graphite is highly feasible,
reliable, and effective. Graphite makes up a significant chunk
of the minerals in an electric car's battery, but its supply
chain is heavily dominated by China.
Some of the loopholes created in the regulations can be
addressed by legislation, like the Ways and Means Committee did
in April 2024 by passing legislation to reverse the Biden
Administration's rule, with the End Chinese Dominance of
Electric Vehicles in America Act and the Stop Executive
Overreach on Trade Agreements Act. Some of the regulatory
overreach was not authorized in the legislation and conflicts
with what is plainly written in law--that any input sourced
from an FEOC would make a vehicle ineligible for the subsidy.
This Joint Resolution of Disapproval is needed to protect
Congressional authority and prevent these regulations from
continuing to be in effect.
C. Legislative History
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.J. Res. 148,
the joint resolution providing for Congressional disapproval
under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule
submitted by the Department of the Treasury relating to ``Clean
Vehicle Credits Under Sections 25E and 30D; Transfer of
Credits; Critical Minerals and Battery Components; Foreign
Entities of Concern,'' on July 9, 2024, and ordered the
resolution favorably reported (with a quorum being present).
D. Legislative History
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop and consider H.J. Res. 148:
On April 19, 2023, the Committee held a Hearing on the U.S.
Tax Code Subsidizing Green Corporate Handouts and the Chinese
Communist Party.
On April 11, 2024, the Committee held a Hearing on
Expanding on the Success of the 2017 Tax Relief to Help
Hardworking Americans.
II. EXPLANATION OF THE RESOLUTION
A. Joint Resolution of Disapproval (Secs. 30D and 25E of the Internal
Revenue Code and Secs. 801-808 of Title 5 of the United States Code)
PRESENT LAW
1. The clean vehicle credit (sec. 30D)
In general
Present law allows a credit for each new clean vehicle
placed in service (the ``CV credit''). A new clean vehicle is a
motor vehicle the original use of which commences with the
taxpayer, is acquired for use or lease by the taxpayer and not
for resale, is made by a qualified manufacturer,\1\ has a gross
vehicle weight rating of less than 14,000 pounds, is treated as
a motor vehicle for purposes of title II of the Clean Air Act,
and is propelled to a significant extent by an electric motor
drawing electricity from a battery (1) with at least seven
kilowatt-hours of capacity and (2) which is capable of being
recharged from an external source of electricity.\2\ A new
clean vehicle must have final assembly occur within North
America.\3\ The person who sells the vehicle must provide a
report to the taxpayer and Secretary of the Treasury (the
``Secretary'') that includes the name and taxpayer
identification number of the taxpayer, the vehicle
identification number of the vehicle, the battery capacity of
the vehicle, verification that original use of the vehicle
commences with the taxpayer, and the maximum credit allowable
to the taxpayer with respect to the vehicle.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\A qualified manufacturer must be a manufacturer as defined in
regulations prescribed by the Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency for purposes of the administration of title II of the
Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. sec. 7521 et seq.) and must provide periodic
written reports to the Secretary which include vehicle identification
numbers. Sec. 30D(d)(3). Unless otherwise stated, all section
references are to the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
\2\Sec. 30D(d)(1).
\3\Sec. 30D(d)(1)(G).
\4\Sec. 30D(d)(1)(H).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
New qualified fuel cell motor vehicles which have final
assembly within North America and for which sellers provide a
report, as described above, are new clean vehicles for purposes
of the credit.\5\ A new qualified fuel cell motor vehicle is a
motor vehicle propelled by power derived from one or more cells
which convert chemical energy directly into electricity by
combining oxygen with hydrogen fuel stored on board the vehicle
and which has received certain emissions-standard
certification.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Sec. 30D(d)(6).
\6\As defined in section 30B(b)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A vehicle with any applicable critical minerals in the
battery that are extracted, processed, or recycled by a foreign
entity of concern that are placed in service after December 31,
2024, or a vehicle with any components contained in the battery
of the vehicle that are manufactured or assembled by a foreign
entity of concern that are placed in service after December 31,
2023 does not qualify for the credit.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Sec. 30D(d)(7). Treasury and the U.S. Department of Energy have
released final regulations on excluded entities for the clean vehicle
credit and foreign entities of concern. See Notice of Final Rulemaking,
89 Fed. Reg. 33706, May 6, 2024, and Notice of Final Rulemaking, 89
Fed. Reg. 37079, May 6, 2024, respectively.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A foreign entity of concern\8\ is a foreign entity that is
(1) designated as a foreign terrorist organization by the
Secretary of State; (2) included on the list of specially
designated nationals and blocked persons maintained by the
Office of Foreign Assets Control of the Department of the
Treasury (``SDN list''); (3) owned by, controlled by, or
subject to the jurisdiction or direction of the government of a
covered nation;\9\ (4) alleged by the Attorney General to have
been involved in activities for which a conviction was obtained
under certain laws;\10\ or (5) determined by the Secretary of
Energy, in consultation with the Secretary of Defense and the
Director of National Intelligence, to be engaged in
unauthorized conduct that is detrimental to the national
security or foreign policy of the United States.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\As defined in 42 U.S.C. sec. 18741(a)(5).
\9\10 U.S.C. sec. 4872(d). Covered nation means the Democratic
People's Republic of North Korea, the People's Republic of China, the
Russian Federation, and the Islamic Republic of Iran.
\10\42 U.S.C. sec. 18741(a)(5)(D).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CV credit amount
A new clean vehicle is eligible for a maximum credit of up
to $7,500 if certain requirements are met. One $3,750 amount is
allowed if a critical minerals requirement for the battery is
met.\11\ Another $3,750 amount is allowed if a battery
components requirement is met.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Sec. 30D(b)(2).
\12\Sec. 30D(b)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critical minerals requirement
To satisfy the critical minerals requirement, a new clean
vehicle's battery (from which the electric motor draws
electricity) must have a percentage of the value of applicable
critical minerals\13\ that were (1) extracted or processed in
the United States or a country that has a free trade
agreement\14\ with the United States or (2) recycled in North
America, which is equal to or greater than an applicable
percentage.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Critical minerals as defined in sec. 45X(c)(6).
\14\Treasury has released final regulations on the clean vehicle
credit which include interpreting the term free trade agreement. See
Notice of Final Rulemaking, 89 Fed. Reg. 37079, May 6, 2024.
\15\Sec. 30D(e)(1)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For this purpose, the applicable percentage is 40 percent
for a vehicle placed in service before January 1, 2024. The
applicable percentage is 50 percent for a vehicle placed in
service during calendar year 2024, 60 percent for 2025, 70
percent for 2026, and 80 percent after 2026.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Sec. 30D(e)(1)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Battery components requirement
To satisfy the battery components requirement, a new clean
vehicle's battery (from which the electric motor draws
electricity) must have a percentage of the value of components
that were manufactured or assembled in North America equal to
or greater than an applicable percentage.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Sec. 30D(e)(2)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For this purpose the applicable percentage is 50 percent
for a vehicle placed in service before January 1, 2024. The
applicable percentage is 60 percent for a vehicle placed in
service during calendar year 2024 or 2025, 70 percent for 2026,
80 percent for 2027, 90 percent for 2028, and 100 percent after
2028.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Sec. 30D(e)(2)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vehicle price and AGI limitations
The manufacturer's suggested retail price (``MSRP'') of a
new clean vehicle purchased by the taxpayer may not exceed
certain limitations. That is, the credit amount is $0 if the
MSRP for the vehicle exceeds the applicable limitation. This
limitation is $80,000 in the case of a van, sport utility
vehicle, or pickup truck, and $55,000 in the case of any other
vehicle. The Secretary is directed to release regulations or
guidance to characterize vehicles into the appropriate category
by applying rules similar to those employed by the
Environmental Protection Agency (``EPA'') and the Department of
Energy to determine vehicle class and size.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\Sec. 30D(f)(11). Treasury has released final regulations on the
clean vehicle credit which include the determination of vehicle
classifications. See Notice of Final Rulemaking, 89 Fed. Reg. 37079,
May 6, 2024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, no credit is allowed if the taxpayer's income
exceeds $300,000 in the case of a joint return or surviving
spouse, $225,000 in the case of a head of household, or
$150,000 in the case of any other taxpayer.\20\ For purposes of
this limitation, the taxpayer's income is the lesser of
modified adjusted gross income (``AGI'') of the current taxable
year or modified AGI of the preceding taxable year.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Sec. 30D(f)(10).
\21\``Modified AGI'' is AGI increased by any amount excluded from
gross income under section 911, 931, or 933. Sec. 30D(f)(10)(C).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Transfer of credit
A taxpayer who has purchased or leased a vehicle may elect
to transfer the credit to an eligible entity, subject to
regulations or guidance the Secretary deems necessary.\22\ The
eligible entity is then treated as the taxpayer with respect to
the credit.\23\ The Secretary is directed to establish a
program to provide advance payments of these credit amounts to
eligible entities.\24\ An election to transfer the credit must
be made on or before the date of vehicle purchase.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Treasury has released final regulations on the transfer of
clean vehicle credits. See Notice of Final Rulemaking, 89 Fed. Reg.
37079, May 6, 2024.
\23\Sec. 30D(g)(1).
\24\Sec. 30D(g)(7).
\25\Sec. 30D(g)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An eligible entity is a dealer\26\ which meets the
following requirements: First, the dealer must be registered
with the Secretary. Second, prior to the election of transfer,
the dealer must disclose information to the buyer on the MSRP
price of the vehicle, value of the credit or other incentives
available, and the amount provided by the dealer as a condition
of an election to transfer. Third, the dealer must pay the
taxpayer for the amount of the credit allowable.\27\ Finally,
the dealer must ensure that the availability or use of any
other available manufacturer or dealer incentive does not limit
the ability of the taxpayer to make an election and that the
election will not limit the value or use of any such
incentive.\28\ The Secretary may revoke the registration of
dealers that fail to comply with these requirements.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\A dealer is a person licensed by a State, territory of the
United States, Indian tribal government, or Alaska Native Corporation
to engage in the sale of vehicles. Sec. 30D(g)(8).
\27\The payment may be in cash or in the form of a partial down
payment for the purchase of the vehicle.
\28\Sec. 30D(g)(2).
\29\Sec. 30D(g)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The payment made by dealers to buyers in connection with a
credit transfer election is not includable in the gross income
of the taxpayer and is not deductible to the dealer.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\Sec. 30D(g)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If a taxpayer that does not meet the AGI requirements for
the credit elects to transfer a credit and receives a payment
in connection with such credit transfer, the tax liability of
such taxpayer is increased by the amount of such payment.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Sec. 30D(g)(10).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other rules
A vehicle that is predominantly used outside the United
States does not qualify for the credit.\32\ A vehicle must meet
certain emissions and safety standards in order to qualify for
the credit.\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\Sec. 30D(f)(4).
\33\Sec. 30D(f)(7).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The basis of any qualified vehicle is reduced by the amount
of the credit.\34\ The portion of the credit attributable to
vehicles of a character subject to an allowance for
depreciation is treated as part of the general business credit;
the nonbusiness portion of the credit is allowable to the
extent of the excess of the regular tax and the alternative
minimum tax (reduced by certain other credits) for the taxable
year.\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\34\Sec. 30D(f)(1).
\35\Sec. 30D(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Only one credit is allowed for each vehicle and a taxpayer
must include the vehicle identification number of the vehicle
on a tax return to claim the credit.\36\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\Sec. 30D(f)(8) and (9).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Expiration
No credit is allowed for any vehicle placed in service
after December 31, 2032.\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\37\Sec. 30D(h).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Previously-owned clean vehicles (sec. 25E)
In general
Present law allows a credit for previously-owned clean
vehicle placed in service by a qualified buyer (the
``previously-owned CV credit''). A previously-owned clean
vehicle is a motor vehicle with a model year at least two years
earlier than the calendar year in which the taxpayer acquires
the vehicle, the original use of which commences with a person
other than the taxpayer, which has a gross vehicle weight
rating of less than 14,000 pounds,\38\ and which is acquired by
the taxpayer in a qualified sale.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\38\Sec. 25E(c)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A qualified sale is a sale by a dealer\39\ that is the
first transfer since the date of enactment of section 25E
(August 16, 2022)\40\ to a qualified buyer other than the
person with whom the original use of such vehicle
commenced.\41\ A qualified sale does not include a transfer to
a qualified buyer made after the vehicle has been used and
owned by a person other than the person with whom the original
use of such vehicle commenced, even if such use and ownership
was not by a qualified buyer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\A dealer is a person licensed by a State, territory of the
United States, Indian tribal government, or Alaska Native Corporation
to engage in the sale of vehicles. Sec. 30D(g)(8).
\40\The date of enactment of Pub. L. No. 117-169.
\41\Sec. 25E(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, a previously-owned clean vehicle must be an
electric vehicle or a fuel cell vehicle that satisfies certain
criteria. Specifically, a previously-owned clean vehicle must
also either (1) be propelled to a significant extent by an
electric motor drawing electricity from a battery (a) with at
least seven kilowatt-hours of capacity and (b) which is capable
of being recharged from an external source of electricity, made
by a qualified manufacturer, treated as a motor vehicle for
purposes of title II of the Clean Air Act, and with respect to
which the person who sells the vehicle provide a report to the
taxpayer and Secretary that includes the name and taxpayer
identification number of the taxpayer, the vehicle
identification number of the vehicle, the battery capacity of
the vehicle, and the maximum credit allowable to the taxpayer
with respect to the vehicle;\42\ or (2) be propelled by power
derived from one or more cells which convert chemical energy
directly into electricity by combining oxygen with hydrogen
fuel stored on board the vehicle and which has received certain
emissions-standard certification.\43\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\42\Sec. 25E(c)(1)(D)(i).
\43\Sec. 25E(c)(1)(D)(ii). Fuel cell vehicles must satisfy the
requirements of section 30B(b)(3)(A) and (B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A qualified buyer is an individual who purchases a vehicle
for use and not resale, who cannot be claimed as a dependent,
and during the three-year period prior to such purchase, has
not made any purchases for which a previously-owned CV credit
was claimed.
Previously-owned CV credit amount
The amount of the credit is the lesser of (1) $4,000 or (2)
30 percent of the sale price of the vehicle.\44\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\44\Sec. 25E(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The sale price of a previously-owned clean vehicle
purchased by the taxpayer may not exceed $25,000.\45\ That is,
the credit amount is $0 if the sale price for the vehicle
exceeds this amount.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\45\Sec. 25E(c)(2)(B).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, no credit is allowed if the taxpayer's income
exceeds $150,000 in the case of a joint return or surviving
spouse, $112,500 in the case of a head of household, or $75,0