Background and Need for Legislation
Congress enacted the 1972 amendments to the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act, commonly referred to as the Clean Water
Act (CWA), with the goal to ``restore and maintain the
chemical, physical, and biological integrity of the Nation's
waters.''\1\ The CWA protects ``navigable waters,'' which is
defined in the CWA as the ``waters of the United States,
including the territorial seas.''\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\CWA, Pub. L. No. 92-500, 86 Stat. 816.
\2\Id. at Sec. 502(7).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, the CWA does not further define the term ``waters
of the United States'' (WOTUS), leaving it up to EPA and the
Corps to define which waters are subject to Federal regulation
under the CWA. Since the CWA grants authority to EPA and the
Corps to implement the Act, EPA and the Corps have promulgated
several sets of rules interpreting the agencies' jurisdiction
over WOTUS and the corresponding scope of CWA authority.
A clear WOTUS definition consistent with Congressional
intent is important, as the definition of WOTUS governs the
application of CWA programs.\3\ For example, the CWA in
Sections 402 and 404 prohibits the discharge of any pollutant
by any person into ``navigable waters,'' unless in compliance
with one of the enumerated permitting provisions in the Act.
The two permitting authorities in the CWA are Section 402 (the
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System, or ``NPDES'')
for discharges of pollutants from point sources, and Section
404, for discharges of dredged or fill material.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Id. at Sec. Sec. 301, 303, 311, 401, 402, 404.
\4\Id. at Sec. Sec. 402(b) and 404.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When Congress passed the CWA in 1972, it never intended for
the Federal Government to have jurisdiction over every water in
the Nation.\5\ During a recent Subcommittee on Water Resources
and Environment hearing on February 8, 2023, entitled
``Stakeholder Perspectives on the Impacts of the Biden
Administration's Waters of the United States (WOTUS) Rule,''
this was further elaborated on by Ms. Susan Parker Bodine,
Partner at Earth & Water Law LLC, who stated, ``Congress did
not tell EPA and the Corps: `do whatever you think is necessary
to protect water.' Instead, the CWA . . . carefully prescribes
federal authority.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\See Brief of Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, Rep. Sam Graves, and a
Coalition of 199 Members of Congress as Amici Curiae supporting
Petitioners, Sackett v. EPA, No. 21-454, (Oct. 3, 2022).
\6\Stakeholder Perspectives on the Impacts of the Biden
Administration's Waters of the United States (WOTUS) Rule: Hearing
before the Subcomm. on Water Resources and Environment of the H. Comm.
on Transportation and Infrastructure, 118th Cong. (2023) (written
testimony of Ms. Susan Parker Bodine, Partner, Earth & Water Law LLC).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 1985, the Supreme Court took up United States v.
Riverside Bayview Homes, Inc. (Riverside Bayview).\7\ The Court
unanimously upheld the Corps' jurisdiction over wetlands
adjacent to jurisdictional waters and held that such wetlands
were ``waters of the United States'' under the CWA.\8\
Following Riverside Bayview, EPA and the Corps promulgated
regulations in 1986 and 1988, which remained in effect for much
of the past several decades.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\United States v. Riverside Bayview Homes, 474 U.S. 121 (1985).
\8\See id.
\9\Final Rule for Regulatory Programs of the Corps of Engineers, 51
Fed. Reg. 41206 (November 13, 1986); Clean Water Act Section 404
Program Definitions and Permit Exemptions, Section 404 State Regulation
Programs, 53 Fed. Reg. 20764 (June 6, 1988).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2001, the Court ruled in Solid Waste Agency of Northern
Cook County v. Army Corps of Engineers (``SWANCC''), evaluating
whether CWA jurisdiction included an abandoned sand and gravel
pit which had become a habitat for migratory birds.\10\ A 5-4
decision rejected the Corps' claim that CWA jurisdiction
extended over isolated waters purely based on their usage by
migratory birds, but did not affect the agencies' underlying
regulations defining WOTUS.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County (SWANCC) v. U.S.
Army Corps of Engineers, 531 U.S. 159 (2001).
\11\See generally Stephen P. Mulligan, Evolution of the meaning of
``waters of the United States'' in the Clean Water Act, Cong. Research
Service (R44585), updated March 5, 2019, [hereinafter CRS Report
R44585], available at https://www.crs.gov/reports/pdf/R44585/
R44585.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2006, the Supreme Court issued a 4-1-4 opinion in
Rapanos v. United States (Rapanos) that did not produce a
clear, legal standard on determining jurisdiction under the
CWA.\12\ Justice Scalia's plurality opinion provided a
``relatively permanent/flowing waters'' test with ``continuous
surface connection.''\13\ Writing alone, Justice Kennedy
proposed a ``significant nexus'' test for WOTUS, concluding
that a case-by-case basis for determining navigable waters was
appropriate.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Rapanos v. United States, 547 U.S. 715 (2006).
\13\Id. at 739, 742.
\14\Id. at 782 (Kennedy, J., concurring).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since Rapanos, successive Administrations have struggled to
interpret the term waters of the United States for the purpose
of implementing various requirements of the CWA.\15\ Prior to
the Biden Administration, executive branch efforts to define
WOTUS administratively included regulations promulgated by the
Corps and EPA in the 1980s and supplemented with interpretive
guidance developed in response to Supreme Court rulings; the
2015 Clean Water Rule; and the 2020 Navigable Waters Protection
Rule.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Laura Gatz & Kate R. Bowers, Redefining waters of the United
States (WOTUS): Recent developments, CONG. RESEARCH SERVICE (R46927),
updated July 8, 2022 [hereinafter CRS REPORT R46927], available at
https://www.crs.gov/reports/pdf/R46927/R46927.pdf.
\16\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The agencies' efforts to define WOTUS in regulation during
both the Obama and Trump Administrations were controversial and
led to litigation. Many observers viewed the Obama
Administration's 2015 Clean Water Rule as defining WOTUS too
broadly, while many viewed the Trump Administration's 2020
Navigable Waters Protection Rule (NWPR) as defining WOTUS too
narrowly. The Obama Administration's Clean Water Rule relied on
the significant nexus test while simultaneously expanding the
number of waters categorically deemed as WOTUS, thus capturing
more waters under Federal control.\17\ This rule was
significantly challenged in the courts and rescinded under the
Trump Administration.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Clean Water Rule: Definition of ``waters of the United
States'', Final Rule, 80 Fed. Reg. 37,054 (June 29, 2015), available at
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2015-06-29/pdf/2015-13435.pdf.
\18\See Definition of ``Waters of the United States''-
Recodification of Pre-Existing Rules, 84 Fed. Reg. 56,626 (Oct. 22,
2019), available at https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2019-10-22/
pdf/2019-20550.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The NWPR focused on relatively permanent bodies of water
that provide surface flow to traditional navigable waters in a
typical year.\19\ As such, the WOTUS definition provided in the
NWPR was more consistent with the Scalia opinion in Rapanos,
and provided clarity for Americans subject to CWA provisions. A
federal district court vacated the Navigable Waters Protection
Rule in September 2021.\20\ However, during a recent
Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment hearing on the
February 8, 2023, a witness, Mr. Garrett Hawkins, President of
the Missouri Farm Bureau, testified that ``[t]he bright lines
under the NWPR . . . were appreciated because, for the first
time, we actually felt certainty.''\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\The Navigable Waters Protection Rule: Definition of ``Waters of
the United States,'' 85 Fed. Reg. 22250 (April 21, 2020).
\20\See Pascua Yaqui Tribe, et. al. v. EPA, No. CV-20-00266 (D.
Ariz. Aug. 30, 2021).
\21\Stakeholder Perspectives on the Impacts of the Biden
Administration's Waters of the United States (WOTUS) Rule: Hearing
before the Subcomm. on Water Resources and Environment of the H. Comm.
on Transportation and Infrastructure, 118th Cong. (2023) (statement of
Mr. Garrett Hawkins, President, Missouri Farm Bureau).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In January 2021, President Biden signed Executive Order
13990, revoking President Trump's Executive Order directing EPA
and the Corps to revise and rescind the 2015 Clean Water
Rule.\22\ In June of 2021, EPA and the Corps officially
announced their intent to revise the WOTUS definition.\23\
Following a rulemaking process intended to return the
regulatory landscape to pre-2015 Clean Water Rule
implementation and gauge stakeholder perspectives, the agencies
issued a proposed Rule to change the definition of WOTUS in
December 2021.\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Exec. Order No. 13,990, (Jan. 20, 2021), available at https://
www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2021-01-25/pdf/2021-01765.pdf.
\23\Press Release, EPA, EPA, Army announce intent to revise
definition of WOTUS, (June 9, 2021), available at https://www.epa.gov/
newsreleases/epa-army-announce-intent-revise-definition-wotus.
\24\Revised Definition of ``Waters of the United States'', 86 Fed.
Reg. 69,372 (2021), available at https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/
FR-2021-12-07/pdf/2021-25601.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On January 18, 2023, EPA and the Corps published their
final rule entitled the ``Revised Definition of the `Waters of
the United States'''.\25\ This WOTUS definition builds upon the
pre-2015 regulations, while authorizing CWA jurisdiction under
either the ``relatively permanent waters'' or ``significant
nexus'' test concepts.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Revised Definition of ``waters of the United States'' Final
Rule, 88 Fed. Reg. 3004 (Jan. 18, 2023).
\26\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EPA and the Corps state that the new WOTUS definition will
have only minimal economic impact when compared to the 1986
regulations currently in place due to the vacatur of the NWPR.
However, the Small Business Administration's (SBA's)
independent Office of Advocacy denotes:
``The Agencies estimate that CWA Sec. 404 permit
costs would increases between $108.6 million to $275.9
million for projects based in 26 states in transmitting
from the NWPR to the proposed rule. These amounts do
not reflect costs for Sec. 404 projects in the
remaining States and other jurisdictions subject to CWA
jurisdiction, nor do they reflect additional costs
increases associated with other CWA programs, such as
Section 402 permitting or Section 311 oil spill
prevention plans.''\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\SBA, Off. of Advoc., SBA, Comment Letter on the EPA and Army's
Proposed Rule defining ``the waters of the United States'' under the
CWA (Feb. 7, 2022), available at https://cdn.advocacy.sba.gov/wp-
content/uploads/2022/02/08152154/Comment-Letter-Proposed-WOTUS-
Definition-2022.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, regulatory delays, increased permitting
costs, and legal fees caused by this action will drive up the
costs to grow food, create energy, and build critical
infrastructure. Ms. Alicia Huey of the National Association of
Home Builders, in written testimony provided for the February
8, 2023, Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment
hearing, explained that ``government regulations from federal,
state and local governments account for up to 25 [percent] of
the price of a new single-family home and over 40 [percent] of
multifamily development.''\28\ The increased costs associated
with obtaining CWA permits using the EPA and the Corps' new
definition of WOTUS will be passed on to the American
economy.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\Stakeholder Perspectives on the Impacts of the Biden
Administration's Waters of the United States (WOTUS) Rule: Hearing
before the Subcomm. on Water Resources and Environment of the H. Comm.
on Transportation and Infrastructure, 118th Cong. (2023) (written
testimony of Ms. Alicia Huey, Chairman, National Association of Home
Builders).
\29\See David Sunding & Gina Waterfield, Review of the EPA and Corp
2021 Economic Analysis for the Proposed ``Revised Definition of `Waters
of the United States''' Rule, compiled for Waters Advocacy Coalition,
(Feb. 7, 2022), available at https://www.ipaa.org/wp-content/uploads/
2022/02/2022-WAC-Final-Exhibit-10.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Notably, EPA and the Corps continued with the WOTUS
rulemaking despite a pending Supreme Court case, Sackett v. EPA
(Sackett), which could affect the definition of WOTUS.\30\ On
January 24, 2022, the Court announced it would take the
case.\31\ The Court then heard oral arguments in Sackett on
October 3, 2022, and a ruling is expected in 2023. However,
throughout all this, EPA and the Corps continued with the rule,
publishing the final version in January 2023.\32\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\Sackett v. EPA, cert. granted, (21-454) 142 S. Ct. 896 (Jan.
24, 2022).
\31\Supreme Court takes WOTUS case, E&E News Greenwire, Jan. 4,
2022, available at https://www.eenews.net/articles/supreme-court-takes-
wotus-case/.
\32\Revised definition of ``waters of the United States'' Final
Rule, 88 Fed Reg. 3004 (Jan. 18, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Sackett case could be resolved with a narrow ruling
based solely on the facts of the case.\33\ However, Sackett may
also be an opportunity for the Supreme Court to rule broadly on
what the proper test is for determining WOTUS.\34\ Depending on
the Court's decision in Sackett, much of the Biden
Administration's WOTUS rule could be inapplicable and
irrelevant.\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\Ariel Wittenberg & Hannah Northey, Can EPA's Clean Water Rule
survive the courts, E&E News, Jan. 3, 2023, available at https://
www.eenews.net/articles/can-epas-clean-water-act-rule-survive-the-
courts
\34\Id.
\35\Bobby Magill, EPA's Federal waters update seen vulnerable at
top court, Bloomberg Law (Jan. 4, 2023), available at https://
news.bloomberglaw.com/environment-and-energy/epas-federal-waters-
clarification-seen-vulnerable-at-top-court.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.J. Res. 27 returns the WOTUS definition to the guidelines
promulgated by EPA and the Corps in 1986, which is the standard
when Administration rules are vacated or stayed in the
courts.\36\ These guidelines were put in place 20 years prior
to the 2006 Rapanos decision, and therefore do not include the
``significant nexus'' test. Pursuant to the Congressional
Review Act (CRA), H.J. Res. 27 would not prohibit EPA and the
Corps from writing a new WOTUS definition, post Sackett
decision. However, if this joint resolution of disapproval is
enacted, the CRA provides that a future rule may not be issued
in a ``substantially the same form'' as the disapproved rule
unless it is specifically authorized by a subsequent law.\37\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\Susan Parker Bodine, Comment Letter on the EPA and Army's
Proposed Rule defining ``the waters of the United States'' under the
CWA (Feb. 7, 2022), available at https://www.regulations.gov/comment/
EPA-HQ-OW-2021-0602-2327.
\37\Pub. L. No. 104-121, Sec. 801(b); see also Bowers and Gatz,
``Waters of the United States (WOTUS): Frequently Asked Questions About
the Scope of the Clean Water Act (R47408), Congressional Research
Service.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.J. Res. 27 would invalidate the ``Revised Definition of
the `Waters of the United States''' replacement Rule
promulgated by EPA and the Corps.
Hearings
For the purposes of rule XIII, clause 3(c)(6)(A) of the
118th Congress--
The following hearing was used to develop or consider H.J.
Res. 27: the Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment
held a hearing titled, ``Stakeholder Perspectives on the
Impacts of the Biden Administration's Waters of the United
States (WOTUS) Rule.'' At the hearing Members received
testimony from Mr. Garrett Hawkins, President, Missouri Farm
Bureau, Ms. Alicia Huey, Chairman, National Association of Home
Builders, Mr. Mark Williams, Environmental Manager, Luck
Companies, on behalf of National Stone, Sand & Gravel
Association, Ms. Susan Parker Bodine, Partner, Earth & Water
Law LLC, and Mr. Dave Owen, Professor of Law and Faculty
Director of Scholarly Publications, UC College of the Law, San
Francisco. This hearing examined the rule from the EPA and
Corps redefining the term ``waters of the United States,''
under the CWA, and the regulatory impact of the rule on
interested stakeholders.
LEGISLATIVE HISTORY AND CONSIDERATION
H.J. Res. 27, Providing for congressional disapproval under
Chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted
by the Department of the Army, Corps of Engineers, Department
of Defense and the Environmental Protection Agency relating to
`Revised Definition of ``Waters of the United States''', was
introduced in the United States House of Representatives on
February 2, 2023, by Mr. Graves of Missouri, Mr. Rouzer of
North Carolina, and 147 original co-sponsors and referred to
the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. Within the
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, H.J. Res. 27
was referred to the Subcommittee on Water Resources and
Environment. The Subcommittee on Water Resources and
Environment was discharged from further consideration of H.J.
Res. 27 on February 28, 2023.
The Committee considered H.J. Res. 27 on February 28, 2023,
and ordered the measure to be reported to the House with a
favorable recommendation, without amendment, by a recorded vote
of 30 yeas to 24 nays.
Dissenting Views
Clean water is a basic need--essential for the health and
safety of our communities, our families, and our overall
environment. Clean water is also vital to the success of the
nation's economy and to the businesses and industries that rely
on safe, sustainable, and reliable sources of clean water.
Simply put, clean water is critical to our very survival--for
without water, we simply could not live.
House Democrats stand for clean water.
House Democrats led the charge in the 117th Congress for
enactment of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law (BIL), which
provided $13 billion in clean water infrastructure
investments.\1\ This once-in-a-generation infusion of federal
funding will help address the wastewater infrastructure needs
of local communities regardless of size or geographic location.
With the additional $2.2 billion in local BIL investments
announced in February of 2023 through the Clean Water State
Revolving Fund, we are just starting to realize the human
health, economic, and environmental benefits of this
transformative law.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pub. L. 117-58.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
House Democrats also stand for comprehensive rules that
protect our water while providing certainty and predictability
to states, businesses, local governments, farmers, hunters and
fishers, and American citizens who depend on clean water for
their lives and livelihoods. Critical to that effort, House
Democrats recognize that we need to do everything we can to
ensure we have safe, sufficient and sustainable supplies of
water to meet our economic and agricultural needs, our quality-
of-life needs, and our day-to-day survival.
This Congressional Review Act (CRA) resolution, H.J. Res.
27, is the latest attack on clean water in communities all
around the country. It will create ambiguity and confusion over
protecting the rivers, streams, and other waterbodies that
provide drinking water to over 117 million Americans at a time
when many states are facing historic droughts.\2\ It will hurt
efforts to restore protections for rivers, streams, and
wetlands gutted by the previous administration.\3\ It
recklessly ties the hands of federal agencies seeking to
provide predictability for farmers and developers while
protecting our nation's water quality and supply. It frustrates
state and local efforts to protect locally important
waterbodies and create greater uncertainty and anxiety over
future sustainable drinking and agricultural water supplies.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\See EPA, ``Percentage of Surface Drinking Water from
Intermittent, Ephemeral, and Headwater Streams,'' found at https://
www.epa.gov/cwa-404/geographic-information-systems-analysis-surface-
drinking-water-providedintermittent.
\3\The previous administration's Navigable Waters Protection Rule
(85 Fed. Reg. 22250, Apr. 21, 2020) removed historic Clean Water Act
protections on over 50 percent of the nation's remaining wetlands and
up to 70 percent of its rivers, lakes, and streams. A federal district
court overturned the Rule in 2021 (Pascua Yaqui Tribe, et. al. v. EPA,
No. CV-20-00266 (D. Ariz. Aug. 30, 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In our view, protection of the nation's water quality and
regulatory certainty can go hand in hand, as demonstrated by
the current administration's efforts to restore legally
justified and scientifically based regulations defining those
waters protected by the Clean Water Act.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\USACE and EPA, Revised Definition of ``Waters of the United
States'' (88 Fed. Reg. 3004, Jan. 18, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This CRA resolution is the wrong tool to make changes to
Clean Water Act regulations. Instead of improving the
regulations or adding greater certainty, enacting this CRA
resolution will create chaos and void important clarifications
and exclusions that farmers, ranchers, and landowners rely on.
This resolution will lessen, not increase, certainty, and
will harm national efforts to protect the health of our
waterbodies and the communities, businesses, and economy that
depend on clean water.
In our view, this CRA resolution is a big mistake and
should be rejected.
Rick Larsen,
Ranking Member.
Grace F. Napolitano,
Ranking Member, Subcommittee
on Water Resources and
Environment.
Eleanor Holmes Norton.
Steve Cohen.
Henry C. ``Hank'' Johnson, Jr.
Andre Carson.
Dina Titus.
Jared Huffman.
Julia Brownley.
Frederica S. Wilson.
Donald M. Payne, Jr.
Mark DeSaulnier.
Jake Auchincloss.
Troy A. Carter, Sr.
Rob Menendez.
Emilia Sykes.
Valerie Foushee.