Minority Views
[To accompany H.J. Res. 127]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the joint resolution (H.J. Res. 127) providing for
congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United
States Code, of the rule submitted by the Securities and
Exchange Commission relating to ``The Enhancement and
Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors'',
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon without
amendment and recommends that the joint resolution do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Related Hearings................................................. 3
Committee Consideration.......................................... 3
Committee Votes.................................................. 3
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 5
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 5
Congressional Budget Office Estimates............................ 5
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 6
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 6
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 6
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 6
Earmark Identification........................................... 6
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 6
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 7
Minority Views................................................... 8
Purpose and Summary
Introduced on April 8, 2024, by Representative Bill
Huizenga, H.J. Res. 127, a resolution providing for
congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United
States Code, of the rule submitted by the Securities and
Exchange Commission relating to the ``Enhancement and
Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors,''
would rescind the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC)
rule ``The Enhancement and Standardization of Climate-Related
Disclosures for Investors.''
Background and Need for Legislation
On March 6, 2024, the Securities and Exchange Commission
(``SEC'') voted 3-2 to adopt an 886-page rule entitled ``The
Enhancement and Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures
for Investors'' (``the Climate Rule'' or ``the rule''). The
rule introduces sweeping changes to existing disclosure
obligations for public companies. Among its many requirements,
the rule imposes new obligations including but not limited to
scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas (``GHG'') emissions; climate-
related risks; board oversight of climate risks; management's
assessment and management of climate-related risks; climate-
related targets and goals; and financial statement effects of
certain climate related risks. In adopting the final rule, the
SEC overstepped its authority by finalizing climate-related
regulations without a clear directive from Congress. The rule
will have ripple effects that will be felt throughout the
economy.
Shortly after adoption, numerous lawsuits challenging the
rule were filed, including by companies, trade groups and
attorneys general from several Republican-led states. On March
15, 2024, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals granted a request
for an administrative stay on the rule. The stay was
subsequently lifted and, following the SEC's request to
consolidate pending litigation, the Eighth Circuit Court of
Appeals was selected via a lottery to hear the consolidated
case. On April 4, 2024, the SEC voluntarily stayed the rule
pending the outcome of ongoing litigation.
The SEC should not have finalized the Climate Rule. For
example, the Climate Rule likely violates the major questions
doctrine, which requires agencies to decide on issues of major
political or economic significance only where there is clear
Congressional authority. As Committee Republicans have
repeatedly made clear, Congress never authorized the SEC to
promulgate climate-related regulations. Moreover, to comply
with the Administrative Procedure Act (``APA''), the SEC should
have re-proposed the rule after significant changes had been
made. Finally, there are serious concerns that the types of
disclosures required by the rule compel speech in violation of
the First Amendment. In fact, the information that must be
disclosed is not ``purely factual and uncontroversial'' and may
be used as an attempt to name and shame market participants.
Notwithstanding several notable changes to the proposed
rule, the Climate Rule remains an unworkable and overly
burdensome attempt to achieve progressive climate policy goals.
For example, the rule deviates from the materiality standard,
replacing a principles-based approach to disclosures with
several prescriptive new requirements. Despite arguments to the
contrary, the disclosures required by the rule will overwhelm,
not inform, everyday investors. In addition, the rule will
substantially increase costs, litigation risk, and operational
complexity while providing no comparable benefits to companies
or investors. Given the rule's relatively short timeline for
compliance, public companies must act immediately to adhere to
the rule's requirements. Ultimately, everyday Americans will
suffer, as companies will hire fewer employees, raise prices to
afford higher compliance costs, or avoid going public.
RELATED HEARINGS
118TH CONGRESS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop H.J. Res. 127: The full Committee
on Financial Services held a hearing on April 10, 2024, titled
``Beyond Scope: How the SEC's Climate Rule Threatens American
Markets.''
Committee Consideration
The Committee on Financial Services met in open session on
April 17, 2024, and ordered H.J. Res. 127 to be reported
favorably to the House by a recorded vote of 28 ayes to 22 nays
(Record vote no. FC-137), a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee to list the record votes
on the order to report legislation and amendments thereto. H.J.
Res. 127 was ordered reported favorably to the House by a
recorded vote of 28 ayes to 22 nays (Record vote no. FC-137), a
quorum being present.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
COMMITTEE OVERSIGHT FINDINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee, based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.J. Res. 127 is to
rescind the SEC's rule ``The Enhancement and Standardization of
Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors.''
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE ESTIMATES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following is the cost estimate
provided by the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.J. Res. 127 would disapprove a final rule published by
the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in March 2024.\1\
By invoking a legislative process established in the
Congressional Review Act, the resolution would repeal the rule
and prohibit the agency from issuing the same or any similar
rule in the future.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Securities and Exchange Commission, ``The Enhancement and
Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures for Investors,'' Final
Rule, 89 Fed. Reg. 21688 (March 28, 2024), https://tinyurl.com/
3zxsjsp9.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The rule requires public companies that are subject to the
SEC's reporting requirements to disclose material risks from
climate-related effects on the company's financial condition.
CBO estimates that repealing the rule would have an
insignificant effect on the SEC's costs. Because the SEC is
authorized to collect fees each year to offset its annual
appropriation, CBO expects that the net effect on discretionary
spending over the 2024-2029 period would be negligible,
assuming appropriation actions consistent with that authority.
CBO also expects that repealing the rule could reduce civil
monetary penalties that the SEC may seek against individuals
and companies that violate the disclosure requirements of the
rule. Civil monetary penalties are recorded as revenues in the
federal budget. CBO expects that companies would generally
comply with the requirements in that rule and thus any
reduction in civil monetary penalties under the bill would be
insignificant over the 2024-2034 period.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Aurora Swanson.
The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss, Deputy
Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY, ENTITLEMENT AUTHORITY, AND TAX EXPENDITURES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee adopts as its own the
estimate of new budget authority, entitlement authority, or tax
expenditures or revenues contained in the cost estimate
prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget Office
pursuant to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1973.
FEDERAL MANDATES STATEMENT
Pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act, the Committee adopts as its own the estimate of the
Federal mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional
Budget Office.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE STATEMENT
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
EARMARK IDENTIFICATION
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE LEGISLATION
This Joint Resolution disapproves the rule submitted by the
Securities and Exchange Commission relating to ``The
Enhancement and Standardization of Climate-Related Disclosures
for Investors'' and asserts that such rule shall have no force
or effect.
Minority Views
H.J. Res. 127 is a Congressional Review Act (``CRA'')
resolution that would nullify the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission's (the ``SEC'' or ``Commission'') rule to enhance
and standardize climate-related disclosures for investors,
which was recently finalized on March 6, 2024. While the final
rule is narrower than the rule as originally proposed, it
represents a meaningful first step in standardizing climate-
related disclosures for public companies, and if overturned
would do significant investor harm.
Since their inception over 90 years ago, U.S. securities
laws have required public companies to disclose material
information to their investors in order to allow investors to
make sound decisions with their hard-earned dollars. However,
current SEC rules provide limited guidance on what climate-
related information these companies must provide. Many
companies recognize that such information is important to
investors and disclose various climate-related data points. Due
to a lack of standardization from the SEC, however, there are
considerable differences across public companies which makes it
difficult for investors to compare such information. For
several years now, investors in publicly traded companies and
investment funds have increasingly requested the disclosure of
standardized and reliable data regarding environmental-related
factors. Just in 2023 alone, investors, asset managers, and
banks with $136 trillion assets under management requested
thousands of companies disclose climate-related information to
help inform their investing and voting decisions.
In response to this overwhelming investor and industry
demand for standardized climate-related information--and after
receiving tens of thousands of public comments--the SEC voted
earlier this spring to finalize its climate disclosure rule.
According to Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable Capital Markets,
although the final rule is narrower than the original proposal,
on the whole, it will benefit investors in several key ways.\1\
First, the status quo is costly for investors. Institutional
investors already spend $1.4 million per year on average to
collect, analyze, and report climate data to their investors,
which is more than 2.5 times the average annual cost ($533,000)
companies pay to voluntarily disclose this data.\2\ Second, the
status quo is problematic for public companies. It can be
challenging for companies to determine which voluntary
reporting frameworks to use, and discrepancies and
inconsistencies among the frameworks can result in misleading
disclosures which may confuse and even harm investors.\3\
Third, the status quo does not allow for comparability between
companies' disclosures, which is what investors need when
making portfolio-wide capital allocation decisions.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable Capital Markets, Overview:
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission's Proposed Rule on Climate
Disclosure (accessed Jun. 20, 2024).
\2\Id.
\3\Id.
\4\Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable Capital Markets, Overview:
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission's Proposed Rule on Climate
Disclosure (accessed Jun. 20, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, the standardization and reliability of
climate information brought about by the rule will also provide
investors with the following benefits, per Ceres.\5\ Emissions
data will enable investors to better understand individual
companies' short- and long term exposure to climate risks and
the potential ensuing financial and performance-related impacts
that may come with them.\6\ In addition, investors can use
emissions data to better inform their purchasing decisions and
portfolio construction, risk management, as well as their (or
their proxy's) decisions on how to vote on proposals that
influence the direction of the corporation.\7\ By nullifying
the climate rule, H.J. Res. 127 would eliminate these benefits
for investors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Id.
\6\Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable Capital Markets, Overview:
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission's Proposed Rule on Climate
Disclosure (accessed Jun. 20, 2024).
\7\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The SEC's climate rule was purposely drafted to comport
with Republican's prior views of the SEC's authority to require
disclosures. A key premise of the SEC's final rule is that
public companies only need to disclose the climate-related
information specified in the rule if the company itself
determines such information to be ``material'' to its
investors. This came after nearly three years of consideration
and a lengthy comment period which saw thousands of investors
confirm that climate-related information is important with
respect to their investment decisions. Consistent with this
extensive feedback as well as Supreme Court precedent around
the definition of materiality--the Commission's final climate
rule stated that, ``as with other materiality determinations
under the Federal securities laws . . . the guiding principle
for [a climate-related] determination is whether a reasonable
investor would consider the disclosure of an item of
information . . . important when making an investment or voting
decision or such a reasonable investor would view omission of
the disclosure as having significantly altered the total mix of
information made available.'' Notably, this standard is also in
line with the standard laid out in the 117th Congress by Rep.
Bill Huizenga--the author of this resolution--in his
``Mandatory Materiality Requirement Act of 2022'' (the
``MMRA''). Much like the final climate rule, the MMRA would
have limited new SEC disclosure requirements to cases where
``the Commission expressly determines that there is a
substantial likelihood that a reasonable investor of the issuer
would consider the information disclosed to the Commission
under the requirement to be important with respect to an
investment decision regarding the issuer.'' The slight
difference in this case, which actually makes the final rule
more company-friendly and less burdensome than the regime
envisioned by the MMRA, is that with the climate rule the
company rather than the SEC gets to make the final materiality
determination.
The following is a brief selection of the thousands of
groups that previously wrote to the SEC in support of the
Commission's original climate disclosure rule proposal or the
principles underlying the proposal:
Nonprofit Organizations (General): Americans for Financial
Reform; Better Markets; Ceres Accelerator for Sustainable
Capital Markets; Public Citizen; Union of Concerned Scientists;
Alliance to Save Energy; American Sustainable Business Council;
Business for Social Responsibility; Center for Climate and
Energy Solutions; Earth Action, Inc.; Environmental Defense
Fund; Environmental Protection Network; Governance Institute;
Green America; Innovation Network for Communities; Institute
for Market Transformation (IMT); Natural Resources Defense
Council; World Business Council for Sustainable Development;
Climate Emergency Fund; Citizens Energy Corporation; Catholic
Divestment Network; United Nations Foundation; Evergreen
Action; Ocean Conservancy; Sierra Club; The Sunrise Project;
Accelerate Neighborhood Climate Action; Accountability Counsel;
Action Center on Race and the Economy; Amazon Watch; American
Federation of Teachers; Businesses for a Livable Climate;
CatholicNetwork US; Center for International Environmental Law;
Citizen's Alliance for a Sustainable Englewood; Climate Finance
Fund; Climate First!, Inc.; Community for Sustainable Energy;
Earth Action, Inc.; Earthjustice; Earthworks; Endangered
Species Coalition; Friends of the Earth US; Green America;
GreenFaith; Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy; League
of Conservation Voters; Mental Health & Inclusion Ministries;
National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition; People's Action;
Positive Money US; Private Equity Stakeholder Project; Publish
What You Pay--US; Rainforest Action Network; RapidShift
Network; Save EPA (former employees); Service Employees
International Union; Small Business Alliance; Social Value US;
Spirit of the Sun, Inc.; Stand.earth; System Change Not Climate
Change; The Green House Connection Center; The Greenlining
Institute; The Revolving Door Project; Transformative Wealth
Management, LLC; Wall of Women; Wallace Global Fund; Waterway
Advocates.
Asset Managers: Ariel Investments; Boston Common Asset
Management; Clean Energy Ventures (CEV); ClearBridge
Investments; Rockefeller Asset Management; Steinberg Asset
Management, LLC; Sustainable Insight Capital Management; Terra
Alpha Investments LLC; Loring, Wolcott & Coolidge; Trillium
Asset Management; Zevin Asset Management.
State-level Investors: California State Teachers Retirement
System (CalSTRS); New York State Common Retirement Fund; Oregon
State Treasury Minnesota State Board of Investment; Connecticut
Office of the State Treasurer; Illinois State Treasurer Michael
Frerichs.
State and Regional-affiliated Nonprofits: 350 Colorado; 350
Conejo / San Fernando Valley; 350 New Orleans; 350 Seattle; 350
Silicon Valley; Call to Action Colorado; Climate Reality
Montgomery County; CO Businesses for a Livable Climate;
Connecticut Citizen Action Group; Elders Climate Action
Maryland; Greater New Orleans Housing Alliance; I-70 Citizens
Advisory Group; Southwest Organization for Sustainability;
Unite North Metro Denver.
For these reasons, we oppose H.J. Res. 127.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters,
Ranking Member.
Nydia M. Velazquez,
Brad Sherman,
Gregory W. Meeks,
David Scott,
Stephen F. Lynch,
Al Green,
Emanuel Cleaver II,
Jim Himes,
Bill Foster,
Joyce Beatty,
Juan Vargas,
Sean Casten,
Ayanna Pressley,
Rashida Tlaib,
Sylvia R. Garcia,
Nikema Williams,
Members of Congress.
[all]