Dissenting Views
The Committee on the Judiciary, having considered this Report, reports favorably thereon and recommends that the Report be approved. The form of the Resolution that the Committee on the Judiciary would recommend to the House of Representatives citing Mark Zwonitzer for contempt of Congress pursuant to this Report is as follows: Resolved, That Mark Zwonitzer shall be found to be in contempt of Congress for failure to comply with a congressional subpoena. Resolved, That pursuant to 2 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 192 and 194, the Speaker of the House of Representatives shall certify the report of the Committee on the Judiciary, detailing the refusal of Mark Zwonitzer to produce documents, records, and materials to the Committee on the Judiciary as directed by subpoena, to the United States Attorney for the District of Columbia, to the end that Mark Zwonitzer be proceeded against in the manner and form provided by law. Resolved, That the Speaker of the House shall otherwise take all appropriate action to enforce the subpoena. CONTENTS Page Executive Summary................................................ 2 Authority and Purpose............................................ 4 Background on the Investigation.................................. 4 Zwonitzer's Failure to Produce the Subpoenaed Records Warrants Contempt....................................................... 10 Conclusion....................................................... 17 Committee Consideration.......................................... 17 Committee Votes.................................................. 17 Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 25 New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 25 Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 25 Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 25 Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 25 Dissenting Views................................................. 25 Executive Summary In the weeks following the February 5, 2024, release of Special Counsel Robert K. Hur's report, the Committee on the Judiciary (the ``Committee''), engaged with Mark Zwonitzer to obtain a limited set of documents and records related to Special Counsel Hur's report.\1\ Zwonitzer served as the ghostwriter for President Joe Biden's memoirs and Special Counsel Hur's report revealed that Zwonitzer possessed records that would inform potential legislative reforms. After Zwonitzer declined to provide the relevant documents and records, the Committee issued a subpoena on March 22, 2024, to Zwonitzer compelling the production of six specific categories of documents and records, including audio recordings and transcripts of his interviews with President Joe Biden relating to his ghostwriting work on the President's memoirs, Promise Me, Dad and Promises to Keep.\2\ The Committee subpoenaed these materials for several reasons--including to determine if legislation is needed to codify procedures governing clear statutory guidelines related to the handling, storage, and disclosure of classified materials or modify criminal penalties for the unauthorized dissemination and disclosure of classified materials. To date, Zwonitzer has refused to produce any of the requested documents or materials. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\Letter from Rep. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, to Mr. Mark Zwonitzer (Feb. 14, 2024) (requesting six narrow categories of documents and materials relating to Zwonitzer's ghostwriting work on President Biden's memoirs). \2\Letter from Rep. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, to Mr. Mark Zwonitzer (Mar. 22, 2024) (enclosing subpoena compelling six narrow categories of documents and materials relating to Zwonitzer's ghostwriting work on President Biden's memoirs) (hereinafter ``Zwonitzer Subpoena Letter''). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- During Special Counsel Hur's investigation, his team uncovered evidence that President Biden ``willfully retained and disclosed classified materials after his vice presidency when he was a private citizen.''\3\ Special Counsel Hur found that Vice President Biden had ``strong motivations'' to flout the rules for properly handling classified materials.\4\ In particular, Special Counsel Hur observed that ``months before leaving office''\5\ as vice president, President Biden decided to write a book for ``an advance of $8 million.''\6\ The classified materials retained by President Biden were an ``invaluable resource that he consulted liberally'' while writing his book so that he could give Zwonitzer ``raw material . . . detailing meetings and events that would be of interest to prospective readers and buyers of his book.''\7\ Additionally, Special Counsel Hur observed that President Biden viewed the classified materials ``as an irreplaceable contemporaneous record of some of the most important moments of his vice presidency[,]'' which ``was valuable to him for many reasons, including to help defend his record and buttress his legacy as a world leader.''\8\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\Report on the Investigation Into Unauthorized Removal, Retention, and Disclosure of Classified Documents Discovered at Locations Including the Penn Biden Center and the Delaware Private Residence of President Joseph R. Biden, Jr., Special Counsel Robert K. Hur, U.S. Dep't of Justice at 1 (Feb. 2024) (hereinafter ``Hur Report''). \4\Id. at 8, 231. \5\Id. at 231. \6\Id. at 141. \7\Id. at 231. \8\Id. at 231-32. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- As Special Counsel Hur acknowledged, ``during his dozens of hours of interviews with Zwonitzer, [President] Biden read from notebook entries relating to many classified meetings, including National Security Council meetings, CIA briefings, Department of Defense briefings, and other meetings and briefings with foreign policy officials.''\9\ Special Counsel Hur also found that President Biden even ``showed part of [his classified] handwritten [notes] to Zwonitzer[,]'' and warned him that ``[s]ome of this may be classified, so be careful.''\10\ Despite this evidence, Special Counsel Hur ultimately decided not to pursue charges against President Biden.\11\ Additionally, during his investigation, Special Counsel Hur noted that, ``[a]t some point after learning of [the Special Counsel's] appointment . . . Zwonitzer[] deleted digital audio recordings of his conversations with [President] Biden during the writing of [the President's memoir], Promise Me, Dad.''\12\ According to Special Counsel Hur, the recordings ``had significant evidentiary value.''\13\ However, ``Zwonitzer turned over his laptop computer and external hard drive and gave consent for investigators to search the devices[]'' and ``FBI technicians were able to recover [the] deleted recordings.''\14\ Because Zwonitzer cooperated with investigators, ``preserved the transcripts and produced them to investigators[,]'' and ``later produced the devices on which the recordings had been stored and consented to a search of those devices[,]'' Special Counsel Hur declined to bring charges for obstruction of justice against Zwonitzer.\15\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\Id. at 106. \10\Id. \11\Id. at 345. \12\Id. at 334. \13\Id. \14\Id. \15\Id. at 343. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- President Biden has vehemently denied some of the findings in Special Counsel Hur's report and he and his legal team have attempted to frame Special Counsel Hur's mention of President Biden's poor memory as ``gratuitous.''\16\ Yet during his testimony before the Committee, Special Counsel Hur stated that, ``[t]he evidence and the President himself put his memory squarely at issue.''\17\ In his report, Special Counsel Hur noted that, during both his and Zwonitzer's interviews with President Biden, the president's ``memory was significantly limited,'' and he ``struggle[ed] to remember events and strain[ed] at times to read and relay his own [handwriting].''\18\ Special Counsel Hur also observed that President Biden ``did not remember when he was vice president,'' ``did not remember when he was vice president,'' and ``did not remember, even within several years, when his son Beau died.''\19\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \16\Rebecca Beitsch, et al., Special counsel overstepped mandate with `gratuitous' Biden slams, say ex-DOJ Dems, The Hill (Feb. 12, 2024) (```When the inevitable conclusion is that the facts and the evidence don't support any charges,' said Ian Sams, a spokesman for the White House's special counsel office, `you're left to wonder why this report spends time making gratuitous and inappropriate criticisms of the president.'''); see Letter from Mr. Richard Sauber, Special Counsel to the President, The White House, and Mr. Bob Bauer, Personal Counsel to Joseph R. Biden. Jr., to Mr. Bradley Weinsheimer, Assoc. Deputy Att'y Gen., U.S. Dep't of Justice at 2-3 (Feb. 12, 2024) (``This is the very definition of a derogatory comment. . . .''). \17\Hearing on the Report of Special Counsel Robert Hur: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, 118th Cong. 17 (2024) (statement of Special Counsel Robert K. Hur, U.S. Dep't of Justice) (hereinafter ``Hearing on Hur Report''). \18\Hur Report, supra note 3, at 207. \19\Id.. at 208. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Zwonitzer continues to withhold all documents and materials in his possession that are responsive to the subpoena from the Committee. The materials requested from Zwonitzer are crucial for the Committee's understanding of the manner and extent of President Biden's mishandling and unlawful disclosure of classified materials, as well as Zwonitzer's use, storage, and deletion of classified materials on his computer. Zwonitzer's failure to fully comply with the Committee's subpoena has hindered the Committee's ability to adequately conduct oversight of Special Counsel Hur's investigative findings, the Justice Department's commitment to impartial justice, and the President's retention and disclosure of classified materials. Authority and Purpose Article I of the Constitution vests in Congress a ``broad'' and ``indispensable'' power to conduct oversight and investigations that ``encompasses inquiries concerning the administration of existing laws as well as proposed or possibly needed statutes[,]'' and ``includes surveys of defects in our social, economic or political system for the purpose of enabling Congress to remedy them.''\20\ The Supreme Court has noted that without such power, Congress would not be able to ``legislate wisely or effectively.''\21\ Courts recognize that ``this power of inquiry--with the process to enforce it--is an essential and appropriate auxiliary to the legislative function.''\22\ Pursuant to the Rules of the House of Representatives, the Committee is authorized to conduct oversight of the Department of Justice and of criminal justice matters in the United States to inform potential legislative reforms.\23\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \20\Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178, 187, 215 (1957). \21\McGrain v. Daughtery, 273 U.S. 135, 175 (1927). \22\Id.. at 174 (emphasis added). \23\Rules of the U.S. House of Representatives, R. X, cl. 1(l) (2023). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- To further the Committee's constitutionally mandated oversight and legislative duties, it must ensure compliance with duly authorized congressional subpoenas. The information that the Committee requires, and Zwonitzer is in possession of, is necessary for the Committee to consider potential legislative reforms to the Department and its use of special counsels to conduct investigations of current and former Presidents of the United States. These potential legislative reforms may include, among other things, changing certain procedures governing the Department's special counsel investigations to better ensure that the Department pursues impartial justice. The Committee may also consider legislative reforms governing criminal penalties for destroying evidence-- especially when that evidence includes classified information that was disclosed in an unauthorized manner. The circumstances of Special Counsel Hur's investigative findings demonstrate why such potential legislative reforms may be necessary. Background on the Investigation According to the report of Special Counsel Robert K. Hur, in November 2022, Patrick Moore, one of President Biden's personal attorneys, discovered 44 pages of documents ``classified up to the Top Secret level'' stemming from his tenure as Vice President at President Biden's office in Washington, D.C., located at the Penn Biden Center.\24\ Moore notified his colleague Bob Bauer, who then notified White House Counsel Stuart Delery.\25\ The same day, the White House Counsel's Office passed the information along to the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), which retrieved the documents, and referred the case to the Department and Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).\26\ Additionally, between December 2022 and January 2023, Bauer, Moore, and another Biden personal counsel, Jennifer Miller, discovered additional classified materials, also from his tenure as Vice President, in the garage, basement den, and office of President Biden's personal residence in Wilmington, Delaware.\27\ Between January and June 2023, FBI agents located additional materials with classification markings at the Morris Library and Biden Institute at the University of Delaware.\28\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \24\Hur Report, supra note 3, at 19-20 (The classification marks on the documents ``dat[ed] back to [President Biden]'s vice presidency''). \25\Id. \26\Id. \27\Id. at 24-25. \28\Id. at 28. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- After receiving notification from NARA of the discovery of classified documents at the Penn Biden Center, on November 14, 2022, Attorney General Garland assigned John Lausch, then the U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Illinois, to lead an investigation into President Biden's retention of classified materials and ``assess whether the Attorney General should appoint a special counsel to investigate the matter.''\29\ After further discoveries of classified material at President Biden's home and the University of Delaware, Lausch determined that the appointment of a special counsel was necessary.\30\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \29\Id. at 21. \30\Id. at 26. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- On January 12, 2023, Attorney General Garland appointed Robert K. Hur to serve as special counsel to investigate whether President Biden unlawfully retained classified information when he left office after the vice presidency.\31\ During his investigation, Special Counsel Hur conducted 173 interviews of 147 witnesses, including President Biden himself and his memoir ghostwriter, Mark Zwonitzer.\32\ Special Counsel Hur collected over seven million documents, including e-mails, text messages, photographs, videos, toll records, and other materials from both classified and unclassified sources.\33\ On February 8, 2024, Attorney General Garland released Special Counsel Hur's 375-page report, which concluded that although there was evidence that President Biden had ``willfully retained and disclosed classified materials . . . [as] a private citizen,''\34\ criminal charges were not warranted because, among other things, President Biden is an ``elderly man with a poor memory.''\35\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \31\Id.; Attorney General Merrick B. Garland Delivers Remarks on the Appointment of a Special Counsel, U.S. Dep't of Justice (Jan, 12, 2023). \32\Hur Report, supra note 3, at 26. \33\Id. at 29. \34\Id. at 1. \35\Id. at 6, 219. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Special Counsel Hur found that President Biden ``had strong motivations to ignore the proper procedures for safeguarding the classified information in his notebooks. He decided months before leaving office to write a book and began meeting with his ghostwriter while still vice president.''\36\ Notably, Special Counsel Hur's report found that President Biden received an advance of $8 million to produce a memoir.\37\ President Biden's 2017 memoir, Promise Me, Dad, discussed, among other things, President Biden's thoughts on foreign policy.\38\ While working with Zwonitzer on this memoir, Special Counsel Hur's report noted that President Biden read from classified materials ``verbatim,'' and such classified materials included notes regarding ``the President's Daily Brief[,]'' ``meeting notes summariz[ing] the actions and views of U.S. military leaders and CIA director relating to a foreign country,'' ``notebook entries related to many classified meetings, including National Security Council meetings, CIA briefings, Department of Defense briefings, and other meetings and briefings with foreign policy officials.''\39\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \36\Id. at 231. \37\Id. at 97-106. \38\See, e.g., id. at 97. \39\Id. at 97-106. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Apparently, in two instances, on February 16, and April 10, 2017, after he was no longer vice president, President Biden met with Zwonitzer and ``read from notes [then-Vice President Biden] took during a meeting in the Situation Room in the summer of 2015, which was attended by senior military officials, the CIA Director, and others.''\40\ These notes ``summarized the actions and views of U.S. military leaders and the CIA Director relating to a foreign country and a foreign terrorist organization.''\41\ According to Special Counsel Hur's report, during the February 16, 2017, meeting, President Biden read to Zwonitzer ``portions [of the notes] containing information that remain classified up to the Secret level.''\42\ During the April 10, 2