Background
In 1797, nine years after the U.S. Constitution was
ratified by all 13 states, Congress passed legislation
requiring that every Member of Congress be provided a copy of
the Constitution.\1\ By that time, Congress had already passed
12 amendments to the Constitution, ten of which were ratified
by the states and became known as the Bill of Rights.\2\ Our
federal system of government was still very new and, as Members
of Congress understood, subject to modification. Over the
course of the nineteenth century, copies provided to Members
were expanded to include indexes and Supreme Court case
citations.\3\ But as constitutional law grew increasingly
complex, Congress struggled to make sense of how the
Constitution's provisions applied to a range of legal
questions. In 1921, the Senate took steps to address this
limitation and passed S. Res. 151, a resolution providing for
an updated reprint of the Constitution that would contain
additional resources.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Cong. Rsch. Serv., Intro.1 The 2022 Edition, https://
constitution.congress.gov/about/
constitution-annotated/
#::text=How%20to%20Cite%20the%20Constitution,.gov%20(last%20
visited%20Aug. (last visited April 30, 2024).
\2\The first ten amendments to the Constitution, known as the Bill
of Rights, were ratified by the states in 1791.
\3\Cong. Rsch. Serv., Intro.1 The 2022 Edition.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The November 23, 1921, Senate floor debate on S. Res. 151
reflected the frustration Senators increasingly encountered
when trying to make sense of Supreme Court decisions and lists
of citations attached to clauses of the Constitution, with no
accompanying explanations or interpretations. Senator Miles
Poindexter (R-WA), addressing the bill's manager, Senator Knute
Nelson (R-MN), argued that merely bringing up to date the
copies of the Constitution that Senators received was not
particularly helpful:
I call the attention of the Senator from Minnesota to
the fact that a great deal of that work was practically
useless on account of the way in which it was done. As
a lawyer I am sure the Senator has had the same
experience I have had. The copy of the Constitution
which is printed for the use of the Senate contains
those annotations. After the various clauses of the
Constitution is a list of the decisions of the Supreme
Court, sometimes a page or more of citations. In that
maze of citations there is not a gleam of light as to
what particular question under the section or clause of
the Constitution was decided by the case which is
cited. In order to make them of very much use the
annotator ought to cite in brief language the point
decided by the court in the case which he cites.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\S. REP. No. 8155-8187, at 23 (1921).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Senator Frank Brandegee (R-CT) seconded the views expressed
by Senator Poindexter:
I agree with the suggestion of the Senator from
Washington that really, when we get 100 Supreme Court
citations at the foot of one clause of the
Constitution, as contained in our manual, without
anything to show what particular question was before
the court under that clause of the Constitution, it is
not much of a labor-saving device, but we have to look
through the whole of them to find perhaps the one point
which we are seeking.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The views expressed by Senators Poindexter and Brandegee
resonated with many of their colleagues. Prior to voting to
adopt S. Res. 151 on December 7, 1921, various Senators sought
to confirm that the updated reprints of the Constitution would
contain explanatory language, making sense of the case
citations throughout.\6\ The resolution also authorized the
Committee on Rules to employ a ``competent person'' to assist
in preparing the citations and called for printing 1,500
additional copies for the use of the Senate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\S. REP. No. 79-110, at 93-95 (1921).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 1936, the Committee on Rules handed the responsibility
for preparing citations and drafting explanatory language over
to the Library of Congress, which assigned the task to the
Legislative Reference Service (LRS).\7\ Compilations of the
Constitution Annotated\8\ (or, CONAN as the guide is more
commonly known today) were printed every 10-13 years until
Members of Congress once again began to question the guide's
usefulness. This time around, the issue was that the guide
quickly became outdated soon after it was printed. In 1970,
Congress took steps to remedy this limitation. Senator B.
Everett Jordan (D-NC), then-chairman of the Senate Committee on
Rules and Administration, introduced S.J. Res. 236, a joint
resolution requiring the LRS to prepare revised editions of
CONAN every 10 years, commencing with the June 1972 edition,
along with cumulative supplements every two years. The
decennial editions were to be hardbound, and the biennial
supplements were to be paperbound and designed to fit in a
pocket in the back of the hardbound volume.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\The Legislative Reference Service was renamed the Congressional
Research Service in 1970, as part of the Legislative Reorganization
Act. See H.R. No. 91-1598 (1970) for context on when the Legislative
Reference Service began preparing CONAN.
\8\By 1970, the Constitution of the United States-Analysis and
Interpretation had become more popularly known as the Constitution
Annotated. See H.R. No. 91-1598 (1970).
\9\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After the Senate passed S.J. Res. 236 on September 25,
1970, the joint resolution was sent to the House and referred
to the Committee on House Administration. The Committee
favorably reported the joint resolution without amendment to
the House on October 13, 1970 and recommended that it pass,
which it did on December 15, 1970.\10\ The Committee on House
Administration report accompanying S.J. Res. 236 noted that the
1964 edition of the guide, the most recent edition available at
that time, was ``regrettably out of date in some fundamentally
important areas of constitutional law''\11\ due to a number of
important Supreme Court decisions rendered since 1964. The
report also noted that Members, judges, scholars, libraries,
and others had regularly asked the Library of Congress to
update the Constitution Annotated.\12\ By requiring biennial
supplements to CONAN, S.J. Res. 236 fulfilled a demand for more
current information and vastly improved the usefulness of the
guide.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\S.J. Res. 236 became PL 91-589 on December 24, 1970. See 2
U.S.C. 168, codifying PL 91-1589.
\11\See H.R. No. 91-1598 (1970).
\12\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The new law\13\ commenced with the printing of the 1972
hardbound edition of CONAN and has not been changed since. But
while the statute has remained static, the way people access
information and resources has changed tremendously. The World
Wide Web entered the public domain in 1993 and made digital
versions of vast print materials widely available to the
public.\14\ The Library of Congress debuted its first website
in 1994\15\ and 25 years later, in 2019, the Constitution
Annotated website (constitution.congress.gov) was launched. The
publicly accessible site features hundreds of pages of
constitutional analysis and content, presented in a concise,
user-friendly format. The site is searchable, provides links to
Supreme Court decisions, and is updated in real-time by the
Congressional Research Service (CRS).\16\ The website has
received more than 28 million visits and 55 million page views
since its inception and is an important resource for the
public, including schools, libraries, and Congress.
Additionally, CRS works closely with the Chief Information
Officer at the Library of Congress to ensure that bugs are
addressed and that useability and accessibility enhancements to
the website are made regularly.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See PL 91-589 (1970).
\14\World Wide Web Timeline, Pew Research Center (March 11, 2014)
https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2014/03/11/world-wide-web-
timeline/.
\15\The Library of Congress: A Timeline, Library of Congress,
https://www.loc.gov/about/history-of-the-library/timeline/ (last
visited April 30, 2024).
\16\See testimony given by Director of the Congressional Research
Service Robert Randolph Newlen, Legislative Proposals to Support
Modernizing the Congressional Research Service and the Use of Federal
Data: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin. Modernization Subcommittee,
118th Cong. (2024).
\17\See Newlen Questions for the Record, Legislative Proposals to
Support Modernizing the Congressional Research Service and the Use of
Federal Data: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin. Modernization
Subcommittee, 118th Cong. (2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Beginning with the addition of Supreme Court case citations
in the nineteenth century and followed by the inclusion of case
interpretations and more frequent updates in the twentieth
century, Congress has long demonstrated a desire to ensure that
the Constitution Annotated meets the evolving needs of Members
and other users. The twenty-first century launch of a web-based
guide continues this tradition by providing case updates and
analysis as soon as the Supreme Court issues a new decision,
which can be several times a week during any given term.
Because the Constitution Annotated website provides Members
with the most up-to-date information and analysis available,
eliminating production of the hardbound version and paperbound
supplements is a logical next step for Congress. In testimony
before the Subcommittee on Modernization on March 20, 2024, CRS
Interim Director Robert Newlen described the hardbound version
of CONAN as ``outdated upon delivery.''\18\ The legislative
history of CONAN makes clear that Members and other users want
the guide to be as current as possible and the website far
surpasses the hardbound print in this regard. Indeed, proposed
bill language to eliminate the hardcopy distribution of CONAN
included in the Library of Congress' FY 2024 budget request
describes hardcopy products as ``essentially obsolete and
incapable of timely updates.''\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\See testimony given by Director of the Congressional Research
Service Robert Randolph Newlen, Legislative Proposals to Support
Modernizing the Congressional Research Service and the Use of Federal
Data: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin. Modernization Subcommittee,
118th Cong. (2024).
\19\Fiscal 2024 Budget Justification, United States Library of
Congress, https://www.loc.gov/static/portals/about/reports-and-budgets/
documents/budgets/fy2024.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Replacing the statutory print requirement for the
Constitution Annotated with a digital requirement would also
provide significant cost savings for taxpayers. Mr. Newlen's
testimony describes these projected savings:
Elimination of the hardbound version of CONAN would
provide significant savings for CRS as well as the
Government Publishing Office (GPO). Production costs
for the 2012 version of CONAN, including labor, paper
and binding, totaled over $960,000. In addition to the
production of content for the print, time is required
of CRS to coordinate formatting and pagination with GPO
officials, contractors, and others and to perform other
tasks to meet printing deadlines. In total, CRS
estimates the time expended on production of the
hardbound editions to be the equivalent of the work of
three full-time employees. Transitioning CONAN to a
digital-only product would enable CRS to better deploy
its resources toward the timely production of CONAN'S
digital content and enhancements to the website.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\See testimony given by Director of the Congressional Research
Service Robert Randolph Newlen, Legislative Proposals to Support
Modernizing the Congressional Research Service and the Use of Federal
Data: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin. Modernization Subcommittee,
118th Cong. (2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Government Publishing Office (GPO) produced a total of
2,685 hardbound copies of CONAN in 2012 and 1,401 copies in
2022. While the original statute requires GPO to produce a set
number of print copies for use by the House, Senate, and the
Joint Committee on Printing (these are referred to as ``bylaw''
copies), GPO instead prints only the number requested by these
entities.\21\ GPO's ability to circumvent the statutory print
requirement is derived from the Joint Committee on Printing,
which may use ``any measures it considers necessary to remedy
neglect, delay, duplication, or waste in the public printing
and binding and the distribution of Government
publications.''\22\ In the case of CONAN, the Joint Committee
on Printing has the authority to direct GPO to only print the
number of requested copies so as to remedy waste in printing,
binding, and distribution. In 2012, GPO printed 1,022 bylaw
copies of CONAN; in 2022, GPO printed just 659 bylaw copies.
Federal agencies are also afforded the opportunity to order
hardbound copies, as are the federal deposit libraries.\23\
Additional copies are also made available for the public to
purchase. According to GPO, the 2012 hardbound edition of CONAN
cost $964,749 to produce and the 2022 edition cost an estimated
$476,528.\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\2 U.S.C. Sec. 168b.
\22\See 44 U.S.C. Sec. 103. Joint Committee on Printing: remedial
powers.
\23\GPO reports that most of the orders they receive come from the
federal courts. The U.S. Supreme Court, for example, requested 23
hardbound copies of the 2022 CONAN. Subcommittee staff spoke with the
Court's acting librarian who noted that the Court's practice is to cite
print versions of documents whenever they are available. Despite this
preference for print, the acting librarian noted that the Court has
adjusted when other publications have moved to digital-only versions.
\24\The 2022 numbers provided by GPO only noted that the total cost
was for printing and binding. GPO is currently conducting an internal
financial audit to determine if that number should also specify labor,
as is the case for the 2012 costs. GPO also notes that the agency
changed production processes for the 2022 CONAN so a comprehensive,
direct ``apples to apples'' comparison of labor costs isn't possible.
Some of the labor costs related to the 2022 CONAN production were more
appropriately attributable to building the capability for CONAN
production into GPO's new XPub composition system as part of its
development process. As a result, those costs were deemed part of the
development costs of XPub, similar to how costs associated with
building the capability to produce bills, resolutions, amendments, and
reports are considered XPub development costs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While GPO is responsible for printing, binding, and
distributing CONAN, CRS is responsible for drafting the
decennial versions, as well as the paperbound updates every two
years. Today, five CRS employees spend a significant amount of
their time supporting CONAN functions, although historically,
other attorneys, support staff, and operations employees have
contributed portions of their time to CONAN work. The estimated
cost to CRS for hardbound production, based on work for the
2022 hardbound copy, is $770,000 or the equivalent of the work
of three full-time American Law Division employees together
with contract costs for formatting.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\See Newlen Questions for the Record, Legislative Proposals to
Support Modernizing the Congressional Research Service and the Use of
Federal Data: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin. Modernization
Subcommittee, 118th Cong. (2024). (Note that these costs do not include
the estimated cost of performing core CONAN functions, which include
research, writing, and presenting on constitutional developments
contemporaneous with the Supreme Court's issuance of new decisions so
as to ensure that CONAN is always current.)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Between GPO and CRS, the total cost of producing the 2022
edition of CONAN was an estimated $1,246,528.\26\ Notably, this
figure does not include the cost to CRS of performing the core
work necessary for maintaining the CONAN website, including
research, writing, and presenting on constitutional
developments contemporaneous with the Supreme Court's issuance
of new decisions. Also not included in this estimate is the
additional cost of producing and printing the biennial
paperbound supplements.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\Id. (GPO provided an estimated total cost figure of $476,528
for producing the 2022 edition of CONAN. This, combined with CRS's
estimated cost of $770,000 equals $1,246,528.)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEED FOR LEGISLATION
Replacing the CONAN print requirement with a digital
requirement will eliminate inefficient use of both GPO and CRS
staff time and will save significant costs associated with
printing, producing, and distributing the hardbound version and
paperbound supplements. The legislative history of the
Constitution Annotated makes clear that Congress prioritizes
current interpretation and analysis of Supreme Court cases,
which the CONAN website currently provides. The hardbound
version of CONAN is, by contrast, ``an inferior research tool .
. . because of the time required to produce the print version,
there will always be a lag between when the Supreme Court
issues a decision and when that decision will be available in a
print format.''\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\See Newlen Questions for the Record, Legislative Proposals to
Support Modernizing the Congressional Research Service and the Use of
Federal Data: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin. Modernization
Subcommittee, 118th Cong. (2024).
---
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
in the 118th Congress, the Subcommittee on Modernization held
two Subcommittees hearings regarding H.R. 7592.
1. On April 26, 2023, the Subcommittee on
Modernization held a hearing titled, ``The Path Toward
a More Modern and Effective Congressional Research
Service.'' The hearing focused on CRS's leadership and
strategic goals and how CRS can best meet the needs of
a modern Congress, including by incorporating
technology to better advise and assist Congress. The
hearing was a first step in a longer-term process of
strengthening and improving the agency to meet the
needs of an evolving Congress. The Subcommittee heard
testimony from Dr. Mary B. Mazanec, CRS Director,
Joseph Dunne, Director of the European Parliament
Liaison Office in Washington, D.C., and formerly a
Director in the European Parliamentary Research
Service, Richard Coffin, Chief of Research and Advocacy
at USA Facts, and Kevin Kosar, Senior Fellow of Legal
and Constitutional Studies at American Enterprise
Institute.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\The Path Toward a More Modern and Effective Congressional
Research Service: Hearing Before the Subcommittee on Modernization,
118th Cong. (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. On March 20, 2024, the Subcommittee held a
legislative hearing titled, ``Legislative Proposals to
Support Modernizing the Congressional Research Service
and the Use of Federal Data.'' The purpose of the
hearing was to initiate a legislative record and
receive testimony on three measures referred to the
Subcommittee: H.R. 7592, To Direct the Librarian of
Congress to promote the more cost-effective, efficient,
and expanded availability of the Annotated Constitution
and pocket-part supplements by replacing the hardbound
versions with digital versions; H.R. 7593, the
Modernizing the Congressional Research Service's Access
to Data Act; and H. Con. Res. 49, the Congressional
Evidence-Based Policymaking Resolution. The
Subcommittee heard testimony from Robert Newlen, CRS
Interim Director, Elise J. Bean, Director, Washington
Office, Carl Levin Center for Oversight and Democracy
at Wayne State University Law School, Dr. Matthew
Glassman, Senior Fellow, Government Affairs Institute
at Georgetown University, and Dr. Nicholas Hart,
President and CEO, Data Foundation.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Legislative Proposals to Support Modernizing the Congressional
Research Service and the Use of Federal Data: Hearing Before the
Subcommittee on Modernization, 118th Cong. (2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Repeal requirement for Congressional Research Service to
prepare Annotated Constitution and supplements in hardbound
version
This section directs the Librarian of Congress to replace
the hardbound versions of the Annotated Constitution and
supplements with digital versions, commencing upon the
completion of the October 2031 term of the Supreme Court.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
PUBLIC LAW 91-589
* * * * * * *
Resolved by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled, That (a)
subject to subsection (b), the Librarian of Congress shall have
prepared--
(1) a hardbound revised edition of the Constitution
of the United States of America-Analysis and
Interpretation, published as Senate Document Numbered
39, Eighty-eighth Congress (referred to hereinafter as
the ``Constitution Annotated''), which shall contain
annotations of decisions of the Supreme Court of the
United States through the end of the October 1971 term
of the Supreme Court, construing provisions of the
Constitution;
(2) upon the completion of each of the October 1973,
October 1975, October 1977, and October 1979 terms of
the Supreme Court, a cumulative pocket-part supplement
to the hardbound revised edition of the Constitution
Annotated prepared pursuant to clause (I), which shall
contain cumulative annotations of all such decisions
rendered by the Supreme Court after the end of the
October 1971 term;
(3) upon the completion of the October 1981 term of
the Supreme Court, and upon the completion of each
tenth October term of the Supreme Court thereafter, a
hardbound decennial revised edition of the constitution
Annotated, which shall contain annotations of all
decisicms theretofore rendered by the Supreme Court
construing provisions of the Constitution; and
(4) upon the completion of the October 1983 term of
the Supreme Court, and upon the completion of each
subsequent October term of the Supreme Court beginning
in an odd-numbered year (the final digit of which is
not a I), a cumulative pocket-part supplement to the
most recent hardbound decennial revised edition of the
Constitution Annotated, which shall contain cumulative
annotations of all such decisions rendered by the
Supreme Court which were not included in that hardbound
decennial revised edition of the Constitution
Annotated.
(b)(1) Upon the completion of the October 2031 term of the
Supreme Court and upon the completion of each tenth October
term of the Supreme Court thereafter, the Librarian of Congress
shall have prepared a digital decennial revised edition of the
Constitution Annotated, which shall contain annotations of all
decisions theretofore rendered by the Supreme Court construing
provisions of the Constitution, in place of the hardbound
decennial revised edition of the Constitution Annotated
described in subsection (a)(3).
(2) Upon the completion of the October 2023 term of the
Supreme Court and upon the completion of each subsequent
October term of the Supreme Court beginning in an odd-numbered
year (the final digit of which is not a 1), the Librarian shall
have prepared a digital cumulative pocket-part supplement to
the most recent decennial revised edition of the Constitution
Annotated, which shall contain cumulative annotations of all
such decisions rendered by the Supreme Court which were not
included in the most recent revised edition of the Constitution
Annotated, in place of the hardbound editions of the cumulative
pocket-part supplement described in subsection (a)(4).
Sec. 2. (a) All hardbound revised editions and all
cumulative pocket-part supplements shall be printed as Senate
documents.
(b)(1) The digital decennial revised editions of the
Constitution Annotated prepared under subsection (b)(1) of the
first section of this Joint Resolution and the digital
cumulative pocket-part supplements prepared under subsection
(b)(2) of the first section of this Joint Resolution shall be
available at a public website of the Library of Congress.
(2) The Librarian of Congress shall ensure the continuing
availability of the documents referred to in paragraph (1) to
Congress and the public.
Sec. 3. (a) There shall be printed four thousand eight
hundred and seventy additional copies of the hardbound revised
editions prepared pursuant to clause (1) of the first section
and of all cumulative pocket-part supplements thereto, of which
two thousand six hundred and thirty-four copies shall be for
the use of the House of Representatives, one thousand two
hundred and thirty-six copies shall be for the use of the
Senate, and one thousand copies shall be for the use of the
Joint Committee on Printing. All Members of the Congress, Vice
Presidents of the United States, and Delegates and Resident
Commissioners, newly elected subsequent to the issuance of the
hardbound revised edition prepared pursuant to such clause and
prior to the first hardbound decennial revised edition, who did
not receive a copy of the edition prepared pursuant to such
clause, shall, upon timely request, receive one copy of such
edition and the then current cumulative pocket-part supplement
and any further supplements thereto. All Members of the
Congress, Vice Presidents of the United States, and Delegates
and Resident Commissioners, 110 longer serving after the
issuance of the hardbound revised edition prepared pursuant to
such clause and who received such edition, may receive one copy
of each cumulative pocket-part supplement thereto upon timely
request.
(b) Subsection (a) does not apply after completion of the
October 2023 term of the Supreme Court, and the Librarian of
Congress shall provide the decennial revised editions of the
Constitution Annotated and the cumulative pocket part
supplements prepared under this Joint Resolution exclusively in
a digital format available at a public website of the Library
of Congress.
[Sec. 4. Additional copies of each hardbound decennial
revised edition and of the cumulative pocket-part supplements
thereto shall be printed and distributed in accordance with the
provisions of any concurrent resolution hereafter adopted with
respect thereto. ]
* * * * * * *