Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 8790]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 8790) to expedite under the National
Environmental Policy Act of 1969 and improve forest management
activities on National Forest System lands, on public lands
under the jurisdiction of the Bureau of Land Management, and on
Tribal lands to return resilience to overgrown, fire-prone
forested lands, and for other purposes, having considered the
same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Fix Our Forests
Act''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Definitions.
TITLE I--LANDSCAPE-SCALE RESTORATION
Subtitle A--Addressing Emergency Wildfire Risks in High Priority
Firesheds
Sec. 101. Designation of fireshed management areas.
Sec. 102. Fireshed center.
Sec. 103. Fireshed registry.
Sec. 104. Shared stewardship.
Sec. 105. Fireshed assessments.
Sec. 106. Emergency fireshed management.
Sec. 107. Sunset.
Subtitle B--Expanding Collaborative Tools to Reduce Wildfire Risk and
Improve Forest Health
Sec. 111. Modification of the treatment of certain revenue and payments
under good neighbor agreements.
Sec. 112. Fixing stewardship end result contracting.
Sec. 113. Intra-agency strike teams.
Sec. 114. Locally-led restoration.
Sec. 115. Joint Chiefs landscape restoration partnership program.
Sec. 116. Collaborative forest landscape restoration program.
Subtitle C--Litigation Reform
Sec. 121. Commonsense litigation reform.
Sec. 122. Consultation on forest plans.
TITLE II--PROTECTING COMMUNITIES IN THE WILDLAND-URBAN INTERFACE
Sec. 201. Community wildfire risk reduction program.
Sec. 202. Community wildfire defense research program.
Sec. 203. Vegetation management, facility inspection, and operation and
maintenance relating to electric transmission and distribution facility
rights-of-way.
Sec. 204. Categorical exclusion for electric utility lines rights-of-
way.
Sec. 205. Seeds of success.
TITLE III--TRANSPARENCY AND TECHNOLOGY
Sec. 301. Biochar innovations and opportunities for conservation,
health, and advancements in research.
Sec. 302. Accurate hazardous fuels reduction reports.
Sec. 303. Public-private wildfire technology deployment and testbed
partnership.
Sec. 304. GAO study on Forest Service policies.
Sec. 305. Forest Service Western headquarters study.
Sec. 306. Keeping forest plans current and monitored.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) Director.--The term ``Director'' means the Director of
the Fireshed Center appointed under section 102.
(2) Fireshed.--The term ``fireshed'' means a landscape-scale
area that faces similar wildfire threat where a response
strategy could influence the wildfire outcome.
(3) Fireshed management project.--The term ``fireshed
management project'' means a project under section 106.
(4) Fireshed registry.--The term ``Fireshed Registry'' means
the fireshed registry established under section 103.
(5) Forest plan.--The term ``forest plan'' means--
(A) a land use plan prepared by the Bureau of Land
Management for public lands pursuant to section 202 of
the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 (43
U.S.C. 1712);
(B) a land and resource management plan prepared by
the Forest Service for a unit of the National Forest
System pursuant to section 6 of the Forest and
Rangeland Renewable Resources Planning Act of 1974 (16
U.S.C. 1604); or
(C) a forest management plan (as defined in section
304 of the National Indian Forests Resources Management
Act (25 U.S.C. 3104)) with respect to Indian forest
land or rangeland.
(6) Governor.--The term ``Governor'' means the Governor or
any other appropriate executive official of an affected State
or Indian Tribe or the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico.
(7) Hazardous fuels management activities.--The term
``hazardous fuels management activities'' means any vegetation
management activities (or combination thereof) that reduce the
risk of wildfire, including mechanical thinning, mastication,
prescribed burning, cultural burning (as determined by the
applicable Indian Tribe), timber harvest, and grazing.
(8) HFRA terms.--The terms ``at-risk community'', ``community
wildfire protection plan'', and ``wildland-urban interface''
have the meanings given such terms, respectively, in section
101 of the Healthy Forests Restoration Act of 2003 (16 U.S.C.
6511).
(9) Indian forest land or rangeland.--The term ``Indian
forest land or rangeland'' means land that--
(A) is held in trust by, or with a restriction
against alienation by, the United States for an Indian
Tribe or a member of an Indian Tribe; and
(B)(i)(I) is Indian forest land (as defined in
section 304 of the National Indian Forest Resources
Management Act (25 U.S.C. 3103)); or
(II) has a cover of grasses, brush,
or any similar vegetation; or
(ii) formerly had a forest cover or
vegetative cover that is capable of
restoration.
(10) Indian tribe.--The term ``Indian Tribe'' has the meaning
given that term in section 4 of the Indian Self-Determination
and Education Assistance Act (25 U.S.C. 5304).
(11) National forest system lands.--The term ``National
Forest System lands'' has the meaning given the term in section
11(a) of the Forest and Rangeland Renewable Resources Planning
Act of 1974 (16 U.S.C. 1609).
(12) Public lands.--The term ``public lands'' has the meaning
given that term in section 103 of the Federal Land Policy and
Management Act of 1976 (43 U.S.C. 1702), except that the term
includes Coos Bay Wagon Road Grant lands and Oregon and
California Railroad Grant lands.
(13) Relevant congressional committees.--The term ``relevant
Congressional Committees'' means--
(A) the Committees on Natural Resources and
Agriculture of the House of Representatives; and
(B) the Committees on Energy and Natural Resources
and Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry of the Senate.
(14) Responsible official.--The term ``responsible official''
means an employee of the Department of the Interior or Forest
Service who has the authority to make and implement a decision
on a proposed action.
(15) Secretaries.--The term ``Secretaries'' means each of--
(A) the Secretary of the Interior; and
(B) the Secretary of Agriculture.
(16) Secretary.--The term ``Secretary'' means the Secretary
of Agriculture.
(17) Secretary concerned.--The term ``Secretary concerned''
means--
(A) the Secretary of Agriculture, with respect to
National Forest System lands; and
(B) the Secretary of the Interior, with respect to
public lands.
(18) State.--The term ``State'' means each of the several
States, the District of Columbia, and each territory of the
United States
TITLE I--LANDSCAPE-SCALE RESTORATION
Subtitle A--Addressing Emergency Wildfire Risks in High Priority
Firesheds
SEC. 101. DESIGNATION OF FIRESHED MANAGEMENT AREAS.
(a) Designation of Fireshed Management Areas.--
(1) Initial designations.--For the period beginning on the
date of enactment of this Act and ending on the date that is 5
years after the date of enactment of this Act, there are
designated fireshed management areas, which--
(A) shall be comprised of individual landscape-scale
firesheds identified as being a high risk fireshed in
the ``Wildfire Crisis Strategy'' published by the
Forest Service in January 2022;
(B) shall be comprised of individual landscape-scale
firesheds identified by the Secretary, in consultation
with the Secretary of the Interior, as being in the top
20 percent of the 7,688 firesheds published by the
Rocky Mountain Research Station of the Forest Service
in 2019 for wildfire exposure based on the following
criteria--
(i) wildfire exposure and corresponding risk
to communities, including risk to structures
and life;
(ii) wildfire exposure and corresponding risk
to municipal watersheds, including tribal water
supplies and systems; and
(iii) risk of forest conversion due to
wildfire;
(C) shall not overlap with any other fireshed
management areas;
(D) may contain Federal and non-Federal land,
including Indian forest lands or rangelands; and
(E) where the Secretary concerned shall carry out
fireshed management projects.
(2) Further fireshed management area designations.--
(A) In general.--On the date that is 5 years after
the date of the enactment of this Act and every 5 years
thereafter, the Secretary, in consultation with the
Secretary of the Interior, shall submit to the relevant
Congressional Committees an updated map of firesheds
based on the Fireshed Registry maintained under section
103.
(B) Designation.--Not later than 60 days after
submitting an updated fireshed map under subparagraph
(A), the Secretary shall, based on such map, designate
additional fireshed management areas that are
identified as being in the top 20 percent of firesheds
at risk of wildfire exposure based on the criteria
specified in subparagraphs (B), (C), (D), and (E) of
paragraph (1).
(b) Applicability of Nepa.--The designation of fireshed management
areas under this section shall not be subject to the requirements of
the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.).
SEC. 102. FIRESHED CENTER.
(a) Establishment.--
(1) In general.--The Secretary, acting through the Chief of
the Forest Service, and the Secretary of the Interior, acting
through the Director of the U.S. Geological Survey, shall
jointly establish a Fireshed Center (hereinafter referred to as
the ``Center'') comprised of at least one career representative
from each of the following:
(A) The Forest Service.
(B) The Bureau of Land Management.
(C) The National Park Service.
(D) The Bureau of Indian Affairs.
(E) The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
(F) The U.S. Geological Survey.
(G) The Department of Defense.
(H) The Department of Homeland Security.
(I) The Department of Energy.
(J) The Federal Emergency Management Agency.
(K) The National Science Foundation.
(L) The National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration.
(M) The National Aeronautics and Space
Administration.
(N) The National Institute of Standards and
Technology.
(2) Director.--The Secretary, acting through the Chief of the
Forest Service, and the Secretary of the Interior, acting
through the Director of the U.S. Geological Survey, shall
jointly appoint a Director of the Center, who--
(A) shall be an employee of the U.S. Geological
Survey or the Forest Service;
(B) shall serve an initial term of not more than 7
years; and
(C) may serve one additional term of not more than 7
years after the initial term described in subparagraph
(B).
(3) Additional representation.--The Secretary, acting through
the Chief of the Forest Service and the Secretary of the
Interior, acting through the Director of the U.S. Geological
Survey, may jointly appoint additional representatives of
Federal agencies to the Center, as the Secretaries determine
necessary.
(b) Purposes.--The purposes of the Center are to--
(1) comprehensively assess and predict fire and smoke in the
wildland and built environment interface across jurisdictions
to inform--
(A) land and fuels management;
(B) community, public health, and built environment
risk reduction; and
(C) fire response and post-fire recovery;
(2) provide data aggregation, real-time predictive services,
and science-based decision support services;
(3) reduce fragmentation and duplication across Federal land
management agencies with respect to predictive service and
decision support functions related to wildland fire and smoke;
(4) promote coordination and sharing of data regarding
wildland fire and smoke decision making between Federal
agencies, States, Indian Tribes, local governments, academic or
research institutions, and private entities;
(5) streamline procurement processes and cybersecurity
systems related to addressing wildland fire and smoke;
(6) provide publicly accessible data, models, technologies
(including mapping technologies), assessments, and fire weather
forecasts to support short- and long-term planning regarding
wildland fire and smoke risk reduction and post-fire recovery;
and
(7) maintain the Fireshed Registry established under section
103.
(c) Memoranda of Understanding.--The Center may enter into
memorandums of understanding, contracts, or other agreements with State
governments, Indian Tribes, local governments, academic or research
institutions, and private entities to improve the information and
operations of the Center.
(d) Administrative Support, Technical Services, and Staff Support.--
(1) USGS support.--The Secretary of the Interior shall make
personnel of the U.S. Geological Survey available to the Center
for such administrative support, technical services, and
development and dissemination of data as the Secretary
determines necessary to carry out this section.
(2) USFS support.--The Secretary shall make personnel of the
Forest Service available to the Center for such administrative
support, technical services, and the development and
dissemination of information related to fireshed management and
the Fireshed Registry as the Secretary determines necessary to
carry out this section.
SEC. 103. FIRESHED REGISTRY.
(a) Fireshed Registry.--The Secretary, acting through the Director of
the Fireshed Center appointed under section 102, shall maintain a
Fireshed Registry on a publicly accessible website that provides
interactive geospatial data on individual firesheds, including
information on--
(1) wildfire exposure delineated by ownership, including
rights-of-way for utilities and other public or private
purposes;
(2) any hazardous fuels management activities that have
occurred within an individual fireshed in the past 10 years;
(3) wildfire exposure with respect to such fireshed
delineated by--
(A) wildfire exposure and corresponding risk to
communities, including risk to structures and life;
(B) wildfire exposure and corresponding risk to
municipal watersheds, including tribal water supplies
and systems; and
(C) risk of forest conversion due to wildfire;
(4) the percentage of the fireshed that has burned in
wildfires in the past 10 years, including, to the extent
practicable, delineations of acres that have burned at a high
severity;
(5) spatial patterns of wildfire exposure, including
plausible extreme fire events; and
(6) any hazardous fuels management activities planned for the
fireshed, including fireshed management projects.
(b) Community Wildfire Protection Plans.--The Director shall make
data from the Fireshed Registry available to local communities
developing or updating community wildfire protection plans.
(c) Requirement to Maintain.--As part of the website containing the
Fireshed Registry, the Director shall--
(1) publish fireshed assessments created under section 105;
and
(2) maintain a searchable database to track--
(A) the status of Federal environmental reviews,
permits, and authorizations for fireshed management
projects, including--
(i) a comprehensive permitting timetable;
(ii) the status of the compliance of each
lead agency, cooperating agency, and
participating agency with the permitting
timetable with respect to such fireshed
management projects;
(iii) any modifications of the permitting
timetable required under clause (i), including
an explanation as to why the permitting
timetable was modified; and
(iv) information about project-related public
meetings, public hearings, and public comment
periods, which shall be presented in English
and the predominant language of the community
or communities most affected by the project, as
that information becomes available;
(B) the projected cost of such fireshed management
projects; and
(C) in the case of completed fireshed management
projects, the effectiveness of suc
Background and Need for Legislation
OVERVIEW
Across the country, more than one billion acres are at risk
of wildland fire.\1\ Federal land management agencies now
identify a combined 117 million acres of federal land at high
or very high risk for wildfire, representing nearly one-fifth
of the overall land overseen by these agencies.\2\ High-risk
federal forests are overloaded with dangerous dry fuels that
have accumulated through a century of fire suppression combined
with a lack of thinning, prescribed burns, and mechanical
treatments.\3\ Overstocking makes forests less resilient by
increasing competition among trees for the water, minerals, and
sunlight necessary to sustain a healthy forest. In California
over 4 million acres burned in 2020, and a record-breaking
``gigafire''--a term referring to a blaze that consumes more
than 1 million acres--exemplifies this situation.\4\ Before
European settlement, California forests had roughly 64 trees
per acre. Those same forests now have over 300 trees per
acre.\5\ As a result, over 173 million trees died across the
state in the past 20 years, and an estimated 36.3 million trees
died in 2022 alone, a 282 percent increase from the year
prior.\6\ Unprecedented drought facing the West further
weakened overgrown national forests, leaving them extremely
vulnerable to wildfire. Recent research shows that some areas
are experiencing the driest conditions in 1,200 years.\7\ These
conditions turned vast swaths of the nation's forests into
ticking time bombs that can ignite with a single spark. It is
no longer a matter of ``if'' these areas will experience
catastrophic wildfire but ``when.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Testimony of Christopher French, Deputy Chief, U.S. Forest
Service, before the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, June
24, 2021, https://www.energy.senate.gov/services/files/AAF7DF40- 2A47-
4951-ADA4-4B124AD3894F.
\2\Hoover, Katie, ``Federal Wildfire Management: Ten-Year Funding
Trends and Issues (FY2011-FY2020),'' October 28, 2020, CRS, R46583.
\3\Ingram, Robert G. ``Robert G. Ingram: Forest Fuel Management--
the Ugly Truth.'' TheUnion.com, October 9, 2020, www.theunion.com/
opinion/columns/robert-g-ingram-forest-fuel-management-the-ugly-truth/.
\4\CNN, ``California fire is now a 'gigafire,' a rare designation
for a blaze that burns at least a million acres, 10/6/20, https://
www.cnn.com/2020/10/06/us/gigafire-california-august-complex-trnd/
index.html.
\5\Data provided by the U.S. Forest Service.
\6\Fehely, Devin, `` California drought leading to tens of millions
of trees dying in state,'' CBS News, July 25, 2022, https://
www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/california-drought-leading-to-tens-
of-millions-of-trees-dying-in-state/. CNN, ``Drought and disease in
California forests leaves behind an estimated 36 million dead trees,
survey finds,'' 2/10/2023, https://www.cnn.com/2023/02/10/us/
california-drought-millions-trees-dead/index.html.
\7\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the last 20 years, the United States lost an average of
7 million acres per year to catastrophic wildfires, more than
double the average seen during the 1990's.\8\ Since 2000,
wildfires damaged over 164 million acres, a collective area
roughly three times the size of the entire State of Utah.\9\
Prior to 2015, the United States never burned more than 10
million acres in a single wildfire season. In the past decade,
the country has now hit that ominous mark three times during
some of the worst wildfire seasons on record (2015, 2017, and
2020).\10\ This crisis has wreaked unprecedented havoc on
landscapes and communities across the Western United States.
Catastrophic wildfires have destroyed lives and property,
degraded air and water quality, and irreparably damaged
millions of acres of wildlife habitat. A new study has shown a
246 percent increase in the number of homes and properties
destroyed between 2010 and 2020 compared to the prior
decade.\11\ In the last five years, wildfires caused over $22
billion in property damages.\12\ Perhaps most concerning,
worsening wildfires continue to cause unthinkable and tragic
losses of life, with 430 people sadly perishing in wildfires
since 2013.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Congressional Research Service, ``Wildfire Statistics'', Katie
Hoover, June 1, 2023, https://www.crs.gov/Reports/
IF10244?source=search&guid=b82a4d954677449b918a65ece823396f &index=0.
\9\NIFC, ``Wildfires and Acres, https://www.nifc.gov/fire-
information/statistics/wildfires.
\10\Id.
\11\PNAS Nexus, ``Shifting social-ecological fire regimes explain
increasing structure loss from Western wildfires'', Philip E. Higuera
et al., March 2023, https://academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/article/2/3/
pgad005/7017542.
\12\Value Penguin, ``Wildfire Statistics: Damage, Fatalities, and
Insurance Rates'', Lindsay Bishop, March 15, 2024, https://
www.valuepenguin.com/homeowners-insurance/wildfire-statistics.
\13\Statista, ``Number of deaths due to wildfire in the United
States from 1990 to 2023'', Erick Burgueo Salas, November 8, 2023,
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1422130/usa-number-of-deaths-due-
to-wildfires/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
We know what needs to be done to turn the tide of this
crisis and restore our forests to healthy, resilient
conditions. Despite the fearmongering of increasingly isolated,
radical environmentalists, there is a scientific consensus
among a broad array of stakeholders recognizing the importance
of active forest management.\14\ In fact, research published
this year ``found overwhelming evidence'' that forest
treatments like mechanical thinning and prescribed burning
reduce wildfire severity by as much as 72 percent compared to
untreated areas.\15\ Active forest management encourages
sustained, healthy growth while removing much of the dangerous
fuel buildups that lead to catastrophic wildfires.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\American Forest Resource Council, ``Solutions'', https://
amforest.org/solutions/.
\15\Davis, et al., ``Tamm review: A meta-analysis of thinning,
prescribed fire, and wildfire effects on subsequent wildfire severity
in conifer dominated forests of the Western US,'' Forest Ecology and
Management Volume 561, 1 June 2024, 121885.
\16\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite this clear consensus, land managers still struggle
to increase the pace and scale of forest management due in
large part to a mixture of bureaucratic red tape, onerous
regulations, and frivolous litigation. For decades, land
management agencies consistently fell short of carrying out
forest management activities at the pace and scale necessary to
truly confront the wildfire crisis in a meaningful way. The
U.S. Forest Service (USFS), for instance, only carried out 2
million acres of treatments on average annually in recent
decades.\17\ At this paltry rate, it would take USFS over 30
years to complete the necessary treatments to treat just the
highest risk areas. Increased funding alone cannot address this
crisis. Despite billions of dollars from the Inflation
Reduction Act and Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act
(IIJA), USFS still failed to meaningfully ramp up the number of
acres treated.\18\ In fact, the agency plans to treat fewer
acres this year than it did two years prior.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\PERC, ``Does Environmental Review Worsen the Wildfire Crisis'',
Eric Edwards, Sara Sutherland, June 14, 2022, https://perc.org/2022/06/
14/does-environmental-review-worsen-the-wildfire-crisis/.
\18\P.L. 117-58. P.L. 117-169.
\19\U.S. Department of Agriculture, U.S. Forest Service, ``Fiscal
Year 2025 Budget Justification'', https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/
default/files/fs-fy25-congressional-budget-justification.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), in
particular, creates a major roadblock in improving the health
of our nation's forests.\20\ Vital forest management projects
are often delayed or canceled as land managers divert finite
agency time and resources from important management activities
to endless analysis to ``bulletproof'' NEPA documents, circular
consultations with other agencies, and combating obstructionist
lawsuits. For example, USFS spent seven years and an estimated
15,000 pages of documentation analyzing a roughly 7,000-acre
treatment project in the Nez-Perce Clearwater National Forest
in Idaho, or approximately 0.008 percent of the National Forest
acreage estimated to be at moderate to high risk of
catastrophic wildfire.\21\ In another example in Montana, USFS
completed 1,300 pages of documentation for a project on the
Lewis and Clark National Forest that proposed treating roughly
330 acres per year over 20 years.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\43 U.S. Code Sec. 1638.
\21\Data provided by FFRC.
\22\Ibid. FFRC.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE FIX OUR FORESTS ACT
The bipartisan ``Fix Our Forests Act'' (FOFA), championed
by Chairman Bruce Westerman (R-AR) and Congressman Scott Peters
(D-CA), is a comprehensive package that would restore forest
health, increase resiliency to catastrophic wildfires, and
protect communities in the wildland-urban interface (WUI). FOFA
is the culmination of the House Committee on Natural Resources'
efforts this Congress to advance thoughtful solutions to
increase the pace and scale of forest management, protect
vulnerable communities, and deliver transparency and
innovation. The bill would accomplish these goals by expediting
environmental analyses, reducing frivolous lawsuits, and
improving existing and successful tools that promote
collaboration and partnerships. The legislation would give
federal land managers, including USFS and Bureau of Land
Management (BLM), the critical tools they need to implement
forest restoration treatments immediately. This bill will
revolutionize the way we manage our forests and support active
and responsible management of federal lands with the best
available technology and science, leaving them more resilient
for generations to come.
TITLE I--LANDSCAPE-SCALE RESTORATION
Subtitle A--Addressing Emergency Wildfire Risks in High-Priority
Firesheds
The enormity of the wildfire threat requires broader and
more strategic forest management efforts that transcend
traditional man-made boundaries. Finding ways to empower
landscape-scale treatments across multiple jurisdictions
remains key to this effort. In an attempt to better track and
manage wildfire risk, USFS scientists developed a Fireshed
Registry that tracks ``risk trajectories on lands where
destructive wildfires are likely to originate.''\23\ This
geospatial mapping framework identified 7,688 firesheds that
are, on average, about 250,000 acres in size and include
planning areas that are roughly 25,000 acres each.\24\ This
cutting-edge technology maps firesheds across the nation that
face the greatest risk of experiencing a catastrophic wildfire
that would affect nearby communities. This technology became
instrumental in formulating the basis of USFS's 10-year
``Confronting the Wildfire Crisis'' strategy.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\U.S. Forest Service Rocky Mountain Research Station,
``Development and Application of the Fireshed Registry'', Alan Ager et
al, https://www.fs.usda.gov/rm/pubs_series/rmrs/gtr/rmrs_gtr425.pdf.
\24\A fireshed is a landscape-scale area that faces similar
wildfire threats where a fire management strategy could affect fire
outcomes. U.S. Forest Service, ``The Fireshed Registry: Prioritizing
forest and fuel management investments to reduce wildfire risk to
developed areas'', https://www.iawfonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/
12/BP2-Fireshed-Registry.pdf.
\25\USDA, ``Secretary Vilsack Announces New 10 Year Strategy to
Confront the Wildfire Crisis,'' January 18, 2022, https://www.usda.gov/
media/press-releases/2022/01/18/secretary-vilsack-announces-new-10-
year-strategy-confront-wildfire.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The results of the Fireshed Registry are very concerning.
They identify hundreds of Western communities exposed to a
predicted wildfire risk higher than those that existed just
before the Camp Fire, a horrific 2018 tragedy that leveled the
California towns of Concow and Paradise.\26\ In total, USFS
researchers identified 1,812 communities in the Western United
States that could be significantly impacted by future
wildfires, exposing an estimated 4,000 structures to wildfire
on average annually.\27\ Sobering fire models even predicted
plausible extreme fire scenarios in the near future where
almost 500,000 buildings could be lost to wildfire in a single
fire season.\28\ Other scenarios identified the probability of
wildfires igniting on USFS lands and burning over 1.5 million
acres in Southern California, destroying 100,000 structures and
putting thousands of lives at risk.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\Id.
\27\U.S. Forest Service Rocky Mountain Research Station, ``Cross-
Boundary Wildfire and Community Exposure: A Framework and Application
in the Western U.S.'' Alan Ager et al, 2019, https://www.fs.usda.gov/
rm/pubs_series/rmrs/gtr/rmrs_gtr392.pdf.
\28\Finney MA, McHugh CW, Grenfell IC, Riley KL, Short KC. A
simulation of probabilistic wildfire risk components for the
continental United States. Stochastic Environmental Research and Risk
Assessment, 2011; 25:973-1000. Short KC, Finney MA, Vogler K, Scott JH,
Gilbertson-Day JW, Julie W, Grenfell IC. Spatial datasets of
probabilistic wildfire risk components for the United States (270m)
2020. Available at: https://doi.org/10.2737/RDS-2016-0034.
\29\Eliza Barclay, ``This is a worst-possible wildfire scenario for
Southern California,'' Vox, https://www.vox.com/2019/9/10/20804560/
climate-change-california-wildfire-2019.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title I of the Fix Our Forests Act utilizes this new
science as an innovative blueprint to target the top 20 percent
of high-risk firesheds, where many of these threatened
communities are located. This will prioritize treatments in the
highest-risk areas with the most degraded forest health
conditions and where the greatest community and watershed risks
are present. To increase the pace of treatments, Section 106 of
the bill codifies emergency authorities that the Biden
administration utilized in Region 5 to address hazard trees and
threats to Giant Sequoias.\30\ This authority has been a
successful tool that allows agencies to complete critical work
before completing an environmental analysis under NEPA without
waiving any environmental laws. This section addresses the
challenge of scaling up forest management projects by
encouraging the use of existing categorical exclusions (CEs)
under NEPA and increasing the limitations on those CEs from
3,000-4,500 acres to 10,000 acres.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\USFS, ``Giant Sequoia Emergency Response,'' https://
www.fs.usda.gov/detail/r5/landmanagement/resourcemanagement/
?cid=fseprd1078184#::text=An%20Emergency%20
Response%20was%20approved,threatens%20these%20giant%2C%20iconic%20trees.
USFS, ``Region 5 Post-Disturbance Hazardous Tree Management Project,''
https://www.fs.usda.gov/project/?project=60950&exp=overview#::text=
Region%205%20Post%2DDisturbance%20Hazardous%20
Tree%20Management%20Project&text=Hazard%20tree%20felling%20and%20removal
,level%20 analyses%20and%20nine%20decisions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title I will also establish a brand-new Fireshed Center
comprised of relevant land management and science-focused
agencies to comprehensively assess and predict fire in the
wildland and wildland-urban interface. This will reduce
fragmentation and create a ``one-stop shop'' for predictive
services that can help inform suppression and management
decisions across jurisdictional landscapes. The Fireshed Center
will also be tasked with maintaining an easily accessible
fireshed registry for the public that provides interactive
geospatial data on individual firesheds, including wildfire
risk, burn history, past fuels treatments, and at-risk
communities. This concept aligns with a recommendation from the
Wildland Fire Commission.\31\ In recognition of the importance
of cross-boundary coordination, this bipartisan bill also
codifies the principles of shared stewardship between federal
and state land managers to designate additional fireshed
management areas.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subtitle B--Expanding Collaborative Tools To Reduce Wildfire Risk and
Improve Forest Health
The size and scope of the wildfire and forest health crisis
cannot be tackled by any one entity alone. It is vital that
more be done to encourage coordination and empower cross-
boundary management on a landscape scale. Roughly 47 percent of
Western lands are managed by the federal government, primarily
under the jurisdiction of USFS and BLM.\32\ Western states,
Tribes, and counties all possess a significant stake in how
federal lands are managed for wildfires. Several tools are in
place to empower more state, Tribal, and local coordination on
forest management and restoration work, yet many have not
achieved their full potential.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\New York Times, ``Why the Government Owns So Much Land in the
West'', Quoctrung Bui and Margo Sanger-Katz, January 5, 2016, https://
www.nytimes.com/2016/01/06/upshot/why-the-government-owns-so-much-land-
in-the-west.html#::text=The%20United%20States%20
government%20owns,owned%20by%20the%20 federal%20government.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A major impediment to carrying out necessary fuels
management has been the loss of sawmill infrastructure. Since
2000, over 1,500 sawmills, which is one-third of the total
number of sawmills in operation at that time, have closed.\33\
The loss of this critically important infrastructure and mill
capacity greatly hampers efforts to ramp up forest management
activities and process hazardous fuels, exacerbating the
wildfire crisis across the nation. A lack of reliable federal
timber is consistently cited as a primary cause of many of
these mill closures in Western states with large amounts of
federal land. In spring of 2024, C&D Lumber, which began
operations in southern Oregon in 1890, announced its permanent
closure, explaining that ``timber supply issues'' among other
challenges, ``have made it
Committee Action
H.R. 8790 was introduced on June 18, 2024, by Rep. Bruce
Westerman (R-AR). The bill was referred to the Committee on
Natural Resources, and within the Committee to the Subcommittee
on Federal Lands. The bill was also referred to the Committees
on Agriculture and Science, Space, and Technology. On April 17,
2024, the Subcommittee on Federal Lands held a hearing on the
discussion draft of the bill. On June 26, 2024, the Committee
on Natural Resources met to consider the bill. The Subcommittee
on Federal Lands was discharged from further consideration of
H.R. 8790 by unanimous consent. Representative Tom Tiffany (R
WI) offered an Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
designated Tiffany ANS_FOFA. Representative Jared Huffman (D-
CA) offered a Substitute Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute designated Huffman 100 Substitute ANS. The amendment
designated Huffman 100 Substitute ANS was not agreed to by a
roll call vote of 14 to 19, as follows:
Representative Russ Fulcher (R-ID) offered an amendment to
the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated
Westerman #1. The amendment was agreed to by voice vote.
Representative Susie Lee (D-NV) offered an amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Leger
Fernandez #5. The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call
vote of 14 to 19, as follows:
Representative Katie Porter (D-CA) offered an amendment to
the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Porter
#1. The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 14
to 19, as follows:
Representative Val Hoyle (D-OR) offered an amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Hoyle_038.
The amendment was agreed to by voice vote. Representative Val
Hoyle (D-OR) offered an amendment to the Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute designated HoyleG7X037. The amendment
was withdrawn. Representative Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered an
amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
designated Kamlager-Dove #3. The amendment was not agreed to by
a roll call vote of 14 to 19, as follows:
The Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated
Tiffany ANS_FOFA, as amended, was agreed to by voice vote. The
bill, as amended, was ordered favorably reported to the House
of Representatives by voice vote.
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the Subcommittee on Federal Lands held on April 17,
2024.
Section-by-Section Analysis
TITLE I--LANDSCAPE-SCALE RESTORATION
SUBTITLE A--ADDRESSING EMERGENCY WILDFIRE RISKS IN HIGH PRIORITY
FIRESHEDS
Section 101. Designation of fireshed management areas
Section 101 designates fireshed management areas, which are
comprised of individual landscape-scale firesheds identified as
being in the top 20 percent of the 7,688 firesheds identified
in the Fireshed Registry for fireshed risk exposure, for five
years. This section also designates existing high-risk
firesheds identified in the ``Wildfire Crisis Strategy'' as
fireshed management areas. A criterion is also established
under this section to consider ranking fireshed management
areas based on wildfire exposure to communities, including risk
to structures and life, wildfire exposure to municipal
watersheds, and risk of forest conversion due to wildfire. This
section also requires the Secretary of Agriculture, in
consultation with the Secretary of the Interior, to submit an
updated fireshed map after five years and to update fireshed
management area designations based on the updated map.
Section 102. Fireshed center
Section 102 establishes an interagency office within the
Forest Service (USFS) and U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) known
as the Fireshed Center comprised of USFS, USGS, Bureau of Land
Management (BLM), National Park Service (NPS), Bureau of Indian
Affairs (BIA), U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS),
Department of Defense (DOD), Department of Homeland Security
(DHS), Department of Energy (DOE), Federal Emergency Management
Agency (FEMA), National Science Foundation (NSF), National
Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), National
Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), and the National
Institute of Standards and Technology. This section provides
for a Director, member term limits, and additional
appointments.
The Fireshed Center established under this section will be
tasked with focusing on comprehensively assessing and
predicting fire and smoke in the wildland and built environment
interface through data integration and science-based decision
support service. The Center will also focus on reducing
fragmentation and duplication across federal land managers with
respect to predictive service and decision support functions
for wildland fire. The Center will promote inter-organizational
coordination, the sharing of data regarding wildland fire
decision-making, and streamlining procurement processes and
cyber security systems. Additionally, under this section, the
Fireshed Center will be responsible for providing publicly
accessible data, models, technologies, assessments, and fire
weather forecasts, as well as maintaining the Fireshed
Registry. This section allows for cooperative agreements with
State governments, Tribal governments, local governments,
academic institutions, and private entities to support
operations of the Center. Finally, USFS and USGS are both
permitted to provide administrative support, technical
services, and staff support to the Center.
Section 103. Fireshed registry
Section 103 requires the Fireshed Center to maintain a
registry on a publicly accessible website that provides
interactive geospatial data on individual firesheds.
Information for each fireshed is required to include wildfire
exposure by ownership, including rights-of-ways; hazardous
fuels treatments that occurred in the previous decade; wildfire
exposure threat delineated by threats to communities and
municipal watersheds, as well as the risk of forest conversion;
the percentage of the fireshed that burned in wildfires in the
previous decade, delineated to include high severity acres;
spatial patterns of wildfire exposure, including plausible
extreme fire events, and any planned hazardous fuels reduction
treatments. This section requires the sharing of this
information with communities to help inform community wildfire
protection plans. The Director of the Center is required to
publish fireshed assessments and maintain a public, searchable
permitting dashboard, based on the FAST 41 permitting
dashboard, to track the status of fireshed management projects.
Section 104. Shared stewardship
Section 104 codifies the principles of shared stewardship
to promote cross-boundary collaboration between federal and
state land managers by requiring the Secretaries of the
Interior and Agriculture to enter into shared stewardship
agreements within 90 days of receiving a request from a state
or Indian Tribe. Shared stewardship agreements will promote
joint wildfire risk reduction and the completion of fireshed
assessments. This section also allows the Secretaries to
designate additional fireshed management areas upon the request
of a Governor or Tribe. Existing shared stewardship agreements,
or similar agreements, are permitted to satisfy the
requirements of this section.
Section 105. Fireshed assessments
Section 105 directs the applicable Secretary and Governor
or Indian Tribe, after signing a shared stewardship agreement,
to conduct a fireshed assessment of the fireshed management
areas within the state. The fireshed assessment will be
regularly updated and identify wildfire exposure risks, at-risk
communities, and potential fireshed management projects. This
will include a strategy for reducing the threat of wildfire to
at-risk communities in the wildland-urban interface and
timelines or long-term benchmark goals for the completion of
fireshed management projects. This section allows local
governments within an applicable state to participate in
fireshed assessments. The Secretary is permitted under this
section to enter into memorandums of understanding to improve
the technology informing fireshed assessments. This section
requires the Secretary to utilize the best available science
from sources such as traditional ecological knowledge and state
forest action plans. Finally, this section clarifies the
assessments are not subject to the National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA).
Section 106. Emergency fireshed management
Section 106 directs the Secretary concerned to carry out
fireshed management projects in fireshed management areas. This
includes conducting hazardous fuels management, including
mechanical thinning, prescribed burning, cultural burning,
timber harvest, mastication, and grazing; creating fuel breaks
and fire breaks; removing hazard trees, dead trees, dying
trees, or trees at risk of dying; developing, approving, or
conducting routine maintenance under a vegetation management,
facility inspection, and operation and maintenance plan;
removing trees to address overstocking or crowding in a forest
stand, consistent with the appropriate basal area of the forest
stand as determined by the responsible official; using chemical
treatments to address insects and disease and control
vegetation competition or invasive species; any activities
recommended by the state-specific fireshed assessment carried
out under section 105; and any activities recommended by an
applicable community wildfire protection plan.
This section codifies emergency NEPA, National Historic
Preservation Act (NHPA), and Endangered Species Act (ESA)
regulations in fireshed management areas. Fireshed management
projects under this section are also permitted to occur under
existing statutory categorical exclusions (CEs).
This section increases acreage limitations on the insects
and disease CE from 3,000 acres to 10,000 acres; the wildfire
resilience CE from 3,000 acres to 10,000 acres; the sage grouse
and mule deer CE from 4,500 acres to 10,000 acres; and the fuel
breaks CE from 3,000 acres to 10,000 acres. The 10,000-acre
Tahoe CE is expanded beyond the Tahoe Basin.
This section applies the exemption for administrative
reviews from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA).
Federal land managers are directed by this section to apply CEs
for fireshed management projects in a manner consistent with
the statute establishing such CE and in all areas designated as
suitable for timber production within the applicable forest
plan or where timber harvesting is not prohibited. This section
directs the federal land managers to comply with NEPA, as
amended by the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023.
Finally, the Secretaries are directed to use the
authorities provided by this section in conjunction with other
authorities, such as Good Neighbor Authority (GNA), stewardship
contracting, self-determination contracts and self-governance
compact agreements with Indian Tribes, and agreements under the
Tribal Forest Protection Act of 2004.
Section 107. Sunset
Section 107 sunsets authorities in this subtitle after
seven years.
SUBTITLE B--EXPANDING COLLABORATIVE TOOLS TO REDUCE WILDFIRE RISK AND
IMPROVE FOREST HEALTH
Section 111. Modification of the treatment of certain revenue and
payments under Good Neighbor Agreements
Section 111 revises the GNA program to modify the treatment
of revenue from timber sale contracts under good neighbor
agreements with the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and
Department of the Interior (DOI). Under this section, Indian
Tribes and counties are permitted to retain revenue generated
from timber sales under a good neighbor agreement and states,
Indian Tribes, and counties may use such revenue for authorized
restoration projects on non-federal lands under a good neighbor
agreement. This section allows remaining funds to be used to
administer a GNA program by a state, Indian Tribe, or county.
GNA is extended through fiscal year (FY) 2029 by this section.
Section 112. Fixing stewardship end result contracting
Section 112 codifies 20-year stewardship contracting and
adds the retention and expansion of existing forest products
infrastructure as a goal under stewardship contracting. This
section also provides that any long-term stewardship contract
cancelled by USFS or BLM shall provide 10 percent of the
contract amount as cancellation costs.
Sec. 113. Intra-agency strike teams
Section 113 allows the Secretaries to each create 10-person
intra-agency strike teams to assist with environmental reviews,
site preparation, and the implementation of fireshed management
projects. Strike teams can be comprised of DOI or USFS
employees, private contractors, Tribal governments, State
governments, local governments, or volunteers. Under this
section, this authority will expire after seven years.
Sec. 114. Locally-led restoration
Section 114 raises the threshold on advertised timber sales
from $10,000 to $55,000, adjusted for inflation, to allow for
more direct bids of timber sales. This section also requires
the Secretary of Agriculture to solicit bids under the National
Forest Management Act of 1976 for fireshed management projects.
Section. 115. Joint Chiefs Landscape Restoration Partnership Program
Section 115 reauthorizes the Joint Chiefs' Landscape
Restoration Partnership Program through FY 2028. This section
also adds recovery from wildfire and the enhancement of soil,
water, and related natural resources to the list of eligible
activities under the program.
Section. 116. Collaborative Forest Landscape Restoration Program
Section 116 reauthorizes the Collaborative Forest Landscape
Restoration Program (CFLRP) through FY 2029. Regional foresters
are required by this section to develop a plan to provide
support for collaborative processes for each nominated project
proposal. This section encourages the further utilization of
innovative tools such as GNA as part of CFLRP projects. This
section encourages the prioritization of proposals seeking to
reduce uncharacteristic wildfire risk or increase ecological
restoration across jurisdictions or within the wildland-urban
interface. Finally, this section modifies the limitation on the
amount of overall CFLRP projects that can occur in a given year
to no more than four per USFS region.
SUBTITLE C--ADDRESSING FRIVOLOUS LITIGATION
Section 121. Commonsense litigation reform
Section 121 expands existing litigation reforms from IIJA
(no injunctions if the plaintiff is unlikely to succeed in the
case) and the Healthy Forests Restoration Act (balance of harms
when considering an injunction, time limitations for injunctive
relief).
This section also provides that a court shall not hold
unlawful, set aside, limit, delay, stay, vacate, or enjoin a
fireshed management project unless the project poses a risk of
proximate and substantial environmental harm and no other
equitable remedy is available. This section limits applicable
remedies by only allowing courts to remand a project back to
the agencies for a period of 180 days with instructions to
address specific errors or deficiencies. Such instructions
cannot include the preparation of a new environmental document
unless the court finds the agency failed to prepare the
appropriate document. During remand, a project may continue if
a specific action being conducted under the project does not
impact the additional actions that must be addressed on remand.
This section also limits those who can file claims against
a fireshed management project to those who participated in the
administrative proceedings regarding such project and submitted
a comment related to the subject of their lawsuit. Such claims
must be filed within 120 days of a final notice or decision on
a project.
Section 122. Consultation on forest plans
Section 122 amends the Forest and Rangeland Renewable
Resources Planning Act of 1974 and the Federal Land Management
and Policy Act of 1976 to specify that neither USFS nor BLM,
respectively, are required to reinitiate consultation on a land
management or use plan approved, amended, or revised when a
species is listed as threatened or endangered, critical habitat
is designated, or new information concerning a listed species
or critical habitat becomes available.
TITLE II--PROTECTING COMMUNITIES IN THE WILDLAND-URBAN INTERFACE
Section 201. Community Wildfire Risk Reduction Program
Section 201 creates a joint program between DOI's Office of
Wildland Fire, NPS, BLM, USFWS, BIA, USFS, FEMA, the U.S. Fire
Administration, and the National Institute of Standards and
Technology to advance research and science in wildfire
resilience and land management in the wildland-urban interface.
This program is also tasked with supporting Tribal and local
adoption of fire-resistant building methods, codes, and
standards; supporting Tribal and local efforts to address the
effects of wildland fires on communities, including property
damage, air quality, and water quality; encouraging public-
private partnerships to reduce hazardous fuels in the wildland-
urban interface, and providing technical and financial
assistance to communities through streamlined and unified
mechanisms. This section creates a centralized, uniform
application process for the various federal grants provided to
communities to address wildfire risk. The Secretary is
permitted under this section to provide technical assistance to
communities looking to apply for various grant programs. This
program will sunset after seven years.
Section 202. Community Wildfire Defense Research Program
Section 202 establishes a joint DOI USDA ``Community
Wildfire Defense Research Program'' under the Joint Fire
Science Program for the purpose of testing and advancing
innovative designs to create wildfire-resistant structures and
communities. This can include evaluations of different
affordable building materials, including mass timber; home
hardening techniques, including policies to incentivize and
incorporate defensible space; subdivision design and other land
use planning and design; landscape architecture; and other
wildfire-resistant designs for structures or communities, as
determined by the Secretary.
This section allows the Secretaries, in carrying out the
research program, to carry out a competition for innovative
wildfire-resistant designs, to be known as the Community
Wildfire Defense Innovation Prize.
This program will sunset after seven years.
Section 203. Vegetation management, facility inspection, and operation
and maintenance relating to electric transmission and
distribution facility rights-of-way
Section 203 amends existing expedited authorities under the
Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 (FLPMA) with
respect to rights of ways to allow the clearing of hazard trees
within 150 feet of an electric power line (currently this limit
is set at 10 feet). This section also allows for additional
consultation with private landowners. Under this section,
vegetation management plans submitted by electric utilities
will be automatically approved after approximately four months
without amendment. For plans with a modification, this section
sets specific timelines for plan approval by the agencies.
Sec. 204. Categorical exclusion for electric utility lines rights-of-
way
Section 204 creates a new CE for activities under a
vegetation management, facility inspection, and operation and
maintenance plan developed and approved under FLPMA for utility
rights-of-way. Wilderness areas and areas where the removal of
vegetation is restricted or prohibited are excluded under this
section. This section prohibits the establishment of permanent
roads. Finally, this section applies emergency regulations for
ESA and NHPA consultations.
Section 205. Seeds of success
Section 205 directs DOI, USDA, and DOD to develop and
implement a joint strategy to facilitate sustained interagency
coordination and a comprehensive approach to native plant
materials development and restoration. This strategy will also
promote the re-seeding of native or fire-resistant vegetation
post-wildfire, particularly in the wildland-urban interface,
and create information on native or fire-resistant vegetation
that can be shared with state, Tribal, and local governments.
Additionally, the agencies will be tasked with building
regional programs and partnerships to promote native plant
materials development and native plant restoration, giving
priority to regions of the BLM where such partnerships and
programs do not already exist. The strategy will also expand
seed storage and seed-cleaning infrastructure; expand the BLM's
Seed Warehouse System, particularly its cold storage capacity;
and shorten the timeline for the approval of permits to collect
seeds on public lands managed by the BLM. This section directs
the agencies to submit the strategy to Congress.
TITLE III--TRANSPARENCY AND TECHNOLOGY
Section 301. Biochar innovations and opportunities for conservation,
health, and advancements in research
Section 301 directs the Secretaries of Agriculture, the
Interior, and Energy to enter into partnerships to conduct
biochar demonstration projects in each region of the USFS and
BLM in two years. Under this section, the Secretaries must give
priority to project proposals that have the most carbon
sequestration potential, create new jobs in rural areas,
demonstrate the benefits of biochar, and are located in markets
that have the greatest need for biochar production units due to
high demand or wildfire risk. Feedstocks used for biochar
demonstration projects must derive at least 50 percent of their
materials from thinning activities conducted on federal lands
under this section.
The Secretaries are permitted under this section to provide
technical and financial assistance for demonstration projects
to acquire and test various feedstocks, develop and optimize
biochar production units, and build o
Dissenting Views
Democrats are committed to responding to the wildfire
crisis in a way that promotes the restoration of our forests
and public lands, strengthens community resilience and safety,
and supports the sustainable management of national forests. In
fact, House Democrats have taken real action to responsibly
address wildfire and forest management. Historic investments
outlined in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA)
and the Inflation Reduction Act enabled the Biden-Harris
administration to achieve record acres of hazard fuels
reduction and prescribed burns in the most at-risk priority
landscapes identified in the Wildfire Crisis Strategy.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\USFS, Wildfire Crisis Strategy (2022), https://www.fs.usda.gov/
sites/default/files/fs_media/fs_document/Confronting-the-Wildfire-
Crisis.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to securing investments and policy reforms,
House Democrats helped establish the Wildland Fire Mitigation
and Management Commission (WFMMC), which published a final
report containing 148 policy recommendations to address nearly
every facet of the wildfire crisis, including mitigation,
management, and postfire rehabilitation and recovery.\2\
Unfortunately, H.R. 8790, as reported by committee, strays from
these consensus-based recommendations and instead advances
longstanding Republican policy priorities that undermine
bedrock environmental standards and jeopardize public
involvement in forest planning.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\WFMMC, ON FIRE: The Report of the Wildland Fire Mitigation and
Management Commission (2023), https://www.usda.gov/sites/default/files/
documents/wfmmc-final-report-09-2023.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title I of the bill does lean into ongoing work outlined in
the Wildfire Crisis Strategy by requiring the U.S. Forest
Service (USFS) and Department of the Interior (DOI) to identify
new fireshed management areas (in addition to those already
established by the Wildfire Crisis Strategy), roll out a
fireshed registry, develop a fireshed data center, conduct
fireshed assessments, and implement fireshed management
projects. Several of these provisions align with the
recommendations from the WFMMC Report. For example, the
Fireshed Data Center outlined in section 102 of the bill would
be a new program in line with the recommendation to establish
``an interagency joint office with dedicated and separate
funding to fulfill the mission of comprehensive assessment and
prediction of fire in the wildland and built environment
interface through data aggregation and science-based decision
support services.''\3\ This is a critical need and innovation,
but H.R. 8790 lacks any language to ensure the availability of
funding. The lack of funding is a critical shortcoming that
impacts the potential success of this program.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Id. at 195.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, as reported, the bill continues to include
provisions that go beyond or even counter the WFMMC
recommendations. For example, Title I waives all environmental
planning requirements for the establishment of priority
firesheds, codifies the National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA) alternative arrangements typically utilized only for
discrete emergency situations, and includes a blanket
authorization to utilize expanded categorical exclusions (CEs)
for a broad range of so-called firesheds management projects.
Taken together, these provisions shortcut critical
opportunities to accelerate environmental reviews while
protecting communities, the environment and public input
opportunities in the development of forest management projects.
Achieving cross-boundary restoration goals across millions of
acres of public, state, private, and tribal land requires
collaboration. This is often achieved through the NEPA process,
especially as projects get bigger and more complex. Removing
these safeguards and opportunities for public input is a step
in the wrong direction.
Section 121 of the bill would place limits on injunctive
relief and block the public's access to the courts for judicial
review of firesheds management projects. Under the bill, the
public would be required to file a claim or protest to a
project within 120 days of when the notice is filed in the
Federal Register. In the case of projects developed with a
public comment process--a potentially rare feature of future
projects developed under the authority provided by this bill--
judicial review would be limited to parties who participated in
the public comment period. While these attacks on public
participation are being sold as ``commonsense'' reforms
designed to end ``frivolous'' litigation, they would unfairly
shut off access to the courts. A 2020 study showed that only
one out of every 450 NEPA reviews are ever litigated.\4\
Limiting judicial review is not the solution to permitting
delays and/or costs. In fact, it could come with swaths of
unintended consequences and limit necessary checks on agency
action.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\John C. Ruple & Kayla M. Race, Measuring the NEPA Litigation
Burden, 50(2) Env't L. 479 (Lewis and Clark Law School) (2020), https:/
/www.jstor.org/stable/26939867.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, section 122 consists of the so-called
``Cottonwood Fix.'' Committee Democrats continue to oppose the
controversial H.R. 200, the so-called FIR Act, which the
majority has insisted on marking up as a standalone bill and as
part of Chair Westerman's so-called Recovering America's
Habitat Act. Now making its third markup appearance in the Fix
Our Forests Act, this language limits thoughtful planning when
new endangered species are listed, critical habitat is
designated, or new scientific information arises on USFS lands.
This could be damaging for newly listed species and for
adapting management plans as the impacts of climate change
grow. Federal forests are managed for multiple benefits and
uses, including providing critical habitat for endangered and
threatened species. Protections and safeguards that exist on
federal land mitigate the impacts of development that occurs
elsewhere. Undermining the Endangered Species Act (ESA) upsets
that balance and has the potential to do lasting harm to
threatened and endangered wildlife populations.
Consultation is not the obstacle or detriment to project
implementation as it is characterized by proponents of the FIR
Act. In fact, a peer reviewed article published in the
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United
States of America analyzed 81,461 informal consultations and
6,829 formal consultations from January 2008 through January
2015 and found that the median duration of consultation was 13
days for informal consultation and 62 days for formal
consultations. Claims to the contrary cherry-pick extreme
examples to undermine ESA protections. Rather than focus on
hyperbolic rhetoric that ignores evidence, Congress should
provide federal agencies with the tools and resources they need
to make science-informed decisions. Allowing land managers to
rely on decades-old plans that turn a blind eye to the latest
information is counterproductive at best.
Title II of the reported bill falls short in its supposed
goal of addressing concerns about the built environment and the
wildland-urban interface. It would establish a severely
narrowed down version of a Community Wildfire Risk Reduction
Program (recommendation from WFMMC Report) and a Wildfire
Defense Research Program. Given the urgent need to prioritize
and provide funding for urgent activities like community
planning and home hardening, these are potentially critical
components of confronting the wildfire crisis. That's exactly
why House Democrats fought to include $1 billion in the IIJA to
establish the Community Wildfire Defense Program.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\https://www.fs.usda.gov/managing-land/fire/grants/cwdg.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title II purports to build on this success but falls short
of identifying new funds. Additionally, this Title would
establish another set of CEs for vegetation management projects
adjacent to electrical utility lines and expands the range
definition of a hazard tree from the existing 10-foot range up
to 150 feet. The language would also classify these projects as
emergencies under the ESA and the National Historic
Preservation Act, a procedure that could have unintended
impacts on both threatened and endangered species and
vulnerable cultural resources.
Title III is almost entirely composed of pieces of
legislation that have already been considered as standalone
bills by the Federal Lands Subcommittee, some of which have
even been reported out of committee and passed by the House.
The Title purports to increase programs dedicated to new and
innovative ways of responding to wildfires, including by
promoting biochar development and new wildfire detection
devices. It also would require a new Government Accountability
Office (GAO) study on USFS's wildland fire operations and a
pointless and expensive USFS study about relocating its
headquarters to the West. Some sections are duplicative and
mirror already existing programs (see Fire Weather Testbed\6\
and Seeds of Success\7\). Like many aspects of H.R. 8790, Title
III would require a significant investment from U.S. Forest
Service and, again, does not provide any additional resources.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://gsl.noaa.gov/fire-wx/fire-weather-testbed.
\7\https://www.blm.gov/programs/natural-resources/native-plant-
communities/native-plant-and-seed-material-development/collection.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Democrats offered various amendments to modify the most
contentious provisions and shape a bill that could be supported
on a truly bipartisan basis. Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife,
and Fisheries Ranking Member Jared Huffman offered an amendment
that would have removed many of the more problematic sections
highlighted in these views. In addition to removing attacks on
NEPA and ESA, the amendment would have incorporated additional
improvements throughout the bill to retain federal decision-
making authority, improve and enhance tribal representation,
and incorporate technical assistance provided by the Forest
Service and the Department of the Interior. While the amendment
presented by the minority retained most of the bill and sought
only to rein in its most extreme elements, it was rejected on a
party-line vote. Democrats also offered a standalone amendment
to strike Section 121.
Committee Republicans were unwilling to work on the
sections of this bill that are most concerning to Democrats to
make this a truly bipartisan bill among committee members.
Votes were split on a party line.
In addition to highlighting specific policy concerns,
Democrats presented a findings amendment that emphasized the
impact that climate change has on wildfire and forest health.
Democrats also offered an amendment to authorize approximately
$1 billion over seven years to actually enable the various new
authorities and requirements presented in this bill. Effective
wildfire work requires both pre-fire and suppression financial
support. You cannot have one without the other. One billion
over seven years is minimal compared to the $3.17 billion the
U.S. government spent on suppression in 2023 alone.
Both of these amendments were similarly rejected by the
majority in party-line votes. Chair Westerman contended that
the climate amendment was ``talk and no action'' suggesting
that active forest management is the solution. However, this
bill does not work to balance forest management with
restoration and climate goals and instead favors logging in the
name of wildfire prevention. Further, Committee Republicans did
not support the funding amendment, claiming that it would hold
the bill up because it would not be eligible for floor process.
However, a lack of funding will ultimately be detrimental to
the directions in this bill as the agencies will be further
burdened without proper support. These investments are
necessary.
Many of the management challenges associated with our
national forests are related to the lack of federal funding.
That should not be a partisan issue. The Committee should focus
on improving existing management tools and implementing the
WFMMC's consensus-based recommendations.
There is common ground on these issues. Democrats stand
ready to work with the majority to move forward on a bipartisan
basis on forest health, fire, disease, bugs, and providing
economic opportunity in rural, forest counties across the
country.
Unfortunately, this bill is anchored in the false notion
that public participation and environmental review are impeding
active management, and the bill ignores experts who
continuously cite the lack of agency capacity, unstable
budgets, and outdated technology as the main sources of delays.
That's what actually needs to be ``fixed.''
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member.