Background
H.R. 9076 was introduced on July 22, 2024, and was referred
to the Committee on Ways and Means.
COMMITTEE HEARINGS
The Committee has held four child welfare hearings in the
118th Congress to inform the policy changes in H.R. 9076.
On September 28, 2023, the Committee on Ways and Means Work
and Welfare Subcommittee held a hearing titled, ``Modernizing
Child Welfare to Protect Vulnerable Children,'' which focused
on ways to modernize the Title IV-B program and challenges
facing the child welfare system, including lack of foster
homes, case worker shortages, court backlogs, and lack of
support for family members caring for children who might
otherwise be in foster care.
On January 17, 2024, the Committee on Ways and Means Work
and Welfare Subcommittee held a hearing titled, ``Pathways to
Independence: Supporting Youth Aging Out of Foster Care,''
which addressed opportunities to better support foster youth,
so they have the tools they need to succeed in adulthood.
On May 10, 2024, the Committee on Ways and Means held a
field hearing in Arizona titled, ``Empowering Native American
and Rural Communities,'' which addressed disparities for tribal
child welfare providers and the need to monitor state actions
that affect children protected by the Indian Child Welfare Act.
On June 26, 2024, the Committee on Ways and Means held a
hearing titled, ``Strengthening Child Welfare and Protecting
America's Children,'' which highlighted the need to reauthorize
the Title IV-B program, protect vulnerable youth, and modernize
the program.
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 9076, the
``Protecting America's Children by Strengthening Families
Act,'' on July 24, 2024, and ordered the bill, as amended,
favorably reported (with a quorum being present).
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearing was used to develop and consider this legislation:
(1) The Committee on Ways and Means Full Committee
hearing on ``Strengthening Child Welfare and Protecting
America's Children'' held on June 26, 2024.
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
Section. 1. Short title; references
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Committee believes the title accurately reflects the
content of the bill.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
This section provides the title for the bill ``Protecting
America's Children by Strengthening Families Act''.
Section 2. Table of contents
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Committee believes this accurately reflects the content
of the bill.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
This section provides a table of contents.
Section 3. Reauthorization of child welfare programs
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Committee is responsible for ensuring the Title IV-B
program is authorized and that federal funding is achieving its
purpose and responsive to the needs of families and children
involved in the child welfare system as well as community-based
partners working to prevent child abuse and neglect.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
This section extends the authorization for the Stephanie
Tubbs Jones Child Welfare Services (CWS) program (Title IV-B,
Subpart 1 of the Social Security Act (SSA)) from fiscal year FY
2025-FY 2029 at the current level. Extends the authorization
for the MaryLee Allen Promoting Safe and Stable Families (PSSF)
program (Title IV-B, Subpart 2 of the SSA) at the current level
of discretionary funding from FY 2025-FY 2029 and at $345
million for FY 2025 and $420 million for each of FY 2026-FY
2029.
Adds a cap of $10 million to the reservation of funds for
Grants to States for Enhancing Collaboration between State
Child Welfare and Juvenile Justice Systems. Current law
requires that in any year when CWS funds receive an
appropriation that exceeds $270 million, the Department of
Health and Human Services (HHS) must reserve a portion of the
``excess'' funds to make competitive grants for this purpose
but does not currently stipulate any limit on the amount funds
HHS may reserve.
Section 4. Enhancements to the court improvement program
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Court Improvement Program (CIP) is essential to
ensuring that courts can best serve children and families in
the child welfare system. Courts' ability to conduct and
expedite child welfare and permanency hearings significantly
impacts families' involvement with the system and the time
children spend in care. This bill increases funding to promote
greater innovation and codifies modernization policies to
provide courts with greater flexibility in conducting remote
hearings when appropriate and in the best interests of the
child and family.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
Increases the set-aside funding for CIP from $30 million to
$40 million beginning with FY 2026. Extends the state court
match requirement of 25% from FY 2025-FY 2029. CIP is a
mandatory formula grant available to the highest court of
appeal in every state, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico
and the U.S. Virgin Islands. The purpose of the CIP is to: (1)
promote the continuous quality improvement of court processes
and legal representation in child welfare proceedings through
ongoing data analysis, assessment, interventions and training;
and (2) enhance and expand collaboration between the judicial
branch of state government, the title IV-B agency and tribes to
improve child welfare outcomes.
Modernizes and improves the CIP by allowing funds to be
used for technology to conduct remote hearings and ensure the
continuity of court services during public health crises,
natural disasters, or cyberattacks, with informed participant
consent. Requires HHS to issue implementation guidance to state
courts and tribes by October 1, 2025, and every five years
thereafter, on best practices related to the use of remote
technology, and to consult with Indian tribes on state court
proceedings involving Indian children to support compliance
with the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) of 1978.
Section 5. Expanding Regional Partnership Grants (RPGs) to address
parental substance abuse disorder as cause of child removal
REASONS FOR CHANGE
In FY 2022, 33% of children were removed from their homes
and entered the child welfare system due to parental substance
abuse.\1\ This section seeks to increase coordinated support
for addressing parental substance use disorders (SUD) directly,
by investing in cost and outcome-effective interventions
through RPGs, and indirectly, by growing the number of
evidence-based interventions related to SUD which are available
for federal matching funds. RPG projects support interagency
collaborations and integration of programs, services, and
activities designed to increase the well-being, improve the
permanency, and enhance the safety of children who are in, or
at risk of, out-of-home placements as the result of a parent or
caregiver's substance use disorder. The partnerships implement
a range of activities and interventions, including peer
recovery coaching, family-centered and prevention-focused
services, parenting and family strengthening programs,
specialized services to fathers, and pregnant and postpartum
women, medication assisted treatment, in-home parenting and
child safety support for families, and related evidence-based
practices.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Children's Bureau. (2024, March 13). AFCARS Report #30. U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since RPG began in 2007, 127 projects across 40 states have
been funded and grantees have served more than 37,000 children;
27,000 adults; and 22,000 families. A cross-site evaluation
found that, upon exiting the program, parental opioid use
decreased from 16% to 4%, and 86% of participants sustained
program strategies.\2\ Increased funding and modernization of
RPG's is needed to serve families, better support inclusion of
programs in the Family First Prevention Services Clearinghouse,
and align grant requirements with best practices identified in
prior evaluations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\U.S. Department of Health & Human Services. (2018). Emerging
findings from the 2012-2017 National Cross-Site Evaluation of the
Regional Partnership Grant (RPG) Program.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
Requires HHS to make grants under the RPG program in each
of FY 2025-FY 2029 and increases the funding set-aside from $20
million to $30 million beginning in FY 2026. Extends the five
percent limitation on use of funds for administrative purposes
(FY 2025-FY 2029).
Modernizes and improves the RPG program by: requiring HHS
to consider whether RPG's applying for funds demonstrate
capacity to conduct rigorous evaluation of program
effectiveness and whether partnerships outline a plan to
increase the availability of services statewide; requiring HHS
to report whether RPG programs are submitted for rating to the
Family First Prevention Services Clearinghouse; adding child
permanency and family reunification as performance indicators;
requiring consultation with relevant HHS agencies, including
the National Institute on Drug Abuse on development of core
indicators; requiring juvenile or state family courts to be a
part of partnerships; and adding a performance indicator
related to families with children overrepresented in foster
care, difficult to place, or with disproportionately low
permanency rates.
Permits HHS to waive, on a case-by-case basis, the planning
phase requirement if a grantee demonstrates they have completed
sufficient planning before submitting their application and
removes the $250,000 cap on planning phase grants.
Section 6. Modernization; reducing administrative burden
REASONS FOR CHANGE
This section includes several updates to modernize the
Title IV-B program, clarify allowable uses of funds, and
improve coordination and alignment with the 2018 Family First
Prevention Services Act (P.L. 115-123), which provided federal
matching funds for evidence-based prevention services to
families at-risk of involvement in the child welfare system.
These updates aim to better address the needs of vulnerable
children and families and to prevent or limit child welfare
involvement whenever possible.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
Modernizes and improves the Title IV-B program by:
allowing funding to be used for an
electronic or digital portal that facilitates access to
community support that meet specific needs of children
and families. Provides a limitation that portals shall
not maintain or share personal information for any
purpose other than referrals.
amending the definition of family support
services to include family resource centers that act as
community or school-based hubs and support families
using a multigenerational, strengths-based and family-
centered approach. Provides that expenditures for
family resource centers may be considered as an
expenditure in any one or more of the four categorical
services areas listed in Subpart 2 as long as the
expenditure is related to serving children and families
in the specified category and consistent with the
overall purpose of the category. Services meeting this
definition do not need to be provided exclusively by a
program with the name ``family resource center'' and
may apply to community-based family strengthening
services such as state children's trust funds and
nonprofits that assist families in building protective
factors linked to the prevention of child abuse and
neglect.
updating state plan requirements to:
include a description of steps
the state will take to ensure children,
parents, guardians, or other custodians have
access to information about available
independent legal representation, to help
ensure that all parties have representation.
include mental health service
providers and professionals when developing
plans for coordination of health care services
for all children in foster care including
infants, toddlers, young children, and teens
and requiring informed consent of youth in
protocols for use of psychotropic medication.
eliminating the requirement that
the state agency administering child welfare
services be the same state agency that
administers the Social Services Block Grant.
Reduces administrative burden on recipients of Title IV-B
Subpart 1 and 2 funding by requiring HHS, in consultation with
states, tribes and tribal organizations, and territories, to
review and revise administrative requirements related to
paperwork and data collection forms to reduce hours spent on
compliance by at least 15 percent. As part of the tribal
review, the Committee expects HHS to consider and fully
administer tribal IV-B funding as an eligible integrated
service, as may be applicable per Section 477 of Indian
Employment, Training, and Related Services Demonstration Act of
1992 (P.L. 102-477), as amended by the Indian Employment,
Training and Related Services Consolidation Act of 2017 (P.L.
115-93).
Requires HHS to implement changes within two years and
submit a Report to Congress on how the agency complied with the
requirements within three years of enactment. Provides a
limitation that the section shall not affect state plan
requirements used for oversight and to monitor proper
expenditure of funds.
Improves transparency by requiring HHS to create a
standardized format for state plans, including aggregated
information with national summaries of state submissions and
comparisons of trends, and make the plans available on a public
website.
Adds primary prevention partners, including community-based
organizations with experience in preventing unnecessary child
welfare system involvement, to the parties HHS must consult
with when evaluating the effectiveness of programs under Title
IV B.
Section 7. Streamlining funding for Indian tribes
REASONS FOR CHANGE
Child welfare funding for tribes is outdated and
fragmented, leading to a limited number of tribes having access
to Title IV-B. This bill aims to modernize funding for tribes
under Subpart 1, originally established in 1935, and also under
Subpart 2. It provides greater administrative flexibility,
allowing tribes with smaller populations and allocations to
make meaningful investments in Indian children and families to
prevent their entry into the child welfare system.
The Ways and Means Full Committee Field Hearing on May 10,
2024, titled ``Empowering Native American and Rural
Communities'' highlighted the need to streamline Title IV-B
funding for tribes and monitor state policies and procedures to
protect child and tribal rights as described in the Indian
Child Welfare Act of 1978 (ICWA). The Committee heard directly
from representatives of tribal communities about the importance
and impact of making these changes.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
Streamlines and increases funding for Indian tribes and
tribal organizations by providing a required 3% set-aside under
Subpart 1 (to match the set-aside in Subpart 2) and requires
HHS to make payments directly to Indian tribes which operate
child welfare programs. Current law gives HHS discretion to
determine the amount of Subpart 1 funding that goes to tribes
and provides funding through deductions from the state's
allocation. Currently, that amount is approximately 2.7% of
Subpart 1 funds.
Updates existing plan requirement for states to describe
their policies and procedures that meet ICWA requirements by
expanding to include how they will ensure Indian tribes and
tribal organizations receive pertinent information for custody
proceedings involving Indian children, including timely notice
and transfers of jurisdiction.
Requires HHS to develop a plan not later than October 1,
2025, in consultation with tribal organizations and states, to
provide technical assistance to support effective
implementation of ICWA. Requires the plan to address areas for
state improvement including timely identification of Indian
children and extended family members, timely notice of state
custody proceedings involving Indian children, reports of cases
in which a transfer of jurisdiction was not granted and reasons
for denial, and efforts to prevent the breakup of Indian
families. Requires Department of Interior to provide guidance
to HHS and assistance as needed to help state and public child
welfare agencies comply with ICWA. Requires HHS to submit a
biennial Report to Congress on state compliance with ICWA and
how the HHS Secretary is assisting states and Indian tribes in
improving the implementation of standards in order to support
Congressional oversight.
The language under Section 429B of the bill regarding a
biennial report to Congress on state implementation of the
Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 reflects the Committee's
understanding of 42 U.S.C. 422(b)(9) as requiring a state, in
consultation with tribal organizations in the state, to provide
a description of measures taken to comply with ICWA as part of
the state's plan and not a specific measure of state ICWA
compliance. The Committee also recognizes the data collected
under Section 429B for the purposes of informing this report is
not a specific measure of ICWA compliance, but does provide
useful information on how states are implementing key
requirements of ICWA.
Provides HHS authority to modify reporting requirements for
Indian tribes and organizations receiving not more than $50,000
to reduce administrative burden on tribes. The modifications
must be made in consultation with affected Indian tribes and
tribal organizations in a way that limits administrative
burden.
Provides new flexibilities for Indian tribes administering
child welfare programs including: permitting Indian tribes to
substitute a different administrative cost rate as negotiated
and used by tribe for other federal grants; specifying that
Indian tribes administering child welfare programs meet the
$10,000 threshold under Subpart 2 based on consideration of
both mandatory and discretionary funding provided under Subpart
2, and that the 3% in funding reserved for tribes under Subpart
2 must be reserved before other set-asides of that funding.
Increases funding for the CIP program for tribes from $1
million to $2 million beginning in FY 2026. These grants are
awarded competitively.
Section 8. Accelerating access to Family First Prevention Services
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Family First Prevention Services Clearinghouse assesses
research evaluations of programs designed to prevent children
from entering the child welfare system. Established in 2018 by
the Family First Prevention Services Act (P.L. 115-123), the
Clearinghouse provides ratings mental health support, substance
abuse prevention and treatment, in-home parent skill-based
programs, and kinship navigator programs. Only programs in the
Clearinghouse are eligible for federal prevention services
matching funds. As of July 2024, 85 programs have been approved
by the Clearinghouse, with many organizations citing challenges
in developing and conducting the rigorous research needed for
approval.\3\ This bill intends to improve the number and
selection of prevention services offered under Family First by
providing competitive grants for researching programs to meet
Clearinghouse standards.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Administration for Children and Families (ACF), U.S. Department
of Health and Human Services (HHS). (2024). Title IV-E Prevention
Services Clearinghouse.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EXPLANATION OF PROVISIONS
Reserves $5 million in discretionary funding for
competitive grants for each of FY 2025-FY 2029 to eligible
entities to support the timely evaluation of prevention
services and programs to fill gaps in the interventions
currently available to states in the Clearinghouse. Projects
must be carried out by at least one partner entity that is able
to provide the service or program and one that is able to
evaluate that w