Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 9462]
The Committee on Ways and Means, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 9462) to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to
allow a credit against tax for charitable donations to
nonprofit organizations providing education scholarships to
qualified elementary and secondary students, having considered
the same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND........................................... 7
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 7
B. Background and Need for Legislation................. 7
C. Legislative History................................. 8
D. Designated Hearing.................................. 8
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL.......................................... 8
A. Tax Credit for Contributions of Individuals to
Scholarship Granting Organizations; Exemption from
Gross Income for Scholarships for Qualified
Elementary or Secondary Education Expenses of
Eligible Students; Organizational and Parental
Autonomy (secs. 2, 3, and 4 of the bill and new
sections 25F, 139J, and 4969 of the Code).......... 8
III. VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE.......................................... 14
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL...................................... 18
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects............. 18
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax
Expenditures Budget Authority...................... 19
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office............................................. 19
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE...... 19
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations.... 19
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and
Objectives......................................... 19
C. Tax Complexity Analysis............................. 19
D. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates........... 20
E. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and
Limited Tariff Benefits............................ 20
F. Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 20
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED........... 20
A. Changes in Existing Law Proposed by the Bill, as
Reported........................................... 20
VII. EXCHANGE OF LETTERS............................................. 33
VIII.DISSENTING VIEWS................................................ 35
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Educational Choice for Children Act of
2024''.
SEC. 2. TAX CREDIT FOR CONTRIBUTIONS OF INDIVIDUALS TO SCHOLARSHIP
GRANTING ORGANIZATIONS.
(a) Allowance of Credit.--
(1) In general.--Subpart A of part IV of subchapter A of
chapter 1 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 is amended by
inserting after section 25E the following new section:
``SEC. 25F. QUALIFIED ELEMENTARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION SCHOLARSHIPS.
``(a) Allowance of Credit.--In the case of an individual, there shall
be allowed as a credit against the tax imposed by this chapter for the
taxable year an amount equal to the aggregate amount of qualified
contributions made by the taxpayer during the taxable year.
``(b) Limitations.--
``(1) In general.--The credit allowed under subsection (a) to
any taxpayer for any taxable year shall not exceed an amount
equal to the greater of--
``(A) 10 percent of the adjusted gross income of the
taxpayer for the taxable year, or
``(B) $5,000.
``(2) Allocation of volume cap.--The credit allowed under
subsection (a) to any taxpayer for any taxable year shall not
exceed the amount of the volume cap allocated by the Secretary
to such taxpayer under subsection (g) with respect to qualified
contributions made by the taxpayer during the taxable year.
``(3) Reduction based on state credit.--The amount allowed as
a credit under subsection (a) for a taxable year shall be
reduced by the amount allowed as a credit on any State tax
return of the taxpayer for qualified contributions made by the
taxpayer during the taxable year.
``(c) Definitions.--For purposes of this section--
``(1) Eligible student.--The term `eligible student' means an
individual who--
``(A) is a member of a household with an income which
is not greater than 300 percent of the area median
gross income (as such term is used in section 42), and
``(B) is eligible to enroll in a public elementary or
secondary school.
``(2) Qualified contribution.--The term `qualified
contribution' means a charitable contribution (as defined by
section 170(c)) to a scholarship granting organization in the
form of cash or marketable securities.
``(3) Qualified elementary or secondary education expense.--
The term `qualified elementary or secondary education expense'
means the following expenses in connection with enrollment or
attendance at, or for students enrolled at or attending, an
elementary or secondary public, private, or religious school:
``(A) Tuition.
``(B) Curriculum and curricular materials.
``(C) Books or other instructional materials.
``(D) Online educational materials.
``(E) Tuition for tutoring or educational classes
outside of the home, including at a tutoring facility,
but only if the tutor or instructor is not related to
the student and--
``(i) is licensed as a teacher in any State,
``(ii) has taught at an eligible educational
institution, or
``(iii) is a subject matter expert in the
relevant subject.
``(F) Fees for a nationally standardized norm-
referenced achievement test, an advanced placement
examination, or any examinations related to college or
university admission.
``(G) Fees for dual enrollment in an institution of
higher education.
``(H) Educational therapies for students with
disabilities provided by a licensed or accredited
practitioner or provider, including occupational,
behavioral, physical, and speech-language therapies.
Such term shall include expenses for the purposes described in
subparagraphs (A) through (H) in connection with a homeschool
(whether treated as a homeschool or a private school for
purposes of applicable State law).
``(4) Scholarship granting organization.--The term
`scholarship granting organization' means any organization--
``(A) which--
``(i) is described in section 501(c)(3) and
exempt from tax under section 501(a), and
``(ii) is not a private foundation,
``(B) substantially all of the activities of which
are providing scholarships for qualified elementary or
secondary education expenses of eligible students,
``(C) which prevents the co-mingling of qualified
contributions with other amounts by maintaining one or
more separate accounts exclusively for qualified
contributions, and
``(D) which either--
``(i) meets the requirements of subsection
(d), or
``(ii) pursuant to State law, was able (as of
the date of the enactment of this section) to
receive contributions that are eligible for a
State tax credit if such contributions are used
by the organization to provide scholarships to
individual elementary and secondary students,
including scholarships for attending private
schools.
``(d) Requirements for Scholarship Granting Organizations.--
``(1) In general.--An organization meets the requirements of
this subsection if--
``(A) such organization provides scholarships to 2 or
more students, provided that not all such students
attend the same school,
``(B) such organization does not provide scholarships
for any expenses other than qualified elementary or
secondary education expenses,
``(C) such organization provides a scholarship to
eligible students with a priority for--
``(i) students awarded a scholarship the
previous school year, and
``(ii) after application of clause (i), any
such students who have a sibling who was
awarded a scholarship from such organization,
``(D) such organization does not earmark or set aside
contributions for scholarships on behalf of any
particular student,
``(E) such organization takes appropriate steps to
verify the annual household income and family size of
eligible students to whom it awards scholarships, and
limits them to a member of a household for which the
income does not exceed the amount established under
subsection (c)(1)(A),
``(F) such organization--
``(i) obtains from an independent certified
public accountant annual financial and
compliance audits, and
``(ii) certifies to the Secretary (at such
time, and in such form and manner, as the
Secretary may prescribe) that the audit
described in clause (i) has been completed, and
``(G) no officer or board member of such organization
has been convicted of a felony.
``(2) Income verification.--For purposes of paragraph (1)(E),
review of all of the following (as applicable) shall be treated
as satisfying the requirement to take appropriate steps to
verify annual household income:
``(A) Federal and State income tax returns or tax
return transcripts with applicable schedules for the
taxable year prior to application.
``(B) Income reporting statements for tax purposes or
wage and income transcripts from the Internal Revenue
Service.
``(C) Notarized income verification letter from
employers.
``(D) Unemployment or workers compensation
statements.
``(E) Budget letters regarding public assistance
payments and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program
(SNAP) payments including a list of household members.
``(3) Independent certified public accountant.--For purposes
of paragraph (1)(F), the term `independent certified public
accountant' means, with respect to an organization, a certified
public accountant who is not a person described in section
465(b)(3)(A) with respect to such organization or any employee
of such organization.
``(4) Prohibition on self-dealing.--
``(A) In general.--A scholarship granting
organization may not award a scholarship to any
disqualified person.
``(B) Disqualified person.--For purposes of this
paragraph, a disqualified person shall be determined
pursuant to rules similar to the rules of section 4946.
``(e) Denial of Double Benefit.--Any qualified contribution for which
a credit is allowed under this section shall not be taken into account
as a charitable contribution for purposes of section 170.
``(f) Carryforward of Unused Credit.--
``(1) In general.--If the credit allowable under subsection
(a) for any taxable year exceeds the limitation imposed by
section 26(a) for such taxable year reduced by the sum of the
credits allowable under this subpart (other than this section,
section 23, and section 25D), such excess shall be carried to
the succeeding taxable year and added to the credit allowable
under subsection (a) for such taxable year.
``(2) Limitation.--No credit may be carried forward under
this subsection to any taxable year following the fifth taxable
year after the taxable year in which the credit arose. For
purposes of the preceding sentence, credits shall be treated as
used on a first-in first-out basis.
``(g) Volume Cap.--
``(1) In general.--The volume cap applicable under this
section shall be $5,000,000,000 for each of calendar years 2025
through 2028, and zero for calendar years thereafter. Such
amount shall be allocated by the Secretary as provided in
paragraph (2) to taxpayers with respect to qualified
contributions made by such taxpayers, except that 10 percent of
such amount shall be divided evenly among the States, and shall
be available with respect to individuals residing in such
States.
``(2) First-come, first-serve.--For purposes of applying the
volume cap under this section, such volume cap for any calendar
year shall be allocated by the Secretary on a first-come,
first-serve basis, as determined based on the time (during such
calendar year) at which the taxpayer made the qualified
contribution with respect to which the allocation is made. The
Secretary shall not make any allocation of volume cap for any
calendar year after December 31 of such calendar year.
``(3) Real-time information.--For purposes of this section,
the Secretary shall develop a system to track the amount of
qualified contributions made during the calendar year for which
a credit may be claimed under this section, with such
information to be updated in real time.
``(4) Annual increases.--
``(A) In general.--In the case of the calendar year
after a high use calendar year, the dollar amount
otherwise in effect under subsection (a) for such
calendar year shall be equal to 105 percent of the
dollar amount in effect for such high use calendar
year.
``(B) High use calendar year.--For purposes of this
subsection, the term `high use calendar year' means any
calendar year for which 90 percent or more of the
volume cap in effect for such calendar year under
subsection (a) is allocated to taxpayers.
``(C) Prevention of decreases in annual volume cap.--
The volume cap in effect under subsection (a) for any
calendar year shall not be less than the volume cap in
effect under such subsection for the preceding calendar
year.
``(D) Publication of annual volume cap.--The
Secretary shall make publicly available the dollar
amount of the volume cap in effect under subsection (a)
for each calendar year.
``(5) States.--For purposes of this subsection, the term
`State' includes the District of Columbia.''.
(2) Conforming amendments.--
(A) Section 25(e)(1)(C) of such Code is amended by
striking ``and 25D'' and inserting ``25D, and 25F''.
(B) The table of sections for subpart A of part IV of
subchapter A of chapter 1 of such Code is amended by
inserting after the item relating to section 25E the
following new item:
``Sec. 25F. Qualified elementary and secondary education
scholarships.''.
(b) Failure of Scholarship Granting Organizations to Make
Distributions.--
(1) In general.--Chapter 42 of such Code is amended by adding
at the end the following new subchapter:
``Subchapter I--Scholarship Granting Organizations
``Sec. 4969. Failure to distribute receipts.
``SEC. 4969. FAILURE TO DISTRIBUTE RECEIPTS.
``(a) In General.--In the case of any scholarship granting
organization (as defined in section 25F) which has been determined by
the Secretary to have failed to satisfy the requirement under
subsection (b) for any taxable year, any contribution made to such
organization during the first taxable year beginning after the date of
such determination shall not be treated as a qualified contribution (as
defined in section 25F(c)(2)) for purposes of section 25F.
``(b) Requirement.--The requirement described in this subsection is
that the amount of receipts of the scholarship granting organization
for the taxable year which are distributed before the distribution
deadline with respect to such receipts shall not be less than the
required distribution amount with respect to such taxable year.
``(c) Definitions.--For purposes of this section--
``(1) Required distribution amount.--
``(A) In general.--The required distribution amount
with respect to a taxable year is the amount equal to
100 percent of the total receipts of the scholarship
granting organization for such taxable year--
``(i) reduced by the sum of such receipts
that are retained for reasonable administrative
expenses for the taxable year or are carried to
the succeeding taxable year under subparagraph
(C), and
``(ii) increased by the amount of the
carryover under subparagraph (C) from the
preceding taxable year.
``(B) Safe harbor for reasonable administrative
expenses.--For purposes of subparagraph (A)(i), if the
percentage of total receipts of a scholarship granting
organization for a taxable year which are used for
administrative purposes is equal to or less than 10
percent, such expenses shall be deemed to be reasonable
Background
H.R. 9462 was introduced on September 6, 2024, and was
referred to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Committee Hearings
On October 25, 2023, the Committee held a hearing on,
``Educational Freedom and Opportunity for American Families,
Students and Workers.''
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 9462, the
``Educational Choice for Children Act of 2024,'' on September
11, 2024, and ordered the bill, as amended, favorably reported
(with a quorum being present).
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop and consider H.R. 9462:
On October 25, 2023, the Committee held a hearing on,
``Educational Freedom and Opportunity for American
Families, Students and Workers.''
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. Tax Credit for Contributions of Individuals to Scholarship Granting
Organizations; Exemption From Gross Income for Scholarships for
Qualified Elementary or Secondary Education Expenses of Eligible
Students; Organizational and Parental Autonomy (Secs. 2, 3, and 4 of
the Bill and New Sections 25F, 139J, and 4969 of the Code)
PRESENT LAW
Charitable contribution deduction
In computing taxable income, an individual taxpayer who
itemizes deductions or a corporate taxpayer generally is
allowed to deduct the amount of cash and the fair market value
of property contributed to an organization described in section
501(c)(3) or to a Federal, State, or local governmental entity,
including to most educational organizations.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Within certain limitations, donors also are entitled to deduct
such contributions for estate and gift tax purposes. See secs. 2055 and
2522.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The amount of the deduction allowable for a taxable year
with respect to a charitable contribution of property may be
reduced depending on the type of property contributed, the type
of charitable organization to which the property is
contributed, and the income of the taxpayer.\2\ For individual
taxpayers, the income-based limitation on the charitable
contribution deduction is higher for gifts made to public
charities than for gifts made to private foundations.
Contributions of cash to a public charity generally are
deductible up to 60 percent\3\ of the donor's adjusted gross
income (``AGI'')\4\ (30 percent for capital gain property, and
50 percent for non-capital gain property other than cash),
whereas contributions to most private foundations generally are
deductible up to 30 percent of the donor's AGI (20 percent for
capital gain property).\5\ For corporate taxpayers, the
deductible amount of charitable contributions generally is
limited to 10 percent of taxable income.\6\ For all taxpayers,
gifts of capital gain property to a public charity generally
are deductible at the property's fair market value,\7\ whereas
gifts of capital gain property (other than publicly traded
stock) to most private foundations are deductible at the
taxpayer's basis (cost) in the property.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Sec. 170(b) and (e).
\3\For contributions made in taxable years beginning after December
31, 2025, the 60-percent limit is reduced to 50 percent. Sec.
170(b)(1)(G)(i).
\4\The charitable percentage limits are applied to the donor's
``contribution base,'' which is the donor's AGI computed without regard
to any net operating loss carryback to the taxable year under section
172. Sec. 170(b)(1)(H).
\5\Sec. 170(b)(1).
\6\Sec. 170(b)(2).
\7\Sec. 170(e)(1). However, contributions of tangible personal
property not for an exempt purpose of the donee organization are
deductible at the taxpayer's basis in the property. Sec.
170(e)(1)(B)(i). A special rule determines the aggregate deduction for
contributions of certain intellectual property. Sec. 170(e)(1)(B)(iii)
and 170(m).
\8\Sec. 170(e)(1)(B)(ii) and 170(e)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Qualified scholarships and qualified tuition reduction
Present law provides an exclusion from gross income for
income tax purposes and from wages for employment tax purposes
for amounts received as a qualified scholarship by an
individual who is a candidate for a degree at an educational
organization described in section 170(b)(1)(A)(ii) (a
``qualifying educational organization'').\9\ In general, a
qualified scholarship is any amount received by such an
individual as a scholarship or fellowship grant if the amount
is used for qualified tuition and related expenses. Qualified
tuition and related expenses include tuition and fees required
for enrollment or attendance, or for fees, books, supplies, and
equipment required for courses of instruction, at the
qualifying educational organization. This definition does not
include regular living expenses, such as room and board. A
qualifying educational organization is an educational
organization that normally maintains a regular faculty and
curriculum and normally has a regularly enrolled body of pupils
or students in attendance at the place where its educational
activities are regularly carried on. These institutions include
K-12 schools.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Secs. 117(a) and 3121(a)(20).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Present law also provides an exclusion from gross income
for income tax purposes and from wages for employment tax
purposes for qualified tuition reductions for certain education
(below the graduate level) that is provided to employees (and
their spouses and dependents) of qualifying educational
organizations.\10\ The education must be provided at the
employing organization or another qualifying educational
organization. This exclusion does not apply to any amount
received by a student that represents payment for teaching,
research, or other services by the student required as a
condition for receiving the tuition reduction.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Secs. 117(d) and 3121(a)(20).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gift tax exclusion for educational expenses
Under present law, gift tax is imposed on transfers of
property by gift, subject to several exceptions. One exception
is the gift tax annual exclusion of section 2503(b). Under this
exclusion, a donor can transfer up to $18,000 of property to
each of an unlimited number of donees without incurring gift
tax on such transfers.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\The Code provides an amount of $10,000 for the maximum gift tax
annual exclusion, adjusted in $1,000 increments for inflation occurring
after 1997. The inflation-adjusted amount for 2024 is $18,000.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to the gift tax annual exclusion, the Code
provides that certain tuition payments are not considered
transfers of property by gift for gift tax purposes.\12\ This
exclusion covers amounts paid on behalf of an individual as
tuition to a qualifying educational organization. An unlimited
exclusion applies only to direct transfers to the educational
institution, not to reimbursements to donees for amounts paid
by them for otherwise qualifying services, or to trusts to
provide for the education of designated beneficiaries.\13\
Further, an unlimited exclusion is not permitted for books,
supplies, dormitory fees, board, or other similar expenses that
do not constitute direct tuition costs.\14\ This exclusion
applies without regard to the relationship of the donor and
donee.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Sec. 2503(e).
\13\Treas. Reg. sec. 25.2503-6(c), ex. 2.
\14\Treas. Reg. sec. 25.2503-6(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Committee believes that the COVID-19 pandemic caused
significant harm to student learning and educational
achievement. The Committee further believes that educational
choice is critical so that parents may choose the schools that
will provide their children with the best opportunities for
success. Therefore, the Committee provides a new credit for
contributions to scholarship granting organizations, which it
believes will promote greater educational freedom and
opportunities for qualified elementary and secondary students.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISION
Tax credit for contributions of individuals to scholarship granting
organizations
Individual income tax credit
The provision creates a nonrefundable income tax credit
that is equal to the aggregate amount of qualified
contributions made by the taxpayer during the taxable year. The
credit allowed to a taxpayer for a taxable year may not exceed
the greater of 10 percent of the taxpayer's aggregate gross
income or $5,000. An individual is allowed the credit only to
the extent that the Secretary of the Treasury (the
``Secretary''), subject to an aggregate volume cap that is
described below, allocates the credit to the individual.
For purposes of the credit, a ``qualified contribution'' is
a charitable contribution (within the meaning of section
170(c)) to a scholarship granting organization in the form of
cash or marketable securities. The amount allowed as a credit
to a taxpayer for a taxable year is reduced by the amount
allowed as a credit on any State tax return of the taxpayer for
qualified contributions made by the taxpayer during the taxable
year. The provision provides that any qualified contribution
for which a credit is allowed is not taken into account as a
charitable contribution for purposes of section 170.
A ``scholarship granting organization'' is any organization
(a) that is described in section 501(c)(3), is exempt from tax
under section 501(a), and is not a private foundation; (b)
substantially all of the activities of which are providing
scholarships for qualified elementary or secondary education
expenses of eligible students; (c) that prevents the co-
mingling of qualified contributions with other amounts by
maintaining one or more separate accounts exclusively for
qualified contributions; and (d) that either meets the
requirements to be a scholarship granting organization
(discussed below) or was eligible on the date of enactment to
receive contributions for which the donor is entitled to a
State tax credit if the contributions are used by the
organization to provide scholarships. An ``eligible student''
is an individual who is a member of a household with annual
income of no greater than 300 percent of the area median gross
income (within the meaning of that term in section 42) and is
eligible to enroll in a public elementary or secondary school.
An organization meets the requirements of a scholarship
granting organization (referred to above) only if (a) the
organization provides scholarships to two or more students at
two or more schools, (b) the organization does not provide
scholarships for expenses other than qualified elementary or
secondary education expenses, (c) the organization provides
scholarships to eligible students with a priority for students
awarded a scholarship the previous year and their siblings, (d)
the organization does not earmark or set aside contributions
for scholarships for any particular student, (e) the
organization takes appropriate steps to verify the income and
family size of eligible students to whom it awards
scholarships, and limits scholarships to individuals in
households with annual household income that meets the limits
set forth in the definition of an eligible student (the
``income verification requirement''), (f) the organization
obtains from an independent certified public accountant\15\
annual financial and compliance audits and certifies to the
Secretary that the audit has been completed, and (g) no officer
or board member of the organization has been convicted of a
felony.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\For purposes of this requirement, the term ``independent
certified public accountant'' means a certified public accountant who
is not a person described in section 465(b)(3)(A) (i.e., having an
interest, or being a related person to a person having an interest)
with respect to such organization or any employee of such organization.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The term ``qualified elementary or secondary education
expense'' means the following expenses in connection with
enrollment or attendance at, or for students enrolled at or
attending, an elementary or secondary public, private, or
religious school: tuition; curriculum and curricular materials;
books or other instructional materials; online educational
materials; tuition for certain tutoring or educational classes
outside of the home;\16\ fees for a nationally standardized
norm-referenced achievement test, an Advanced Placement
examination, or any examinations related to college or
university admission; fees for dual enrollment in an
institution of higher education; and educational therapies for
students with disabilities provided by a licensed or accredited
practitioner or provider. Such expenses include expenses in
connection with a homeschool (whether treated as a homeschool
or a private school for purposes of applicable State law).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Such tuition is a qualified expense only if the tutor or
instructor is not related to the student and is licensed as a teacher
in any State, has taught at an eligible educational institution, or is
a subject matter expert in the relevant subject.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A scholarship granting organization can satisfy the income
verification requirement, discussed above, by reviewing all of
the following documents (as applicable): (1) Federal and State
income tax returns or tax return transcripts with applicable
schedules for the taxable year prior to application, (2) income
reporting statements for tax purposes or wage and income
transcripts from the Internal Revenue Service, (3) notarized
income verification letter from employers, (4) unemployment or
workers compensation statements, and (5) budget letters
regarding public assistance payments and Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program (``SNAP'') payments including a list of
household members.
The credit is a nonrefundable personal tax credit taken
against income tax liability. The credit is allowable against
both the regular tax and the alternative minimum tax under
section 26(a). If the credit allowable for any taxable year
exceeds the limitation imposed by section 26(a) for such
taxable year reduced by the sum of nonrefundable personal tax
credits (other than the individual credit under the provision
and the credits allowable under section 23 and section 25D),
the excess is carried to the succeeding taxable year and added
to the credit allowable for such taxable year. However, no
credit may be carried forward to any taxable year following the
fifth taxable year after the taxable year in which the credit
arose. For this purpose, credits are treated as used on a
first-in, first-out basis.
The provision provides rules against self-dealing, such
that a scholarship granting organization may not award a
scholarship to a disqualified person. For this purpose, a
disqualified person is determined pursuant to rules similar to
rules in section 4946, and includes, for example, substantial
contributors, founders, and family members of substantial
contributors and founders.
Failure of scholarship granting organizations to make
distributions
If the Secretary determines that a scholarship granting
organization has not satisfied one or more of the
distributional requirements, described below, any contribution
made to the organization during the first taxable year
beginning after the date of the determination is not treated as
a qualified contribution for purposes of the tax credit for
individuals created under the provision.
Under the provision, the amount of receipts of the
scholarship granting organization for the taxable year which
are distributed before the distribution deadline with respect
to such receipts must be at least equal to the required
distribution amount for the taxable year. The ``required
distribution amount'' with respect to a taxable year is equal
to 100 percent of the total receipts of the scholarship
granting organization for the taxable year, (a) reduced by the
sum of the receipts that are retained for reasonable
administrative expenses for the taxable year or are carried to
the succeeding taxable year, and (b) increased by the amount of
carryover from the preceding taxable year. Administrative
expenses of a scholarship granting organization are deemed to
be reasonable if the expenses do not exceed 10 percent of the
organization's total receipts for the taxable year. At the
election of the scholarship granting organization, an amount of
up to 15 percent of the total receipts of the organization may
be carried to the succeeding taxable year.
Under the provision, a ``distribution'' includes amounts
which are formally committed but not distributed. A formal
commitment may include contributions set aside for eligible
students for more than one year. The distribution deadline with
respect to receipts for a taxable year is the first day of the
third taxable year following the taxable year in which the
scholarship granting organization receives the receipts.
Volume cap
The provision sets an aggregate volume cap on the total
amount of credits at $5 billion for each of calendar years 2025
through 2028, and zero for any calendar years after 2028. In
the case of a calendar year for which the volume cap is in
effect and which follows a high use calendar year, the volume
cap is increased to 105 percent of the dollar amount in effect
for the high use calendar year. The term ``high use calendar
year'' means any calendar year for which 90 percent or more of
the volume cap in effect for such calendar year is allocated to
taxpayers. The provision provides that the volume cap in effect
for a calendar year must at least equal the volume cap in
effect for the preceding calendar year. Thus, if the volume cap
is increased in a year following a high-use calendar year, it
is not subsequently reduced.
Generally, for purposes of allocating volume cap for a
calendar year, the Secretary is directed to allocate the credit
on a first-come, first-served basis, based on the time (during
that calendar year) at which the taxpayer made the qualified
contribution with respect to which the allocation is made. The
Secretary may not allocate volume cap for a calendar year after
December 31 of that calendar year. However, 10 percent of the
annual volume cap is evenly divided among the States,\17\ with
such amounts being available to individuals residing in such
States. The Secretary is directed to develop a system to track
the amount of qualified distributions made during the calendar
year for which a credit may be claimed, with such information
updated in real time.
----------------------------
Dissenting Views
Once again, we have before us an extreme proposal that
doubles down on Republican efforts to defund and to devalue our
public schools. This is really a companion piece of legislation
to their current federal government funding proposal. House
Republicans would cut the Department of Education and slash
Title I funding for teachers by almost $5 billion dollars. This
could mean 72,000 fewer public-school teachers to help our
children learn to have the skills to be successful. They say we
can't afford this, but they can afford to provide this strange
tax credit to encourage people to choose private over public
education.
And of course, this is just the first step, because under
Trump's Project 2025, their blueprint for what these
Republicans plan to do to America next year, they will
eliminate the Department of Education and they will eliminate
all Title I funding. This bill presented as a school choice is
really only about eroding support for our public schools. It
establishes what is a federalized voucher program that would
pull needed resources from public schools in many situations
just to reward and reimburse some well-connected parents for
their private school tuition. The opportunity this bill
actually advances has less funding, fewer teachers, more
crowded classrooms, and narrowed opportunities for the 90% of
our nation's children that rely on public schools.
Texas is a great example of a state that has starved public
schools for student funding--under Governor Greg Abbott has
fallen to more than $4,000 below the national average. We rank
44th among the states. Average teacher pay in Texas has dropped
to more than $7,000 below the national average. And Governor
Abbott has blocked school funding and much-needed teacher pay
raises because a few courageous Republican legislators joined
all Democrats to reject his voucher giveaway proposal. In
Austin, Texas, my hometown, the school board, like school
boards across Texas, has faced a budget crisis forced to make
substantial cuts and even to place on the ballot a property tax
increase to try to get by until reality provides a better
solution in a future legislature.
The one solution to the chronic underfunding of public
schools that has been offered has been this voucher program.
And, as I said in our public hearing, some of the strongest
words about the harm that programs like this bill would
accomplish come from Republicans--state Republican
representatives. Dr, Gary Vandeaver, a Republican from
Northeast Texas, says ``if I were to use three adjectives to
describe myself politically, I would say Conservative,
Christian, and Texan. In short, I oppose vouchers. As a fiscal
conservative, I cannot support creating a second parallel
education system.''
Drew Darby, from San Angelo, Texas, a Republican state
representative in another Trump district: ``it is objectionable
to take dollars out of public schools and support parochial
schools that don't have the same accountability, the same
testing, and the same transparency. Ken King, a Republican from
Canadian in the Texas Panhandle: ``it's horrible for rural
Texas--the only people it's going to help are the kids who
don't need the help. This is not going to help the kids in my
district who truly need help.''
The original version of this proposal co-sponsored by 153
Republicans cost $100 billion dollars if you can believe the
estimate--all unpaid for, not a dime paid for. All these fiscal
conservatives don't mind adding more and more to our national
debt. But, like other Republican tax schemes, this has been
disguised by providing a shorter term to be extended
permanently.
Finally, part of the disguise is the way this particular
Bill seeks to circumvent the First Amendment requirement of a
separation of church and state because it does not provide
direct vouchers because that would clearly be unconstitutional.
It attempts to do this with this unprecedented use of the form
of indirect voucher that is provided here it has the parent of
a religious school child donate to a charity. The charity
launders the donation and uses it to pay for the child's
tuition, all in an attempt to avoid the command of the First
Amendment of the United States, the Bill of Rights. It should
be rejected.
Lloyd Doggett.
[all]