Dissenting Views
The Committee on Foreign Affairs, having considered this
Report, reports favorably thereon and recommends that the
Report be approved.
The form of the Resolution that the Committee would
recommend to the House of Representatives citing Secretary of
State Antony J. Blinken for contempt of Congress pursuant to
this Report is as follows:
Resolved, That Antony J. Blinken, Secretary of State, shall
be found to be in contempt of Congress for failure to comply
with a congressional subpoena.
Resolved, That pursuant to sections 102 and 104 of the
Revised Statutes of the United States (2 U.S.C. 192 and 194),
the Speaker of the House of Representatives shall certify the
report of the Committee on Foreign Affairs, detailing the
refusal of Antony J. Blinken, Secretary of State, to give
testimony to the Committee on Foreign Affairs as directed by
subpoena, to the United States Attorney for the District of
Columbia, to the end that Secretary Blinken be proceeded
against in the manner and form provided by law.
Resolved, That the Speaker of the House shall otherwise
take all appropriate action to enforce the subpoena.
CONTENTS
Page
Executive Summary................................................ 2
Authority and Purpose............................................ 3
Background on the Investigation.................................. 5
A. The Committee Seeks Information Related to the
Investigative Purpose of the Committee's Inquiry into the
United States' Withdrawal from Afghanistan................. 5
a. The Committee's Request for Testimony Comes After
Thorough Investigation................................. 5
b. Secretary Blinken Must Speak on Behalf of the
Department Over Which He Holds Ultimate Responsibility. 6
c. Investigation Findings on the Afghanistan Withdrawal.. 7
d. State Department Obstruction of Congressional
Oversight of the Afghanistan Withdrawal................ 18
B. The Committee's Subpoena for Secretary Blinken's Testimony 21
C. Secretary Blinken's Testimony is Needed to Address the
Committee's Legislative Proposals.......................... 25
D. Secretary Blinken's Defiance of Subpoena Warrants Contempt
of Congress................................................ 26
Conclusion....................................................... 27
Hearings......................................................... 27
Committee Consideration and Votes................................ 27
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 28
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 28
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 28
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 28
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 28
Dissenting Views................................................. 30
Executive Summary
On September 24, 2024, U.S. Secretary of State Antony
Blinken failed to comply with a duly served subpoena issued by
the Committee on Foreign Affairs on September 18 for his
testimony before the Committee pertaining to the Chairman of
the Committee on Foreign Affairs' investigation into the 2021
withdrawal from Afghanistan and the subsequent noncombatant
evacuation operation (NEO). The Committee's September 18
subpoena superseded a September 3 subpoena served on Secretary
Blinken as an accommodation to the Secretary's travel schedule,
compelling his appearance on a date the Secretary stated he
would be in the United States. Despite repeated warnings and
accommodations, Secretary Blinken refused to appear to provide
his testimony before the Committee. Accordingly, Secretary
Blinken has violated federal law, and must be held in contempt
of Congress.
Secretary Blinken's testimony is a vital component of the
Committee's investigation into the 2021 Afghanistan withdrawal,
his department's shortcomings during that period, and Chairman
McCaul's proposed legislative remedies. On September 9, 2021,
Chairman McCaul published a report, ``Willful Blindness: An
Assessment of the Biden-Harris Administration's Withdrawal from
Afghanistan and the Chaos that Followed'' (the Report),
detailing the findings of the investigation. As the Report
outlines, the investigation found, among other facts, that (1)
Secretary Blinken actively participated in the interagency
review culminating in President Biden's Go-to-Zero order, (2)
Secretary Blinken directed his department to keep U.S. Embassy
Kabul open as the United States military retrograded, despite
the evident risks, (3) Secretary Blinken failed to ensure the
State Department planned for all contingencies, and (4)
Secretary Blinken failed to request a NEO until after Kabul
fell to the Taliban. As the principal decision-maker during the
Afghanistan withdrawal, Secretary Blinken is responsible for
the State Department's failure to effectively execute on its
responsibilities to advance American foreign policy and protect
American interests and citizens overseas.
The Committee seeks, through Secretary Blinken's testimony,
to advance the appropriate legislative proposals to remedy the
causes of the failures identified in the Committee's
investigation. The investigation's Report proposes legislative
remedies including but not limited to codification of NEO
authorities, the reestablishment of a crisis bureau in the
State Department and ensuring more rigorous oversight for
leadership in high threat State Department posts. The failures
that led to the 2021 withdrawal from Afghanistan placed
Americans at risk and continue to undermine American national
security and interests abroad. Secretary Blinken's testimony is
crucial to guaranteeing the appropriate remedies are instated
to rectify the failures that led to the 2021 Afghanistan
withdrawal and NEO.
Secretary Blinken has never appeared before the 118th
Congress with regard to the Committee's investigation into the
United States' withdrawal from Afghanistan. To date, he has
only appeared before this Committee for a public hearing
twice--both of which were for the State Department's annual
budget hearings on March 23, 2023 and May 22, 2024.\1\ The
objective of those hearings was to address the State
Department's fiscal year budget requests, not to discuss the
U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan or the Report, which had to
yet to be published.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\The State of American Diplomacy in 2024: Global Instability,
Budget Challenges, and Great Power Competition: Hearing Before the H.
Comm. on Foreign Affs., 118th Cong., (May 22, 2024); The State of
American Diplomacy in 2023: Growing Conflicts, Budget Challenges, and
Great Power Competition: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Foreign Affs.,
118th Cong., (March 23, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the 117th Congress, Secretary Blinken appeared one time
for a public hearing exclusively on Afghanistan in the
immediate aftermath of the deadly NEO.\2\ That appearance
predated the Committee's investigation, meaning this Committee
had yet to conduct any transcribed interviews or document
discovery. Further, Secretary Blinken's testimony in that
hearing contained misleading accounts and members did not have
the benefit of this Committee's investigative findings to seek
the truth.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Afghanistan 2001-2021: Evaluating the Withdrawal and U.S.
Policies Part 1: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Foreign Affs., 117th
Cong., (Sept. 13, 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Secretary Blinken's refusal to comply with the Committee's
subpoena--despite months of notice and offers of
accommodations--warrants contempt. Accordingly, Chairman McCaul
recommends that Congress find Antony Blinken in contempt of
Congress for his failure to comply with the Committee's duly
issued subpoena.
Authority and Purpose
Article I of the Constitution vests in Congress a ``broad''
and ``indispensable'' power to conduct oversight and
investigations that ``encompasses inquiries into the
administration of existing laws, studies of proposed laws, and
surveys in our social, economic or political system for the
purpose of enabling Congress to remedy them.''\3\ The scope of
that power of inquiry ``is as penetrating and far-reaching as
the potential power to enact and appropriate under the
Constitution.''\4\ Congress's oversight and legislative powers
have been repeatedly affirmed by the United States Supreme
Court.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178, 187, 215 (1957).
\4\Barenblatt v. United States, 360 U.S. 109, 111 (1959).
\5\See U.S. Const. art. I; McGrain v. Daugherty, 273 U.S. 135, 174
(1927) (holding that ``the power of inquiry--with process to enforce
it--is an essential and appropriate auxiliary to the legislative
function''); Eastland v. U.S. Servicemen's Fund, 421 U.S. 491, 504
(1975) (holding that ``the power to investigate is inherent in the
power to make laws''); Barenblatt v. United States, 360 U.S. 109, 111
(1959) (holding that ``the scope of power of inquiry . . . is as
penetrating and far-reaching as the potential power to enact and
appropriate under the Constitution'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further, federal law makes it a crime to willfully fail to
comply with a valid congressional subpoena for documents or
testimony, ``upon any matter under inquiry before either House
. . . or any committee of either House of Congress.''\6\
Additionally, Congress has statutorily required that, ``[t]he
Department of State shall keep . . . the Committee on Foreign
Affairs of the House of Representatives fully and currently
informed with respect to all activities and responsibilities
within the jurisdiction of these committees. Any Federal
department, agency, or independent establishment shall furnish
any information requested by . . . such committee relating to
any such activity or responsibility.''\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\2 U.S.C. Sec. 192.
\7\22 U.S.C. Sec. 2680.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Per the Rules of the House of Representatives, adopted
pursuant to the Rulemaking Clause of the Constitution, the
Committee on Foreign Affairs (Committee) is a standing
committee of the House of Representatives.\8\ House rule XI
grants the Committee the authority ``to require, by subpoena or
otherwise, the attendance and testimony of such witnesses and
the production of such books, records, correspondence,
memoranda, papers, and documents as it considers necessary''
for ``the purpose of carrying out any of its functions and
duties.''\9\ Pursuant to House rule X, the Committee is
empowered to exercise that authority to conduct oversight of
the Department of State and over, among other things,
``[r]elations of the United States with foreign nations
generally,'' ``[d]iplomatic service,'' and ``[p]rotection of
American citizens abroad and expatriation.''\10\ Further, House
rule XI allows the Committee to delegate the power to authorize
and issue subpoenas directly to the chairman of the committee,
which the Committee has done by adopting Committee Rule 22.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 5, cl. 2.
\9\Clerk of the H.R., 118th Cong., Rules of the H.R., Rule
XI(2)(m)(1) (2023). https://rules.house.gov/sites/
republicans.rules118.house.gov/files/documents/Rules%20and%20Resources/
118-House-Rules-Clerk.pdf.
\10\Id., Rule X(1)(i).
\11\Clerk of the H.R., 118th Cong., Rules of the H.R., Rule
XI(2)(m)(3)(A)(i); Rules of the Committee on Foreign Affairs for the
118th Congress, rule 22 (empowering the chairman of the Committee on
Foreign Affairs to authorize and issue subpoenas ``in the conduct of
any investigation or activity . . . within the jurisdiction of the
Committee.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken was responsible for
State Department equities throughout each phase of the United
States' withdrawal from Afghanistan, including the decision-
making process culminating in the ``Go to Zero'' order
officially announced by President Biden on April 14, 2021, the
United States military retrograde subsequent to that order, and
the noncombatant evacuation operation (NEO) ordered by
President Biden on August 16, 2021. In testimony before the
Committee, current and former State Department officials
confirmed that Secretary Blinken served as the final
decisionmaker for the State Department on all issues, including
issues related to the United States' withdrawal from
Afghanistan.
On September 9, 2024, House Committee on Foreign Affairs
Chairman Michael McCaul published his report, titled ``Willful
Blindness: An Assessment of the Biden Harris-Administration's
Withdrawal from Afghanistan and the Chaos that Followed'' (the
Report), presenting his findings and legislative
recommendations stemming from the Committee's three-year
investigation into the Biden-Harris Administration's withdrawal
from Afghanistan in 2021.\12\ As explained in that Report:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Michael T. McCaul, Willful Blindness: An Assessment of The
Biden-Harris Withdrawal from Afghanistan and the Chaos that Followed,
118th Cong. (Sept. 9, 2024).
On May 22, 2024, Chairman McCaul requested U.S.
Secretary of State Antony Blinken appear for a public
hearing in September on the committee's report. The
Chairman restated his request on August 12, 2024.
Secretary Blinken asserted his intention to not appear
on September 3rd, triggering the issuance of a subpoena
by the committee that day, mandating his appearance for
September 19th. Appropriate measures, including
congressional contempt, shall be pursued should
Secretary Blinken not appear.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Michael T. McCaul, Willful Blindness: An Assessment of The
Biden-Harris Withdrawal from Afghanistan and the Chaos that Followed,
118th Cong., at 11 (Sept. 9, 2024).
As laid out in the Report, a subpoena was duly authorized,
issued to, and served upon the Secretary of State on September
3, 2024, in connection with this Committee's investigation into
the United States' withdrawal from Afghanistan, pursuant to
authority vested in it under House rule X.
Secretary Blinken's testimony is necessary to address the
findings of the Report, as well as to address the legislative
proposals set forth therein. The State Department played a
critical role in executing all elements of the United States'
withdrawal from Afghanistan, making Secretary Blinken's
testimony essential. Indeed, over half of the 23 legislative
proposals in Chairman McCaul's report relate to changes in the
structure or operation of the State Department, including
recommendations for codifying responsibilities for planning and
executing a NEO, increasing oversight of high threat State
Department posts, and reforming the State Department's
reporting processes to Congress.\14\ Contempt is warranted as a
result of Secretary Blinken withholding testimony on these
subjects.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Id. at 237-45.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background on the Investigation
A. THE COMMITTEE SEEKS INFORMATION RELATED TO THE INVESTIGA-
TIVE PURPOSE OF THE COMMITTEE'S INQUIRY INTO THE UNITED
STATES' WITHDRAWAL FROM AFGHANISTAN
a. The Committee's Request for Testimony Comes After Thorough
Investigation
On January 12, 2023, the Committee launched an
investigation into the United States' withdrawal from
Afghanistan. Upon taking the majority, the Committee's
investigation included three components: (1) public hearings,
(2) transcribed interviews, and (3) document discovery. The
Committee held seven public hearings and roundtables, 18
transcribed interviews with current or former State Department,
Department of Defense, and White House officials, and reviewed
over 20,000 pages of documents. All State Department
witnesses--except for one foreign service officer--appeared
under threat of subpoena. Regarding document productions, as
explained in the Report:
Through compulsory process, the committee majority
obtained internal State Department memoranda, interview
notes from the State Department's After Action Review
(AAR), and a Dissent Channel Cable sent by U.S. Embassy
Kabul staff in July of 2021, all of which were
available for review by both majority and minority
Representatives and staff. In order to secure these
documents, the majority was forced to issue two
subpoenas to Secretary of State Antony Blinken,
threatening contempt on both occasions. Prior to the
issuance of these subpoenas, the State Department's
document productions consisted of duplicative
documents, over- redactions, over-classification, and
impertinent information.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Id. at 14.
To date, the Committee has served Secretary Blinken with
four subpoenas relating to this investigation, with the most
recent one being the subject of this contempt report. The
Committee has scheduled two contempt markups for Secretary
Blinken. A robust explanation of State Department obstruction
is included in Chairman McCaul's Report.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Id. at 195-198.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
b. Secretary Blinken Must Speak on Behalf of the Department Over
Which He Holds Ultimate Responsibility
The Secretary of State has a statutory responsibility to
administer, coordinate, and direct the State Department and the
Foreign Service.\17\ Secretary Blinken, for that reason, is
accountable for the policymaking and execution of State
Department actions, including those conducted by subordinate
Department officials.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\See 22 U.S.C. Sec. 2651a (explaining that the Secretary of
State exercises principal authority to administer, coordinate, and
direct the State Department and the Foreign Service); 22 U.S.C. 2656
(explaining that the Secretary of State serves as the President's
principal
Hearings
At 10:00 a.m. on September 24, 2024, the Committee convened
a hearing on ``An Assessment of the State Department's
Withdrawal from Afghanistan by America's Top Diplomat,'' at
which Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken had been directed to
appear and testify by a duly authorized and issued subpoena of
the Committee on Foreign Affairs. Secretary Blinken failed to
appear and provide testimony at that hearing.
Committee Consideration and Votes
On September 24, 2024, the Committee met pursuant to
notice, in open session, to consider the foregoing report on a
``Resolution recommending that the House of Representatives
find Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken in contempt of
Congress for refusal to comply with a subpoena duly issued by
the Committee on Foreign Affairs,'' a draft of which had been
provided beforehand to Members and posted publicly on the
Internet. The following amendments were considered by the
Committee:
Meeks amendment #1 (to insert content from a
minority staff memorandum on the Committee's
investigation in the 118th Congress into the U.S.
withdrawal from Afghanistan) failed by a record vote of
25 ayes and 26 noes:
Ayes (25): Meeks, Sherman,
Connolly, Keating, Bera, Castro, Titus, Lieu,
Wild, Phillips, Allred, Andy Kim (NJ), Jacobs,
Manning, Cherfilus-McCormick, Stanton, Dean,
Moskowitz, Jonathan Jackson (IL), Kamlager-
Dove, Costa, Crow, Amo, Mfume, Schneider.
Noes (26): McCaul, Smith,
Wilson, Perry, Issa, Wagner, Mast, Burchett,
Green, Ronny Jackson (TX), Young Kim (CA),
Huizenga, Radewagen, Hill, Davidson, Baird,
Waltz, Kean, Lawler, Mills, McCormick, Moran,
James, Self, Zinke, Moylan.
Meeks amendment #2 (to strike the assertion
that Secretary Blinken has violated federal law and
replace it with statements from letters by Secretary
Blinken and the Assistant Secretary of State for
Legislative Affairs) failed by a record vote of 25 ayes
and 26 noes:
Ayes (25): Meeks, Sherman,
Connolly, Keating, Bera, Castro, Titus, Lieu,
Wild, Phillips, Allred, Andy Kim (NJ), Jacobs,
Manning, Cherfilus-McCormick, Stanton, Dean,
Moskowitz, Jonathan Jackson (IL), Kamlager-
Dove, Costa, Crow, Amo, Mfume, Schneider.
Noes (26): McCaul, Smith,
Wilson, Perry, Issa, Wagner, Mast, Burchett,
Green, Ronny Jackson (TX), Young Kim (CA),
Huizenga, Radewagen, Hill, Davidson, Baird,
Waltz, Kean, Lawler, Mills, McCormick, Moran,
James, Self, Zinke, Moylan.
The report was ordered favorably reported to the House by a
vote of 26 ayes to 25 noes:
Ayes (26): McCaul, Smith, Wilson, Perry,
Issa, Wagner, Mast, Burchett, Green, Ronny Jackson
(TX), Young Kim (CA), Huizenga, Radewagen, Hill,
Davidson, Baird, Waltz, Kean, Lawler, Mills, McCormick,
Moran, James, Self, Zinke, Moylan.
Noes (25): Meeks, Sherman, Connolly,
Keating, Bera, Castro, Titus, Lieu, Wild, Phillips,
Allred, Andy Kim (NJ), Jacobs, Manning, Cherfilus-
McCormick, Stanton, Dean, Moskowitz, Jonathan Jackson
(IL), Kamlager-Dove, Costa, Crow, Amo, Mfume,
Schneider.
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the ``Authority and Purpose'' and ``Background
on the Investigation'' sections above.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
The Committee finds the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of
rule XIII and section 308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, and the requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII and
section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, to be
inapplicable to this report. Accordingly, the Committee did not
request or receive a cost estimate from the Congressional
Budget Office and makes no findings as to the budgetary impacts
of this Report or costs incurred to carry out the Report.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of this report establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
Although this report does not authorize any funding for
purposes of House rule XIII(3)(c)(4), the goal of this report
is to secure compliance with a duly issued congressional
subpoena.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, this report
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(e), 9(f), or 9(g) of House rule XXI.
Dissenting Views
Introduction
The Minority has long voiced concerns about the Majority's
efforts to politicize the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan,
including throughout the Committee's investigation into the
withdrawal during the 118th Congress.
The Majority's markup of the Committee report recommending
that the House of Representatives find Secretary of State
Antony Blinken in contempt of Congress for refusal to comply
with a subpoena to testify before the Committee on September
24, 2024 is the latest example of such politicization. This
effort to hold Secretary Blinken in contempt is unwarranted,
since Secretary Blinken clearly stated in writing that though
his professional responsibilities did not allow him to appear
on September 24th, he is willing to testify on another date.\1\
In fact, on September 24, Secretary Blinken was engaging in
high-level diplomacy alongside President Biden and world
leaders at the 2024 United Nations General Assembly in New York
City.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Letter from Secretary of State Antony Blinken to House Foreign
Affairs Committee Chairman Michael McCaul, September 22, 2024 (online
at https://democrats-foreignaffairs.house.gov/_cache/files/0/1/
011896ca-e984-4b51-a01d-220511847cbc/383BEF39C5BB7E184449DCC56DF96
A12.2024.09.22-state-to-mccaul-re-s-subpoena.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Majority first issued a subpoena for Secretary
Blinken's testimony on September 3, 2024 to appear on September
19, 2024. The Majority later issued a ``superseding'' subpoena
on September 18 to appear on September 24, as Secretary Blinken
was in Egypt on September 19 working to secure a ceasefire
agreement in the Middle East and the release of several
American hostages held by Hamas.
The United Nations General Assembly high-level week which
required Secretary Blinken to be in New York on September 24 is
an annual, highly publicized event that U.S. Secretaries of
State regularly attend, and this year's high-level week was
widely known to already be scheduled before September 18 when
the Majority revised their subpoena and date for Secretary
Blinken's testimony. Why did the Majority not work with the
Secretary to find a reasonable alternative date for him to
appear? What was the urgency to hear from him in September 2024
about a withdrawal that occurred more than three years prior?
Politics. There is no other reason, and there is no reason to
hold him in contempt since the Secretary has repeatedly made
clear he is willing to testify.
This Committee report recommending contempt comes after a
series of similarly partisan or politicized steps in the
Majority's handling of the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan.
The Majority released a report on the Committee's investigation
into the Afghanistan withdrawal on September 9, 2024, into
which the Minority had no input and had only received a copy
hours before it was publicly posted.\2\ This came on the heels
of former President Trump using an August 26 visit to Arlington
National Cemetery to honor 13 American service members killed
in an ISIS-K terrorist attack as a campaign event to call the
Biden-Harris Administration culpable, though the Majority knew
for months that the attack was not preventable and that, even
though a witness told our Committee he thought he had the ISIS-
K bomber in his sights, he did not.\3\ And it follows the
Chairman's subpoena to Secretary of State Blinken compelling
testimony Secretary Blinken has already provided to the
Committee, including as the first cabinet official to publicly
testify about the withdrawal in September 2021.\4\ The Majority
has also threatened to subpoena National Security Advisor
Sullivan after making unfounded accusations of misconduct
against him and, for months, has cherry-picked witness
testimony to exclude anything unhelpful to a predetermined,
partisan narrative about the Afghanistan withdrawal.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\``Chairman McCaul Releases Historic, Comprehensive Report on
Biden-Harris Administration's Afghanistan Withdrawal,'' Foreign Affairs
Committee Majority press release, September 9, 2024 (online at https://
foreignaffairs.house.gov/press-release/chairman-mccaul-releases-
historic-comprehensive-report-on-biden-harris-administrations-
afghanistan-withdrawal/).
\3\Trump Campaign Staff Had Altercation With Arlington National
Cemetery Official, NPR, August 27, 2024 (online at https://www.npr.org/
2024/08/27/nx-s1-5091154/trump-arlington-cemetery); Kabul Airport
Attack Review Affirms Initial Findings, Identifies Attacker, DOD News,
April 15, 2024 (online at https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/
Article/Article/3741245/kabul-airport-attack-review-reaffirms-initial-
findings-identifies-attacker/).
\4\Committee on Foreign Affairs, Testimony of Secretary of State
Antony J. Blinken, Hearing on Afghanistan 2001-2021: Evaluating the
Withdrawal and U.S. Policies (Sept. 13, 2021) (online at https://
www.congress.gov/117/chrg/CHRG-117hhrg45496/CHRG-117hhrg45496.pdf).
\5\``Chairman McCaul Sends Final Letter Requesting NSA Sullivan
Testify on Afghanistan Withdrawal or Face Subpoena,'' Foreign Affairs
Committee Majority press release, September 18, 2024 (online at https:/
/foreignaffairs.house.gov/press-release/chairman-mccaul-sends-final-
letter-requesting-nsa-sullivan-testify-on-afghanistan-withdrawal-or-
face-subpoena/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further underscoring their partisanship, the Majority has
taken particular pains to avoid facts involving former
President Trump that have been reinforced by multiple witnesses
in their investigation--including his committing the United
States to a full, date-specific withdrawal in a deal he
negotiated with the Taliban that excluded the Afghan
government. The deal, which former President Trump initiated,
also failed to include any reference to the rights of Afghan
women and girls. His subsequent unilateral directives to draw
down U.S. troops, often a surprise to many of his own senior
officials, undercut U.S. leverage because those announcements
were divorced from Taliban compliance with the deal. And his
deal forced the Afghan government to release 5,000 Taliban
fighters back to the battlefield before a final Taliban
offensive ultimately took Kabul. When former President Trump
took office, there were approximately 14,000 American troops in
Afghanistan. Days before leaving office, the former President
ordered a further reduction to 2,500. President Trump initiated
a withdrawal that was irreversible without sending
significantly more American troops to Afghanistan to face
renewed combat with the Taliban. All witnesses who testified on
this issue to the Committee agreed that the United States would
have faced renewed combat with the Taliban had we not continued
the withdrawal. Rather than send more Americans to fight a war
in Afghanistan, President Biden decided to end it.
The Majority's partisan attempts to garner headlines rather
than acknowledge the full facts and substance of their
investigation have only increased with the heat of an election
season, and after recent public criticisms about the
investigation from former Majority staff.\6\ With the
ascendance of Vice President Kamala Harris to the top of the
Democratic presidential ticket, the GOP performance has reached
a crescendo. The Majority now claims Vice President Harris was
a leading architect of the U.S. withdrawal though she is
referenced only three times in 3,288 pages of the Committee's
interview transcripts--transcripts that I pressed the Chairman
to publicly release in a November 14, 2023 Committee hearing
which are now buried deep in a difficult-to-find repository on
the Committee Majority's website.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\House GOP lets military off the hook for Afghanistan debacle,
Washington Examiner, August 26, 2024 (online at https://
www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/3133727/house-gop-lets-
military-off-the-hook-for-afghanistan-debacle/).
\7\``Investigative Work: Getting Answers on the Disastrous
Afghanistan Withdrawal,'' Foreign Affairs Committee Majority website
repository (online at https://foreignaffairs.house.gov/
investigative-work-getting-answers-on-the-disastrous-afghanistan-
withdrawal/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Majority seemingly has a fundamental objection to
President Biden fulfilling his pledge to be the last Commander-
in-Chief to preside over the war in Afghanistan. Republicans
are masking their displeasure with criticisms and so-called
``oversight,'' but have failed to offer feasible alternatives.
Similarly, their recommendation to hold Secretary Blinken in
contempt of Congress is a performative effort to distract from
the lack of new facts in their own investigation and tarnish
the name of yet another senior Biden Administration official in
an election season.
Background on the Committee's Investigation and Secretary
Blinken's Cooperation
In a January 12, 2023 letter to Secretary of State Antony
Blinken, House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Michael
McCaul signaled his intent to investigate what he described as
the Biden Administration's ``catastrophic withdrawal from
Afghanistan'' in the 118th Congress and issued a request for
extensive documents and information on the withdrawal, the bulk
of which was keyed to a timeframe beginning in January 2021.\8\
With respect to this, and all subsequent, requests from the
Chairman for documents or transcribed interviews in this
investigation, the Committee Majority did not consult with the
Minority before they were issued. On January 18, 2023, the
State Department confirmed in writing its intent to cooperate
with the Chairman's investigation and to begin an
accommodations process to produce responsive documents and
information to the Committee.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Letter from Chairman Michael McCaul, Committee on Foreign
Affairs, to Secretary Antony Blinken, U.S. Department of State (Jan.
12, 2023) (online at https://foreignaffairs.house.gov/wp-content/
uploads/2023/01/20230112190224869%5b28%5d.pdf).
\9\Letter from Assistant Secretary of State for Legislative Affairs
Naz Durakoglu to House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Michael
McCaul, January 18, 2023 (online at https://
democrats-foreignaffairs.house.gov/_cache/files/b/2/b2d83d7f-67ba-4c6e-
8e80-3252341c9e72/DE482FBD60E7D5F18967C9CA33428F1C.2023.01.18-state-to-
mccaul-re-afg.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At Secretary Blinken's direction, the Department has a
long, demonstrable record of ensuing cooperation with the
Committee's investigation, summarized below, that sharply
undercuts the Majority's assertions that he is contemptuous of
Congress' oversight.
DOCUMENT PRODUCTIONS COMPRISE THOUSANDS OF PAGES AND
EXTRAORDINARY ACCOMMODATIONS
The Department has made 59 separate document productions to
the Committee, totaling 19,778 pages of both unclassified and
classified content, on a rolling basis throughout the
investigation.
After Chairman McCaul threatened to hold Secretary Blinken
in contempt in May 2023, the Department made available to
Committee members, in camera, a July 2021 Afghanistan dissent
channel cable in what it characterized as an extraordinary
accommodation, given the internal and carefully regulated
nature of the Department's dissent channel to protect dissent
cable drafters.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\``McCaul Threatens to Hold Blinken in Contempt if State
Continues to Withhold Dissent Cable,'' Foreign Affairs Committee
Majority press release, May 8, 2023 (online at https://
foreignaffairs.house.gov/press-release/mccaul-threatens-to-hold-
blinken-in-contempt-if-state-continues-to-withhold-dissent-cable/);
Foreign Affairs Manual Volume 2 Section 070, Dissent Channel (2 FAM 070
Dissent Channel), U.S. Department of State (online at https://
fam.state.gov/FAM/02FAM/02FAM0070.html).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Chairman again threatened to hold Secretary Blinken in
contempt in February 2024 for withholding interview notes
underlying the State Department's internal Afghanistan After
Action Review (AAR).\11\ The AAR had already been transmitted
to Congress by Secretary Blinken on April 6, 2023 with an
unclassified version of the report publicly posted shortly
thereafter.\12\ The AAR itself--led by a highly-esteemed former
career Ambassador, Daniel B. Smith, who had also sat for a
transcribed interview with the Committee to answer extensive
questions about it in August 2023--cautioned on page 3 that out
of concern for ``the integrity of this process and in
anticipation of future after action reviews,'' the wishes of
the interviewees to remain anonymous or unnamed should ``be
fully respected.'' In another extraordinary accommodation,
Secretary Blinken directed the Department to produce the notes
with minimal redactions in March 2024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\``Chairman McCaul Threatens to Hold Blinken in Contempt if
State Continues Withholding Key Afghanistan Withdrawal Documents,''
Foreign Affairs Committee Majority press release, February 26, 2024
(online at https://foreignaffairs.house.gov/press-release/chairman-
mccaul-threatens-to-hold-blinken-in-contempt-if-state-continues-
withholding-key-afghanistan-withdrawal-documents/).
\12\``After Action Review on Afghanistan,'' press statement from
Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken, April 6, 2023 (online at https://
www.state.gov/after-action-review-on-afghanistan/); After Action Review
on Afghanistan January 2020--August 2021, U.S. Department of State
(online at https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/State-AAR-
AFG.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ALL REQUESTED INTERVIEWS WITH CURRENT OR FORMER
DEPARTMENT OFFICIALS WERE FACILITATED
In addition, the Chairman requested closed-door transcribed
interviews (TIs) with multiple current and former State
Department officials--these requests comprised both career
officials and Biden Administration political appointees, but
only one non-career political appointee from the Trump
Administration (Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad) who President
Biden retained in his role as Special Representative for
Afghanistan Reconciliation. The Department subsequently
facilitated transcribed interviews with all of these
individuals--15 in total. Ambassador Khalilzad also testified
on the same matter in a subsequent public hearing before the
Committee on February 15, 2024, without obstruction from the
State Department. Separately, one former State Department
officer (Samuel Aronson) agreed directly to be interviewed in
response to a direct request from the Majority. (Additionally,
one former U.S. military official, General Austin ``Scott''
Miller, and one former White House official, Jen Psaki, sat for
transcribed interviews requested by the Chairman without
obstruction from the current Administration.) Interviewees who
appeared voluntarily for TIs and the date of the interview are
below, with final transcripts for all Tis available online:\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\``Investigative Work: Getting Answers on the Disastrous
Afghanistan Withdrawal,'' Foreign Affairs Committee Majority website
repository (online at https://foreignaffairs.house.gov/
investigative-work-getting-answers-on-the-disastrous-afghanistan-
withdrawal/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-- Former Deputy to Ambassador John Bass in Kabul,
James (``Jim'') DeHart, June 16, 2023
-- Former Acting Chief of Staff to Ambassador Carol
Perez, Jonathan Mennuti, July 20, 2023
-- Former Consular Affairs Lead in Kabul, Jayne
Howell, July 28, 2023
-- Former Acting Deputy Assistant Secretary for
Afghanistan, Mark Evans, August 23, 2023
-- AAR Lead, Daniel (``Dan'') Smith, August 31, 2023
-- Former Consular Officer in Kabul, Samuel (``Sam'')
Aronson, September 15, 2023
-- Director of Policy Planning, Salman Ahmed, October
12, 2023
-- Former Charge d'Affaires to Afghanistan,
Ambassador Ross Wilson, October 24, 2023
-- Former Afghanistan Task Force Lead and Former
Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary in the Bureau of
South and Central Asian Affairs, Dean Thompson, October
27, 2023
-- Former Special Representative for Afghanistan
Reconciliation (SRAR), Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad,
November 8, 2023
-- Former Acting Under Secretary of State for
Management, Ambassador Carol Perez, November 15, 2023
-- Former Deputy Secretary for Management and
Resources, Brian McKeon, November 29, 2023
-- Former Spokesperson for the State Department,
Edward (``Ned'') Price, December 12, 2023
-- Chief of Staff to Secretary Blinken, Suzy George,
December 14, 2023
-- Former Counselor to the State Department, Derek
Chollet, December 19, 2023
-- Former U.S. Ambassador to Afghanistan, John Bass,
January 22, 2024
-- Former Commander of U.S. Forces and the NATO
Resolute Support Mission in Afghanistan, General Austin
``Scott'' Miller (retired), April 15, 2024
-- Former White House Press Secretary, Jen Psaki,
July 26, 2024
In these events, witnesses provided clear testimony that
was broadly consistent across interviews and with the
Department's document productions, narrative responses,
briefings, and AAR findings.
Concerns
THE MAJORITY MISREPRESENTS THE FACTUAL RECORD ON ITS OWN
INVESTIGATION INTO THE U.S. WITHDRAWAL FROM AFGHANISTAN
The consistent testimony from witnesses across the
Majority's investigation does not support assertions that the
Majority has repeatedly made about the U.S. withdrawal and
alleged leadership failures--specifically in the State
Department and the White House--that, in their telling, demand
accountability. The question of whether Secretary Blinken
deserves to be held in contempt of Congress for not yet
testifying pursuant to the Chairman's subpoena is separate from
those raised about the substance of the investigation itself.
But it bears noting here in brief what information the
investigation has actually yielded, since it undercuts the
Majority's dubious findings they are now relying on to claim
that Secretary Blinken's testimony is necessary, including on
proposed legislation to remedy purported problems that only the
Majority has identified.
Key Finding #1: The Trump Administration Set a Time-Bound, Full
Withdrawal into Motion Without Regard for Facts on the
Ground and Fa