Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 4587]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4587) to provide that the Administrator of the
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration shall not issue
an interim or final rule that includes an area closure in the
South Atlantic for species managed under the Snapper-Grouper
Fishery Management Plan until the South Atlantic Great Red
Snapper Count study is complete and the data related to that
study is integrated into the stock assessment, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Red Snapper Act of 2023''.
SEC. 2. CONDITIONS FOR RULES RELATED TO CERTAIN AREA CLOSURES.
(a) Findings.--Congress finds the following:
(1) Fishing is a major economic driver in the South Atlantic.
In Florida alone, recreational anglers provide $14,000,000,000
in economic output and support 119,000 jobs.
(2) Red snapper is a highly prized and sought after reef fish
by both recreational and commercial fishermen.
(3) The 6-day recreational red snapper season in 2018 added
$13,000,000 to the gross domestic product of the South Atlantic
region.
(4) For the last 10 years, fishery managers have successfully
been working to rebuild the red snapper stock in the South
Atlantic. There is currently record high abundance and strong
recruitment within the stock.
(5) This record abundance has led to increased out-of-season
encounters and discards which is driving red snapper mortality.
(6) Despite these increased discards, it is the overriding
opinion of the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council's
Snapper Grouper Advisory Panel that based on members'
collective on-the-water experience, the red snapper fishery is
recovered.
(7) However, options for future consideration to reduce out-
of-season encounters and red snapper mortalities include
shorter seasons and broad area closures for the snapper-grouper
fishery in the South Atlantic.
(8) The State of Florida is concerned with the economic
implications of area closures for the South Atlantic snapper-
grouper recreational fishery.
(9) $5,100,000 has been invested in independent survey data
over the last three fiscal years, including $3,300,000 for the
South Atlantic Great Red Snapper Count to estimate the number
of red snapper (Lutjanus campechanus) in the South Atlantic
waters from North Carolina to Florida.
(10) The National Marine Fisheries Service should incorporate
data from this survey into the National Marine Fisheries
Service stock assessments as expeditiously as possible to
better inform fishery management decisions.
(b) Condition on Issuance of Rule.--The Administrator of the National
Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration shall not issue an interim or
final rule that includes an area closure in the South Atlantic for
species managed under the Snapper-Grouper Fishery Management Plan
until--
(1) the South Atlantic Great Red Snapper Count study is
complete; and
(2) the data related to that study is integrated into the
upcoming South Atlantic red snapper research track and
operational stock assessment.
PURPOSE OF THE LEGISLATION
The purpose of H.R. 4587 is to provide that the
Administrator of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration shall not issue an interim or final rule that
includes an area closure in the South Atlantic for species
managed under the Snapper-Grouper Fishery Management Plan until
the South Atlantic Great Red Snapper Count study is complete
and the data related to that study is integrated into the stock
assessment.
Background and Need for Legislation
H.R. 4587 would prevent the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) from implementing area
closures in the South Atlantic until the South Atlantic Great
Red Snapper Count study is completed, and the findings are
integrated into the fishery's stock assessment.
The South Atlantic Red Snapper is managed by the South
Atlantic Fishery Management Council (Council). The Council was
created under the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and
Management Act of 1976 (MSA), which is the primary law
governing fisheries resources and fishing activities in federal
waters. The eight Councils implement the statutory goals of
MSA, in coordination with the National Marine Fisheries Service
(NMFS). This process is accomplished through Council-based
Fisheries Management Plans (FMPs) for each fishery. FMPs
require scientific stock assessments of the fishery. Following
a Council's development of an FMP, a Council forwards the plan
to NOAA for approval. If the plan is approved, NMFS must then
issue regulations to implement the plan.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\``About the MSA.'' U.S. Regional Fishery Management Councils,
http://www.fisherycouncils.org/about-the-msa.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The South Atlantic red snapper is a highly sought
commercial and recreational reef fish whose annual harvest
levels are dependent on fishery management decisions based on
stock assessments. Since 2010, the South Atlantic red snapper
has rebounded and both scientists and fishermen agree the stock
is at record abundance and biomass.\2\ However, success in
rebuilding the species population has not translated into
management that provides reasonable harvest opportunities. The
recreational fishery has largely been closed for the past 13
years except for a few weekend openings. In 2023, the season
was two days.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Testimony from Martha Guyas before the House Natural Resources
Committee, March 8, 2023. https://naturalresources.house.gov/
uploadedfiles/testimony_guyas.pdf.
\3\``NOAA Fisheries Announces Limited Openings of Recreational and
Commercial Red Snapper Seasons in South Atlantic Federal Waters'' May
23, 2023. https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/bulletin/noaa-fisheries-
announces-limited-openings-recreational-and-commercial-red-snapper-3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Successful rebuilding has not affected the status of the
Atlantic red snapper stock. The most recent stock assessment
was completed in 2021, known as SEDAR 73.\4\ The results of
SEDAR 73 indicated that South Atlantic red snapper are
overfished, and overfishing is occurring.\5\ Although red
snapper are abundant, the fishery is considered overfished
because most of the fish in the stock are young, and it is
believed that older fish are the key to a healthy population.
The assessment asserts that the overfishing is being primarily
driven by high numbers of dead discards by the recreational
sector.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\SEDAR 73 South Atlantic Red Snapper Stock Assessment Report,
https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/inport/item/65078.
\5\Draft Regulatory Amendment 35 to the Fishery Management Plan for
the Snapper Grouper Fishery of the South Atlantic Region, March 2023.
https://safmc.net/documents/sg_a3a_regam35draftamendment_mar2023-pdf/.
\6\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This has raised questions about the data utilized to make
fishery management determinations. As a result, Congress
appropriated $5.1 million over a three-year period to conduct a
``South Atlantic Great Red Snapper Count.''\7\ The South
Atlantic Red Snapper Count will provide independent data on
Atlantic red snapper to inform the next stock assessment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\``South Atlantic Red Snapper Research Spend Plan'', South
Atlantic Fishery Management Council, https://safmc.net/documents/noaa-
satl-red-snapper-count-june-2022/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite this ongoing work, NOAA has advocated for the
Council to consider seasonal and/or area-based bottom fishing
closures for all 55 species of snapper grouper as a way address
overfishing.\8\ H.R. 4587 would prevent NOAA from forcing any
area closures in the South Atlantic until the South Atlantic
Great Red Snapper Count study is completed, and the findings
are integrated into the fishery's stock assessment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Testimony from Martha Guyas before the House Natural Resources
Committee, March 8, 2023. https://naturalresources.house.gov/
uploadedfiles/testimony_guyas.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Action
H.R. 4587 was introduced on July 12, 2023, by Rep. John
Rutherford (R-FL). The bill was referred to the Committee on
Natural Resources, and within the Committee to the Subcommittee
on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries. On July 27, 2023, the
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries held a hearing on
the bill. On October 25-26, 2023 the Committee on Natural
Resources met to consider the bill. The Subcommittee on Water,
Wildlife and Fisheries was discharged from further
consideration of H.R. 4587 by unanimous consent. Chairman Bruce
Westerman (R-AR) offered an amendment in the nature of a
substitute designated Westerman_058 ANS. The amendment in the
nature of a substitute was adopted by voice vote.
Representative Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered an amendment to the
amendment in the nature of a substitute designated Huffman #1.
The amendment to the amendment in the nature of a substitute
was not adopted by a roll call vote of 18 yeas to 21 nays, as
follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 4587, as amended, was ordered favorably reported to
the House of Representatives by a roll call vote of 21 yeas to
18 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries
held on July 27, 2023.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title
This Act may be cited as the ``Red Snapper Act of 2023''.
Sec. 2. Conditions for rules related to certain area closures
Prevents NOAA from implementing area closures in the South
Atlantic until the South Atlantic Great Red Snapper Count study
is completed, and the findings are integrated into the
fishery's stock assessment.
COMMITTEE OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
COMPLIANCE WITH HOUSE RULE XIII AND CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET ACT
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) and (3) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and
sections 308(a) and 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, the Committee has received the following estimate for the
bill from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 4587 would prohibit the National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) from issuing an interim or
final rule that would close fishing areas in the South Atlantic
Ocean for any fish species managed under the Snapper-Grouper
Fishery Management Plan. That prohibition would remain in place
until the South Atlantic Great Red Snapper Count study is
completed and the data is integrated into the agency's stock
assessment of the fishery.
Background: In 2021, a stock assessment for the South
Atlantic red snapper was completed by a cooperative group of
coastal states, certain regional fishery management councils,
and NOAA, which determined that the species is currently
overfished. Under current law, when a species is determined to
be overfished the relevant fishery management council is
required to develop a management plan to mitigate overfishing
and rebuild the species' population, which can include closing
fishing areas. If NOAA closes fishing areas anyone who violates
that requirement is subject to civil penalties, which are
recorded in the budget as revenues.
According to NOAA, the South Atlantic Fishery Management
Council currently is not proposing that NOAA close any fishing
areas in the South Atlantic.
Federal costs: CBO cannot predict whether the fishing areas
for red snapper in the South Atlantic will be closed in the
coming years. Using information from NOAA, CBO expects that if
the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council recommends
closing those fishing areas the earliest NOAA could implement
rules to do so would be in 2025 and that an updated stock
assessment including data from the count study will be
completed in 2027.
Because H.R. 4587 would prevent NOAA from closing the
fishing area until a new stock assessment is completed, CBO
estimates that enacting the bill could reduce civil penalties
that may be collected if the fishing area is closed before the
end of 2027. Because of the uncertainty that such a closure
would occur and because of the few cases likely to be affected,
CBO estimates that any reduction in civil penalties would not
be significant over the 2024-2034 period.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Aurora Swanson.
The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss, Deputy
Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
2. General Performance Goals and Objectives. As required by
clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general performance goal or
objective of this bill is to provide that the Administrator of
the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration shall not
issue an interim or final rule that includes an area closure in
the South Atlantic for species managed under the Snapper-
Grouper Fishery Management Plan until the South Atlantic Great
Red Snapper Count study is complete and the data related to
that study is integrated into the stock assessment.
EARMARK STATEMENT
This bill does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined
under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives.
UNFUNDED MANDATES REFORM ACT STATEMENT
According to the Congressional Budget Office, H.R. 4587
contains no unfunded mandates as defined by the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act.
EXISTING PROGRAMS
Directed Rule Making. This bill does not contain any
directed rule makings.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This bill does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
PREEMPTION OF STATE, LOCAL OR TRIBAL LAW
Any preemptive effect of this bill over state, local, or
tribal law is intended to be consistent with the bill's
purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
U.S. Constitution.
CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW
As ordered reported by the Committee on Natural Resources,
H.R. 4587 would make no changes in existing law.
Dissenting Views
H.R. 4587 would prevent NOAA from closing areas to fishing
in the South Atlantic until the Great Red Snapper Count is
complete and the findings are integrated into the fishery's
stock assessment. This legislation would undermine a
precautionary approach to fishery management and hold science-
backed regulatory decisions hostage until some unknown,
undefined event in the future.
Red snapper is a reef fish found in bottom waters, rocky
areas, and reefs in the Gulf of Mexico and in the South
Atlantic, along the eastern coasts of North America, Central
America, and northern South America. South Atlantic red snapper
is highly sought-after in recreational and commercial fishing
and has been the subject of controversy in recent years as the
fishery recovers from overfishing and new stock assessments are
conducted. Dispute over the total number of South Atlantic red
snappers has led to the commissioning of the ``Great Red
Snapper Count,'' a collaborative effort between government and
private researchers to count red snappers in the South
Atlantic. The study began in March 2021, and results are
expected by 2025.
To cut down on dead discards, in 2022, the South Atlantic
Fishery Management Council proposed Regulatory Amendment 35 to
the Snapper Grouper Fishery Management Plan. The Amendment
included possible gear modifications, new fishing seasons, and
area closures. However, due to inaction by the council, in June
of 2024, the National Marine Fisheries Service implemented
interim measures reducing recreational and commercial catch
limits to reduce overfishing. NOAA testified at the legislative
hearing on this bill that no area or time closures are
currently under consideration, and therefore, this bill is
unnecessary.
This bill would prevent any area closures until the Great
Red Snapper Count is complete and integrated into the research
track and operational stock assessment. This process will take
years, so the bill could unnecessarily delay important
strategies for continuing to rebuild the stock based on
available science. Furthermore, this bill could invite lawsuits
over whether the Great Red Snapper Count is complete and
integrated.
The Great Red Snapper Count for the South Atlantic will
undoubtedly provide important data for fishery management;
however, this data is not yet available, and NOAA is required
to make fisheries management decisions based on the best
available science. Preventing NOAA and the South Atlantic
Fishery Management Council from making science-based decisions
based on available data is not an effective fishery management
strategy and undermines the progress the council and NMFS are
making to rebuild the stock and ensure a sustainable population
of red snapper for the future. Instead, efforts should be spent
on helping to reduce red snapper mortality from off-season
discards and other known threats to the population.
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member.
[all]