Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title
Designates the bill as the ``Critical Mineral Consistency
Act of 2024''.
Section 2. Critical materials included as critical minerals
Amends Section 7002 of the Energy Act of 2020, adding
critical materials designated by the Secretary of Energy to the
definition of critical minerals. This section also stipulates
that the Secretary of the Interior must update the CML no later
than 45 days after the Secretary of Energy deems a commodity as
a critical material.
Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
Compliance With House Rule XIII and
Congressional Budget Act
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) and (3) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and
sections 308(a) and 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, the Committee has received the following estimate for the
bill from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 8446 would require the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS)
to update its list of minerals essential to the United States'
economy or national security to include any materials that the
Department of Energy (DOE) has designated as critical for
energy technologies.
Currently, there are five materials designated as critical
by DOE that are not included in the USGS's list of critical
minerals. If those materials were added to the list, the agency
would be required to identify all known sources of each
material and annually report on each material's projected
supply and demand. Using information from the USGS about the
costs of its current assessments, CBO estimates that listing
and assessing the five additional materials would cost $1
million over the 2024-2029 period.
If DOE designates new materials after enactment, the USGS
would be required to include them on its list and in subsequent
annual reports. Using information about the timing of past
updates to DOE's list and the costs of the USGS's current
assessments, CBO estimates that listing and reporting on any
new DOE designations would cost $1 million over the 2024-2029
period.
In total, CBO estimates that implementing H.R. 8446 would
cost $2 million over the 2024-2029 period; any related spending
would be subject to the availability of appropriated funds.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Emma Uebelhor.
The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss, Deputy
Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
2. General Performance Goals and Objectives. As required by
clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general performance goal or
objective of this bill is to amend the Energy Act of 2020 to
include critical materials in the definition of critical
mineral, and for other purposes.
Earmark Statement
This bill does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined
under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Statement
According to the Congressional Budget Office, H.R. 8446
contains no unfunded mandates as defined by the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act.
Existing Programs
Directed Rule Making. This bill does not contain any
directed rule makings.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This bill does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Preemption of State, Local or Tribal Law
Any preemptive effect of this bill over state, local, or
tribal law is intended to be consistent with the bill's
purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
U.S. Constitution.
H.L.C.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
ENERGY ACT OF 2020
DIVISION Z--ENERGY ACT OF 2020
* * * * * * *
TITLE VII--CRITICAL MINERALS
* * * * * * *
SEC. 7002. MINERAL SECURITY.
(a) Definitions.--In this section:
(1) Byproduct.--The term ``byproduct'' means a
critical mineral--
(A) the recovery of which depends on the
production of a host mineral that is not
designated as a critical mineral; and
(B) that exists in sufficient quantities to
be recovered during processing or refining.
(2) Critical material.--The term ``critical
material'' means--
(A) any non-fuel mineral, element, substance,
or material that the Secretary of Energy
determines--
(i) has a high risk of a supply chain
disruption; and
(ii) serves an essential function in
1 or more energy technologies,
including technologies that produce,
transmit, store, and conserve energy;
or
(B) a critical mineral.
(3) Critical mineral.--
[(A) In general.--The term ``critical
mineral'' means any mineral, element,
substance, or material designated as critical
by the Secretary under subsection (c).]
(A) In general.--The term ``critical
mineral'' means--
(i) any mineral, element, substance,
or material designated as critical by
the Secretary under subsection (c); and
(ii) a critical material as
determined by the Secretary of Energy
under paragraph (2)(A).
(B) Exclusions.--The term ``critical
mineral'' does not include--
(i) fuel minerals;
(ii) water, ice, or snow;
(iii) common varieties of sand,
gravel, stone, pumice, cinders, and
clay.
(4) Indian tribe.--The term ``Indian Tribe'' has the
meaning given the term in section 4 of the Indian Self-
Determination and Education Assistance Act (25 U.S.C.
5304).
(5) Secretary.--The term ``Secretary'' means the
Secretary of the Interior.
(6) State.--The term ``State'' means--
(A) a State;
(B) the District of Columbia;
(C) the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico;
(D) Guam;
(E) American Samoa;
(F) the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana
Islands; and
(G) the United States Virgin Islands.
(7) Institution of higher education.--The term
``institution of higher education'' means--
(A) an institution of higher education (as
defined in section 101(a) of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001(a))); or
(B) a postsecondary vocational institution
(as defined in section 102(c) of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1002(c))).
(b) Policy.--
(1) In general.--Section 3 of the National Materials
and Minerals Policy, Research and Development Act of
1980 (30 U.S.C. 1602) is amended--
(A) by striking paragraph (3) and inserting
the following:
``(3) establish an analytical and forecasting
capability for identifying critical mineral demand,
supply, and other factors to allow informed actions to
be taken to avoid supply shortages, mitigate price
volatility, and prepare for demand growth and other
market shifts;'';
(B) in paragraph (6), by striking ``and''
after the semicolon at the end; and
(C) by striking paragraph (7) and inserting
the following:
``(7) facilitate the availability, development, and
environmentally responsible production of domestic
resources to meet national material or critical mineral
needs;
``(8) avoid duplication of effort, prevent
unnecessary paperwork, and minimize delays in the
administration of applicable laws (including
regulations) and the issuance of permits and
authorizations necessary to explore for, develop, and
produce critical minerals and to construct critical
mineral manufacturing facilities in accordance with
applicable environmental and land management laws;
``(9) strengthen--
``(A) educational and research capabilities
at not lower than the secondary school level;
and
``(B) workforce training for exploration and
development of critical minerals and critical
mineral manufacturing;
``(10) bolster international cooperation through
technology transfer, information sharing, and other
means;
``(11) promote the efficient production, use, and
recycling of critical minerals;
``(12) develop alternatives to critical minerals; and
``(13) establish contingencies for the production of,
or access to, critical minerals for which viable
sources do not exist within the United States.''.
(2) Conforming amendment.--Section 2(b) of the
National Materials and Minerals Policy, Research and
Development Act of 1980 (30 U.S.C. 1601(b)) is amended
by striking ``(b) As used in this Act, the term'' and
inserting the following:
``(b) Definitions.--In this Act:
``(1) Critical mineral.--The term `critical mineral'
means any mineral, element, substance, or material
designated as critical by the Secretary under section
7002(c) of the Energy Act of 2020.
``(2) Materials.--The term''.
(c) Critical Mineral Designations.--
(1) Draft methodology and list.--The Secretary,
acting through the Director of the United States
Geological Survey (referred to in this subsection as
the ``Secretary''), shall publish in the Federal
Register for public comment--
(A) a description of the draft methodology
used to identify a draft list of critical
minerals;
(B) a draft list of minerals, elements,
substances, and materials that qualify as
critical minerals; and
(C) a draft list of critical minerals
recovered as byproducts and their host
minerals.
(2) Availability of data.--If available data is
insufficient to provide a quantitative basis for the
methodology developed under this subsection,
qualitative evidence may be used to the extent
necessary.
(3) Final methodology and list.--After reviewing
public comments on the draft methodology and the draft
lists published under paragraph (1) and updating the
methodology and lists as appropriate, not later than 45
days after the date on which the public comment period
with respect to the draft methodology and draft lists
closes, the Secretary shall publish in the Federal
Register--
(A) a description of the final methodology
for determining which minerals, elements,
substances, and materials qualify as critical
minerals;
(B) the final list of critical minerals; and
(C) the final list of critical minerals
recovered as byproducts and their host
minerals.
(4) Designations.--
(A) In general.--For purposes of carrying out
this subsection, the Secretary shall maintain a
list of minerals, elements, substances, and
materials designated as critical, pursuant to
the final methodology published under paragraph
(3), that the Secretary determines--
(i) are essential to the economic or
national security of the United States;
(ii) the supply chain of which is
vulnerable to disruption (including
restrictions associated with foreign
political risk, abrupt demand growth,
military conflict, violent unrest,
anti-competitive or protectionist
behaviors, and other risks throughout
the supply chain); and
(iii) serve an essential function in
the manufacturing of a product
(including energy technology-, defense-
, currency-, agriculture-, consumer
electronics-, and health care-related
applications), the absence of which
would have significant consequences for
the economic or national security of
the United States.
(B) Inclusions.--Notwithstanding the criteria
under paragraph (3), the Secretary may
designate and include on the list any mineral,
element, substance, or material determined by
another Federal agency to be strategic and
critical to the defense or national security of
the United States.
(C) Required consultation.--The Secretary
shall consult with the Secretaries of Defense,
Commerce, Agriculture, and Energy and the
United States Trade Representative in
designating minerals, elements, substances, and
materials as critical under this paragraph.
(5) Subsequent review.--
(A) In general.--The Secretary, in
consultation with the Secretaries of Defense,
Commerce, Agriculture, and Energy and the
United States Trade Representative, shall
review the methodology and list under paragraph
(3) and the designations under paragraph (4) at
least every 3 years, or more frequently as the
Secretary considers to be appropriate.
(B) Revisions.--Subject to paragraph (4)(A),
the Secretary may--
(i) revise the methodology described
in this subsection;
(ii) determine that minerals,
elements, substances, and materials
previously determined to be critical
minerals are no longer critical
minerals; and
(iii) designate additional minerals,
elements, substances, or materials as
critical minerals.
(C) Inclusion of critical materials.--Not
later than 45 days after the date on which the
Secretary of Energy determines a non-fuel
mineral, element, substance, or material to be
a critical material under subsection (a)(2)(A),
the Secretary shall update the list of critical
minerals published under paragraph (3) to
include such critical material.
(6) Notice.--On finalization of the methodology and
the list under paragraph (3), or any revision to the
methodology or list under paragraph (5), the Secretary
shall submit to Congress written notice of the action.
(d) Resource Assessment.--
(1) In general.--Not later than 4 years after the
date of enactment of this Act, in consultation with
applicable State (including geological surveys), local,
academic, industry, and other entities, the Secretary
(acting through the Director of the United States
Geological Survey) or a designee of the Secretary,
shall complete a comprehensive national assessment of
each critical mineral that--
(A) identifies and quantifies known critical
mineral resources, using all available public
and private information and datasets, including
exploration histories; and
(B) provides a quantitative and qualitative
assessment of undiscovered critical mineral
resources throughout the United States,
including probability estimates of tonnage and
grade, using all available public and private
information and datasets, including exploration
histories.
(2) Supplementary information.--In carrying out this
subsection, the Secretary may carry out surveys and
field work (including drilling, remote sensing,
geophysical surveys, topographical and geological
mapping, and geochemical sampling and analysis) to
supplement existing information and datasets available
for determining the existence of critical minerals in
the United States.
(3) Public access.--Subject to applicable law, to the
maximum extent practicable, the Secretary shall make
all data and metadata collected from the comprehensive
national assessment carried out under paragraph (1)
publically and electronically accessible.
(4)
Dissenting Views
H.R. 8446 would amend the definition of ``critical
mineral'' in the Energy Act of 2020 to include critical
materials from the Department of Energy (DOE) critical
materials list. Critical minerals are currently designated by
the United States Geological Survey (USGS) in accordance with
the mandates of the Energy Act, using peer-reviewed scientific
methodology.
Sections 7002(a) and (c) of the Energy Act of 2020 define a
``critical mineral'' as a non-fuel mineral or mineral material
essential to the economic or national security of the U.S. and
which has a supply chain vulnerable to disruption. Critical
minerals are also characterized as serving an essential
function in the manufacturing of a product, the absence of
which would have significant consequences for the economy or
national security.
USGS maintains the federal critical minerals list; the 2022
list names 50 minerals that are critical to the U.S. economy
and national security and are vulnerable to supply chain
disruptions. This is a dynamic list, which will be updated at
least every three years to reflect mineral supply, demand,
production, and evolving mineral supply chain risks. The Energy
Act of 2020 created the framework for updating the critical
minerals list, requiring the Department of the Interior (DOI)
to use the best available science and incorporate interagency
and public feedback into the critical mineral designations.
In addition to the USGS critical minerals list, both DOE
and the Department of Defense, Defense Logistics Agency (DLA)
have their own lists of ``critical materials'' and ``strategic
materials,'' respectively. These lists are specific to these
agencies' activities and mandates; they draw on the USGS list
but include sector-specific analysis and modeling. The DOE list
is specific to energy needs, and the DLA list is specific to
the needs of defense and includes authorities to stockpile
certain materials.
The Biden administration and the 117th Congress made
significant investments in domestic research on and production
of critical minerals and materials, including tax and
permitting incentives under the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA),
the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA), the CHIPS
and Science Act, and executive actions invoking the Defense
Production Act. Some of these are available exclusively to
minerals on the USGS list, but other investments or incentives
target strategic or critical materials (materials on the DOD or
DOE lists) or a subset of any of these lists. Benefits
exclusive to the USGS critical minerals list include expedited
permitting under Title 41 of the Fixing Americas Surface
Transportation Act (FAST-41) and certain grants from IIJA and
the CHIPS and Science Act.
Due to the incentives targeting critical minerals, the USGS
critical minerals list and methodologies have come under
significant scrutiny since the publication of the 2022 list. In
particular, many have criticized the critical minerals
assessment for not including demand projections, relying on
past data, and not incorporating modeled future risks.
Unlike USGS's list, the DOE critical materials list is
forward-looking and bases criticality determinations on
projections of risk and demand in the near (2020-2025) and
medium (2025-2030) term.\1\ Critics of USGS's critical minerals
list methodology have pointed to DOE's more forward-looking
list as more useful for informing supply chain planning.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Rowan, Linda R. April 8, 2024. ``Critical Mineral Resources:
National Policy and Critical Minerals List.'' Congressional Research
Service. https://www.crs.gov/Reports/R47982.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In accordance with the Energy Act of 2020, USGS is working
on the 2025 critical minerals list. As USGS testified at the
legislative hearing on H.R. 8446, the agency is updating its
methodology for the 2025 list to ``incorporate a data-driven
modeling approach to evaluate potential risks to mineral supply
chains.''
Congress should support this inclusive, science-based
approach rather than adding minerals to the list through
legislative action. Given the significant investments and
incentives available to critical minerals, mining interests
have made concentrated lobbying efforts to legislatively add
specific minerals to the USGS critical minerals list. The major
discrepancy between the DOE critical materials list and the
USGS critical minerals list is copper, which is currently
considered a critical material by DOE but not a critical
mineral by USGS. Given industry lobbying for copper to be
considered critical and previous legislative pushes to add
copper to the USGS critical minerals list, H.R. 8446 can be
understood as an attempt to make copper eligible for federal
support for critical minerals.
While copper plays an important role in the economy and
national security, its supply chain is not currently considered
at risk. The U.S. is a significant producer of copper; the USGS
estimates that the U.S. mined 1.3 million tons of copper in
2022 from 25 operating copper mines. There are currently
multiple additional copper mines in the permitting process,
which will likely begin production in several years. The U.S.
also has ``multiple domestic options for downstream smelting
and refining to copper metal.''\2\ Importantly, copper is
highly recyclable, and the U.S. supplied about a third of the
copper used domestically through recycling in 2022.\3\ More
recycling could go even further toward mitigating supply chain
risks while reducing environmental impact.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\David Applegate, Director of USGS. Letter to Senators Sinema,
Kelly, Manchin, Braun, Warnock, and Romney re: designating copper as a
critical mineral. April 13, 2023. https://
subscriber.politicopro.com/eenews/f/eenews/?id=00000188-4953-d998-ab8f-
fb5f223b0000.
\3\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the economy is considered vulnerable to a supply
disruption for copper, this vulnerability is ``mitigated by a
relatively low U.S. net import reliance on foreign supplies and
a diversity of foreign supply sources.''\4\ Although net import
reliance increased from 2018 to 2021, the latest data--
published in 2023--show that import reliance decreased from
2021 to 2022; imports decreased even as domestic copper
consumption increased.\5\ Furthermore, ``American imports of
refined copper come predominantly from Chile, Canada, and
Mexico, reliable trade partners with whom the U.S. has free
trade agreements.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Ibid.
\5\Ibid.
\6\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Copper's inclusion on DOE's critical materials list is
controversial because DOE's own analyses do not show copper to
be critical in the near term or medium term, although it is
considered near critical in the medium term.
The critical minerals list is designed to focus attention
and resources on the most essential and at-risk mineral supply
chains. In adding critical materials to the definition of
critical minerals in the Energy Act of 2020, copper would
become eligible for production support, research grants, and
expedited permitting--potentially siphoning resources from much
more at-risk and fragile mineral supply chains to the well-
developed copper industry.
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member.
[all]