Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4551]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4551) to prohibit the Securities and Exchange
Commission from requiring that personally identifiable
information be collected under consolidated audit trail
reporting requirements, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Related Hearing.................................................. 3
Committee Consideration.......................................... 3
Committee Votes.................................................. 3
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 5
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 5
Congressional Budget Office Estimates............................ 5
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 6
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 6
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 6
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 6
Earmark Identification........................................... 6
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 6
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 7
Minority Views................................................... 8
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Protecting Investors' Personally
Identifiable Information Act''.
SEC. 2. PERSONALLY IDENTIFIABLE INFORMATION EXCLUDED FROM CONSOLIDATED
AUDIT TRAIL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS.
(a) In General.--The Securities and Exchange Commission may not
require a national securities exchange, a national securities
association, or a member of such an exchange or association to provide
personally identifiable information with respect to a market
participant to meet the requirements relating to an order or a
reportable event under section 242.613(c)(7) of title 17, Code of
Federal Regulations (or successor regulations).
(b) Definition of Personally Identifiable Information.--In this
section, the term ``personally identifiable information''--
(1) means information that can be used to distinguish or
trace an individual's identity, either alone or when combined
with other personal or identifying information that is linked
or linkable to a specific individual, including an individual's
name, address, date or year of birth, Social Security number,
telephone number, email, and IP-address; and
(2) does not include a CAT-Order-ID or CAT-Reporter-ID, as
such terms are defined in section 242.613(j) of title 17, Code
of Federal Regulations (or successor regulations).
Purpose and Summary
Introduced on July 11, 2023, by Representative Barry
Loudermilk, H.R. 4551, the Protecting Investors' Personally
Identifiable Information Act, would prohibit the SEC from
collecting personally identifiable information (PII) through
the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT).
Background and Need for Legislation
Established in 2012 as a result of the 2010 ``Flash Crash''
and from SEC Rule 613, the CAT system's goal is to monitor
National Market System (``NMS'') securities across U.S.
markets. It is intended to gather comprehensive data covering
the entire trade lifecycle from initial order receipt to order
execution. The CAT is governed by the CAT Operating Committee,
which is comprised of representatives of the various self-
regulatory organizations (``SROs'') that own CAT NMS, LLC. The
Operating Committee is responsible for overseeing CAT's
operations and modifications to reporting, with recent
expansion to the scope of reportable data and events.
This extensive database, with troves of personal data, is
accessible to thousands of employees at the SEC and the SROs,
enabling real-time monitoring of investors' activities. There
are significant concerns about the CAT's constitutionality, as
well as its effects on privacy and civil liberties, which are
the subject of litigation.\1\ For example, there is a concern
that CAT will be used as a sweeping surveillance database as it
gathers and stores extensive trade and quote data from every
broker account. The database's sheer scale presents an ongoing
risk of unauthorized access or misuse.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\See, e.g., American Securities Association and Citadel
Securities LLC v. United States Securities and Exchange Commission, No.
23-13396.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Regardless of constitutional challenges, H.R. 4551 is
necessary to prevent the SEC from needlessly collecting PII.
This legislation takes an important step to preserve investor
privacy and protect against government surveillance.
RELATED HEARING
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearing was used to develop H.R. 4551: The Subcommittee on
Capital Markets held a hearing on March 20, 2024, titled ``SEC
Overreach: Examining the Need for Reform.''
Committee Consideration
The Committee on Financial Services met in open session on
May 16, 2014, and ordered H.R. 4551 as amended to be reported
favorably to the House by a recorded vote of 27 ayes to 22 nays
(Record vote no. FC-151), a quorum being present. Before the
question was called to order the bill favorably reported, the
Committee adopted an amendment in the nature of a substitute
offered by Mr. Loudermilk by voice vote.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee to list the record votes
on the order to report legislation and amendments thereto. H.R.
4551 as amended was ordered reported favorably to the House by
a recorded vote of 27 ayes to 22 nays (Record vote no. FC-151),
a quorum being present.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
COMMITTEE OVERSIGHT FINDINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee, based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.R. 4551 is to prevent
the Securities and Exchange Commission (or ``SEC'') from
requiring a national securities exchange, association, or a
member of either to provide a market participant's personally
identifiable information to satisfy the reporting requirements
of the CAT.
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE ESTIMATES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following is the cost estimate
provided by the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 4551 would prohibit the Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC) from requiring that a national securities
exchange, a national securities association, or a member of
such an exchange or association provide personally identifiable
information to meet the reporting requirements for tracking
orders in U.S. markets.
Based on the cost of similar provisions, CBO estimates it
would cost the SEC less than $500,000 over the 2024-2029 period
to update their requirements. However, because the SEC is
authorized to collect fees each year to offset its annual
appropriation, CBO expects the net effect on discretionary
spending over the 2024-2029 period would be negligible,
assuming appropriation actions consistent with that authority.
If the SEC increases annual fees to offset the costs of
implementing the bill, H.R. 4551 would increase the cost of an
existing private-sector mandate on entities required to pay
those fees. CBO estimates that the incremental cost of the
mandate would be small and fall well below the annual threshold
established in the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA) for
private-sector mandates ($200 million in 2024, adjusted
annually for inflation).
The bill contains no intergovernmental mandates as defined
in UMRA.
The CBO staff contacts for this estimate are Margot Berman
(for the Securities and Exchange Commission) and Rachel Austin
(for mandates). The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel
Papenfuss, Deputy Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY, ENTITLEMENT AUTHORITY,
AND TAX EXPENDITURES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee adopts as its own the
estimate of new budget authority, entitlement authority, or tax
expenditures or revenues contained in the cost estimate
prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget Office
pursuant to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1973.
FEDERAL MANDATES STATEMENT
Pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act, the Committee adopts as its own the estimate of the
Federal mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional
Budget Office.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE STATEMENT
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
EARMARK IDENTIFICATION
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE LEGISLATION
Section 1: Short title
This section cites H.R. 4551 as the ``Protecting Investors'
Personally Identifiable Information Act''.
Section 2: Personally identifiable information excluded from
Consolidated Audit Trail reporting requirements
This section defines ``personally identifiable
information'' to include information that can be used to
distinguish or trace an individual's identity. It also prevents
the SEC from requiring a national securities exchange,
association, or a member of either to provide a market
participant's personally identifiable information to satisfy
the reporting requirements of the CAT.
Minority Views
H.R. 4551 allows securities exchanges and members of
exchanges (like broker-dealers, which purchase securities on
behalf of clients or for their own accounts) to no longer
provide personally-identifiable data (``PII'') when it comes to
complying with the Consolidated Audit Trail (``CAT''). The CAT
was established by the SEC to track securities orders
throughout their lifecycle, identify the broker-dealers
handling them, and allow regulators to efficiently track
activity in securities throughout the U.S. markets. This bill,
however, would severely curtail the ability of the SEC to
monitor our markets for illicit activity, harming investors.
The CAT was borne partially out of the 2010 ``Flash Crash''
when markets plunged almost 10% and then recovered inside the
space of an hour, due primarily to aggressive selling orders
executed by high-frequency trading algorithms that triggered a
massive decline in market prices.\1\ Although the market
indices managed to partially rebound in the same day, the flash
crash erased almost $1 trillion in market value.\2\ Nearly five
years later, in 2015, a London-based trader was arrested
following allegations of market manipulation that resulted in
the Flash Crash.\3\ In the aftermath of this crash, the
Commission adopted Rule 613 to create the CAT so that
regulators would have a means to efficiently and accurately
track activity throughout U.S. securities markets, and to
ensure that regulators would be able to quickly access data
they need to analyze market activity in response to major
market events.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Corporate Finance Institute, 2010 Flash Crash (accessed May 14,
2024).
\2\Id.
\3\Corporate Finance Institute, 2010 Flash Crash (accessed May 14,
2024).
\4\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The CAT helps SEC staff to better understand the variables
that lead to market volatility and investor harm, and the use
of personally identifiable information (``PII'') helps it to
more quickly ascertain any wrongdoing that may have
contributed. PII also helps the agency to identify bad actors
that the agency can then levy civil and administrative actions
against, which in turn can reimburse investors for their
losses. By restricting the CAT's use of PII, this bill reduces
the overall effectiveness of the CAT and therefore the agency's
ability to protect investors from future harm and more quickly
address market volatility and individual malfeasance.
Additionally, this bill would destroy the utility of the
CAT, affirmatively making US markets less policed than they
were decades ago. It is difficult to identify misconduct unless
you know who is doing the trading, and who to investigate. The
CAT is the primary (and, at times, only) mechanism for
investigating market manipulation and other trading activities.
At its root, manipulative activity is often unidentifiable and
might otherwise appear to be noise if customer information is
not available. For example, one trader may enter 50 orders in
50 different ways to appear as though there is market demand,
when there is no such demand. This type of ``spoofing'' and
market manipulation has led to catastrophic market events
(including the 2010 Flash Crash by the aforementioned trader)
as well as many investor abuses and losses. CAT can identify
and help regulators stop that, but if this bill passed,
regulators would be unable to engage in even basic policing of
the markets in ways that have been done for decades.
Finally, this bill is attempting to assert an artificial
and new ``right to privacy'' for trading in public markets,
where none has ever existed, with no exception for abusive or
illegal trading. Regulators don't currently have access to PII
information directly today, but rather a masked identifier. The
actual human PII is only available upon further investigation.
Additionally, broker dealers have access to this PII as well,
but this bill does not address those concerns. It is important
to note that the CAT has steps to ensure PII is not improperly
accessed, but, as discussed above, this bill isn't really about
PII.
This bill is opposed by the investor advocate organization,
Americans for Financial Reform.
For these reasons, we oppose H.R. 4551.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters,
Ranking Member.
Nydia M. Velazquez,
Stephen F. Lynch,
Emanuel Cleaver II,
Brad Sherman,
Al Green,
Ranking Member, Subcommittee
on Oversight and
Investigations.
Bill Foster,
Joyce Beatty,
Ayanna Pressley,
Sylvia R. Garcia,
Juan Vargas,
Rashida Tlaib,
Nikema Williams,
Members of Congress.
[all]