Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 6951]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and the Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 6951) to lower the cost of
postsecondary education for students and families, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``College Cost
Reduction Act''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. References.
TITLE I--TRANSPARENCY
Part A--DEFINITIONS
Sec. 101. Definitions.
Part B--COLLEGE COSTS AND FINANCIAL VALUE
Sec. 111. Financial aid offers.
Sec. 112. College scorecard website.
Sec. 113. Postsecondary student data system.
Sec. 114. Database of student information prohibited.
TITLE II--ACCESS AND AFFORDABILITY
Part A--FINANCIAL NEED
Sec. 201. Amount of need; cost of attendance; median cost of college.
Part B--FINANCIAL AID
subpart 1--grants
Sec. 211. Federal Pell Grant program.
Sec. 212. Campus-based aid programs.
subpart 2--loans
Sec. 221. Loan limits.
Sec. 222. Loan repayment.
Sec. 223. Loan rehabilitation.
Sec. 224. Interest capitalization.
Sec. 225. Origination fees.
TITLE III--ACCOUNTABILITY AND STUDENT SUCCESS
Part A--ACCOUNTABILITY
subpart 1--department of education
Sec. 301. Agreements with institutions.
Sec. 302. Regulatory relief.
Sec. 303. Limitation on authority of Secretary to propose or issue
regulations and Executive actions.
Sec. 304. Office of Federal Student Aid.
subpart 2--accreditors
Sec. 311. Accrediting agency recognition.
Sec. 312. National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and
Integrity (NACIQI).
Sec. 313. Alternative quality assurance experimental site initiative.
Part B--STUDENT SUCCESS
Sec. 321. Postsecondary student success grants.
Sec. 322. Reverse Transfer Efficiency Act.
Sec. 323. Transparent and fair transfer of credit policies.
SEC. 2. REFERENCES.
(a) Higher Education Act of 1965.--Except as otherwise expressly
provided, whenever in this Act an amendment or repeal is expressed in
terms of an amendment to, or repeal of, a section or other provision,
the reference shall be considered to be made to a section or other
provision of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001 et seq.).
(b) FAFSA Simplification Act.--Except as otherwise expressly
provided, whenever in this Act a reference to a section or other
provision of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001 et seq.)
refers to such section or other provision as amended or added by the
FAFSA Simplification Act, the reference shall be considered to be made
to the section or other provision as amended or added by--
(1) title VII of division FF of the Consolidated
Appropriations Act, 2021 (title VII of division FF of Public
Law 116-260), subject to the effective date of section 701(b)
of such Act, as amended by section 102(a) of the FAFSA
Simplification Act Technical Corrections Act (division R of
Public Law 117-103) (including the authorization provided under
section 102(c)(1)(A) of such Act); and
(2) the FAFSA Simplification Act Technical Corrections Act
(division R of Public Law 117-103).
TITLE I--TRANSPARENCY
PART A--DEFINITIONS
SEC. 101. DEFINITIONS.
(a) Definitions.--Section 103 of the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20
U.S.C. 1003) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(25) Cip code.--The term `CIP code' means the six-digit
taxonomic identification code assigned by an institution of
higher education to a specific program of study at the
institution, determined by the institution in accordance with
the Classification of Instructional Programs published by the
National Center for Education Statistics.
``(26) Credential level.--
``(A) In general.--The term `credential level' means
the level of the degree or other credential awarded by
an institution of higher education to students who
complete a program of study of the institution. Each
degree or other credential awarded by an institution
shall be categorized by the institution as either
undergraduate credential level or graduate credential
level.
``(B) Undergraduate credential.--When used with
respect to a credential or credential level, the term
`undergraduate credential' includes credentials such as
an undergraduate certificate, an associate degree, a
bachelor's degree, and a post-baccalaureate
certificate.
``(C) Graduate credential.--When used with respect to
a credential or credential level, the term `graduate
credential' includes credentials such as a master's
degree, a doctoral degree, a professional degree, and a
postgraduate certificate.
``(27) Program of study.--The term `program of study' means
an academic program of study offered to students by an
institution of higher education that--
``(A) upon completion of the program, results in the
award of a credential to a student, including a degree,
diploma, or certificate, for one credential level;
``(B) is certified as a program of study in the
institution's program participation agreement under
section 487; and
``(C) is classified by a combination of--
``(i) a CIP code; and
``(ii) one credential level, determined by
the credential awarded upon completion of the
program.
``(28) Program length.--The term `program length' means the
minimum amount of time in weeks, months, or years that is
specified in the catalog, marketing materials, or other
official publications of an institution of higher education for
a full-time student to complete the requirements for a specific
program of study and to obtain the degree or credential awarded
by such program.
``(29) Time to credential.--The term `time to credential'
means, with respect to a student, the actual amount of time in
weeks, months, or years it takes the student to complete the
requirements for a specific program of study and to obtain the
degree or credential awarded by such program.
``(30) Value-added earnings.--
``(A) Calculation.--With respect to a student who
received Federal financial aid under title IV and who
completed a program of study offered by an institution
of higher education, the term `value-added earnings'
means--
``(i) the annual earnings of such student
measured during the applicable earnings
measurement period for such program (as
determined under subparagraph (C)); minus
``(ii) in the case of a student who completed
a program of study that awards--
``(I) an undergraduate credential
(other than such a credential awarded
by a qualifying undergraduate program
as defined in section
455(a)(4)(B)(ii)), 150 percent of the
poverty line applicable to a single
individual as determined under section
673(2) of the Community Services Block
Grant Act (42 U.S.C. 9902(2)) for such
year; or
``(II) a graduate credential or an
undergraduate credential awarded by a
qualifying undergraduate program as
defined in section 455(a)(4)(B)(ii),
300 percent of the poverty line
applicable to a single individual as
determined under section 673(2) of the
Community Services Block Grant Act (42
U.S.C. 9902(2)) for such year.
``(B) Geographic adjustment.--
``(i) In general.--Except as provided in
clause (ii), the Secretary shall use the
geographic location of the institution at which
a student completed a program of study to
adjust the value-added earnings of the student
calculated under subparagraph (A) by dividing--
``(I) the difference between
subclauses (I) and (II) of such
subparagraph; by
``(II) the most recent regional price
parity index of the Bureau of Economics
Analysis for the State or, as
applicable, metropolitan area in which
such institution is located.
``(ii) Exception.--The value-added earnings
of a student calculated under subparagraph (A)
shall not be adjusted based on geographic
location in accordance with clause (i) if such
student attended principally through distance
education.
``(C) Earnings measurement period.--
``(i) In general.--For the purpose of
calculating the value-added earnings of a
student, except as provided in clause (ii), the
annual earnings of a student shall be
measured--
``(I) in the case of a program of
study that awards an undergraduate
certificate, post baccalaureate
certificate, or graduate certificate,
one year after the student completes
such program;
``(II) in the case of a program of
study that awards an associate's degree
or master's degree, 2 years after the
student completes such program; and
``(III) in the case of a program of
study that awards a bachelor's degree,
doctoral degree, or professional
degree, 4 years after the student
completes such program.
``(ii) Exception.--The Secretary may, as the
Secretary determines appropriate based on the
characteristics of a program of study, extend
an earnings measurement period described in
clause (i) for a program of study that--
``(I) requires completion of an
additional educational program after
completion of the program of study in
order to obtain a licensure associated
with the credential awarded for such
program of study; and
``(II) when combined with the program
length of such additional educational
program for licensure, has a total
program length that exceeds the
relevant earnings measurement period
prescribed for such program of study
under clause (i),
except that in no case shall the annual
earnings of a student be measured more than 5
years after the student completes a program of
study.''.
PART B--COLLEGE COSTS AND FINANCIAL VALUE
SEC. 111. FINANCIAL AID OFFERS.
(a) Institution Financial Aid Offer.--Part B of title I of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1011 et seq.) is amended by adding at
the end the following:
``SEC. 124. INSTITUTION FINANCIAL AID OFFER FORM.
``(a) Standard Form and Terminology.--The Secretary, in consultation
with the heads of relevant Federal agencies, shall develop standard
terminology and a standard form for financial aid offers based on
recommendations from representatives of students, veterans,
servicemembers, families of students, institutions of higher education
(including community colleges, for-profit institutions, four-year
public institutions, and four-year private nonprofit institutions),
financial aid experts, secondary school and postsecondary counselors,
college access professionals, nonprofit organizations, and consumer
groups.
``(b) Key Required Contents for Aid Offer.--The standard form
developed pursuant to subsection (a) shall be titled `Financial Aid
Offer' and shall include the following items in a consumer-friendly
manner that is simple and understandable, with costs listed first,
followed by grants and scholarships, clearly separated from each other
with separate headings:
``(1) Cost information.--
``(A) In general.--Information on the student's
estimated cost of attendance, including the following:
``(i) Direct costs.--The total cost of all
items described in section 472 that are billed
to the student by the institution or otherwise
required by the institution for enrollment,
including such total cost disaggregated by the
cost of each such item, including, as
determined under such section--
``(I) tuition and fees (and other
required expenses); and
``(II) housing and food for a student
electing institutionally owned or
operated food services or
institutionally owned or operated
housing.
``(ii) Indirect costs.--The total cost
(including such total cost disaggregated by the
cost of each item) as determined under section
472, of--
``(I) housing and food for a student
not electing institutionally owned or
operated food services and not living
in institutionally owned or operated
housing;
``(II) books, school supplies,
equipment, course materials, and rental
or purchase of a personal computer;
``(III) transportation; and
``(IV) any other item described in
such section and not described in
clause (i) determined to be necessary
by the institution.
``(B) The academic period covered by the financial
aid offer, and an explanation that the amount of
financial aid offered may differ--
``(i) for academic periods not covered by the
aid offer, such as a summer term or future
academic year; or
``(ii) by program.
``(C) An indication of whether cost and aid estimates
are based on full-time or part-time enrollment.
``(D) An indication, as applicable, about whether any
costs described in subparagraph (A)(i) which are
subject to change are--
``(i) estimated based on the previous year;
or
``(ii) set for the academic period indicated
in accordance with subparagraph (B).
``(2) Grants and scholarships.--The aggregate amount of
grants and scholarships, differentiated by source, that the
student does not have to repay, such as grant aid offered under
title IV, grant aid offered through other Federal programs,
grant aid offered by the institution, grant aid offered by the
State, and, if known, grant aid or scholarship from an outside
source to the student for such academic period, including a
disclosure that the grants and scholarships do not have to be
repaid, except that institutions shall be authorized to list
individual grants and scholarships by name at the discretion of
the institution.
``(3) Net price.--
``(A) In general.--The net price that the student, is
estimated to have to pay for the student to attend the
institution for such academic period, including the
following:
``(i) Minimum amount covered by student for
enrollment.--The net price of tuition and fees
(and other required expenses), which is equal
to--
``(I) the sum of the costs described
in paragraph (1)(A) that are required
for students (as determined under
paragraph (5)(B)) for the period
indicated in paragraph (1)(B); minus
``(II) the total amount of grant and
scholarship aid described in paragraph
(2) that is included in the financial
aid offer and available to the student
Committee Action
117TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On March 17, 2021, the Committee's Subcommittee on Higher
Education and Workforce Development held a hearing on ``Rising
to the Challenge: The Future of Higher Education Post COVID-
19'' to examine challenges and opportunities in postsecondary
education following the COVID-19 pandemic. Testifying before
the Subcommittee were Dr. Lindsey M. Burke, Fellow, Heritage
Foundation, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Keith Thorton Jr., Student,
Florida International University, Miami, Florida; Mr. Eloy
Oritz Oakley, Chancellor, California Community Colleges,
Sacramento, California; and Mr. Daniel Zibel, Vice President
and Chief Counsel, National Student Legal Defense Network,
Washington, D.C.
On April 20, 2021, the Full Committee held a hearing on
``For-Profit College Conversions: Examining Ways to Improve
Accountability and Fraud'' to examine ways to improve the
process for and oversight of college mergers, conversions, and
changes of ownership. Testifying before the Committee were Ms.
Melissa Emrey-Arras, Director of Education, Workforce, and
Income Security, Government Accountability Office, Washington,
D.C.; Dr. Andrew Gillen, Senior Policy Analyst, Texas Public
Policy Foundation, Austin, Texas; Ms. Yan Cao, Fellow, The
Century Foundation, Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Brian Galle,
Professor, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C.
On April 28, 2021, the Full Committee held a hearing on
``Building Back Better: Investing in Improving Schools,
Creating Jobs, and Strengthening Families and Our Economy'' to
examine the implications of the proposed Build Back Better Act,
which included provisions offering ``free'' community college
and increased Pell Grants. Testifying before the Committee were
Dr. Neal McCluskey, Director, Center for Educational Freedom,
Cato Institute, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Brian Riedl, Senior
Fellow, Manhattan Institute, New York, New York; Mr. Rasheed
Malik, Senior Policy Analyst, Center for American Progress,
Washington, D.C.; Mr. Mark Mitsui, President, Portland
Community College, Portland, Oregon; Mr. Bob Lanter, Executive
Director, California Workforce Association, Sacramento,
California; and Ms. Mary Filardo, Executive Director, 21st
Century School Fund, Washington, D.C.
On July 29, 2021, the Committee's Subcommittee on Higher
Education and Workforce Development held a hearing on ``Keeping
the Pell Grant Promise: Increasing Enrollment, Supporting
Success'' to examine ways to improve the Pell Grant program as
well as other policies to improve postsecondary opportunities
and success for low-income students. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Dr. Justin Ortagus, Associate Professor of
Higher Education Administration & Policy and Director of the
Institute of Higher Education, University of Florida,
Gainesville, Florida; Dr. Robert J. Jones, Chancellor,
University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Champaign, Illinois;
Dr. Michael B. Poliakoff, President, American Council of
Trustees and Alumni, Washington, D.C.; and Ms. Darleny Suriel,
Student, City College of New York, New York, New York.
On September 30, 2021, the Committee's Subcommittee on
Higher Education and Workforce Development held a hearing on
``Protecting Students and Taxpayers: Improving the Closed
School Discharge Process'' to examine ways to improve the
Department of Education's ability to protect students and
taxpayers from precipitous school closures. Testifying before
the Subcommittee were Ms. Melissa Emrey-Arras, Director of
Education, Workforce, and Income Security, Government
Accountability Office, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Karyn Rhodes,
Student Borrower, Torrance, California; Mr. Preston Cooper,
Research Fellow, Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity,
Washington, D.C.; and Ms. Robyn Smith, Senior Attorney, Legal
Aid Foundation of Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California.
Second Session--Hearings
On March 2, 2022, the Committee's Subcommittee on Higher
Education and Workforce Development held a hearing on
``Investing in Economic Mobility: The Important Role of
Hispanic Serving Institutions and Other Minority Serving
Institutions'' to examine the role that minority-serving
institutions play in promoting economic mobility, which helped
inform policies such as the PROMISE program included in H.R.
6951. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Dr. Jose Cruz
Rivera, President, Northern Arizona University, Flagstaff,
Arizona; Dr. Patricia Ramsey, President, Medgar Evers College,
Brooklyn, New York; Dr. Janine Davidson, President,
Metropolitan State University, Denver, Colorado; and Dr. Robert
Teranishi, Professor of Social Science and Comparative
Education, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles,
California.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 8, 2023, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``American Education in Crisis'' to
examine the state of American education, including K-12
education, postsecondary education, and workforce development.
During the hearing, witness Dr. Monty Sullivan responded to a
question from Ranking Member Scott that measuring earnings as a
way to determine value was a key component of separating
effective from ineffective programs. Dr. Sullivan also stated
that America's worker shortage ``is too big for America's
public institutions only to solve.'' Mr. Scott Pulsipher echoed
Dr. Sullivan, stating that the value of a program is more
important than its modality. Testifying before the Committee
were Mrs. Virginia Gentles, Director, Education Freedom Center,
Independent Women's Forum, Arlington, Virginia; Dr. Monty
Sullivan, President, Louisiana Community and Technical College
System, Baton Rouge, Louisiana; Mr. Scott Pulsipher, President,
Western Governors University, Salt Lake City, Utah; and The
Hon. Jared Polis, Governor, State of Colorado, Denver,
Colorado.
On March 23, 2023, the Committee's Subcommittee on Higher
Education and Workforce Development held a hearing on
``Breaking the System: Examining the Implications of Biden's
Student Loan Policies for Students and Taxpayers.'' The purpose
of the hearing was to discuss with policy experts the harms of
the Biden administration's loan cancellation policies for
students, taxpayers, and the economy. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Mr. Marc Goldwein, Senior Vice President and
Senior Policy Director, Committee for a Responsible Federal
Budget, Washington, D.C.; Dr. Adam Looney, Director, Marriner
S. Eccles Institute for Economics and Quantitative Analysis,
University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT; Mr. Sameer Gadkaree,
President, the Institute for College Access & Success, Los
Angeles, California; Dr. Carlo Salerno, Economist and Financial
Aid Expert, Los Angeles, California.
On May 16, 2023, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Examining the Policies and
Priorities of the U.S. Department of Education.'' The purpose
of the hearing was to examine the policies and priorities of
the U.S. Department of Education. Testifying before the
Committee was the Honorable Miguel Cardona, Secretary, U.S.
Department of Education, Washington, D.C.
On May 24, 2023, the Committee's Subcommittee on Higher
Education and Workforce Development held a hearing on
``Breaking the System Part II: Examining the Implications of
Biden's Student Loan Policies for Students and Taxpayers.'' The
purpose of the hearing was to discuss with policy experts the
harms of the Biden administration's loan cancellation policies
for students, taxpayers, and the economy. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were the Honorable James Kvaal, Under Secretary of
Education, U.S. Department of Education, Washington, D.C; and
Mr. Richard Cordray, Chief Operating Officer, Office of Federal
Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education, Washington, D.C.
On June 14, 2023, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Postsecondary Innovation:
Preparing Today's Students for Tomorrow's Opportunities.'' The
purpose of the hearing was to examine innovative ways to
improve access, completion, workforce alignment, and student
success in postsecondary education through innovative policies
and practices. Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Tim
Renick, Executive Director, National Institute for Student
Success, Georgia State University; Mr. Keith Shoates, Chief
Operating Officer, Student Freedom Initiative, Washington,
D.C.; Ms. Lanae Erickson, Senior Vice President for Social
Policy, Education and Politics, Third Way, Washington, D.C.;
Dr. Lori Carrell, Chancellor, University of Minnesota Rochester
and Co-Director, College-in-3 Initiative, Rochester, Minnesota.
On July 27, 2023, the Committee's Subcommittee on Higher
Education and Workforce Development held a hearing on
``Lowering the Costs and Increasing Value for Students,
Institutions, and Taxpayers.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to discuss ways in which the accountability system of the HEA
can be reformed. During the hearing, witnesses testified that a
return-on-investment metric would be an appropriate
accountability metric. Testifying before the Subcommittee were
Dr. Andrew Gillen, Senior Policy Analyst, Texas Public Policy
Foundation, Austin, Texas; Mr. Michael Horn, Co-Founder,
Clayton Christensen Institute, Lexington, Massachusetts; Mr.
Stig Leschly, Founder and President, Postsecondary Commission,
Boston, Massachusetts; and Dr. Stephanie Cellini, Professor of
Public Policy and Public Administration, and of Economics, The
George Washington University, Washington, D.C.
Legislative Action
On March 27, 2023, Rep. Bob Good (R-VA) introduced H.J.
Res. 45, providing for congressional disapproval under chapter
8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted by the
Department of Education relating to ``Waivers and Modifications
of Federal Student Loans. `` The bill was referred solely to
the Committee on Education and the Workforce. On May 10, 2023,
the Committee considered H.J. Res. 45 in legislative session
and reported it favorably to the House of Representatives by a
recorded vote of 24-18. On May 24, 2023, the full House
considered H.J. Res. 45 and passed it by a recorded vote of
218-203. On June 1, 2023, the Senate passed H.J. Res. 45 by a
vote of 52-46. On June 7, 2023, it was presented to and vetoed
by President Biden. On June 21, 2023, the House failed to
override the veto by a vote of 221-206.
On September 5, 2023, Rep. Lisa McClain (R-MI) introduced
H.J. Res. 88, providing for congressional disapproval under
chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted
by the Department of Education relating to ``Improving Income
Driven Repayment for the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan
Program and the Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) Program.''
The bill was referred solely to the Committee on Education and
the Workforce. On September 14, 2023, the Committee considered
H.J. Res. 88 in legislative session and reported it favorably,
as amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote
of 23 to 19. On December 7, 2023, the full House considered
H.J. Res. 88 and passed it by a recorded vote of 210-189.
On December 5, 2023, Representatives Elise Stefanik (R-NY),
Virginia Foxx (R-NC), Bobby Scott (D-VA), and Mark DeSaulnier
(D-CA) introduced H.R. 6585, the Bipartisan Workforce Pell Act.
The bill was referred solely to the Committee on Education and
the Workforce. On December 12, 2023, the Committee considered
H.R. 6585 in legislative session and reported it favorably, as
amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of
37-8.
On January 11, 2024, Chairwoman Virginia Foxx introduced
H.R. 6951, the College Cost Reduction Act, with Representatives
Burgess Owens (R-UT), Glenn Grothman (R-WI), Rick Allen (R-GA),
Lloyd Smucker (R-PA), Lisa McClain, Michelle Steel (R-CA), and
Brandon Williams (R-NY) as original co-sponsors. On March 21,
2024, the Committee considered H.R. 6951 in a legislative
session and reported it favorably, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by a recorded vote of 22-19. The Committee
considered the following amendments to H.R. 6951:
1. Rep. Owens offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute that makes technical changes to the text.
The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
2. Rep. Hayes (D-CT) offered an amendment that would
increase the total maximum Pell Grant amount awarded
during the 2025-2026 award year from the current amount
of $7,395 to $10,000 and increase it incrementally
thereafter. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
3. Rep. Hayes offered an amendment to that would
provide federal student loan forgiveness for teachers.
The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #3,
which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
4. Rep. Stevens (D-MI) offered an amendment that
would make post baccalaureate students eligible to
receive a Pell Grant. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote
of 17-22.
5. Rep. DeSaulnier (D-CA) offered an amendment that
would increase the total number of semesters a student
can be eligible for Pell Grants from 12 to 18. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1, which
failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
6. Rep. Courtney (D-CT) offered an amendment that
would expand the Public Service Loan Forgiveness
program. The amendment was included in amendment En
Bloc #1, which failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
7. Rep. Wilson (D-FL) offered an amendment that would
allow graduate or professional students to be eligible
to receive a federal Direct Stafford Loan, excluding
graduate medical school, nursing school, veterinary
school or a school located outside the U.S. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #1, which
failed by a roll call vote of 17-22.
8. Rep. Stevens offered an amendment that would
stipulate that nothing under the bill can be construed
to prevent graduate students from exercising collective
bargaining rights under the National Labor Relations
Act. The amendment was included in amendment En Bloc
#2, which failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
9. Rep. Wilson offered an amendment that would strike
a provision to repeal regulations related to financial
value transparency and gainful employment, and
stipulate that the Department of Education would not be
permitted to promulgate or enforce any regulation or
rules related to the application of the term ``gainful
employment.'' The amendment was included in amendment
En Bloc #4, which failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
10. Ranking Member Scott (D-VA) offered an amendment
that would establish an interest rate equal to the high
yield of the 10-year Treasury note auctioned at the
final auction prior to June 1, 2025, or 5 percent for
new federal Direct Unsubsidized Stafford loans, federal
Direct Stafford loans, and federal Direct PLUS loans
issued on or after July 1, 2025. It also would
establish a new rate for any federal Direct
Consolidation Loan. The amendment would also authorize
the Department of Education to establish a program to
refinance federal Direct Loans. It also would authorize
the Department to establish a program to refinance
eligible private education loans. It would establish
guidelines for determining the interest rate for
refinanced loans through both programs, which would be
fixed. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of 19-
22.
11. Rep. Leger Fernandez (D-NM) offered an amendment
that would direct the Department of Education, in
consultation with the Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau, Financial Literacy and Education Commission,
and IRS, to establish a personal finance education
portal on a centralized and publicly available
Department website for federal financial aid. Rep.
Leger Fernandez subsequently withdrew the amendment.
12. Rep. Leger Fernandez offered an amendment that
would authorize the Department of Education to award
grants for tuition free community college to eligible
states and tribal colleges and universities. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #5, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
13. Rep. Takano (D-CA) offered an amendment that
would strike a provision to repeal the current 90/10
regulation that caps the percentage of revenue that a
for-profit school can receive from federal financial
aid sources at 90 percent and stipulate that the other
10 percent of revenue must come from alternative
sources. The amendment failed by a roll call vote of
19-22.
14. Rep. Takano offered an amendment that would add
language to stipulate that the bill's provisions would
not take effect until the inspectors general of the
departments of Education and Veterans Affairs submit a
report to Congress certifying that the bill will not
result in fraud or abuse of veteran students. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
15. Rep. Adams (D-NC) offered an amendment that would
stipulate that no claim from a federal student loan can
be collected by administrative offset for any payments
related to Social Security. It would apply to any
payments made after the bill's enactment. The amendment
failed by a roll call vote of 19-22.
16. Rep. Adams offered an amendment that would
require the Department of Education, a guaranty agency,
or an eligible loan holder to remove any adverse item
of information related to a loan from a borrower's
credit history upon the sale or assignment of a loan
after the loan is reported as being in default. The
amendment was included in amendment En Bloc #3, which
failed by a roll call vote of 18-22.
17. Rep. Sablan (D-MP) offered an amendment that
would establish a program to enable college-bound
residents of the Northern Mariana Islands and American
Samoa to have additional choices to attend higher
education institutions. The amendment was included in
amendment En Bloc #5, which failed by a roll call vote
of 19-22.
18. Rep. McBath (D-GA) offered an amendment that
would strike a provision to repeal current regulations
related to closed school loan discharges. The amendment
was included in amendment En Bloc #4, which failed by a
roll call vote of 19-22.
19. Rep. Bonamici (D-OR) offered an amendment that
would add language to require colleges and universities
to accept individualized education programs or plans
describing service
Minority Views
Introduction
H.R. 6951, the College Cost Reduction Act, amends the
Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA) in ways Committee Democrats
firmly believe will lower the quality of higher education and
make higher education more expensive for students. Although
H.R. 6951 makes good strides to improve transparency in higher
education, it falls short of holistically providing the key
data points students need to make informed decisions about
college enrollment. H.R. 6951 also includes provisions to
weaken the Direct Loan program and eliminate the PLUS Loan
program, which will make it harder for some students to afford
a college degree, and impossible for others. Finally, the bill
dismantles the existing higher education accountability
framework to protect students and taxpayers from waste, fraud,
and abuse without proposing a viable alternative framework.
Despite some of the bipartisan policies scattered throughout
H.R. 6951, on the whole this bill will have a net-negative
impact on both students and institutions of higher education.
Background on the Rising Cost of College and the Flawed Consideration
of H.R. 6951
The value of a college degree cannot be understated.
Research has consistently found that a college degree confers
significant financial and non-financial returns, particularly
for low-income students and students of color.\1\ Typically,
people with bachelor's degrees make over $1 million more than
high school graduates over their lifetimes.\2\ In addition to
increased learning potential, a college degree also provides
financial stability. During the COVID-19 pandemic, job losses
were concentrated in low wage industries and among workers who
had the least education.\3\ While access is important, success
in obtaining a college degree is crucial; research also shows
that students who do not complete college have higher levels of
debt, default, and repayment hardship.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Susan K. Urahn et al., Pursuing the American Dream: Economic
Mobility Across Generations 3, The Pew Charitable Trusts (Jul. 2012),
https://www.pewtrusts.org//media/legacy/uploadedfiles/wwwpewtrustsorg/
reports/economic_mobility/pursuingamericandreampdf.pdf; H. Comm. on
Educ. & Lab., Don't Stop Believin' (In the Value of a College Degree)i,
(2019), https://democrats-edworkforce.house.gov/imo/media/doc/
Updated%20College%20Rerport%20Final.pdf.
\2\H. Comm. on Educ. & Labor, supra note 01 at i.
\3\Nicole Bateman & Martha Ross, The Pandemic Hurt Low-Wage Workers
the Most--and So Far, the Recovery has Helped Them the Least, The
Brookings Inst. (Jul. 28, 2021), https://www.brookings.edu/articles/
the-pandemic-hurt-
low-wage-workers-the-most-and-so-far-the-recovery-has-helped-them-the-
least/.
\4\Sandy Baum & Martha Johnson, Student Debt: Who Borrows Most?
What Lies Ahead? 7, The Urban Inst. (Apr. 2015), https://www.urban.org/
sites/default/files/alfresco/publication-pdfs/
2000191-Student-Debt-Who-Borrows-Most-What-Lies-Ahead.pdf; Nat'l Ass'n
of Student Fin. Aid Admins., The College Completion Crisi Fuels the
Student Debt Crisis 2, https://static1.squarespace.com/static/
63617bfab00c640904baab4c/t/65b9c02d84a68b37242921c6/
1706672174156/College_Completion_Crisis_Fuels_Student_Debt_Crisis.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As the cost of obtaining a degree has risen sharply over
the last three decades, apprehension about the value of college
has risen as well. From 1990 to 2019, the net cost of
attendance has grown 81 percent at public four-year colleges,
33 percent at private nonprofit colleges, and 19 percent at
public two-year colleges.\5\ The cost of college has
significantly outpaced inflation, and many Americans' ability
to afford a college education has declined.\6\ Nearly 7 million
students, most of whom have family incomes under $40,000 a
year, rely on the Pell Grant to attend and complete college.\7\
However, the Pell Grant has not grown sufficiently to keep pace
with increases in tuition and fees. The Pell Grant now covers
the smallest share of college costs in four decades.\8\
Further, state investment in higher education has declined over
the decades. In 1980, 79 percent of revenue for public colleges
came from state and local investments, but in 2021 it was only
57 percent of revenue.\9\ Students are forced to make up that
difference; to cover the remaining costs of college, low-income
students are taking out loans at higher rates than their high-
income peers and graduating with higher debt loads.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Rethinking Higher Education, U.S. Dep't of Education (Dec.
2018), https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED591005.pdf.
\6\H. Comm. on Educ. & Labor, supra note 01, at 1.
\7\#DoublePell for College Affordability, NCAN, https://
www.ncan.org/page/Pell (last visited on Feb. 9, 2024).
\8\The Inst. For Coll. Access & Success, A State-by-State Look at
College (Un)Affordability 10, (Apr. 2017), https://ticas.org/files/
pub_files/college_costs_in_context.pdf; see also, #Double Pell, The
Case for Doubling the Pell Grant, (Jun. 2021), https://doublepell.org/
wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Double-Pell-Mini-Policy-Paper.pdf.
\9\See State Higher Educ. Exec. Officers Ass'n., State Higher
Education Finance: FY 2021 70-71, (2022), https://shef.sheeo.org/wp-
content/uploads/2022/06/
SHEEO_SHEF_FY21_Report.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The federal government has a responsibility to support
students in achieving their higher education goals by
addressing these issues of the rising cost of college.
Regrettably, Committee Republicans are taking a flawed approach
to these issues through H.R. 6951. Although some policies in
this bill have the goal of incentivizing institutions to lower
their prices, the U.S. higher education system is not simply a
free market, and these faulty, incomplete policies will create
more questions and concerns than solutions for students and
institutions alike. The policies proposed in H.R. 6951 will
make it harder for institutions to deliver quality education,
for students to afford higher education, and for the federal
government to provide oversight of the federal student aid
program.
H.R. 6951 Makes Improvements to College Transparency
H.R. 6951 makes laudable strides to improve transparency
within higher education. Although there is substantial room for
improvement, the transparency provisions in the bill could
significantly increase many students' and families' ability to
make informed financial decisions in postsecondary education.
Committee Democrats stand eager to work in a bipartisan,
bicameral fashion to build upon shared goals and enact policies
that will meaningfully improve student-level and program-level
data on college pricing and outcomes.
FINANCIAL AID OFFERS
H.R. 6951 requires the Secretary of Education to create a
standardized financial aid form for all institutions of higher
education to use to provide students and families with
information about the cost of college and their financial aid
award. Currently, there is no federal law requiring
standardization between institutions when transmitting
financial aid reward offers to students.\10\ A uniform
standardized financial aid form would provide students and
parents with a detailed comparable data points on the cost of
college. Committee Democrats support creating a standardized
financial aid form to provide students and families with more
clarity on college costs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Stephen Burd et al., Decoding the Cost of College: The Case for
Transparent Financial Aid Award Letters 7, New America (Jun. 5, 2018),
https://d1y8sb8igg2f8e.cloudfront.net/documents
/Decoding_the_Cost_of_College_Final_6218.pdf; U.S. Gov't Accountability
Off., GAO-23-104708, Financial Aid Offers: Action Needed to Improve
Information on College Costs and Student Aid 36, (2022), https://
www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23 104708.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
COLLEGE SCORECARD
H.R. 6951 proposes improvements to the College
Scorecard,\11\, a key tool prospective students can use to
compare colleges. Specifically, the bill requires the College
Scorecard to include program-level data on costs, student aid,
and outcomes. Program-level data allows students to more easily
determine whether a program of study best fits their academic
needs. By collecting thorough data on whether individual
programs meet the needs of their students, program-level data
also provides institutions granularity necessary to identify
and reform low-performing programs.\12\ The bill further
improves the ability of students to comparison shop between
different institutions by building on the bipartisan, bicameral
Net Price Calculator Improvement Act, introduced by Reps. Brett
Guthrie (R-KY) and Lori Trahan (D-MA), to streamline cost
comparisons.\13\ Specifically, it mandates the College
Scorecard include a universal net price calculator, giving
students better access to clear, standardized information about
college costs.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\U.S Dep't of Educ., College Scorecard https://
collegescorecard.ed.gov (last visited Feb. 19, 2024).
\12\Michael Itzkowitz, Which College Programs Give Students the
Best Bang for Their Buck? 2, Third Way (Aug. 13, 2021), https://
thirdway.imgix.net/pdfs/which-college-programs-give-
students-the-best-bang-for-their-buck.pdf.
\13\H.R. 1214, 118th Cong. (as introduced in the House, Feb. 27,
2023).
\14\Monica Maldonado, How Net Price Calculators Can Better Serve
Students, Inst. for Higher Educ. Pol'y (Oct. 23, 2019), https://
www.ihep.org/how-net-price-calculators-can-better-serve-
students.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Transparency in the college selection process is a
bipartisan concern; the award letter standardization and
college scorecard provisions of H.R. 6951 have strong
bipartisan support and could form the basis of legislation with
a viable chance of passage into law.
POSTSECONDARY STUDENT DATA SYSTEM
The postsecondary data system has long needed reform, but
the proposal under H.R. 6951 creates more problems than it
solves by insisting on a dogmatic, counterproductive federal
ban on student-level data collection. First proposed by
Chairwoman Foxx in an amendment to the College Cost Reduction
and Access Act in 2007,\15\ this ban prohibits the federal
government from collecting student-level data, something many
states already do to provide strong data on higher education
costs and benefits. Higher education stakeholders have long
advocated for the bipartisan College Transparency Act (CTA),
introduced in the 118th Congress by Reps. Raja Krishnamoorthi
(D-IL), Joe Wilson (R-SC), Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR), Nancy Mace
(R-SC) and Mikie Sherrill (D-NJ).\16\. The CTA, which is
supported by over 150 organizations,\17\ would lift the federal
ban and establish a comprehensive student-level data network
(SLDN) that would ``provide important, aggregate information on
all postsecondary students and their outcomes for
stakeholders.''\18\ This framework would provide key outcomes
data including enrollment, completion, and post-completion
success for all students in higher education; those data could
be aggregated and disaggregated to identify trends across
student populations, institutions, and other categories.\19\
Regrettably, H.R. 6951, does not lift the student-level data
ban and mandates data collection and reporting of data for only
recipients of federal student aid, Workforce Innovation and
Opportunity Act (WIOA) program participants, veterans'
education benefit recipients, and other military-connected
students. According to the Association of Public and Land Grant
Universities, this limitation will exclude data for roughly 30
percent of all students across higher education.\20\ Included
in this glaring gap are more than half of all community college
students in credit-bearing classes.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\College Cost Reduction and Access Act, Pub. L. No: 110 84, 121
Stat. 784 (2007) (codified at 20 U.S.C. 1001).
\16\H.R. 2957, 118 Cong. (as introduced in the House, Apr. 27,
2023).
\17\Letter from the Postsecondary Data Collaborative & National
Skills Coalition to Sen. Bill Cassidy, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, Sen.
Roger Marshall, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, Sen. Chuck Grassley, Sen. John
Hickenlooper, Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi, Rep. Joe Wilson, Rep. Suzanne
Bonamici, Rep. Nancy Mace, and Rep. Mikie Sherrill 2-5 (May 2023),
available at https://www.ihep.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/
PostsecData-National-Skills-Coalition-2023-CTA-Sign-On-May-
2023.docx.pdf.
\18\Erin Dunlop Velez et al., Implementing a Federal Student-Level
Data Network: Advice from Experts, 2, RTI Int'l & Inst. for Higher
Educ. Pol'y (Aug. 2020), https://www.ihep.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/
11/ihep_sldn_brief_rd4_web.pdf.
\19\Sen. Bill Cassidy & Sen. Elizabeth Warren, College Transparency
Act, https://www.help.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/cta_one_pager.pdf (last
visited on Feb. 9, 2024).
\20\Letter from Mark Becker, President, Ass'n of Pub. and Land-
grant Univ., to Reps. Foxx & Scott (Jan. 29, 2024), available at
https://www.aplu.org/wp-content/uploads/CCRA-Markup-
Letter-Signed.pdf.
\21\Letter from Walter G. Bumphus, Ph.D., President & CEO, Am.
Ass'n of Comm. Colls., to Reps. Foxx & Scott (Jan. 30, 2024), available
at https://www.aacc.nche.edu/2024/01/31/aacc-
letter-on-college-cost-reduction-act/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to resulting in incomplete data sets, the
student-level data ban places an unnecessary burden on
institutions. Institutions are already required under HEA to
report data to the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data
System (IPEDS) for all their students. As drafted, H.R. 6951
will require institutions to report to IPEDS and this new data
network using two unique sets of data. This duplication in data
reporting will be especially burdensome for community
colleges,\22\ since 1) they will have a disproportionate
percentage of students to exclude compared to other types of
institutions, and 2) they typically have fewer administrative
resources compared to other types of institutions. In
comparison, a core goal of the College Transparency Act
framework is to streamline the federal reporting system, in
turn decreasing institutional burden. Chairwoman Foxx continues
to oppose the College Transparency Act, arguing it is
``political hackery'' to give bureaucrats ``unfettered access
to pry into the lives of Americans.''\23\ In reality, the
College Transparency Act includes provisions to protect student
privacy by requiring the use of privacy-and security-enhanced
technology, mandating compliance with all Federal privacy and
data security laws, and explicitly prohibiting the collection
of student health data, discipline records, exact addresses,
citizenship status and national origin status, college entrance
exam results, political affiliation, and religion.\24\ Without
the comprehensive reform proposed in the College Transparency
Act, data provisions in H.R. 6951 will prevent students from
seeing the full picture of student outcome data and force
institutions into redundant and incomplete data submissions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Id.
\23\Scott Jaschik, House Approves College Transparency Act, Inside
Higher Ed (Feb. 6, 2022), https://www.insidehighered.com/news/ 2022/02/
07/house-passes-college-transparency-act.
\24\H.R. 2957, supra note 16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6951 Decreases College Access and Makes College Less Affordable
H.R. 6951 proposes a package of damaging policies that will
create a bleak landscape for college access and affordability.
Committee Democrats are deeply concerned that the proposed
changes to federal student aid in H.R. 6951 will collectively
limit access to a range of programs of study for low-income
students, steer students into the private loan market, and make
it harder for borrowers to pay off their loans, in direct
opposition to the goals that drove the creation of the HEA.
CAPPING AID AT THE MEDIAN COST OF COLLEGE
H.R. 6951 caps the total amount of federal student aid that
any student can receive at the median cost of attendance for a
student enrolled in a similar program of study, based on
national data. The stated intent of this policy is to encourage
institutions of higher education to lower their tuition prices;
however, Committee Democrats are not aware of any research that
signals this policy is an appropriate approach to lower college
costs. As a threshold matter, capping aid at the median cost of
attendance would mean 50 percent of students who rely on
federal student aid would not receive enough federal aid to
cover the cost of their program. Higher education advocates
rightfully argue this will create a harmful funding gap that
impacts students' ability to cover the basics needs components
of their cost of attendance, such as housing and transportation
and will be detrimental to students' ability to obtain their
degree.\25\ Further, by using nationwide averages to cap costs,
students attending school in high cost of living areas will be
disproportionately impacted. Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA)
offered an amendment to adjust the allowable amounts of federal
student aid based on location to account for high cost-of-
living areas, but Committee Republicans rejected the amendment
on a party-line vote. Without this adjustment, the basic needs
issues of students attending institutions in urban areas will
be exacerbated. Although Committee Republicans believe this aid
cap will incentivize institutions to lower their prices,
Committee Democrats believe this unfounded, procrustean
approach does not take into consideration variables across the
higher education system. When coupled with provisions limiting
the Secretary's ability to regulate discussed later in these
views, this provision would sew chaos throughout higher
education by discouraging students from entering school to
begin with or drive them into the private loan market.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Letter from Justin Draeger, President & CEO, Nat'l Ass'n of
Student Fin. Aid Admins., to Reps. Foxx & Scott (Jan. 26, 2024),
available at https://www.nasfaa.org/uploads/documents/
College_Cost_Reduction_Act_Letter.pdf; Letter from Ted Mitchell,
President, Am. Council on Educ., to Reps. Foxx & Scott (Jan. 30, 2024),
available at https://www.aamc.org/media/74636/download.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
PELL GRANTS
H.R. 6951 as reported by the Committee does nothing to
strengthen the Pell Grant program--the cornerstone of federal
student aid. Despite the declining purchasing power of the Pell
Grant, it remains a powerful tool that unlocks significant
additional financial