Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 7198]
The Committee on the Judiciary, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 7198) to amend title 5, United States Code, to
require greater transparency for Federal regulatory decisions
that impact small businesses, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 5
Background and Need for the Legislation.......................... 5
Hearings......................................................... 7
Committee Consideration.......................................... 8
Committee Votes.................................................. 8
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 15
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 15
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 15
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects.......................... 15
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 15
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 15
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 16
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 16
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 16
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 16
Correspondence................................................... 17
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 20
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 21
Dissenting Views................................................. 29
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all that follows the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Prove It Act of 2024''.
SEC. 2. INITIAL REGULATORY FLEXIBILITY ANALYSIS.
(a) In General.--Chapter 6 of title 5, United States Code, is
amended--
(1) in section 603(b)--
(A) in paragraph (5), by striking the period at the
end and inserting ``; and''; and
(B) by adding at the end the following:
``(6) where feasible, any reasonably foreseeable potential
indirect costs the proposed rule may impose on small entities,
including small entities that--
``(A) purchase products or services from, sell
products or services to, or otherwise conduct business
with entities directly regulated by the rule;
``(B) are directly regulated by other governmental
entities as a result of the rule; or
``(C) are not directly regulated by the agency as a
result of the rule but are otherwise subject to other
agency rules as a result of the rule.'';
(2) in section 605(b), by striking ``The agency'' and
inserting ``Not later than 10 days after completing the
certification described in this subsection, the agency''; and
(3) by inserting after section 605 the following:
``Sec. 605A. Review procedures relating to initial regulatory
flexibility analysis certifications
``(a) Filing a Petition to Review Agency Certification of a Proposed
Rule.--
``(1) In general.--Any small entity, group of small entities,
or organization representing the interests of small entities
may petition the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small
Business Administration (in this section referred to as the
`Chief Counsel') to review a certification published under
section 605(b) that a proposed rule will not, if promulgated,
have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of
small entities.
``(2) Form.--The Chief Counsel shall--
``(A) determine the method, timing, and form of
disseminating a petition described in paragraph (1);
and
``(B) display the information described in
subparagraph (A) on the website of the Office of
Advocacy of the Small Business Administration in a
conspicuous manner.
``(3) Contents.--Each petition described in paragraph (1)
with respect to a certification published under section 605(b)
for a proposed rule shall clearly and concisely--
``(A) specify the name of the petitioner and a
telephone number, a mailing address, and an email
address that the Chief Counsel may use to communicate
with the petitioner;
``(B) if the petitioner is an organization, provide
additional identifying information, as applicable,
including the organizational or corporate status of the
petitioner, the State of incorporation of the
petitioner, the registered agent of the petitioner, the
interest of the petitioner in representing small
entities affected by the proposed rule and the
certification at issue, and the name and authority of
the individual who signed the petition on behalf of the
organizational or corporate petitioner;
``(C) present the specific problems or issues that
the petitioner believes should be addressed or
considered through a review of the certification, such
as--
``(i) any specific circumstances in which the
determination of the certification that the
proposed rule will not, if promulgated, have a
significant economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities is incorrect,
incomplete, or inadequate; or
``(ii) why the proposed rule would, if
promulgated, have a significant economic impact
on a substantial number of small entities;
``(D) cite, enclose, or reference any relevant and
non-protected or confidential technical, scientific, or
other data or information supporting any assertion of
the problems or issues with the certification;
``(E) present a proposed solution to the problems or
issues raised in the petition, including potential
regulatory or compliance alternatives to the proposed
rule;
``(F) provide an analysis, discussion, or argument
that explains how the proposed solution described in
subparagraph (E) solves the problems or issues raised
in the petition; and
``(G) cite, enclose, or reference any other publicly
available data or information supporting the proposed
solution described in subparagraph (E).
``(b) Consultation.--
``(1) In general.--Any entity or organization desiring to
file a petition under subsection (a) may request a consultation
with the Chief Counsel before or after filing the petition.
``(2) Form.--The Chief Counsel shall--
``(A) determine the method, timing, and form of
requesting a consultation with the Chief Counsel under
paragraph (1); and
``(B) display the information described in
subparagraph (A) on the website of the Office of
Advocacy of the Small Business Administration in a
conspicuous manner.
``(3) Limitations on assistance.--In any consultation
regarding a petition under paragraph (1), the Chief Counsel--
``(A) may only--
``(i) describe the process for filing,
docketing, tracking, closing, amending,
withdrawing, and resolving the petition; and
``(ii) assist the petitioner to clarify the
petition so that the Chief Counsel is able to
understand the issues of concern to the
petitioner; and
``(B) may not advise a petitioner on whether the
petition should be amended or withdrawn.
``(c) Prima Facie Review.--
``(1) In general.--Upon receipt of a petition filed under
this section with respect to the certification of a proposed
rule, the Chief Counsel shall make an initial prima facie
determination on the merit of the issues raised in petition as
to the properness of the certification and whether the proposed
rule in question would, if promulgated, have a significant
economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
``(2) No further review.--If, following the prima facie
review of a petition under paragraph (1), the Chief Counsel
determines that the issues raised in the petition do not merit
further review by the Chief Counsel, the Chief Counsel shall,
not later than 10 days after receipt of the petition, inform
the petitioner of that determination and the matter shall be
closed.
``(3) Further review.--If, following the prima facie review
of a petition under paragraph (1), the Chief Counsel determines
that the issues raised in the petition do merit further review
by the Chief Counsel, the Chief Counsel shall, not later than
10 days after receipt of the petition, inform the petitioner
and the agency that promulgated the proposed rule that the
Chief Counsel shall conduct a full review of the certification
and proposed rule to which the petition relates under
subsection (d).
``(d) Full Review.--
``(1) Considerations; meeting.--In conducting a full review
under this subsection with respect to the certification made
under section 605(b), the Chief Counsel shall--
``(A) consider--
``(i) whether the agency that promulgated the
proposed rule correctly determined which small
entities will be affected by the proposed rule;
``(ii) whether the agency considered adequate
economic data to assess whether the proposed
rule will have a significant impact on a
substantial number of small entities; and
``(iii) the economic implications of the
proposed rule; and
``(B) convene a virtual or in-person meeting between
the Chief Counsel, the petitioner, representatives of
the agency that promulgated the proposed rule who are
determined appropriate by the Chief Counsel, and the
Administrator of the Office of Information and
Regulatory affairs to--
``(i) provide positions and support for those
positions regarding the certification of the
proposed rule; and
``(ii) allow the Chief Counsel to ask
questions as the Chief Counsel determines
necessary to make a final determination as to
the validity of the certification.
``(2) Publication.--Not later than 30 days after the date on
which the Chief Counsel begins a full review of a certification
made with respect to a proposed rule under paragraph (1), the
Chief Counsel shall submit to the petitioner and the agency
that promulgated the proposed rule, and publish in the Federal
Register and on the website of the Office of Advocacy of the
Small Business Administration, the results of the review
conducted under paragraph (1).
``(3) Requirement to perform analyses.--If, after a full
review of a certification made with respect to a proposed rule
under paragraph (1), the Chief Counsel determines that the
proposed rule will, if promulgated, have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities, the agency
that promulgated the proposed rule shall perform an initial
regulatory flexibility analysis and a final regulatory
flexibility analysis for the proposed rule under sections 603
and 604, respectively.
``(4) Penalty.--If an agency fails to attend the required
meeting under paragraph (1)(B) or in any other way fails to
assist the Chief Counsel in a full review under paragraph (1)
with respect to a proposed rule of the agency, as determined by
the Chief Counsel, the final rule shall not apply to small
entities.
``(5) Judicial review.--For purposes of judicial review under
chapter 7 of this title, a certification made by an agency
under section 605(b) for which a petition is filed under
subsection (a) shall be considered final agency action as of
the date on which the Chief Counsel--
``(A) makes a determination under subsection (c)(2)
that the issues raised in the petition do not merit
further review; or
``(B) publishes the results of a full review of the
certification under paragraph (1).''.
(b) Technical and Conforming Amendment.--The table of sections for
chapter 6 of title 5, United States Code, is amended by inserting after
the item relating to section 605 the following:
``605A. Review procedures relating to initial regulatory flexibility
analysis certifications.''.
SEC. 3. PUBLICATION OF GUIDANCE.
Section 609 of title 5, United States Code, is amended by adding at
the end the following:
``(f) With respect to any rule that an agency determines is likely to
have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities, the head of the agency shall, on regulations.gov or any
similar internet website--
``(1) publish all guidance documents and other relevant
documents, as determined by the agency, including any updated
guidance documents that set forth interpretations of the rule;
and
``(2) allow for comments on the documents described in
paragraph (1) to ensure that small entities may access and
provide feedback on those documents.''.
SEC. 4. REVIEW PROCEDURES FOR SECTION 610 PERIODIC REVIEW OF RULES.
(a) In General.--Section 610 of title 5, United States Code, is
amended--
(1) in subsection (b)--
(A) in the matter preceding paragraph (1), by
striking ``the following factors'';
(B) in paragraph (4), by striking ``and'' at the end;
(C) in paragraph (5), by striking the period at the
end and inserting ``; and''; and
(D) by adding at the end the following:
``(6) any indirect costs described in the initial regulatory
flexibility analysis under section 603(b)(6), and any other
indirect costs that may have arisen during the 10-year period
described in subsection (a).''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(d) If an agency fails to conduct a review of a rule as required
under this section within the 10-year period described in subsection
(a)--
``(1) the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small Business
Administration shall notify the agency that the rule has ceased
to be effective;
``(2) the agency shall publish in the Federal Register a
notification that the rule has ceased to be effective, and
solicit comments for why the rule should be reinstated; and
``(3) if, based on the comments received under paragraph (2),
the agency determines that the rule should be reinstated--
``(A) the agency shall have 180 days beginning on the
date of that determination to complete the review of
the rule under this section; and
``(B) upon completion of the review under
subparagraph (A), the rule shall be reinstated,
notwithstanding the notice and comment rulemaking
procedures under section 553 of this title.''.
(b) Application.--The amendment made by subsection (a)(2) shall apply
with respect to any final rule issued by an agency--
(1) during the 5-year period preceding the date of enactment
of this Act; or
(2) on or after the date of enactment of this Act.
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 7198, the Prove It Act of 2024, introduced by Rep.
Brad Finstad (R-MN), amends the Regulatory Flexibility Act
(RFA) to require agencies to better account for the effects of
regulations on small businesses. The bill empowers small
businesses to petition the Small Business Administration's
Chief Counsel for Advocacy to review an agency's certification
that a proposed regulation will not have a significant economic
impact on small businesses, requires agencies to publish
guidance documents interpreting regulations that have a
significant economic impact on small businesses, and improves
the periodic review process for regulations.
Background and Need for the Legislation
The RFA,\1\ enacted in 1980, requires ``federal agencies to
consider the effects of their regulations on small businesses
and other small entities.''\2\ The RFA's goal is to reduce the
economic impact of agency regulation on small businesses.\3\ In
1996, Congress amended the RFA to add judicial review relative
to some of its provisions, require some agencies to hold small
business advocacy review panels, and mandate that federal
agencies produce regulatory compliance guidelines.\4\ Congress
has not amended the RFA since 2010, when it made technical
corrections and mandated that the newly-formed Consumer
Financial Protection Bureau convene small business review
panels when promulgating rules.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\5 U.S.C. Sec. 601-612 (1980).
\2\Maeve P. Carey, The Regulatory Flexibility Act: An Overview,
Cong. Research Serv. 1 (2021).
\3\Id.
\4\Id.
\5\The Regulatory Flexibility Act, U.S. Small Business
Administration (last accessed Mar. 14, 2024), available at https://
advocacy.sba.gov/resources/the-regulatory-flexibility-act/; see also
Dodd Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, Pub. L. No.
111-203 (2010), Sec. 1100G; Small Business Jobs Act of 2010, Pub. L.
No. 111-240 (2010), Sec. 1601.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under the RFA, when an agency begins the rulemaking
process, the head of the agency must determine whether the
proposed rule will have a ``significant economic impact on a
substantial number of small entities.''\6\ The agency must
either certify that the regulation will not have a significant
economic impact on small businesses or conduct an initial
regulatory flexibility analysis to determine the extent of the
impact on small businesses.\7\ If such an analysis is
conducted, it must contain a justification for the rule, a
description of the agency's goals for the rule, and a
description of alternatives to the proposed regulation.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Maeve P. Carey, supra note 2.
\7\Id.; see also The Regulatory Flexibility Act, supra note 5.
\8\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When preparing the final rule, the agency conducts a final
regulatory flexibility analysis where the agency must justify
its choice of regulation and explain why the agency rejected
less burdensome alternatives.\9\ The agency must publish all
analyses and certifications in the Federal Register.\10\ In
addition, the RFA gives small businesses a voice in the room
when discussing proposed regulation. Whenever a rulemaking
begins, the promulgating agency must notify the Small Business
Administration's Chief Counsel for Advocacy, who may choose to
comment on the rulemaking.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Meave P. Carey, supra note 2.
\10\The Regulatory Flexibility Act, supra note 5.
\11\Maeve P. Carey, supra note 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Need for the Legislation
After Congress enacted the RFA, some evidence has suggested
that federal agencies took seriously the policy of reducing
regulatory burden on small businesses--but evidence shows that
the burden on small business continues to increase. For
example, an analysis conducted by the National Federation of
Independent Business (NFIB) found that proposed and final rules
dropped significantly after the RFA's enactment.\12\ However,
despite that initial reduction in the number of regulations
affecting small businesses, the cost of compliance continued to
grow significantly. For example, in 2001, small businesses
spent nearly double what medium-sized businesses spent per
employee to comply with federal regulations.\13\ By 2014, small
businesses spent nearly five times as much per employee as
medium-sized businesses on compliance.\14\ Today, small
businesses spend over seven times as much per employee as
medium-sized businesses on spent per employee on
compliance.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\See Rob Smith, The Regulatory Flexibility Act: Turning a Paper
Tiger into a Legitimate Constraint on One-Size-Fits-All Agency
Rulemaking, NFIB 4 (2023).
\13\See W. Mark Crain & Thomas D. Hopkins, The Impact of Regulatory
Costs on Small Firms, Office of Advocacy, U.S. Small Business
Administration (2001).
\14\W. Mark Crain & Nicole V. Crain, The Cost of Federal Regulation
to the U.S. Economy, Manufacturing, and Small Business, National
Association of Manufacturers (2014).
\15\Nicole V. Crain & W. Mark Crain, The Cost of Federal Regulation
to the U.S. Economy, Manufacturing, and Small Business, National
Association of Manufacturers (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
More recently it has become clear that federal agencies
often blatantly ignore the RFA's requirements. The NFIB found
that in 75 percent of rulemakings, the SBA determined that
federal agencies ``either ignored costs on small business or
underestimated [the regulation's] cost.''\16\ Along with
ignoring the RFA's requirements, the Biden-Harris
Administration has significantly increased the number of
regulations affecting small businesses, with nearly half of the
regulations affecting small businesses in 2022 requiring a
regulatory flexibility analysis.\17\ Further, the other half
affected small businesses ``in some fashion,'' but were below
the RFA's threshold for requiring regulatory flexibility
analysis.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Rob Smith, supra note 11, at 26.
\17\See Clyde Wayne Crews, Ten Thousand Commandments 2023,
Competitive Enterprise Institute 5 (2023).
\18\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the direct cost of regulation is relatively simple to
estimate,\19\ many costs are only indirectly associated with
regulation but nonetheless impose a genuine cost on small
businesses and the economy.\20\ The average annual cost of
regulation is independently estimated to be over $14,000 per
employee for American small businesses.\21\ However, agencies
are not currently required to account for indirect costs borne
by small business because of regulations, making the true
economic costs of regulations on small business unclear.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\An example of direct regulatory costs is the direct purchase of
equipment necessary to comply with the regulation. See The Costs and
Benefits of Government Regulation: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on
Consumers of the S. Comm. on Commerce, Science, and Transportation,
95th Cong. (1978) (Statement of Harry S. Havens, Dir., Prog. Analysis
Div., U.S. Gen. Accounting Office).
\20\See Jerry Ellig, What are the Indirect Costs of Regulation?,
Mercatus Center (Dec. 1, 2011).
\21\Nicole V. Crain & W. Mark Crain, The Cost of Federal Regulation
to the U.S. Economy, Manufacturing, and Small Business, National
Association of Manufacturers (2023).
\22\Maeve P. Carey, The Regulatory Flexibility Act: Implementation
Issues and Proposed Reforms, Cong. Research Serv. n. 31 (2011) (``The
SBA Chief Counsel for Advocacy said his office's ``biggest concern with
the RFA is that it does not require agencies to analyze indirect
impacts.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is particularly problematic because regulatory burdens
make it more difficult and costly to start a business,
suppressing entrepreneurial activity and new business
formation.\23\ Piling regulations on small businesses across
the country makes it more likely that would-be entrepreneurs
will abandon their ideas altogether instead of undergoing
significant startup expense and related risk.\24\ This
reduction in small business activity harms innovation and
competition.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\See, e.g., Triple Threat to Workers and Households: Impacts of
Federal Regulations on Jobs, Wages, and Startups: Hearing Before the
Subcomm. on Regulatory Reform, Commercial, and Antitrust Law of the H.
Comm. on the Judic., 114th Cong. (2016) (Testimony of Patrick A
McLaughlin, Senior Research Fellow, Mercatus Center at George Mason
University).
\24\See id.
\25\See Kathryn Kobe and Richard Schwinn, Small Business
Administration Office of Advocacy, Small Business GDP 1998-2014 40
(2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 7198, the Prove It Act, will shift more power to small
businesses and force regulators to better consider the overall
effect that regulation has on small business before finalizing
economically burdensome rules.\26\ Among other things, H.R.
7198 creates a mechanism for small businesses to challenge
regulations when regulators do not correctly consider the
effects on small businesses, makes small businesses exempt from
regulations under certain circumstances, and ensures that small
businesses can more easily access regulatory compliance
guidance documents.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\See generally Press Release, Rep. Nathanel Moran, Moran,
Finstad, Caraveo Introduce the Prove It Act, Protecting Small
Businesses from Burdensome Regulations (Feb. 2, 2024).
\27\Prove It Act of 2024, H.R. 7198 (2024), Sec. 2(a)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Regulatory Flexibility Act was a pivotal first step in
ensuring that small businesses have a way to challenge the
administrative state. But agencies still underreport, minimize,
or ignore the effect regulations have on small businesses,
rendering the RFA nearly toothless.\28\ The Prove It Act
strengthens the RFA, will help to force the administrative
state to comply with the RFA, ensure that indirect costs on
small business are properly accounted for, and gives small
businesses a way to challenge non-compliant agencies.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\See generally Letter from Josh McLeod, Dir. Fed. Gov't
Relations, NFIB to Rep. Brad Finstad, Member, U.S. House of
Representatives (Feb. 1, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
the following hearing was used to develop H.R. 7198: ``Reining
in the Administrative State: Reclaiming Congress''s Legislative
Power,'' a hearing held on March 10, 2023, before the
Subcommittee on the Administrative State, Regulatory Reform,
and Antitrust of the Committee on the Judiciary. The
Subcommittee heard testimony from the following witnesses:
Allyson N. Ho, Partner and Co-Chair of
Appellate and Constitutional Law, Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP;
Jonathan Wolfson, Chief Legal Officer and
Policy Director, Cicero Institute;
Ryan Cleckner, Co-Founder, Gun University
LLC and Owner, Law office of Ryan M. Cleckner; and
Emily Hammond, Professor, George Washington
University Law School.
The hearing addressed the growth of the administrative state
and how it has aggrandized legislative power.
Committee Consideration
On March 21, 2024, the Committee met in open session and
ordered the bill, H.R. 7198, favorably reported with an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, by a roll call vote of
17 to 10, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following roll call votes occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 7198:
1. Vote on Amendment #1 to H.R. 7198 ANS, offered by Mr.
Nadler, failed 9-14
2. Vote on Amendment #2 to H.R. 7198 ANS, offered by Mr.
Nadler, failed 10-16
3. Vote on Amendment #3 to H.R. 7198 ANS, offered by Mr.
Nadler, failed 10-16
4. Vote on Amendment #4 to H.R. 7198 ANS, offered by Ms.
McBath, failed 8-13
5. Vote on Amendment #5 to H.R. 7198 ANS, offered by Ms.
Balint, failed 7-8
6. Vote on favorably reporting H.R. 7198, as amended,
passed 17-10
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause2(b)(1) of
rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are incorporated
in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and with respect
to the requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives and section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has requested
but not received a cost estimate for this bill from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office. The Committee has
requested but not received from the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office a statement as to whether this bill
contains any new budget authority, spending authority, credit
authority, or an increase or decrease in revenues or tax
expenditures. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such
estimate and statement to be printed in the Congressional
Record upon its receipt by the Committee.
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, a cost
estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office pursuant
to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not
made available to the Committee in time for the filing of this
report. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such estimate
to be printed in the Congressional Record upon its receipt by
the Committee.
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(d)(1) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 7198 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, H.R. 7198 would amend the Regulatory
Flexibility Act to require agencies to better account for the
effects of regulations on small businesses.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 7198
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House Rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
An estimate of federal mandates prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget office pursuant to section 423 of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act was not made available to the
Committee in time for the filing of this report. The Chairman
of the Committee shall cause such estimate to be printed in the
Congressional Record upon its receipt by the Committee.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act (Pub. L. 104-
1).
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title
This section sets forth the short title of the bill as the
``Prove It Act of 2024''.
Section 2. Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
This section amends 5 U.S.C. Sec. 603(b) to require that an
agency's Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis (IRFA)
include, where feasible, the reasonably foreseeable potential
indirect costs that a proposed rule may impose on small
entities. This section also amends 5 U.S.C. Sec. 605(b) to
impose a new 10-day deadline for when the head of an agency
certifying that a rule will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities must provide
that certification to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy at the
Small Business Administration (Chief Counsel).
This section further creates after 5 U.S.C. Sec. 605 a new
section, ``Sec. 605A, Review procedures relating to initial
regulatory flexibility analysis certifications.'' The new
section:
Authorizes small entities to petition the
Chief Counsel for Advocacy to review a certification
under section 605(b); requires the Chief Counsel to
determine and publish the process and form for
submitting petitions; and establishes requirements for
the contents of petitions.
Establishes an opportunity for consultation
with the Chief Counsel before or after an entity files
a petition; requires the Chief Counsel to determine and
publish the process and form for requesting
consultation; and sets limits on the scope of the Chief
Counsel's assistance during consultation.
Sets forth standards for the Chief Counsel's
initial review of petitions; directs the Chief Counsel
how to proceed if a petition lacks merit; and requires
that the Chief Counsel tell the petitioner and relevant
agency if the Chief Counsel will conduct a ``full
review'' of the certification and proposed rule.
Sets forth requirements for the Chief
Counsel's conducting a ``full review'' with respect to
an agency certification, including what the Chief
Counsel shall consider in conducting the review, and
that the Chief Counsel convene a meeting with the
petitioner and agency that issued the proposed rule to
help the Chief Counsel assess the certification.
Requires that the Chief Counsel provide and publish the
results of the full review within 30 days after the
full review begins.
Requires that if the Chief Counsel
determines--notwithstanding the agency's
certification--that the proposed rule will have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of
small entities, the agency must perform an initial and
final regulatory flexibility analysis for the rule
under sections 603 and 604.
Provides that if an agency fails to assist
the Chief Counsel's full review, the Chief Counsel may
determine the final rule shall not apply to small
entities.
Provides that an agency certification under
section 605(b) for which a petition is filed shall be
considered final agency action for purposes of judicial
review.
Section 3. Publication of guidance
This section amends 5 U.S.C. Sec. 609 by requiring that an
agency publish and collect comments on guidance or other
relevant documents related to any rule the agency determines is
likely to have a significant economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities.
Section 4. Review Procedures for Section 610 periodic review of rules
This section amends 5 U.S.C. Sec. 610(b) to require that an
agency's review to minimize a rule's significant economic
impact upon a substantial number of small entities shall
consider certain indirect costs.
The section also provides that if an agency fails to timely
conduct review of a rule as 5 U.S.C. Sec. 610 requires, the
Chief Counsel shall notify the agency the rule is no longer
effective; the agency must notify the public that the rule has
ceased to be effective and solicit comments for why the rule
should be reinstated; and, if the agency determines based on
comments the rule should be reinstated, it will have 180 days
to review the rule as required, and the rule shall be
reinstated. These requirements apply to any final rule issued
on or after the date of enactment, or during the 5-year period
before the date of enactment.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
TITLE 5, UNITED STATES CODE
* * * * * * *
PART I--THE AGENCIES GENERALLY
* * * * * * *
CHAPTER 6--THE ANALYSIS OF REGULATORY FUNCTIONS
Sec.
601. Definitions.
* * * * * * *
605A. Review procedures relating to initial regulatory flexibility
analysis certifications.
* * * * * * *
Sec. 603. Initial regulatory flexibility analysis
(a) Whenever an agency is required by section 553 of this
title, or any other law, to publish general notice of proposed
rulemaking for any proposed rule, or publishes a notice of
proposed rulemaking for an interpretative rule involving the
internal revenue laws of the United States, the agency shall
prepare and make available for public comment an initial
regulatory flexibility analysis. Such analysis shall describe
the impact of the proposed rule on small entities. The initial
regulatory flexibility analysis or a summary shall be published
in the Federal Register at the time of the publication of
general notice of proposed rulemaking for the rule. The agency
shall transmit a copy of the initial regulatory flexibility
analysis to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small
Business Administration. In the case of an interpretative rule
involving the internal revenue laws of the United States, this
chapter applies to interpretative rules published in the
Federal Register for codification in the Code of Federal
Regulations, but only to the extent that such interpretative
rules impose on small entities a collection of information
requirement.
(b) Each initial regulatory flexibility analysis required
under this section shall contain--
(1) a description of the reasons why action by the
agency is being considered;
(2) a succinct statement of the objectives of, and
legal basis for, the proposed rule;
(3) a description of and, where feasible, an estimate
of the number of small entities to which the proposed
rule will apply;
(4) a description of the projected reporting,
recordkeeping and other compliance requirements of the
proposed rule, including an estimate of the classes of
small entities which will be subject to the requirement
and the type of professional skills necessary for
preparation of the report or record;
(5) an identification, to the extent practicable, of
all relevant Federal rules which may duplicate, overlap
or conflict with the proposed rule[.]; and
(6) where feasible, any reasonably foreseeable
potential indirect costs the proposed rule may impose
on small entities, including small entities that--
(A) purchase products or services from, sell
products or services to, or otherwise conduct
business with entities directly regulated by
the rule;
(B) are directly regulated by other
governmental entities as a result of the rule;
or
(C) are not directly regulated by the agency
as a result of the rule but are otherwise
subject to other agency rules as a result of
the rule.
(c) Each initial regulatory flexibility analysis shall also
contain a description of any significant alternatives to the
proposed rule which accomplish the stated objectives of
applicable statutes and which minimize any significant economic
impact of the proposed rule on small entities. Consistent with
the stated objectives of applicable statutes, the analysis
shall discuss significant alternatives such as--
(1) the establishment of differing compliance or
reporting requirements or timetables that take into
account the resources available to small entities;
(2) the clarification, consolidation, or
simplification of compliance and reporting requirements
under the rule for such small entities;
(3) the use of performance rather than design
standards; and
(4) an exemption from coverage of the rule, or any
part thereof, for such small entities.
(d)(1) For a covered agency, as defined in section 609(d)(2),
each initial regulatory flexibility analysis shall include a
description of--
(A) any projected increase in the cost of credit for
small entities;
(B) any significant alternatives to the proposed rule
which accomplish the stated objectives of applicable
statutes and which minimize any increase in the cost of
credit for small entities; and
(C) advice and recommendations of representatives of
small entities relating to issues described in
subparagraphs (A) and (B) and subsection (b).
(2) A covered agency, as defined in section 609(d)(2), shall,
for purposes of complying with paragraph (1)(C)--
(A) identify representatives of small entities in
consultation with the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the
Small Business Administration; and
(B) collect advice and recommendations from the
representatives identified under subparagraph (A)
relating to issues described in subparagraphs (A) and
(B) of paragraph (1) and subsection (b).
* * * * * * *
Sec. 605. Avoidance of duplicative or unnecessary analyses
(a) Any Federal agency may perform the analyses required by
sections 602, 603, and 604 of this title in conjunction with or
as a part of any other agenda or analysis required by any other
law if such other analysis satisfies the provisions of such
sections.
(b) Sections 603 and 604 of this title shall not apply to any
proposed or final rule if the head of the agency certifies that
the rule will not, if promulgated, have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities. If the head
of the agency makes a certification under the preceding
sentence, the agency shall publish such certification in the
Federal Register at the time of publication of general notice
of proposed rulemaking for the rule or at the time of
publication of the final rule, along with a statement providing
the factual basis for such certification. [The agency] Not
later than 10 days after completing the certification described
in this subsection, the agency shall provide such certification
and statement to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small
Business Administration.
(c) In order to avoid duplicative action, an agency may
consider a series of closely related rules as one rule for the
purposes of sections 602, 603, 604 and 610 of this title.
Sec. 605A. Review procedures relating to initial regulatory flexibility
analysis certifications
(a) Filing a Petition to Review Agency Certification of a
Proposed Rule.--
(1) In general.--Any small entity, group of small
entities, or organization representing the interests of
small entities may petition the Chief Counsel for
Advocacy of the Small Business Administration (in this
section referred to as the ``Chief Counsel'') to review
a certification published under section 605(b) that a
proposed rule will not, if promulgated, have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of
small entities.
(2) Form.--The Chief Counsel shall--
(A) determine the method, timing, and form of
disseminating a petition described in paragraph
(1); and
(B) display the information described in
subparagraph (A) on the website of the Office
of Advocacy of the Small Business
Administration in a conspicuous manner.
(3) Contents.--Each petition described in paragraph
(1) with respect to a certification published under
section 605(b) for a proposed rule shall clearly and
concisely--
(A) specify the name of the petitioner and a
telephone number, a mailing address, and an
email address that the Chief Counsel may use to
communicate with the petitioner;
(B) if the petitioner is an organization,
provide additional identifying information, as
applicable, including the organizational or
corporate status of the petitioner, the State
of incorporation of the petitioner, the
registered agent of the petitioner, the
interest of the petitioner in representing
small entities affected by the proposed rule
and the certification at issue, and the name
and authority of the individual who signed the
petition on behalf of the organizational or
corporate petitioner;
(C) present the specific problems or issues
that the petitioner believes should be
addressed or considered through a review of the
certification, such as--
(i) any specific circumstances in
which the determination of the
certification that the proposed rule
will not, if promulgated, have a
significant economic impact on a
substantial number of small entities is
incorrect, incomplete, or inadequate;
or
(ii) why the proposed rule would, if
promulgated, have a significant
economic impact on a substantial number
of small entities;
(D) cite, enclose, or reference any relevant
and non-protected or confidential technical,
scientific, or other data or information
supporting any assertion of the problems or
issues with the certification;
(E) present a proposed solution to the
problems or issues raised in the petition,
including potential regulatory or compliance
alternatives to the proposed rule;
(F) provide an analysis, discussion, or
argument that explains how the proposed
solution described in subparagraph (E) solves
the problems or issues raised in the petition;
and
(G) cite, enclose, or reference any other
publicly available data or information
supporting the proposed solution described in
subparagraph (E).
(b) Consultation.--
(1) In general.--Any entity or organization desiring
to file a petition under subsection (a) may request a
consultation with the Chief Counsel before or after
filing the petition.
(2) Form.--The Chief Counsel shall--
(A) determine the method, timing, and form of
requesting a consultation with the Chief
Counsel under paragraph (1); and
(B) display the information described in
subparagraph (A) on the website of the Office
of Advocacy of the Small Business
Administration in a conspicuous manner.
(3) Limitations on assistance.--In any consultation
regarding a petition under paragraph (1), the Chief
Counsel--
(A) may only--
(i) describe the process for filing,
docketing, tracking, closing, amending,
withdrawing, and resolving the
petition; and
(ii) assist the petitioner to clarify
the petition so that the Chief Counsel
is able to understand the issues of
concern to the petitioner; and
(B) may not advise a petitioner on whether
the petition should be amended or withdrawn.
(c) Prima Facie Review.--
(1) In general.--Upon receipt of a petition filed
under this section with respect to the certification of
a proposed rule, the Chief Counsel shall make an
initial prima facie determination on the merit of the
issues raised in petition as to the properness of the
certification and whether the proposed rule in question
would, if promulgated, have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small entities.
(2) No further review.--If, following the prima facie
review of a petition under paragraph (1), the Chief
Counsel determines that the issues raised in the
petition do not merit further review by the Chief
Counsel, the Chief Counsel shall, not later than 10
days after receipt of the petition, inform the
petitioner of that determination and the matter shall
be closed.
(3) Further review.--If, following the prima facie
review of a petition under paragraph (1), the Chief
Counsel determines that the issues raised in the
petition do merit further review by the Chief Counsel,
the Chief Counsel shall, not later than 10 days after
receipt of the petition, inform the petitioner and the
agency that promulgated the proposed rule that the
Chief Counsel shall conduct a full review of the
certification and proposed rule to which the petition
relates under subsection (d).
(d) Full Review.--
(1) Considerations; meeting.--In conducting a full
review under this subsection with respect to the
certification made under section 605(b), the Chief
Counsel shall--
(A) consider--
(i) whether the agency that
promulgated the proposed rule correctly
determined which small entities will be
affected by the proposed rule;
(ii) whether the agency considered
adequate economic data to assess
whether the proposed rule will have a
significant impact on a substant
Dissenting Views
I. Introduction
H.R. 7198, the ``Prove It Act of 2024,'' imposes a series
of requirements on regulatory agencies, and provides
substantial authority to the Chief Counsel of a little-known
office at the Small Business Administration, that would empower
large companies and undermine the regulatory process that keeps
Americans safe.
Regulatory agencies write rules designed to protect our
food supply, environment, physical infrastructure, and more.
These regulations safeguard the freedoms that all Americans
enjoy. While efforts to ease burdens on small businesses can be
useful, they should not prevent regulators from doing their
jobs in the public interest. The Prove It Act, under the guise
of helping small businesses, would give powerful special
interests an effective veto over whole swathes of regulations.
The bill would task a single official in the Small Business
Administration with responding to petitions to review agency
rules. As structured, the law could allow big trade
associations to game the system and flood the SBA with more
challenges to regulations than it can possibly review under its
current structure. The chaos that would result would subject
important rules to delays and uncertainty while doing nothing
to help small businesses.
II. Concerns
A. BACKGROUND ON THE REGULATORY FLEXIBILITY ACT
The Regulatory Flexibility Act\1\ (``RFA'') requires
agencies to analyze the effects of most proposed rules on small
entities. The agency must prepare an initial regulatory
flexibility analysis when it issues a notice of proposed
rulemaking (``NPRM'') describing ``the impact of the proposed
rule on small entities,''\2\ defined to include small
businesses, small nonprofits, and small governments.\3\ The
initial regulatory flexibility analysis must include an
estimate of how many small entities the rule will impact and
describe ``any significant alternatives'' available to the
agency.\4\ The agency must publish the initial regulatory
flexibility analysis in the Federal Register and transmit a
copy to the Chief Counsel in the Office of Advocacy (the
``Chief Counsel'') at the Small Business Administration
(``SBA'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\5 U.S.C. Sec. 601 et seq.
\2\5 U.S.C. Sec. 603(a).
\3\5 U.S.C. Sec. 601.
\4\5 U.S.C. Sec. 603.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When the agency promulgates its final rule, it must publish
a final regulatory flexibility analysis.\5\ The final
regulatory flexibility analysis must describe the comments it
received in response to the initial regulatory flexibility
analysis, responding to any comments from the Chief Counsel,
and describing the number of impacted small entities and the
effects of the final rule on those small entities.\6\ For
either regulatory flexibility analysis, the law allows the
agency to describe the effects of the proposed rule with ``a
quantifiable or numerical description'' or by ``more general
descriptive statements if quantification is not practicable or
reliable.''\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\5 U.S.C. Sec. 604(a).
\6\5 U.S.C. Sec. 604(a).
\7\5 U.S.C. Sec. 607.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An agency is not required to perform either regulatory
flexibility analysis if the agency head certifies at the time
of the NPRM or at the time of publishing the final rule that
the rule will not ``have a significant economic impact on a
substantial number of small entities.''\8\ The agency must
publish its certification in the Federal Register with ``a
statement providing the factual basis for such certification,''
and provide a copy to the Chief Counsel.\9\ The law also
requires agencies to conduct periodic reviews of all
regulations with significant economic impact on small entities
and determine if they are still needed.\10\ Finally, the law
provides for judicial review of agencies' compliance with its
major terms.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\5 U.S.C. Sec. 605(b).
\9\Id.
\10\5 U.S.C. Sec. 610.
\11\5 U.S.C. Sec. 611.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. THE PROVE IT ACT WOULD GIVE SPECIAL INTERESTS A VETO OVER
REGULATIONS
Congress passed the RFA in 1980 out of concern that uniform
regulations disproportionately burdened small firms.\12\ Rather
than increase the competitiveness of small firms against their
larger rivals, however, the law has instead become another tool
for rent-seeking corporate titans to obstruct the regulatory
process. The Prove It Act would exacerbate the flaws in the
original legislation, giving the biggest companies a powerful
new cudgel to wield against regulations and causing further
harm to the very small entities it purports to help.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Stuart Shapiro & Deanna Moran, The Checkered History of
Regulatory Reform, 19 N.Y.U. J. Legis. & Pub. Pol'y 141, 153-54 (2016)
(describing hearings leading up to passage of the RFA).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill creates an unworkable quasi-judicial process
within the SBA for reviewing agencies' determinations that
regulatory flexibility analyses are not required. Unlike the
original RFA, which only allows small entities to seek judicial
review,\13\ the Prove It Act would also allow an ``organization
representing the interests of small entities'' to file a
petition for review with the Chief Counsel. This addition would
let powerful trade associations like the U.S. Chamber of
Commerce petition the SBA to review a certification if the
organization can claim to represent some small entities
affected by the underlying rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\5 U.S.C. Sec. 611.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Once a petition is filed, the Chief Counsel would have 10
days to determine if the petition warrants a full review. If
the Chief Counsel determines that a full review is required,
the Chief Counsel has a further 30 days to conduct the review
and publish the results. The Chief Counsel would also have
unreviewable discretion to sanction the agency promulgating the
rule by making the final rule inapplicable to small agencies
upon a finding that the agency failed to assist the Chief
Counsel. Moreover, the bill would require agencies to include
indirect economic effects of rules in their regulatory
flexibility analyses, giving petitioners a stronger basis to
argue that any rule would have a significant economic impact on
a substantial number of small entities.
Beyond requiring the Chief Counsel to review petitions
related to new rules, the bill also charges the Chief Counsel
with tracking agencies' completion of mandatory reviews of
existing rules every 10 years. If the Chief Counsel finds that
an agency failed to conduct a required review of a rule, the
Chief Counsel can suspend operation of the rule. The bill would
require the Chief Counsel to conduct such a review
retroactively for every rule issued in the five years prior to
enactment, as well as to all rules after enactment.
The bill thus vests an enormous amount of authority in a
chronically underfunded office within the SBA that has not been
headed by a Senate-confirmed appointee since 2017.\14\ By
opening the door for well-resourced trade associations to
challenge virtually any rule, the bill could end up requiring
the Chief Counsel to review agencies' RFA compliance for many
of the thousands of rules issued each year, to say nothing of
agencies' periodic reviews of existing rules. That will do
little to help small businesses, but for powerful companies
with money to hire well-connected lobbyists, it could prove to
be a windfall.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\See Letter from Chairman Roger Williams and Ranking Member
Nydia M. Velazquez to President Joseph R. Biden (Feb. 16, 2023),
https://smallbusiness.house.gov/uploadedfiles/02.16.2023_-
_letter_to_sba_office__of_advocacy_final.pdf (urging the President to
nominate a Chief Counsel for Advocacy).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During markup, Democrats offered a number of amendments to
address some of the bill's most glaring weaknesses. I offered
three amendments: (1) to strike the provision of the bill
related to indirect costs, which are notoriously unreliable and
nearly impossible to calculate; (2) to strike the retroactive
review provision nullification in the bill; and (3) to exclude
rules related to environmental permits under the Clean Air Act
or the Clean Water Act. Rep. Lucy McBath (D-GA) offered an
amendment to exempt rules related to the health and safety of
children and Rep. Balint (D-VT) offered an amendment to exempt
rules from the National Labor Relations Board. Unfortunately,
each amendment was defeated on party line votes.
III. Conclusion
The Prove It Act is a dangerous proposal that is designed
to hamper and undermine the good and expert work of our public
agencies. It would undermine the effective enforcement of the
laws Congress passes and it would give one small and
underfunded office in the Small Business Administration (SBA)
nearly unchecked veto power over critical rules that protect
public health and safety. This veto power is likely to be
wielded in service of the most well-resourced businesses who
can bend the ear of the SBA and convince them to work on their
behalf rather than the American people.
For all these reasons, I dissent, and I urge my colleagues
to oppose this bill.
Jerrold Nadler,
Ranking Member.
[all]