Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 8337]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 8337) to amend the Federal banking laws to
improve the safety and soundness of the United States banking
system, and for other purposes, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that
the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 12
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 14
Related Hearing.................................................. 15
Committee Consideration.......................................... 15
Committee Votes.................................................. 15
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 18
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 18
Congressional Budget Office Estimates............................ 18
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 18
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 18
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 19
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 19
Earmark Identification........................................... 19
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 19
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 19
Ramseyer......................................................... 22
Minority Views................................................... 169
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Bank Resilience and
Regulatory Improvement Act''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
TITLE I--FINANCIAL INSTITUTION REGULATORY TAILORING ENHANCEMENT
Sec. 101. Increased asset thresholds.
TITLE II--BANK FAILURE PREVENTION
Sec. 201. Complete record on an application.
TITLE III--STRESS TESTING ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY
Sec. 301. Rulemaking related to stress capital buffer requirements.
Sec. 302. Rulemaking relating to stress testing.
Sec. 303. GAO report.
TITLE IV--BANK SUPERVISION APPEALS IMPROVEMENT
Sec. 401. Timeliness of examinations and required permission,
regulatory, and reporting guidance.
Sec. 402. Update of independent intra-agency appellate process for
reviewing material supervisory determinations.
Sec. 403. Review of resolution actions resulting in a material loss.
TITLE V--REVIEW OF DISCOUNT WINDOW OPERATIONS
Sec. 501. Review of discount window operations.
TITLE VI--SMALL BANK HOLDING COMPANY RELIEF
Sec. 601. Changes required to the Small Bank Holding Company and
Savings and Loan Holding Company Policy Statement.
TITLE I--FINANCIAL INSTITUTION REGULATORY TAILORING ENHANCEMENT
SEC. 101. INCREASED ASSET THRESHOLDS.
(a) Bureau Supervision.--Section 1025(a) of the Consumer Financial
Protection Act of 2010 (12 U.S.C. 5515) is amended by striking
``$10,000,000,000'' each place it occurs and inserting
``$50,000,000,000''.
(b) Durbin Amendment Requirements.--Section 921(a)(6) of the
Electronic Fund Transfer Act (15 U.S.C. 1693o-2(a)(6)) is amended by
striking ``$10,000,000,000'' and inserting ``$50,000,000,000''.
(c) Volker Rule Requirements.--Section 13(h)(1)(B)(i) of the Bank
Holding Company Act of 1956 (12 U.S.C. 1851(h)(1)(B)(i)) is amended by
striking ``$10,000,000,000'' and inserting ``$50,000,000,000''.
(d) Qualified Mortgage Requirements.--Section 129C(b)(F)(i) of the
Truth in Lending Act (15 U.S.C. 1639c(b)(F)(i)) is amended by striking
``$10,000,000,000'' and inserting ``$50,000,000,000''.
(e) Leverage and Risk-Based Capital Requirements.--Section
201(a)(3)(A) of the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer
Protection Act (12 U.S.C. 5371 note (a)(3)(A)) is amended by striking
``$10,000,000,000'' and inserting ``$50,000,000,000''.
TITLE II--BANK FAILURE PREVENTION
SEC. 201. COMPLETE RECORD ON AN APPLICATION.
(a) Bank Holding Companies.--Section 3(b)(1) of the Bank Holding
Company Act of 1956 (12 U.S.C. 1842(b)(1)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``Upon receiving'' and inserting the
following:
``(A) In general.--Upon receiving'';
(2) by striking ``required'' and inserting ``acquired'';
(3) by striking ``In the event of the failure of the Board to
act on any application for approval under this section within
the ninety-one-day period which begins on the date of
submission to the Board of the complete record on that
application, the application shall be deemed to have been
granted.''; and
(4) by adding at the end the following:
``(B) Complete record on an application.--
``(i) Notice to applicant.--Not later than 30 days
after the date on which the Board receives an
application for approval under this section, the Board
shall transmit to the applicant a letter that either--
``(I) confirms the record on the application
is complete; or
``(II) details all additional information
that is required for the record on that
application to be complete.
``(ii) Extension of notice.--Notwithstanding clause
(i), the Board may, if an application is complex,
extend the 30-day period described under clause (i) for
an additional 30 days.
``(iii) Receipt of response; deeming of complete
record.--Upon receipt of a response from an applicant
to a notice requesting additional information described
under clause (i)(II), the record on the application
shall be deemed complete unless the Board--
``(I) determines that the applicant's
response was materially deficient; and
``(II) not later than 30 days after the date
on which the Board received the response,
provides the applicant a detailed notice
describing the deficiencies.
``(iv) Treatment of third-party information.--In
determining whether the record on an application is
complete, the Board may take into account only
information provided by the applicant, and may not base
the determination of completeness on any information
(including reports, views, or recommendations) provided
by third parties.
``(C) Deadline for determination.--
``(i) In general.--Notwithstanding subparagraphs (A)
and (B), the Board shall grant or deny an application
submitted under this section not later than 90 days
after the date on which the application was initially
submitted to the Board, regardless of whether the
record on such initial application was complete.
``(ii) Failure to make a determination.--If the Board
does not grant or deny an application within the time
period described under clause (i), such application
shall be deemed to have been granted.
``(iii) Tolling of period.--The Board may at any time
extend the deadline described under clause (i) at the
request of the applicant, but may not extend the
deadline more than 30 days past the deadline described
under clause (i).''.
(b) Savings and Loan Holding Companies.--Section 10(e) of the Home
Owners' Loan Act (12 U.S.C. 1467a(e)) is amended--
(1) in paragraph (2), by striking ``, and shall render a
decision within 90 days after submission to the Board of the
complete record on the application'';
(2) by redesignating paragraph (7) as paragraph (9); and
(3) by inserting after paragraph (6) the following:
``(7) Complete record on an application.--
``(A) Notice to applicant.--Not later than 30 days
after the date on which the Board receives an
application for approval under this subsection, the
Board shall transmit to the applicant a letter that
either--
``(i) confirms the record on the application
is complete; or
``(ii) details all additional information
that is required for the record on that
application to be complete.
``(B) Extension of notice.--Notwithstanding
subparagraph (A), the Board may, if an application is
complex, extend the 30-day period described under
subparagraph (A) for an additional 30 days.
``(C) Receipt of response; deeming of complete
record.--Upon receipt of a response from an applicant
to a notice requesting additional information described
under subparagraph (A)(ii), the record on the
application shall be deemed complete unless the Board--
``(i) determines that the applicant's
response was materially deficient; and
``(ii) not later than 30 days after the date
on which the Board received the response,
provides the applicant a detailed notice
describing the deficiencies.
``(D) Treatment of third-party information.--In
determining whether the record on an application is
complete, the Board may take into account only
information provided by the applicant, and may not base
the determination of completeness on any information
(including reports, views, or recommendations) provided
by third parties.
``(8) Deadline for determination.--
``(A) In general.--Notwithstanding any other
provision of this subsection, the Board shall grant or
deny an application submitted under this subsection not
later than 90 days after the date on which the
application was initially submitted to the Board,
regardless of whether the record on such initial
application was complete.
``(B) Failure to make a determination.--If the Board
does not grant or deny an application within the time
period described under subparagraph (A), such
application shall be deemed to have been granted.
``(C) Tolling of period.--The Board may at any time
extend the deadline described under subparagraph (A) at
the request of the applicant, but may not extend the
deadline more than 30 days past the deadline described
under subparagraph (A).''.
(c) Insured Depository Institutions.--Section 18(c) of the Federal
Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1828(c)) is amended by adding at the
end the following:
``(14) Complete Record on an Application.--
``(A) Notice to applicant.--Not later than 30 days after the
date on which the responsible agency receives a merger
application for approval under this subsection, the responsible
agency shall transmit to the applicant a letter that either--
``(i) confirms the record on the application is
complete; or
``(ii) details all additional information that is
required for the record on that application to be
complete.
``(B) Extension of notice.--Notwithstanding subparagraph (A),
the responsible agency may, if an application is unusually
complex, extend the 30-day period described under subparagraph
(A) for an additional 30 days.
``(C) Receipt of response; deeming of complete record.--Upon
receipt of a response from an applicant to a notice requesting
additional information described under subparagraph (A)(ii),
the record on the application shall be deemed complete unless
the responsible agency--
``(i) determines that the applicant's response was
materially deficient; and
``(ii) not later than 30 days after the date on which
the responsible agency received the response, provides
the applicant a detailed notice describing the
deficiencies.
``(D) Treatment of third-party information.--In determining
whether the record on an application is complete, the
responsible agency may take into account only information
provided by the applicant, and may not base the determination
of completeness on any information (including reports, views,
or recommendations) provided by third parties.
``(15) Deadline for Determination.--
``(A) In general.--Notwithstanding any other provision of
this subsection, the responsible agency shall grant or deny a
merger application submitted under this subsection not later
than 90 days after the date on which the application was
initially submitted to the responsible agency, regardless of
whether the record on such initial application was complete.
``(B) Failure to make a determination.--If the responsible
agency does not grant or deny an application within the time
period described under subparagraph (A), such application shall
be deemed to have been granted.
``(C) Tolling of period.--The responsible agency may at any
time extend the deadline described under subparagraph (A) at
the request of the applicant, but may not extend the deadline
more than 30 days past the deadline described under
subparagraph (A).''.
TITLE III--STRESS TESTING ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY
SEC. 301. RULEMAKING RELATED TO STRESS CAPITAL BUFFER REQUIREMENTS.
(a) In General.--Not later than 90 days after the date of the
enactment of this section, the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System (in this title referred to as the ``Board'') shall issue
a rule to establish any models, assumptions, formulas, or other
decisional methodologies that are used to determine any component or
subcomponent of the stress capital buffer requirement for a bank
holding company.
(b) Changes.--The Board may only make changes to the rule issued
under subsection (a) through notice and comment rulemaking.
(c) Stress Capital Buffer Requirement Defined.--The term ``stress
capital buffer requirement'' has the meaning given the term in section
225.8(c) of title 12 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 302. RULEMAKING RELATING TO STRESS TESTING.
(a) In General.--Beginning in the first calendar year beginning after
the date of the enactment of this section, the Board shall, not less
than 30 days before conducting a stress test pursuant to section 165(i)
of the Financial Stability Act of 2010, issue a rule to establish each
scenario to be used in such stress test.
(b) Prohibition.--The Board may not, by rule or otherwise, subject
any nonbank financial company to a climate-related stress test using
the authority provided in section 165(i) of the Financial Stability Act
of 2010.
SEC. 303. GAO REPORT.
(a) In General.--The Comptroller General of the United States shall,
every 3 years, conduct a study and submit a report to the Congress with
respect to the stress tests conducted by the Board under section 165(i)
of the Financial Stability Act of 2010 in the 3 most recent calendar
years.
(b) Contents.--The report submitted to the Congress under subsection
(a) shall consider the effectiveness of the stress tests in
evaluating--
(1) the safety and soundness of the nonbank financial
institutions subjected to stress tests;
(2) the stability of the United States financial system.
TITLE IV--BANK SUPERVISION APPEALS IMPROVEMENT
SEC. 401. TIMELINESS OF EXAMINATIONS AND REQUIRED PERMISSION,
REGULATORY, AND REPORTING GUIDANCE.
(a) Exit Interview Requirement; Timeliness of Examinations.--
(1) Insured depository institutions.--Section 10(d) of the
Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1820(d)) is amended by
adding at the end the following:
``(11) Examination timeliness.--The appropriate Federal
banking agency shall complete any examination of an insured
depository institution within 270 days of commencing the
examination, except that such period may be extended by the
appropriate Federal banking agency by providing written notice
to the insured depository institution describing with
particularity the reasons that a longer period is needed.
``(12) Exit interview requirement.--Within 30 days of
completing an examination, the appropriate Federal banking
agency shall conduct an exit interview with the insured
depository institution's senior management and board of
directors.
``(13) Timeliness of examination reports.--
``(A) Final examination report.--With respect to an
examination of an insured depository institution by an
appropriate Federal banking agency, the appropriate
Federal banking agency shall provide a final
examination report to the insured depository
institution not later than 60 days after the later of--
``(i) the exit interview for the examination;
or
``(ii) the provision of additional
information by the insured depository
institution relating to the examination.
``(B) Examination materials.--Upon the request of an
insured depository institution, the appropriate Federal
banking agency shall include with a final examination
report an appendix listing all materials relied upon by
the agency in support of all material supervisory
determinations.
``(C) Material supervisory determination defined.--In
this paragraph, the term `material supervisory
determination' has the meaning given such term in
section 309(i) of the Riegle Community Development and
Regulatory Improvement Act of 1994.''.
(2) Insured credit unions.
Purpose and Summary
Introduced on May 10, 2024, by Representative Andy Barr,
H.R. 8337, the Bank Resilience and Regulatory Improvement Act,
is a compilation of six previously introduced bills.
Title I--H.R. 6398, the Financial Institution Regulatory Tailoring
Enhancement Act, was introduced on November 14, 2023, by Rep.
Andy Barr (R-KY)
Title I would increase certain asset thresholds for
community bank regulatory relief to $50 billion from $10
billion.
Title II--H.R. 7403, the Bank Failure Prevention Act of 2024, was
introduced on February 16, 2024, by Rep. Andy Barr (R-KY)
Title II would improve the bank merger application process
by setting clear timelines and improving predictability. The
title would require the Federal Reserve to promptly inform
applicants whether their application is complete and to either
approve or deny an application within 90 days of filing.
Title III--H.R. 8287, the Stress Testing Accountability and
Transparency Act, was introduced on May 8, 2024, by Rep. Andy
Barr (R-KY)
Title III would require the Federal Reserve to subject to
notice-and-comment rulemaking both the formulas used to
calculate the Stress Capital Buffer (SCB) and prohibit the
Federal Reserve from altering the SCB calculation without a new
rulemaking. The Federal Reserve would also be required to
subject the annual stress test scenarios to the notice-and-
comment rulemaking process on an annual basis. In addition, the
title would direct the Government Accountability Office (GAO)
to conduct a study and report to Congress on the stress testing
scenarios every three years.
Title IV--H.R. 8264, the Bank Supervision Appeals Improvement Act, was
introduced on May 7, 2024, by Rep. Andy Barr (R-KY)
Title IV would make the following improvements to the
federal banking agencies' supervisory appeals processes: (i)
encourage supervised entities to appeal material supervisory
determinations with which they disagree; (ii) ensure that
supervised entities receive due process; (iii) ensure that the
processes remain efficient and affordable for institutions of
all sizes; and (iv) clarify that supervised entities may seek
judicial review when they are dissatisfied with the result of
the appeal process. The title would also improve examination
timing and require the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation's
(FDIC) Inspector General to review the FDIC's resolution
activity whenever there is a material loss to the Deposit
Insurance Fund (DIF).
Title V--H.R. 8288, the Bringing the Discount Window into the 21st
Century Act, was introduced on May 8, 2024, by Rep. Andy Barr
(R-KY)
Title V would require the Federal Reserve to review its
discount window operations, seek public comment on discount
window operations, and to develop and implement a plan to
address any identified deficiencies. The Federal Reserve would
be required to submit a report on its review and plan to
Congress. Prior to submitting the report, the Federal Reserve
would be required to solicit feedback from both the Inspector
General of the Federal Reserve System (OIG) and the GAO. The
Federal Reserve Chair would be required to testify regarding
the report. In addition, the Federal Reserve would be required
to submit annual reports on the effectiveness of discount
window operations. The OIG would be required to submit an
annual report on the Federal Reserve's progress in implementing
its remediation plan.
Title VI--H.R. 4346, the Small Bank Holding Company Relief Act of 2023,
was introduced on June 23, 2024, by Rep. Alex Mooney (R-WVA)
Title VI requires the Federal Reserve Board to raise the
consolidated asset threshold under which a specified policy
statement applies to small bank holding companies. The policy
statement allows small bank holding companies to operate with
higher debt levels than would be allowed for larger bank
holding companies.
Background and Need for Legislation
Title I: There has been a growing trend of community banks
merging, being acquired, or simply closing their doors
partially because of increased costs related to compliance and
regulatory burdens. Rural counties continue to use bank
branches at higher rates than other groups.\1\ Although many
community members can access accounts online and through mobile
banking, the Federal Reserve found that not all needs of rural
consumers and small businesses, such as obtaining safety
deposit boxes or making of cash deposits and withdrawals, can
be met by online services.\2\ Many communities report that
following a branch closure, they also lose financial and
community resources including financial advisors and civic
leadership from bank employees. These losses leave communities
with unanswered questions and potential financial-resource
deficiencies. Continued bank closures in rural communities
throughout America place customers and small businesses without
sufficient and convenient access to financial services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Perspectives
from Main Street: Bank Branch Access in Rural Communities, (November
2019), https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/files/bank-branch-
access-in-rural-communities.pdf.
\2\FDIC, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked
Households, https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html
at 1, 13 (October 2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title II: It takes far too long for the Federal banking
agencies to approve any merger. Trying to make a slow and
opaque process even slower and more opaque makes little sense.
Moreover, a drawn-out merger review process presents
operational challenges for banks that may find it difficult to
retain or hire talent while waiting for the merger to be
completed. Clear expectations and timelines surrounding the
review process are critical so banks can make an informed
decision: whether to continue devoting resources and incurring
costs when approval is likely; or withdraw an application and
reduce expenses when it is not.
Title III: Each stress test model used by the Federal
Reserve involves mathematical formulae derived from statistical
models. These models are then applied to the portfolios of each
firm subject to the stress test. Even though the stress tests
generate binding capital requirements in the SCB, the Federal
Reserve has failed to publish, let alone publish for notice and
comment, the models, mathematical formulae, and other
decisional methodologies that it uses to calculate firms'
legally binding stress capital buffer requirements. Instead, it
keeps the mathematical formulae and derivation of the SCB
calculation secret.
Like the stress testing models, the annual stress test
scenarios are essential elements of the methodology by which
the Federal Reserve determines SCB requirements for subject
firms. Even small variations in those scenarios may result in
large changes to the resulting SCB requirement to which a firm
is legally bound. Unlike the stress test models, the Federal
Reserve publishes its stress testing scenarios each year.
However, it does not subject the scenarios to notice-and-
comment rulemaking.
Title IV: Under the Riegle Community Development and
Regulatory Improvement Act of 1994, each Federal banking
agency, among other things, is required to establish a process
for supervised institutions to appeal material supervisory
determinations (i.e., significant exam findings, such as
matters requiring attention). Although each agency established
a process in the 1990s, supervised institutions have rarely
availed themselves of the process. In general, industry
questions whether the established processes allow for
meaningful reviews.
Title V: During the March 2023 banking turmoil, there were
inefficiencies in the Federal Reserve's discount window
operations. In particular, during the SVB and Signature Bank
bank runs, the banks had difficulty obtaining discount window
advances, both because of antiquated processes and issues
surrounding priority liens on collateral previously pledged to
Federal Home Loan Banks. Federal Reserve Chair Powell described
the discount window operations during March 2023 as ``clunky.''
Title VI: In the decade following enactment of the Dodd-
Frank Act, banks and bank holding companies have been subject
to a litany of new and onerous banking regulations. These
regulations have disproportionately impacted smaller financial
institutions that often lack the resources of larger firms,
making them less competitive.
Related Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop H.R. 8337:
The Subcommittee on Financial Institutions and Monetary
Policy held a hearing on June 6, 2023, titled ``Uncertain Debt
Management: Treasury markets and Financial Institutions.'' The
Subcommittee on Financial Institutions and Monetary Policy held
a hearing on May 1, 2024, titled ``Merger Policies of the
Federal Banking Agencies.'' The Committee on Financial Services
held a hearing on May 15, 2024, titled ``Oversight of
Prudential Regulators.''
Committee Consideration
The Committee on Financial Services met in open session on
May 16, 2014, and ordered H.R. 8337 as amended to be reported
favorably to the House by a recorded vote of 24 ayes to 22 nays
(Record vote no. FC-144), a quorum being present. Before the
question was called to order the bill favorably reported, the
Committee adopted an amendment in the nature of a substitute
offered by Mr. Barr by voice vote.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee to list the record votes
on the order to report legislation and amendments thereto. H.R.
8337 as amended was ordered reported favorably to the House by
a recorded vote of 24 ayes to 22 nays (Record vote no. FC-144),
a quorum being present.
An amendment offered by Mr. Foster, no. 5, was not agreed
to by a voice vote, a quorum being present.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Committee Oversight Findings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee, based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.R. 8337 is to improve
bank regulation and supervision to promote a diverse and
vibrant banking sector. This bill increases asset thresholds to
reflect the different risk profiles posed by smaller banks as
compared to larger banks. This bill amends the stress testing
process to ensure that there is transparency, accountability,
and public participation in the design and execution of stress
tests. This bill amends the bank merger review process to
provide definitive timelines, helping provide certainty and
clarity for banks and investors. This bill revises the process
by which banks can challenge supervisory findings, ensuring
that banks have a meaningful avenue for challenging examination
ratings and findings. This bill requires the Federal Reserve to
review and improve its discount window operations, to ensure
that it is accessible to banks throughout the economic cycle.
This bill also requires the Federal Reserve to amend its small
bank holding company policy statement to reflect asset growth
within the banking sector.
Congressional Budget Office Estimates
The Committee has requested but not received a cost
estimate from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office.
However, pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee will adopt as its own the cost estimate by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office once it has been
prepared.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
The Committee has requested but not received an estimate
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office. However,
pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, once an estimate has been prepared by
the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, as required by
section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1973, the
Committee will adopt as its own the estimate of new budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee has requested but not received from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office an estimate of the
Federal mandates pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act. The Committee will adopt the estimate once
it has been prepared by the Director.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Earmark Identification
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Short Title; Table of Contents
TITLE I--FINANCIAL INSTITUTION REGULATORY TAILORING ENHANCEMENT
Sec. 101. Increased asset thresholds
This section amends the Consumer Financial Protection Act,
the Electronic Fund Transfer Act, the Bank Holding Company Act,
the Truth in Lending Act, and the Economic Growth, Regulatory
Relief, and Consumer Protection Act to increase asset
thresholds from $10 billion to $50 billion.
TITLE II--BANK FAILURE PREVENTION
Sec. 201. Complete record on an application
This section requires the Federal Reserve Board to grant or
deny applications submitted by bank holding companies within 90
days after the application was initially submitted. This
section also implements similar requirements on the Federal
Reserve Board for applications submitted by savings and loan
holding companies.
This section also requires the Federal banking agencies to
grant or deny merger applications submitted by insured
depository institutions within 90 days after the application
was initially submitted.
TITLE III--STRESS TESTING ACCOUNTABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY
Sec. 301. Rulemaking related to stress capital buffer requirements
This section requires the Federal Reserve Board to issue a
rule within 90 days to establish any models, assumptions,
formulas, or other decision methodologies that are used to
determine any component or subcomponent of the Stress Capital
Buffer for a bank holding company.
This section further requires that the Federal Reserve
Board use notice and comment rulemaking to make any future
amendments to the rule issued to establish the methodology for
calculating the Stress Capital Buffer.
Sec. 302. Rulemaking relating to stress testing
This section requires that the Federal Reserve Board, at
least 30 days prior to conducting the annual stress tests
required by section 165 of the Dodd Frank Act, issue a rule to
establish each scenario to be used in the stress test.
This section further prohibits the Federal Reserve Board
from using section 165 of the Dodd Frank Act to subject any
covered financial institution to a climate-related stress
scenario.
Sec. 303. GAO report
This section requires the Comptroller General of the United
States (GAO) to conduct a study and submit a report to Congress
on the Federal Reserve Board's stress tests every three years.
The GAO is directed to: (i) evaluate whether the stress tests
are sufficiently robust and promote preparedness, and (ii) to
consider whether the stress tests adequately identify salient
risks to the safety and soundness of the covered financial
institutions subject to stress tests and to the stability of
the U.S. financial system.
TITLE IV--BANK SUPERVISION APPEALS IMPROVEMENT
Sec. 401. Timeliness of examinations and required permission,
regulatory, and reporting guidance
This section amends the Federal Deposit Insurance Act to
require that Federal banking agencies complete examinations of
insured depository institutions within 270 days of commencing
the examination, or to provide a detailed, written notice
explaining any delay.
This section further amends the Federal Deposit Insurance
Act to require the Federal banking agencies to conduct an exit
interview following an examination, to provide the examination
report in a timely manner, and to provide, upon request, an
appendix listing all the materials that examiners relied on in
making any material supervisory determinations.
This section further amends the Federal Deposit Insurance
Act to require that the Federal banking agencies provide timely
responses to requests for written determinations by the Federal
banking agencies as to the permissibility of certain actions,
interpretations of law or regulation, or the interpretation of
accounting principles.
This section amends the Federal Credit Union Act to
establish parallel requirements for the National Credit Union
Administration Board.
Sec. 402. Update of independent intra-agency appellate process for
reviewing material supervisory determinations
This section amends the Riegle Act to update the intra-
agency appellate processes for disputing material supervisory
determinations.
This section requires each Federal banking agency and the
National Credit Union Administration Board to establish within
their agency an Office of Supervisory Appeals that is tasked
with running the intra-agency appellate process. Each agency is
further required to establish a pool of officials to hear
intra-agency appeals of material supervisory determinations.
The section establishes three categories of officials who are
to be appointed, including individuals with financial services
regulatory experience, officials with private sector
experience, and officials recommended by supervised entities or
their trade associations.
This section requires that each agency update their process
to allow supervised institutions to first appeal material
supervisory determinations to the agency's head of supervision
and then to appeal to three-official panels, who would conduct
a de novo review of the determination. The supervised entities
would have the right to an informal hearing before the three-
official panel but would not be subject to cross-examination or
subject to rules of evidence. Appealing supervised institutions
would have the right to submit exceptions to the three-official
panel's decision to the head of the appropriate Federal banking
agency, who in turn makes the final agency decision.
This section further authorizes supervised institutions to
seek judicial review of final agency decisions of material
supervisory determinations.
This section requires that each agency publish appeals
decisions, with identifying information redacted to protect the
identity of the appealing institutions.
Sec. 403. Review of resolution actions resulting in a material loss
This section requires the Federal Deposit Insurance
Corporation Inspector General to review the Corporation's
resolution of any institution that results in a material loss
to the deposit insurance fund. This section requires the
Inspector General to issue a written report to the Corporation
and Congress containing the results of the review and any
recommendations for preventing a future material loss. This
section also requires the Inspector General to testify before
the House Financial Services Committee and the Senate Banking
Committee whenever the Inspector General concludes that a
resolution could have been carried out in a manner to avoid a
material loss.
TITLE V--REVIEW OF DISCOUNT WINDOW OPERATIONS
Sec. 501. Review of discount window operations
This section amends the Federal Reserve Act to require the
Federal Reserve Board to conduct a review of the discount
window lending programs of the Federal Reserve banks. The
review would be required to start within 60 days of enactment
and be completed within 240 days.
This section further requires that the Federal Reserve
Board, in conducting the review, provide an opportunity for the
public to comment on the effectiveness of discount window
operations and to offer suggestions for improving operations.
This section further requires that after completing the
required review and considering any public comments received,
the Federal Reserve Board develop a written plan to remediate
any identified deficiencies or areas for enhancement.
This section further requires that the Federal Reserve
Board prepare a report to Congress, within 365 days of
enactment, that details the findings of the review and the
required remediation plan. The Federal Reserve Board must
submit a copy of the proposed report to the Comptroller General
and the Federal Reserve Inspector General to obtain feedback.
The Federal Reserve Board must vote to approve the report.
This section further requires that the Federal Reserve
Chair testify before the House Financial Services Committee and
the Senate Banking Committee on the report.
This section further requires the Federal Reserve Board to
submit an annual report to Congress containing a review of the
effectiveness of discount window operations. The Federal
Reserve Inspector General must submit an annual report to
Congress on the progress of the Federal Reserve Board in
implementing the remediation plan.
The section further authorizes that any required report may
be submitted with a confidential annex that details any
cybersecurity deficiencies or any deficiencies, which if made
public, could cause financial instability.
TITLE VI--SMALL BANK HOLDING COMPANY RELIEF
Sec. 601. Changes required to the Small Bank Holding Company and
Savings and Loan Holding Company Policy Statement
This section requires the Federal Reserve Board to amend
appendix C to part 225 of title 12, Code of Federal
Regulations--the ``Small Bank Holding Company and Savings and
Loan Holding Company Policy Statement''--to raise the asset
threshold to $10 billion.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION ACT OF 2010
* * * * * * *
TITLE X--BUREAU OF CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION
* * * * * * *
Subtitle B--General Powers of the Bureau
* * * * * * *
SEC. 1025. SUPERVISION OF VERY LARGE BANKS, SAVINGS ASSOCIATIONS, AND
CREDIT UNIONS.
(a) Scope of Coverage.--This section shall apply to any
covered person that is--
(1) an insured depository institution with total
assets of more than [$10,000,000,000] $50,000,000,000
and any affiliate thereof; or
(2) an insured credit union with total assets of more
than [$10,000,000,000] $50,000,000,000 and any
affiliate thereof.
(b) Supervision.--
(1) In general.--The Bureau shall have exclusive
authority to require reports and conduct examinations
on a periodic basis of persons described in subsection
(a) for purposes of--
(A) assessing compliance with the
requirements of Federal consumer financial
laws;
(B) obtaining information about the
activities subject to such laws and the
associated compliance systems or procedures of
such persons; and
(C) detecting and assessing associated risks
to consumers and to markets for consumer
financial products and services.
(2) Coordination.--To minimize regulatory burden, the
Bureau shall coordinate its supervisory activities with
the supervisory activities conducted by prudential
regulators and the State bank regulatory authorities,
including consultation regarding their respective
schedules for examining such persons described in
subsection (a) and requirements regarding reports to be
submitted by such persons.
(3) Use of existing reports.--The Bureau shall, to
the fullest extent possible, use--
(A) reports pertaining to a person described
in subsection (a) that have been provided or
required to have been provided to a Federal or
State agency; and
(B) information that has been reported
publicly.
(4) Preservation of authority.--Nothing in this title
may be construed as limiting the authority of the
Director to require reports from a person described in
subsection (a), as permitted under paragraph (1),
regarding information owned or under the control of
such person, regardless of whether such information is
maintained, stored, or processed by another person.
(5) Reports of tax law noncompliance.--The Bureau
shall provide the Commissioner of Internal Revenue with
any report of examination or related information
identifying possible tax law noncompliance.
(c) Primary Enforcement Authority.--
(1) The bureau to have primary enforcement
authority.--To the extent that the Bureau and another
Federal agency are authorized to enforce a Federal
consumer financial law, the Bureau shall have primary
authority to enforce that Federal consumer financial
law with respect to any person described in subsection
(a).
(2) Referral.--Any Federal agency, other than the
Federal Trade Commission, that is authorized to enforce
a Federal consumer financial law may recommend, in
writing, to the Bureau that the Bureau initiate an
enforcement proceeding with respect to a person
described in subsection (a), as the Bureau is
authorized to do by that Federal consumer financial
law.
(3) Backup enforcement authority of other federal
agency.--If the Bureau does not, before the end of the
120-day period beginning on the date on which the
Bureau receives a recommendation under paragraph (2),
initiate an enforcement proceeding, the other agency
referred to in paragraph (2) may initiate an
enforcement proceeding, including performing follow up
supervisory and support functions incidental thereto,
to assure compliance with such proceeding.
(d) Service Providers.--A service provider to a person
described in subsection (a) shall be subject to the authority
of the Bureau under this section, to the same extent as if the
Bureau were an appropriate Federal banking agency under section
7(c) of the Bank Service Company Act 12 U.S.C. 1867(c). In
conducting any examination or requiring any report from a
service provider subject to this subsection, the Bureau shall
coordinate with the appropriate prudential regulator.
(e) Simultaneous and Coordinated Supervisory Action.--
(1) Examinations.--A prudential regulator and the
Bureau shall, with respect to each insured depository
institution, insured credit union, or other covered
person described in subsection (a) that is supervised
by the prudential regulator and the Bureau,
respectively--
(A) coordinate the scheduling of examinations
of the insured depository institution, insured
credit union, or other covered person described
in sub
Minority Views
We oppose H.R. 8337, which draws the wrong lessons from the
regional bank failures from last year and represents a
dangerous rollback of critical safeguards designed to protect
consumers, maintain stability in our financial system, and
promote fair competition in the marketplace. We agree that it
is important that the regulatory framework be risk-based and
appropriately focused on significant financial risks. However,
it is equally important that basic safeguards and oversight
remain in place so consumers are protected and bank failures do
not turn into larger problems.
This bill proposes several exemptions from basic banking
rules and with little evidence to justify such a change in
policy. For example, the bill would raise a number of exemption
thresholds by 500%, from $10 billion to $50 billion, even
though 97% of all banks are already exempt from things like
CFPB supervision. The bill would also exempt many banks from
the Durbin amendment, which curbs debit card interchange fees
to keep costs down for consumers.
Moreover, instead of including provisions to ensure
regulators can quickly escalate unaddressed safety and
soundness issues that examiners find, this bill will make it
easier for large banks like Silicon Valley Bank to appeal and
challenge those supervisory findings. This bill will make it
harder for banking supervisors to do their job to promote
safety and soundness.
This is also an anti-competitive bill that will make big
banks even bigger, resulting in higher prices for consumers,
more closures of bank branches, fewer loans for small
businesses, and fewer community banks. Instead of addressing
the rubber-stamping problem that we've seen in recent years,
with nearly all bank merger applications being approved, this
bill will accelerate bank consolidation by forcing regulators
to render a decision on mergers even before they have all the
information to do so.
Reducing the scrutiny of mergers as H.R. 8337 does will
increase the cost and reduce the availability of services that
consumers need. In places across the country, we've seen bank
mergers lead to branch closures--making it even harder,
particularly for low-income consumers, to access banking
services. One study examining banking deserts that were created
as a result of industry consolidation between 2008-2016, showed
these deserts disproportionally impacted people of color, with
25% of rural branch closures occurring in majority-minority
census tracts.
Furthermore, the largest credit card companies charge
consumers higher interest rates compared to smaller credit card
companies, resulting in many consumers paying $400 to $500 more
every year in additional financing costs for effectively the
same service. Small businesses suffer, too. For instance, fewer
banks mean lending declines and for those who are able to
secure credit, it becomes more expensive and the average loan
size shrinks.
While we object to many of the provisions in the bill,
there is work to be done to address problems exposed by the
significant and sudden failures of Silicon Valley Bank,
Signature Bank, and First Republic Bank last year. For example,
there are a couple of targeted provisions focused on improving
stress testing and the functionality of the Fed's discount
window that we could find common ground on together on. To that
end, Rep. Bill Foster (D-IL) offered an amendment with some
improvements to these sections, though Republicans rejected the
amendment by voice vote.
Moreover, there was a substitute amendment offered by
Ranking Member Maxine Waters (D-CA), Rep. Brad Sherman (D-CA),
Rep. Al Green (D-TX), Rep. Stephen Lynch (D-MA), Rep. Sean
Casten (D-IL), Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-MI), and Rep. Brittany
Pettersen (D-CO) that would replace H.R. 8337 with a set of
commonsense reforms to enhance bank executive accountability,
improve stress testing, shield community banks from paying for
large bank failures, and ensure a competitive bidding process
for failed banks. It would also require banking regulators to
establish a supervisory framework to ensure compliance problems
are properly escalated and addressed promptly; ensure more
public input on bank merger reviews, especially for large bank
mergers; and extend CARES Act provisions so thousands of small
credit unions have access to emergency liquidity through NCUA's
Central Liquidity Facility (CLF).
While Committee Democrats amendments were rejected, we
would note some of the reforms we offered have been advancing
through the Senate with bipartisan support. While we oppose
H.R. 8337, we stand ready to work with Republicans to advance
sensible reforms that promote safety and soundness, fair
competition, and ensure the stability of our financial system.
More than 220 consumer advocate and retailer organizations
oppose H.R. 8337, including Americans for Financial Reform,
Center for Responsible Lending, Consumer Federation of America,
National Consumer Law Center (on behalf of its low-income
clients), Public Citizen, American Beverage Licensees, American
Booksellers Association, Coalition of Franchisee Associations,
Energy Marketers of America, FMI--The Food Industry
Association, Franchisee Business Services, Independent
Restaurant Coalition, International Franchise Association,
Middle Atlantic College Store Association, National Association
of Convenience Stores, National Association of College Stores,
National Association of Theatre Owners, National Franchisee
Association, National Grocers Association, National Lumber &
Building Material Dealers Association, National Restaurant
Association, National Retail Federation, National Small
Business Association (NSBA), Northwest College Bookstore
Association, Retail Industry Leaders Association, Workplace
Solutions Association, Mid-Atlantic Petroleum Distributors'
Association, New England Convenience Store & Energy Marketer
Association, Northeast Campus Stores Association, Rocky
Mountain Skyline Bookstore Association, SAASOA, Southwest
College Bookstore Association, Tri-State Bookstore Association
(MN, ND, SD), Alabama Grocers Association, Alabama Retail
Association, Petroleum & Convenience Marketers of Alabama
(P&CMA), Alaska Fuel Storage & Handlers Alliance, Inc. (AFSHA),
Arizona Petroleum Marketers Association (APMA), Arizona
Retailers Association, Arkansas Grocers and Retail Merchants
Association, Arkansas Oil Marketers Association (AOMA),
California Fuels + Convenience Alliance, Colorado Petroleum
Marketers and Convenience Store Association, Colorado Retail
Council, Connecticut Energy Marketers Association (CEMA),
Connecticut Food Association, Delaware Association of Chain
Drug Stores, Delaware Food Industry Council, Florida Petroleum
Marketers Association, Inc., Georgia Food Industry Association,
Georgia Oilmen's Association, Hawaii Energy Marketers
Association, Hawaii Food Industry Association, Idaho Petroleum
Marketers and Convenience Store Association, Idaho Retailers
Association, Illinois Fuel & Retail Association, Illinois
Retail Merchants Association, Indiana Food & Fuel Association,
Indiana Retail Council, FuelIowa, Iowa Grocery Industry
Association, Iowa Retail Federation, Fuel True: Independent
Energy and Convenience, Kentucky Grocers & Convenience Store
Association, Kentucky Petroleum Marketers Association, Kentucky
Retail Federation, Louisiana Oil Marketers and Convenience
Store Association, Louisiana Retailers Association, Maine
Energy Marketers Association, Maine Grocers & Food Producers
Association, Retail Association of Maine , Maryland Retailers
Alliance, Massachusetts Food Association, Retailers Association
of Massachusetts, Michigan Association of College Stores,
Michigan Petroleum Association/Michigan Association of
Convenience Stores, Michigan Retailers Association, Fueling
Minnesota, Minnesota Grocers Association, Mississippi Petroleum
Marketers & Convenience Stores Association, Missouri Grocers
Association, Missouri Petroleum & Convenience Association,
Missouri Retailers Association, Montana Equipment Dealers
Association, Montana Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store
Association, Montana Restaurant Association, Montana Retail
Association, Nebraska Grocery Industry Association, Nebraska
Retail Federation, Nebraska Petroleum Marketers & Convenience
Store Association, Nevada Petroleum Marketers & Convenience
Store Association, New Hampshire Grocers Association, New
Hampshire Retail Association, Fuel Merchants Association of New
Jersey, New Jersey Food Council, New Mexico Petroleum Marketers
Association, Empire State Energy Association, Inc., Food
Industry Alliance of New York State, New York Association of
Convenience Stores, Retail Association of Nevada, College
Stores Association of North Carolina, North Carolina Petroleum
& Convenience Marketers (NCPCM), North Carolina Retail
Merchants Association, North Dakota Petroleum Marketers
Association, Ohio Association of College Stores, Ohio Energy
and Convenience Association, Oklahoma Grocers Association,
Oklahoma Petroleum Marketers & Convenience Store Association,
Oregon Fuels Association--OFA, Pennsylvania Food Merchants
Association, Pennsylvania Petroleum Association, Energy
Marketers Association of Rhode Island (EMARI), South Carolina
Association of College Stores, South Carolina Convenience &
Petroleum Marketers Association (SCCPMA), South Carolina Retail
Association, South Dakota Petroleum & Propane Marketers
Association (SDP2MA), South Dakota Retailers Association,
Tennessee Fuel & Convenience Store Association, Tennessee
Grocers & Convenience Store Association, Greater Houston
Retailers Cooperative Association, Inc., Texas Food & Fuel
Association, Texas Retailers Association, Utah Food Industry
Association, Utah Petroleum Marketers & Retailers Association,
Utah Retail Merchants Association, Vermont Fuel Dealers
Association (VFDA), Vermont Retail & Grocers Association,
Virginia Food Industry Association, Virginia Retail Federation,
Virginia Petroleum & Convenience Marketers Association (VPCMA),
Washington Food Industry Association, Washington Independent
Distributors of Energy (WIDE), West Virginia Oil Marketers &
Grocers Association, Wisconsin Association of College Stores,
Wisconsin Fuel & Retail Association (WFRA), Wisconsin Grocers
Association, Western Petroleum Marketers Association, and
Wyoming Petroleum Marketers & Convenience Store Association.
For these reasons, we oppose H.R. 8337.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters
Ranking Member.
Nydia M. Velazquez,
Brad Sherman,
Stephen F. Lynch,
Al Green,
Emanuel Cleaver, II,
Bill Foster,
Joyce Beatty,
Juan Vargas,
Sean Casten,
Ayanna Pressley,
Rashida Tlaib,
Sylvia R. Garcia,
Nikema Williams,
Members of Congress.
[all]