Committee Action
109TH CONGRESS
Legislative Action
On February 2, 2005, Representative Sam Johnson (R-TX),
then-Chairman of the Employer-Employee Relations Subcommittee
of the Committee on Education and the Workforce (Committee),
introduced the Small Business Health Fairness Act (H.R. 525).
On March 16, 2005, the Committee ordered H.R. 525, without
amendment, favorably reported to the House of Representatives
by a vote of 25 to 22. On July 26, 2005, H.R. 525 passed the
full House by a vote of 263 to 165.
111TH CONGRESS
Legislative Action
Between July 15 and 17, 2009, the Committee met to mark up
H.R. 3200, the America's Affordable Health Choices Act of
2009.\1\ During the markup, Representative Howard P. ``Buck''
McKeon (R-CA) offered an amendment including rules governing
association health plans (AHPs), the treatment of single-
employer arrangements, enforcement provisions, and other
provisions related to AHPs. The amendment was defeated by a
vote of 21 to 27.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H.R. 3200 was the House precursor to the law known as the
Affordable Care Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On November 7, 2009, the House passed H.R. 3962, the
Affordable Health Care for America Act. During the debate,
former Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) included the AHP legislative
text in the Republican motion to recommit.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\H. Amend. 510 to H.R. 3962, 111th Cong. (2009).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On March 21, 2010, the House passed the Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act by a vote of 219 to 212 to resolve
differences with the Senate. The bill was signed by President
Obama on March 23, 2010.\3\ On March 25, 2010, the House passed
the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 by a
vote of 220 to 207 to resolve differences with the Senate. This
bill was signed into law by President Obama on March 30,
2010.\4\ Collectively, the two bills are known as the
Affordable Care Act (ACA or Obamacare).\5\ The ACA did not
include AHP legislative text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Pub. L. No. 111-148
(2010).
\4\Health and Education Reconciliation Act, Pub. L. No. 111-152
(2010).
\5\Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Pub. L. No. 111-148
(2010), and Health and Education Reconciliation Act, Pub. L. No. 111-
152 (2010).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
112TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On February 9, 2011, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``The Impact of the Health Care Law on the Economy, Employers,
and the Workforce,'' which examined AHPs, among other topics.
The witnesses were Dr. Paul Howard, Senior Fellow, Manhattan
Institute, New York, NY; Ms. Gail Johnson, President and CEO,
Rainbow Station, Inc., Glenn Allen, VA; Dr. Paul Van de Water,
Senior Fellow, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities,
Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Neil Trautwein, Vice President and
Employee Benefits Policy Counsel, National Retail Federation,
Washington, D.C.
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 1, 2017, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Rescuing Americans from the Failed Health Care Law and
Advancing Patient-Centered Solutions,'' which examined failures
of the ACA; it also examined AHPs. Witnesses were Mr. Scott
Bollenbacher, CPA, Managing Partner, Bollenbacher and
Associates, LLC, Portland, IN; Mr. Joe Eddy, President and
Chief Executive Officer, Eagle Manufacturing Company,
Wellsburg, WV; Ms. Angela Schlaack, St. Joseph, Michigan; and
Dr. Tevi Troy, Chief Executive Officer, American Health Policy
Institute, Washington, D.C.
On March 1, 2017, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Legislative Proposals to Improve Health Care Coverage and
Provide Lower Costs for Families,'' which examined the Small
Business Health Fairness Act of 2017 (H.R. 1101) addressing
AHPs, among other proposals. Witnesses were Mr. Jon B. Hurst,
President, Retailers Association of Massachusetts, Boston, MA;
Ms. Allison R. Klausner, J.D., Principal, Government Relations
Leader, Conduent, Secaucus, NJ; Ms. Lydia Mitts, Associate
Director of Affordability Initiatives, Families USA,
Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Jay Ritchie, Executive Vice
President, Tokio Marine HHC, Kennesaw, GA.
Legislative Action
On February 16, 2017, Representative Sam Johnson introduced
the Small Business Health Fairness Act of 2017 (H.R. 1101) with
then-Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions
(HELP) Chairman Tim Walberg (R-MI).
On March 8, 2017, the Committee considered H.R. 1101.
Representative Walberg offered an amendment in the nature of a
substitute (ANS), making technical changes to the introduced
bill. The Committee voted to adopt the ANS by voice vote. The
Committee favorably reported H.R. 1101, as amended, to the
House of Representatives by a vote of 22 to 17. On March 22,
2017, the House passed H.R. 1101 by a vote of 236-175.
Second Session--Hearing
On March 20, 2018, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Expanding Affordable Health Care Options: Examining
the Department of Labor's Proposed Rule on Association Health
Plans.'' Witnesses were Mr. Christopher Condeluci, Principal
and Sole Shareholder, CC Law and Policy PLLC, Washington, D.C.;
Mr. Michael McGrew, CEO McGrew Real Estate, Lawrence, KS; Ms.
Catherine Monson, CEO and President, FASTSIGNS International,
Inc., Carrollton, TX; and Mr. John Arensmeyer, Founder and CEO,
Small Business Majority, Washington, D.C.
117TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearing
On February 17, 2022, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Exploring Pathways to Affordable, Universal Health
Coverage,'' which examined, among other topics, the benefits of
expanding AHPs. The witnesses were Dr. Brian Blase, President,
Paragon Health Institute, Ponte Verde, Florida; Dr. Georges C.
Benjamin, Executive Director, the American Public Health
Association, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Katie Keith, Center on
Health Insurance Reforms, Georgetown University, Washington,
D.C.; and Mr. Robert B. Reich, Carmel P. Friesen Professor of
Public Policy, Goldman School of Public Policy, University of
California, Berkley, CA.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On April 26, 2023, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Reducing Health Care Costs for Working Americans and
Their Families,'' which examined H.R. 2868, the Association
Health Plans Act, among other proposals. Witnesses were Mr.
Joel White, President, Council for Affordable Health Coverage
(CAHC), Washington, D.C.; Mrs. Tracy Watts, Senior Partner,
Mercer, Washington, D.C.; Marcie Strouse, Partner, Capitol
Benefits Group, Des Moines, IA; and Ms. Sabrina Corlette, J.D.,
Senior Research Professor, Center on Health Insurance Reforms,
Georgetown University's Health Policy Institute, Washington,
D.C.
Legislative Action
On April 25, 2023, Representative Walberg introduced the
Association Health Plans Act (H.R. 2868) with Chairwoman Foxx,
HELP Subcommittee Chairman Bob Good (R-VA), and Representatives
Rick Allen (R-GA), Dan Crenshaw (R-TX), and Michael Burgess (R-
TX) as original cosponsors. On June 6, 2023, the Committee
considered H.R. 2868 in legislative session and reported it
favorably, as amended, to the House of Representatives by a
recorded vote of 23 to 18. Representative Walberg offered an
ANS clarifying that an organization has to be active for two
years prior to the establishment of an AHP in order for the AHP
to qualify as a group health plan under the bill. In section 3,
the ANS also struck ``employee welfare benefit plan'' and
inserted ``group health plan'' to clarify that premium rates
are for health care only. The ANS was adopted by voice vote.
Second Session--Hearing
On May 15, 2024, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Examining the Policies and Priorities of the Department of
Health and Human Services.'' The sole witness was the Honorable
Xavier Becerra, Secretary of Health and Human Services,
Washington, D.C. During this hearing, Members asked Secretary
Becerra about the increase in the cost of health insurance
premiums after the Biden-Harris administration rescinded the
2018 AHP rule.
On September 10, 2024, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``ERISA's 50th Anniversary: The Value of Employer-
Sponsored Health Benefits,'' which discussed the 2024
Department of Labor (DOL) final rule rescinding the 2018 Trump
administration AHP rule. Witnesses were Ms. Ilyse Schuman,
Senior Vice President, Health and Paid Leave Policy, American
Benefits Council, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Holly Wade, Executive
Director, National Federation of Independent Business Research
Center, Washington, D.C.; Dr. Paul Fronstin, Director, Health
Benefits Research, Employee Benefit Research Institute,
Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Anthony Wright, Executive Director,
Families USA, Davis, CA.
Legislative Action
On July 2, 2024, Representative Walberg introduced H.J.
Res. 181, Providing for congressional disapproval under chapter
8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted by the
Department of Labor relating to ``Definition of `Employer'-
Association Health Plans,'' with Chairwoman Virginia Foxx (R-
NC) and Representatives Neal Dunn (R-FL), Burgess, Allen,
Crenshaw, Aaron Bean (R-FL), Good (HELP Subcommittee Chairman),
Adrian Smith (R-NE), Russ Fulcher (R-ID), Dan Meuser (R-PA),
Claudia Tenney (R-NY), Troy Balderson (R-OH), Dusty Johnson (R-
SD), Andy Ogles (R-TN), Lloyd Smucker (R-PA), Glenn Grothman
(R-WI), Glenn Thompson (R-PA), and Burgess Owens (R-UT). On
September 11, 2024, the Committee considered H.J. Res. 181 in
legislative session and reported it favorably to the House of
Representatives by a recorded vote of 23 to 12.
COMMITTEE VIEWS
Introduction
The Committee has a long history of supporting expanded
access to AHPs which give small employers increased ability to
spread risk and lower health care costs. The Committee supports
expanded access to more affordable health care coverage for
small employers and self-employed individuals. Expanding AHPs
would allow small businesses and independent contractors to
band together across state lines through associations, thus
increasing their bargaining power with health plans and
providers and placing them on a more level playing field with
larger companies and unions. AHPs free small businesses from
costly state-mandated benefit packages, distribute the risk for
self-employed individuals among all enrolled, and lower
overhead costs, enabling employers to offer more affordable
health care coverage to their workers and enabling self-
employed individuals to access more affordable health care
coverage. Nullifying the Biden-Harris administration's reversal
of the Trump administration's efforts to expand AHPs is an
important first step in helping small businesses.
Background on employer-sponsored health insurance
The Committee on Education and the Workforce has
jurisdiction over employer-sponsored health coverage. Employer-
sponsored insurance (ESI) covers over half of the non-elderly
population--an estimated 153 million employees and their
dependents.\6\ Employer-sponsored health benefits are governed
by several laws, including the Employee Retirement Income
Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), which is the foundation of
employer-sponsored health care.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://files.kff.org/attachment/Employer-Health-Benefits-
Survey-2023-Annual-Survey.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ERISA establishes federal guidelines governing the conduct
of employee benefit plans, including employer-sponsored group
health plans. Private employers that implement group health
plans may implement uniform benefit plans because ERISA
preempts state regulation of such plans. Approximately 99
million employees and family members have coverage from
employers that self-insure their own health plans, making them
subject to regulation only under ERISA and the Internal Revenue
Code (Code).\7\ The remainder of private employers offering
health benefits purchase fully insured coverage from
traditional insurance companies, which is generally governed by
ERISA, the Code, the Public Health Service Act (PHSA), and
state insurance laws.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ESI is the core of America's health care system. Employers
have historically been at the forefront of creating innovative,
market-driven approaches to providing health benefits. Ninety-
three percent of Americans covered by ESI are satisfied with
their employer-sponsored coverage.\8\ Fifty-three percent of
small firms (firms with 3-199 workers) and 98 percent of large
firms (firms with 200 or more workers) offered health benefits
to their workers in 2023.\9\ When employees can participate in
ESI, 75 percent enroll.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\https://www.techtarget.com/healthcarepayers/news/366603783/93-
of-Employees-Satisfied-with -Employer-Sponsored-Health-
Insurance#::text=93%25%20of%20Employees%20Satisfied%20with
%20Employer%20Sponsored%20Health%20Insurance%20%7C%20TechTarget&text=Fol
low:.
\9\https://files.kff.org/attachment/Employer-Health-Benefits-
Survey-2023-Annual-Survey.pdf.
\10\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Challenges facing small employers' ability to offer health insurance
Health costs continue to rise at unsustainable rates. In
2023, health care spending was 17.6 percent of the U.S. Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) or $14,423 per person and is expected to
rise to 19.7 percent of GDP or $21,927 per person within the
next decade.\11\ In 2023, annual premiums for family coverage
rose by 7 percent.\12\ The increase in health costs has led
large employers subject to the Affordable Care Act (ACA)
employer mandate to reduce benefits and has led small employers
increasingly to drop coverage. For more than 30 years, NFIB
members have identified the cost of health insurance as the top
small business problem, with 48 percent ranking it as a
critical problem.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/
hlthaff.2024.00469#::text=Health%20care%20spe
nding%20in%20the,health%20spending%20(exhibit%201).
\12\https://www.kff.org/report-section/ehbs-2023-section-1-cost-of-
health-insurance/.
\13\https://strgnfibcom.blob.core.windows.net/nfibcom/Health-
Insurance-Survey-2023.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the ACA requires employers with more than 50 full-
time employees to offer ESI coverage, many small employers
(with fewer than 50 employees) choose to offer coverage anyway.
Sixty-three percent of small employers believe it is important
for them to offer health coverage in order to recruit and
retain employees.\14\ According to the NFIB Small Business
Health Insurance Survey, 56 percent of small employers offer
health insurance, including 89 percent of employers with more
than 30 employees and 39 percent of employers with fewer than
10 employees. Seventy-seven percent of small employers fully
insure their plans, meaning they pay premiums to an insurance
company that bears the financial risk for the plan, while 8
percent of small employers self-fund, meaning the employer
itself bears the financial risk.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\https://strgnfibcom.blob.core.windows.net/nfibcom/Health-
insurance-survey-NFIB.pdf.
\15\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, many small employers dropped health insurance
coverage for their employees due to the increased financial
risks in offering health coverage after the ACA, which are
further exacerbated by rising health care costs. In testimony
before the HELP Subcommittee on April 26, 2023, Mr. Joel White,
President of the Council for Affordable Health Coverage, argued
that ACA mandates applicable to small businesses increase the
cost of providing health care coverage and limit choices: ``As
Congress increased [costs for small businesses] and limited
their choices, the authors of ACA created powerful incentives
for small businesses to drop coverage. And they did.''\16\
Among small employers that do not offer health insurance, 65
percent say that it is simply too expensive, but only 9 percent
cited government-run health care options as the reason they do
not offer coverage. Overall, 94 percent of small employers find
it challenging to manage the cost of their health plans, and 98
percent believe that the cost of their health plans will become
unsustainable within the next decade. Seventy-nine percent of
small employers expressed interest in joining an AHP because it
could help alleviate their health care costs.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\https://edworkforce.house.gov/calendar/
eventsingle.aspx?EventID=409078.
\17\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
AHPs would help small businesses offer affordable coverage
An AHP is a type of group health plan that allows multiple
employers to band together to purchase health coverage. The
term AHP is not in ERISA but operates as a type of multiple
employer welfare arrangement (MEWA) for federal regulatory
purposes. By participating in AHPs, employers can obtain
coverage that is not subject to the burdensome state and
federal regulations that govern individual and small-group
coverage and extend to MEWAs. Under current law, AHPs can form
under limited circumstances that are governed by a series of
advisory opinions and guidance documents from DOL. For
employers to band together, they must (1) have a common nexus
and a ``genuine organizational relationship'' between the
association and participating employees and (2) provide
benefits to the employees of two or more employers.\18\ AHPs
permit multiple small businesses to deliver lower-cost health
plans by pooling risk and self-funding.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\https://www.dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/ebsa/about-ebsa/our-
activities/resource-center/publicatio ns/mewa-under-erisa-a-guide-to-
federal-and-state-regulation.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2018, DOL under the Trump administration published a
final rule to expand AHPs by expanding the commonality-of-
interest standard to include geographic proximity (bona fide
association provision) and allowing for the participation of
self-employed individuals (working owner provision).\19\ New
AHPs produced savings of up to 29 percent on average while the
rule was in effect, and realtor groups saw average savings of
up to 50 percent.\20\
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
Committee Democrats oppose H. J. Res. 181, Providing for
congressional disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United
States Code, of the rule submitted by the Department of Labor
relating to ``Definition of `Employer'-Association Health
Plans.'' This misguided use of the Congressional Review Act\1\
would reinstate the Trump Administration's Association Health
Plan (AHP) Final Rule\2\ that was largely invalidated by a
Federal court in 2019.\3\ By attempting to reinstate a rule,
the fundamental provisions of which have never taken effect and
have been invalidated, would create confusion as to which
regulation applies and the extent to which the Department of
Labor (DOL) can take future actions in this area to protect
consumers. As a result, this resolution would--like other
Republican efforts to expand AHPs--threaten to put
comprehensive and affordable coverage for small businesses and
workers at risk, create loopholes that undermine critical
consumer protections, and raise costs across the broader health
insurance market. This is why H. J. Res. 181 is opposed by more
than 15 leading consumer and patient groups\4\ and why
Committee Democrats unanimously reject this harmful application
of the Congressional Review Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\5 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 801-808.
\2\U.S. Dep't of Lab., Final Rule: Definition of ``Employer'' Under
Section 3(5) of ERISA Association Health Plans, 83 Fed. Reg. 28912
(June 21, 2018), https://www.federalregister.gov/docu ments/2018/06/21/
2018-12992/definition-of-employer-under-section-35-of-erisa-
association-health-plans.
\3\New York v. United States Dep't of Lab., 363 F. Supp. 3d 109
(D.D.C. 2019).
\4\Patient community concerns H.J. Res. 181, Congressional Review
Act resolution to stop the Biden-Harris rule limiting access to
Association Health Plans (AHPs), Letter to Chair Virginia Foxx and
Ranking Member Bobby Scott, H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, Full
Committee Markup (Sept. 11, 2024) (on file with Comm.) (hereinafter
Patient Community Letter).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE ACA IMPROVED ACCESS TO AFFORDABLE, QUALITY HEALTH COVERAGE
Before the Affordable Care Act (ACA),\5\ workers often had
limited options for obtaining affordable health coverage.\6\
People with preexisting conditions were particularly
disadvantaged because they could be charged higher rates or
denied coverage altogether in the individual market. Small
businesses employing women or workers with chronic or high-cost
illnesses could be charged higher premiums, often making
coverage unaffordable. Those who could afford to buy coverage
in the individual and small group market often found their
insurance did not cover vital services, such as behavioral
health or maternity care.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Pub. L. No. 111-148 (2010).
\6\Sara R. Collins et al., How the Affordable Care Act Has Improved
Americans' Ability to Buy Health Insurance on Their Own, Commonwealth
Fund (Feb. 1, 2017), https://www.commonw ealthfund.org/publications/
issue-briefs/2017/feb/how-affordable-care-act-has-improved-americans-
ability-buy.
\7\Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Essential Health
Benefits Under Threat, https://www.cbpp.org/essential-health-benefits-
under-threat (last visited Sept. 25, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ACA took steps to level the playing field--establishing
safeguards for workers and employers alike. Not only did the
ACA create Marketplaces where individuals, self-employed
people, and families can access affordable health coverage, the
law also protects workers and businesses in the small group
market from unfair practices.\8\ Consumers have benefited from
these protections for over a decade despite dozens of attempts
by Republicans to repeal the ACA in Congress\9\ and
ideologically-driven litigation--most recently through a
lawsuit attacking coverage for lifesaving preventive health
services such as lung cancer screenings, preexposure
prophylaxis for HIV prevention, and medications to lower the
risk of breast cancer for high-risk women.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Nicole Rapfogel et al., 10 Ways the ACA Has Improved Health Care
in the Past Decade, Center for American Progress (Mar. 23, 2020),
https://www.americanprogress.org/article/10-ways- aca-improved-health-
care-past-decade/.
\9\Chris Riotta, GOP Aims To Kill Obamacare Yet Again After Failing
70 Times, Newsweek (July 29, 2017), https://www.newsweek.com/gop-
health-care-bill-repeal-and-replace-70-failed-
attempts-643832.
\10\Laurie Sobel et al., Explaining Litigation Challenging the
ACA's Preventive Services Requirements: Braidwood Management Inc. v.
Becerra, Kaiser Family Foundation (May 15, 2023), https://www.kff.org/
womens-health-policy/issue-brief/explaining-litigation-challenging-the-
acas-preventive-services-requirements-braidwood-management-inc-v-
becerra/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to instituting crucial consumer protections,
the ACA has led to historic improvements in the number of
people with health coverage. In 2022, the uninsured rate fell
to 8 percent--the lowest level in history\11\--and remained
stable at 8 percent in 2023.\12\ During the 117th Congress,
Democrats took bold action to build upon this progress and
further improve affordability. The American Rescue Plan Act\13\
and the Inflation Reduction Act\14\ strengthened the advance
premium tax credits and eliminated the subsidy ``cliff'' for
individuals earning over 400 percent of the Federal Poverty
Level through 2025. Thanks to these reforms, during the most
recent Open Enrollment Period, a record 21.3 million people\15\
signed up for coverage through Healthcare.gov and State-Based
Marketplaces, and the average consumer saved $705 per year in
premiums.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Aiden Lee et al., National Uninsured Rate Reaches All-Time Low
in Early 2022, Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, U.S.
Dept. of Health and Human Services (Aug. 2022), https://aspe.hhs.gov/
sites/default/files/documents/15c1f9899b3f203887deba90e3005f5a/
Uninsured -Q1-2022-Data-Point-HP-2022-23-08.pdf.
\12\Council for Economic Advisors, Executive Office of the
President, The 2023 Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Reports:
Strong household income gains, lower official poverty, uninsured rate
near record low (Sept. 10, 2024), https://www.whitehouse.gov/cea/
written-materials/2024/09/10/the-2023-income-poverty-and-health-
insurance-reports-strong-household-income-gains-lower-official-poverty-
uninsured-rate-near-record-low/
#::text=Health%20insurance%20coverage%20re
mained%20high,from%202022's%207.9%20percent%20rate.
\13\Pub. L. No. 117-2 (2021).
\14\Pub. L. No. 117-169 (2022).
\15\Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Historic 21.3 Million
People Choose ACA Marketplace Coverage (Jan. 24, 2024), https://
www.cms.gov/newsroom/press-releases/historic-213-mil lion-people-
choose-aca-marketplace-coverage.
\16\Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Health Insurance
Marketplaces 2024 Open Enrollment Report, https://www.cms.gov/files/
document/health-insurance-exchanges-2024-open-en rollment-report-
final.pdf (last visited Sept. 25, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EXPANSION OF AHPS WOULD JEOPARDIZE HEALTH COVERAGE FOR CONSUMERS
Under current law, coverage offered through a group or
association to individuals or small employers generally must
comply with the patient protections of the ACA and state
insurance law.\17\ However, under the guise of lowering costs,
Republicans have long sought to expand AHPs and eliminate many
of these guardrails. Such proposals would take the country
backwards and undermine the reforms made by the ACA to improve
the quality and affordability of health coverage. Proposals to
expand AHPs generally allow such arrangements to evade certain
state and federal benefit standards and consumer
protections.\18\ As a result, AHP enrollees are at risk of--
potentially unknowingly--losing out on comprehensive care that
would otherwise be guaranteed under the ACA and state law.
While proposals to expand AHPs may include some consumer
protections (e.g., nominal protections against discrimination
based on preexisting conditions), gaps in these requirements
often leave consumers vulnerable to harm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\29 U.S.C. Sec. 1144(b)(6); Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services, Application of Individual and Group Market Requirements under
Title XXVII of the Public Health Service Act when Insurance Coverage Is
Sold to, or through, Associations (Sept. 1, 2011), https://www.cms.gov/
CCIIO/Resources/Files/Downloads/association_coverage_9_1_2011.pdf.
\18\See, e.g., H.R. 2868, the Association Health Plan Act (118th
Cong.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crucially, allowing insurers and health plans to avoid
covering needed benefits is a longstanding tenet of
Republicans' approach to health care.\19\ Despite coverage of
Essential Health Benefits being both popular and necessary,\20\
AHPs would be exempt from this foundational protection of the
ACA because they would be considered large group plans.\21\ As
a result, AHPs could exclude certain categories of coverage,
such as maternity care, mental health, or substance use
disorder, to dissuade certain groups or individuals from
enrolling. Reducing benefit levels or avoiding the costs of
providing comprehensive benefits can reduce costs for AHPs in
the short-term but will ultimately negatively impact consumers
and people who need coverage the most. Individuals enrolled in
AHPs could be shocked to find they do not have access to the
care they need or the financial security they expected.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\See e.g., Lydia Mitts et al., House Republicans Gut Protections
for Pre-Existing Conditions in Latest Proposal, Families USA (Mar. 26,
2017), https://familiesusa.org/resources/house-repub licans-gut-
protections-for-pre-existing-conditions-in-latest-proposal/.
\20\Dania Palanker, Eliminating Essential Health Benefits Will
Shift Financial Risk Back to Consumers, The Commonwealth Fund (Mar. 24,
2017), https://www.commonwealthfund.org/blog/2017/eliminating-
essential-health-benefits-will-shift-financial-risk-back-consumers.
\21\42 U.S.C. Sec. 18022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
AHPS CREATE MARKET FRAGMENTATION AND RAISE COSTS THROUGHOUT THE SYSTEM
While health care costs for many workers and businesses
remain a challenge, Republican efforts to expand AHPs are not
the answer. Rather, AHPs harm workers and small businesses
throughout the overall health care system by shifting costs,
thereby making coverage more expensive for many and entirely
out of reach for some.
Experts have consistently warned that the approach of
pulling certain populations out of the risk pool--which is
antithetical to the foundational principles of the ACA that
ensure no one gets left behind--would fragment the health
insurance market. According to the American Academy of
Actuaries, allowing AHPs to operate under different rules could
result in adverse selection that raises costs throughout the
insurance pool and creates a market in which higher-cost
groups--namely, those that are generally sicker or older--
``could find it more difficult to obtain coverage.''\22\
Similarly, the Congressional Budget Office determined that
``the primary factor driving lower premiums for AHPs is the
ability to price premiums on the basis of each association's
expected health care spending and thereby attract employers
with relatively low-risk employees and avoid those with higher-
risk employees.''\23\ The Federation of American Hospitals has
also noted that ``segmenting of risk would result in higher and
increasing premiums for individuals left out of associations,
which could spiral over time, ever worsening adverse selection
that would destabilize the non-AHP products.''\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\American Academy of Actuaries, Issue Brief: Association Health
Plans (Feb. 2017), http://www.actuary.org/content/association-health-
plans-0.
\23\Cong. Budget Office, How CBO and JCT Analyzed Coverage Effects
of New Rules for Association Health Plans and Short-Term Plans 5 (Jan.
2019), https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019-01/54915-
New_Rules_for_AHPs_STPs.pdf.
\24\Statement of the Federation of American Hospitals to the U.S.
House of Representatives Committee on Education & The Workforce, Re:
Markup of 6 Bills on September 11, 2024, Letter to Chair Virginia Foxx
and Ranking Member Bobby Scott, H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, Full
Committee Markup (Sept. 11, 2024) (on file with Comm.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee also examined this issue during the current
Congress and heard expert testimony reiterating the gravity of
this concern. On April 26, 2023, during a hearing held by the
Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions titled
Reducing Health Care Costs for Working Americans and Their
Families (HELP Subcommittee Hearing), Sabrina Corlette,
Research Professor and Co-Director of the Center on Health
Insurance Reforms at Georgetown University's McCourt School of
Public Policy, warned of the consequences of AHPs, stating that
``AHPs just create new winners and losers, with the losers
being those who are older and sicker.''\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Reducing Health Care Costs for Working Americans and Their
Families: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Health, Empl., Lab., and
Pensions of the H. Comm. On Educ. & the Workforce, 118th Cong. 10
(2023) (testimony of Sabrina Corlette, Research Professor and Co-
Director, Center on Health Insurance Reforms at the Georgetown
University McCourt School of Public Policy).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EXPANDING AHPS GAMBLES WITH THE FINANCIAL SECURITY OF WORKERS,
EMPLOYERS, AND HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS
As patient advocacy groups have pointed out, ``Association
Health Plans (AHPs) have historically proven risky for
enrollees--sometimes leaving patients with thousands of dollars
in medical debt.''\26\ Fraud and solvency issues among AHPs are
profoundly dangerous for consumers and employers who
participate in these arrangements, as well as the doctors,
health centers, and hospitals who may not receive reimbursement
for the medical care they provide. Ms. Corlette explained the
high stakes at the HELP Subcommittee Hearing:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\Patient Community Letter, supra note 3.
. . . if history is any guide, many AHPs may seem
strong at first because they are able to attract
healthy groups and can offer low rates and generous
benefits to those groups. Over time, however, as
workers get older and sicker, the risk in the pool
deteriorates. AHPs then either must raise rates, reduce
benefits, disband, or, in the worst cases, become
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
insolvent.\27\
\27\Corlette, supra note 24 at 10.
The history of multiple employer welfare arrangements
(MEWAs) offers a sobering warning for the financial risks posed
by the proliferation of AHPs. Proposals to expand AHPs that are
under limited regulation and oversight would bring us back to
the time when MEWAs also enjoyed limited regulation and gambled
with the financial security of both workers and employers.\28\
In 2001, Sunkist Growers, Inc., a California-based MEWA that
covered 23,000 people, became insolvent, leaving behind
approximately $11 million in unpaid claims.\29\ Similarly, New
Jersey's Coalition of Automotive Retailers became insolvent in
2002, leaving 20,000 individuals without coverage and $15
million in unpaid claims.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\U.S. Dept. of Lab., MEWAs Multiple Employer Welfare
Arrangements under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA):
A Guide to Federal and State Regulation at 3 (``Recognizing that it was
both appropriate and necessary for States to be able to establish,
apply and enforce State insurance laws with respect to MEWAs, the U.S.
Congress amended ERISA in 1983, as part of Public Law 97-473, to
provide an exception to ERISA's broad preemption provisions for the
regulation of MEWAs under State insurance laws.'')
\29\Mila Kofman, et al., MEWAs: The Threat of Plan Insolvency and
Other Challenges, Commonwealth Fund (Mar. 2004), https://
www.commonwealthfund.org/sites/default/files/documents/
media_files_publications_issue_brief_2004_mar_mewas_the_threat_of_plan_i
nsolvency_and_othe r_challenges_kofman_mewas_pdf.pdf.
\30\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately, MEWAs continue to face financial challenges
and heightened risk of fraud to this day. DOL routinely
documents investigations and enforcement actions against MEWAs
that have committed violations of ERISA and failed to pay
promised benefits.\31\ In May of 2023, it was announced that
health plan participants, employers, and medical providers
harmed by a MEWA operating in 36 states would begin to finally
receive payments related to more than $54 million in unpaid
health claims.\32\ Unfortunately, despite these enforcement
efforts, victims are often not made whole, leaving workers,
employers, and health care providers to absorb financial losses
caused by fraudulent and mismanaged MEWAs.\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Christine Monahan, Updates from the MEWA Files: The Good, the
Bad, and the Ugly of Federal Enforcement Efforts, CHIRblog (Dec. 19,
2019), https://chirblog.org/mewa-files-part-3-good-bad-ugly/.
\32\Press Release, U.S. Dep't of Labor, Federal Court Approves Plan
To Distribute Assets to Participants Harmed by Underfunded Group Health
Plan Arrangement Operating in 36 States (May 1, 2023), https://
www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/ebsa/ebsa20230501.
\33\Monahan, supra note 30.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE TRUMP AHP FINAL RULE RECYCLED HARMFUL IDEAS
Following years of failed Republican efforts to enact
legislation to expand AHPs, in 2018 the Trump Administration
attempted to circumvent Congress through a controversial
rulemaking (the 2018 Final Rule) under the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA).\34\ The 2018 Final Rule
would have dramatically expanded the circumstances under which
AHPs could be offered as single-employer group health plans--
even to self-employed individuals without any common law
employees. The AHP arrangements allowed under the rule would
have been treated as large group health