Committee Action
112TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings.
Full Committee hearing on DOL's policies and priorities
On February 16, 2011, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce (Committee) held a hearing titled ``Policies and
Priorities at the U.S. Department of Labor.'' The purpose of
the hearing was to examine, among other subjects, DOL's 2010
proposed rule (2010 proposal) significantly expanding the
definition of ``fiduciary'' under the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) and the Internal Revenue
Code (Tax Code).\1\ The Honorable Hilda L. Solis, Secretary of
Labor, was the sole witness. During the hearing,
Representatives Judy Biggert (R-IL) and Carolyn McCarthy (D-NY)
expressed concerns regarding DOL's proposed rule in regard to
DOL's lack of coordination with the Securities and Exchange
Commission (SEC).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Definition of the Term ``Fiduciary,'' 75 Fed. Reg. 65,263
(proposed Oct. 22, 2010).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subcommittee hearing on 2010 fiduciary proposal
On July 26, 2011, the Subcommittee on Health, Employment,
Labor, and Pensions (HELP Subcommittee) held a hearing titled
``Redefining `Fiduciary': Assessing the Impact of the Labor
Department's Proposal on Workers and Retirees'' to examine the
consequences of the 2010 proposal. Witnesses were the Honorable
Phyllis Borzi, Assistant Secretary of Labor, Employee Benefits
Security Administration, Washington, D.C.; Kenneth Bentsen,
Executive Vice President, Securities Industry and Financial
Markets Association, Washington, D.C.; Kent Mason, Partner,
Davis and Harman LLP, Washington, D.C.; Donald Myers, Partner,
Morgan, Lewis and Bockius LLP, Washington, D.C.; Norman Stein,
Professor, Earle Mack School of Law, Drexel University,
Philadelphia, PA; and Jeffrey Tarbell, Director, Houlihan
Lokey, San Francisco, CA.
Second Session--Full Committee hearing on Fiscal Year (FY) 2013 budget
proposal for DOL
On March 21, 2012, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Reviewing the President's Fiscal Year 2013 Budget Proposal
for the Department of Labor.'' Secretary Solis was the sole
witness. During the hearing, Republican and Democrat Members
thanked Secretary Solis for withdrawing the 2010 proposal.
113TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Full Committee hearing on FY 2015 budget proposal for
DOL
On March 26, 2014, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Reviewing the President's Fiscal Year 2015 Budget Proposal
for the Department of Labor.'' The Honorable Thomas E. Perez,
Secretary of Labor, was the sole witness. During this hearing,
Chairman John Kline (R-MN) raised concerns regarding DOL's
ongoing fiduciary rulemaking, including the impact on important
investment advice that low-income people might need.
114TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
Full Committee hearing on FY 2016 budget proposal for DOL
On March 18, 2015, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Reviewing the President's Fiscal Year 2016 Budget Proposal
for the Department of Labor.'' Secretary Perez was the sole
witness. During the hearing, Representative Frederica Wilson
(D-FL) raised concerns about the impact of a new proposed
fiduciary rule on the availability of affordable investment
advice.
Subcommittee hearing on 2015 proposed fiduciary rule
On June 17, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Restricting Access to Financial Advice: Evaluating the
Costs and Consequences for Working Families and Retirees.'' The
purpose of the hearing was to examine DOL's proposed rule
titled ``Definition of the Term ``Fiduciary'': Conflict of
Interest Rule--Retirement Investment Advice,'' published on
April 20, 2015.\2\ Witnesses were Secretary Perez; Jack Haley,
Executive Vice President, Fidelity Investments, Boston, MA;
Dean Harman, Managing Director, Harman Wealth Management, The
Woodlands, TX; Dennis Kelleher, President and CEO, Better
Markets, Washington, D.C.; Kent Mason, Partner, Davis and
Harman LLP, Washington, D.C.; and Brian Reid, Chief Economist,
Investment Company Institute, Washington, D.C.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Definition of the Term ``Fiduciary''; Conflict of Interest
Rule--Retirement Investment Advice, 80 Fed. Reg. 21,928 (proposed Apr.
20, 2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subcommittee hearing on 2015 proposed fiduciary rule
On December 2, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Principles for Ensuring Retirement Advice Serves the
Best Interests of Working Families and Retirees'' to examine
DOL's 2015 proposed fiduciary rule. Witnesses before the
Subcommittee were the Honorable Bradford (Brad) Campbell,
Counsel, Drinker Biddle and Reath LLP, Washington, D.C.; Rachel
A. Doba, President, DB Engineering, LLC, Indianapolis, IN;
Jules O. Gaudreau, Jr., President, The Gaudreau Group, Inc.,
Wilbraham, MA; and Marilyn Mohrman-Gillis, Managing Director,
Public Policy and Communications, Certified Financial Planner
Board of Standards, Washington, D.C. The Subcommittee
considered, among other subjects, the potential negative
effects of the 2015 proposed fiduciary rule on small businesses
and lower- and middle-income families.
Legislative Action
H.R. 4293, Affordable Retirement Advice Protection Act, introduced
On December 18, 2015, Representative Phil Roe (R-TN),
Chairman of the HELP Subcommittee, along with Representatives
Richard Neal (D-CT), Peter Roskam (R-IL), John Larson (D-CT),
Earl L. ``Buddy'' Carter (R-GA), and David Scott (D-GA),
introduced the Affordable Retirement Advice Protection Act
(H.R. 4293).\3\ The legislation ensures retirement advisors act
in their clients' best interests and prohibits DOL from
implementing its flawed proposal unless Congress affirmatively
approves the final rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\H.R. 4293, 114th Cong. (2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 4294, Strengthening Access to Valuable Education and Retirement
Support Act of 2015, introduced
On December 18, 2015, Representative Roskam, along with
Representatives Roe, Neal, Larson, Tom Reed (R-NY), and
Michelle Lujan Grisham (D-NM), introduced the Strengthening
Access to Valuable Education and Retirement Support Act of 2015
(H.R. 4294).\4\ The legislation amends the Tax Code to ensure
retirement advisors act in their clients' best interests and
prohibits DOL from implementing its flawed proposal unless
Congress affirmatively approves the final rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\H.R. 4294, 114th Cong. (2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee passes H.R. 4293, Affordable Retirement Advice Protection Act
On February 2, 2016, the Committee considered H.R. 4293,
the Affordable Retirement Advice Protection Act, in legislative
session. Representative Roe offered an amendment in the nature
of a substitute (ANS) making technical changes to the bill,
which was adopted by voice vote. The Committee favorably
reported H.R. 4293, as amended, to the House of Representatives
by a recorded vote of 22-14.
Committee passes H.R. 4294, Strengthening Access to Valuable Education
and Retirement Support Act of 2015
On February 2, 2016, the Committee considered H.R. 4294,
the Strengthening Access to Valuable Education and Retirement
Support Act of 2015, in legislative session. Representative
Carter offered an ANS making technical changes to the
introduced bill, which was adopted by voice vote. The Committee
favorably reported H.R. 4294, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by a recorded vote of 22-14.
H.J. Res. 88, Disapproving the Rule Submitted by the Department of
Labor Related to the Definition of the Term ``Fiduciary,''
introduced
On April 19, 2016, Representative Roe, along with
Representatives Charles Boustany (R-LA) and Ann Wagner (R-MO),
introduced H.J. Res. 88, Disapproving the rule submitted by the
Department of Labor relating to the definition of the term
``Fiduciary,'' pursuant to the Congressional Review Act. H.J.
Res. 88 would nullify DOL's final rule titled ``Definition of
the Term ``Fiduciary'': Conflict of Interest Rule--Retirement
Investment Advice'' published on April 8, 2016 (2016 Rule).\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Definition of the Term ``Fiduciary''; Conflict of Interest
Rule--Retirement Investment Advice, 81 Fed. Reg. 20,946 (Apr. 8, 2016).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee passes H.J. Res. 88, Disapproving the Rule Submitted by the
Department of Labor Related to the Definition of the Term
``Fiduciary''
On April 21, 2016, the Committee considered H.J. Res. 88 in
legislative session and reported the resolution favorably to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 22-14.
Congressional passage of H.J. Res. 88, Disapproving the Rule Submitted
by the Department of Labor Related to the Definition of the
Term ``Fiduciary''
On April 28, 2016, the House of Representatives passed H.J.
Res. 88 by a vote of 234-183. The Senate subsequently passed
H.J. Res. 88 on May 24, 2016, by a vote of 56-41.
Presidential veto of H.J. Res. 88, Disapproving the Rule Submitted by
the Department of Labor Related to the Definition of the Term
``Fiduciary''
On June 7, 2016, President Obama vetoed H.J. Res. 88. On
June 22, 2016, the passage of H.J. Res. 88, the objections of
the President to the contrary notwithstanding, failed in the
House of Representatives by a vote of 239-180, less than the
two-thirds majority needed.
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
Subcommittee hearing on DOL's 2016 final fiduciary rule
On May 18, 2017, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Regulatory Barriers Facing Workers and Families Saving
for Retirement'' to examine the impact of the 2016 Rule.
Witnesses before the Subcommittee were the Honorable Bradford
(Brad) Campbell, Partner, Drinker Biddle and Reath LLP,
Washington, D.C.; Jason Furman, Senior Fellow, Peterson
Institute for International Economics, Washington, D.C.; James
Kais, Senior Vice President and Managing Director, Retirement
Practice Leader, Transamerica, Saint Petersburg, FL; and Erik
Sossa, Vice President, Global Benefits and Wellness, PepsiCo,
Inc., Purchase, NY. The hearing examined, among other subjects,
increased costs and reduced access to investment advice when
the 2016 Rule was to go into effect on June 9, 2017.
Full Committee hearing on DOL's policies and priorities
On November 15, 2017, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Examining the Policies and Priorities of the U.S. Department
of Labor.'' The sole witness was the Honorable R. Alexander
Acosta, Secretary of Labor, Washington, D.C. Members discussed,
among other subjects, the flawed definition of ``fiduciary'' in
the 2016 Rule.
Legislative Action
H.R. 2823, Affordable Retirement Advice for Savers Act, introduced
On June 8, 2017, Representative Roe, along with
Representatives Roskam, Tim Walberg (R-MI), and Joe Wilson (R-
SC), introduced H.R. 2823, the Affordable Retirement Advice for
Savers Act, to overturn the 2016 Rule and to improve policies
governing financial advice in order to enhance protections for
retirement savers.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\H.R. 2823, 115th Cong. (2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee passes H.R. 2823, Affordable Retirement Advice for Savers Act
On July 19, 2017, the Committee considered H.R. 2823, the
Affordable Retirement Advice for Savers Act, in legislative
session. Representative Roe offered an ANS making technical
changes to the bill, which was adopted by voice vote. The
Committee favorably reported H.R. 2823, as amended, to the
House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 23-17.
117TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Full Committee hearing on DOL's policies and priorities
On June 14, 2022, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Examining the Policies and Priorities of the U.S. Department
of Labor.'' The sole witness was the Honorable Martin J. Walsh,
Secretary of Labor, Washington, D.C. During this hearing,
Members discussed, among other subjects, potential efforts by
DOL to resurrect the court-vacated 2016 Rule.
118TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
Subcommittee hearing on protecting retirees
On February 15, 2024, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Protecting American Savers and Retirees from DOL's
Regulatory Overreach.'' Witnesses were Doug Ommen,
Commissioner, Iowa Insurance Division, Des Moines, IA; Thomas
Roberts, Principal, Groom Law Group, Washington, D.C.; Jason
Berkowitz, Chief Legal and Regulatory Affairs Officer, Insured
Retirement Institute, Washington, D.C.; and Joseph Peiffer,
President, Public Investors Advocate Bar Association, Norman,
OK. The hearing examined DOL's proposed rule titled
``Retirement Security Rule: Definition of Advice Fiduciary''
published on November 3, 2023,\7\ including the proposed rule's
rushed rulemaking process, similarities to the court-vacated
2016 Rule, and negative impacts that a similar rule would have
on retirees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Retirement Security Rule: Definition of an Investment Advice
Fiduciary, 88 Fed. Reg. 75,890 (proposed Nov. 3, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Full Committee hearing on DOL's policies and priorities
On May 1, 2024, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Examining the Policies and Priorities of the Department of
Labor.'' The sole witness was the Honorable Julie A. Su, Acting
Secretary of Labor, Washington, D.C. During this hearing,
Members discussed, among other subjects, the burdensome nature
of the final rule published on April 25, 2024, titled
``Retirement Security Rule: Definition of Advice Fiduciary''
(2024 Rule),\8\ the truncated comment period during the
rulemaking process, and its similarity to the vacated 2016
rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Retirement Security Rule: Definition of an Investment Advice
Fiduciary, 89 Fed. Reg. 32,122 (Apr. 25, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subcommittee hearing on Employee Benefits Security Administration's
policies and priorities
On June 27, 2024, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Examining the Policies and Priorities of the Employee
Benefits Security Administration.'' The sole witness was the
Honorable Lisa M. Gomez, Assistant Secretary, Employee Benefits
Security Administration, Washington, D.C. The hearing examined,
among other subjects, the burdensome nature of the 2024 Rule,
the truncated comment period during the rulemaking process,
similarities to the court-vacated 2016 rule, and H.J. Res. 142.
Legislative Action
H.J. Res. 142, Providing for Congressional Disapproval Under Chapter 8
of Title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted by the
Department of Labor relating to ``Retirement Security Rule:
Definition of an Investment Advice Fiduciary,'' introduced
On May 15, 2024, Representative Rick Allen (R-GA)
introduced H.J. Res. 142, Providing for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the Department of Labor relating to
``Retirement Security Rule: Definition of an Investment Advice
Fiduciary,'' along with Representatives Pete Sessions (R-TX),
Jeff Duncan (R-SC), Wagner, Ralph Norman (R-SC), Byron Donalds
(R-FL), Walberg, Kevin Hern (R-OK), Carol D. Miller (R-WV),
John R. Moolenaar (R-MI), Lloyd Smucker (R-PA), Roger Williams
(R-TX), John H. Rutherford (R-FL), Bruce Westerman (R-AR), Jim
Banks (R-IN), Julia Letlow (R-LA), J. French Hill (R-AR),
Tracey Mann (R-KS), Stephanie Bice (R-OK), Zachary Nunn (R-IA),
Brad Finstad (R-MN), William R. Timmons (R-SC), John Joyce (R-
PA), Carter, David Kustoff (R-TN), and Daniel Meuser (R-PA).
The resolution was referred to the Committee.
Committee passes H.J. Res. 142, Providing for Congressional Disapproval
Under Chapter 8 of Title 5, United States Code, of the rule
submitted by the Department of Labor relating to ``Retirement
Security Rule: Definition of an Investment Advice Fiduciary''
On July 10, 2024, the Committee considered H.J. Res. 142 in
legislative session and reported it favorably to the House of
Representatives by a recorded vote of 23-18.
COMMITTEE VIEWS
Introduction
DOL issued a final rule titled ``Retirement Security Rule:
Definition of an Investment Advice Fiduciary'' on April 25,
2024 (2024 Rule).\9\ The 2024 Rule redefines who is a fiduciary
subject to ERISA by reason of giving investment advice. The
2024 Rule greatly expands both the individuals and activities
subject to ERISA's fiduciary duties of prudence and loyalty and
as well as the prohibited transaction rules.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Retirement Security Rule: Definition of an Investment Advice
Fiduciary, 89 Fed. Reg. 32,122 (Apr. 25, 2024).
\10\Id. at 32,242 (``[T]his rule will expand the parties that will
be considered investment advice fiduciaries and also will narrow the
exemption alternatives.'')
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOL rushed the 2024 Rule through a truncated comment period
that did not allow stakeholders to provide fulsome feedback.
The 2024 Rule will have significant harmful impact on
retirement savings for lower- and middle-income Americans by
restricting access to retirement products, imposing significant
and expensive regulatory burdens, and creating marketplace
confusion. H.J. Res. 142 will nullify the 2024 Rule and
prohibit DOL from issuing another similar rule.
ERISA Fiduciaries
In 1974, Congress enacted ERISA to govern private,
employer-sponsored benefit plans, including pension plans and
other employee benefit plans that provide health and welfare
benefits.\11\ In the House of Representatives, the Committee
has jurisdiction over ERISA, although many ERISA provisions are
parallel to Tax Code provisions, which are subject to the
jurisdiction of the Committee on Ways and Means.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Pub. L. No. 93-406 (1974); 29 U.S.C. Sec. 1001 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ERISA confers fiduciary status based on a person's
functional relationship to an employer-sponsored benefit plan.
With respect to investment advice, ERISA defines
Background
The Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) is the
federal law establishing minimum standards for employer-
provided retirement plans.\2\ ERISA's fiduciary standard is
recognized as the highest ethical standard, requiring advisors
to always act in their client's best interest by avoiding
recommendations that puts their own financial interests ahead
of that of the clients. In 1975, shortly after ERISA was
enacted, DOL issued regulations setting forth a five-part test
that must be met for an advisor to be held to ERISA's fiduciary
standard when providing retirement investment advice.\3\
Specifically, under the five-part test, a person is an
``investment advice'' fiduciary under ERISA when: (1) providing
advice or recommendations regarding investing in, purchasing,
selling or with respect to the value of securities or other
properties for a fee; (2) on a regular basis; (3) pursuant to a
mutual understanding with the plan or plan fiduciary; (4) that
the advice serves as a primary basis for investment decisions;
and (5) is individualized.\4\ The 1975 five-part test has not
kept pace with the changed retirement savings landscape. It was
promulgated prior to the existence of 401(k) plans and
widespread investments in IRAs. Defined contribution (DC)
plans, such as 401(k)s, have largely replaced traditional
defined benefit (DB) pensions as the primary retirement plans
offered by employers. According to the Congressional Research
Service (CRS), 27.2 million workers participated in DB plans in
1975 and 11.2 million workers participated in DC plans.\5\ In
2019, 85.5 million workers participated in DC plans and 12.6
million participated in DB plans.\6\ In 2021, workers held
roughly $9.4 trillion in DC plans and $13.2 trillion in
IRAs.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\29 U.S.C. 1001 et seq.
\3\U.S. Dep't of Labor, Definition of `Fiduciary,' 40 Fed. Reg.
50,843 (Oct. 31, 1975) (to be codified at 29 C.F.R. Sec. 2510.3-
21(c)(ii)(A)-(B)), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2010-
title29-vol9/pdf/CFR-2010-title29-vol9-sec2510-3-21.pdf. [hereinafter
1975 Regulation].
\4\Id.
\5\Cong. Research Serv., IF12007, A Visual Depiction of the Shift
from Defined Benefit (DB) to Defined Contribution (DC) Pension Plans in
the Private Sector (Dec. 27, 2021), https://crsreports.congress.gov/
product/pdf/IF/IF12007 (citing: U.S. Department of Labor, Employee
Benefits Security Administration (EBSA), Private Pension Plan Bulletin
Historical Tables and Graphs: 1975-2019 (Sept. 2021)).
\6\Id.
\7\Cong. Research Serv., IF12117, U.S. Retirement Assets: Amount in
Pensions and IRAs (May 23, 2022), https://crsreports.congress.gov/
product/pdf/IF/IF12117/2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The shift from traditional DB plans to DC plans has meant
that workers are ``on their own'' to figure out how to invest
and manage their retirement savings. According to DOL, ``the
shift has been accompanied by a dramatic increase in the
variety and complexity of financial products and services,
which has widened the information gap between investment advice
providers and their clients.''\8\ DOL also notes that ``[p]lan
participants and other retirement investors may be unable to
assess the quality of the advice they receive and may not be in
a position to learn of and guard against the investment advice
provider's conflicts of interest.''\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\U.S. Dep't of Labor, Retirement Security Rule: Definition of an
Investment Advice Fiduciary, 89 Fed. Reg. 32122, (Apr. 25, 2024) (to be
codified at 29 C.F.R. pt. 2510), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/
FR-2024-04-25/pdf/2024-08065.pdf [hereinafter Retirement Security
Rule].
\9\Retirement Security Rule, supra note 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Given that shift, the 1975 five-part test has loopholes
that can be easily exploited, particularly because every prong
must be met for an advisor to be deemed as providing fiduciary
investment advice. For instance, only advice that is furnished
on a ``regular basis'' is considered fiduciary investment
advice. A small retirement plan may hire an advisor as a
consultant on a one-time basis for an investment
recommendation. According to the Obama-era DOL, ``the plan
could be investing hundreds of millions of dollars in plan
assets, and it could be the most critical investment decision
the plan ever makes, but the adviser would have no fiduciary
responsibility under the 1975 regulation.''\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\1975 Regulation, supra note 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many workers and their families do not have an on-going
relationship with a financial professional but may
understandably hire an advisor on a one-time basis for
investing their retirement nest egg--particularly when they
roll over assets from their workplace 401(k) plan into an
Individual Retirement Account (IRA). This can be the biggest
financial decision of their lives. Unfortunately, there's no
guarantee they will receive retirement investment advice that
is in their best interest. While many advisors do right by
their retirement clients, unscrupulous ones can exploit the
loopholes in the deficient, decades-old five-part test. Such
advisors can steer retirement clients toward investments that
provides a larger financial incentive for the advisors even if
it is not the best choice for the clients. This practice is
known as providing ``conflicted advice,'' and it significantly
harms retirement savers and costs them billions of dollars in
losses every year.
Specifically, according to the Obama Administration's
analysis, conflicted advice costs retirement plan participants
up to $17 billion in losses every year.\11\ If there is
conflicted advice, and a retiree experiences a 100-basis point
(1%) reduction in investment performance as a result of it, but
that person spends down his/her retirement savings as normal,
the savings would be completely depleted more than five years
early.\12\ The Biden Administration is ``especially concerned
about the proper regulation of fixed index annuities.''\13\
Fixed index annuities are complex financial products typically
sold by insurance companies and regulated by state insurance
commissioners. According to the White House Council on Economic
Advisors (CEA), there may be ``strong incentives'' for advisors
to steer their retirement clients toward a fixed index annuity
even if such product is not in their best interest.\14\ The
incentives are in the form of ``large commissions'' paid to the
advisor.\15\ The CEA identified one annuity that provides
commissions ranging from 6.5% for sales to under-75-year-olds
to 3.5% for sales to those over the age of 80.\16\ The CEA
estimates that the cost of conflicted advice in the sale of
fixed index annuities may cost Americans as much as $5 billion
in retirement savings per year.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\The Effects of Conflicted Investment Advice on Retirement
Savings,'' Obama White House Archives (Feb. 2015), https://
obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/docs/
cea__coi_report_final.pdf.
\12\Id.
\13\U.S. Dep't of Labor, Retirement Security Rule: Definition of an
Investment Advice Fiduciary, 80 Fed. Reg. 75890 (Oct. 31, 2023) (to be
codified at 29 C.F.R. pt. 2510), https://www.federalregister.gov/
documents/2023/11/03/2023-23779/retirement-security-rule-definition-of-
an-investment-advice-fiduciary#citation-195-p75917 [hereinafter
Proposed Retirement Security Rule].
\14\The White House, Council on Economic Advisors, The Retirement
Security Rule--Strengthening Protections for Americans Saving for
Retirement (Oct. 31, 2023), https://www.whitehouse.gov/cea/written-
materials/2023/10/31/retirement-rule/.
\15\Id.
\16\Id.
\17\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Attorneys who are members of Public Investors Advocate Bar
Association (PIABA) have seen tens of thousands of victims of
conflicted advice.\18\ PIABA indicated that ``[a]lmost every
week'' a retiree comes to their attorneys' offices ``who has
lost a substantial amount of his life savings. These are often
proud, strong workers that have saved to pay off their house,
put their children through college and build a nest egg--all on
middle-income salaries.''\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association, Statement for the
Record Submitted to the U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefits
Security Administration, Conflicts of Interest Proposed Rule (Aug. 11,
2015), https://www.dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/EBSA/laws-and-
regulations/rules-and-regulations/public-comments/1210-AB32-2/written-
testimony-35.pdf.
\19\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On February 15, 2024, the Committee's Subcommittee on
Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions held a hearing
examining the Biden-Harris Administration's proposed Retirement
Security Rule. Mr. Joseph Peiffer, who is the President of
PIABA, testified at the hearing. In his testimony, Mr. Peiffer
noted that ``the difference between getting conflicted
retirement advice and receiving advice in the investor's
interest is sometimes the difference between the retiree being
able to visit their grandkids or not, the difference between
being able to afford a retirement home close to their children
or living with them.''\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Protecting American Savers and Retirees from DOL's Regulatory
Overreach: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on H, Employ., Lab., & Pensions
of the H. Comm. on Educ. & the Wrkf., 118th Cong. (2024) (testimony of
Joseph Peiffer, President, Public Investors Advocate Bar Association)
(accessible at https://piaba.org/piaba-newsroom/testimony-joseph-c-
peiffer-protecting-american-savers-and-retirees-dols-regulatory).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
RETIREMENT SECURITY RULE
The Biden-Harris Administration understood the harm that
the broken status quo causes retirement savers. In an effort to
address it, DOL recently finalized a rule that would replace
the 1975 five-part test and update its regulation defining a
``fiduciary'' under ERISA to reflect current practices in the
investment advice marketplace. The Retirement Security Rule
specifies when fiduciary responsibilities attach to a person
who gives investment advice for a fee to an investor in a
workplace retirement plan (such as a 401(k) or an IRA). The
Retirement Security Rule encompasses certain types of advice
that are currently not covered, including:
One-time advice about whether to roll-over a
401(k) into a new retirement account such as an IRA or
an annuity;
Advice about purchasing non-securities such
as fixed-indexed annuities; and
Advice given to plan sponsors and employers
(rather than just plan participants) about the types of
products to include in their plan line-ups.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\The White House, Fact Sheet: President Biden to Announce New
Actions to Protect Retirement Security by Cracking Down on Junk Fees in
Retirement Advice (Oct. 31, 2023), https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-
room/statements-releases/2023/10/31/fact-sheet-president-biden-to-
announce-new-actions-to-protect-retirement-security-by-cracking-down-
on-junk-fees-in-retirement-investment-advice/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Morningstar, which is an investment research company,
assessed DOL's proposed Retirement Security Rule and found that
it ``would have significant benefits for retirement
investors.''\22\ Specifically, according to Morningstar,
participants would save over $55 billion in the first 10 years
and over $130 billion in the subsequent 10 years, in
undiscounted and nominal dollars.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Morningstar, Comment Submitted to the Employee Benefits
Security Administration on Definition of Fiduciary--RIN 1210-AC02 (Jan.
2, 2024), https://www.regulations.gov/comment/EBSA-2023-0014-0339.
\23\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DOL's Retirement Security Rule aligns with retirement
savers' expectations that they are already receiving investment
advice in their best interest. For instance, according to a
survey conducted by the Certified Financial Planning (CFP)
Board of Standards earlier this year, 92% of those surveyed
already assumed that financial professionals provide retirement
savings advice and recommendations in their clients' best
interests.\24\ Further, nearly 97% of those surveyed broadly
agreed that financial professionals giving retirement savings
advice and recommendations should be required to act in the
best interests of their clients, even if they are giving the
client one-time advice.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\See Retirement Investor Expectations From Financial Advisors
Survey, CFP Board of Standards (Mar. 11, 2024), https://www.cfp.net/
news/2024/03/cfp-board-survey-americans-want-retirement-investment-
advice-to-be-in-their-best-interest.
\25\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CORRECTING THE RECORD ABOUT THE RETIREMENT SECURITY RULE
During the full Committee markup of H.J. Res. 142,
Committee Republicans made several inaccurate comments about
the Retirement Security Rule. It is important to correct the
record.
The Retirement Security Rule Is Substantially Different From the Obama-
era Fiduciary Rule
The Obama Administration sought to address the problem of
conflicted advice by promulgating a rule holding those who
provide retirement investment advice to an ERISA fiduciary
standard. The Obama-era rule faced multiple legal challenges.
Several federal district courts and the 10th Circuit Court of
Appeals upheld it.\26\ However, a three-judge panel of the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit vacated the rule in toto
in March 2018.\27\ In its decision vacating the 2016 Obama-era
fiduciary rule, the Fifth Circuit found that it ``swept too
broadly'' and extended to relationships that lacked ``trust and
confidence,'' which the court stated were hallmarks of the
common law fiduciary relationship that Congress intended to
incorporate into the statutory definitions.\28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\Mkt. Synergy Grp., Inc. v. Acosta, No. 17-3038 (10th Cir. Mar.
13, 2018); Mkt. Synergy Grp., Inc. v. U.S. Dep't of Labor, 16-CV 4083-
DDC KGS, (D. Kan. Feb. 17, 2017); Chamber of Com. of the U.S. et al. v.
Hugler, No. 3:16-cv-1476-M (N.D. Tex. Feb. 8, 2017); Nat'l Ass'n for
Fixed Annuities v. Perez, 16-cv-1035, 2016 WL 6573480 (D.D.C. Nov. 4,
2016); Thrivent Fin. for Lutherans v. Perez, No. 0:16-cv-03289 (D.
Minn. Sept. 29, 2016).
\27\Chamber of Com. of the U.S. et al v. Acosta, No. 17-10238 (5th
Cir. Mar. 15, 2018) (vacating the fiduciary rule in toto), http://
www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/17/17-10238-CV0.pdf.
\28\Retirement Security Rule, supra note 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the Committee markup of H.J. Res. 142, Rep. Rick
Allen (R-GA) said that the Retirement Security Rule is
``nothing more than a revival of an Obama-era regulation.''\29\
This assertion is not accurate. Unlike the 2016 Obama-era
fiduciary rule, the Retirement Security Rule applies only where
it is reasonable to conclude that the advice is individualized,
and that the investor may trust and rely upon that advice.
Moreover, the Retirement Security Rule leaves all business
models intact, including commission-based sales. In contrast
with the 2016 Obama-era fiduciary rule, the Retirement Security
Rule does not require firms to execute contracts warranting
compliance.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\Comm. on Educ. & Wrkf. Dems., Markup of H.R. 8932, H.R. 2574,
H.R. 2941, H.R. 6319, and H.J. Res. 142, YouTube (July 10, 2024),
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KimMkV0D0pM [hereinafter July 10
Markup].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Retirement Security Rule Was the Result of a Full and Fair
Regulatory Process
During the Committee markup of H.J. Res. 142, Rep. Allen
also said that ``DOL's comment process evidenced virtually no
interest in public comments, a clear violation of the
Administration [sic] Procedure Act.''\30\ This statement is not
accurate. DOL provided a 60-day public comment process and
received over 400 individual comments and just under 20,000
petition submissions.\31\ DOL also held a virtual public
hearing on December 12-13, 2023, at which over 40 witnesses
testified.\32\ DOL indicated that it ``made certain changes and
clarifications in the final rule in response to public comments
on the proposal and the testimony presented at the public
hearings.''\33\ For instance, the final rule ``narrows the
contexts in which a covered recommendation will constitute
ERISA fiduciary investment advice.''\34\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\Id.
\31\Retirement Security Rule, supra note 8.
\32\Id.
\33\Id.
\34\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Biden-Harris Administration's thoughtful and thorough
process for the Retirement Security Rule appears to be
consistent with the Administrative Procedure Act and represents
a clear contrast with how the Trump-era DOL handled a similar
rulemaking. After the Fifth Circuit vacated the Obama-era
fiduciary rule, the Trump Administration took regulatory
action.\35\ The Trump-era DOL reinstated the deficient five-
part test as a final rule without any public comment. It also
issued a proposed Prohibited Transaction Exemption (PTE) to
ERISA and provided only 30-days for the public to comment.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\See U.S. Dep't of Labor, Improving Investment Advice for
Workers & Retirees, 85 Fed. Reg. 40,834 (July 7, 2020) (to be codified
at 29 C.F.R. pt. 2550) https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2020-07-
07/pdf/2020-14261.pdf and U.S. Dep't of Labor, Conflict of Interest
Rule--Retirement Investment Advice: Notice of Court Vacatur, 85 Fed.
Reg. 40,589 (July 7, 2020) (to be codified at 29 C.F.R. pts. 2509 &
2510), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2020-07-07/pdf/2020-
14260.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Related Rules are No Substitute for the Retirement Security Rule
During the Committee markup of H.J. Res. 1