Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 9533]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 9533) to amend the Endangered Species Act of
1973 to optimize conservation through resource prioritization,
incentivize wildlife conservation on private lands, provide for
greater incentives to recover listed species, create greater
transparency and accountability in recovering listed species,
and limit reasonable and prudent measures, having considered
the same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``ESA Amendments Act
of 2024''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Endangered Species Act of 1973 definitions.
Sec. 3. Authorization of appropriations.
Sec. 4. Rule of construction.
TITLE I--OPTIMIZING CONSERVATION THROUGH RESOURCE PRIORITIZATION
Sec. 101. Prioritization of listing petitions, reviews, and
determinations.
TITLE II--INCENTIVIZING WILDLIFE CONSERVATION ON PRIVATE LANDS
Sec. 201. Candidate Conservation Agreements with Assurances.
Sec. 202. Designation of critical habitat.
TITLE III--PROVIDING FOR GREATER INCENTIVES TO RECOVER LISTED SPECIES
Sec. 301. Protective regulations under Endangered Species Act of 1973.
Sec. 302. 5-year review determinations.
Sec. 303. Judicial review during monitoring period.
Sec. 304. Codification of regulation.
TITLE IV--CREATING GREATER TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN
RECOVERING LISTED SPECIES
Sec. 401. Requirement to publish basis for listings on Internet.
Sec. 402. Decisional transparency and use of State, Tribal, and local
information.
Sec. 403. Disclosure of expenditures under Endangered Species Act of
1973.
Sec. 404. Award of litigation costs to prevailing parties in accordance
with existing law.
Sec. 405. Analysis of impacts and benefits of determination of
endangered or threatened status.
TITLE V--LIMITATION ON REASONABLE AND PRUDENT MEASURES
Sec. 501. Limitation on reasonable and prudent measures.
SEC. 2. ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973 DEFINITIONS.
(a) Foreseeable Future.--The final rule titled ``Endangered and
Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Regulations for Listing Species and
Designating Critical Habitat'' (84 Fed. Reg. 45020; published August
27, 2019) shall have the force and effect of law with respect to the
use of the term ``foreseeable future''.
(b) Habitat.--Section 3(5) of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16
U.S.C. 1532(5)) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(D) For the purposes of designating critical habitat under
this Act, the term `habitat' means the abiotic and biotic
setting that currently or periodically contains the resources
and conditions necessary to support 1 or more life processes of
a species.''.
(c) Environmental Baseline.--Section 7(a) of the Endangered Species
Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1536(a)) is amended by adding at the end the
following:
``(5) For the purposes of carrying out a consultation under this
section with respect to a threatened species or an endangered species,
the term `environmental baseline'--
``(A) means the condition of the species or the critical
habitat of the species in the action area, without the
consequences to the species or the critical habitat of the
species caused by the proposed action; and
``(B) includes--
``(i) the past and present effects of all Federal,
State, and private actions and other human activities
in the action area;
``(ii) the anticipated effects of each proposed
Federal project within the action area for which a
consultation under this section has been completed;
``(iii) the effects of State and private actions that
are contemporaneous with the consultation in process;
and
``(iv) the ongoing impacts to listed species or
designated critical habitat from existing facilities or
activities that are not caused by the proposed action
or that are not within the discretion of the Federal
action agency to modify.''.
SEC. 3. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.
Section 15 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1542) is
amended--
(1) in subsection (a)--
(A) by striking ``subsection (b), (c), and (d)'' and
inserting ``subsections (b) and (c)'';
(B) in paragraph (1)--
(i) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal year
1991,''; and
(ii) by inserting ``, and $302,025,000 for
each of fiscal years 2025 through 2030'' after
``fiscal year 1992'';
(C) in paragraph (2)--
(i) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal years
1989 and 1990,''; and
(ii) by inserting ``, and $116,630,000 for
each of fiscal years 2025 through 2030'' after
``fiscal years 1991 and 1992''; and
(D) in paragraph (3)--
(i) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal years
1989 and 1990,''; and
(ii) by inserting ``and $2,600,000 for each
of fiscal years 2025 through 2030'' after
``fiscal years 1991 and 1992,'';
(2) in subsection (b), by inserting ``and $600,000 for each
of fiscal years 2025 through 2030'' after ``1992''; and
(3) in subsection (c)--
(A) by striking ``and'' after ``fiscal years 1988,
1989, and 1990,''; and
(B) by inserting ``and $9,900,000 for each of fiscal
years 2025 through 2030,'' after ``fiscal years 1991
and 1992,''.
SEC. 4. RULE OF CONSTRUCTION.
Nothing in this Act or the amendments made by this Act may be
construed to enlarge or diminish the authority, jurisdiction, or
responsibility of a State (as that term is defined in section 3 of the
Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1532)) to manage, control, or
regulate fish and wildlife on lands and waters, including Federal lands
and waters, within the State.
TITLE I--OPTIMIZING CONSERVATION
THROUGH RESOURCE PRIORITIZATION
SECTION 101. PRIORITIZATION OF LISTING PETITIONS, REVIEWS, AND
DETERMINATIONS.
(a) In General.--Section 4 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16
U.S.C. 1533) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(j) National Listing Work Plan.--
``(1) In general.--Not later than the date described in
paragraph (2), the Secretary shall submit to Congress a
national listing work plan that establishes, for each covered
species, a schedule for the completion during the 5-fiscal year
period beginning on October 1 of the first fiscal year after
the date of the submission of the work plan of--
``(A) findings as described in subsection (b)(3)(B)
for each such covered species;
``(B) proposed and final determinations regarding
listing each such covered species under this section;
and
``(C) proposed and final critical habitat
designations under subsection (a)(3) relating to each
such covered species.
``(2) Submission to congress.--
``(A) In general.--The Secretary shall submit to
Congress--
``(i) together with the budget request of the
Secretary for the first fiscal year that begins
not less than 365 days after the date of the
enactment of this subsection, the initial work
plan required under paragraph (1); and
``(ii) together with the budget request of
the Secretary for each fiscal year thereafter,
an updated work plan under paragraph (1).
``(B) Additional inclusions.--The Secretary shall
include with each budget request referred to in
subparagraph (A) a description of the amounts to be
requested to carry out the work plan for the fiscal
year covered by the budget request, including any
amounts requested to address emergency listings if the
Secretary identifies any emergency posing a significant
risk to the well-being of any species of fish or
wildlife or plant.
``(3) Priority.--
``(A) In general.--In developing a work plan under
this subsection, the Secretary shall assign to each
species included in the work plan a priority
classification of Priority 1 through Priority 5, such
that, as determined by the Secretary, the following
apply:
``(i) Priority 1 represents species of the
highest priority, to be designated as
critically imperiled and in need of immediate
action.
``(ii) Priority 2 represents species with
respect to which the best scientific and
commercial data available support a clear
decision regarding the status of the species.
``(iii) Priority 3 represents species with
respect to which studies regarding the status
of the species are being carried out--
``(I) to answer key questions that
may influence the findings of a
petition to list the species submitted
under subsection (b)(3); and
``(II) to resolve any uncertainty
regarding the status of the species
within a reasonable timeframe.
``(iv) Priority 4 represents species for
which proactive conservation efforts likely to
reduce threats to the species are being
developed or carried out, within a reasonable
timeframe and in an organized manner, by
Federal agencies, States, landowners, or other
stakeholders.
``(v) Priority 5 represents species--
``(I) for which there exists little
information regarding--
``(aa) threats to the
species; or
``(bb) the status of the
species; or
``(II) that would receive limited
conservation benefit in the foreseeable
future by listing the species as a
threatened species or endangered
species under this section.
``(B) Use of methodology.--The Secretary shall
establish and assign priority classifications under
subparagraph (A) in accordance with the notice of the
Director of the United States Fish and Wildlife Service
titled `Methodology for Prioritizing Status Reviews and
Accompanying 12-Month Findings on Petitions for Listing
Under the Endangered Species Act' (81 Fed. Reg. 49248;
published July 27, 2016).
``(C) Extensions for certain priority
classifications.--
``(i) Priority 3.--With respect to a species
classified as Priority 3 under subparagraph
(A)(iii), if the Secretary determines that
additional time would allow for more complete
data collection or the completion of studies
relating to the species, the Secretary may
retain the species under the work plan for a
period of not more than 5 years after the
deadline under paragraph (4).
``(ii) Priority 4.--With respect to a species
classified as Priority 4 under subparagraph
(A)(iv), if the Secretary determines that
existing conservation efforts continue to meet
the conservation needs of the species, the
Secretary may retain the species under the work
plan for a period of not more than 5 years
after the deadline under paragraph (4).
``(iii) Priority 5.--With respect to a
species classified as Priority 5 under
subparagraph (A)(v), the Secretary may retain
the species under the work plan for a period of
not more than 5 years after the deadline under
paragraph (4).
``(D) Revision of priority classification.--The
Secretary may revise, in accordance with subparagraph
(A), the assignment to a priority classification of a
species included in a work plan at any time during the
fiscal years to which the work plan applies.
``(E) Effect of priority classification.--The
assignment of a priority classification to a species
included in a work plan is not a final agency action.
``(4) Deadline.--The Secretary shall act on any petition to
add a species to a list published under subsection (c)
submitted under subsection (b)(3) not later than the last day
of the fiscal year specified for that petition in the most
recent work plan.
``(5) Regulations.--The Secretary may issue such regulations
as the Secretary determines appropriate to carry out this
subsection.
``(6) Effect of subsection.--Nothing in this subsection may
be construed to preclude or otherwise affect the emergency
listing authority of the Secretary under subsection (b)(7).
``(7) Definitions.--In this subsection:
``(A) Covered species.--The term `covered species'
means a species that is not included on a list
published under subsection (c)--
``(i) for which a petition to add the species
to such a list has been submitted under
subsection (b)(3); or
``(ii) that is otherwise under consideration
by the Secretary for addition to such a list.
``(B) Work plan.--The term `work plan' means the
national listing work plan submitted by the Secretary
under paragraph (1).''.
(b) Conforming Amendments.--Section 4(b)(3) of the Endangered Species
Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1533(b)(3)) is amended--
(1) in subparagraph (B), by striking ``Within 12 months'' and
inserting ``In accordance with the national listing work plan
submitted under subsection (j),''; and
(2) in subparagraph (C), to read as follows:
``(C) Judicial review.--Any negative finding
described in subparagraph (A) and any finding described
in subparagraph (B)(i)(I) shall be subject to judicial
review.''.
TITLE II--INCENTIVIZING WILDLIFE
CONSERVATION ON PRIVATE LANDS
SECTION 201. CANDIDATE CONSERVATION AGREEMENTS WITH ASSURANCES.
(a) Listing Determinations.--Section 4(b)(1) of the Endangered
Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1533(b)(1)) is amended by adding at the
end the following:
``(C) Candidate conservation agreements with
assurances.--In making a determination under subsection
(a)(1) with respect to a species, the Secretary shall
take into account and document the effect of any net
conservation benefit (as that term is defined in
subsection (k) of section 10) of any Candidate
Conservation Agreement with Assurances or any
programmatic Candidate Conservation Agreement with
Assurances (as those terms are defined in that
subsection) relating to such species.''.
(b) Candidate Conservation Agreements With Assurances.--Section 10 of
the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1539) is amended by
adding at the end the following:
``(k) Candidate Conservation Agreements With Assurances.--
``(1) Proposed agreement.--A covered party may submit a
proposed Agreement to the Secretary.
``(2) Approval.--Not later than 120 days after the date of
the receipt of a proposed Agreement under paragraph (1), the
Secretary shall approve the proposed Agreement if the Secretary
determines that the proposed Agreement--
``(A) sets forth specific management activities that
the covered party will undertake to conserve the
covered species;
``(B) provides a positive estimate of the net
conservation benefit of such management activities to
the covered species;
``(C) describes, to the maximum extent practicable,
the existing population levels of the covered species
or the existing quality of habitat;
``(D) includes a monitoring plan to be carried out by
the parties to the Agreement; and
``(E) provides assurances to the covered party that
no additional conservation measures will be required
and additional land, water, or resource use
restrictions will not be imposed on the covered party
if the covered species becomes listed after the
effective date of such Agreement.
``(3) Denial.--Not later than 120 days after the date of the
receipt of a proposed Agreement under paragraph (1), the
Secretary shall--
``(A) deny the proposed Agreement if the Secretary
Background and Need for Legislation
The Endangered Species Act (P.L. 93-205) was enacted in
1973 ``to provide a means whereby the ecosystems upon which
endangered species and threatened species depend may be
conserved, to provide a program for the conservation of such
endangered species and threatened species, and to take such
steps as may be appropriate to achieve the purposes of the
treaties and conventions set forth'' in the Act.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Endangered Species Act of 1973, 16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The last time Congress significantly amended the Endangered
Species Act (ESA or Act) was in 1988.\2\ Despite these
revisions, the main provisions of the ESA remain intact and
govern species conservation efforts today. H.R. 9533 would make
significant improvements to the ESA for the betterment of the
species it is charged with recovering and the people that are
impacted directly by its associated regulations. The bill would
also reauthorize the ESA for five fiscal years at funding
levels that correspond to the funding levels set in Fiscal Year
(FY) 2025 appropriations bills introduced in the House of
Representatives.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Public Law 100-478, the Endangered Species Act Amendment of
1988. https://www.congress.gov/100/STATUTE-102/STATUTE-102-Pg2306.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill would codify the Trump administration's framework
for determining the ``foreseeable future'' when determining
whether a species qualifies as threatened under the ESA.\3\
This means that when the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS)
and the National Marine Fisheries Service (the Services)
considers the ``foreseeable future'', it can extend only so far
into the future as the Services can reasonably determine that
both the threats and the species responses to those threats are
likely.\4\ Prior to the adoption this framework, ``foreseeable
future'' was undefined causing inconsistences in how the term
was applied. The Biden administration has signaled their
interest in rescinding this framework.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\84 FR 45020.
\4\Id.
\5\89 FR 23919.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill would also codify the Trump administration's
definition of ``habitat'' as it relates to the designation of
critical habitat. On December 16, 2020, the Services published
a final rule that defined ``habitat,'' for the purposes of
designating critical habitat as the abiotic and biotic setting
that currently or periodically contains the resources and
conditions necessary to support one or more life processes of
species.\6\ This was in response to the 2018 U.S. Supreme Court
decision in Weyerhaeuser Co. v. U.S. FWS, which stated an area
must logically be considered ``habitat'' for that area to meet
the definition of ``critical habitat'' under the ESA.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Regulations for
Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and Designating Critical
Habitat.'' 87 FR 37757. Federal Register: Endangered and Threatened
Wildlife and Plants; Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened
Species and Designating Critical Habitat.
\7\``Final Rules Amending ESA Critical Habitat Regulations.'' Erin
H. Ward and Pervaze A. Sheikh. Congressional Research Service. IF11740
(congress.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Biden administration rescinded the 2020 regulatory
definition of ``habitat'' in 2022, giving the Services
significant discretion in designating critical habitat.\8\ This
includes the ability to designate critical habitat in areas
that are not (emphasis added) currently occupied by the species
in question and in some cases, have not been occupied in
decades and may never be occupied. By codifying a definition of
``habitat'' as it relates to critical habitat, this bill
provides certainty and brings the Services in compliance with
the Weyerhaeuser decision.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\``U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and NOAA Fisheries Rescind
Regulatory Definition of ``Habitat'' Under the Endangered Species
Act.'' Marilyn Kitchell and Lauren Gaches. U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service. 6/23/2022. Rescind Regulatory Definition of ``Habitat'' Under
the Endangered Species Act U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service (fws.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill would also codify into law a definition of
``environmental baseline'' into the ESA statute. When
conducting interagency consultations on federal actions, the
Services use the environmental baseline to help determine the
effect on listed species and critical habitat by that action.
On April 5, 2024, the Services finalized a rule that mandated
the following factors be considered when calculating the
environmental baseline: (1) the past and present effects of all
activities in an action area; (2) the anticipated effects of
each proposed federal project in an action area where
consultation has been completed; (3) the effects of state and
private actions that are contemporaneous with the consultation
process; (4) the impacts to listed species or designated
critical habitat from ongoing federal agency activities or
existing federal agency facilities that are not within the
agency's discretion to modify.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\89 FR 24268.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This bill would amend and replace the fourth consideration
with: ``the ongoing impacts to listed species or critical
habitat from existing facilities or activities that are not
caused by the proposed action or that are not within the
discretion of the Federal action to modify.'' The environmental
baseline should act as a ``snapshot'' of a species health at
the time of the consultation. However, too often the Services
have used the environmental baseline to create a hypothetical
environment that ignores existing infrastructure. This would
require the Services to use a more complete picture of current
impacts to species.
Title I amends section 4 to codify into law existing
Services' efforts to address current backlogs in listing
petitions and critical habitat designation through a ``National
Listing Work Plan.''\10\ These changes would decrease the risk
of litigation in the listing process and to allow the Services
to better allocate their resources towards species most in need
of protection. The Services would be required to submit a work
plan to Congress at the beginning of each fiscal year that
covers listing actions for the next seven fiscal years. The
work plan must include information on species status reviews,
listing determinations, and critical habitat designations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\``National Listing Workplan.'' U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
National Listing Workplan U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service
(fws.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Services would be required to assign each species
included in the work plan a priority classification, with
priority 1 being the highest and priority 5 being the lowest.
For example, a priority 1 species would be classified as
critically imperiled and in need of immediate action. Whereas a
priority 5 species is a species for which little information
exists regarding threats and the status of the species.
Unfortunately, the ESA has been ineffective in
accomplishing its goal of recovering species and taking them
off the endangered species list, with only three percent of
species that have ever been listed under the act having ever
been delisted.
Private lands play a significant role in managing and the
recovery of endangered and threatened species. As Aldo Leopold
put it, ``conservation will ultimately boil down to rewarding
the private landowner who conserves the public interest.''\11\
In 2023, the FWS reported that ``two-thirds of federally listed
species have at least some habitat on private land, and some
species have most of their remaining habitat on private
land.''\12\ For example, according to the Audubon Society, more
than 80 percent of the grassland and wetlands that provide
essential bird habitat are in private ownership.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Flader, S.L., Callicott, J.B., & Leopold, A. (1992). The River
of the mother of God: and other Essays by Aldo Leopold. Madison:
University of Wisconsin Press.
\12\``ESA Basics: 50 Years of Conserving Endangered Species.'' U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service. 2/1/23. Endangered Species Act Basics
(fws.gov).
\13\Wilsey1, CB, J Grand, J Wu, N Michel, J Grogan-Brown, B Trusty.
2019. North American Grasslands. National Audubon Society, New York,
New York, USA. https://nas-national-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/
audubon_north_american_grasslands_birds_report-final.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To incentivize private landowners to invest in wildlife
conservation on their lands, the legislation amends the ESA to
provide regulatory certainty to private landowners. This is
done by codifying into law Candidate Conservation Agreements
(CCAs) and Candidate Conservation Agreements with Assurances
(CCAAs). These agreements allow private landowners to commit to
implementing voluntary actions designed to reduce threats to a
species that is a candidate to be listed under the ESA. In
return, if the species is listed, landowners who are a part of
the agreement would be able to continue their operations should
a listing take place. Currently, these agreements only exist
through executive action and secretarial orders, giving the
Services great discretion in how they take these agreements
into account when making listing decisions. The bill explicitly
states that the Services must take the conservation benefit of
these agreements into account when making listing decisions.
In addition, the legislation would give private landowners
who are investing in, or want to invest in, habitat
conservation on their lands the regulatory certainty to do so.
Specifically, the bill prohibits the Services from designating
critical habitat on private lands that are implementing habitat
conservation and restoration actions designed to conserve the
species in question and approved by the Services. This language
mirrors language from the Sikes Act (16 U.S.C. 670a), which
prevents critical habitat designations on lands controlled by
the Department of Defense if those lands are implementing
approved habitat conservation measures.
The ESA requires the Services to ``cooperate to the maximum
extent practicable with the states'' in implementing the Act,
including ``consultation with the States concerned before
acquiring any land or water, or interest therein, for the
purpose of conserving any endangered species or threatened
species.''\14\ Unfortunately, over the course of the ESA's
fifty-year history, states have often been left out of the
process, with power being consolidated in the hands of
officials at the Services. Title III reasserts congressional
intent by giving regulatory incentives and opportunities for
states in the ESA process.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Endangered Species act of 1973, 16 U.S.C., 1531-1544 (1973).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 9 prohibits the ``take'' of an endangered species.
Take is defined as to ``harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot,
wound, kill, trap, capture or collect, or to attempt to engage
in any such conduct.''\15\ The Act, however, does not
automatically apply the same prohibitions to threatened
species. Instead, Section 4(d) gives the Services the
discretion to grant some exceptions to the take prohibitions
for threatened species.\16\ While National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has taken advantage of this
flexibility,\17\ the FWS continues to take steps to manage
threatened species as endangered species, counter to
congressional intent.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\16 USC Ch. 35. Sec 1532.
\16\USC Ch. 35. Sec 1533.
\17\88 FR 40742.
\18\Revisions of the Regulation for Prohibitions to Threatened
Wildlife and Plants.'' Megan E. Jenkins and Camille Wardle. The Center
for Growth and Opportunity at Utah State University. 10/17/18.
Regulations for Prohibitions to Threatened Wildlife and Plants--The
CGO.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FWS began issuing 4(d) rules in 1974, but in 1975 they
finalized what has become known as the ``blanket 4(d) rule''
(blanket rule).\19\ This rule allowed the FWS to extend all
Section 9 prohibitions to threatened species unless a specific
4(d) rule for the species was drafted that exempted certain
activities from those prohibitions. The blanket rule
effectively removes incentives for parties impacted by
threatened species and any of the benefits that result in
downlisting a listed species because no regulatory burdens are
lowered. In 2019, the Trump administration finalized a
rulemaking that took away FWS's ability to blanket rules,\20\
but this rule was rescinded by the Biden administration earlier
this year.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\``Unlocking the Full Power of Section 4(d) to Facilitate
Collaboration and Greater Species Recovery.'' David Willms, J.D.
https://republicans-naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/
Codex_II_Chapter_3.pdf.
\20\84 FR 44753.
\21\89 FR 23919.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The legislation changes this dynamic by requiring the
Services to include the following whenever they issue a 4(d)
rule that contains take prohibitions: (1) objective,
incremental recovery goals for the species in question; (2)
provide for the stringency of the prohibitions to decrease as
such recovery goals are met; and (3) provide for state
management of the species once all recovery goals are met in
preparation for the species being delisted.
These steps create greater accountability, transparency,
and incentives to take conservation actions that restore
habitat for and recover listed species because tangible
regulatory relief will come with it. The bill also adopts a
similar approach for the recovery of species listed as
endangered. Specifically, the bill requires the Services to
propose objective and incremental recovery goals for endangered
species. Those goals would form the basis for a 4(d) rule when
the species is downlisted to threatened species status.
This gives states the opportunity to propose a ``recovery
strategy'' for threatened species and species that are
candidates for listing in that state. The bill requires the
Services to review the proposed recovery strategy and determine
whether (1) the state would be able to implement the strategy
and (2) whether that strategy would be effective in conserving
the species in question. If it is determined that both of those
tests are satisfied, the strategy is approved, and it would
become the regulation governing the species in that state.
In addition, the bill amends the definition of
``conserve,'' ``conserving,'' and ``conservation'' to allow for
the regulated take of threatened species. Currently, the
definition only allows for regulated take ``in the
extraordinary case where population pressures within a given
ecosystem cannot be otherwise relieved.''\22\ This standard has
been interpreted by federal courts to mostly prohibit any
regulated take of threatened species.\23\ This raises tensions
with the public, who have no means to control populations of
listed species, even when the population of that species is
well above its population goals. Additionally, it amends the
definition to allow for regulated take ``at the discretion of
the Secretary,'' therefore granting additional flexibility to
the Services.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\16 USC Ch. 35. Sec 1532.
\23\``Unlocking the Full Power of Section 4(d) to Facilitate
Collaboration and Greater Species Recovery.'' David Willms, J.D.
https://republicans-naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/
Codex_II_Chapter_3.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title III would also amend section 4(g) to require the
Services to monitor, in cooperation with the states, the status
of a species for no less than five years after it is delisted
to ensure it does require relisting. A provision is included
which prohibits judicial review on the delisting of species
during the five-year post-delisting monitoring period. There
are many examples of species that have been successfully
delisted through rigorous scientific decisions, such as wolves
and grizzly bears, only to have a court overrule that decision.
Title IV amends the ESA to require the ``best scientific
and commercial data available'' used to make listing and
critical habitat decision be readily available and accessible
online. ESA-related regulations are often controversial and
impact the public in many ways, including land use, access to
natural resources, and the value of property. In many cases,
all the public gets to see is the result of a decision-making
process, but not what led to that decision being made. The bill
gives the public the ability to understand what the Services
identified as the ``best scientific and commercial data
available.''
Additionally, the Services would be required to coordinate
with states when making listing and critical habitat decisions.
Before finalizing an ESA regulation, the Services must provide
each affected state the data used as the basis of a regulation.
The bill defines ``best scientific and commercial data
available'' to include all such data submitted to the Services
by state, tribal, and local governments.
The Services would be required to disclose to Congress and
make publicly available, each fiscal year, all federal
government expenditures on ESA-related lawsuits. The ESA has
become a magnet for lawsuits designed to frustrate the process
laid out in the underlying statute, with the Services often
settling with litigious environmental groups.
Lastly, Title IV requires an analysis of the economic
impacts, national security impacts, and any other relevant
impacts concurrently with any listing decision. This section
wouldn't preclude a species from being listed for economic and
national security reasons but would give the public necessary
information on how a listing may impact them.
Committee Action
H.R. 9533 was introduced on September 10, 2024, by Chairman
Bruce Westerman (R-AR). The bill was referred to the Committee
on Natural Resources. On July 9, 2024, the Subcommittee on
Water, Wildlife and Fisheries held a hearing on the discussion
draft of this bill. On September 19, 2024, the Committee on
Natural Resources met to consider the bill. Chairman Bruce
Westerman (R-AR) offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute designated Westerman_097 ANS. The amendment in the
nature of a substitute was agreed to by voice vote.
Representative Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered an amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Huffman #1.
The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 13 yeas
to 20 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Representative Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered an amendment to
the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Huffman
#2. The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 13
yeas to 20 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Representative Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered an amendment to
the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Huffman
#8. The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 12
yeas to 22 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Representative Katie Porter (D-CA) offered an amendment to
the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Porter
#4 revised. The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote
of 13 yeas to 21 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Representative Katie Porter (D-CA) offered an amendment to
the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute designated Porter
#7. The amendment was not agreed to by a roll call vote of 13
yeas to 21 nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
The bill, as amended, was ordered favorably reported to the
House of Representatives by a roll call vote of 22 yeas to 13
nays, as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries
held on the discussion draft of this legislation on July 9,
2024.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title; Table of Contents
Defines this Act may be cited as the ``ESA Amendments Act
of 2024''.
Definitions
Codifies the definition of the ``foreseeable future'' that
was adopted by the Trump administration in a 2019 rulemaking.
The bill would also codify the definition of ``habitat'' as it
relates to critical habitat that was adopted by the Trump
administration and codify a definition of ``environmental
baseline'' in the Section 7 consultation process that includes
considering the impacts of existing infrastructure that are not
caused by the proposed action or that are not within the
discretion of the federal action agency to modify.
TITLE I. OPTIMIZING CONSERVATION THROUGH
RESOURCE PRIORITIZATION
Codifies the structure of the listing work plan to create
flexibility on listing timelines in times where too many
petitions are being submitted relative to the capacity of the
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and National Marine Fisheries
Service (the Services) to process them.
TITLE II. INCENTIVIZING WILDLIFE CONSERVATION ON PRIVATE LANDS
Codifies into statute the need for the Services to consider
the net conservation benefit of Candidate Conservation
Agreements with Assurance (CCAA's) or any programmatic CCAA's
for a species when making a listing decision on that species
under the ESA. Would also replicate, on private lands, language
from the Sikes Act (16 U.S.C. 670a) giving regulatory certainty
that critical habitat will not be designated if a landowner is
working to implement a land management plan that conserves the
listed species in question.
TITLE III. PROVIDING FOR GREATER INCENTIVES TO RECOVER
LISTED SPECIES
Amends Section 4(d) to require the Services to establish
objective, incremental recovery goals for threatened species,
provide for the stringency of regulations to decrease as
recovery goals are met, and provide for state management of
that species once all recovery goals are met in preparation for
delisting. Would allow states to develop and submit recovery
strategies to the Services for species that are candidates for
listing or listed as threatened. If the Services determine that
the proposed recovery strategy would be effective in conserving
the species, it will become the regulation governing the
management of the species in that state. For species listed as
endangered, the Services must develop objective incremental
recovery goals that would form the basis of a regulation under
Section 4(d) once a species is upgraded to threatened. The bill
would also require the Services to act on 5-year review
determinations of listed species and prohibit judicial review
within the 5-year monitoring period after a species is
delisted. The bill would also codify into the 2019 final rule
from the Trump Administration that prohibited the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service from adopted ``blanket'' 4(d) rules.
TITLE IV. CREATING GREATER TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
IN RECOVERING LISTED SPECIES
Requires the Services to make publicly available on the
internet the best scientific and commercial data available that
are used as the basis for listing and critical habitat
determinations. This title would provide exceptions for data
that states, or the Department of Defense do not want to be
made publicly available. The Services would also be required to
disclose to states affected by a listing or critical habitat
determination all data used to make that determination. The
definition of ``best scientific and commercial data available''
would be amended to include all such data submitted to the
Secretary by a state, Tribal, or county government. Requires
the Services to disclose to Congress all costs associated with
ESA-related lawsuits. Places a cap on the award of attorney's
fees to successful litigants in line with the Equal Access to
Justice Act. It also requires an analysis of the economic
impacts and national security impacts of each listing and
critical habitat determination. Clarifies that these analyses
do not change the listing criteria set out by the ESA.
TITLE V. LIMITATION ON REASONABLE AND PRUDENT MEASURES
Amends Section 7(b)(4) of the ESA to clarify that the
Services cannot require federal agencies or project applicants
to fully mitigate or offset impacts to listed species caused by
an action.
Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
Compliance With House Rule XIII and
Congressional Budget Act
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of House rule XIII and section
308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, and pursuant to
clause 3(c)(3) of House rule XIII and section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has requested
but not received from the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office a budgetary analysis and a cost estimate of this bill.
2. General Performance Goals and Objectives. As required by
clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general performance goal or
objective of this bill is to amend the Endangered Species Act
of 1973 to optimize conservation through resource
prioritization, incentivize wildlife conservation on private
lands, provide for greater incentives to recover listed
species, create greater transparency and accountability in
recovering listed species, and limit reasonable and prudent
measures.
Earmark Statement
This bill does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined
under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Statement
An estimate of federal mandates prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 423 of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act was not made available to the
Committee in time for the filing of this report. The Chair of
the Committee shall cause such estimate to be printed in the
Congressional Record upon its receipt by the Committee, if such
estimate is not publicly available on the Congressional Budget
Office website.
Existing Programs
Directed Rule Making. This bill does not contain any
directed rule makings.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This bill does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Preemption of State, Local or Tribal Law
Any preemptive effect of this bill over state, local, or
tribal law is intended to be consistent with the bill's
purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
U.S. Constitution.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of
the United States of America in Congress assembled, That this
Act may be cited as the ``Endangered Species Act of 1973''.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Sec. 2. Findings, purposes, and policy.
* * * * * * *
[Sec. 13. Conforming amendments.]
Sec. 13. Disclosure of expenditures.
* * * * * * *
definitions
Sec. 3. For the purposes of this Act--
(1) The term ``alternative courses of action'' means all
alternatives and thus is not limited to original project
objectives and agency jurisdiction.
(2) The term ``best scientific and commercial data
available'' includes data submitted to the Secretary by a
State, Tribal, or county government.
[(2)] (3) The term ``commercial activity'' means all
activities of industry and trade, including, but not limited
to, the buying or selling of commodities and activities
conducted for the purpose of facilitating such buying and
selling: Provided, however, That it does not include
exhibitions of commodities by museums or similar cultural or
historical organizations.
[(3)] (4) The terms ``conserve,''``conserving,'' and
``conservation'' mean to use and the use of all methods and
procedures which are necessary to bring any endangered species
or threatened species to the point at which the measures
provided pursuant to this Act are no longer necessary. Such
methods and procedures include, but are not limited to, all
activities associated with scientific resources management such
as research, census, law enforcement, habitat acquisition and
maintenance, propagation, live trapping, [and transplantation,
and, in the extraordinary case where population pressures
within a given ecosystem cannot be otherwise relieved, may
include] transplantation, and, at the discretion of the
Secretary, regulated taking.
[(4)] (5) The term ``Convention'' means the Convention on
International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and
Flora, signed on March 3, 1973, and the appendices thereto.
[(5)] (6)(A) The term ``critical habitat'' for a threatened
or endangered species means--
(i) the specific areas within the geographical area
occupied by the species, at the time it is listed in
accordance with the provisions of section 4 of this
Act, on which are found those physical or biological
features (I) essential to the conservation of the
species and (II) which may require special management
considerations or protection; and
(ii) specific areas outside the geographical area
occupied by the species at the time it is listed in
accordance with the provisions of section 4 of this
Act, upon a determination by the Secretary that such
areas are essential for the conservation of the
species.
(B) Critical habitat may be established for those species now
listed as threatened or endangered species for which no
critical habitat has heretofore been established as set forth
in subparagraph (A) of this paragraph.
(C) Except in those circumstances determined by the
Secretary, critical habitat shall not include the entire
geographical area which can be occupied by the threatened or
endangered species.
(D) For the purposes of designating critical habitat under
this Act, the term ``habitat'' means the abiotic and biotic
setting that currently or periodically contains the resources
and conditions necessary to support 1 or more life processes of
a species.
[(6)] (7) The term ``endangered species'' means any species
which is in danger of extinction throughout all or a
significant portion of its range other than a species of the
Class Insecta determined by the Secretary to constitute a pest
whose protection under the provisions of this Act would present
an overwhelming and overriding risk to man.
[(7)] (8) The term ``Federal agency'' means any department,
agency, or instrumentality of the United States.
[(8)] (9) The term ``fish or wildlife'' means any member of
the animal kingdom, including without limitation any mammal,
fish, bird (including any migratory, nonmigratory, or
endangered bird for which protection is also afforded by treaty
or other international agreement), amphibian, reptile, mollusk,
crustacean, arthropod or other invertebrate, and includes any
part, product, egg, or offspring thereof, or the dead body or
parts thereof.
[(9)] (10) The term ``foreign commerce'' includes, among
other things, any transaction--
(A) between persons within one foreign country;
(B) between persons in two or more foreign countries;
(C) between a person within the United States and a
person in a foreign country; or
(D) between persons within the United States, where
the fish and wildlife in question are moving in any
country or countries outside the United States.
[(10)] (11) The term ``import'' means to land on, bring into,
or introduce into or attempt to land on, bring into, or
introduce into, any place subject to the jurisdiction of the
United States, whether or not such landing, bringing, or
introduction constitutes an importation within the meaning of
the customs laws of the United States.
(12) The term ``permit or license applicant'' means, when
used with respect to an action of a Federal agency for which
exemption is sought under section 7, any person whose
application to such agency for a permit or license has been
denied primarily because of the application of section 7(a) to
such agency action.
(13) The term ``person'' means an individual, corporation,
partnership, trust, association, or any other private entity;
or any officer, employee, agent, department, or instrumentality
of the Federal Government, of any State, municipality, or
political subdivision of a State, or of any foreign government;
any State, municipality, or political subdivision of a State;
or any other entity subject to the jurisdiction of the United
States.
(14) The term ``plant'' means any member of the plant
kingdom, including seeds, roots and other parts thereof.
(15) The term ``Secretary'' means, except as otherwise herein
provided, the Secretary of the Interior or the Secretary of
Commerce as program responsibilities are vested pursuant to the
provisions of Reorganization Plan Numbered 4 of 1970; except
that with respect to the enforcement of the provisions of this
Act and the Convention which pertain to the importation or
exportation of terrestrial plants, the term also means the
Secretary of Agriculture.
(16) The term ``species'' includes any subspecies of fish or
wildlife or plants, and any distinct population segment of any
species of vertebrate fish or wildlife which interbreeds when
mature.
(17) The term ``State'' means any of the several States, the
District of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, American
Samoa, the Virgin Islands, Guam, and the Trust Territory of the
Pacific Islands.
(18) The term ``State agency'' means any State agency,
department, board, commission, or other governmental entity
which is responsible for the management and conservation of
fish, plant, or wildlife resources within a State.
(19) The term ``take'' means to harass, harm, pursue, hunt,
shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect, or to attempt to
engage in any such conduct.
(20) The term ``threatened species'' means any species which
is likely to become an endangered species within the
foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of
its range.
(21) The term ``United States,'' when used in a geographical
context, includes all States.
determination of endangered species and threatened species
Sec. 4. (a) General.--(1) The Secretary shall by regulation
promulgated in accordance with subsection (b) determine whether
any species is an endangered species or a threatened species
because of any of the following factors:
(A) the present or threatened destruction,
modification, or curtailment of its habitat or range;
(B) overutilization for commercial, recreational,
scientific, or educational purposes;
(C) disease or predation;
(D) the inadequacy of existing regulatory mechanisms;
or
(E) other natural or manmade factors affecting its
continued existence.
(2) With respect to any species over which program
responsibilities have been vested in the Secretary of Commerce
pursuant to Reorganization Plan Numbered 4 of 1970--
(A) in any case in which the Secretary of Commerce
determines that such species should--
(i) be listed as an endangered species or a
threatened species, or
(ii) be changed in status from a threatened
species to an endangered species, he shall so
inform the Secretary of the Interior, who shall
list such species in accordance with this
section;
(B) in any case in which the Secretary of Commerce
determines that such species should--
(i) be removed from any list published
pursuant to subsection (c) of this section, or
(ii) be changed in status from an endangered
species to a threatened species, he shall
recommend such action to the Secretary of the
Interior, and the Secretary of the Interior, if
he concurs in the recommendation, shall
implement such action; and
(C) the Secretary of the Interior may not list or
remove from any list any such species, and may not
change the status of any such species which are listed,
without a prior favorable determination made pursuant
to this section by the Secretary of Commerce.
(3)(A) The Secretary, by regulation promulgated in accordance
with subsection (b) and to the maximum extent prudent and
determinable--
(i) shall, concurrently with making a determination
under paragraph (1) that a species is an endangered
species or a threatened species, designate any habitat
of such species which is then considered to be critical
habitat; and
(ii) may, from time-to-time thereafter as
appropriate, revise such designation.
(B)(i) The Secretary shall not designate as critical habitat
any lands or other geographical areas owned or controlled by
the Department of Defense, or designated for its use, that are
subject to an integrated natural resources management plan
prepared under section 101 of the Sikes Act (16 U.S.C. 670a),
if the Secretary determines in writing that such plan provides
a benefit to the species for which critical habitat is proposed
for designation.
(ii) Nothing in this paragraph affects the requirement to
consult under section 7(a)(2) with respect to an agency action
(as that term is defined in that section).
(iii) Nothing in this paragraph affects the obligation of the
Department of Defense to comply with section 9, in
Dissenting Views
H.R. 9533, the ``ESA Amendments Act of 2024,'' would weaken
the authority and effectiveness of the Endangered Species Act
(ESA). It would codify several 2019 Trump administration--era
ESA rules weakening protections for threatened and endangered
species and their critical habitat and requiring economic
analyses that should remain outside the science-based decision-
making process. The bill would increase the timeframe for
listing species while fast-tracking de-listing and blocking
judicial review. It would create narrow definitions for key
terms to limit the scope of ESA consultations and require that
``best available science'' include information from states,
tribes, and local communities without regard for the quality of
the data. The bill would also create new, burdensome reporting
requirements for ESA-related agency litigation and cap awards
of litigation costs to disincentivize accountability.
Human-related impacts, including habitat destruction,
invasive species, disease, and climate change, threaten many
species of wildlife and plants. One million species globally
are threatened with extinction.\1\ In the United States, 34% of
plants and 40% of animals are at risk of extinction, and 41% of
our ecosystems are at risk of range-wide collapse.\2\ The loss
of biodiversity and ecosystems worldwide could lead to a global
GDP loss of $2.7 trillion annually by 2030.\3\ In light of this
extinction crisis, the ESA is a critical tool for preventing
extinction and putting imperiled species on the road to
recovery. It is ``the most comprehensive legislation for the
preservation of endangered species enacted by any nation.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\IPBES (2019): Global assessment report on biodiversity and
ecosystem services of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on
Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services. E.S. Brondizio, J. Settele, S.
Diaz, and H.T. Ngo (editors). IPBES secretariat, Bonn, Germany. https:/
/doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3831673.
\2\NatureServe https://www.natureserve.org/sites/default/files/
NatureServe_BiodiversityInFocus
Report_medium.pdf.
\3\Johnson, Justin Andrew; Ruta, Giovanni; Baldos, Uris; Cervigni,
Raffaello; Chonabayashi, Shun; Corong, Erwin; Gavryliuk, Olga; Gerber,
James; Hertel, Thomas; Nootenboom, Christopher; Polasky, Stephen;
Gerber, James; Ruta, Giovanni; Polasky, Stephen. 2021. The Economic
Case for Nature: A Global Earth-Economy Model to Assess Development
Policy Pathways. World Bank, Washington, DC. http://hdl.handle.net/
10986/35882 License: CC BY 3.0 IGO.
\4\TVA v. Hill, 473 U.S. 153, 180 (1978).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This bill would extend the deadlines to list some species
from the mandatory 12-month deadline to 5 years. It provides no
course of action should the Secretary misclassify a species to
a lower priority, allowing for administrative misconduct to
legally delay the listing for a species. The bill would fast-
track the de-listing of species by requiring a rulemaking
within 30 days of the five-year review and then prevent any
judicial review of a de-listing decision for the next five
years. These changes would make it harder for species to be
listed and then easier for them to be de-listed prematurely,
with little recourse to challenge either action.
This bill is filled with harmful definitions that are a
departure from the decades of established, working definitions.
It expands ``Best scientific and commercial data available'' to
include all data from ``State, tribal or county governments,''
regardless of its quality. The best science should be about the
quality of the data--not the source. It would also exclude
unoccupied habitat from the definition of critical habitat--
regardless of whether it was historically where these species
were found but no longer are, or if the unoccupied habitat is
suitable for species recovery and would thus help save them
from extinction. This includes precluding the designation of
critical habitat for ``any privately owned or controlled land
or other geographical area'' subject to a land management plan
that meets their criteria.
This bill would also put threatened species in peril by
removing the blanket 4(d) rule, which guarantees the same
comprehensive and immediate protection for threatened species
afforded to endangered species. The bill would also push
threatened species recovery onto states without clear and
objective science-based recovery goals. States can already
manage ESA-listed species under Section 6(c) of the ESA but
have not used the authority. The bill would reinstate a
shortsighted definition for critical habitat and block
directives to mitigate the impacts of actions on threatened and
endangered species.
The Republican attempts to undermine the ESA would hinder
the ability to protect species from extinction, no matter how
close to extinction a species may be or what the best available
science says about the status, recovery, or management.
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member.
[all]