Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 8914]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Ways and Means, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 8914) to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to
impose penalties with respect to civil rights violations by
certain tax-exempt educational institutions, having considered
the same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND........................................... 3
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 3
B. Background and Need for Legislation................. 4
C. Legislative History................................. 4
D. Designated Hearing.................................. 5
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL.......................................... 5
A. Penalties with Respect to Civil Rights Violations by
Certain Tax-exempt Educational Institutions (sec. 2
of the bill and new sec. 6720D of the Code)........ 5
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE........................................... 10
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL...................................... 11
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects............. 11
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax
Expenditures Budget Authority...................... 11
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office............................................. 11
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE...... 13
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations.... 13
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and
Objectives......................................... 13
C. Applicability of House Rule XXI, Clause 5(b)........ 13
D. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates........... 13
E. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and
Limited Tariff Benefits............................ 13
F. Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 13
G. Tax Complexity Analysis............................. 14
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED........... 14
A. Changes in Existing Law Proposed by the Bill, as
Reported........................................... 14
VII. DISSENTING VIEWS................................................ 52
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``University Accountability Act''.
SEC. 2. PENALTIES WITH RESPECT TO CIVIL RIGHTS VIOLATIONS BY CERTAIN
TAX-EXEMPT EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS.
(a) In General.--Part I of subchapter B of chapter 68 of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986 is amended by adding at the end the following new
section:
``SEC. 6720D. CIVIL RIGHTS VIOLATIONS BY CERTAIN TAX-EXEMPT EDUCATIONAL
INSTITUTIONS.
``(a) In General.--There is hereby imposed a penalty equal to the
applicable penalty amount on a specified tax-exempt educational
institution with respect to each determination of civil rights
violation with respect to such institution.
``(b) Timing of Liability.--
``(1) In general.--A specified tax-exempt educational
institution shall be liable for the penalty imposed under
subsection (a) with respect to any determination of civil
rights violation on the date of the judgment referred to in
subsection (c).
``(2) Reversal of determinations.--In the event that any
determination of civil rights violation is vacated, overturned,
or otherwise reversed, the Secretary shall refund any penalty
paid with respect to the determination of civil rights
violation. The preceding sentence shall not be interpreted to
prevent the application of this section with respect to any
determination of civil rights violation that is reinstated or
otherwise redetermined following any such reversal.
``(c) Determination of Civil Rights Violation.--For purposes of this
section--
``(1) In general.--The term `determination of civil rights
violation' means, with respect to any specified tax-exempt
educational institution, any civil judgment of a Federal court
of competent jurisdiction that such institution violated any
provision of title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
``(2) Authority to treat certain judgments as a single
determination of civil rights violation.--If the Secretary
determines that two or more judgments are based on the same set
of facts and circumstances, such judgments shall be treated as
a single determination of civil rights violation for purposes
of this section, section 501(s), and such provisions of section
6033(o) as the Secretary determines appropriate.
``(d) Applicable Penalty Amount.--For purposes of this section--
``(1) In general.--The term `applicable penalty amount'
means, with respect to each determination of civil rights
violation made with respect to any specified tax-exempt
educational institution, the greater of--
``(A) $100,000, or
``(B) in the case of an institution subject to the
requirements of section 6033(a), 5 percent of the
aggregate administrative compensation paid by such
specified tax-exempt educational institution during the
taxable year in which such violation occurred.
``(2) Administrative compensation.--The term `administrative
compensation' means, with respect to any specified tax-exempt
educational institution, the compensation and other payments
described in section 6033(b)(7) made by such institution.
``(e) Specified Tax-exempt Educational Institution.--For purposes of
this section, the term `specified tax-exempt educational institution'
means any eligible educational institution (as defined in section
25A(f)(2)) which is described in section 501(c) or section
511(a)(2)(B).
``(f) Waiver of Limitations on Assessment and Refund.--Sections 6501
and 6511 shall not apply to any penalty imposed under subsection (a) or
refund made under subsection (b)(2).''.
(b) Mandatory Review of Exempt Status Upon Repeated Civil Rights
Violations.--Section 501 of such Code is amended by adding at the end
the following new subsection:
``(s) Mandatory Review of Exempt Status of Certain Educational
Institutions With Repeated Civil Rights Violations.--Upon any
determination of civil rights violation (as defined in section
6720D(c)) with respect to any specified tax-exempt educational
institution (as defined in section 6720D(e)), if such determination is
not one of the first 2 such determinations (made after the date of the
enactment of this subsection) with respect to such institution, the
Secretary shall conduct a review to determine if such institution
remains an organization described in subsection (c) which is entitled
to exemption from tax under subsection (a). Any determination which is
vacated, overturned, or otherwise reversed shall not be taken into
account under the preceding sentence (unless subsequently reinstated or
otherwise redetermined).''.
(c) Reporting by Specified Tax-exempt Educational Institutions of
Determinations of Civil Rights Violation.--Section 6033 of such Code is
amended by redesignating subsection (o) as subsection (p) and by
inserting after subsection (n) the following new subsection:
``(o) Additional Provisions Relating to Specified Tax-exempt
Educational Institutions.--
``(1) In general.--Every specified tax-exempt educational
institution (as defined in section 6720D(c)) which is subject
to the requirements of subsection (a) shall, on the return
required under subsection (a) for the taxable year, include the
following:
``(A) With respect to each determination of civil
rights violation (as defined in section 6720D(c)) made
with respect to such institution during such taxable
year:
``(i) A description of such determination
(including the date of such determination) and
of the civil rights violation to which such
determination relates.
``(ii) The number of determinations of civil
rights violation (determined by disregarding
determinations not taken into account under the
last sentence of section 501(s)) made with
respect to such institution before such
determination (and after the date of the
enactment of this subsection).
``(iii) Such other information as the
Secretary may require.
``(B) With respect to each determination of civil
rights violation (as defined in section 6720D(c)) which
is vacated, overturned, or otherwise reversed during
such taxable year:
``(i) A description of the order or judgment
which so reversed such determination, including
the date of such order or judgment.
``(ii) The information described in
subparagraph (A)(i) with respect to the
determination so reversed.
``(iii) Such other information as the
Secretary may require.
``(2) Application to state colleges and universities.--Every
specified tax-exempt educational institution (as defined in
section 6720D(c)) which is described in section 511(a)(2)(B)
shall, for any taxable year with respect to which there is a
determination of civil rights violation described in
subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1) with respect to such
institution, file an annual return that contains the
information described in such subparagraphs. The penalties
applicable to returns required under subsection (a) shall apply
to returns required under this paragraph.''.
(d) Clerical Amendment.--The table of sections for part I of
subchapter B of chapter 68 of such Code is amended by adding at the end
the following new item:
``Sec. 6720D. Civil rights violations by certain tax-exempt educational
institutions.''.
(e) Effective Date.--The amendments made by this section shall apply
with respect to determinations of civil rights violation made after the
date of the enactment of this Act.
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
The bill, H.R. 8914, the ``University Accountability Act,''
as ordered reported by the Committee on Ways and Means on July
9, 2024, imposes an assessable penalty on certain tax-exempt
educational institutions with respect to each determination of
a civil rights violation by the institution. Generally, for
each determination of a civil rights violation, the penalty
amount is the greater of: (1) $100,000; or (2) in the case of
an institution that is required to file a Form 990-series
return, five percent of the aggregate administrative
compensation paid by the institution during the taxable year in
which the violation occurred. Upon the third such determination
with respect to an institution, the U.S. Department of the
Treasury is required to conduct a review of the institution's
tax-exempt status.
B. Background and Need for Legislation
Under current law, the primary avenue to hold colleges and
universities accountable for violating the rights of Jewish
students rests within Title VI of the Civil Rights Act, which
prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, or
national origin. The U.S. Department of Education's Office for
Civil Rights (``OCR'') is charged with enforcing Title VI
through its investigation and complaint process. A violation of
Title VI can result in the loss of federal funds for the
violating recipient, including a violating college or
university. However, it is rare for OCR to find that a Title VI
violation has occurred, and when they do, it often results in
mere corrective actions meant to bring the college or
university back into compliance with Title VI. As a result,
colleges and universities are almost never at risk of losing
their federal funds.
Despite receiving generous tax benefits from the federal
government, including tax-exempt status under the Internal
Revenue Code (``IRC''), data and public reporting make clear
that colleges and universities have not done enough to
investigate, mitigate, and crack down on clear instances of
antisemitic behavior occurring on their campuses. As a result,
many Jewish students have filed lawsuits against their
universities alleging Title VI violations, whereas OCR has been
slower to act. And, when OCR has taken action, historically,
they elected to settle Title VI cases, including those alleging
antisemitism, and resolve them through resolution agreements
without determining whether a violation occurred; thereby
creating a hollow deterrent for schools that allow such
activity on campus, and an easy remedy for schools seeking to
avoid a revocation of federal funds. Additionally, while the
revocation of tax-exempt status remains the only current
punishment for entities who violate their exempt purpose under
the IRC, this punishment is almost never implemented by the
Internal Revenue Service (``IRS'') and is reliant on the agency
taking decisive action, which is rare. As a result, and to hold
tax-exempt colleges and universities accountable for violating
students' civil rights, H.R. 8914 considers additional
mechanisms to ensure that institutions of higher education are
held responsible for violating students' civil rights.
C. Legislative History
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 8914, the
``University Accountability Act,'' on July 9, 2024, and ordered
the bill, as amended, favorably reported (with a quorum being
present).\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Markup of H.R. 8914, H.R. 8913, H.R.
8915, and H.J. Res. 148 (July 9, 2024), https://waysandmeans.house.gov/
event/markup-of-h-r-8914-h-r-8913-h-r-8915-and-h-j-res-148/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop and consider H.R. 8914:
On November 15, 2023, the Committee held a hearing
entitled, ``From Ivory Towers to Dark Corners: Investigating
the Nexus Between Antisemitism, Tax-Exempt Universities, and
Terror Financing.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Hearing: From Ivory Towers to Dark
Corners: Investigating the Nexus Between Antisemitism, Tax-Exempt
Universities, and Terror Financing (Nov. 15, 2023), https://
waysandmeans.house.gov/event/hearing-from-ivory-towers-to-dark-corners-
investigating-the-nexus-between-antisemitism-tax-exempt-universities-
and-terror-financing/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On June 13, 2024, the Committee held a hearing entitled,
``Crisis on Campus: Antisemitism, Radical Faculty, and Failure
of University Leadership.''\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Hearing on the Crisis on Campus:
Antisemitism, Radical Faculty, and the Failure of University Leadership
(June 13, 2024), https://waysandmeans.house.gov/event/hearing-on-the-
crisis-on-campus-antisemitism-radical-faculty-and-the-failure-of-
university-leadership/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. Penalties With Respect to Civil Rights Violations by Certain Tax-
Exempt Educational Institutions (sec. 2 of the bill and new sec. 6720D
of the Code)
PRESENT LAW
Section 501(c) tax-exempt organizations
Section 501(c) describes 28 different categories of
organizations that are generally exempt from Federal income
tax.\6\ Section 501(c)(3) provides tax-exempt status to certain
nonprofit entities organized and operated exclusively for
charitable, religious, educational, or certain other purposes,
provided that no part of the net earnings of the organization
inures to the benefit of any private shareholder or individual.
Organizations described in section 501(c)(3), which are
generally referred to as ``charities,'' are classified as
either public charities or private foundations.\7\ In addition
to the tax-exempt status conferred on organizations described
in section 501(c)(3), charitable contributions to such
organizations are tax-deductible to the donor for Federal
income, estate, and gift tax purposes.\8\ In addition, section
501(c)(3) organizations are eligible for certain tax-exempt
financing benefits.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Sec. 501(c)(1) through (19) and (21) through (29). These ``tax-
exempt organizations''' generally are exempt from Federal income tax on
income derived from activities substantially related to their exempt
purposes and on their investment income. Such organizations generally
are subject to tax (unrelated business income tax, or ``UBIT'') on any
income derived from business activities that are regularly carried on
and not substantially related to their exempt purposes. Secs. 511-514.
\7\Sec. 509(a). Private foundations are defined under section
509(a) as all organizations described in section 501(c)(3) other than
the organizations granted public charity status by reason of: (1) being
a specific type of organization (i.e., churches, educational
institutions, hospitals and certain other medical organizations,
certain organizations providing assistance to colleges and
universities, or a governmental unit); (2) receiving a substantial part
of its support from governmental units or direct or indirect
contributions from the general public; (3) providing support to another
section 501(c)(3) entity that is not a private foundation (i.e., being
a ``supporting organization''); or (4) being organized and operated
exclusively for testing for public safety. In contrast to public
charities, private foundations generally are funded from one or a
limited number of sources (an individual, family, or corporation) and
are subject to restrictions not applicable to public charities. In
general, more generous charitable contribution deduction rules apply to
gifts to public charities.
\8\See secs. 170, 642(c), 2055(a)(2), 2106(a)(2)(A)(ii), and
2522(a)(2). Organizations described in section 501(c)(3) generally are
eligible for reduced postal rates and, depending on the applicable
State and local laws, may also be eligible for State and local income,
property, and sales tax benefits.
\9\See sec. 145.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tax exemption for educational organizations
The term ``charitable'' includes, for purposes of section
501(c)(3), the advancement of education or science.\10\ The
term ``educational,'' as used in section 501(c)(3), relates to
the instruction or training of individuals for the purpose of
improving or developing their capabilities, or the instruction
of the public on subjects useful to individuals and beneficial
to the community.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Treas. Reg. sec. 1.501(c)(3)-1(d)(2).
\11\Treas. Reg. sec. 1.501(c)(3)-1(d)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The following types of organizations may qualify as
educational within section 501(c)(3): (1) an organization, such
as a primary or secondary school, a college or university, or a
professional or trade school, that has a regularly scheduled
curriculum, a regular faculty, and a regularly enrolled student
body in attendance at a place where the educational activities
are regularly carried on; (2) an organization whose activities
consist of conducting public discussion groups, forums, panels,
lectures, or other similar programs; (3) an organization that
presents a course of instruction by correspondence or through
the use of television or radio; (4) a museum, zoo, planetarium,
symphony orchestra, or other similar organization; and (5) a
nonprofit children's day care center.\12\ In addition, college
athletic organizations that promote certain aspects of athletic
competition have generally been held to be educational and,
thus, exempt under section 501(c)(3). The exemption is based on
the principle that an athletic program conducted for the
physical development and betterment of the students is an
integral part of a university's overall educational activities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Civil tax penalties
The Code provides for both civil and criminal penalties to
ensure complete and accurate reporting of tax liability and to
discourage fraudulent attempts to defeat or evade tax. Civil
and criminal penalties are applied separately. Thus, a taxpayer
convicted of a criminal tax offense may be subject to both
criminal and civil penalties, and a taxpayer acquitted of a
criminal tax offense may nonetheless be subject to civil tax
penalties. In cases involving both criminal and civil
penalties, the IRS generally does not pursue both
simultaneously, but delays pursuit of civil penalties until the
criminal proceedings have concluded.
The majority of delinquent taxes and penalties are
collected through the civil process. In determining whether a
penalty applies along with an adjustment to a tax return, the
examining agent is constrained not only by the applicable
statutory provisions, but also by the written policy of the IRS
not to treat penalties as bargaining points but instead to
develop facts sufficient to support the decision to assert or
not to assert a penalty.\13\ The goal is to ensure consistency,
fairness, and predictability in administration of penalties.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Policy Statement 20-1, Internal Revenue Manual, sec.
1.2.20.1.1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Civil penalties are provided in Chapter 68 of the Code
(sections 6651 to 6751). Some penalties are calculated by
reference to the tax liability, such as the penalty for fraud,
while others are fixed dollar amounts or fixed percentages,
such as the failure to file a tax return or to pay tax. In
general, there is a penalty for (i) fraud;\14\ (ii) failure to
pay or file (referred to as delinquency penalties);\15\ (iii)
failure to pay estimated tax;\16\ (iv) failure to deposit
estimated tax amounts;\17\ (v) negligence, substantial
understatement, substantial valuation misstatements,
substantial overstatement of pension liabilities, substantial
estate or gift tax valuation understatement, lack of economic
substance, undisclosed foreign financial asset understatements,
and understatements with respect to reportable transactions
(all of the items in this list are referred to as accuracy
related penalties);\18\ (vi) not filing or filing incorrect
information returns;\19\ and (vii) aiding and abetting
understatements, taking unreasonable return positions (applied
to return preparers), promoting abusive tax shelters, and
failing to furnish information regarding tax shelters (referred
to collectively as the preparer, promoter, and protestor
penalties).\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Section 6663(a) applies a penalty of 75 percent on any amount
of an underpayment attributable to fraud. Fraud differs from negligence
in that fraud requires an intent to evade taxes.
\15\Section 6651(a) applies the delinquency penalties. Failing to
pay the amount shown as tax will result in a 0.5 percent monthly
penalty on the net amount due, increasing to 1 percent monthly in the
first month starting after the IRS gives notice and demand for
immediate payment. The maximum aggregate penalty is 25 percent. Failing
to file a return results in a penalty of 5 percent per month on the tax
required to be shown on the return, up to a maximum aggregate penalty
of 25 percent.
\16\Section 6654 provides for additions to tax for underpayment of
estimated tax for individuals. Section 6655 provides for the additions
to tax for underpayment of estimated tax for corporations. In both
cases, the additions to tax are computed by applying the underpayment
rate under section 6621 to the amount of the underpayment, for the
period of the underpayment. Section 6621 applies an interest rate of
the federal short-term interest rate plus 3 percent.
\17\Section 6656(a) applies a penalty for failure to deposit of 2
percent if the failure to deposit is 5 days or less, 5 percent if the
failure is greater than 5 days but not more than 15 days, and 10
percent if the failure is more than 15 days.
\18\Section 6662 applies a 20 percent penalty to any part of an
underpayment attributable to accuracy related errors as listed in
section 6662(b). This penalty increases to 40 percent in certain
circumstances.
\19\Section 6721 applies a $250 penalty for failure to file a
correct information return, up to a maximum of $3 million per year.
These amounts are adjusted annually to account for inflation. For a
failure relating to a return required to be filed in 2025 (i.e., a 2024
return), the penalty amount is $330, up to a maximum of $3,987,000 per
year. Rev. Proc. 2023-48, 2023-48 I.R.B. 1287, November 27, 2023. No
penalty is imposed if the failure is due to reasonable cause.
\20\Section 6701 applies a penalty of $1,000 on any person who aids
in the understatement of tax liability for individuals and $10,000 on
any person who aids in the understatement of tax liability for a
corporation. Section 6700 applies a penalty of $1,000 against anyone
involved directly or indirectly in the sale of an abusive tax shelter.
These are not currently adjusted for inflation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These penalties are categorized into two types: additions
to the tax and additional amounts (herein ``additions to
tax''), and assessable penalties. The additions to tax
penalties are generally subject to deficiency proceedings and
include delinquency penalties (section 6651), failure by
individuals to pay estimated income tax (section 6654), failure
by corporations to pay estimated income tax (section 6655),
failure to make deposit of taxes (section 6656), accuracy-
related penalties (sections 6662 and 6662A), and the fraud
penalty (section 6663). Some of these penalties may be waived
under certain circumstances, including a showing of reasonable
cause under section 6664.
Assessable penalties can be assessed without restrictions
(such as the opportunity for preassessment judicial review)
applicable in deficiency cases. These penalties are imposed for
failure to pay over collected taxes and to file information
returns reporting specified information and transactions
(section 6671 through 6720C), for failure to comply with
certain information reporting requirements, such as failure to
file correct information returns (section 6721), failure to
furnish correct payee statements (section 6722), and failure to
comply with other information reporting requirements (sections
6723 and 6725). These penalties may also be waived under
certain circumstances, including a showing of reasonable cause
under section 6724.
REASONS FOR CHANGE
Under present law, there is no civil tax penalty that is
imposed on colleges and universities that are found to have
violated a student's civil rights. Generally, the Committee
believes that colleges and universities should be subject to a
tax penalty if they are determined by a Federal court to have
violated title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The
Committee further believes that tax-exempt institutions should
be subject to a mandatory review of their tax-exempt status
upon the third determination of civil rights violation.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISION
Penalty for civil rights violation
The provision imposes an assessable penalty on a
``specified tax-exempt educational institution'' with respect
to each determination of civil rights violation with respect to
the institution. The penalty is equal to the applicable penalty
amount, as described below.
For purposes of the provision, a ``specified tax-exempt
educational institution'' is an eligible educational
institution as defined in section 25A(f)(2)\21\ that is
described in section 501(c) (describing certain organizations
exempt from Federal income tax) or section 511(a)(2)(B)
(generally describing State colleges and universities).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Section 25A(f)(2) defines an eligible educational institution
as an institution that (1) is described in section 481 of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. sec. 1088), as in effect on August 5,
1977, and (2) is eligible to participate in a program under title IV of
such Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A determination of civil rights violation means, with
respect to a specified tax-exempt educational institution, any
civil judgment of a Federal court of competent jurisdiction
that the institution violated any provision of title VI of the
Civil Rights Act of 1964. Title VI generally prohibits
discrimination on the basis of race, color, or national origin
in programs and activities receiving Federal financial
assistance. If the Secretary of the Treasury (the
``Secretary'') determines that two or more judgments are based
on the same set of facts and circumstances, such judgments
shall be treated as a single determination of civil rights
violation for purposes of the penalty, the mandatory review of
tax-exempt status (discussed below), and such portions of the
reporting requirements (also discussed below) as the Secretary
determines appropriate.
The term ``applicable penalty amount'' means, with respect
to each determination of civil rights violation made with
respect to a specified tax-exempt educational institution, the
greater of (1) $100,000, or (2) in the case of an institution
that is required to file a Form 990-series return under section
6033(a), five percent of the aggregate administrative
compensation paid by the institution during the taxable year in
which the violation occurred. Thus, the applicable penalty
amount is $100,000 in the case of a State college or university
that is not, under present law, required to file a Form 990-
series return. Administrative compensation means, with respect
to a specified tax-exempt educational institution, the
compensation and other payments described in section 6033(b)(7)
made by the institution. Section 6033(b)(7) generally describes
compensation and other payments made during the year by a
section 501(c)(3) organization to individuals who are
foundation managers (within the meaning of section
4946(b)(1))\22\ or highly compensated employees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Section 4946(b)(1) defines the term ``foundation manager'' to
include an officer, director, or trustee (or an individual having
powers or responsibilities similar to those of officers, directors, or
trustees) and with respect to any act (or failure to act) the employees
having the authority or responsibility with respect to such act (or
failure to act).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A specified tax-exempt educational institution is liable
for the penalty with respect to any determination of civil
rights violation on the date of the judgment referred to above.
In the event such a determination is vacated, overturned, or
otherwise reversed, the Secretary shall refund any penalty paid
with respect to the determination. This requirement to refund
the penalty, however, does not prevent the imposition of a
penalty with respect to any determination of civil rights
violation that is reinstated or otherwise redetermined
following a reversal.
Under the provision, the limitations periods for timely
assessment and collections under section 6501 and limitations
periods for claiming refunds under section 6511 are
inapplicable to the penalties and refund thereof.
Mandatory review of tax-exempt status upon third determination of a
violation
Upon the determination of civil rights violation with
respect to a specified tax-exempt educational institution, if
it is not one of the first two such determinations made after
the date of enactment, the Secretary shall conduct a review to
determine whether the institution remains an organization that
is described in section 501(c) and entitled to ex
Dissenting Views
There's no question that antisemitism in the United States
is a very real problem, that it is a growing problem, and that
it is growing with alarming speed and ferocity across the
nation, especially on our college campuses.
We saw shocking incidents of rank antisemitism against
Jewish students individually and the Jewish community in
general throughout the just completed academic year, and
especially towards the end of the year with the encampments,
obstructions of finals, and graduation ceremonies. What made
the headlines is just the tip of the iceberg of what Jewish
students on campuses experienced across the country. I have
heard from countless students about their personal experiences
on campus. Last December, I hosted a roundtable conversation
with Jewish university students and another roundtable in May.
In all these conversations, I have been shocked by the
level of discomfort, distress, and disconnection from their
college communities many of these students have described. We
for sure have to do better. Of course, the rising antisemitism
is not limited to college campuses. It's being experienced in
high schools and workplaces, in the public square and in local
communities and neighborhoods.
Just a week ago Saturday, my own neighborhood was targeted
when militant activists came marching down my street at 2:30 in
the morning--banging drums, blasting sirens and horns, and
spewing vile, antisemitic chants at me and my neighbors.
And on July Fourth, the posters of the hostages still being
held by Hamas in Gaza, including 8 Americans, that I had
outside my office, were aggressively ripped from the wall,
shredded, and tossed across the hallway.
Whomever tore down those posters did so with hate in their
heart. But with love and devotion to bring the hostages home, I
am pleased to share that the posters are back up and we remain
undaunted in our support for Israel, our commitment to bring
the hostages home, and our commitment to continue to pursue
peace.
We can all agree that we must address the rising incidence
and pervasiveness of antisemitism on college campuses. It is
fair to expect administrations to do more to respond to these
incidents. I think we would also agree that must address
antisemitism at its root causes--in the academies and in our
communities.
It's not simply a matter of calling out hate and bigotry.
We need to work together--Republicans and Democrats--to defeat
it. To cut it at the source, root and branch.
Unfortunately, the bills related to antisemitism we are
discussing today are not bipartisan efforts to craft effective
policy, but rather hyper partisan messaging that will not move
us forward on this issue.
The University Accountability Act is a missed opportunity
to combat antisemitism and hate on college campuses. While it
claims to promote accountability, this bill fails to address
the issue head on and focuses on punishing schools instead of
working to improve them.
I'm concerned about this bill's unintended consequence--the
very real potential for creating a vicious cycle of aggressive
and tendentious claims against universities to force schools
into settlements so as to garner steep legal fees and rich
settlements and avoid penalties of up to $2 million, regardless
of the merit or severity of a case.
Instead of focusing on funneling cases into litigation, we
should be giving the Office of Civil Rights the resources to
actually combat and defeat the antisemitism that is infecting
our schools. Every student, wherever they are pursuing their
academic advancement, should be able to grow and learn in
environment free of hate.
Our unifying goal should be to protect these students and
make our schools better. Colleges and universities should be
places where all students' views can be challenged in a civil
and safe learning environment, and where they can continue to
grow in a positive way.
Instead of rushing through a poorly conceived bill, we
should be focusing on improving enforcement and investing in
education and training to address the root cause of
antisemitism and all forms of discrimination.
Congress should pass the Showing Up for Students Act and
provide OCR with the funding it needs to improve enforcement
and invest in education--money that could go to hire more staff
to decrease the backlog of cases and resolve issues in a timely
manner.
I'm disappointed that the Majority decided to rush this
poorly thought-out bill through our committee instead of
working together across the aisle. I've been working with my
colleagues across the aisle with Rep. Kustoff and on bills
introduced to revoke the tax-exempt status of organizations
that provide financial support and resources to terrorist
groups, and we passed through the House with overwhelming
bipartisan support.
We all agree that more must be done to combat rising
antisemitism. Unfortunately, this bill is an insincere attempt
by my colleagues in the Majority to take credit for reacting to
a rising problem in higher education without giving those who
actually enforce the law the tools they need.
Bradley Scott Schneider.
[all]