Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 5]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and the Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 5) to ensure the rights of parents are
honored and protected in the Nation's public schools, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Parents Bill of Rights Act''.
TITLE I--AMENDMENTS TO THE ELEMENTARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION ACT OF
1965
SEC. 101. STATE PLAN ASSURANCES.
Section 1111(g)(2) of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of
1965 (20 U.S.C. 6311(g)(2)) is amended--
(1) in subparagraph (M), by striking ``and'' at the end;
(2) in subparagraph (N), by striking the period at the end
and inserting a semicolon; and
(3) by adding at the end the following:
``(O) the State will ensure that each local
educational agency in the State--
``(i) in a case in which the curriculum for
an elementary or secondary school grade level
is freely and publicly available on the
internet--
``(I) posts on a publicly accessible
website of the agency, such curriculum;
or
``(II) if such agency does not
operate a website, widely disseminates
to the public such curriculum; or
``(ii) in a case in which the curriculum for
an elementary or secondary school grade level
is not freely and publicly available on the
internet--
``(I) posts on a publicly accessible
website of the agency--
``(aa) a description of such
curriculum; and
``(bb) information on how
parents can review such
curriculum as described in
section 1112(e)(1)(A); or
``(II) if such agency does not
operate a website, widely disseminates
to the public the description and
information described in items (aa) and
(bb) of subclause (I); and
``(P) in the case of any revisions to the State's
challenging State academic standards (including any
revisions to the levels of achievement within the
State's academic achievement standards), the State
educational agency will post to the homepage of its
website, and widely disseminate to the public, notice
of such revisions and a copy of such revisions, except
that the State educational agency shall not be required
to submit such notice or such revisions to the
Secretary.''.
SEC. 102. ANNUAL LOCAL EDUCATIONAL AGENCY REPORT CARDS.
Section 1111(h)(2) of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of
1965 (20 U.S.C. 6311(h)(2)) is amended by inserting at the end the
following new subparagraph:
``(E) Budget.--Each local educational agency report
card shall include the budget for the school year for
which such report card is being prepared (including all
revenues and expenditures (including expenditures made
to private entities)) for the local educational agency
as a whole, and for each elementary school and
secondary school served by the local educational
agency. In addition to the detailed budget information
required under the preceding sentence, the agency shall
include a separate fact sheet that summarizes such
information in a clear and easily understandable
format.''.
SEC. 103. LOCAL EDUCATIONAL AGENCY PLAN ASSURANCES.
Section 1112(c) of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965
(20 U.S.C. 6312(c)) is amended--
(1) in paragraph (6), by striking ``and'' at the end;
(2) in paragraph (7), by striking the period at the end and
inserting a semicolon; and
(3) by adding at the end the following:
``(8) meet the requirements described in section
1111(g)(2)(O);
``(9) post on a publicly accessible website of the local
educational agency or, if the local educational agency does not
operate a website, widely disseminate to the public, the plan
for carrying out the parent and family engagement described in
section 1116 and all policies and procedures that result from
such engagement;
``(10) ensure that each elementary school served by the local
educational agency notifies the parents of any student enrolled
at such school when the student does not score as grade-level
proficient in reading or language arts at the end of the third
grade based on the reading or language arts assessments
administered under section 1111(b)(2)(B)(v)(I)(aa) or another
assessment administered to all third grade students by such
school; and
``(11) ensure that each elementary school and secondary
school served by the local educational agency provides to the
parents of students enrolled at such school, before a person
speaks (in-person or virtually) to such students in a class,
school assembly, or any other school-sponsored event, notice
that includes the name of the speaker and the name of the
organization or other entity being represented by the
speaker.''.
SEC. 104. PARENTS RIGHT-TO-KNOW.
Section 1112(e) of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965
(20 U.S.C. 6312(e)) is amended--
(1) by redesignating paragraphs (1), (2), (3), and (4) as
paragraphs (2), (3), (4), and (6), respectively;
(2) by inserting before paragraph (2) (as so redesignated),
the following:
``(1) Notice of rights.--A local educational agency receiving
funds under this part shall ensure that each elementary school
and secondary school served by such agency posts on a publicly
accessible website of the school or, if the school does not
operate a website, widely disseminates to the public, a summary
notice of the right of parents to information about their
children's education as required under this Act, which shall be
in an understandable format for parents and include, at
minimum--
``(A) the right to review, and make copies of, at no
cost, the curriculum of their child's school;
``(B) the right to know if the State alters the
State's challenging State academic standards;
``(C) the right to meet with each teacher of their
child not less than twice during each school year in
accordance with paragraph (5)(A);
``(D) the right to review the budget, including all
revenues and expenditures, of their child's school;
``(E) the right to--
``(i) a list of the books and other reading
materials available in the library of their
child's school; and
``(ii) inspect such books or other reading
materials;
``(F) the right to information about all schools in
which their child can enroll, including options for
enrolling in or transferring to--
``(i) other schools served by the local
educational agency;
``(ii) charter schools; and
``(iii) schools served by a different local
educational agency in the State;
``(G) the right to address the school board of the
local educational agency;
``(H) the right to information about violent activity
in their child's school;
``(I) the right to information about any plans to
eliminate gifted and talented programs in the child's
school;
``(J) the right to review any professional
development materials;
``(K) the right to know if their child is not grade-
level proficient in reading or language arts at the end
of the third grade as described in subsection (c)(10);
``(L) the right to know if a school employee or
contractor acts to--
``(i) change a minor child's gender markers,
pronouns, or preferred name; or
``(ii) allow a child to change the child's
sex-based accommodations, including locker
rooms or bathrooms;
``(M) the right to know if--
``(i) a school employee or contractor acts
to--
``(I) treat, advise, or address the
cyberbullying of a student;
``(II) treat, advise, or address the
bullying or hazing of a student;
``(III) treat, advise, or address a
student's mental health, suicidal
ideation, or instances of self-harm;
``(IV) treat, advise, or address a
specific threat to the safety of a
student;
``(V) treat, advise, or address the
possession or use of drugs and other
controlled substances; or
``(VI) treat, advise, or address an
eating disorder; or
``(ii) a child brings a weapon to school; and
``(N) the right to the notice described in subsection
(c)(11) before a person speaks (in-person or virtually)
to their child in a class, school assembly, or any
other school-sponsored event.'';
(3) in paragraph (2)(B) (as redesignated by paragraph (1))--
(A) by redesignating clause (i) and clause (ii) as
subclause (I) and subclause (II), respectively;
(B) by striking ``(B) Additional information.--'' and
inserting:
``(B) Additional information.--
``(i) In general.--''; and
(C) by adding at the end the following:
``(ii) School library.--A local educational
agency receiving funds under this part shall
ensure that each elementary school and
secondary school served by such agency provides
the parents of each child who is a student in
such school--
``(I) at the beginning of each school
year, a list of books and other reading
materials available in the library of
such school; and
``(II) the opportunity to inspect
such books and other reading materials.
``(iii) Violent activity.--A local
educational agency receiving funds under this
part shall ensure that each elementary school
and secondary school served by such agency
provides the parents of each child who is a
student in such school timely notification of
any violent activity occurring on school
grounds or at school-sponsored activities in
which one or more individuals suffer injuries,
except that such notification shall not contain
names or the grade level of any students
involved in the activity.
``(iv) Gifted and talented programs.--A local
educational agency receiving funds under this
part shall ensure that each elementary school
and secondary school served by such agency
provides the parents of each child who is a
student in such school timely notification of
any plan to eliminate gifted and talented
programs in such school.''; and
(4) by inserting after paragraph (4) (as redesignated by
paragraph (1)) the following:
``(5) Transparency.--A local educational agency receiving
funds under this part shall provide the parents of each child
who is a student in an elementary school or secondary school
served by such agency--
``(A)(i) the opportunity to meet in-person or
virtually via videoconference with each teacher of such
child not less than twice during each school year; and
``(ii) a notification, at the beginning of each
school year, of the opportunity for such meetings,
including the option to attend such meetings virtually
via videoconference; and
``(B) the opportunity to address the school board of
such local educational agency on issues impacting the
education of children in such agency.''.
SEC. 105. SENSE OF CONGRESS ON FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS.
Title VIII of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20
U.S.C. 7801 et seq.) is amended--
(1) by redesignating section 8549C as section 8549D; and
(2) by inserting after section 8549B the following new
section:
``SEC. 8549C. SENSE OF CONGRESS ON FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS.
``(a) Findings.--Congress finds the following:
``(1) Parents have a First Amendment right to express their
opinions on decisions made by State and local education
leaders.
``(2) States and local educational agencies should empower
parents to communicate regularly with Federal, State, and local
policymakers and educators regarding the education and well-
being of their children.
``(3) Transparent and cooperative relationships between
parents and schools have significant and long-lasting positive
effects on the development of children.
``(4) Parents' concerns over content and pedagogy deserve to
be heard and fully considered by school professionals.
``(5) Parent and other community input about schools that is
presented in a lawful and appropriate manner should always be
encouraged.
``(6) Educators, policymakers, elected officials, Executive
Branch officials and employees, and other stakeholders should
never seek to use law enforcement to criminalize the lawfully
expressed concerns of parents about their children's education,
but should never hesitate to contact public safety officials if
there is a credible threat to the safety and security of
students, parents, educators, policymakers, elected officials,
executive branch officials or employees, or other stakeholders,
school faculty, or staff.
``(b) Sense of Congress.--It is the sense of Congress that the First
Amendment guarantees parents and other stakeholders the right to
assemble and express their opinions on decisions affecting their
children and communities, and that educators and policymakers should
welcome and encourage that engagement and consider that feedback when
making decisions.''.
TITLE II--AMENDMENTS TO FERPA AND PPRA
SEC. 201. AMENDMENTS TO THE FAMILY EDUCATIONAL RIGHTS AND PRIVACY ACT
OF 1974.
(a) Enforcement.--Section 444(f) of the General Education Provisions
Act (20 U.S.C. 1232g) (also known as the ``Family Educational Rights
and Privacy Act of 1974'') (20 U.S.C. 1232g(f)) is amended by adding at
the end the following: ``The Secretary shall comply with the reporting
requirement under section 445(e)(2)(C)(ii) with respect to the
enforcement actions taken under this subsection to ensure compliance
with this section.''.
(b) Prohibition on Educational Agencies or Institutions Acting as an
Agent of a Parent.--Section 444 of the General Education Provisions Act
(20 U.S.C. 1232g) (also known as the ``Family Educational Rights and
Privacy Act of 1974'') is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(k) Prohibition on Educational Agencies or Institutions Acting as
Agent of a Parent for Use of Technology.--An educational agency or
institution may not act as the agent of a parent of a student in
attendance at a school of such agency or at such institution for
purposes of providing verifiable parental consent for the use of
technology in the classroom for purposes of educating the student
without providing notice and an opportunity for the parent to object to
the use of such technology.
``(l) Prohibition on Educational Agencies or Institutions Acting as
Agent of a Parent for Vaccines.--An educational agency or institution
may not act as the agent of a parent of a student in attendance at a
school of such agency or at such institution for purposes of providing
verifiable parental consent for a vaccination.''.
(c) Prohibition on Sale of Information for Commercial Purposes.--
Section 444 of the General Education Provisions Act (20 U.S.C. 1232g)
(also known as the ``Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act of
1974''), as amended by this section, is further amended by adding at
the end the following:
``(l) Prohibition on Sale of Information for Commercial Purposes.--
``(1) In general.--Except as provided in paragraph (2), no
educational agency or institution or authorized representative
of such agency or institution may sell student information for
commercial or financial gain.
``(2) Exceptions.--The prohibition described in paragraph (1)
shall not apply to products sold to students by or on behalf of
Committee Action
116TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On June 15, 2020, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a virtual hearing on ``Budget Cuts and Lost
Learning: Assessing the Impact of Covid-19 on Public
Education.'' The hearing was the first in a series examining
the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on K-12 education. The
purpose of the hearing was to evaluate the state of education
funding and examine the learning losses students are projected
to experience. Testifying before the Committee were Mr. Mark
Johnson, State Superintendent, North Carolina Department of
Public Instruction, Raleigh, NC; Dr. Michael Leachman, Vice
President for State Fiscal Policy, Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Eric Gordon, CEO, Cleveland
Metropolitan School District, Cleveland, OH; and Ms. Becky
Pringle, Vice President, National Education Association,
Washington, D.C.
On July 21, 2020, the Committee's Subcommittee on Early
Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education (ECESE) held a
virtual hearing on ``Underfunded & Unprepared: Examining How to
Overcome Obstacles to Safely Reopen Public Schools.'' The
purpose of the hearing was to discuss the barriers to reopening
schools and how to overcome them. Testifying before the
subcommittee were Mrs. Penny Schwinn, Commissioner, Tennessee
Department of Education, Nashville, TN; Ms. Leslie Boggs,
President, National Parent Teachers Association, Alexandria,
VA; Dr. Michael Hinojosa, Superintendent, Dallas Independent
School District, Dallas, TX; and Dr. Sean O'Leary, Pediatric
Infectious Disease Specialist, Children's Hospital Colorado,
Co-Chair of the Immunization Committee, Colorado Chapter of the
American Academy of Pediatrics, Aurora, CO.
Second Session--Hearings
Legislative Action
On April 30, 2019, the Committee held a legislative hearing
on school integration and civil rights enforcement. A review of
Committee archives suggests this is the first hearing focused
on school segregation since the 101st Congress, nearly 30 years
ago. The hearing, titled ``Brown v. Board of Education at 65: A
Promise Unfulfilled,'' was used to inform the development of
H.R. 2639. On May 9, 2019, Rep. Marcia Fudge (D-OH) introduced
H.R. 2639, the Strength in Diversity Act of 2019, with Chairman
Bobby Scott (D-VA) and Rep. Gregorio Sablan (D-MP), Chair of
the Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary
Education, as original co-sponsors. On May 16, 2019, the
Committee considered H.R. 2639 in a legislative session and
ordered it reported favorably, as amended, to the House of
Representative by a vote of 26-20. The Committee considered and
adopted the following amendments to H.R. 2639:
1. Rep. Fudge offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute (ANS) that made numerous changes to H.R.
2639. The ANS improved provisions under section 5 of
the bill to ensure outreach to parents and students is
produced in commonly understandable language. It also
ensured consultation with students and families in the
district or region targeted for diversity improvement
efforts. Under section 6, the ANS expanded planning
grant activities to include the development of a robust
family, student, and community engagement plan. It also
explicitly stated that funds can be used to support
school districts under a court-ordered school
desegregation plan. The ANS expanded implementation
grants activities to include the development of
innovative and equitable school assignment plans and
other innovative activities to increase racial and
socioeconomic diversity. Under section 7, the ANS added
reducing school discipline rates as a measure of a
school integration plan's success. Under section 8, the
ANS expanded the annual reporting requirement to
include a description of the entity's efforts to
increase inclusivity in schools. Finally, the ANS added
a new section to specify that GEPA section 426 does not
apply to funds authorized by the bill.
The Committee further considered the following amendments
to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2639:
2. Rep. Rick Allen (R-GA) offered an amendment to the
ANS that proposed to strike the authorization of the
new federal grant program created in H.R. 2639 to
support voluntary community-driven efforts to increase
diversity in schools. The amendment instead amended
section 4106 of the Elementary and Secondary Education
Act of 1965\8\ to allow school districts to use funds
authorized by such act to develop or implement
strategies to improve diversity and reduce or eliminate
racial or socioeconomic isolation in schools. The
amendment also permitted LEAs to use funds received
under section 4106 to cover fees associated with
accelerated learning examinations given to low-income
students. Lastly, the amendment exempted funds used
pursuant to the authorized uses from the requirements
of GEPA section 426. Because the amendment proposed to
amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of
1965, a law not amended by the underlying bill, the
amendment expanded the scope of the bill and was ruled
out of order by the Chairman.
The Committee again worked with the Committee on
Appropriations on longstanding anti-integration riders during
the Fiscal Year 2021 (FY21) appropriations process. As a
result, H.R. 7617, the Defense, Commerce, Justice, Science,
Energy and Water Development, Financial Services and General
Government, Labor, Health and Human Services, Education,
Transportation, Housing, and Urban Development Appropriations
Act, 2021 included a provision striking GEPA section 426 from
law entirely. H.R. 7617 passed the House July 31, 2020 by a
vote of 217-197.
On May 2, 2019, Rep. Kim Schrier (D-WA) introduced H.R.
2480, the Stronger Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act,
with Reps. James Comer (R-KY), Lori Trahan (D-MA), Dusty
Johnson (R-SD), Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR), Elise Stefanik (R-NY),
Chairman Bobby Scott (D-VA), and Ranking Member Virginia Foxx
(R-NC) as original co-sponsors. On May 8, 2019, the Committee
considered H.R. 2480 in a legislative session and reported it
favorably, as amended, to the House of Representative by a
voice vote. The Committee considered and adopted the following
amendments to H.R. 2480:
1. Rep. Bonamici offered an Amendment in the Nature
of a Substitute (ANS) that made several improvements to
H.R. 2480. The ANS narrowed the condition of receipt of
funds in Section 103(d) to grants received through
Section 106. In Section 106(a)(5)(A), housing agencies
were added to the list of service providers
participating in state and local networks supporting
child and family well-being to establish connections
between the child welfare system and agencies that
support families in finding and securing stable
housing.
The ANS made two important changes to support
prevention efforts in tribal communities. The amendment
added Indian tribes and tribal organizations to the
list of entities that receive equitable distribution of
assistance in Section 107 and required the Government
Accountability Office (GAO) to examine and make
recommendations about issues relating to child abuse
and neglect in Indian tribal communities.
Several changes were made in Section 110 through the
ANS to clarify the intent of and strengthen the
electronic data exchange system. First, language was
added to ensure that standards and policies governing
the electronic interstate data exchange adhere to
federal law in addition to state law. The ANS also
clarified that the exchange can only be used for
purposes of child safety and is not to be used for any
other purpose. To this end, the ANS included a
prohibition on the Secretary from accessing or storing
data exchanged on the system. The ANS also required
that each state provide the Secretary an assurance that
its child abuse and neglect registry provides
procedural due process for individuals placed on such a
registry. Finally, the ANS modified the appropriations
reservation for Section 110 such that out of annual
funds appropriated in Title I, $2 million per year for
fiscal years 2020 and 2021 and $1 million per year for
fiscal years 2022 through 2025 are reserved for the
development and implementation of the electronic data
exchange system.
The ANS also included a change in Title II to raise
the administrative cap on funds received in excess of
fiscal year 2019 state allocations from four percent to
ten percent to ensure lead entities are able to
effectively monitor and provide oversight of prevention
services. The ANS was adopted via voice vote.
During the legislative session the Committee adopted
several amendments to the ANS:
1. Rep. Lucy McBath (D-GA) offered, in coordination
with Rep. Stefanik (R-NY), an amendment to the ANS
allowing the Secretary to fund a national hotline for
child abuse and neglect. The amendment was adopted via
voice vote.
2. Rep. Russ Fulcher (R-ID) offered an amendment to
the amendment in the nature of the substitute requiring
the working group established in Section 110 to
generate best practices that ensure due process for
individuals included in state child abuse and neglect
registries. The amendment was adopted via voice vote.
3. Rep. David Trone (D-MD) offered, in coordination
with Rep. Ron Wright (R-TX), an amendment to the ANS
allowing states to carry out programs or strategies
that promote the recruitment, support, or retention of
the child welfare workforce. The amendment was adopted
via voice vote.
2. Rep. Lloyd Smucker (R-PA) offered, in coordination
with Rep. Lauren Underwood (D-PA), an amendment to the
ANS ensuring the Secretary includes parent substance
use disorder as a factor in the study examining
adoption outcomes. The amendment was adopted via voice
vote.
3. Rep. Van Taylor (R-TX) offered, in coordination
with Rep. Joe Morelle (D-NY), an amendment to the ANS
requiring the Secretary to conduct a study of
exemptions to state laws pertaining to the minimum age
of marriage and examine how such exemptions affect
child safety. The amendment was adopted via voice vote.
4. Rep. Susan Wild (D-PA) offered, in coordination
with Rep. Glenn ``GT'' Thompson (R-PA), an amendment to
the ANS requiring the Secretary to conduct a study of
mandatory reporter state laws and examine differences
in rates of referrals related to such state laws. The
amendment was adopted via voice vote.
5. Rep. Steve Watkins (R-KS) offered, in coordination
with Rep. Susie Lee (D-NV), an amendment to the ANS
ensuring that no child protective services protocols or
systems authorize the separation of a child from their
family due solely to poverty. The amendment was adopted
via voice vote.
6. Rep. Josh Harder (D-CA) offered, in coordination
with Rep. Dan Meuser (R-PA), an amendment to the ANS
allowing states to carry out activities that reduce
child abuse and neglect due to the substance use
disorder of a parent. The amendment was adopted via
voice vote.
The Committee further considered the following amendment
H.R. 2480, as amended:
7. Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) offered, in
coordination with Rep. Brett Guthrie (R-KY), an
amendment to the ANS ensuring that infants whose
prenatal drug exposure is the result of maternal intake
of drugs as prescribed by a physician are not reported
to child protective services. The amendment was
withdrawn with a commitment to work with Committee
leadership to improve this language for inclusion in
the bill.
On May 8, 2019, Chairman Scott and House Judiciary
Committee Chairman Nadler introduced H.R. 2574, the Equity and
Inclusion Enforcement Act, with Rep. Gregorio Sablan (D-MP),
Chair of the Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary, and
Secondary Education, and Rep. Alma Adams (D-NC), Chair of the
Subcommittee on Workforce Protections as original co-sponsors.
On May 16, 2019, the Committee considered H.R. 2574 in a
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representative by a vote of 26-20. The Committee
considered and adopted the following amendment to H.R. 2574:
1. Rep. Scott offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute (ANS) that made technical improvements to
H.R. 2574. The ANS amended the Short Title of the bill,
and made clear that under section 4, the newly created
Special Assistant position shall advise both the
Secretary and Deputy Secretary on all matters relating
to equity and inclusion in a manner consistent with
Title VI.
During the legislative session the Committee considered one
amendment to the ANS:
1. Rep. James Comer (R-KY) offered an amendment to
the ANS that would strike language from the bill
restoring the private right of action under Title VI
and would modify the new Special Assistant for Equity
and Inclusion at the Department, consolidating its
duties with an existing Special Assistant for Gender
Equity. Because the amendment proposed to amend a
portion of the bill outside of the jurisdiction of the
Committee (as defined in rule X of the Rules of the
House of Representatives), the amendment was ruled out
of order.
117TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On April 28, 2021, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Building Back Better: Investing
in Improving Schools, Creating Jobs, and Strengthening Families
and our Economy.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine
the Biden administration's American Jobs Plan and American
Families Plan. Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Neal
McCluskey, Director, Center for Educational Freedom, CATO
Institute, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Brian Riedl, Senior Fellow,
Manhattan Institute, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Mark Mitsui,
President, Portland Community College, Portland, Oregon; Mr.
Rasheed Malik, Senior Policy Analyst, Early Childhood Policy,
Center for American Progress, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Mary
Filardo, Founder and Executive Director, 21st Century School
Fund, Washington, D.C.
On May 6, 2021, the Committee's Subcommittee on Early
Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education (ECESE) held a
hearing on ``Addressing the Impact of COVID-19 on Students with
Disabilities.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine the
negative consequences of COVID-19 on students with disabilities
and strategies to address the loss of services and learning.
Testifying before the subcommittee were Mr. Reade Bush, Parent,
Arlington, VA; Mr. Ron Hager, Managing Attorney for Education
and Employment, National Disability Rights Network, Washington,
D.C.; Dr. Danielle Kovach, Special Education Teacher, Tulsa
Trail Elementary School, Hopatcong, NJ; Ms. Kanika Littleton,
Project Director, Michigan Alliance for Families, Lansing, MI.
On September 29, 2021, the Committee's Subcommittee on
Early Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education (ECESE)
held a hearing on ``Back to School: Highlighting Best Practices
for Safely Reopening School.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to examine efforts to reopen schools this fall in light of the
Delta variant of COVID-19. Testifying before the subcommittee
were Mr. David Zweig, Journalist, Hastings on Hudson, NY; Dr.
Jesus Jara, Superintendent, Clark County School District, Las
Vegas, NV; Ms. Denise Forte, Interim Chief Executive Officer,
The Education Trust, Washington, DC; Dr. Ashish Jha, Dean,
School of Public Health at Brown University, Providence, RI.
On November 17, 2021, the Committee's Joint Subcommittee on
Early Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education (ECESE)
held a hearing on ``Examining the Implementation of COVID-19
Education Funds.'' The purpose of the hearing was to conduct
oversight of the Education Stabilization Fund (ESF). Testifying
before the subcommittee were The Honorable Cindy Marten, Deputy
Secretary, U.S. Department of Education, Washington, D.C.; The
Honorable James Kvaal, Under Secretary, U.S. Department of
Education, Washington, D.C.
Second Session--Hearings
On February 16, 2022, the Committee's Subcommittee on Early
Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education (ECESE) held a
hearing on ``Serving All Students: Promoting a Healthier, More
Supportive School Environment.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to examine school safety practices such as seclusion and
restraint and corporal punishment, and proposals to fund school
districts' efforts to create positive school climates.
Testifying before the subcommittee were Mr. Max Eden, Research
Fellow, American Enterprise Institute, Washington D.C.; Ms.
Kristen Harper, Vice President For Public Policy and
Engagement, Child Trends, Bethesda, MD; Mr. Guy Stephens,
Founder and Executive Director, Alliance Against Seclusion and
Restraint, Solomons, MD; Ms. Morgan Craven, National Director
of Policy, Advocacy and Community Engagement, Intercultural
Development Research Association, San Antonio, TX.
On May 26, 2022, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Examining the Policies and
Priorities of the U.S. Department of Education.'' The purpose
of the hearing was to review the Fiscal Year 2023 budget
priorities of the U.S. Department of Education. Testifying
before the Committee was The Honorable Miguel Cardona,
Secretary, U.S. Department of Education, Washington, D.C.
On September 20, 2022, the Committee's Subcommittee on
Early Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education (ECESE)
held a hearing on ``Back to School: Meeting Students' Academic,
Social and Emotional Needs.'' The purpose of the hearing was to
examine how states and school districts are meeting the
academic and mental health needs of students at this stage of
the pandemic. Testifying before the subcommittee were Dr. Penny
Schwinn, Commissioner, Tennessee Department of Education,
Nashville, TN; Dr. Aaliyah A. Samuel, President and Chief
Executive Officer, Collaborative for Academic, Social, and
Emotional Learning, Chicago, IL; Dr. Matthew Blomstedt,
Commissioner, Nebraska Department of Education, Lincoln, NE;
Ms. Phyllis Jordan, Associate Director, Future Ed, Georgetown
University, Washington, D.C.
Legislative Action
On September 29, 2021, Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D-FL)
introduced H.R. 5428, the School Shooting Preparedness and
Safety Act, with Reps. McBath and Hayes as original co-
spo
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
The Majority claims that H.R. 5, the Parents Bill of Rights
Act, seeks to ``put in place concrete legal protections that
will ensure parents always have a seat at the table when it
comes to their child's education.''\1\ However, the bill is
largely duplicative of current law, lacks clarity in how its
provisions will actually address students well-being, and
stands as an example of the type federal overreach
Congressional Republicans have long claimed would harm
children, teachers and schools.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Press Release, Rep. Julia Letlow, Letlow Introduces Parents Bill
of Rights (Mar. 1, 2023), https://letlow.house.gov/media/press-
releases/letlow-reintroduces-parents-bill-rights.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY OF CONCERNS
H.R. 5 is Duplicative of Current Law
The provisions in H.R. 5 are largely duplicative of current
law and create unnecessary and burdensome requirements on state
education agencies (SEAs), local education agencies (LEAs), and
schools. The bill would require these entities to divert
essential resources and personnel away from serving students
and providing them with the supports they need. Recognizing
this is not an exhaustive list, the following are examples of
duplicative provisions contained in H.R. 5.
Under the Protection of Pupils Rights Amendment (PPRA),
parents already have the right to access instructional
materials used by their child's school.\2\ Title I of
Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (Title I) also
currently requires that districts conduct outreach to parents
and family members, and implement programs, activities, and
procedures to involve parents and families in their child's
education.\3\ Under the law, each district that receives Title
I funds must have a written parent and family engagement policy
in place that, in part, provides parents with a description and
explanation of the curriculum and assessments used in their
child's school.\4\ Districts and schools must distribute this
policy to parents and family members and hold at least one
annual meeting with families to explain the policy and their
right to be involved.\5\ Many of the additional requirements
placed on SEAs and LEAs would unduly burden Title I schools,
which serve higher portions of students from low-income
backgrounds and students of color. For example, if H.R. 5
became law, funds spent compiling and disseminating required
lists of books and reading materials to families could
otherwise be spent on direct educational services for
disadvantaged students or efforts to close achievement gaps, as
the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) mandates.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\20 U.S.C. 1232h(c)(1).
\3\20 U.S.C. 6318(a)(1), (b), (d); 20 U.S.C. 6311(d); 20 U.S.C.
6314(b).
\4\20 U.S.C. 6318(a)(1); 20 U.S.C. 6318(b), (d).
\5\20 U.S.C. 6318.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Like the amendments to ESEA, the student data privacy
provisions in H.R. 5 are largely redundant of provisions
currently required by law. Currently, PPRA requires that
educational institutions make parents aware of instances in
which their child's information may be used for marketing or
sales and provide parents with the opportunity to opt their
child out.\6\ Likewise, PPRA currently requires that school
districts develop policies, in consultation with families, to
protect student data privacy and govern the disclosure of
student information online.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\20 U.S.C. 1232h(c).
\7\20 U.S.C. 1232h(c)(1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 5 Lacks Clarity in Addressing Student Well-being
Additionally, there are concerned with H.R. 5's proposed
amendments to PPRA that pertain to school-based health
examinations. The language is problematic for several reasons.
For example, the bill changes ``physical'' to ``medical,''
thereby expanding the PPRA to non-physical (i.e., mental)
health, and then requires an opt-in with prior notice to and
consent from parents before ``any medical examination or
screening'', except in case of emergency.\8\ The bill does not
specify how often schools would be required to collect and
confirm parental consent prior to providing students with
medical care. As a result, the requirement could prevent
students from accessing needed medical services at school--
particularly in instances where parents cannot be reached--and
could create an additional administrative burden for both
schools and families. The bill also does not define ``mental
health screening'' or ``emergency,'' leaving room for
potentially broad and inconsistent interpretations, and could
negatively impact the provision of vital mental health support.
This could be particularly harmful due to recent rises in
suicide, anxiety, and depression among students.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\It should be noted that the Committee supports ensuring that
behavioral health is encompassed within health.
\9\Ctrs. For Disease Control & Prevention, Mental Health, Poor
Mental Health Is a Problem for Adolescents, (last reviewed Feb. 13,
2023) https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/mental-health/
index.htm#::text=In%202021%2C%20more%20than%204,10%20(10%25)%20attempte
d%20suicide.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 5 is an Example of Federal Overreach
In addition to being duplicative of existing federal law,
the requirements in H.R. 5 are at best redundant, and at worst
in direct conflict, to requirements of state and local
education laws. For example, a number of states and districts
have enacted policies to provide transparency and access to
documents and proceedings already. If signed into law, H.R. 5
could institute an additional set of standards and requirements
to accomplish the same goal. Further, key terms are undefined,
leaving the true scope of work necessary for compliance
unclear. For example, schools are required to inform parents of
all ``violent activity'' which results in injury, but the
vagueness of the bill could leave to question whether these
``activities'' include playground squabbles and skinned knees,
which, while low stakes may involve violence, or something much
more serious (e.g., robbery) which may involve the threat of
violence, but not actual violence.
This is especially troubling as H.R. 5 makes a mockery of
long-standing Republican ideals of federalism in education and
local control over educational decisions. The bill is a litany
of unfunded mandates put on schools with no real theory as to
how any of these requirements will actually improve educational
quality. For example, the bill includes a ``notice of rights''
for parents, including the right to review curriculum, budget,
and the list of books and other reading materials but does not
take into consideration any current state or local laws which
may beduplicative in purpose yet incongruent with the bill in
implementation. While Congressional Democrats generally support a
strong federal role in education, we believe in many instances, federal
education law can provide a floor of support that localities can build
on based on their unique needs.
It was in this spirit that Committee Democrats offered a
series of amendments that simply provided assurances that
nothing in H.R. 5 could be construed to permit federal
involvement in the teaching of many aspects of history that we
know state PBOR bills are explicitly targeting. This began with
Rep. Courtney (D-CT) offering a blanket amendment on ensuring
H.R. 5 could not be construed to allow the federal government
to meddle in curriculum, which was accepted as a restatement of
law. Democrats then offered amendments to specify that certain
history curricula would also be safe from federal intrusion
under H.R. 5. These include, but are not limited to, African-
American history, Latino history, Asian-American history,
LGBTQ+ history, Women's history, the Holocaust and the history
of Anti-Semitism in America. Committee Democrats recognize that
these subjects are not taught in every school, and nothing in
our amendments would compel they be taught, as that would
violate longstanding federal policy. But we did want to protect
the schools and teachers who have chosen to teach these
subjects, letting them know state law mandates to ``Don't Say
Gay''\10\ or ``Teach the Controversy''\11\ could not be
construed to be required by H.R. 5. Committee Republicans voted
down all of these measures on party line votes, with Chairwoman
Foxx repeatedly invoking the longstanding federal ban on
involvement with curricula as the reason.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\2022 Fla. Laws 22.
\11\Terry Gross, From slavery to socialism, new legislation
restricts what teachers can discuss, NPR, Feb. 3, 2022, https://
www.npr.org/2022/02/03/1077878538/legislation-restricts-what-teachers-
can-discuss.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shortly after those amendments were considered, Rep.
Williams (R-NY) offered Sense of Congress language (shared with
the Committee mere minutes before its consideration 12 hours
into the markup) that all public elementary and secondary
school students should have opportunities to learn the history
of the Holocaust and anti-Semitism. While this provision was at
best aspirational and carried no force of law whatsoever,
Democrats led by Rep. Bonamici (D-CA) sought to perfect it by
including the other marginalized groups mentioned in our
previous amendments to this Sense of Congress. The Bonamici
amendment would put Congress on the record as supporting an
expansive and inclusive teaching of history in our schools.
Rather than vote on this provision, the Majority insisted
the Bonamici amendment to the Williams expanded upon the
fundamental purpose of the Williams amendment, which they
determined was the teaching of history relating to the
Holocaust and Anti-Semitism. Despite a masterful argument from
Rep. Takano (D-CA) illustrating the intersectionality of all
our varied histories in American history, and a reminder from
Ranking Member Scott that just because a point of order lies
against an amendment, it doesn't need to be insisted upon
(especially if the provision would materially improve the
bill), the Majority ruled the Bonamici amendment as out of
order and not germane to the fundamental purpose of the
Williams amendment. In the space of less than an hour, the
Majority abandoned its principles of federalism by refusing to
guarantee H.R. 5 could not be used to stifle local curricula
choices. It then introduced language telegraphing what
curricula it thought should be taught, and then prevented the
Committee from expanding that list of curricula to be inclusive
via parliamentary tactics.
H.R. 5 Would Harm Children, Teachers, and Schools
Finally, we must highlight the real harm that PBOR bills,
and H.R. 5 specifically, will inflict on students and their
families. While many of H.R. 5's provisions detail what seem to
be simple ways parents can involve themselves with their
child's educational experience, many of those provisions
already exist in federal law or are even further detailed in
state law. Coupled with these provisions H.R. 5 includes
impactful provisions that may harm children, teachers, and
school communities. For example, by expanding the PPRA to non-
physical (i.e., mental) health and requiring an opt-in with
prior notice to and consent from parents before ``any medical
examination or screening'', except in case of emergency, the
bill could essentially be forcing a school to share information
about a student's sexual orientation in order for the parent to
approve such services. A school official may know that this
sharing would result in harm coming to the child, but under
H.R. 5, they would have no discretion in the matter.
Additionally, there are concerns that requiring prior approval
for such examinations and screenings could allow parents to
essentially conceal abuse in the home, evidence a student would
otherwise share with a relevant mental health professional.
Educators are also worried about H.R. 5\12\ For example,
the National Education Association stated ``. . .the
legislation tells teachers, school counselors, librarians, and
other school professionals that despite their education,
expertise, experience, and dedication to their students, they
cannot be trusted to work with parents and their communities to
determine what materials are appropriate, how to design
curricula that meet students'' needs, nor how to ascertain
students' progress.''\13\ Additionally, there are concerns that
the bill could create the conditions to amplify censorship. The
American Library Association expressed ``concern about the
potential for the negative unintended consequences of further
book banning and censorship of viewpoints that may results if
these federal requirements are imposed on local schools.''\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Libby Stanford, Teachers Say a New Parents' Bill of Rights
Doesn't Solve Schools' Problems, EdWeek, March 7, 2023, https://
www.edweek.org/leadership/teachers-say-a-new-parents-bill-of-rights-
doesnt-solve-schools-problems/2023/03.
\13\Letter from Marc Egan, Director of Government Relations,
National Education Association, to the Committee on Education and the
Workforce (March 7, 2023).
\14\Letter from Alan S. Inouye, Ph.D., Senior Director, Public
Policy & Government Relations and Interim Associate Executive Director,
American Library Association, to the Honorable Virginia Foxx,
Chairwoman, House Education and the Workforce Committee and the
Honorable Bobby Scott, Ranking Member, House Education and the
Workforce Committee (March 3, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DEMOCRATIC AMENDMENTS OFFERED DURING THE MARKUP OF H.R. 5
Committee Democrats put forward 30 amendments in response
to H.R. 5. Democrats offered proposals focusing on improve
parental engagement and ensuring that every child receives an
inclusive, well-funded, and accurate education. Democrats also
offered amendments that addressed impractical aspects of the
bill, including Rep. Alma Adams's successful amendment to
ensure parents could attend conferences remotely and Ranking
Member Scott's unsuccessful amendment which clarified that
parents' right to address school boards come with
reasonablelimitations. Committee Republicans rejected 26 of the 30
Democratic amendments that were considered.
Amendment Number Offered By Description Action Taken
2 Ms. Bonamici Democratic Substitute Defeated
4 Mrs. Hayes Authorizes $117,000,000 for teacher Defeated
preparation, training, and recruiting
under Title II of ESEA
6 Mr. Scott Adds the Strength in Diversity Act, a Defeated
grant program to increase diversity in
schools, to the bill
7 Mr. Scott Rule of construction that nothing in the Defeated
bill may be construed to authorize
Federal funds to arm any person
8 Mr. Grijalva Rule of construction that nothing in the Defeated
bill may be construed to allow the
banning or censorship of books in
public elementary or public secondary
schools
10 Mr. Courtney Rule of construction that nothing in the Adopted
bill may be construed to permit federal
involvement in the curriculum, program
of instruction, administration, or
personnel of any educational
institution, school, or school system
12 Mr. Grijalva Rule of construction that nothing in the Defeated
bill may be construed to permit federal
involvement in the curriculum or
program of instruction of any
educational institution, school, or
school system, including with respect
to Latino history
14 Mr. Grijalva Rule of construction that nothing in the Defeated
bill may be construed to permit federal
involvement in the curriculum or
program of instruction of any
educational institution, school, or
school system, including with respect
to Native American history
16 Mr. Bowman Rule of construction that nothing in the Defeated
bill may be construed to permit federal
involvement in the curriculum or
program of instruction of any
educational institution, school, or
school system, including with respect
to Black history
18 Mr. Scott (Amendment to Amendment #17 offered by Adopted
Mr. Good of Virginia) Clarifies that
public safety officials should be
engaged in certain instances when there
is a credible threat
19 Mr. Takano Rule of construction that nothing in the Defeated
bill may be construed to permit federal
involvement in the curriculum or