Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4428]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Oversight and Accountability, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 4428) to require a guidance clarity
statement on certain agency guidance, and for other purposes,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Summary and Purpose of Legislation............................... 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 3
Legislative History.............................................. 3
Committee Consideration.......................................... 4
Roll Call Votes.................................................. 4
Explanation of Amendments........................................ 6
List of Related Committee Hearings............................... 6
Statement of Oversight Findings and Recommendations of the
Committee...................................................... 6
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 6
Application of Law to the Legislative Branch..................... 6
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 6
Federal Advisory Committee Act Statement......................... 7
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Statement........................... 7
Earmark Identification........................................... 7
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 7
New Budget Authority and Congressional Budget Office Cost
Estimate....................................................... 7
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 8
Minority Views................................................... 9
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Guidance Clarity Act''.
SEC. 2. GUIDANCE CLARITY STATEMENT REQUIRED.
(a) Requirement.--Each agency, as defined in section 551 of title 5,
United States Code, shall include a guidance clarity statement as
described in subsection (b) on any guidance issued by that agency under
section 553(b)(4)(A) of title 5, United States Code, on and after the
date that is 30 days after the date on which the Director of the Office
of Management and Budget issues the guidance required under subsection
(c).
(b) Guidance Clarity Statement.--A guidance clarity statement
required under subsection (a) shall--
(1) be displayed prominently on the first page of the
document; and
(2) include the following: ``The contents of this document do
not have the force and effect of law and do not, of themselves,
bind the public or the agency. This document is intended only
to provide clarity to the public regarding existing
requirements under the law or agency policies.''.
(c) OMB Guidance.--Not later than 90 days after the date of enactment
of this Act, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget shall
issue guidance to implement this Act.
SUMMARY AND PURPOSE OF LEGISLATION
H.R. 4428 requires federal agencies to state prominently on
the opening page of any guidance document that: (1) agency
guidance does not have the force and effect of law and is not
binding on the public; and (2) the document is intended only to
provide clarity to the public about existing legal requirements
or agency policies. H.R. 4428 will help small businesses,
households, and other recipients of agency guidance to
understand that such guidance is not legally binding upon them
and cannot be used as the basis for agency enforcement action
against them.
Background and Need for Legislation
Agency guidance documents have long served a useful
function in the federal regulatory system, helping the public
to understand legal authorities agencies administer and
policies agencies follow. They take various forms, including
``policy statements, manuals, bulletins, advisories, and
more.''\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Memorandum from Dominic J. Mancini, Acting Administrator, Office
of Information & Regulatory Affairs (Oct. 31, 2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
According to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB),
agency guidance documents ``should only clarify existing
obligations; they should not be a vehicle for implementing new,
binding requirements on the public.''\2\ In recent decades,
however, agencies increasingly have relied on guidance
documents ``in attempts to regulate the public without
following the rulemaking procedures'' of the Administrative
Procedure Act, which agencies must follow before issuing
binding rules.\3\ Guidance documents of this sort can ``carry
the implicit threat of enforcement action if the regulated
public does not comply,'' even though they are not supposed to
be binding.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Id.
\3\Executive Order 13891, Promoting the Rule of Law through
Improved Agency Guidance Documents, 84 Fed. Reg. 55235 (Oct. 15, 2019).
\4\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To prevent this type of abuse, the Guidance Clarity Act was
first introduced during the 115th Congress, then as this term
by Rep. Blaine Luetkemeyer (R-MO).\5\ During President Donald
J. Trump's first administration, President Trump ordered
through Executive Order 13891\6\ that agencies during his
administration implement guidance reforms including reforms
contained in the Guidance Clarity Act. President Joseph R.
Biden, however, rescinded E.O. 13891 upon assuming office in
2021.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\H.R. 7378, 115th Congress.
\6\Supra, n. 3.
\7\Executive Order 13992, Revocation of Certain Executive Orders
Concerning Federal Regulation, 86 Fed. Reg. 7049 (Jan. 25, 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 4428 is therefore needed to reinstitute and make
permanent by statute the important guidance reforms it
contains. It requires agencies to display on the first page of
covered guidance documents a guidance clarity statement
explaining that the contents of the document do not have the
force and effect of law, are not binding on the public, and are
intended only to provide clarity about existing requirements
under the law or agency policy. H.R. 4428 brings transparency
and accountability to agency guidance documents and ensures
federal agencies cannot abuse nonbinding guidance documents as
de facto regulations.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title
The short title is the ``Guidance Clarity Act of
2023.''
Section 2. Guidance clarity statement required
Subsection (a) requires each Executive branch
agency, as defined in 5 U.S.C. 551, to issue guidance clarity
statements, as required under subsection (b), for any guidance
document issued under 5 U.S.C. sec. 553(b)(4)(A) (which
includes interpretive rules and general statements of policy)
after 30 days following issuance by the Office of Management
and Budget (OMB) Director of implementation guidance required
under subsection (c).
Subsection (b) requires agencies to prominently
display on p. 1 of agency guidance a guidance clarity statement
which explicitly states: ``The contents of this document do not
have the force and effect of law and do not, of themselves,
bind the public or the agency. This document is intended only
to provide clarity to the public regarding existing
requirements under the law or agency policies.''
Subsection (c) requires the OMB Director to issue
implementation guidance within 90 days of the bill's enactment.
LEGISLATIVE HISTORY
H.R. 4428, the Guidance Clarity Act of 2023, was introduced
on June 30, 2023, by Representative Blaine Luetkemeyer. The
following Representatives are cosponsors of the bill: Jared
Golden (D-ME), James Comer (R-KY), Emanuel Cleaver (D-MO),
Elise Stefanik (R-NY), Pat Fallon (R-TX), Gary Palmer (R-AL),
Donald Davis (D-NC), Byron Donalds (R-FL), and Pete Sessions
(R-TX). The bill was referred to the Committee on Oversight and
Accountability. The Committee on Oversight and Accountability
held a hearing related to and used for development and
consideration of the bill on June 14, 2023. The Committee
considered H.R. 4428 at a business meeting on September 20,
2023, and ordered the bill as amended favorably reported by a
recorded vote.
Committee Consideration
On September 20, the Committee met in open session and
ordered the bill, H.R. 4428, favorably reported with an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, by a roll call vote of
24-19, a quorum being present.
ROLL CALL VOTES
In compliance with clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the following roll call vote
occurred during the Committee's consideration of H.R. 4428:
The first roll call vote was on favorably reporting H.R.
4428. The bill was agreed to in a recorded vote of 24-19.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
EXPLANATION OF AMENDMENTS
During Committee consideration of the bill, Representative
James Comer (R-KY), Chairman of the Committee, offered an
amendment in the nature of a substitute that made certain
technical changes to the bill. The amendment in the nature of a
substitute, as amended, passed by voice vote.
LIST OF RELATED COMMITTEE HEARINGS
In accordance with House rule XIII, clause 3(c)(6), (1) the
following hearing was used to develop or consider H.R. 4428:
On June 14, 2023, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Death by a Thousand Regulations: The Biden Administration's
Campaign to Bury America in Red Tape'' with the following
witnesses: Mr. Anthony P. Campau, Principal, Clark Hill Public
Strategies; Prof. Casey Mulligan, University of Chicago; Mr.
Adam J. White, Senior Fellow, American Enterprise Institute,
and Co-Executive Director, the C. Boyden Gray Center for the
Study of the Administrative State, George Mason University
Antonin Scalia Law School; and Prof. Sally Katzen, New York
University School of Law.
STATEMENT OF OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE
COMMITTEE
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII and clause
(2)(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the Committee's oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the Background and Need for
Legislation section above.
STATEMENT OF GENERAL PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
In accordance with clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee's performance
goals or objectives of this bill are to require federal
agencies to state prominently on the opening page of any
guidance document that: (1) agency guidance does not have the
force and effect of law and is not binding on the public; and
(2) the document is intended only to provide clarity to the
public about existing legal requirements or agency policies.
APPLICATION OF LAW TO THE LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
Section 102(b)(3) of Public Law 104-1 requires a
description of the application of this bill to the legislative
branch where the bill relates to the terms and conditions of
employment or access to public services and accommodations.
This bill does not relate to employment or access to public
services and accommodations in the legislative branch.
DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
In accordance with clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII no provision
of this bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
Federal Government known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, a program that was included in any report from the
Government Accountability Office to Congress pursuant to
section 21 of Public Law 111-139, or a program related to a
program identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal
Domestic Assistance.
FEDERAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE ACT STATEMENT
The Committee finds that this legislation does not direct
the establishment of advisory committees within the definition
of Section 5(b) of the appendix to title 5, U.S.C.
UNFUNDED MANDATES REFORM ACT STATEMENT
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
EARMARK IDENTIFICATION
This bill does not include any congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in
clause 9 of rule XXI of the House of Representatives.
COMMITTEE COST ESTIMATE
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
includes below a cost estimate prepared by the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY AND CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives and section 308(a) of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, and pursuant to clause
3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the cost estimate prepared by the
Congressional Budget Office and submitted pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 is as follows:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 4428 would require federal agencies to include text in
their guidance documents to clarify that such guidance is not
legally binding. Guidance documents typically explain how
regulations are interpreted by the agency but do not carry the
force of law. Agencies disseminate guidance to the public in
memorandums, notices, bulletins, directives, news releases,
letters, blog posts, or speeches.
CBO expects that placing a clarifying statement in each
guidance document would not significantly increase agencies'
administrative costs. CBO estimates that the administrative
expenses associated with implementing H.R. 4428 would cost less
than $500,000 over the 2024-2028 period; any spending would be
subject to the availability of appropriated funds.
Enacting H.R. 4428 could affect direct spending by some
agencies that are allowed to use fees, receipts from the sale
of goods, and other collections to cover operating costs. CBO
estimates that any net changes in direct spending by those
agencies would be negligible because most of them can adjust
amounts collected to reflect changes in operating costs.
On April 17, 2023, CBO transmitted a cost estimate for S.
108, the Guidance Clarity Act of 2023, as ordered reported by
the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental
Affairs on March 29, 2023. The two bills are similar, and CBO's
estimates of their budgetary effects are the same.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Matthew
Pickford. The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss,
Deputy Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED
The requirements of clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives do not apply to H.R. 4428.
Minority Views
H.R. 4428, the Guidance Clarity Act, would require federal
agencies to state on the first page of any guidance document
that the guidance does not have the force and effect of law and
is intended only to provide clarity to the public about
existing legal requirements or agency policies.
Although agency-issued guidance to the public does not
literally have the force of law, stating this on every piece of
guidance would be tremendously confusing and misleading,
particularly for all the statutory programs and regimes that
rely on a combination of statute and implementing guidance in
the real world to function properly.
This legislation would furnish regulated entities more
opportunities to escape the law and to bring frivolous suits
over agency guidance, with the inevitable result being that
agencies will be unable to hold polluters accountable, protect
worker safety, and ensure that the public has access to
healthy, safe food, water, air, and products.
Jamie Raskin,
Ranking Member.
[all]