Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 1419]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 1419) to direct the Secretary of the Interior to
issue a new rule removing the Northern Continental Divide
Ecosystem population of grizzly bears from the Federal list of
endangered and threatened wildlife, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon without amendment and recommends that
the bill do pass.
PURPOSE OF THE LEGISLATION
The purpose of H.R. 1419 is to direct the Secretary of the
Interior to issue a new rule removing the Northern Continental
Divide Ecosystem population of grizzly bears from the Federal
list of endangered and threatened wildlife.
Background and Need for Legislation
H.R. 1419 requires the Secretary of the Interior to, not
later than 180 days after enactment, issue a final rule
removing the Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem (NCDE)
population of grizzly bears from the federal list of endangered
and threatened wildlife. The bill also prohibits the rule from
being subject to judicial review.
The grizzly bear was first listed under the Endangered
Species Act (ESA) in 1975 as a threatened species in the lower
48 states. A grizzly bear recovery plan was developed in 1982
and amended in 1993 with the goal of delisting the species in
the future.\1\ The 1993 recovery plan created six distinct
recovery areas across the grizzly bear's historic range: the
Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem, Northern Continental Divide
Ecosystem, Cabinet-Yaak Ecosystem, Selkirk Ecosystem, North
Cascades Ecosystem, and Bitterroot Ecosystem. The NCDE occurs
only in Montana.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\``Grizzly Bear Recovery Plan.'' Dr. Christopher Servheen.
September 10, 1993. fws.pdf (npshistory.com).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In December 2021, the State of Montana petitioned the U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) to delist grizzly bears
within the NCDE. At the time the delisting petition was filed,
Montana estimated the NCDE population at approximately 1,100
bears.\2\ In addition to population numbers, NCDE grizzly bears
have more than doubled their range area since being listed,
according to the USFWS. The NCDE grizzly range has grown from
24,800 square kilometers to over 67,652 square kilometers.\3\
For context, this means NCDE grizzlies are distributing to
areas outside of the area known as the Rocky Mountain Front to
prairie lands in eastern Montana, where they have not been for
over a century.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\``Governor Gianforte: Montana Petitioning Federal Government to
Delist NCDE Grizzly Bears.'' Governor's Office. December 6, 2021. Gov.
Gianforte: Montana Petitioning Federal Government to Delist NCDE
Grizzly Bears (mt.gov).
\3\``Grizzly Bear Recovery Program.'' 2021 Annual Report. Grizzly
Bear Recovery Program. 2021 Grizzly Bear Recovery Program Annual Report
FWS.gov.
\4\``Governor Gianforte: Montana Petitioning Federal Government to
Delist NCDE Grizzly Bears.'' Governor's Office. December 6, 2021. Gov.
Gianforte: Montana Petitioning Federal Government to Delist NCDE
Grizzly Bears (mt.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
According to a 2021 USFWS Report, the NCDE grizzly bear
population had achieved at least 2 out of the 3 population
objectives to warrant delisting: (1) NCDE grizzlies have
maintained a well-distributed grizzly bear population within
the NCDE; and (2) mortalities have been managed to keep an
estimated probability of at least 90% that the grizzly bear
population remains above 800 bears. The third objective,
genetic connectivity between populations, is still being
monitored by Montana and USFWS.\5\ Since the publication of
that report, the State of Montana committed in its delisting
petition to provide connectivity of NCDE grizzly bears to other
populations areas.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\``Grizzly Bear Recovery Program.'' 2021 Annual Report. Grizzly
Bear Recovery Program. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2021 GBRP Annual
Report.pdf (fws.gov).
\6\``A Petition to Identify and Delist the Northern Continental
Divide Distinct Population Segment of the Grizzly Bear (Ursus arctos
horribilis) Under the Endangered Species Act.'' Governor Greg Gianforte
and Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife, and Parks. December 17, 2021.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In preparation for possible delisting, the Montana Fish and
Wildlife Commission approved a population objective in 2018
that mirrored the USFWS objective of maintaining a population
of over 800 bears with at least 90 percent certainty.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\``Governor Gianforte: Montana Petitioning Federal Government to
Delist NCDE Grizzly Bears.'' Governor's Office. December 6, 2021. Gov.
Gianforte: Montana Petitioning Federal Government to Delist NCDE
Grizzly Bears (mt.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, the NCDE grizzly bear meets the five factors
identified in Section 4(a)(1) of the ESA. Included in these
five factors is the need for adequate regulatory mechanisms to
be in place post delisting, in order to ensure the long-term
viability of the species. Montana has laid out adequate
regulatory mechanisms in its delisting petition to ensure the
long-term viability of the species, post delisting.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These mechanisms include enshrining in state statute that
the state of Montana shall: maintain the recovered status of
the NCDE grizzly bear, limit motorized access in grizzly bear
habitat in order to minimize grizzly bear/human conflicts,
align grizzly bear take laws with policies already approved by
the USFWS for wolves, and employ a fulltime employee dedicated
solely to translocation of grizzlies for the specific goal of
genetic diversity.
In response to Montana's petition, the USFWS announced on
February 3, 2023, that a delisting in the NCDE ``may be
warranted'' and initiated a 12-month status review of the
species.\9\ However any rulemaking delisting the NCDE grizzly
bear, like similar delisting rules on other grizzly bear
populations, will be vulnerable to litigation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\``Service to initiate grizzly bear status review in the Northern
Continental Divide and Greater Yellowstone ecosystems.'' U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service. February 3, 2023. Service to initiate grizzly bear
status review in the Northern Continental Divide & Greater Yellowstone
ecosystems U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service (fws.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For the ESA to work properly, there must be an achievable
recovery goal for land managers and private landowners to
reach. In the case of the NCDE grizzly bear, that goal has been
reached and we should be celebrating that as a success story.
The state of Montana is ready and able to take over management
control of a delisted NCDE grizzly bear population and this
bill would do just that.
Committee Action
H.R. 1419 was introduced on March 7, 2023, by Rep. Matthew
M. Rosendale, Sr. (R-MT). The bill was referred to the
Committee on Natural Resources, and within the Committee to the
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries. On March 23,
2023, the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries held a
hearing on the bill. On April 27-28, 2023, the Committee on
Natural Resources met to consider the bill. The Subcommittee on
Water, Wildlife and Fisheries was discharged by unanimous
consent. Ranking Member Raul Grijalva (D-AZ) offered an
amendment designated Grijalva #1. The amendment offered by
Ranking Member Grijalva was not adopted by a roll call vote of
17 yeas to 21 nays, as follows:
The bill was then ordered favorably reported to the House
of Representatives by a roll call vote of 22 yeas to 17 nays,
as follows:
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries
held on March 23, 2023.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title
Section 1 establishes the short title of the bill as the
``Comprehensive Grizzly Bear Management Act of 2023''.
Section 2. Removal of Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem population
of grizzly bears from Federal list of endangered and threatened
wildlife
Section 2 requires the Secretary of the Interior, not later
than 180 days after the enactment of the Act, to issue a final
rule removing the Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem
population of grizzly bears from the Federal list of endangered
and threatened wildlife. This section also precludes issuance
of the final rule, and section 2 of the Act, from judicial
review.
COMMITTEE OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
COMPLIANCE WITH HOUSE RULE XIII
AND CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET ACT
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) and (3) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and
section 308(a) and 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974,
the Committee has received the following estimate for the bill
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
H.R. 1419 would direct the Secretary of the Interior to
issue, without regard to other provisions of law, a final rule
removing the Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem population
of grizzly bears from the list of threatened and endangered
species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). H.R. 1419 also
would exempt the final rule from judicial review.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) is authorized to
collect permitting fees for lawful activities that involve
protected species, including scientific research, conservation,
and unintentional taking of the animals while performing
permitted activities. Under H.R. 1419, permits would no longer
be required for such activities involving grizzly bears in the
Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem. Permitting fees are
recorded in the budget as offsetting receipts (or reductions in
direct spending) and are available to be spent without further
appropriation. Using information from USFWS, CBO estimates that
enacting H.R. 1419 would reduce those receipts and the
consequent spending by an insignificant amount over the 2024-
2033 period so that the net increase in direct spending would
be negligible.
Violators of the ESA are subject to civil and criminal
penalties, which are recorded as revenues and are available for
spending without further appropriation. Using information from
USFWS, CBO estimates that any reductions in penalties or
associated spending would be insignificant because of the small
number of related cases expected to occur over the 2024-2033
period.
Finally, CBO estimates that the administrative costs to
issue the final rule under H.R. 1419 would be insignificant;
any spending would be subject to the availability of
appropriated funds.
H.R. 1419 would impose an intergovernmental and private-
sector mandate as defined in the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act
(UMRA) by eliminating a right of action for entities to seek
judicial review of the administrative rule required by the
bill. Because the rights of action precluded under the bill do
not generally result in monetary damages, CBO estimates that
the cost of the mandates would fall well below the
intergovernmental and private-sector thresholds established in
UMRA ($99 million and $198 million in 2023, respectively,
adjusted annually for inflation).
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Lilia Ledezma
(for federal costs) and Brandon Lever (for mandates). The
estimate was reviewed by Emily Stern, Senior Adviser for Budget
Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
2. General Performance Goals and Objectives. As required by
clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general performance goal or
objective of this bill is to direct the Secretary of the
Interior to issue a new rule removing the Northern Continental
Divide Ecosystem population of grizzly bears from the Federal
list of endangered and threatened wildlife.
EARMARK STATEMENT
This bill does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined
under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives.
UNFUNDED MANDATES REFORM ACT STATEMENT
According to the Congressional Budget Office, H.R. 1419
would impose an intergovernmental and private-sector mandate as
defined in the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act by eliminating a
right of action for entities to seek judicial review of the
administrative rule required by the bill. However, the
Congressional Budget Office estimates that the cost of the
mandates would fall well below the intergovernmental and
private-sector thresholds established in the Unfunded Mandates
Reform Act, which are $99 million and $198 million in 2023,
respectively, adjusted annually for inflation.
EXISTING PROGRAMS
Directed Rule Making. This bill directs the Secretary of
the Interior, an executive branch official, to issue a final
rule removing the Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem
population of grizzly bears from the list of threatened and
endangered species under the Endangered Species Act.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This bill does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
PREEMPTION OF STATE, LOCAL OR TRIBAL LAW
Any preemptive effect of this bill over state, local, or
tribal law is intended to be consistent with the bill's
purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
U.S. Constitution.
CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW
As ordered reported by the Committee on Natural Resources,
H.R. 1419 would make no changes in existing law.
Dissenting Views
H.R. 1419 would legislatively de-list the Northern
Continental Divide Ecosystem Grizzly Bear from the Endangered
Species Act (ESA). It directs the Secretary of the Interior to
issue a rule removing the Northern Continental Divide Ecosystem
(NCDE) population of grizzly bears, in Northern Montana, from
the Federal List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife. It does
not take into consideration any other provision of law that
applies to the issuance of such a rule, such as the
Administrative Procedure Act. H.R. 1419 would exempt the de-
listing from judicial review.
The NCDE grizzly bear population is approximately 1,060
individuals.\1\ Despite population size and range increases,
grizzlies continue to be threatened by genetic bottlenecks,
habitat loss, lack of habitat connectivity, climate change,
hunting, and other contact with humans. With increased grizzly
population numbers and continued human encroachment and
development in grizzly habitat, encounters have increased.
Unfortunately, state management often allows the hunting of
grizzlies, and even with protections under the ESA,
``problematic'' grizzlies are killed.\2\ Conflicting opinions
on state management and federal protections have created
contention around grizzly management, resulting in many
petitions to de-list the grizzly and lawsuits regarding listing
decisions over the years.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Costello, C. 2020. Email from Cecily Costello, MFWP Grizzly Bear
Research Biologist to Jennifer Fortin-Noreus, USFWS Wildlife Biologist
on January 17, 2020.
\2\See, e.g., Brown, M. US May Lift Protections for Yellowstone,
Glacier Grizzlies. February 3, 2023. https://apnews.com/article/us-
fish-and-wildlife-service-alaska-montana-wyoming-idaho-
ff09eccea665e580248c44692d46115d.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) is conducting a
status review based on three petitions to de-list the grizzly
bear, two of which would de-list the grizzly in the NCDE. Upon
completion of the evaluation, the FWS may choose to alter the
listing status of any of the petitioned populations.
This bill attempts to bypass the species status assessment,
congressionally de-list the grizzly bear in the NCDE, and
prevent any similar listing in the future.
The passage of this bill would circumvent the FWS review
process, which is currently ongoing and being conducted by
experts in their field based on the best available science. If
supporters of this bill believe that the best available science
points to recovery and warrants the de-listing of grizzly
populations in the NCDE, then they should present relevant data
to the FWS and feel confident that an appropriate listing
decision will be made. The current FWS review will be over in
less than 12 months, with an announcement expected next
February. The rush for Republicans to bring this legislation
forward before the FWS results are published lends doubt to
their claims that state management is adequate to protect the
grizzly from future harm and underscores the need for an
unbiased, scientific review of the facts to determine species
listing and de-listing under the ESA.
Further, many Native Americans value the grizzly bear in
ways that are not--and cannot be--accounted for under the ESA.
Their concerns should be considered in the future of grizzly
management. Blocking judicial review removes a vital avenue for
public and tribal recourse on grizzly management issues. The
bill ignores federal trust responsibilities with tribes and
skips tribal consultation, leaving tribes entirely out of the
process.
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member.