Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 215]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 215) to provide long-term water supply and
regulatory reliability to drought-stricken California, and for
other purposes, having considered the same, reports favorably
thereon with an amendment and recommends that the bill as
amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Working to Advance Tangible and
Effective Reforms for California Act'' or the ``WATER for California
Act''.
SEC. 2. TABLE OF CONTENTS.
The table of contents for this Act is as follows:
Sec. 1. Short title.
Sec. 2. Table of contents.
Sec. 3. Definitions.
TITLE I--CVP AND SWP OPERATIONS
Sec. 101. Operation of the CVP and SWP.
Sec. 102. Operations and reviews.
Sec. 103. Application of State laws.
Sec. 104. Reconsultation of NOAA biological opinion and FWS biological
opinion.
Sec. 105. Sunset.
Sec. 106. Consultation on coordinated operations.
TITLE II--ALLOCATIONS FOR SACRAMENTO VALLEY CONTRACTORS
Sec. 201. Definitions.
Sec. 202. Allocations of water.
Sec. 203. Protection of refuge, municipal and industrial, and other
contractors.
Sec. 204. Other contractors.
TITLE III--INFRASTRUCTURE
Sec. 301. Shasta reservoir enlargement project.
Sec. 302. Water supply plan; projects.
Sec. 303. Conservation fish hatcheries.
Sec. 304. Storage; duration.
Sec. 305. Shasta dam enlargement.
TITLE IV--CVPIA ACTIONS
Sec. 401. CVPIA restoration actions.
TITLE V--WATER SUPPLY PERMITTING COORDINATION ACT
Sec. 501. Short title.
Sec. 502. Definitions.
Sec. 503. Establishment of lead agency and cooperating agencies.
Sec. 504. Bureau responsibilities.
Sec. 505. Cooperating agency responsibilities.
Sec. 506. Funding to process permits.
SEC. 3. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act, the following definitions apply:
(1) Cvp.--The term ``CVP'' means the Central Valley Project.
(2) Cvp contractor.--The term ``CVP contractor'' means any
public water agency, water user organization, or person that
has entered into a contract with the United States for water
service from the CVP, whether in the form of a water service
contract, repayment contract, water rights settlement contract,
exchange contract, or refuge contract.
(3) Fws biological opinion.--The term ``FWS Biological
Opinion'' means the United States Fish and Wildlife Service
``Biological Opinion for the Reinitiation of Consultation on
the Coordinated Operations of the Central Valley Project and
State Water Project'' (Service File No. 08FBTD00-2019-F-0164)
signed on October 21, 2019.
(4) Noaa biological opinion.--The term ``NOAA Biological
Opinion'' means the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration Fisheries ``Biological Opinion on the Long-term
Operation of the Central Valley Project and the State Water
Project'' (Consultation Tracking Number: WCRO-2016-00069)
signed on October 21, 2019.
(5) Preferred alternative.--The term ``Preferred
Alternative'' means the Alternative 1 (Preferred Alternative),
as described in the Final Environmental Impact Statement on the
Reinitiation of Consultation on the Coordinated Long-Term
Operation of the Central Valley Project and the State Water
Project, issued by the Bureau of Reclamation, and dated
December 2019.
(6) Swp.--The term ``SWP'' means the California State Water
Project.
(7) Swp contractor.--The term ``SWP contractor'' means a
public agency that has entered into a long-term water supply
contract with the California Department of Water Resources for
water service from the SWP.
TITLE I--CVP AND SWP OPERATIONS
SEC. 101. OPERATION OF THE CVP AND SWP.
(a) Congressional Direction Regarding Cvp and Swp Operations.--The
CVP and the SWP shall be operated, and reporting shall be done, in
accordance with the Preferred Alternative and FWS Biological Opinion
and NOAA Biological Opinion.
(b) Exceptions.--Operation of the CVP and SWP shall proceed pursuant
to subsection (a) of this section, except:
(1) to the extent changes to operations are undertaken
pursuant to one or more agreements, which are voluntarily
entered into, approved, and implemented by CVP contractors, for
operations of the CVP, and SWP contractors, for operations of
the SWP, with all applicable Federal departments and the State
of California, including any agency or board of the State of
California; or
(2) to the extent changes in operations of the CVP, SWP, or
both can be made while improving the supply of water available
to CVP contractors, SWP contractors, or both.
(c) Costs.--No cost, including water supply, financial, mintigation-
related, or otherwise, associated with the implementation of any
agreement under subsection (b)(1) or the implementation of any
reoperation under subsection (b)(2) shall be imposed by any Federal
department or agency or the State of California, including any agency
or board of the State of California, directly or indirectly on any CVP
contractor, SWP contractor, or any other person or entity, unless such
costs are incurred on a voluntary basis.
(d) No Redirected Adverse Impacts.--The Secretary of the Interior and
Secretary of Commerce shall not carry out any specific action
authorized under the applicable provisions of this title that would
directly or through State agency action indirectly result in the
involuntary reduction of water supply to an individual, district, or
agency that has in effect a contract for water with the SWP or the CVP,
including settlement, exchange, and refuge contracts, and Friant
Division contracts.
(e) Endangered Species Act.--Notwithstanding subsection (b),
implementation of subsection (a) shall not conflict with the FWS
Biological Opinion and the NOAA Biological Opinion.
(f) Native Species Protection.--The State of California shall not
impose any bag, catch, or size restriction or limit on the take or
harvest of striped bass or any species of black bass, including
largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, and spotted bass, that occupy the
Sacramento-San Joaquin Rivers Delta or its tributaries.
SEC. 102. OPERATIONS AND REVIEWS.
In carrying out section 101(a), the Secretary of the Interior and the
Secretary of Commerce shall implement their statutory authorities in a
manner that improves water supply reliability and enables the CVP and
SWP to provide the maximum quantity of water supplies practicable to
CVP agricultural, municipal, and industrial contractors, water service
or repayment contractors, water rights settlement contractors, exchange
contractors, refuge contractors, and SWP contractors, in accordance
with the Preferred Alternative, NOAA Biological Opinion, and FWS
Biological Opinion.
SEC. 103. APPLICATION OF STATE LAWS.
(a) Reduced Water Supply.--If, as a result of the application of
applicable State law or regulation, the State of California (including
any agency or board of the State of California) alters operation of the
SWP in a manner that directly or indirectly results in reduced water
supply to the SWP as compared with the water supply available under the
Preferred Alternative, and as a result, CVP yield is greater than it
otherwise would have been under the Preferred Alternative, then that
additional yield shall be made available to the SWP for delivery to SWP
Contractors to offset that reduced water supply. If it is necessary to
reduce water supplies for any authorized uses of the CVP or CVP
Contractors to make available to the SWP that additional yield, such
reductions shall be applied proportionately to those authorized uses or
CVP contractors that benefit from that increased yield.
(b) No Restriction of Certain Water Rights.--The State of California
(including any agency or board of the State of California) shall not
restrict the exercise of any water right obtained pursuant to State
law, including but not limited to a pre-1914 appropriative right or
riparian right in order to offset any impact resulting from the
implementation of this title on any species affected by operations of
the CVP or the SWP.
(c) No Involuntary Water Reduction.--The State of California
(including any agency or board of the State of California), the
Secretary of the Interior and Secretary of Commerce shall not take any
action related to operation of the CVP or SWP that would directly or
indirectly result in the involuntary reduction of water supply to any
CVP agricultural, municipal and industrial contractor, water service or
repayment contractor, water rights settlement contractor, exchange
contractor, refuge contractor or any SWP contractor, as compared to the
water supply available under the Preferred Alternative; and nothing in
this section is intended to modify, amend, or affect any of the rights
and obligations of the parties to such contracts.
SEC. 104. RECONSULTATION OF NOAA BIOLOGICAL OPINION AND FWS BIOLOGICAL
OPINION.
(a) Requirement for Reconsultation.--
(1) Requirement.--Unless action is taken pursuant to section
101(b), neither the Secretary of the Interior, acting through
the Commissioner of the Bureau of Reclamation, nor the
Secretary of Commerce, or their designees shall commence,
complete, or request reinitiation of consultation on the
coordinated long-term operation of the Central Valley Project
and the State Water Project that will result in changes to or
the replacement of the documents listed in paragraph (2)
unless--
(A) more than 75 percent of California has
experienced 4 consecutive years of D3 or D4 level
drought, as defined by the U.S. Drought Monitor;
(B) the Commissioner of the Bureau of Reclamation
identifies one specific factor or combination of
factors under section 402.16 of title 50, Code of
Federal Regulations; and
(C) not fewer than 120 days before officially
commencing or requesting reinitiation, the Secretary of
the Interior notifies the Committee on Natural
Resources of the House of Representatives and Committee
on Energy and Natural Resources of the Senate, in
writing, of--
(i) the intent to commence or request
reinitiation under this section; and
(ii) the detailed justification for the
identification of the specific factor or
combination of factors under section 402.16 of
title 50, Code of Federal Regulations, that was
identified to satisfy the requirement in
subparagraph (B).
(2) Documents.--The documents referred to in paragraph (1)
are the following:
(A) The FWS Biological Opinion.
(B) The NOAA Biological Opinion.
(C) The Record of Decision for the Reinitiation of
Consultation on the Coordinated Long-Term Modified
Operations of the Central Valley Project and State
Water Project, signed on February 18, 2020.
(b) Applicable Procedures and Review.--For the purposes of this Act,
before reinitiating consultation on the Long-Term Operation of the CVP
and SWP, a request by the Secretary of the Interior, the Secretary of
the Commerce, or any other Federal employee, to reinitiate consultation
shall be made in writing and considered a rule under section 551 of
title 5, United States Code, and subject to the requirements of
sections 801 through 808 of that title.
(c) Cooperation.--In implementing this section, the Secretary of the
Interior and the Secretary of Commerce shall comply with requirements
included in section 4004 of the Water Infrastructure Improvements for
the Nation Act (Public Law 114-322).
(d) Exclusion.--Notwithstanding subsection (b), in implementing this
section, section 801(b)(2) of title 5, United States Code, shall not
apply.
SEC. 105. SUNSET.
Sections 101 through 104 shall have no force or effect on and after
the date that is 7 years after the date of the enactment of this Act.
SEC. 106. CONSULTATION ON COORDINATED OPERATIONS.
The Water Infrastructure Improvements for the Nation Act (Public Law
114-322) is amended--
(1) in section 4004(a)--
(A) in the matter preceding paragraph (1), strike
``public water agency that contracts'' and insert
``contractor'';
(B) in paragraph (1), by inserting ``or proposed
action'' before the semicolon;
(C) in paragraph (2), by inserting ``or proposed
action'' before the semicolon;
(D) by redesignating paragraphs (3) through (6) as
paragraphs (4) through (7), respectively;
(E) after paragraph (2), by inserting the following
new paragraph:
``(3) receive a copy of the draft proposed action and have
the opportunity to review that document and provide comment to
the action agency, which comments shall be afforded due
consideration during development;''; and
(F) in paragraph (7), as redesignated by subparagraph
(C) of this paragraph--
(i) in the matter preceding subparagraph (A),
by inserting ``action agency proposes a
proposed action or'' before ``the consulting
agency'';
(ii) in subparagraph (A), by inserting
``proposed action or'' before ``alternative
will''; and
(iii) in subparagraph (B), by striking
``alternative actions'' and insert ``actions or
alternatives''; and
(2) in section 4013, by deleting ``section 4004, which shall
expire 10 years after the date of its enactment;'' and
inserting ``section 4004, which shall expire on December 16,
2033;''.
TITLE II--ALLOCATIONS FOR SACRAMENTO VALLEY CONTRACTORS
SEC. 201. DEFINITIONS.
In this title, the following definitions apply:
(1) The term ``existing CVP agricultural water service or
repayment contractor within the Sacramento River Watershed''
means any water service or repayment contractor within the
Shasta, Trinity, or Sacramento River division of the CVP that
has in effect a water service or repayment contract on the date
of enactment of this title that provides water for irrigation.
(2) The terms ``Above Normal'', ``Below Normal'', ``Dry'',
and ``Wet'', with respect to a year, have the meanings given
those terms in the Sacramento Valley Water Year Type (40-30-30)
Index.
SEC. 202. ALLOCATIONS OF WATER.
Subject to section 203, the Secretary of the Interior shall make
every reasonable effort in the operation of the CVP to allocate water
provided for irrigation purposes to each existing CVP agricultural
water service contractor within the Sacramento River Watershed in
accordance with the following:
(1) Not less than 100 percent of the contract quantity of the
existing CVP agricultural water service contractor within the
Sacramento River Watershed in a Wet year.
(2) Not less than 100 percent of the contract quantity of the
existing CVP agricultural water service contractor within the
Sacramento River Watershed in an Above Normal year.
(3) Not less than 100 percent of the contract quantity of the
existing CVP agricultural water service contractor within the
Sacramento River Watershed in a Below Normal year that is
preceded by an Above Normal or Wet year.
(4) Not less than 50 percent of the contract quantity of the
existing CVP agricultural water service contractor within the
Sacramento River Watershed in a Dry year that is preceded by a
Below Normal, Above Normal, or Wet year.
(5) In any other year not identified in any subsections (a)
through (d), not less than twice the allocation percentage to
south-of-Delta CVP agricultural water service contractors, up
to 100 percent.
SEC. 203. PROTECTION OF REFUGE, MUNICIPAL AND INDUSTRIAL, AND OTHER
CONTRACTORS.
Nothing in section 202 shall--
(1) adversely affect any protections for the environment,
including the obligation of the Secretary of the Interior to
make water available to managed wetlands pursuant to section
3406(d) of the Central Valley Project Improvement Act (title
XXXIV of Public Law 102-575; 106 Stat. 4722);
(2) adversely affect any obligation of the Secretary of the
Interior or the Secretary of Commerce under the FWS Biological
Opinion or the NOAA Biological Opinion;
(3) modify any provision of a water service contract that
addresses municipal or industrial water shortage policies of
the Secretary of the Interior;
(4) affect or limit the authority of the Secretary of the
Interior to adopt or modify municipal and industrial water
shortage policies;
(5) constrain, govern, or affect, directly or indirectly, the
operations of the American River division of the CVP or any
deliveries from that division or a unit or facility of that
division; or
(6) affect any allocation to a CVP municipal or industrial
water service contractor by increasing or decreasing
allocations to the contractor, as compared to the allocation
the contractor would have received absent section 202.
SEC. 204. OTHER CONTRACTORS.
Nothing in section 202 shall--
(1) affect the priority of any individual or entity with a
Sacramento River settlement contract over water service or
repayment contractors;
(2) affect the United States ability to deliver water to the
San Joaquin River exchange contractors from the Sacramento
River and the Delta via the Delta-Mendota Canal or modify or
amend the rights and obligations under the Purchase Contract
between Miller and Lux and the United States and the Second
Amended Exchange Contract between the United States, Department
of the Interior, Bureau of Reclamation and Central California
Irrigation District, San Luis Canal Company, Firebaugh Canal
Water District and Columbia Canal Company;
(3) affect the allocation of water to Friant division
contractors of the CVP;
(4) result in the
Background and Need for Legislation
California's Central Valley is divided into three basins:
the Sacramento Valley, the San Joaquin Valley, and the Tulare
Lake Basin. The total mean annual inflow to the Sacramento and
San Joaquin valleys is approximately 23.1-million-acre feet
(AF), but annual flows have ranged from a low of 6.2 million AF
in 1977 to a high of 52.7 million AF in 1983.\1\ An AF is
326,000 gallons of water, or enough to cover a football field
with water one foot deep.\2\ In the Tulare Lake Basin the
Kings, Kaweah, Tule, and Kern Rivers have a combined mean
annual runoff of approximately 2 million AF.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\USBR, Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers Basin Study, March 2016.
https://www.usbr.gov/watersmart/bsp/docs/finalreport/sacramento-sj/
Sacramento_SanJoaquin_SUMMARY.pdf.
\2\Water Education Foundation, What's an acre-foot?. https://
www.watereducation.org/general-information/whats-acre-foot.
\3\USBR, Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers Basin Study, March 2016.
https://www.usbr.gov/watersmart/bsp/docs/finalreport/sacramento-sj/
Sacramento_SanJoaquin_SUMMARY.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These basins are the water source for the State's main
federal water project, the Central Valley Project (CVP). The
CVP is a system of 20 dams and reservoirs that together can
hold nearly 12 million acre-feet.\4\ Based on CVP water
contracts, the project can deliver up to 9.5 million AF, but
actual deliveries are much lower due various factors including
drought, and federal and state restrictions.\5\ On average, the
CVP delivers about 6 million AF of water per year for
irrigation, municipal, industrial, and environmental
benefits.\6\ The irrigation water, about 5 million AF, is used
on about 3 million acres, or roughly one-third of the
agricultural land in California.\7\ However, over the past two
years, water deliveries have been much lower than average. As a
result of drought conditions, environmental restrictions, and
low reservoir levels, in 2022 deliveries totaled 1.69 million
AF\8\ and 3.9 million AF in 2021--with the majority of the
reductions impacting agriculture.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\UBSR, Central Valley Project, Background. https://www.usbr.gov/
mp/cvp/.
\5\USBR, Central Valley Project, Water Quantities for Delivery
2023. https://www.usbr.gov/mp/cvp-water/docs/cvp-water-quantities-for-
delivery-2023.pdf.
\6\Of the 6 million AF, senior water rights holders receive 3.2
million AF, irrigation contracts receive 2.2 million AF, and
approximately 600,000 AF is for municipal and industrial uses. https://
www.usbr.gov/mp/cvp/.
\7\UBSR, About the Central Valley Project, https://www.usbr.gov/mp/
cvp/about-cvp.html.
\8\USBR, Central Valley Project, Water Quantities for Delivery
2022. https://www.usbr.gov/mp/cvp-water/docs/cvp-water-quantities-for-
delivery-2022.pdf.
\9\USBR, Central Valley Project, Water Quantities for Delivery
2021. https://www.usbr.gov/mp/cvp-water/docs/cvp-allocation.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The CVP system does not have enough storage capacity to
capture water during big storm events and keep it for future
use. The Trump administration tried to increase the storage
capacity of Shasta Dam in northern California to address this
need. Under the Trump administration, the Bureau of Reclamation
(Reclamation) released its Final Supplemental Environmental
Impact Statement on raising Shasta Dam an additional 18.5 feet.
This would have provided an additional 634,000 AF of stored
water to increase anadromous (salmon) fish survival and water
supply reliability while providing for flood control, water
quality, hydropower generation, and recreation
opportunities.\10\ This project has faced repeated opposition
by Democratic Members of Congress and has been ignored by the
Biden administration.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\USBR, Final Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement, Shasta
Lake Water Resources Investigation. https://www.usbr.gov/mp/nepa/
includes/documentShow.php?Doc_ID=47404.
\11\Since FY2021 appropriations, Democrats have included funding
prohibitions for the Shasta dam raise in appropriations bills. Rep. Ken
Calvert has offered amendments to remove this rider each time. https://
calvert.house.gov/media/press-releases/rep-calvert-offers-california-
water-storage-amendments-during-energy-and-water.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For decades, the CVP and the State Water Project (SWP)
operations have been managed in a coordinated manner to deliver
water to cities, communities, and farms. The CVP's operations
have been subject to several controversies and litigation,
especially over the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Some federal
water projects, such as the CVP, are subject to biological
opinions (BiOps) issued by the National Marine Fisheries
Service (NMFS) and/or the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
(USFWS) over ESA-listed species. The intent of a BiOp is to
ensure the project does not reduce the likelihood of survival
and recovery of an ESA-listed species. While a BiOp is not an
ESA recovery plan, it can also serve as a component of a
recovery plan.
The CVP has two BiOps which subject operations and water
deliveries to flow requirements for the endangered three-inch
Delta smelt (regulated by USFWS) and endangered and threatened
salmon species (regulated by NMFS) with some water requirements
for each conflicting with the other. In both cases, however,
federal requirements for these fish can divert water that would
have otherwise been destined for communities and farms.\12\ In
late 2019 and early 2020, the Natural Resources Defense
Council\13\ and the State of California\14\ filed separate
lawsuits against the Trump administration's updated CVP BiOps
alleging that the plans violated federal and state ESA laws. In
addition, California Governor Gavin Newsom's administration
unilaterally issued a new state Incidental Take Permit for the
State Water Project, prompting criticism from the Trump
administration and water users.\15\ Since the CVP and SWP are
intended to be managed in a coordinated manner, these actions
created conflict and uncertainty.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\USBR, Record of Decision for Central Valley Project Operations,
https://www.usbr.gov/mp/bdo/rodcvp.html.
\13\Press Release: NRDC's 100th Suit Against the Trump
Administration Seeks to Protect California Salmon and Endangered
Species, December 3, 2019. https://www.nrdc.org/press-releases/nrdcs-
100th-suit-against-trump-administration-seeks-protect-california-
salmon-and.
\14\Press Release: Attorney General Becerra Files Lawsuit Against
Trump Administration for Failing to Protect Endangered Species in the
Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers, February 20, 2020. https://
oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-becerra-files-lawsuit-
against-trump-administration-failing.
\15\Press Release: Governor Newsom Continues to Recklessly
Jeopardize the Water Supply and Security of Millions of Californians,
May 6, 2020. https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/governor-newsom-
continues-recklessly-jeopardize-water-supply-and-security-millions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When President Joe Biden took office, his administration
initiated a review of both the USFWS and NMFS biological
opinions.\16\ On September 30, 2021, Reclamation restarted the
ESA consultation process for operations of these projects.\17\
Shortly after, in a litigation joint status report to the
courts, the Biden administration and California submitted for
the court's approval an interim operations plan (IOP) for the
2021 2022 water year, while reinitiated consultation continued
at the federal level.\18\ Under the IOP, the Biden
administration would complete a new set of biological opinions
to oversee the CVP. The IOP included changes to Shasta
Reservoir operations to provide temperature control downstream
of the reservoir, new spring outflow requirements, and changes
to CVP water exports.\19\ This filing raised concerns with
several parties who noted that they had requested, but not
received, modeling and other technical information underlying
the IOP.\20\ On October 20, 2021, a federal district court
granted the request to implement the IOP and stay the
litigation.\21\ Beyond the litigation parties, many
agricultural groups\22\ and elected officials\23\ have publicly
expressed concerns with the IOP.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Press Release: California Republican Delegation Urges Biden
Administration to Ensure Continued California Water Supply, February
21, 2021. https://valadao.house.gov/news/
documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=69.
\17\USBR, Letter to USFWS and NMFS re-initiating Section 7
Consultation under ESA, September 30, 2021. https://www.usbr.gov/mp/
bdo/lto/ltr-reinitiation-2021-09-30.pdf.
\18\October 14, 2021, Joint Status Report, Pac. Coast Fed'n of
Fishermen's Ass'n v. Raimondo, No. 1:20-cv-00431, at 1-2 (E.D. Cal.
Oct. 14, 2021).
\19\Id.
\20\October 14, 2021, Joint Status Report, Pac. Coast Fed'n of
Fishermen's Ass'n v. Raimondo, No. 1:20-cv-00431, at 4, 6-7, 16 (E.D.
Cal. Oct. 14, 2021).
\21\Order Regarding Further Scheduling and Status of Pending
Motions, Pac. Coast Fed'n of Fishermen's Ass'n v. Raimondo, No. 1:20-
cv-00431, at 3-5 (E.D. Cal. Oct. 20, 2021).
\22\Letter from Ag Groups to Federal agencies on IOP, October 26,
2021. https://files.constantcontact.com/35cbbf3f001/7d834721-ecf8-4a47-
9507-efbe012ba97b.pdf.
\23\Press Release: California Republican Delegation Expresses Grave
Concern over Proposed Interim Operations Plan for the CVP and SWP,
October 21, 2021. https://valadao.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
2021.10.28_hearing_request.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 215 extends West-wide water storage provisions such as
Section 4007 of the Water Infrastructure Improvements for the
Nation (WIIN) Act (Subtitle J of Public Law 114-322) through
December 31, 2028. The WIIN provision allows a non-governmental
entity to request and be the non-federal partner for federally
owned surface storage projects.
In addition, the bill would require California's CVP and
SWP to be operated consistent with the 2019 BiOps and Preferred
Alternative, which were based on robust modern science and
rigorous scientific input and review during the Trump
administration.\24\ The bill would allow for modification of
CVP and SWP operations based on any agreement that is reached
on a voluntary basis with CVP and SWP water contractors. It
would also prohibit any water supply costs from being imposed
on any entity due to agreements with other parties unless
voluntarily agreed to.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\USBR, Record of Decision for Central Valley Project Operations,
https://www.usbr.gov/mp/bdo/rodcvp.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill would also require the federal government to
provide the maximum amount of water practicable to CVP and SWP
water contractors consistent with the 2019 BiOps. The bill
includes safeguards for SWP water contractors. Specifically, if
California reduces water supplies to SWP water contractors as a
result of actions directed by H.R. 215, then any increase of
water supplies received by CVP water contractors must be
divided between the two projects.
Lastly, it would direct the Secretary of the Interior to
complete the fish, wildlife, and habitat restoration programs
required under the Central Valley Project Improvement Act
(CVPIA or P.L. 102-575) within 2 years of enactment of this
Act.
The bill, as amended, includes language from Congressman
Tom McClintock's Water Supply Permitting Coordination Act. The
legislation was originally introduced in 2014 after a year of
listening and working with stakeholders frustrated with the
cost-prohibitive and time-consuming duplication of regulations
and requirements by overlapping federal agencies when trying to
construct new water storage.
Water districts must navigate a convoluted permitting
process for the construction of new storage in which a host of
federal agencies require an array of permits, decisions, and
approvals--each disjointed from the other--despite the fact
that they are studying the same project, in the same location,
and trying to evaluate the same data.
The legislation creates a ``one-stop-shop'' permitting
process through the Bureau of Reclamation to streamline the
current multi-agency permitting processes for new or expanded
nonfederal surface storage facilities. The language included
has twice received bipartisan support at the Committee on
Natural Resources, and when it passed on the House floor in
2017.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\https://clerk.house.gov/Votes/2017319.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Action
H.R. 215 was introduced on January 9, 2023, by Rep. David
G. Valadao (R-CA). The bill was referred to the Committee on
Natural Resources, and within the Committee to the Subcommittee
on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries. On April 11, 2023, the
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife, and Fisheries held a hearing
on the bill. On April 27-28, 2023, the Committee on Natural
Resources met to consider the bill. The Subcommittee on Water,
Wildlife and Fisheries was discharged by unanimous consent.
Rep. Tom McClintock (R-CA) offered an amendment in the nature
of a substitute to H.R. 215, designated McClintock_008. Rep.
Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered an amendment to the amendment in
the nature of a substitute to H.R. 215, designated Huffman #1.
The amendment offered by Rep. Huffman was not adopted by a roll
call vote of 17 yeas to 22 nays, as follows:
The amendment in the nature of a substitute offered by Rep.
McClintock was adopted by voice vote. The bill, as amended, was
then ordered favorably reported to the House of Representatives
by a roll call vote of 22 yeas to 17 nays, as follows:
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries
held on April 11, 2023.
Section-by-Section Analysis
TITLE I--CVP AND SWP OPERATIONS
Section 101. Operation of the CVP and SWP
Would require the CVP and SWP to be operated consistent
with the 2019 project operations plan and the 2019 USFWS and
NMFS biological opinions. These documents are based on the best
available science and latest data and are designed to improve
water supply reliability for project water contractors through
real-time management in the Delta and its tributaries of the
projects in order to protect listed fish species.
Section 102. Operations and reviews
This section is based on enacted language from the
California water provisions of the WIIN Act. It ensures a
balanced approached to protecting the environment and listed
fish species, while ensuring CVP and SWP water contractors get
the water they contract and pay for.
Section 103. Application of state laws
This section is based, in part, on enacted language from
the California water provisions of the WIIN Act. It protects
SWP water contractors from retaliatory actions taken by
California.
Section 104. Reconsultation of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration Biological Opinion and USFWS Biological Opinion
This section would ensure that initiation of reconsultation
of the Coordinated Long-Term Operation of the CVP and SWP can
occur prior to expiration of the bill or in advance of any
agreements entered into on a voluntary basis with the CVP and
SWP contractors if certain conditions are met.
Section 105. Sunset
Sunsets sections 101-104 seven years after enactment of the
bill.
Section 106. Consultation on coordinated operations
Section 4004 of the WIIN Act directs federal agencies to
cooperate with state and local public water agencies in
developing certain components of any associated USFWS and NMFS
BiOps when conducting reconsultation on the Coordinated Long-
Term Operation of the CVP and SWP. This section would expand
that provision to direct the Bureau of Reclamation to cooperate
with these same entities when developing a Proposed Action for
the operation of both projects.
TITLE II--ALLOCATIONS FOR SACRAMENTO VALLEY CONTRACTORS
Section 201. Definitions
Defines key terms used throughout the Title.
Section 202. Allocations of water
This section would require that CVP agricultural water be
made available consistent with certain water year conditions.
Section 203. Protection of refuge, municipal and industrial, and other
contractors
This section lists a number of water supply protections for
non-agricultural water contractors.
Section 204. Other contractors
This section lists a number of water supply protections for
other water contractors such as the Sacramento River
settlement, San Joaquin River exchange, and refuge contractors.
TITLE III--INFRASTRUCTURE
Section 301. Shasta Reservoir Enlargement project
This section would amend the Infrastructure Investment and
Jobs Act (IIJA, P.L. 117 58) to make the Shasta Dam Raise
Project eligible to receive water storage project funding in
that law. IIJA included $1.15 billion for storage projects but
made it ineligible for such funding.
Section 302. Water supply plan; projects
This section would require the Reclamation Commissioner to
develop a report on water supply shortages in California,
including federal and/or California laws or regulations that
are causing or contributing to the supply shortage, and develop
a list of projects or actions to reduce or eliminate the water
supply shortage.
Section 303. Conservation fish hatcheries
This section would require the Secretaries of the Interior
and of Commerce to report semi-annually to Congress on
implementing conservation fish hatchery programs as required by
Section 4010 of the WIIN Act.
The WIIN Act included provisions for USFWS and NMFS to
expand use of their conservation fish hatcheries for Delta
smelt and Chinook salmon. The purpose of these hatcheries is to
increase the population of these protected species in the Delta
to help with their survival and/or recovery.
Section 304. Storage; duration
This section would reauthorize Section 4007 of the WIIN Act
through December 31, 2028. In addition, the bill would allow
non-governmental entities to request and to be the non-federal
partner for a federally owned surface storage projects
authorized under Section 4007.
Section 305. Shasta Dam enlargement
This section would allow for previously appropriated
funding for the Shasta Dam Enlargement Project, as authorized
by Section 4007 of the WIIN Act and requested by the Secretary
of the Interior in letters from 2019 and 2020 to Congress. It
would also prohibit California from taking any action to
prevent a local public water agency from being the non-federal
partner for a Section 4007-authozied project.
TITLE IV--CVPIA ACTIONS
Section 401. CVPIA restoration actions
This section would direct the Secretary of the Interior
within 2 years of enactment of this Act to complete the fish,
wildlife, and habitat restoration programs required under the
CVPIA. It would also require the Secretary to deem these
actions ``complete'' under the CVPIA by December 30, 2025.
TITLE V--WATER SUPPLY PERMITTING COORDINATION ACT
Section 501. Short title
Provides the short title of the bill to be the ``Water
Supply Permitting Coordination Act''.
Section 502. Definitions
Defines key terms used throughout the Title. As amended,
qualifying projects include all new or expanded surface water
storage projects, unless the project applicant elects not to
participate in the process authorized under this Act.
Section 503. Establishment of lead agency and cooperating agencies
Establishes Reclamation as the lead agency and sets forth
the process by which cooperating agencies are identified and
established. This process requires Reclamation to notify all
agencies with permitting responsibilities related to proposed
projects that those projects have been received and gives
agencies who are improperly identified an opportunity to opt
out of the process if they will not be performing any review
outside of the coordinated process. Section 503 also provides
states with discretion to participate as cooperating agencies
and to involve their state agencies in coordination with the
other cooperating agencies.
Section 504. Bureau responsibilities
Sets forth the responsibilities of Reclamation as the lead
agency, including serving as the point of contact for
applicants, state agencies, Indian tribes, and others regarding
proposed qualifying projects. Reclamation must also coordinate
the preparation of the unified environmental review document
that serves as the basis for all federal decisions necessary to
authorize the use of federal lands for new surface water
storage construction. To begin the process, Section 504
requires Reclamation to notify cooperating agencies of proposed
projects within 30 days and establishes a process by which
Reclamation explains the process and the proposed project,
establishes a schedule for the project and consults with
cooperating agencies. Section 504 also requires that
Reclamation prepare a unified environmental review document for
each qualifying project, incorporating a single environmental
record on which all cooperating agencies shall base project
approval decisions, and to maintain a consolidated
administrative record of the information assembled. Finally,
Section 504 requires that all project data, to the extent
practicable and consistent with existing law, be submitted to
Reclamation as the lead agency and made available online to the
public.
Section 505. Cooperating agency responsibilities
Establishes the Cooperating Agency responsibilities,
including adhering to the coordinated schedule set by
Reclamation, cooperating with compilation of the environmental
record and adhering to it for all decisions, and submitting all
relevant data to Reclamation in a generally accessible format.
Section 506. Funding to process permits
Establishes the process for third party financial
contributions to the ``one-stop-shop'' review process and
requires that the Secretary of the Interior shall remain
impartial in all decision making with respect to permits both
substantively and procedurally.
Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
Compliance With House Rule XIII and
Congressional Budget Act
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) and (3) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and
sections 308(a) and 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, the Committee has received the following estimate for the
bill from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
The bill would
Advance the construction of the Shasta Dam
and Reservoir Enlargement Project
Require the Bureau of Reclamation to
streamline the permitting process for water storage
projects
Require federal agencies to report on water
shortages and on endangered fish species in California
Impose intergovernmental mandates on the
state of California and preempt certain state laws
Estimated budgetary effects would mainly stem from
Spending of appropriations that were
previously provided to advance construction under the
bill
Areas of significant uncertainty include
Predicting whether the project would be
completed under the bill
Bill summary: H.R. 215 would direct the Bureau of
Reclamation (BOR) to use appropriations that were previously
provided to complete the Shasta Dam and Reservoir Enlargement
Project. The bill also would eliminate several impediments to
that project's completion that exist under current law by:
Authorizing BOR to enter into partnerships
with private-sector entities to pay 50percent of the
project's costs (under current law, such partnerships
are restricted to public-sector entities);
Reauthorizing until December 31, 2028, the
water storage program under the Water Infrastructure
Improvements for the Nation Act, which expired in 2021;
and
Asserting that state laws cannot prohibit
public agencies' assistance with the Shasta project.
H.R. 215 also would require the operations of California's
Central Valley Project and State Water Project to be conducted
in accordance with an alternative plan to maximize water
supplies for agricultural, municipal, and industrial
contractors and to account for the biological opinions of the
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS).\1\ (Biological opinions
consider whether a federal action is likely to jeopardize the
existence of an endangered species or result in damage to
critical habitat.) The alternative plan is defined in the
environmental impact statement for the long-term operation of
the two projects, issued by BOR in December 2019. The agencies
and the state also would be required to prepare joint reports
projecting water shortages in California.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\The Central Valley Project is owned by BOR and the State Water
Project is owned by the state of California. Those water storage and
delivery systems operate jointly to supply water to customers in
California.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, H.R. 215 would require BOR to streamline the
permitting process and would allow BOR to accept and spend
contributions from nonfederal sponsors to accelerate permit
approvals for water storage projects in 17 western states.
Estimated Federal cost: The estimated budgetary effect of
H.R. 215 is shown in Table 1. The costs of the legislation fall
within budget function 300 (natural resources and environment).
Basis of estimate: For this estimate, CBO assumes that H.R.
215 will be enacted early in calendar year 2024, that the
estimated amounts will be appropriated in each year, and that
outlays will follow historical spending patterns.
TABLE 1.--ESTIMATED BUDGETARY EFFECTS OF H.R. 215
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By fiscal year, millions of dollars--
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2024-2028 2024-2033
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
INCREASES OR DECREASES (-) IN DIRECT SPENDING
Budget Authoritya.................................... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 n.e. 0 0
Estimated Outlays.................................... 5 12 18 -3 10 35 42 48 25 8 n.e. 42 200
INCREASES IN SPENDING SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATION
Estimated Authorization.............................. 3 2 2 2 22 67 67 72 38 8 n.e. 31 283
Estimated Outlays.................................... 3 2 2 2 9 31 50 67 59 39 n.e. 18 264
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimates are relative to the May 2023 baseline; effects for 2034 were not estimated; n.e. = not estimated.
H.R. 215 would authorize the Bureau of Reclamation to collect and spend funds from nonfederal entities. CBO estimates that any amounts collected would
be spent soon thereafter; thus, the net effect on direct spending would be negligible.
a Enacting the bill would not affect budget authority because the funds that would be used were provided in previous appropriations for water storage
projects.
Background: The Shasta Dam located on the Sacramento River
in Northern California is 602 feet high, and its reservoir can
hold 4.55 million acre-feet of water. In 2015, BOR published a
feasibility report for a plan that would increase the height of
the dam by 18.5 feet, thereby increasing the amount of water
that could be stored in the reservoir. BOR estimated that the
project would cost $1.3 billion.
In 2018, lawmakers authorized BOR to complete the
construction plan in cooperation with a nonfederal sponsor.
However, BOR halted the project in 2019, during
preconstruction, because the agency's nonfederal sponsor, the
Westlands Water District, stopped participating in the project
after the California Supreme Court ruled that enlarging the dam
would violate the state's environmental laws.
Direct spending: CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 215 would
increase direct spending by $200 million over the 2024-2033
period.
Spending of Previously Appropriated Amounts. The bill would
direct BOR to complete the Shasta Dam project using annual
appropriations provided over the 2017-2021 period for water
storage activities and appropriations provided in the
Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) for the 2022-2026
period.
CBO estimates that the cost to complete the project would
be about $2.2 billion. That amount results from adjusting BOR's
initial estimate of $1.3 billion to account for actual and
anticipated inflation. The federal government would be
responsible for half of that cost ($1.1 billion) and, both
under current law and under the bill, a nonfederal sponsor
would need to agree to pay the remaining $1.1 billion up front.
Using information from BOR, CBO expects that $170 million
of the federal share of the project's costs would come from
amounts previously provided in annual appropriation acts for
the water storage program and that $400 million would come from
funds provided in IIJA. The rest of the federal share would
come from future appropriations (see ``Spending Subject to
Appropriation'' below). The costs stemming from previously
appropriated funds are treated as direct spending.
Funds From Annual Appropriation Acts. Under the bill, CBO
estimates that spending of amounts from annual appropriation
acts would increase outlays through 2026 and would then
decrease outlays by an equal amount from 2027 through 2031. CBO
expects that spending would net to zero over the 2024-2033
period because we project that all of those funds would be
spent under current law before 2033.
Funds From IIJA. Under H.R. 215, CBO estimates that amounts
allocated to the Shasta project from IIJA appropriations would
increase spending by $200 million over the 2024-2033 period.
The Congress provided $1.2 billion for water storage projects
in IIJA; CBO projects that $800 million of that amount will be
spent by the end of 2033; some will be spent after 2033 and
some will not be spent. Therefore, CBO estimates that using
IIJA funds to construct the Shasta project would increase
outlays of those funds by $400 million over the 2024-2033
period. That $400 million would be partially offset by
decreased outlays in years after 2033.
The project could not proceed at all, however, unless BOR
finds a nonfederal sponsor willing to pay at least half of the
total cost. CBO has no basis for estimating the likelihood that
BOR will find such a partner. Because of that uncertainty, CBO
has used a 50 percent probability that the Shasta project will
be completed under the bill. Accordingly, CBO estimates that
enacting H.R. 215 would increase direct spending by $200
million over the 2024-2033 period.
CBO estimates that the interaction between the decreased
spending that would begin in 2027 from funds previously
provided in annual appropriation acts and the acceleration of
spending from IIJA funds would result in savings of $3 million
in 2027.
Spending subject to appropriation: Using information from
BOR, and assuming appropriation of the estimated amounts, CBO
estimates that implementing H.R. 215 to complete the Shasta
project and cover administrative costs would require
appropriations totaling $283 million over the 2024-2033 period
(see Table 2). Based on historical spending patterns,
appropriating that much would increase outlays by $264 million
over the same period.
TABLE 2.--ESTIMATED INCREASES IN SPENDING SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATION UNDER H.R. 215
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By fiscal year, millions of dollars--
Dissenting Views
H.R. 215 would reduce the Bureau of Reclamation's ability
to operate California's Central Valley Project for the benefit
of multiple parties and interests by mandating the Central
Valley Project (CVP) and State Water Project (SWP) be operated
under the 2019 U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service (FWS) and National
Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) Biological Opinions and
Preferred Alternative.
The Central Valley Project is the largest federal water
project in the United States, serving over 25 million
Californians and 19 wildlife refuges and providing 75% of its
allocations to agricultural irrigation in California's Central
Valley. The CVP was designed to reduce flooding, produce
hydropower, store water, and provide water to California's
Central Valley for agricultural development. CVP extends 400
miles through California and includes a network of dams,
reservoirs, powerplants, canals and related facilities for the
operation of the project. As the majority of CVP facilities
were designed and constructed prior the enactment of the
Endangered Species Act (ESA) and National Environmental Policy
Act (NEPA), the construction and operation of the CVP has
severely altered California's rivers and environment across the
state.
Under the Trump administration, federal agencies reduced
environmental use allocations to preserve endangered fish and
wildlife by replacing existing biological opinions prepared
under the ESA with the 2019 FWS and NMFS Biological Opinions
and Preferred Alternative to increase deliveries to CVP. The
2019 FWS and NMFS Biological Opinions failed to consider if
actions would jeopardize the existence of endangered or
threatened species and/or result in the destruction or adverse
modification of its critical habitat and eliminated
longstanding measures to protect species, including
requirements to maintain adequate cold water supplies to
preserve the health and reproduction of threatened and
endangered salmon. These actions stopped the evaluation and
reintroduction of winter-run Chinook Salmon above Shasta Dam,
altered California Bay-Delta water pumping and outflow
requirements, reduced instream flows, and eliminated
requirements to manage water temperatures to protect steelhead
and other listed species.
In 2021, the Biden administration reinitiated consultation
under the Endangered Species Act to replace the 2019 FWS and
NMFS Biological Opinions with new BiOps based on the best
available science, as required under the ESA. H.R. 215 would
significantly limit opportunities for any future consultation,
advance controversial dam projects, reduce the allocation for
environmental uses and redirect such water toward agricultural
users, and prevent the Bureau of Reclamation from considering
the best and most recent science in water management decisions
by mandating operations under the 2019 FWS and NMFS Biological
Opinions and Preferred Alternative.
In addition to restricting ongoing consultations on long-
term projects operations, H.R. 215 would create inconsistencies
between federal and state regulatory documents, reduce
collaborative approaches for advancing CVP-SWP operations,
prevent the Bureau of Reclamation from using the best and most
up-to-date scientific data available, and mandate water
allocation increases to Sacramento River Watershed contractors,
effectively restricting Reclamation's ability to appropriately
allocate water based on the conditions of the CVP.
Furthermore, this bill would specifically authorize federal
support for the proposed raising of Shasta Dam and construction
of Temperance Flat Dam and eliminate existing funding
prohibitions for both projects in the Infrastructure Investment
and Jobs Act. Additionally, the legislation would deem the
Central Valley Project Improvement Act (CVPIA) complete within
two years of enactment, despite failure to meet completion
goals, ultimately reducing money paid by CVP contractors to the
CVPIA restoration fund used to support wildlife refuges and
fish and wildlife adversely impacted by the CVP.
As climate change intensifies drought conditions, we must
find bipartisan solutions that provide real drought relief
rather than policies aimed at meeting the interests of the
agricultural industry at the expense of the environment.
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member.
[all]