Additional Views
[To accompany H.R. 2989]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 2989) to improve the health and resiliency of
giant sequoias, and for other purposes, having considered the
same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Save Our Sequoias
Act''.
(b) Table of Contents.--
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Definitions.
Sec. 3. Shared stewardship agreement for giant sequoias.
Sec. 4. Giant sequoia lands coalition.
Sec. 5. Giant sequoia health and resiliency assessment.
Sec. 6. Giant sequoia emergency response.
Sec. 7. Giant sequoia reforestation and rehabilitation strategy.
Sec. 8. Giant sequoia strike teams.
Sec. 9. Giant sequoia collaborative restoration grants.
Sec. 10. Good neighbor authority for giant sequoias.
Sec. 11. Stewardship contracting for giant sequoias.
Sec. 12. Giant Sequoia Emergency Protection Program and Fund.
Sec. 13. Authorization of appropriations.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) Assessment.--The term ``Assessment'' means the Giant
Sequoia Health and Resiliency Assessment required by section 5.
(2) Coalition.--The term ``Coalition'' means the Giant
Sequoia Lands Coalition codified under section 4(a).
(3) Collaborative process.--The term ``collaborative
process'' means a process relating to the management of covered
National Forest system lands or covered public lands by which a
project or forest management activity is developed and
implemented by the Secretary concerned through collaboration
with multiple interested persons representing diverse
interests.
(4) Covered national forest system lands.--The term ``covered
National Forest System lands'' means the proclaimed National
Forest System lands reserved or withdrawn from the public
domain of the United States covering the Sequoia National
Forest and Giant Sequoia National Monument, Sierra National
Forest, and Tahoe National Forest.
(5) Covered public lands.--The term ``covered public lands''
means--
(A) the Case Mountain Extensive Recreation Management
Area in California managed by the Bureau of Land
Management; and
(B) Kings Canyon National Park, Sequoia National
Park, and Yosemite National Park in California managed
by the National Park Service.
(6) Giant sequoia.--The term ``giant sequoia'' means a tree
of the species Sequoiadendron giganteum.
(7) Grove-specific hazardous fuels reduction plan.--The term
``grove-specific hazardous fuels reduction plan'' means a plan
developed by the applicable land management agency prior to
conducting an analysis under the National Environmental Policy
Act (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.) to address hazardous fuels in 1 or
more giant sequoia groves.
(8) Protection project.--The term ``Protection Project''
means a Giant Sequoia Protection Project carried out under
section 6.
(9) Reforestation.--The term ``reforestation'' means the act
of renewing tree cover, taking into consideration species
composition and resilience, by establishing young trees through
natural regeneration, artificial or natural regeneration with
site preparation, planting or direct seeding, or vegetation
competition control following artificial or natural
regeneration.
(10) Rehabilitation.--The term ``rehabilitation'' means any
action taken during the 5-year period beginning on the last day
of a wildland fire to repair or improve fire-impacted lands
which are unlikely to recover to management-approved
conditions.
(11) Relevant congressional committees.--The term ``relevant
Congressional Committees'' means--
(A) the Committees on Natural Resources, Agriculture,
and Appropriations of the House of Representatives; and
(B) the Committees on Energy and Natural Resources,
Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry, and
Appropriations of the Senate.
(12) Responsible official.--The term ``responsible official''
means an employee of the Department of the Interior or Forest
Service who has the authority to make and implement a decision
on a proposed action.
(13) Secretary.--The term ``Secretary'' means the Secretary
of the Interior.
(14) Secretary concerned.--The term ``Secretary concerned''
means--
(A) the Secretary of Agriculture, with respect to
covered National Forest System lands, or their
designee; and
(B) the Secretary of the Interior, with respect to
covered public lands, or their designee.
(15) Strategy.--The term ``Strategy'' means the Giant Sequoia
Reforestation and Rehabilitation Strategy established under
section 7.
(16) Strike team.--The term ``Strike Team'' means a Giant
Sequoia Strike Team established under section 8.
(17) Tribe.--The term ``Tribe'' means the Tule River Indian
Tribe of the Tule River Reservation, California.
SEC. 3. SHARED STEWARDSHIP AGREEMENT FOR GIANT SEQUOIAS.
(a) In General.--Not later than 90 days after receiving a request
from the Governor of the State of California or the Tribe, the
Secretary shall enter into or expand an existing shared stewardship
agreement or enter into a similar agreement with the Secretary of
Agriculture, the Governor of the State of California, and the Tribe to
jointly carry out the short-term and long-term management and
conservation of giant sequoias.
(b) Participation.--
(1) In general.--If the Secretary has not received a request
from the Governor of the State of California or the Tribe under
subsection (a) before the date that is 90 days after the date
of enactment of this Act, the Secretary shall enter into the
agreement under subsection (a) and jointly implement such
agreement with the Secretary of Agriculture.
(2) Future participation.--If the Secretary receives a
request from the Governor of the State of California or the
Tribe any time after entering into the agreement with the
Secretary of Agriculture under paragraph (1), the Secretary
shall accept the Governor of the State of California or the
Tribe as a party to such agreement.
SEC. 4. GIANT SEQUOIA LANDS COALITION.
(a) Codification.--The Coalition is the entity established under the
charter titled ``Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition Charter'' (or successor
charter) signed during the period beginning June 2, 2022 and ending
August 2, 2022 by each of the following:
(1) The National Park Service, representing Sequoia and Kings
Canyon National Parks.
(2) The National Park Service, representing Yosemite National
Park.
(3) The Forest Service, representing Sequoia National Forest
and Giant Sequoia National Monument.
(4) The Forest Service, representing Sierra National Forest.
(5) The Forest Service, representing Tahoe National Forest.
(6) The Bureau of Land Management, representing Case Mountain
Extensive Recreation Management Area.
(7) The Tribe, representing the Tule River Indian
Reservation.
(8) The State of California, representing Calaveras Big Trees
State Park.
(9) The State of California, representing Mountain Home
Demonstration State Forest.
(10) The University of California, Berkeley, representing
Whitaker's Research Forest.
(11) The County of Tulare, California, representing Balch
Park.
(b) Duties.--In addition to the duties specified in the charter
referenced in subsection (a), the Coalition shall--
(1) produce the Assessment under section 5;
(2) observe implementation, and provide policy
recommendations to the Secretary concerned, with respect to--
(A) Protection Projects carried out under section 6;
and
(B) the Strategy established under section 7;
(3) facilitate collaboration and coordination on Protection
Projects, particularly projects that cross jurisdictional
boundaries;
(4) facilitate information sharing, including best available
science as described in section 5(c) and mapping resources; and
(5) support the development and dissemination of educational
materials and programs that inform the public about the threats
to the health and resiliency of giant sequoia groves and
actions being taken to reduce the risk to such groves from
high-severity wildfire, insects, and drought.
(c) Administrative Support, Technical Services, and Staff Support.--
The Secretary shall make personnel of the Department of the Interior
available to the Coalition for administrative support, technical
services, development and dissemination of educational materials, and
staff support that the Secretary determines necessary to carry out this
section.
SEC. 5. GIANT SEQUOIA HEALTH AND RESILIENCY ASSESSMENT.
(a) In General.--Not later than 6 months after the date of the
enactment of this Act, the Coalition shall submit to the relevant
Congressional Committees a Giant Sequoia Health and Resiliency
Assessment that, based on the best available science--
(1) identifies--
(A) each giant sequoia grove that has experienced a--
(i) stand-replacing disturbance; or
(ii) disturbance but continues to have living
giant sequoias within the grove, including
identifying the tree mortality and regeneration
of giant sequoias within such grove;
(B) each giant sequoia grove that is at high risk of
experiencing a stand-replacing disturbance;
(C) lands located near giant sequoia groves that are
at risk of experiencing high-severity wildfires that
could adversely impact such giant sequoia groves; and
(D) each giant sequoia grove that has experienced a
disturbance and is unlikely to naturally regenerate and
is in need of reforestation;
(2) analyzes the resiliency of each giant sequoia grove to
threats, such as--
(A) high-severity wildfire;
(B) insects, including beetle kill; and
(C) drought;
(3) with respect to Protection Projects, proposes a list of
highest priority Protection Projects to be carried out under
section 6, giving priority to projects located on lands
identified under subparagraphs (B) and (C) of subsection
(a)(1);
(4) examines how historical, Tribal, or current approaches to
wildland fire suppression and forest management activities
across various jurisdictions have impacted the health and
resiliency of giant sequoia groves with respect to--
(A) high-severity wildfires;
(B) insects, including beetle kill; and
(C) drought; and
(5) includes program and policy recommendations that
address--
(A) Federal and State policies that impede activities
to improve the health and resiliency of giant sequoias
and proposed policy changes to address such
impediments;
(B) new Federal and State policies necessary to
increase the pace and scale of treatments that improve
the health and resiliency of giant sequoias;
(C) options to enhance communication, coordination,
and collaboration, particularly for cross-boundary
projects, to improve the health and resiliency of giant
sequoias; and
(D) research gaps that should be addressed to improve
the best available science on the giant sequoias.
(b) Annual Updates.--Not later than 1 year after the submission of
the Assessment under subsection (a), and annually thereafter, the
Coalition shall submit an updated Assessment to the relevant
Congressional Committees that--
(1) includes any new data, information, or best available
science that has changed or become available since the previous
Assessment was submitted;
(2) with respect to Protection Projects--
(A) includes information on the number of Protection
Projects initiated the previous year and the estimated
timeline for completing those projects;
(B) includes information on the number of Protection
Projects planned in the upcoming year and the estimated
timeline for completing those projects;
(C) provides status updates and long-term monitoring
reports on giant sequoia groves after the completion of
Protection Projects;
(D) if the Secretary concerned failed to reduce
hazardous fuels in at least 3 giant sequoia groves in
the previous year, a written explanation that
includes--
(i) a detailed explanation of what
impediments resulted in failing to reduce
hazardous fuels in at least 3 giant sequoia
groves;
(ii) a detailed explanation of what actions
the Secretary concerned is taking to ensure
that hazardous fuels are reduced in at least 3
giant sequoia groves the following year; and
(iii) recommendations to Congress on any
policies that need to be changed to assist the
Secretary concerned in reducing hazardous fuels
in giant sequoia groves; and
(3) with respect to reforestation and rehabilitation of giant
sequoias--
(A) contains updates on the implementation of the
Strategy under section 7, including grove-level data on
reforestation and rehabilitation activities; and
(B) provides status updates and monitoring reports on
giant sequoia groves that have experienced natural or
artificial regeneration as part of the Strategy under
section 7.
(c) Dashboard.--
(1) Requirement to maintain.--The Coalition shall create and
maintain a website that--
(A) publishes the Assessment, annual updates to the
Assessment, and other educational materials developed
by the Coalition;
(B) contains searchable information about individual
giant sequoia groves, including the--
(i) resiliency of such groves to threats
described in paragraphs (1) and (2) of
subsection (a);
(ii) Protection Projects that have been
proposed, initiated, or completed in such
groves; and
(iii) reforestation and rehabilitation
activities that have been proposed, initiated,
or completed in such groves; and
(C) maintains a searchable database to track--
(i) the status of Federal environmental
reviews and authorizations for specific
Protection Projects and reforestation and
rehabilitation activities; and
(ii) the projected cost of Protection
Projects and reforestation and rehabilitation
activities.
(2) Searchable database.--The Coalition shall include
information on the status of Protection Projects in the
searchable database created under paragraph (1)(C), including--
(A) a comprehensive permitting timetable;
(B) the status of the compliance of each lead agency,
cooperating agency, and participating agency with the
permitting timetable;
(C) any modifications of the permitting timetable
required under subparagraph (A), including an
explanation as to why the permitting timetable was
modified; and
(D) information about project-related public
meetings, public hearings, and public comment periods,
which shall be presented in English and the predominant
language of the community or communities most affected
by the project, as that information becomes available.
(d) Best Available Science.--In utilizing the best available science
for the Assessment, the Coalition shall include--
(1) data and peer-reviewed research from academic
institutions with a demonstrated history of studying giant
sequoias and with experience analyzing distinct management
strategies to improve giant sequoia resiliency;
(2) traditional ecological knowledge from the Tribe related
to improving the health and resiliency of giant sequoia groves;
and
(3) data from Federal, State, Tribal, and local governments
or agencies.
(e) Technology Improvements.--In carrying out this section, the
Secretary may enter into memorandums of understanding or agreements
with other Federal agencies or departments, State or local governments,
Tribal governments, private entities, or academic institutions to
improve, with respect to the Assessment, the use and integration of--
(1) advanced remote sensing and geospatial technologies;
(2) statistical modeling and analysis; or
(3) any other technology the Secretary determines will
benefit the quality of information used in the Assessment.
(f) Planning.--The Coalition shall make information from this
Assessment available to the Secretary concerned and State of California
to integrate into the--
(1) State of California's Wildfire and Forest Resilience
Action Plan;
(2) Forest Service's 10-year Wildfire Crisis Strategy (or
successor plan); and
(3) Department of the Interior's Wildfire Risk Five-Year
Monitoring, Maintenance, and Treatment Plan (or successor
plan).
(g) Relation to the
Background and Need for Legislation
Overview of Giant Sequoias
Sequoiadendron giganteum (Giant Sequoias) are the largest
trees on Earth and are solely found in roughly 70 distinct
groves across approximately 37,000 acres in the Sierra Nevada
Mountain range in central California.\1\ Giant Sequoias are
world-renowned for their majestic size and ancient lifespan.
For example, the largest Giant Sequoia ever measured was over
36 feet in diameter and 311 feet tall.\2\ For comparison, the
Capitol Dome, including the Statue of Freedom, rises 288 feet
above East Front Plaza.\3\ The world's current largest tree by
volume is the iconic General Sherman Tree in Sequoia and Kings
Canyon National Parks, which is 275 feet tall, 36 feet in
diameter at the base, and weighs an astonishing 2.7 million
pounds.\4\ An extremely resilient species, Giant Sequoias can
live for thousands of years, and the oldest known Giant Sequoia
was dated at roughly 3,266 years old.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Sillett, et al., ``Structure and dynamics of forests dominated
by Sequoiadendron giganteum,'' Forest Ecology and Management 448, June
15, 2019, pages 218-239.
\2\Shive, et al., ``Ancient trees and modern wildfires: Declining
resilience to wildfire in the highly fire-adapted giant
sequoia,''Forest Ecology and Management 511, February 2022.
\3\Architect of the Capitol, ``Dome By-The-Numbers,'' https://
www.aoc.gov/what-we-do/projects/dome-restoration-project/by-the-
numbers.
\4\National Park Service, ``The General Sherman Tree,'' Sequoia and
Kings Canyon National Parks, December 31, 2021, https://www.nps.gov/
seki/learn/nature/sherman.htm.
\5\Shive, supra note 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Giant Sequoias owe this size and longevity to a set of
unique characteristics that make them highly resilient to fire,
insects, and disease. Giant Sequoias possess a very thick and
spongy bark, which typically ranges from 6 10 inches but can be
up to two feet thick, that provides strong protection against
wildfire and insects.\6\ The immense height of the Giant
Sequoias and their branches also means that, historically,
fires have had difficulty reaching the crown (top) of the tree,
thus reducing overall damage to the tree. Even if fires do
reach the crown, older Giant Sequoias can survive if 5 percent
of their crown remains unburned.\7\ Because of this, when Giant
Sequoias died in the past, it was largely due to falling over
or after experiencing several severe fires over their long
lifespans. According to research from the National Park Service
(NPS), Giant Sequoia deaths due to fire events were
``relatively rare'' and standing death unrelated to fire was
``almost never observed by scientists who had spent decades
working in the Sierra Nevada.''\8\ In fact, prior to 2015, the
last recorded evidence of Giant Sequoia mortality due to
wildfires occurred in the year 1297 A.D.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\National Park Service, ``Description of the Giant Sequoia,''
February 2, 2007, https://www.nps.gov/parkhistory/online_books/cook/
sec1.htm#::text=Padilla%20Photo.-,The%20bark%2
0of%20the%20giant%20sequoia%20is%20one%20of%20its,even%20be%202%20feet%2
0thick.
\7\Boxall, Bettina, ``Hundreds of towering giant sequoias killed by
the Castle fire--a stunning loss,'' LA Times, November 16, 2020,
https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2020-11-16/
sierra-nevada-giant-sequoias-killed-castle-fire.
\8\National Park Service, ``Giant Sequoias Face New Threats,''
February 24, 2022, https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/giant-sequoias-
face-new-threats.htm.
\9\Boxall, supra note 7.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Giant Sequoias are important ecologically, scientifically,
and culturally. Giant Sequoias provide abundant recreation
opportunities and millions of visitors flock to these forests
annually to marvel at these majestic trees. The Giant Sequoia
is an iconic symbol in nature and is featured prominently on
the official logo for NPS.\10\ For thousands of years, these
trees also ``provided healing, shelter, and warmth'' to Native
Americans, including the Tule River Tribe.\11\ Like many other
forests, Giant Sequoia groves also provide clean air and clean
water, store archaeological and historic resources, and serve
as important wildlife habitat. Additionally, Giant Sequoias are
extremely important for carbon storage, as certain Giant
Sequoia forests are second only to coastal redwoods in ``carbon
storage per hectare globally.''\12\ Notably, Giant Sequoias
have ``little monetary value'' for wood products due to their
brittleness and large weight.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\National Park Service, ``History of the NPS Arrowhead,'' May
15, 2019, https://www.nps.gov/glac/learn/news/history-of-the-nps-
arrowhead.htm.
\11\Quote from William Garfield, Chairman of the Tule River Tribal
Council, ``Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition Formed to Protect Iconic Trees
from Threats of Climate Change and Catastrophic Wildfire,'' National
Park Service, July 19, 2021, https://www.nps.gov/seki/learn/news/giant-
sequoia-lands-coalition-formed-to-protect-iconic-trees-from-threats-of-
climate-change-and-catastrophic-wildfire.htm.
\12\Shive, supra note 2.
\13\Save The Redwoods League, ``Giant Sequoia,'' https://
www.savetheredwoods.org/redwoods/giant-sequoias/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Management: History, Jurisdictions, and Current Practices
Federal interest in the protection and management of Giant
Sequoias can be traced back to 1864, in the midst of the Civil
War, when President Abraham Lincoln signed legislation
transferring the Mariposa Grove (now located in Yosemite
National Park) to the State of California ``upon the express
conditions that the premises shall be held for public use,
resort and recreation.''\14\ This is considered the first piece
of legislation setting aside lands for public use and future
enjoyment, preceding the creation of the first national parks.
Nearly three decades later, in 1890, Congress created Sequoia
and Yosemite as the second and third national parks,
respectively, to, in part, protect the Giant Sequoias.\15\ In
1903, Teddy Roosevelt's famous camping trip in the Mariposa
Grove, which he dubbed ``a temple greater than any human
architect could by any possibility build,'' inspired him to
expand protections for Giant Sequoias, eventually leading to
the creation of the Sequoia National Forest in 1908.\16\ Nearly
one century later, in 2000, President Clinton designated
328,315 acres in the Sequoia National Forest as the Giant
Sequoia National Monument.\17\ Along with this designation,
Giant Sequoias are now largely under the most restrictive land
designations, including 808,000 acres of wilderness and 29,500
acres of proposed wilderness in Sequoia and Kings Canyon
National Parks and 314,448 acres of wilderness in the Sequoia
National Forest. As such, with the exception of a fairly robust
prescribed burning program within NPS, many Giant Sequoia
groves are not regularly managed with fuels reduction
treatments such as prescribed burning or mechanical thinning.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Glass, Andrew, ``President Lincoln creates Yosemite Park, June
30, 1864,'' Politico, June 30, 2016, https://www.politico.com/story/
2016/06/president-lincoln-creates-yosemite-park-june-30-186 4-224818.
\15\Id.
\16\National Park Service, ``Roosevelt, Muir, and the Grace of
Place,'' August 26, 2021, https://www.nps.gov/yose/learn/
historyculture/roosevelt-muir-and-the-grace-of-place.htm.
\17\U.S. Forest Service, ``The Giant Sequoia National Monument,''
https://www.fs.usda.gov/
detail/sequoia/home/?cid=stelprdb5394941.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although the geographic distribution of Giant Sequoias is
relatively confined, the groves today cross a multitude of
different jurisdictions. The majority of groves are managed by
the federal government, although the following entities all
have a current ownership interest in at least one Giant Sequoia
grove:
Federal Lands:
U.S. Forest Service (USFS):
Sequoia National Forest (including the Giant
Sequoia National Monument), Sierra National
Forest, and Tahoe National Forest.
NPS: Sequoia and Kings Canyon
National Parks and Yosemite National Park.
Bureau of Land Management (BLM):
Case Mountain Extensive Recreation Management
Area.
State and Local Lands: Several groves are
owned and managed by Tulare County and the State of
California, including the Mountain Home Demonstration
State Forest.
Tribal Lands: The Tule River Tribe of the
Tule River Indian Reservation owns and manages a Giant
Sequoia grove.
Private Lands: Several private groves are
owned by organizations such as UC Berkeley and Save the
Redwoods League.
While each agency manages Giant Sequoias in their
jurisdiction differently, for the most part, fire has largely
been excluded from these landscapes by federal land managers
for well over a century. Due to their long lifespans,
scientists can trace the fire history of Giant Sequoias through
several millennia. For the 1,000-year period dating from 800-
1800, groves experienced an average of 30.6 fires per
century.\18\ This coexistence with low-intensity fire was
extremely important for the health and longevity of Giant
Sequoias, which have semi-serotinous cones, or cones that need
heat to open and begin the process of regeneration.\19\ These
low-severity fire intervals also helped clear undergrowth, thin
out shade-tolerant species, and enable seedlings to take root
and receive the necessary sunlight to fully develop.\20\ In
contrast, from 1898-2014, only approximately 17 percent of
groves experienced wildfire, meaning some went untouched by
fire for more than a century.\21\ This exclusion of fire
created a massive build-up of surface fuels.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Van Pelt, Robert, ``Annual Summary of Permanent Research Plots
in Old-Growth Giant Sequoia Forests as Part of the Redwoods and Climate
Change Initiative (RCCI), 2021, page 35.
\19\Shive, supra note 2.
\20\The Guardian. ``It could be a big tree in 1,000 years': tiny
seedlings of giant sequoias rise from ashes of wildfire'' November 2,
2021. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/nov/02/california-giant-
sequoias-wildfires-climate-change-trees.
\21\Van Pelt, supra note 18.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Compounding excessive fuels build-up is the devastating
drought experienced throughout the West and rising
temperatures. In particular, the drought period from 2012-2016
killed an enormous amount of pines, incense-cedars, and firs
around the Giant Sequoias, creating a significant amount of
ladder fuel that could carry fire into the forest canopy and
affect the Giant Sequoias.\22\ Due to ``very low relative
humidity and higher than average temperatures,'' that fuel also
became exceptionally dry and allowed fires to burn day and
night.\23\ For the first time in recorded history, scientists
also observed mortality in 33 standing Giant Sequoias as a
result of bark beetle infestation, thought to have been the
result of drought-related conditions.\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Id.
\23\National Park Service, ``Giant Sequoias Face New Threats,''
February 24, 2022, https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/giant-sequoias-
face-new-threats.htm.
\24\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Current Wildfire Crisis
The past decade marked a significant turning point in the
health and resiliency of Giant Sequoias. According to NPS:
Prior to 2014, scientists recorded only subtle, long-
term changes in forest health. During and after the
drought, they observed large, abrupt, and novel changes
to forests, including . . . unprecedented numbers of
large sequoias dying in severe wildfires, Giant
Sequoias dying from bark beetle attacks, and acute
foliage dieback as a short-term adaptation to
drought.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Id.
Since 2015, the combination of excessive fuels build-up and
drier conditions caused several wildfires to wreak
unprecedented destruction. As stated above, while only 17
percent of groves burned over the 116-year period ending in
2014, six fires in the past six years have burned over 85
percent of groves.\26\ Unlike low-severity fires of the
previous millennia, these fires had a higher severity and were
incredibly deadly to Giant Sequoias. Studies suggest that
groves that experienced high-severity fires had average
mortality rates of 84 percent, with some groves experiencing
100 percent mortality.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\Id. (The six-year period referred to is 2015-2021).
\27\Shive, supra note 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These high mortality events began with the 2015 Rough Fire,
which burned 151,547 acres of USFS and NPS land and killed over
100 Giant Sequoias.\28\ In 2017, the Pier and Railroad Fires
had a combined total footprint of 48,990 acres and killed 110
Giant Sequoias, including 31 larger than 10 feet in
diameter.\29\ Truly unprecedented levels of devastation began
in 2020 when the Castle Fire (also referred to as the SQF
Complex Fire) burned 170,648 acres, including 9,530 acres of
Giant Sequoia groves across federal, State, local, and private
lands.\30\ The Castle Fire devastated Giant Sequoias at a scale
previously unheard of, killing between 7,500 and 10,600 large
Giant Sequoias, or roughly 31 to 42 percent of the Giant
Sequoias within the Castle Fire's footprint. This also amounts
to 10 to 14 percent of the world's mature Giant Sequoias killed
by a single fire.\31\ While scientists have not yet determined
precise ages, they estimate that Giant Sequoias ``killed by the
Castle Fire may have ages ranging from hundreds to as much as
2,000 to 3,000 years.''\32\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\National Park Service, ``Wildfires Kill Unprecedented Numbers
of Large Sequoia Trees,'' February 25, 2022, https://www.nps.gov/
articles/000/wildfires-kill-unprecedented-numbers-of-large-sequoia-
trees.htm.
\29\Id.
\30\Id.
\31\Id.
\32\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Just one year later, the KNP Complex and Windy Fires
wreaked similar devastation across 185,835 acres, including 27
Giant Sequoia groves. Scientists initially estimated that
``2,261-3,637 sequoias over four feet in diameter [were] killed
or will die within the next three to five years'' due to these
two fires.\33\ Combined with the data from the Castle Fire,
this means that an estimated 13 to 19 percent of the world's
mature Giant Sequoias were killed over the course of two
years.\34\ Concerningly, these are conservative estimates that
could increase. Sadly, five of the 13 largest trees known in
the 21st Century died or were negatively affected during these
fires, including the Boole Tree (6th largest) in 2015, the
Stagg Tree (9th largest) in 2020, the Genesis Tree (10th
largest) in 2020, the Ishi Giant (12th largest) in 2015, and
the King Arthur Tree (13th largest) in 2020.\35\ The deaths of
these trees are particularly significant, as named trees are
often singled out for protection during fire response. It is
also important to note that the often-cited statistic of nearly
one-fifth of the world's Giant Sequoias perishing in two short
years refers to mature (often called ``monarch'') Giant
Sequoias. These fires also destroyed untold numbers of smaller
Giant Sequoias that will no longer be able to grow into
``monarch'' trees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\Shive, et al. ``2021 Fire Season Impacts to Giant Sequoias,''
National Park Service, November 23, 2021, https://www.nps.gov/articles/
000/2021-fire-season-impacts-to-giant-sequoias.htm.
\34\Id.
\35\Van Pelt, supra note 18.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately, these fires burned at such a high severity
that ``only minimal seedling establishment has been observed''
in impacted groves.\36\ This means that fires burned so
intensely, the Giant Sequoia cones incinerated, even those high
up in the canopy typically untouched by fire. After the KNP
Complex Fire, NPS estimated that 436 acres were ``vulnerable to
total sequoia loss'' without some level of replanting.\37\
Similar to mortality estimates, these are conservative
estimates of the true scope of reforestation that will be
required. Importantly, while high-severity fires did cause
significant destruction, some groves that experienced low- to
moderate-severity fires over this period did see benefits from
the re-introduction of fire.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\Shive, supra note 2.
\37\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Need for Urgent Action to Confront the Wildfire Crisis Facing Giant
Sequoias
There is perhaps no greater example of the severity of the
wildfire crisis facing the West than the fact that Giant
Sequoias, which have withstood innumerable fires, droughts, and
other natural disasters for thousands of years, are now
succumbing to fire at such a rapid rate. With an estimated
75,000 trees remaining, the need to move quickly to protect
these iconic trees as part of the broader effort to better
manage our nation's forests cannot be overstated.\38\ Without
decisive action, scientists estimate these trees could be
extinct in the next 25 years.\39\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\38\PBS News, ``Wildfires torched up to a fifth of all giant
sequoia trees,'' November 20, 2021, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/
nation/wildfires-torched-up-to-a-fifth-of-all-giant-sequoia-trees.
\39\Mariposa County Resource Conservation District, ``Last of the
Monarchs,'' https://vimeo.com/685657372/c526d9ece1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately, at its standard pace, it would take USFS
approximately 52 years to treat just their 19 most at-risk
Giant Sequoia groves.\40\ Land managers are now recognizing
this alarming, unprecedented destruction as a call to action to
expedite scientifically-sound forest management practices to
improve the health and resiliency of groves. Dr. Christy
Brigham, Chief of Resources Management & Science a
Committee Action
H.R. 2989 was introduced on April 28, 2023, by Rep. Kevin
McCarthy (R-CA). The bill was referred to the Committee on
Natural Resources, and within the Committee to the Subcommittee
on Federal Lands. The bill was also referred to the Committee
on Agriculture. On May 10, 2023, the Committee on Natural
Resources held a hearing on the bill. On May 17, 2023, the
Committee on Natural Resources met to consider the bill. The
Subcommittee on Federal Lands was discharged by unanimous
consent. Rep. Tom Tiffany (R-WI) offered an amendment in the
nature of a substitute, designated Tiffany_018. Chairman Bruce
Westerman (R-AR) offered an amendment to the amendment in the
nature of a substitute, designated Westerman_023 Revised. The
amendment was adopted by voice vote. Rep. Ed Case (D-HI)
offered an amendment to the amendment in the nature of a
substitute, designated Case #2. The amendment to the amendment
in the nature of a substitute was not adopted by a roll call
vote of 17 yeas to 21 nays, as follows:
Rep. Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered a substitute amendment to
the amendment in the nature of a substitute, designated
Huffman_026. The amendment was withdrawn by unanimous consent.
The amendment in the nature of a substitute offered by Rep.
Tiffany, as amended, was adopted by voice vote. The bill, as
amended, was then ordered favorably reported to the House of
Representatives by voice vote.
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the full Committee on Natural Resources held on May
10, 2023.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title; table of contents
Section 2. Definitions
Section 3. Shared stewardship agreement for Giant Sequoias
Directs the Department of the Interior (DOI),
USFS, the State of California, and the Tule River Tribe to
enter into, or expand an existing a shared stewardship, or
similar agreement within 90 days to facilitate cross-boundary
coordination and collaboration on Giant Sequoia management and
conservation. These entities all currently own and manage Giant
Sequoia groves in California.
Section 4. Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition
Codifies the Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition, a
partnership of Giant Sequoia landowners and managers
encompassing USFS, NPS, BLM, State of California, Tule River
Tribe, County of Tulare, and private academic institutions.
The Coalition will conduct the Giant Sequoia
Health and Resiliency Assessment, coordinate joint management
projects, share information and best available science, and
provide oversight of the implementation of the H.R. 2989.
Section 5. Giant Sequoia Health and Resiliency Assessment
Directs the Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition to
conduct a comprehensive Giant Sequoia Health and Resiliency
Assessment based on the best available science to inform forest
management practices for the Giant Sequoias and prioritize
highest priority groves at risk of catastrophic wildfire within
6 months of the date of enactment of the bill. The Assessment
will:
Identify groves that have experienced
stand-replacing disturbances, groves and nearby lands
that are susceptible to experiencing a stand-replacing
disturbance, and groves in need of reforestation
following a stand-replacing disturbance.
Analyze the resiliency of individual
Giant Sequoia groves to wildfire, insects, and drought.
Identify priority forest management
projects to reduce the risk and severity of wildfire,
giving highest priority to areas identified as being at
high-risk of experiencing a stand-replacing
disturbance.
Analyze how historical, Tribal, or
current approaches to forest management have impacted
the health and resiliency of Giant Sequoias.
Include any necessary program and policy
recommendations to improve Giant Sequoia health and
resiliency.
Requires annual updates to the Assessment that
track the status and implementation of forest management and
reforestation activities within Giant Sequoia groves.
Specifies the Coalition shall also maintain a
public website that publishes the Assessment as well as a
dashboard that contains searchable information on the reviews
and costs of Giant Sequoia Protection Projects and
reforestation activities.
Requires the federal land managers to reduce
hazardous fuels in at least 3 Giant Sequoia groves annually.
Clarifies that the Coalition shall rely on data
and peer reviewed research from Federal, State, and academic
sources as well as traditional tribal ecological knowledge.
Allows the Secretary of the Interior to enter into
agreements or memorandums of understanding to improve the use
and integration of technology into the Assessment.
Incorporates data from the Assessment into other
relevant planning documents, such as the Forest Service's 10-
year Wildfire Crisis Strategy.
Clarifies the Assessment shall not be considered
an analysis produced under the National Environmental Policy
Act.
Section 6. Giant Sequoia emergency response
Declares an emergency for the Giant Sequoias that
will expire 7 years after the enactment of the bill. This is
based on existing Forest Service regulations and will allow
federal land managers to respond to this crisis like they would
during a wildfire. During the emergency period, DOI and USFS
officials can take emergency actions prior to initiating
environmental reviews under the National Environmental Policy
Act or consultations under the Endangered Species Act and
National Historic Preservation Act. Allows Protection Projects
to be subject to judicial review and emergency provisions in
the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act and Healthy Forests
Restoration Act. The regulations governing these actions are
codified as well.
Authorized activities for Giant Sequoia Protection
Projects include conducting hazardous fuels management,
removing dead and dying trees, and other activities recommended
by the Giant Sequoia Health and Resiliency Assessment. Those
projects are categorically excluded under NEPA.
Projects must be proposed by the Giant Sequoia
Health and Resiliency Assessment, developed through a
collaborative process, or proposed by a resource advisory
committee. Projects can only occur in Giant Sequoia groves that
have a grove-specific hazardous fuels reduction plan completed
by the relevant land management agency.
Projects can only cover 2,000 acres within a Giant
Sequoia grove and 3,000 acres immediately surrounding the
grove.
Applies emergency, informal consultation
requirements to projects for the National Historic Preservation
Act and Endangered Species Act.
Section 7. Giant Sequoia Reforestation and Rehabilitation Strategy
Directs the development and implementation of a
comprehensive Giant Sequoia Reforestation and Rehabilitation
Strategy to address the Giant Sequoia groves that have burned
in recent years. This strategy:
Creates a priority list of Giant Sequoia
groves in need of artificial or natural regeneration,
giving highest preference to groves that have
experienced a stand- replacing disturbance.
Proposes reforestation and
rehabilitation projects based on the priority list of
Giant Sequoia groves.
Identifies barriers to Giant Sequoia
reforestation, including limited seedlings supply,
workforce shortages, and technological limitations.
Recommends program or policy reforms
necessary to expedite Giant Sequoia reforestation and
rehabilitation.
Makes Giant Sequoia reforestation projects
eligible for priority funding from the Reforestation Trust
Fund.
Clarifies that Giant Sequoia reforestation
projects are consistent with the Wilderness Act to allow for
the re-establishment of Giant Sequoias following stand-
replacing disturbances, consistent with existing exemptions for
fire, insects, and disease. This provision is necessary to
address potential litigation against NPS for reforesting Giant
Sequoia groves that will not naturally regenerate unless
replanting occurs.
Section 8. Giant Sequoia strike teams
Establishes 10-person strike teams at DOI and USFS
to help with the implementation of Protection Projects and
reforestation activities. The strike teams may assist with
environmental reviews and consultations, site preparation, and
the implementation of Protection Projects and reforestation
activities.
Section 9. Giant Sequoia collaborative restoration grants
Provides competitive grants to eligible non-profit
organizations, Tribal or local governments, academic
institutions, or private organizations involved in Giant
Sequoia protection, reforestation, and rehabilitation
activities to promote public-private partnerships in Giant
Sequoia management.
Grants may be used to develop new markets
(including markets for biomass and biochar) for hazardous fuels
removed during Giant Sequoia protection projects, create
facilities that can store or process hazardous fuels, improve
nursery capacity and infrastructure, or reduce transportation
or labor costs associated with Giant Sequoia protection
projects.
Section 10. Good Neighbor Authority for Giant Sequoias
Adds Giant Sequoia Protection Projects to Good
Neighbor Authority (GNA).
Makes the NPS units that manage Giant Sequoias
eligible for GNA.
Reauthorizes GNA for 7 years and cleans up the
code to address drafting errors that have prevented Tribes and
counties from becoming full partners under GNA.
Section 11. Stewardship contracting for Giant Sequoias
Allows projects that promote the health and
resiliency of Giant Sequoias to be eligible for stewardship
contracts. Expands stewardship contracting authority to include
the NPS units that manage Giant Sequoias.
Section 12. Giant Sequoia emergency protection program and fund
Directs the National Park Foundation and National
Forest Foundation, the Congressionally chartered charitable
partners of NPS and USFS, respectively, to create a program to
accept philanthropic donations to promote the resiliency and
reforestation of Giant Sequoias, including funding for Tribal
historic preservation officers.
Directs 15 percent of donations to support Tribal
Giant Sequoia conservation.
Sets a sunset of 7 years.
Section 13. Authorization of appropriations
Provides funding, consistent with House floor
protocols (CUTGO), for the bill including $10 million in fiscal
year (FY) 2024, $25 million in FY 2025, $30 million over FY
2026-2028, and $40 million over FY 2029-2030.
Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
Compliance With House Rule XIII and
Congressional Budget Act
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) and (3) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and
sections 308(a) and 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, the Committee has received the following estimate for the
bill from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
H.R. 2989 would authorize the Department of the Interior
(DOI) and the Department of Agriculture (USDA) to jointly carry
out forest protection and rehabilitation projects in Northern
California. The projects would be conducted by the National
Park Service (NPS), the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), and
the Forest Service in and near giant sequoia groves on federal,
state, local, tribal, and private land.
Specifically, the bill would:
Direct DOI and USDA to enter into or expand
current stewardship agreements with one another,
California, and the Tule River Indian Tribe for
management and conservation of the giant sequoias;
Codify and set duties for the existing Giant
Sequoia Lands Coalition (a group of public-sector
entities--including the Forest Service, NPS, and BLM--
and nongovernmental organizations that work to conserve
giant sequoia groves);
Place federal land in Northern California
under an emergency-response designation for seven years
and exempt reforestation and protection projects on
those lands from certain requirements under
environmental laws;
Require DOI to develop and implement a
reforestation strategy to identify, prioritize, and
establish teams of public and private-sector entities
to complete reforestation projects; and
Establish a restoration grant program to
fund private, tribal, and local efforts to support
giant sequoia health and resiliency.
To carry out those activities, H.R. 2989 would authorize
the appropriation of $205 million over the 2024-2030 period and
would require at least 90 percent of that amount to be directed
toward emergency response projects and restoration grants.
Using historical spending patterns for similar activities,
CBO estimates that implementing H.R. 2989 would cost $113
million over the 2023-2028 period and $205 million over the
2023-2033 period. Such spending would be subject to
availability of appropriated funds.
The costs of the legislation, detailed in Table 1, fall
within budget function 300 (natural resources and environment).
Table 1.--ESTIMATED BUDGETARY EFFECTS OF H.R. 2989
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By fiscal year, millions of dollars--
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2023- 2023-
2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2028 2033
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Increases in Spending Subject to Appropriation
Estimated Authorization......................... 0 10 25 30 30 30 40 40 0 0 0 125 205
Estimated Outlays............................... 0 7 19 27 30 30 37 39 12 4 0 113 205
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Enacting the bill also would affect direct spending by between -$500,000 and $500,000 over the 2024-2033 period.
In addition to authorizing appropriations as discussed
above, enacting H.R. 2989 would make changes that would, in
CBO's estimation, affect direct spending by negligible amounts.
H.R. 2989 would authorize Indian tribes and counties to
retain and spend the proceeds of timber sales under cooperative
forestry agreements, also known as good neighbor agreements
(GNAs). (Under current law, set to expire on October 1, 2023,
only states can retain the proceeds from timber sales under
GNAs to cover the costs of restoration and protection
projects.) BLM and the Forest Service enter into GNAs with
states, federally recognized Indian tribes, and counties to
carry out forest, rangeland, and watershed restoration and
protection projects on federal land. The bill also would extend
the authority to retain proceeds until October 1, 2028, for
states, tribes, and counties.
In addition, H.R. 2989 would authorize the NPS to enter
into GNAs and stewardship contracts with private-sector
entities to carry out restoration projects in certain national
parks. Under the stewardship contracts, an agency can reduce
payments to contractors by an amount equal to the value of
timber or other vegetation a contractor would retain.
CBO estimates that enacting those provisions would not
affect direct spending because, absent the authority for states
and other entities to collect, retain, and spend proceeds from
the sale of timber for restoration and protection projects, and
for the NPS to enter into stewardship contracts, the timber
sales associated with those activities would not occur. (If
they did occur, the proceeds would be classified in the federal
budget as offsetting receipts, or reductions in direct
spending.)
The bill also would require the National Forest Foundation
and the National Park Foundation to establish an emergency
protection fund for the giant sequoias and would authorize the
foundations to accept donations and gifts for deposit into the
fund. Any amounts collected would be recorded in the federal
budget as offsetting receipts and would be available to spend
without further appropriation on the management, conservation,
and reforestation of giant sequoias on certain federal land.
CBO expects that those funds would be spent soon after receipt;
thus, the net effect on direct spending would be negligible.
Under the bill, the authority to collect and spend funds for
such activities would sunset seven years after enactment.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Lilia Ledezma.
The estimate was reviewed by Christina Hawley Anthony, Deputy
Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
2. General Performance Goals and Objectives. As required by
clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general performance goal or
objective of this bill is to improve the health and resiliency
of giant sequoias.
Earmark Statement
This bill does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined
under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Statement
According to the Congressional Budget Office, H.R. 2989
contains no unfunded mandates as defined by the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act.
Existing Programs
Directed Rule Making. This bill does not contain any
directed rule makings.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This bill does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Preemption of State, Local or Tribal Law
Any preemptive effect of this bill over state, local, or
tribal law is intended to be consistent with the bill's
purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
U.S. Constitution.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
FOREST AND RANGELAND RENEWABLE RESOURCES PLANNING ACT OF 1974
* * * * * * *
Sec. 3. Renewable Resource Assessment.--(a) In recognition
of the vital importance of America's renewable resources of the
forest, range, and other associated lands to the Nation's
social and economic well-being, and of the necessity for a long
term perspective in planning and undertaking related national
renewable resource programs administered by the Forest Service,
the Secretary of Agriculture (referred to in this Act as the
``Secretary'') shall prepare a Renewable Resource Assessment
(hereinafter called the ``Assessment''). The Assessment shall
be prepared not later than December 31, 1975, and shall be
undated during 1979 and each tenth year thereafter, and shall
include but not be limited to--
(1) an analysis of present and anticipated uses,
demand for, and suppl
Additional Views
H.R. 2989, the Save Our Sequoias Act, is a reaction to
climate-driven conditions impacting giant sequoia groves
primarily located on public land in California designed to
support and facilitate ongoing restoration efforts.
In response to the devastating mortality events and ongoing
threats to giant sequoias, the National Park Service, U.S.
Forest Service, the Bureau of Land Management, and several non-
federal partners that oversee and manage the sequoia groves,
including the State of California and the Tule River Indian
Tribe, joined together to form The Giant Sequoia Lands
Coalition in 2021.\1\ According to the organization's website,
``the goals of the coalition are to increase wildfire
resilience in our forests and communities; address long term
planning for climate change through research and monitoring;
increase pace and scale of treatments to reduce destructive
forest fuels through prescribed burning and restorative
thinning; and increase efficiency through partnerships aimed at
policy changes that allow for more swift action.''\2\ Since its
formation, the coalition has been extremely successful at
achieving these shared research and restoration goals, doubling
the amount of restoration treatments completed from the
previous year in 2023.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\National Park Service, Sequoia and Kings Canyon National Parks,
Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition Formed to Protect Iconic Trees from
Threats of Climate Change and Catastrophic Wildfire, (2021). https://
www.nps.gov/seki/learn/news/giant-sequoia-lands-coalition-formed-to-
protect-iconic-trees-from-threats-of-climate-change-and-catastrophic-
wildfire.htm.
\2\Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition, About Giant Sequoias. https://
giantsequoias.org/about/.
\3\Giant Sequoia Land Conservancy, 2023 Annual Report, at 1 (2024),
https://giantsequoias.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/2023_GSLC-Annual-
Report.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2989 would codify the existing Giant Sequoia Lands
Coalition, designate an emergency for giant sequoias, establish
new monitoring and data transparency requirements, provide new
authorities for managing and implementing projects in federally
owned sequoia groves, and provide up to $200 million over the
next seven years to further prioritize restoration treatments
in sequoia groves and carry out the provisions of the bill.
Many of the provisions in the bill are well-intentioned and
would be beneficial for the immediate and long-term management
needs of giant sequoias, providing agencies with critical
resources to ensure adequate staff capacity and additional
tools that could help achieve critical restoration goals.
However, the bill would unnecessarily waive or alter
environmental compliance standards, including the National
Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the Endangered Species Act
(ESA), the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), and the
Wilderness Act. NEPA's emergency regulations already allow for
an expedited response to take short-term actions to mitigate
harm to life, property, or important natural or cultural
resources when time doesn't allow for a typical NEPA review.
Rather than follow this established process, the bill would
waive environmental laws under overly broad ``emergency''
conditions and compel agencies to carry out projects decided on
by the Giant Sequoia Lands Coalition without any ability to
modify or adapt them based on NEPA analysis, available staff
capacity, or changing landscape conditions. The bill would
similarly bypass the Endangered Species Act by waiving
consultations that ensure that projects don't drive species
toward extinction.
In addition, the bill does not provide an authorization of
appropriations but rather a statutory allocation mandate that
would direct the Secretary of the Interior and the Secretary of
Agriculture to spend already appropriated funds without
specifying where that money will come from, which means that
the money could be drawn from other DOI and USDA priorities.
Though H.R. 2989 was amended at markup to address several
concerns highlighted by Committee Democrats, the bill still
contains the harmful ``emergency'' language that would
undermine bedrock environmental laws, as outlined in these
views. Congress can support and uplift ongoing efforts without
compromising environmental standards or setting an unnecessary
precedent.
Finally, much of the work that this bill aims to expedite
is already being completed by the National Park Service and
partners utilizing funding passed through the Infrastructure
Investment and Jobs Act. Beginning in 2023, NPS started
reforesting the highest priority groves throughout Sequoia &
Kings Canyon National Parks, including planting 65,000 giant
sequoia seedlings at Redwood Mountain and approximately 3,800
giant sequoias at Board Camp Grove in 2024. Additional grove
planting is already planned for 2025.\4\ The emergency
designations of H.R. 2989 are not necessary for the restoration
work that is actively happening throughout the affected
landscapes.
\4\The National Park Service: Sequoia & Kings Canyon National Park,
``Restoring giant sequoia groves following high-severity wildfire''
(2024). https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/restoring-giant-sequoia-
groves-post-high-severity-wildfires-2024.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member.
[all]