Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 8913]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Ways and Means, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 8913) to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to
exclude certain students from the calculation to determine if
certain private colleges and universities are subject to the
excise tax on net investment income, and for other purposes,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND...........................................2
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 2
B. Background and Need for Legislation................. 3
C. Legislative History................................. 3
D. Designated Hearing.................................. 4
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL..........................................4
A. Certain Students Not Taken into Account for Purposes
of Calculation to Determine if Certain Private
Colleges and Universities are Subject to Excise Tax
on Net Investment Income; Requirement to Report
Certain Information with Respect to Application of
Excise Tax Based on Investment Income of Private
Colleges and Universities (secs. 2 and 3 of the
bill and secs. 4968 and 6033 of the Code).......... 4
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE............................................7
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL.......................................7
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects............. 7
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax
Expenditures Budget Authority...................... 8
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office............................................. 8
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE......10
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations.... 10
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and
Objectives......................................... 10
C. Applicability of House Rule XXI, Clause 5(b)........ 10
D. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates........... 10
E. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and
Limited Tariff Benefits............................ 10
F. Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 11
G. Tax Complexity Analysis............................. 11
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED...........11
A. Changes in Existing Law Proposed by the Bill, as
Reported........................................... 11
VII. DISSENTING VIEWS................................................22
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Protecting American Students Act''.
SEC. 2. CERTAIN STUDENTS NOT TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT FOR PURPOSES OF
CALCULATION TO DETERMINE IF CERTAIN PRIVATE
COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES ARE SUBJECT TO EXCISE TAX
ON NET INVESTMENT INCOME.
(a) In General.--Section 4968(b) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986
is amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph:
``(3) Certain students not taken into account in determining
endowment threshold.--For purposes of paragraph (1)(D), a
student shall not be taken into account with respect to an
eligible educational institution unless such student meets the
student eligibility requirements under section 484(a)(5) of the
Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1091(a)(5)).''.
(b) Effective Date.--The amendment made by this section shall apply
to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2024.
SEC. 3. REQUIREMENT TO REPORT CERTAIN INFORMATION WITH RESPECT TO
APPLICATION OF EXCISE TAX BASED ON INVESTMENT
INCOME OF PRIVATE COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES.
(a) In General.--Section 6033 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 is
amended by redesignating subsection (o) as subsection (p) and by
inserting after subsection (n) the following new subsection:
``(o) Requirement to Report Certain Information With Respect to
Excise Tax Based on Investment Income of Private Colleges and
Universities.--Each applicable educational institution described in
section 4968(b) which is subject to the requirements of subsection (a)
shall include on the return required under subsection (a)--
``(1) the number of students taken into account for purposes
of the calculation in paragraph (1)(D) of section 4968(b)
(determined before the application of paragraph (3) of such
section), and
``(2) the number of students taken into account for purposes
of the calculation in paragraph (1)(D) of section 4968(b)
(determined after the application of paragraph (3) of such
section).''.
(b) Effective Date.--The amendment made by this section shall apply
to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2024.
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
The bill, H.R. 8913, the ``Protecting American Students
Act,'' as ordered by the Committee on Ways and Means on July 9,
2024, modifies the excise tax based on investment income of
private colleges and universities under section 4968 of the
Internal Revenue Code (``IRC''). Under the bill, an institution
is an applicable educational institution subject to the excise
tax if it has assets with a fair market value of at least
$500,000 per student, and only those students who meet the
eligibility requirements of section 484(a)(5) of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 are taken into account.
B. Background and Need for Legislation
To promote tax fairness among private foundations and tax-
exempt organizations--particularly private colleges and
universities--the 2017 Trump tax cuts established the
``Endowment Tax.'' Currently, the Endowment Tax is a 1.4
percent excise tax on the net investment income (``NII'') of a
private college or university endowment above a certain size.
To be within scope of the tax, the institution must have (among
other criteria) (1) at least 500 ``tuition-paying'' students;
and (2) an endowment value of at least $500,000 per ``full-
time'' student. Roughly 30 to 60 institutions fall into scope
of the Endowment Tax in any given year. According to the most
recently available data from the Internal Revenue Service
(``IRS''), in 2022, the Endowment Tax raised $244 million from
58 schools after raising just $68 million from 33 schools in
2021.
As the Committee's investigation into antisemitism has
shown, America's supposedly elite institutions--which receive
generous federal tax benefits--have harbored and promoted
antisemitic behavior while allowing Jewish students to be
threatened, harassed, and assaulted on campus. Data and public
reporting make clear that malign foreign influence, including
some students present in the United States on temporary student
visas, have directly contributed to the rise in antisemitic
behavior on college campuses.
At the same time, public reporting indicates that the
number of foreign students at American universities, especially
at Ivy League schools, has grown significantly in recent years.
Over the last decade, the number of foreign students in the
United States has increased by nearly 30 percent. Reporting
indicates that the average number of foreign students at Ivy
League schools is around 25 percent, reaching as high as 50
percent at some institutions. H.R. 8913 amends the Endowment
Tax formula to only account for students eligible for federal
financial assistance under section 484(a)(5) of the Higher
Education Act of 1965. This includes students who are (1) a
citizen, national, or permanent resident of the United States;
or (2) able to provide evidence from the Immigration and
Naturalization Service that they are in the United States for
other than a temporary purpose with the intention of becoming a
citizen or permanent resident. This would not include students
who are in the U.S. temporarily or on a student visa. H.R. 8913
would incentivize private colleges and universities to either
enroll more students eligible for federal financial assistance
or spend more of their endowment funds on those students to
avoid being subject to the Endowment Tax.
C. Legislative History
Background
H.R. 8913 was introduced on July 2, 2024, and was referred
to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Committee Hearings
On November 15, 2023, the Committee held a hearing
entitled, ``From Ivory Towers to Dark Corners: Investigating
the Nexus Between Antisemitism, Tax-Exempt Universities, and
Terror Financing.''\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Hearing: From Ivory Towers to Dark
Corners: Investigating the Nexus Between Antisemitism, Tax-Exempt
Universities, and Terror Financing (Nov. 15, 2023), https://
waysandmeans.house.gov/event/hearing-from-ivory-towers-to-dark-corners-
investigating-the-nexus-between-antisemitism-tax-exempt-universities-
and-terror-financing/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On June 13, 2024, the Committee held a hearing entitled,
``Crisis on Campus: Antisemitism, Radical Faculty, and Failure
of University Leadership.''\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Hearing on the Crisis on Campus:
Antisemitism, Radical Faculty, and the Failure of University Leadership
(June 13, 2024), https://waysandmeans.house.gov/event/hearing-on-the-
crisis-on-campus-antisemitism-radical-faculty-and-the-failure-of-
university-leadership/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 8913, the
``Protecting American Students Act,'' on July 9, 2024, and
ordered the bill, as amended, favorably reported (with a quorum
being present).\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Markup of H.R. 8914, H.R. 8913, H.R.
8915, and H.J.Res. 148 (July 9, 2024), https://waysandmeans.house.gov/
event/markup-of-h-r-8914-h-r-8913-h-r-8915-and-h-j-res-148/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop and consider H.R. 8913:
On November 15, 2023, the Committee held a hearing
entitled, ``From Ivory Towers to Dark Corners: Investigating
the Nexus Between Antisemitism, Tax-Exempt Universities, and
Terror Financing.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Hearing: From Ivory Towers to Dark
Corners: Investigating the Nexus Between Antisemitism, Tax-Exempt
Universities, and Terror Financing (Nov. 15, 2023), https://
waysandmeans.house.gov/event/hearing-from-ivory-towers-to-dark-corners-
investigating-the-nexus-between-antisemitism-tax-exempt-universities-
and-terror-financing/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On June 13, 2024, the Committee held a hearing entitled,
``Crisis on Campus: Antisemitism, Radical Faculty, and Failure
of University Leadership.''\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Hearing on the Crisis on Campus:
Antisemitism, Radical Faculty, and the Failure of University Leadership
(June 13, 2024), https://waysandmeans.house.gov/event/hearing-on-the-
crisis-on-campus-antisemitism-radical-faculty-and-the-failure-of-
university-leadership/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. Certain Students Not Taken Into Account for Purposes of Calculation
To Determine if Certain Private Colleges and Universities are Subject
to Excise Tax on Net Investment Income; Requirement To Report Certain
Information With Respect to Application of Excise Tax Based on
Investment Income of Private Colleges and Universities (Secs. 2 and 3
of the Bill and Secs. 4968 and 6033 of the Code)
PRESENT LAW
In general
Section 4968 imposes an excise tax on an applicable
educational institution for each taxable year equal to 1.4
percent of the net investment income of the institution for the
taxable year. Net investment income is determined using rules
similar to the rules of section 4940(c) (relating to the net
investment income of a private foundation).
An applicable educational institution is an eligible
education institution (as defined in section 25A):\6\ (1) that
has at least 500 tuition-paying students during the preceding
taxable year; (2) more than 50 percent of the tuition-paying
students of which are located in the United States; (3) that is
not described in the first sentence of section 511(a)(2)(B) of
the Code (generally describing State colleges and
universities); and (4) the aggregate fair market value of the
assets of which at the end of the preceding taxable year (other
than those assets that are used directly in carrying out the
institution's exempt purpose)\7\ is at least $500,000 per
student (the ``asset-per-student threshold''). For these
purposes, the number of students of an institution is based on
the average daily number of full-time students attending the
institution, with part-time students being taken into account
on a full-time student equivalent basis.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Section 25A(f)(2) defines an eligible educational institution as
an institution that (1) is described in section 481 of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. sec. 1088), as in effect on August 5,
1997, and (2) is eligible to participate in a program under title IV of
such Act.
\7\Assets used directly in carrying out the institution's exempt
purpose include, for example, classroom buildings and physical
facilities used for educational activities and office equipment, or
other administrative assets used by employees of the institution in
carrying out exempt activities, among other assets.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For purposes of determining whether an educational
institution meets the asset-per-student threshold\8\ and for
purposes of determining net investment income, assets and net
investment income of a related organization with respect to the
educational institution are treated as assets and net
investment income, respectively, of the educational
institution, except that:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\In cross-referencing the asset-per-student threshold for this
purpose, section 4968(d)(1) includes a reference to subsection
``(b)(1)(C)'' that should instead read ``(b)(1)(D).'' A clerical
correction may be necessary to correct this cross-reference.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
No such amount is taken into account with
respect to more than one educational institution; and
Unless the related organization is
controlled by the educational institution or is a
supporting organization (described in section
509(a)(3)) with respect to the institution for the
taxable year, assets and net investment income that are
not intended or available for the use or benefit of the
educational institution are not taken into account. For
example, assets of a related organization that are
earmarked or restricted for (or fairly attributable to)
the educational institution would be treated as assets
of the educational institution, whereas assets of a
related organization that are held for unrelated
purposes (and are not fairly attributable to the
educational institution) would be disregarded.
An organization is treated as related to the institution
for this purpose if the organization: (1) controls, or is
controlled by, the institution; (2) is controlled by one or
more persons that control the institution; or (3) is a
supported organization\9\ or a supporting organization\10\
during the taxable year with respect to the institution.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Sec. 509(f)(3).
\10\Sec. 509(a)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is intended that the Secretary of the Treasury
promulgate regulations to carry out the intent of the
provision, including regulations that describe: (1) assets that
are used directly in carrying out the educational institution's
exempt purpose; (2) the computation of net investment income;
and (3) assets that are intended or available for the use or
benefit of the educational institution.
The IRS and Treasury Department have issued regulations
addressing this provision.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Treas. Reg. sec. 53.4968-1 through -4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reporting requirements
A private college or university generally must file an
annual information return with the IRS using IRS Form 990,
``Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax.'' Part V,
question 16 of the Form 990 for the year 2023 asks whether the
filing organization is an educational institution that is
subject to the section 4968 excise tax on net investment
income. The instructions to the form include a worksheet to
assist the organization in making this determination.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\See 2023 Instructions for Form 990, pp. 18-19. The student
counts used in determining whether an institution is an applicable
educational institution are referenced in the worksheet but are not
provided to the IRS.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
An organization that answers ``yes'' to question 16 is
required to complete Schedule O of IRS Form 4720, ``Return of
Certain Excise Taxes Under Chapters 41 and 42 of the Internal
Revenue Code.'' Form 4720 is used to report certain excise
taxes that apply to tax-exempt organizations, including the
section 4968 excise tax on the net investment income of private
colleges and universities. On Schedule O, the organization must
provide information about the net investment income of the
filing organization and its related organizations and compute
the amount of section 4968 excise tax owed by the organization.
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Committee believes that the tax laws should incentivize
colleges and universities that do not pay Federal income tax to
enroll more American students and to spend more of their
endowment funds to provide services for and educate students.
In describing students that qualify for Federal financial aid,
the Higher Education Act of 1965 generally requires that a
student be a U.S. citizen or national, a permanent resident, or
able to provide evidence that the student is in the United
States for other than a temporary purpose with the intention of
becoming a citizen or permanent resident. The Committee
believes that the same requirement should apply under the tax
laws in determining whether a student is counted when
calculating an institution's assets-perstudent ratio under the
endowment excise tax.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISION
The provision modifies the asset-per-student calculation
used in determining whether an institution is an applicable
educational institution. Specifically, a student is not taken
into account with respect to an educational institution for
this purpose unless the student meets the eligibility
requirements under section 484(a)(5) of the Higher Education
Act of 1965.\13\ That section requires that the student ``be a
citizen or national of the United States, a permanent resident
of the United States, or able to provide evidence from the
Immigration and Naturalization Service that he or she is in the
United States for other than a temporary purpose with the
intention of becoming a citizen or permanent resident.''
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\20 U.S.C. sec. 1091(a)(5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The provision also requires an applicable educational
institution that is required to file an annual information
return (Form 990) to include on the return the number of
students taken into account for purposes of the asset-per-
student calculation, determined both before and after
application of the rule that limits the student count to
students who meet the eligibility requirements under section
484(a)(5) of the Higher Education Act of 1965.
EFFECTIVE DATE
The provision is effective for taxable years beginning
after December 31, 2024.
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE
In compliance with the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the following statement is made concerning the
vote of the Committee on Ways and Means during the markup
consideration of H.R. 8913, the ``Protecting American Students
Act,'' on July 9, 2024.
H.R. 8913 was ordered favorably reported to the House of
Representatives as amended by a roll call vote of 24 yeas to 13
nays (with a quorum being present). The vote was as follows:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Yea Nay Present Representative Yea Nay Present
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Smith (MO)..................... X ...... ......... Mr. Neal............. ...... X .........
Mr. Buchanan....................... X ...... ......... Mr. Doggett.......... ...... X .........
Mr. Smith (NE)..................... X ...... ......... Mr. Thompson......... ...... X .........
Mr. Kelly.......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Larson........... ...... X .........
Mr. Schweikert..................... X ...... ......... Mr. Blumenauer....... ...... X .........
Mr. LaHood......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Pascrell......... ...... ...... .........
Dr. Wenstrup....................... X ...... ......... Mr. Davis............ ...... ...... .........
Mr. Arrington...................... X ...... ......... Ms. Sanchez.......... ...... ...... .........
Dr. Ferguson....................... X ...... ......... Ms. Sewell........... ...... X .........
Mr. Estes.......................... X ...... ......... Ms. DelBene.......... ...... X .........
Mr. Smucker........................ X ...... ......... Ms. Chu.............. ...... X .........
Mr. Hern........................... X ...... ......... Ms. Moore............ ...... ...... .........
Ms. Miller......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Kildee........... ...... X .........
Dr. Murphy......................... ...... ...... ......... Mr. Beyer............ ...... X .........
Mr. Kustoff........................ X ...... ......... Mr. Evans............ ...... ...... .........
Mr. Fitzpatrick.................... X ...... ......... Mr. Schneider........ ...... X .........
Mr. Steube......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Panetta.......... ...... X .........
Ms. Tenney......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Gomez............ ...... X .........
Mrs. Fischbach..................... X ...... .........
Mr. Moore.......................... X ...... .........
Mrs. Steel......................... X ...... .........
Ms. Van Duyne...................... X ...... .........
Mr. Feenstra....................... X ...... .........
Ms. Malliotakis.................... X ...... .........
Mr. Carey.......................... X ...... .........
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
In compliance with clause 3(d) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the following statement is made
concerning the effects on the budget of the bill, H.R. 8913 as
reported. The estimate prepared by the Joint Committee on
Taxation (``JCT'') is included below.
The provision is estimated to have the following effect on
Federal fiscal year budget receipts. Because the first tax year
following the effective date for most applicable educational
institutions begins July 1, 2025, and ends on June 30, 2026,
changes to excise tax receipts under section 4968 resulting
from this provision generally will not occur until such
institutions file the Form 990 and Form 4270 returns for such
tax year. In general, not including extensions, these returns
have a filing deadline of the 15th day of the 5th month after
the institution's accounting period ends. For this reason, the
provision is not expected to have significant revenue effects
relative to the present law baseline until Federal fiscal year
2027.
Assuming an enactment date of July 31, 2024, the provision
is estimated to have the following effect on Federal fiscal
year budget receipts:
FISCAL YEARS
[Millions of dollars]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2024-28 2024-34
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
...... [1] 26 28 30 33 35 37 40 43 55 273
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NOTE: Details may not add to totals due to rounding.
[1] Gain of less than $500,000.
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures Budget
Authority
In compliance with clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee states that the
bill involves no new or increased budget authority.
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the
Congressional Budget Office
In compliance with clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, requiring a cost estimate
prepared by the CBO, the following statement by CBO is
provided.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 8913 would change the definition of ``student'' for
purposes of determining whether a postsecondary institution is
subject to the excise tax that applies to net investment income
earned on endowment assets. Under current law, that tax applies
to institutions with endowment assets of $500,000 or more per
student. The number of students is the daily average number of
full-time students, with part-time students considered on a
full-time-equivalent basis. H.R. 8913 would specify that the
accounting include only those students who are U.S. citizens,
permanent residents, or able to provide evidence of being in
the country with the intention of becoming a citizen or
permanent resident.
The Congressional Budget Act of 1974, as amended,
stipulates that revenue estimates provided by the staff of the
Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) will be the official
estimates for all tax legislation considered by the Congress.
As such, CBO incorporates those estimates into its cost
estimates of the effects of legislation. The estimates for the
revenue provisions of H.R. 8913 were provided by JCT.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Joint Committee on Taxation, Estimated Revenue Effects of H.R.
8913, the ``Protecting American Students Act,'' JCX-28-24 (July 8,
2024), www.jct.gov/publications/2024/jcx-28-24.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The estimated budgetary effect of H.R. 8913 is shown in
Table 1. The costs of the legislation fall within budget
function 800 (general government).
TABLE 1.--ESTIMATED BUDGETARY EFFECTS OF H.R. 8913
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By fiscal year, millions of dollars--
--------------------------------
Dissenting Views
Antisemitism, like all forms of discrimination, is
absolutely unacceptable. Whether on college campuses or
anywhere in our society, there is no excuse for hatred and
bigotry. Tackling these problems requires Congress to work
together on serious proposals to protect against discrimination
and uphold civil rights. That's what we did when we passed the
COVID-19 Hate Crimes Act during the pandemic, and it is what
the House can do now by passing bills like H.R. 7921, the
bipartisan Countering Antisemitism Act, led by Representatives
Kathy Manning and Chris Smith.
But instead of protecting victims of hate, this bill would
simply blame campus unrest on supposed foreign agitators, and
use this as an excuse to punish institutions that enroll
international students--regardless of where they come from.
Scapegoating these students does not represent a solution to
antisemitism or other forms of discrimination. In fact, it does
the exact opposite by blaming all foreigners for society's
ills. This is a fearmongering tactic that has been used
throughout history, and never with the goal of reducing hatred
and bigotry. It sadly reflects the same xenophobia that led to
shameful policies like the Chinese Exclusion Act and Trump's
Muslim Ban.
And this bill does not restrict its punishment to schools
who enroll international students. By limiting the definition
of students who count as full-time equivalents to only those
who qualify for federal student aid, it would categorize DACA
recipients the same as international students. These are young
people who were brought to this country as children and have no
other country to call home, yet this bill labels them as
foreigners and punishes the institutions that give them a
chance to further their education.
International students and DACA recipients are not our
enemies, and punishing universities for educating them will
only hurt us. During the 2022-2023 academic year, U.S. colleges
and universities hosted more than a million international
students who contributed more than $40 billion to the U.S.
economy. They include countless talented individuals who choose
to come to the United States to study with the goal of finding
a job, contributing to our economy, and making our country
their home. I am proud to represent many of these students at
institutions Caltech in my district, where international
students work on the cutting edge of science and technology and
help to make our economy the best in the world.
This is a misguided bill that would only make our country
weaker. I urge my colleagues to vote no.
Judy Chu.
[all]