Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.J. Res. 46]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Natural Resources, to whom was referred
the joint resolution (H.J. Res. 46) providing for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the National Marine Fisheries Service
relating to ``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants;
Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and
Designating Critical Habitat'', having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon without amendment and recommends that
the joint resolution do pass.
PURPOSE OF THE LEGISLATION
The purpose of H.J. Res. 46 is to provide for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the National Marine Fisheries Service
relating to ``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants;
Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and
Designating Critical Habitat''.
Background and Need for Legislation
The Endangered Species Act (ESA) directs the Secretaries of
the Interior and Commerce, upon listing a species as
endangered, to also designate the ``critical habitat'' of the
species.\1\ The ESA defines ``critical habitat'' as: ``(i) the
specific areas within the geographical area occupied by the
species on which are found those physical or biological
features (I) essential to the conservation of the species and
(II) which may require special management considerations or
protection; and (ii) specific areas outside the geographical
area occupied by the species upon a determination by the
Secretary that such areas are essential for the conservation of
the species.''\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\16 U.S.C. 1533(a)(3)(A)(i).
\2\16 U.S.C. 1532(5)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critical habitat designations can have a devastating impact
on rural communities. One example is the critical habitat
designation for the Northern Spotted Owl in the Pacific
Northwest. Studies have shown that the listing of the Northern
Spotted Owl and its 9.4 million acres of associated critical
habitat\3\ have caused the loss of at least 32,000 timber
jobs.\4\ These designations affect federal actions, funding,
and permitted activities.\5\ Section 7 of the ESA requires
consultation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)
and/or National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) when an
activity, such as forest management, construction of a dam, or
other infrastructure projects, might impact the critical
habitat for a listed species.\6\ This process can take years
and disincentivizes investment into critical infrastructure.
The USFWS describes the difficulties they are having in
conducting Section 7 consultations in a timely manner in its
March 2023 Report to Congress.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\``USFWS Threatened & Endangered Species Active Critical Habitat
Report.'' U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 4/3/2023 USFWS Threatened &
Endangered Species Active Critical Habitat Report.
\4\``Labor market impact of land protection: The Northern Spotted
Owl.'' Ann E. Ferris and Eyal G. Frank. Journal of Environmental
Economics and Management,'' Volume 109, September 2021, 102480. Labor
market impacts of land protection: The Northern Spotted Owl--
ScienceDirect.
\5\``Critical Habitat.'' What is it? U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service. March 2017. Critical Habitat fact sheet (fws.gov).
\6\``Endangered Species Act (ESA) Section 7 Consultation and
Infrastructure Projects.'' Erin H. Ward, R. Eliot Crafton, Pervaze A.
Sheikh. Congressional Research Service. Endangered Species Act (ESA)
Section 7 Consultation and Infrastructure Projects
(everycrsreport.com).
\7\U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Report to Congress: Review of
the ESA Interagency Section 7 Consultation Process and Recommendations
for Improving the Process. March 29, 2023. https://
naturalresources.house.gov/uploadedfiles/
fws_sect.7_report.3.29.2023.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the ESA defines the term ``critical habitat'' it does
not define the term ``habitat.'' In 2018, Weyerhaeuser Co. v.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service created the need for a
regulatory definition of the term. The Weyerhaeuser case
stemmed from a species known as the dusky gopher frog, a rare
species that is confined to a few ephemeral (short lasting)
ponds in the Mississippi River Delta.\8\ In 2010, in response
to litigation by the Center for Biological Diversity, the USFWS
published a proposed critical habitat designation for the dusky
gopher frog.\9\ The USFWS proposed to designate as occupied
critical habitat about 4,933 acres in Forrest, Harrison,
Jackson, and Perry Counties, Mississippi.\10\ The USFWS found
that those areas possessed the three features that the agency
considered ``essential to the conservation'' of the frog and
that required special protection: ephemeral ponds for breeding,
open-canopy forest with holes and burrows for dwelling, and
open-canopy forest connecting breeding and dwelling areas.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\``Final Rules Amending ESA Critical Habitat Regulations.'' Erin
H. Ward and Pervaze A. Sheikh. Congressional Research Service. IF11740
(congress.gov).
\9\Designation of Critical Habitat for Dusky Gopher Frog, 77 Fed.
Reg. 35129-35131 (2012).
\10\Id.
\11\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the same time, USFWS also determined that there was not
enough occupied land to sustain the species and proposed to
designate as unoccupied critical habitat 1,544 acres of private
lands in St. Tammany Parish, Louisiana.\12\ This area only
contained one characteristic suitable for the frog, the
presence of ephemeral ponds.\13\ The landowner, the
Weyerhaeuser Company, sued the USFWS.\14\ Weyerhaeuser
contended that the proposed land was not suitable habitat for
the frog and that USFWS inadequately weighed the benefit to the
species against the economic impacts.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Weyerhaeuser Co. v. United States Fish and Wildlife Serv., 586
U.S.___ (2018).
\13\Designation of Critical Habitat for Dusky Gopher Frog, 77 Fed.
Reg. 35129-35131 (2012).
\14\``Final Rules Amending ESA Critical Habitat Regulations.'' Erin
H. Ward and Pervaze A. Sheikh. Congressional Research Service. IF11740
(congress.gov).
\15\Weyerhaeuser Co. v. United States Fish and Wildlife Serv., 586
U.S.___ (2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2018, the case reached the Supreme Court of the United
States (Supreme Court).\16\ In a unanimous opinion, the Supreme
Court held that to be designated a ``critical habitat'' under
the ESA, the land must also be habitat for the species.\17\ In
light of this opinion the USFWS agreed to remove the areas in
question from critical habitat designations.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\U.S. Supreme Court, Granted and Noted List, October Term 2018.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/qp/17-00071qp.pdf.
\17\Weyerhaeuser Co. v. United States Fish and Wildlife Serv., 586
U.S.___ (2018).
\18\``Settlement Eliminates 1.500 Acres of Designated Dusky Gopher
Frog Critical Habitat.'' David Miller. Nossaman LLP. 7/18/2019.
Settlement Eliminates 1,500 Acres of Designated Dusky Gopher Frog
Critical Habitat (endangeredspecieslawandpolicy.com).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On December 16, 2020, in response to the Weyerhaeuser
decision the USFWS and NMFS published a final rule that defined
``habitat,'' for the purposes of designating critical habitat
under the ESA. The rule defined ``habitat'' as the abiotic and
biotic setting that currently or periodically (emphasis added)
contains the resources and conditions necessary to support one
or more life processes of species.\19\ In effect, this rule
narrowed the scope by which USFWS and NMFS could designate
critical habitat to areas that meet each characteristic needed
to sustain the species. A definition of habitat that excludes
areas not currently suitable for the species provides greater
certainty to stakeholders operating projects with a federal
nexus. Over 900 listed species have designated critical habitat
associated with them, which accounts for over 107 million acres
of land area.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Regulations
for Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and Designating Critical
Habitat.'' 87 FR 37757. Federal Register: Endangered and Threatened
Wildlife and Plants; Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened
Species and Designating Critical Habitat.
\20\``USFWS Threatened & Endangered Species Active Critical Habitat
Report.'' U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 4/3/2023. USFWS Threatened &
Endangered Species Active Critical Habitat Report.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On June 24, 2022, the USFWS and the NMFS announced they
were rescinding the Trump administration`s rule defining
``habitat'' as it relates to designating critical habitat.\21\
This action would revert to previous policies that allow the
two agencies to designate critical habitat in areas that are
not currently occupied by the species in question and in some
cases, have not been occupied in decades and may never be
occupied.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\``U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and NOAA Fisheries Rescind
Regulatory Definition of ``Habitat'' Under the Endangered Species
Act.'' Marilyn Kitchell and Lauren Gaches. U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service. 6/23/2022. Rescind Regulatory Definition of ``Habitat'' Under
the Endangered Species Act|U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service (fws.gov).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Congressional Review Act
The Congressional Review Act (CRA) was enacted in 1996 and
provides Congress with a tool to overturn administrative
regulations. If a CRA joint resolution is approved by both the
House and Senate and signed by the President, the rule at issue
cannot go into effect or continue in effect.
H.J. Res. 46 would repeal the Biden administration's
rescission, reinstating the Trump administration's definition
of ``habitat'' as it relates to designating critical habitat.
Committee Action
H.J. Res. 46 was introduced on March 30, 2023, by Rep.
Cliff Bentz (R-OR). The resolution was referred to the
Committee on Natural Resources, and within the Committee to the
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries. On April 18,
2023, the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries held a
hearing on the resolution. On April 27-28, 2023, the Full
Natural Resources Committee met to consider the resolution. The
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries was discharged by
unanimous consent. Rep. Jared Huffman (D-CA) offered an
amendment designated Huffman #1. The amendment offered by Rep.
Huffman was withdrawn by unanimous consent. The resolution was
then ordered favorably reported to the House of Representatives
by a roll call vote of 17 yeas to 12 nays, as follows:
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6) of House rule XIII, the
following hearing was used to develop or consider this measure:
hearing by the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife, and Fisheries
held on April 18, 2023.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Congress disapproves the rule submitted by the United
States Fish and Wildlife Service relating to ``Endangered and
Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Endangered Species Status for
Northern Long-Eared Bat'' (87 Fed. Reg. 73488; published
November 30, 2022), and such rule shall have no force or
effect.
COMMITTEE OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Regarding clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee on Natural Resources' oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the body of this report.
COMPLIANCE WITH HOUSE RULE XIII AND CONGRESSIONAL
BUDGET ACT
1. Cost of Legislation and the Congressional Budget Act.
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) and (3) of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and
sections 308(a) and 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, the Committee has received the following estimate for the
resolution from the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office:
H.J. Res. 46 would disapprove a rule published in the
Federal Register on July 24, 2022, by the National Marine
Fisheries Service related to ``Endangered and Threatened
Wildlife and Plants; Regulations for Listing Endangered and
Threatened Species and Designating Critical Habitat.'' As a
result, the legislation would reinstate a previous rule,
``Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and
Designating Critical Habitat,'' which was submitted by U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) and National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and published in the Federal
Register on December 16, 2020. That rule defined the term
``habitat'' for regulations concerning critical habitat under
the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The ESA requires agencies to
consult with USFWS and NOAA on activities that could adversely
affect critical habitats.
Using information from USFWS and NOAA, CBO estimates that
reinstating the definition of ``habitat'' would not affect
permitting fees or civil and criminal penalties under the ESA.
There would be some administrative costs to void the
regulation, which CBO estimates would be insignificant; any
spending would be subject to the availability of appropriated
funds.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Lilia Ledezma.
The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss, Deputy
Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
2. General Performance Goals and Objectives. As required by
clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general performance goal or
objective of this resolution is to provide for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the National Marine Fisheries Service
relating to ``Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants;
Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and
Designating Critical Habitat''.
EARMARK STATEMENT
This resolution does not contain any Congressional
earmarks, limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as
defined under clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI of the
Rules of the House of Representatives.
UNFUNDED MANDATES REFORM ACT STATEMENT
According to the Congressional Budget Office, this
resolution contains no unfunded mandates as defined by the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act.
EXISTING PROGRAMS
Directed Rule Making. This resolution does not contain any
directed rule makings.
Duplication of Existing Programs. This resolution does not
establish or reauthorize a program of the federal government
known to be duplicative of another program. Such program was
not included in any report from the Government Accountability
Office to Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139
or identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Public Law 95-220, as amended by Public Law
98-169) as relating to other programs.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
PREEMPTION OF STATE, LOCAL OR TRIBAL LAW
Any preemptive effect of this resolution over state, local,
or tribal law is intended to be consistent with the
resolution's purposes and text and the Supremacy Clause of
Article VI of the U.S. Constitution.
CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW
As reported by the Committee, H.J. Res. 46 makes no changes
in existing law.
Dissenting Views
H.J. Res. 46 is a resolution of congressional disapproval
for a National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) rule that
revoked the December 2020 definition of ``habitat'' under the
Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA). The regulation, jointly
issued by NMFS and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) on
June 24, 2022, would be nullified if H.J. Res. 46 is enacted.
This resolution will undermine federal agencies' authority to
make informed management decisions based on the best available
scientific evidence, as required by the ESA. It also runs
counter to the language and intent of the ESA and could impede
the agencies' ability to identify, designate, and restore
critical habitats for endangered and threatened species,
putting these species at risk of extinction.
Under the ESA, agencies designate ``critical habitat'' for
species recovery. This designation is a crucial component of
ESA implementation. The ESA defines critical habitat as areas
both occupied and unoccupied by the species at the time of
listing. Occupied areas must possess physical or biological
features essential to the species conservation and may require
unique management. Unoccupied areas need only be ``essential
for the conservation of the species'' to qualify as critical
habitat.
A unanimous U.S. Supreme Court decision in 2018 established
that an area must meet the requirements to be considered a
``habitat'' for an endangered species before it can be deemed a
``critical habitat.''\1\ Building upon this decision, the Trump
administration, through FWS and NMFS, issued a final rule on
December 16, 2020, defining ``habitat'' as follows: ``For the
purposes of designating critical habitat only, habitat is the
abiotic and biotic setting that currently or periodically
contains the resources and conditions necessary to support one
or more life processes of a species.''\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Weyerhaeuser Co. v. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Serv., 586 U.S.___
(2018), https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/18pdf/17-71_omjp.pdf.
\2\Regulations for Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and
Designating Critical Habitat (85 Fed. Reg. 81411). December 16, 2020.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This 2020 critical habitat rule directly contradicts the
ESA's definition of critical habitat, which includes occupied
and unoccupied areas. Unoccupied areas can and should be
designated as critical habitat if they are essential for
species conservation. During the April 18, 2023, hearing on
H.J. Res. 46, Robert L. Fishman, Professor of Law at Indiana
University, explained that Congress acknowledged the
conservation necessity of creating new habitats for species
recovery, recognizing that most species cannot rebound from the
brink of extinction without additional habitat to disperse or
be relocated to. Therefore, any regulatory definition of
habitat that excludes unoccupied areas essential to recovery,
as was the case with the 2020 rule, goes against the clear
intent of the ESA.
The 2020 definition limited the ability of FWS and NMFS to
conserve and restore critical habitat based on the best
available science for ESA-listed species recovery. By
restricting habitat to areas that currently or periodically
support the life processes of a species, the 2020 definition
excluded areas requiring restoration or modification to support
species. This limitation disregarded the longstanding practice
of designating degraded habitats as critical habitat under the
ESA and subsequently working toward their restoration to serve
as strongholds for species recovery, particularly in ecosystems
with depleted habitat and reduced species ranges.
Moreover, the definition failed to account for the
flexibility needed by FWS and NMFS in addressing the impact of
climate change on species' habitat. As species' ranges shift in
response to changing temperatures and rising sea levels or to
follow their preferred prey, FWS and NMFS often need to
designate areas as critical habitat that species will inhabit
in the foreseeable future to ensure their survival. Despite the
availability of the best scientific knowledge on wildlife
migrations and climate forecasting, the 2020 definition would
have limited this opportunity in some areas.
Recognizing these deficiencies, the Biden administration
finalized a rule on June 24, 2022, revoking the 2020 definition
of ``habitat.''\3\ The administration concluded that
restricting habitat to areas currently or periodically
supporting species' life processes was inconsistent with the
conservation purpose of the ESA. FWS and NMFS also determined
that the 2020 definition was unclear and would not provide
transparency or reproducible outcomes.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Regulations for
Listing Endangered and Threatened Species and Designating Critical
Habitat (87 Fed. Reg. 37757). June 24, 2022. https://
www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/06/24/2022-13368/endangered-and-
threatened-wildlife-and-plants-regulations-for-listing-endangered-and-
threatened.
\4\See also Erin H. Ward & Pervaze A. Sheikh, Congressional
Research Service, IF11740, CRS in Focus: Final Rules Amending Critical
Habitat Regulations (version two, updated July 11, 2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.J. Res. 46 disapproves the June 24, 2022, rule and
restores the 2020 Trump-era definition of ``habitat.'' This
resolution undermines the Endangered Species Act by impeding
the agencies' flexibility to make well-informed management and
recovery decisions based on the best available science and in
alignment with the ESA's requirements. Additionally, it forces
the agencies to rely on an outdated rule, as using the
Congressional Review Act prohibits them from implementing any
substantially similar rulemaking in the future. Given the
dynamic nature of species' status and range shifts due to
climate change and other factors, this limitation on assessing
and designating critical habitat would significantly hinder
species recovery efforts, which rely on identifying and
preserving essential habitats.
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member, House Committee on Natural Resources.
[all]