Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 8915]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Ways and Means, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 8915) to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to
expand the expenses treated as qualified higher education
expenses for purposes of 529 accounts to include additional
elementary and secondary school expenses and certain
postsecondary credentialing expenses, having considered the
same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND...........................................3
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 3
B. Background and Need for Legislation................. 4
C. Legislative History................................. 4
D. Designated Hearing.................................. 4
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL..........................................5
A. Expand the Expenses Treated as Qualified Higher
Education Expenses for Purposes of 529 Accounts To
Include Additional Elementary and Secondary School
Expenses and Certain Postsecondary Credentialing
Expenses (Secs. 2 and 3 of the Bill and Sec. 529 of
the Code).......................................... 5
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE............................................9
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL.......................................9
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects............. 9
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax
Expenditures Budget Authority...................... 10
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office............................................. 10
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE......11
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations.... 11
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and
Objectives......................................... 11
C. Applicability of House Rule XXI, Clause 5(b)........ 12
D. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates........... 12
E. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and
Limited Tariff Benefits............................ 12
F. Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 12
G. Tax Complexity Analysis............................. 12
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED...........13
A. Changes in Existing Law Proposed by the Bill, as
Reported........................................... 13
VII. DISSENTING VIEWS................................................23
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Education and Workforce Freedom Act''.
SEC. 2. ADDITIONAL ELEMENTARY, SECONDARY, AND HOME SCHOOL EXPENSES
TREATED AS QUALIFIED HIGHER EDUCATION EXPENSES FOR
PURPOSES OF 529 ACCOUNTS.
(a) In General.--Section 529(c)(7) of the Internal Revenue Code of
1986 is amended to read as follows:
``(7) Treatment of elementary and secondary tuition.--Any
reference in this section to the term `qualified higher
education expense' shall include a reference to the following
expenses in connection with enrollment or attendance at, or for
students enrolled at or attending, an elementary or secondary
public, private, or religious school:
``(A) Tuition.
``(B) Curriculum and curricular materials.
``(C) Books or other instructional materials.
``(D) Online educational materials.
``(E) Tuition for tutoring or educational classes
outside of the home, including at a tutoring facility,
but only if the tutor or instructor is not related to
the student and--
``(i) is licensed as a teacher in any State,
``(ii) has taught at an eligible educational
institution, or
``(iii) is a subject matter expert in the
relevant subject.
``(F) Fees for a nationally standardized norm-
referenced achievement test, an advanced placement
examination, or any examinations related to college or
university admission.
``(G) Fees for dual enrollment in an institution of
higher education.
``(H) Educational therapies for students with
disabilities provided by a licensed or accredited
practitioner or provider, including occupational,
behavioral, physical, and speech-language therapies.
Such term shall include expenses for the purposes described in
subparagraphs (A) through (H) in connection with a homeschool
(whether treated as a homeschool or a private school for
purposes of applicable State law).''.
(b) Effective Date.--The amendment made by this section shall apply
to distributions made after the date of the enactment of this Act.
SEC. 3. CERTAIN POSTSECONDARY CREDENTIALING EXPENSES TREATED AS
QUALIFIED HIGHER EDUCATION EXPENSES FOR PURPOSES OF
529 ACCOUNTS.
(a) In General.--Section 529(e)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of
1986 is amended by adding at the end the following new subparagraph:
``(C) Certain postsecondary credentialing expenses.--
The term `qualified higher education expenses' includes
qualified postsecondary credentialing expenses (as
defined in subsection (f)).''.
(b) Qualified Postsecondary Credentialing Expenses.--Section 529 is
amended by redesignating subsection (f) as subsection (g) and by
inserting after subsection (e) the following new subsection:
``(f) Qualified Postsecondary Credentialing Expenses.--For purposes
of this section--
``(1) In general.--The term `qualified postsecondary
credentialing expenses' means--
``(A) tuition, fees, books, supplies, and equipment
required for the enrollment or attendance of a
designated beneficiary in a recognized postsecondary
credential program, or any other expense incurred in
connection with enrollment in or attendance at a
recognized postsecondary credential program if such
expense would, if incurred in connection with
enrollment or attendance at an eligible educational
institution, be covered under subsection (e)(3)(A),
``(B) fees for testing if such testing is required to
obtain or maintain a recognized postsecondary
credential, and
``(C) fees for continuing education if such education
is required to maintain a recognized postsecondary
credential.
``(2) Recognized postsecondary credential program.--For
purposes of this subparagraph, the term `recognized
postsecondary credential program' means any program to obtain a
recognized postsecondary credential if--
``(A) such program is included on a State list
prepared under section 122(d) of the Workforce
Innovation and Opportunity Act (29 U.S.C. 3152(d)),
``(B) such program is listed in the WEAMS Public
directory (or successor directory) maintained by the
Department of Veterans Affairs,
``(C) an examination (developed or administered by an
organization widely recognized as providing reputable
credentials in the occupation) is required to obtain or
maintain such credential and such organization
recognizes such program as providing training or
education which prepares individuals to take such
examination, or
``(D) such program is identified by the Secretary,
after consultation with the Secretary of Labor, as
being a reputable program for obtaining a recognized
postsecondary credential for purposes of this
subparagraph.
``(3) Recognized postsecondary credential.--The term
`recognized postsecondary credential' means--
``(A) any postsecondary employment credential that is
industry recognized, including--
``(i) any postsecondary employment credential
issued by a program that is accredited by the
Institute for Credentialing Excellence, the
National Commission on Certifying Agencies, or
the American National Standards Institute,
``(ii) any postsecondary employment
credential that is included in the
Credentialing Opportunities On-Line (COOL)
directory of credentialing programs (or
successor directory) maintained by the
Department of Defense or by any branch of the
Armed Services, and
``(iii) any postsecondary employment
credential identified for purposes of this
clause by the Secretary, after consultation
with the Secretary of Labor, as being industry
recognized,
``(B) any certificate of completion of an
apprenticeship that is registered and certified with
the Secretary of Labor under the National
Apprenticeship Act (29 U.S.C. 50),
``(C) any occupational or professional license issued
or recognized by a State or the Federal Government (and
any certification that satisfies a condition for
obtaining such a license), and
``(D) any recognized postsecondary credential as
defined in section 3(52) of the Workforce Innovation
and Opportunity Act (29 U.S.C. 3102).''.
(c) Effective Date.--The amendments made by this section shall apply
to distributions made after the date of the enactment of this Act.
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
The bill, H.R. 8915, the ``Education and Workforce Freedom
Act,'' as ordered reported by the Committee on Ways and Means
on July 9, 2024, adds to present law new categories of expenses
that are treated as ``qualified higher education expenses'' and
that, as a result, are allowed favorable tax treatment under
Internal Revenue Code (``Code'') section 529. Section 2 of the
bill broadens the expenses related to elementary and secondary
schools that are treated as qualified higher education expenses
under section 529, and it provides that expenses in connection
with a homeschool are included. Section 3 of the bill treats
certain postsecondary credentialing expenses as qualified
higher education expenses.
B. Background and Need for Legislation
Qualified tuition programs, colloquially known as 529
plans, are valuable tools for millions of American families and
students to help save for educational expenses, most commonly
at the post-secondary four-year degree level. The Committee
believes usage and flexibility of 529 plans should be expanded
to help ease the educational cost burden and expand educational
opportunities for parents and students alike.
H.R. 8915 addresses this by expanding qualified expenses
for 529 plans at the elementary, secondary, and postsecondary
levels. Specifically, H.R. 8915 provides parents and students
with resources to receive the education that is best for them
by expanding 529 plans' qualified expenses to include tuition,
curriculum and curricular materials, books or other
instructional materials, online educational materials,
tutoring, certain fees, and educational therapies. H.R. 8915
also provides students and workers to choose the educational
opportunity that is best for them and helps address America's
growing skills shortage by expanding 529 plans' qualified
expenses to include postsecondary credentialing expenses,
testing fees related to postsecondary credentials, and fees for
continuing education required to maintain a postsecondary
credential.
C. Legislative History
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 8915, the
``Education and Workforce Freedom Act,'' on July 9, 2024, and
ordered the bill, as amended, favorably reported (with a quorum
being present).
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop and consider H.R. 8915:
On September 14, 2023, the Committee held a hearing
entitled, ``Member Day.''
On October 25, 2023, the Committee held a hearing on,
``Educational Freedom and Opportunity for American Families,
Students, and Workers.''
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. Expand the Expenses Treated as Qualified Higher Edu-
cation Expenses for Purposes of 529 Accounts To Include
Additional Elementary and Secondary School Expenses
and Certain Postsecondary Credentialing Expenses (Secs. 2
and 3 of the Bill and Sec. 529 of the Code)
PRESENT LAW
Qualified tuition programs generally
To describe programs that are known colloquially as 529
plans, the Code uses the term ``qualified tuition programs''
and distinguishes between two types of programs.\1\ One type of
program, sometimes referred to as a prepaid tuition program,
allows a person to purchase on behalf of a designated
beneficiary tuition credits or certificates that entitle the
beneficiary to the waiver or payment of the beneficiary's
qualified higher education expenses.\2\ Prepaid tuition
programs are established and maintained by State governments
(or their agencies or instrumentalities) and eligible
educational institutions.\3\ The other type of program,
sometimes referred to as a college savings plan, allows a
person to make contributions to an account that is established
for the purpose of satisfying the qualified higher education
expenses of the designated beneficiary of the account.\4\ A
college savings plan may be established and maintained by State
governments (or their agencies or instrumentalities), not by
educational institutions.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Sec. 529(a), (b).
\2\Sec. 529(b)(1)(A)(i).
\3\Ibid. Section 529(e)(5) defines an eligible educational
institution as an institution that (1) is described in section 481 of
the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. sec. 1088), as in effect on
August 5, 1997, and (2) is eligible to participate in a program under
title IV of such Act.
\4\Sec. 529(b)(1)(A)(ii).
\5\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A qualified tuition program generally is exempt from
Federal income taxation (but is subject to unrelated business
income tax).\6\ As a consequence, contributors to, and
beneficiaries of, these programs (whether prepaid tuition
programs or college savings plans) generally have no taxable
income inclusions from earnings on assets held in the programs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Sec. 529(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To be treated as a qualified tuition program that is
generally exempt from Federal income taxation, a program must
satisfy several requirements. The program must provide that
purchases of tuition credits or certificates or contributions
to a program must be made only in cash.\7\ The program must
provide separate accounting for each designated beneficiary.\8\
The program must provide that a contributor to, or a designated
beneficiary under, the program may direct the investment of any
contributions to the program (or earnings on those investments)
no more than twice a year.\9\ The program must not allow any
interest in the program to be used as a security for a
loan.\10\ The program must provide adequate safeguards to
prevent contributions on behalf of a designated beneficiary
that exceed the amount necessary to pay the beneficiary's
qualified higher education expenses.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Sec. 529(b)(2).
\8\Sec. 529(b)(3).
\9\Sec. 529(b)(4).
\10\Sec. 529(b)(5).
\11\Sec. 529(b)(6).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When there is a cash distribution under a qualified tuition
program, the portion of the distribution that is considered to
be earnings on contributions to the account is includible in
the gross income of the recipient of the distributions only to
the extent that the total amount of cash distributions during
the taxable year exceeds the amount of qualified higher
education expenses of the account beneficiary during that
year.\12\ The income tax that is imposed on a recipient of a
distribution that is included in the recipient's gross income
is, with certain exceptions, increased by 10 percent of the
amount of the inclusion.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Sec. 529(c)(3)(A), (B)(ii). A payor of a distribution generally
is required to report to the IRS and the recipient of the distribution
on Form 1099-Q the amount of the distribution and the portions of the
distributions representing contributions and earnings.
\13\Sec. 529(c)(6).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Qualified higher education expenses
Qualified higher education expenses include, among other
expenses, tuition, fees, books, supplies, and equipment
required for the enrollment or attendance of the account
beneficiary at an eligible educational institution (generally,
a postsecondary school); expenses for special needs services in
the case of a special needs beneficiary that are incurred in
connection with the beneficiary's enrollment or attendance at
an eligible educational institution; expenses for the purchase
of computer equipment and software to be used primarily by the
beneficiary when enrolled at an eligible educational
institution; and, in the case of a beneficiary who is at least
a half-time student, reasonable costs for room and board while
the beneficiary is attending an eligible educational
institution.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Sec. 529(e)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For certain purposes of section 529 (such as the exclusion
from gross income for distributions from a qualified tuition
program to pay qualified higher education expenses) but not for
other purposes of section 529 (such as the requirement that a
qualified tuition program must provide safeguards to prevent
contributions on behalf of a beneficiary that exceed the amount
necessary to pay the beneficiary's qualified higher education
expenses), qualified higher education expenses also include
expenses for tuition in connection with enrollment or
attendance at an elementary or secondary public, private, or
religious school;\15\ amounts for books, supplies, and
equipment required for the participation of a beneficiary in an
apprenticeship program registered and certified with the
Secretary of Labor under section 1 of the National
Apprenticeship Act (29 U.S. Code section 50);\16\ and up to a
$10,000 lifetime maximum in payments of principal and interest
on a beneficiary's (or a beneficiary's sibling's) student
loan.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Sec. 529(c)(7). There is a $10,000 limitation on the total
amount of nontaxable cash distributions that may be made in a taxable
year from all qualified tuition programs with respect to a beneficiary
to pay for that beneficiary's elementary or secondary school tuition.
Sec. 529(e)(3)(A).
\16\Sec. 529(c)(8).
\17\Sec. 529(c)(9).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Certain rules for contributions and distributions
A contribution to a qualified tuition program is treated as
a completed gift for gift tax purposes (and, as a consequence,
may benefit from the gift tax annual exclusion).\18\ If an
individual's total contributions to a qualified tuition program
during a year exceed the gift tax annual exclusion amount in
that year, the individual may elect to take the total amount of
the contributions into account for purposes of the annual
exclusion ratably over the five-year period beginning with the
year of the excess contributions.\19\ An individual's interest
in a qualified tuition program generally is excluded from the
individual's gross estate for estate tax purposes.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Sec. 529(c)(2)(A).
\19\Sec. 529(c)(2)(B).
\20\Sec. 529(c)(4)(A).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A distribution from a qualified tuition program that
otherwise would be included in the income of the recipient of
the distribution (for example, the beneficiary of the account)
may be excluded under rules allowing, subject to limitations,
tax-free rollovers to, among other alternatives, an ABLE
account of the beneficiary or of a member of the family of the
beneficiary, a Roth IRA of the beneficiary, or the credit of
another beneficiary of a qualified tuition program who is a
member of the family of the beneficiary with respect to whom
the distribution was made.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Sec. 529(c)(3)(C), (E).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
REASONS FOR CHANGE
The Committee believes that the Code should give taxpayers
the same incentive to save for education or skills-building
whether the education or skills-building consists of a
traditional four-year college or university, job-related
credentialing programs, or public or private schooling or
homeschooling at the elementary and secondary levels.
Specifically, as it relates to elementary and secondary
education, the Committee believes that the tax code should
provide parents with the ability to seek the education that
best suits their child. Present law, however, restricts
favorable tax treatment under section 529 chiefly to saving for
a traditional four-year college or university education.
EXPLANATION OF PROVISION
Additional elementary, secondary, and home school expenses
treated as qualified higher education expenses for all
purposes of section 529
The provision provides that the following expenses in
connection with the enrollment or attendance of a designated
beneficiary at an elementary or secondary public, private, or
religious school, or in connection with a homeschool, are
qualified higher education expenses: tuition (as under present
law), curriculum and curricular materials, books or other
instructional materials, online educational materials, tuition
for certain tutoring or educational classes outside of the
home, fees for certain tests, fees for dual enrollment in an
institution of higher education, and certain educational
therapies for students with disabilities.
Under the provision, these elementary and secondary school
expenses are considered qualified higher education expenses for
all purposes of section 529, including the requirement that a
qualified tuition program must provide safeguards to prevent
contributions on behalf of a beneficiary that exceed the amount
necessary to pay the beneficiary's qualified higher education
expenses.
Certain postsecondary credentialing expenses treated as qualified
higher education expenses for all purposes of section 529
The provision treats a broad category of postsecondary
credentialing expenses as qualified higher education expenses
for all purposes of section 529. These ``qualified
postsecondary credentialing expenses'' are tuition, fees,
books, supplies, and equipment required for the enrollment or
attendance of a designated beneficiary in a recognized
``postsecondary credential program,'' or any other expense in
connection with enrollment in or attendance at such a program
if such expenses would, if incurred in connection with
enrollment in or attendance at an eligible educational
institution, be considered qualified higher education expenses
before application of the proposal; fees for testing required
to obtain or maintain a recognized postsecondary credential;
and fees for continuing education if such education is required
to maintain a recognized postsecondary credential.
For this purpose, a ``recognized postsecondary credential
program'' means a program to obtain a recognized postsecondary
credential if (a) such program is included on a list prepared
under section 122(d) of the Workforce Innovation and
Opportunity Act; (b) such program is listed in the Web Enabled
Approval Management System (``WEAMS'') Public directory (or a
successor directory) maintained by the Department of Veterans
Affairs; (c) an examination (developed or administered by an
organization widely recognized as providing reputable
credentials in the occupation) is required to obtain or
maintain a postsecondary credential and the organization
recognizes the program as providing training or education that
prepares individuals to take the examination; or (d) such
program is identified by the Secretary of the Treasury, after
consultation with the Secretary of Labor, as being a reputable
program for obtaining a recognized postsecondary
credential.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\The WEAMS Public directory is a publicly-available, Internet-
based search tool for identifying educational institutions that offer
programs approved for veterans training.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A ``recognized postsecondary credential'' means any
postsecondary employment credential that is industry
recognized, any certificate of completion of an apprenticeship
that is registered and certified with the Secretary of Labor
under the National Apprenticeship Act, any occupational or
professional license issued or recognized by a State or the
Federal government, and any recognized postsecondary credential
as defined under section 3 of the Workforce Innovation and
Opportunity Act (29 U.S. Code section 3102).\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Under the proposal, a postsecondary employment credential that
is industry recognized includes (i) any postsecondary employment
credential issued by a program that is accredited by the Institute for
Credentialing Excellence, the National Commission on Certifying
Agencies, or the American National Standards Institute, (ii) any
postsecondary employment credential that is included in the
Credentialing Opportunities On-Line (``COOL'') directory of
credentialing programs (or successor directory) maintained by the
Department of Defense or by any branch of the Armed Services, and (iii)
any postsecondary employment credential identified for purposes of this
clause by the Secretary of the Treasury, after consultation with the
Secretary of Labor, as being industry recognized.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EFFECTIVE DATE
The provision is effective for distributions made after the
date of enactment.
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE
In compliance with the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the following statement is made concerning the
vote of the Committee on Ways and Means during the markup
consideration of H.R. 8915, the ``Education and Workforce
Freedom Act,'' on July 9, 2024.
The vote on the amendment offered by Mr. Doggett to the
amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R. 8915, which
would provide that any distribution from a 529 with respect to
homeschool expenses is subject to Federal income tax if the
distribute, or anyone who can claim the distribute as a
dependent on their Federal income tax return, has adjusted
gross income in excess of $1,000,000 for the taxable year in
which the distribution occurred was not agreed to by a roll
call vote of 14 yeas to 22 nays (with a quorum being present).
The vote was as follows:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Yea Nay Present Representative Yea Nay Present
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Smith (MO)..................... ...... X ......... Mr. Neal............. X ...... .........
Mr. Buchanan....................... ...... ...... ......... Mr. Doggett.......... X ...... .........
Mr. Smith (NE)..................... ...... X ......... Mr. Thompson......... X ...... .........
Mr. Kelly.......................... ...... X ......... Mr. Larson........... X ...... .........
Mr. Schweikert..................... ...... X ......... Mr. Blumenauer....... X ...... .........
Mr. LaHood......................... ...... ...... ......... Mr. Pascrell......... X ...... .........
Dr. Wenstrup....................... ...... X ......... Mr. Davis............ ...... ...... .........
Mr. Arrington...................... ...... X ......... Ms. Sanchez.......... ...... ...... .........
Dr. Ferguson....................... ...... X ......... Ms. Sewell........... X ...... .........
Mr. Estes.......................... ...... X ......... Ms. DelBene.......... X ...... .........
Mr. Smucker........................ ...... X ......... Ms. Chu.............. X ...... .........
Mr. Hern........................... ...... X ......... Ms. Moore............ ...... ...... .........
Ms. Miller......................... ...... ...... ......... Mr. Kildee........... X ...... .........
Dr. Murphy......................... ...... X ......... Mr. Beyer............ X ...... .........
Mr. Kustoff........................ ...... X ......... Mr. Evans............ ...... ...... .........
Mr. Fitzpatrick.................... ...... X ......... Mr. Schneider........ X ...... .........
Mr. Steube......................... ...... X ......... Mr. Panetta.......... X ...... .........
Ms. Tenney......................... ...... X ......... Mr. Gomez............ X ...... .........
Mrs. Fischbach..................... ...... X .........
Mr. Moore.......................... ...... X .........
Mrs. Steel......................... ...... X .........
Ms. Van Duyne...................... ...... X .........
Mr. Feenstra....................... ...... X .........
Ms. Malliotakis.................... ...... X .........
Mr. Carey.......................... ...... X .........
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
In compliance with clause 3(d) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the following statement is made
concerning the effects on the budget
Dissenting Views
529s began as a way to help upper-income families pay for
the soaring cost of higher education. Like many of those
families with professional incomes, my wife and I, together
with their parents, have made 529 contributions for our
grandchildren with the goal of enabling them to obtain all of
their education for which they're willing to work for, debt-
free. But most Americans do not have the disposable income to
set aside thousands of dollars in order to take advantage of
this government tax subsidy. The question that we have here
today is a frequent one before this committee: should we do
more to help those who already have, or should we help those
who have not but want the same opportunities for their children
and their grandchildren that I want for my family?
The same members of this committee who repeatedly insist
that we cannot afford new investments for our public schools
are the same ones demanding that this bill provide more
subsidies for prosperous families. Through the 2017 Trump tax
scam, Republicans exploited 529s, originally designed for
higher education, to subsidize a parallel education system by
including pre-college private academy tuition.
Now each year, an estimated $1 billion in otherwise taxable
revenue is directed to private schools and out of our public
school system. Half of all the money that is in 529 accounts
was held by households with an annual income each year in
excess of $437,000. Data obtained yesterday from the Joint
Committee on Taxation by my colleague Mr. Davis shows that two-
thirds of distributions from 529 accounts are attributable to
families earning over $200,00 per year. However, just fifteen
percent of payments from 529 accounts are attributable to those
earning $100,000 or less.
This is not surprising when you consider the fact that many
Americans who want their children to be able to go to college
or use a 529 are paying off their own student loans and they
don't have a considerable amount of discretionary income to put
into a 529. All over this country our schools are suffering,
particularly in a state with a sorry history of funding for its
public schools, like Texas, which is suffering from inadequate
school budgets. Students need additional and greater Pell
grants to cover the cost of a college education. That is where
I think we should be focusing our attention.
The New York Times conducted a study a couple of years ago
that pointed out what's really behind the movement for 529s. It
found that people with hundreds of thousands of dollars to
spare can create 529 accounts that will end up holding millions
of dollars. These are the so-called ``Dynasty 529s.'' Wealthy
individuals can front-load large 529 deposits in such a way
that the accounts can pay for several college education decades
from now and still have money left over for other family
members pursuing higher education in future generations. It's
all legal, and by jumping through a few modest hoops, it is
generally tax free on a per-saver, per-student basis. It is the
wealthy who have the best opportunity to extract the largest
breaks from the federal government when it comes to saving and
paying for college.
Today's bill is just expanding that a little further,
covering more, and allowing for more of this kind of treatment
of those who have but not those who want to provide a first
time, first-generation student with an opportunity.
Finally, it's important to look at the credentialing
section of this bill. You'd think it's all about getting a
plumber or a contractor licensed, but the way it is written, a
corporate lawyer who wants to take a Mediterranean cruise and
get a little continuing legal education along the way or a
physician who wants to ski in Aspen and get a little continuing
medical education can finance that all out of this tax-
advantaged account the way Republicans are proposing to set it
up. This is not about helping the little guy. This is not about
helping the families that are struggling to advance in our
society. It is about widening the gap between those who have
and those who have not.
Lloyd Doggett,
Member of Congress.
[all]