Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 8235]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Ways and Means, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 8235) to amend title XVIII of the Social Security
Act to modify the distribution of certain additional graduate
medical education positions under the Medicare program, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND........................................... 2
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 2
B. Background and Need for Legislation................. 2
C. Legislative History................................. 3
Background....................................... 3
Committee Hearings............................... 3
Committee Action................................. 3
D. Designated Hearing.................................. 3
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL.......................................... 4
A. Reasons for Change.................................. 4
B. Explanation of Provisions........................... 4
C. Effective Date...................................... 4
III. VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE........................................... 4
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL....................................... 5
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects............. 5
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax
Expenditures Budget Authority...................... 5
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office............................................. 5
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE....... 9
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations.... 9
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and
Objectives......................................... 9
C. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates........... 9
D. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and
Limited Tariff Benefits............................ 10
E. Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 10
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED........... 10
VII. DISSENTING VIEWS............................................... 141
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Rural Physician Workforce Preservation
Act''.
SEC. 2. MODIFYING THE DISTRIBUTION OF CERTAIN ADDITIONAL GRADUATE
MEDICAL EDUCATION POSITIONS UNDER THE MEDICARE
PROGRAM.
Section 1886(h) of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 1395ww(h)) is
amended--
(1) in paragraph (9)--
(A) in subparagraph (B)(ii)(I), by amending such
subclause to read as follows:
``(I) Hospitals that--
``(aa) are located in a rural
area (as defined in section
1886(d)(2)(D)); or
``(bb) are treated as being
located in a rural area
pursuant to section
1886(d)(8)(E), but only if such
hospital so treated meets a
criterion specified in
subclause (I) or (II) of clause
(ii) of such section.''; and
(B) in subparagraph (F)(ii), by inserting ``and
includes, with respect to the distribution of full-time
equivalent residency positions for fiscal year 2023 or
2024, a hospital that is treated as being located in a
rural area pursuant to section 1886(d)(8)(E) regardless
of whether such hospital meets a criterion specified in
subclause (I) or (II) of clause (ii) of such section''
before the period; and
(2) in paragraph (10)(B)(ii)(I), by amending such subclause
to read as follows:
``(I) Hospitals that--
``(aa) are located in a rural
area (as defined in section
1886(d)(2)(D)); or
``(bb) are treated as being
located in a rural area
pursuant to section
1886(d)(8)(E), but only if such
hospital so treated meets a
criterion specified in
subclause (I) or (II) of clause
(ii) of such section.''.
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
The purpose of this bill is to ensure certain graduate
medical education slots are allocated to truly rural teaching
hospitals.
B. Background and Need for Legislation
The federal government supports education and training of
physicians in multiple ways. Most notably, Medicare has
supported the graduate medical education (GME) program since
its enactment in 1965. Medicare's GME payments are based on a
number of factors and rely on complicated formulae, but are
generally meant to account for the direct and indirect costs of
training new physicians. Medicare's GME support was initially
open-ended, but the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 limited the
number of Medicare-funded GME slots to the number of residents
a hospital had in 1996.
Such caps remained in place until the Consolidated
Appropriations Act of 2021 granted 1,000 new GME slots,
followed by the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 which
granted an additional 200 GME slots to be distributed above the
current caps. These new 1,200 caps were legislatively set to be
distributed, in part, according to a specific formula where 10
percent of the slots were to go to hospitals meeting each of
the following criteria: hospitals located in rural areas or
treated as being in a rural area; hospitals training residents
above their current Medicare GEM cap; hospitals located in
states with new medical schools; and hospitals training in
Health Professional Shortage Areas.
Concerningly, after the first few rounds of distributions,
there has been a stray from Congressional intent in slot
allocation. For example, as of May 2024, 93 allocated slots
were attributed to going to ``rural'' hospitals, but in
reality, only 12 of those slots went to truly geographically
rural hospitals while 81 slots went to hospitals who
reclassified to be ``treated as rural''.
There is a clear need for investment in physicians in rural
areas. 91 percent of rural communities face health care
workforce shortages, and 65 percent of rural areas have a
shortage of primary care physicians. The number of medical
school entrants from rural areas declined by 28 percent from
2002-2017. Research shows that family medicine residents who
train in a rural area are six times more likely to practice
medicine in rural areas, yet less than 10 percent of residents
experience any rural training. Additionally, students from
rural backgrounds are 10 times more likely to prefer to work in
rural areas, but the number of physician residents from rural
areas has declined to fewer than 5 percent.
C. Legislative History
Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 8235, the
Rural Physician Workforce Preservation Act, on May 8, 2024, and
favorably reported the bill, as amended, to the House of
Representatives (with quorum being present).
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearing was used to develop and consider H.R. 8235:
``Hearing with Health and Human Services Secretary
Becerra'' on March 20, 2024.
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. Reasons for Change
The Committee on Ways and Means' reason for change is to
ensure certain graduate medical education slots are allocated
to truly rural teaching hospitals.
B. Explanation of Provisions
Section 1. Short title
Establishes the bill's short title as the Rural Physician
Workforce Preservation Act.
Section 2. Modifying the distribution of certain additional graduate
medical education positions under the Medicare program
This section ensures that 10 percent of the Medicare-funded
graduate medical education (GME) slots under the Consolidated
Appropriations Act, 2021 and Consolidated Appropriations Act,
2023 are awarded to geographically rural hospitals.
C. Effective Date
The bill would become effective on the date of enactment.
III. VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE
In compliance with the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the following statement is made concerning the
vote of the Committee on Ways and Means during the markup
consideration of H.R. 8235, the ``Rural Physician Workforce
Preservation Act,'' on May 8, 2024.
H.R. 8235 was ordered favorably reported to the House of
Representatives as amended by a roll call vote of 24 yeas to 16
nays (with a quorum being present). The vote was as follows:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Yea Nay Present Representative Yea Nay Present
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Smith (MO)..................... X ...... ......... Mr. Neal............. ...... X .........
Mr. Buchanan....................... X ...... ......... Mr. Doggett.......... ...... ...... .........
Mr. Smith (NE)..................... X ...... ......... Mr. Thompson......... ...... X .........
Mr. Kelly.......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Larson........... ...... X .........
Mr. Schweikert..................... X ...... ......... Mr. Blumenauer....... ...... X .........
Mr. LaHood......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Pascrell......... ...... X .........
Dr. Wenstrup....................... X ...... ......... Mr. Davis............ ...... X .........
Mr. Arrington...................... X ...... ......... Ms. Sanchez.......... ...... X .........
Dr. Ferguson....................... X ...... ......... Ms. Sewell........... ...... X .........
Mr. Estes.......................... X ...... ......... Ms. DelBene.......... ...... X .........
Mr. Smucker........................ X ...... ......... Ms. Chu.............. ...... X .........
Mr. Hern........................... X ...... ......... Ms. Moore............ ...... X .........
Ms. Miller......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Kildee........... ...... X .........
Dr. Murphy......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Beyer............ ...... X .........
Mr. Kustoff........................ X ...... ......... Mr. Evans............ ...... ...... .........
Mr. Fitzpatrick.................... X ...... ......... Mr. Schneider........ ...... X .........
Mr. Steube......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Panetta.......... ...... X .........
Ms. Tenney......................... X ...... ......... Mr. Gomez............ ...... X .........
Mrs. Fischbach..................... X ...... .........
Mr. Moore.......................... X ...... .........
Mrs. Steel......................... X ...... .........
Ms. Van Duyne...................... X ...... .........
Mr. Feenstra....................... X ...... .........
Ms. Malliotakis.................... X ...... .........
Mr. Carey.......................... X ...... .........
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IV. BUDGET EFFECTS OF THE BILL
A. Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
With respect to clause 3(d) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the following statement is made
concerning the effects on the budget of the bill, H.R. 8235, as
reported. The estimate prepared by the Congressional Budget
Office is included below.
B. Statement Regarding New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures Budget
Authority
In compliance with clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee states that the
bill involved no new or increased budget authority. The
Committee states further that the bill involves no new or
increased tax expenditures.
C. Cost Estimate Prepared by the Congressional Budget Office
In compliance with clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, requiring a cost estimate
prepared by the CBO, the following statement by CBO is
provided.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Summary of legislation: The House Committee on Ways and
Means marked up a total of 10 bills on May 8, 2024, and on June
27, 2024. This document provides estimates for six of those
bills.
Generally, the bills would:
Modify Medicare's payment policy with respect to
ambulances and hospitals that operate in rural areas,
Provide Medicare-funded graduate medical education
slots at rural hospitals,
Reinstate nursing certification programs at
facilities that had previously lost the ability to operate
those programs,
Establish a Medicare pilot program to award grants
to rural hospitals,
Revise the definition of ``rural emergency
hospital'' under Medicare, and
Expand Medicare coverage for the home infusion of
drugs.
Estimated Federal cost: Three of the bills would affect
direct spending; the estimated effects are shown in Table 1.
The costs fall within budget function 570 (Medicare).
TABLE 1.--ESTIMATED EFFECTS ON DIRECT SPENDING OF MEDICARE LEGISLATION, AS ORDERED REPORTED BY THE HOUSE COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS ON MAY 8, 2024 AND
JUNE 27, 2024
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By fiscal year, millions of dollars--
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2025-2029 2025-2034
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
INCREASES OR DECREASES (-) IN DIRECT SPENDING
H.R. 7931:
Budget Authority.................................. 1 3 4 5 6 8 9 11 13 14 19 74
Estimated Outlays................................. 1 3 5 5 6 8 9 11 13 14 19 74
H.R. 8246:
Budget Authority.................................. 0 29 117 193 284 336 443 551 651 807 623 3,411
Estimated Outlays................................. 0 29 117 193 284 336 443 551 651 807 623 3,411
H.R. 8816:
Budget Authority.................................. 1 -8 -11 -14 -13 -15 -17 -17 -18 -17 -45 -129
Estimated Outlays................................. 1 -8 -11 -14 -12 -15 -17 -18 -18 -17 -45 -129
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Components may not sum to totals because of rounding.
Basis of estimate: For this estimate, CBO assumes that each
bill will be enacted in fiscal year 2025.
Direct spending: CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 8235,
H.R. 8244, and H.R. 8245 would have no effect on direct
spending. CBO estimates that enacting the other three of the
six bills would affect direct spending.
H.R. 7931, the Preserving Emergency Access in Key Sites
Act, would increase Medicare payments for certain rural
ambulance suppliers and hospitals. Payments would rise to 101
percent of what is termed reasonable cost, which is greater
than amounts under current law. CBO estimates that enacting the
bill would increase direct spending by $74 million over the
2025-2034 period and that enacting the bill would not affect
revenues.
H.R. 8246, the Second Chances for Rural Hospitals Act,
would allow critical access hospitals and certain small rural
hospitals that closed between January 1, 2014, and December 26,
2020, to reopen as rural emergency hospitals. Those facilities
would qualify for additional Medicare payments, including
higher reimbursement rates and annual facility payments,
depending on their distance from other hospitals. Based on an
assessment of the number of additional locations that would
become eligible for monthly payments, CBO estimates that
enacting the bill would result in about 6,000 additional
monthly payments to rural emergency hospitals, increasing
Medicare fee-for-service spending by $2 billion. That change
also would increase payments to Medicare Advantage plans. CBO
estimates that enacting H.R. 8246 would increase total direct
spending by $3.4 billion over the 2025-2034 period and that
enacting the bill would not affect revenues.
H.R. 8816, the American Medical Innovation and Investment
Act of 2024, would modify rules for determining national and
local coverage in Medicare's programs and revise certain
Medicare payments and benefits. CBO estimates that enacting the
bill would decrease net direct spending by $129 million over
the 2025-2034 period. The bill would provide $5 million to the
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, which CBO estimates
would increase direct spending by the same amount over the
2025-2034 period to implement changes to the national and local
coverage process. The bill also would expand Medicare coverage
for the home infusion of drugs. CBO estimates that enacting
that provision would reduce direct spending by $134 million
over the 2025-2034 period. The bill also would direct the
Department of Health and Human Services to conduct a four-year
demonstration project offering medically tailored, home-
delivered meals to beneficiaries with heart disease, diabetes,
or other conditions. CBO estimates that enacting the medically
tailored meals demonstration would not significantly affect
direct spending over the 2025-2034 period. CBO estimates that
enacting the bill would not affect revenues.
Spending subject to appropriation: CBO has not completed
estimates of spending subject to appropriation for any of the
bills.
Pay-As-You-Go considerations: The Statutory Pay-As-You-Go
Act of 2010 establishes budget-reporting and enforcement
procedures for legislation affecting direct spending or
revenues. The net changes in outlays for the three bills that
are subject to pay-as-you-go procedures are shown in Table 1.
Increase in long-term net direct spending and deficits: CBO
estimates that enacting H.R. 8246 would increase net direct
spending by more than $2.5 billion in at least one of the four
consecutive 10-year periods beginning in 2035. None of the
other bills, if enacted, would do so.
CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 8246 would increase on-
budget deficits by more than $5 billion in at least one of the
four consecutive 10-year periods beginning in 2025. None of the
other bills, if enacted, would do so.
Mandates: The bill contains no intergovernmental or
private-sector mandates as defined in the Unfunded Mandates
Reform Act.
Previous CBO estimate: On March 13, 2024, CBO transmitted a
cost estimate for H.R. 5397, the Joe Fiandra Access to Home
Infusion Act of 2023, as ordered reported by the House
Committee on Energy and Commerce on December 6, 2023. Section 2
of H.R. 5397 is similar to section 4 of H.R. 8816. Both bills
would expand Medicare coverage for the home infusion of drugs.
Estimate prepared by: Federal Costs: Austin Barselau
(Medicare Advantage and Medicare Part D); Cornelia Hall
(Medicare Part B); Hudson Osgood (Medicare Part B); Lara
Robillard (Medicare Part B); Sarah Sajewski (Medicare Part A);
Julia Sheriff (Medicare Part A); Noah Zwiefel (Medicare
Advantage and Medicare Part D). Mandates: Andrew Laughlin.
Estimate reviewed by: Asha Saavoss, Chief, Health Systems
and Medicare Cost Estimates Unit; Kathleen FitzGerald, Chief,
Public and Private Mandates Unit; Chad Chirico, Director of
Budget Analysis.
Estimate approved by: Phillip L. Swagel, Director,
Congressional Budget Office.
V. OTHER MATTERS TO BE DISCUSSED UNDER THE RULES OF THE HOUSE
A. Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations
With respect to clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the Committee made findings and
recommendations that are reflected in this report.
B. Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
With respect to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, the Committee advises that the
bill does not authority funding, so no statement of general
performance goals and objectives is required.
C. Information Relating to Unfunded Mandates
This information is provided in accordance with section 423
of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (Pub. L. No. 104-
4).
The Committee has determined that the bill does not contain
Federal mandates on the private sector. The Committee has
determined that the bill does not impose a Federal
intergovernmental mandate on State, local, or tribal
governments.
D. Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff
Benefits
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill, and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
E. Duplication of Federal Programs
In compliance with clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes: (1) a
program of the Federal Government known to be duplicative of
another Federal program; (2) a program included in any report
from the Government Accountability Office to Congress pursuant
to section 21 of Public Law 111-139; or (3) a program related
to a program identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal
Domestic Assistance, published pursuant to the Federal Program
Information Act (Pub. L. No. 95-220, as amended by Pub. L. No.
98-169).
VI. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
SOCIAL SECURITY ACT
* * * * * * *
TITLE XVIII--HEALTH INSURANCE FOR THE AGED AND DISABLED
* * * * * * *
Part E--Miscellaneous Provisions
* * * * * * *
payment to hospitals for inpatient hospital services
Sec. 1886. (a)(1)(A)(i) The Secretary, in determining the
amount of the payments that may be made under this title with
respect to operating costs of inpatient hospital services (as
defined in paragraph (4)) shall not recognize as reasonable (in
the efficient delivery of health services) costs for the
provision of such services by a hospital for a cost reporting
period to the extent such costs exceed the applicable
percentage (as determined under clause (ii)) of the average of
such costs for all hospitals in the same grouping as such
hospital for comparable time periods.
(ii) For purposes of clause (i), the applicable percentage
for hospital cost reporting periods beginning--
(I) on or after October 1, 1982, and before October
1, 1983, is 120 percent;
(II) on or after October 1, 1983, and before October
1, 1984, is 115 percent; and
(III) on or after October 1, 1984, is 110 percent.
(B)(i) For purposes of subparagraph (A) the Secretary shall
establish case mix indexes for all short- term hospitals, and
shall set limits for each hospital based upon the general mix
of types of medical cases with respect to which such hospital
provides services for which payment may be made under this
title.
(ii) The Secretary shall set such limits for a cost reporting
period of a hospital--
(I) by updating available data for a previous period
to the immediate preceding cost reporting period by the
estimated average rate of change of hospital costs
industry-wide, and
(II) by projecting for the cost reporting period by
the applicable percentage increase (as defined in
subsection (b)(3)(B)).
(C) The limitation established under subparagraph (A) for any
hospital shall in no event be lower than the allowable
operating costs of inpatient hospital services (as defined in
paragraph (4)) recognized under this title for such hospital
for such hospital's last cost reporting period prior to the
hospital's first cost reporting period for which this section
is in effect.
(D) Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to cost reporting
periods beginning on or after October 1, 1983.
(2) The Secretary shall provide for such exemptions from, and
exceptions and adjustments to, the limitation established under
paragraph (1)(A) as he deems appropriate, including those which
he deems necessary to take into account--
(A) the special needs of sole community hospitals, of
new hospitals, of risk based health maintenance
organ
Dissenting Views
I am disappointed at today's markup. I cannot support any
effort to change the current structure of the law WE passed
that allows both rural hospitals and hospitals that are key in
serving rural residents to qualify for slots under the rural
category.
As the proud champion of the bipartisan Resident Physician
Shortage Reduction Act alongside my colleague Rep. Brian
Fitzpatrick, I am passionate about increasing access to
healthcare professionals in rural communities. As the proud
representative of Alabama's 7th district, which consists of
both rural and underserved urban communities including my
hometown of Selma, Alabama a rural community, I understand the
needs of rural America!
This is why I lead the Resident Physician Shortage
Reduction Act, affectionately known as the GME bill, to boost
the number of training slots and attract more doctors to rural
and underserved communities. The GME bill currently has 175
bipartisan co-sponsors in the House, and includes multiple
categories for ensuring America's most vulnerable hospitals
qualify for the Medicare funded residency slots. The
legislation already prioritizes hospitals in rural areas.
By redefining rural hospitals in the Rural Physician
Workforce Preservation Act, hospitals that serve large
populations of rural patients and wish to train additional
physicians will have a harder time accessing these residency
positions.
This will negatively impact two hospitals in my district.
Jackson Medical Center in Clarke County, Alabama as well as
Druid City Hospital in Tuscaloosa are both hospitals that would
not be able to qualify for slots in the rural category in the
GME program under this bill, making it harder for them to
secure funding to train residents. DCH Hospital, in particular,
is essential to accessing care in West Alabama.
Since the 2020 closure of the Pickens County Medical Center
a rural hospital, DCH as the nearest hospital to the area, sees
a large percentage of patients from Pickens County. Though DCH
would not be classified as a qualified hospital to receive GME
slots, they are tasked with providing care for rural patients
with no current access to care.
While I understand my colleagues' desire to support GME
slots at rural hospitals, this legislation does not resolve the
problem. Because rural facilities are not currently applying
for these slots, the changes made by this bill make it less
likely that the slots--which are only available for a limited
number of years--would get used. This means that the progress
we were intending to make in building the physician workforce
with this provision will be stalled. We all know that we have a
physician shortage. This bill would undermine current efforts
to address it.
If my colleagues would like to increase the number of GME
slots at rural hospitals, they should start by co-sponsoring
the Resident Physician Shortage Reduction Act which ultimately
calls for an additional 14,000 slots to the program! Last
Congress, over 1,000 slots were added to the program, but we
can do better to truly support rural hospitals. We must also
provide more funding and support to rural hospitals, who often
do not apply due to the increasing costs of training residents
at their facilities. Democrats passed a bill that would do just
that--the Pathways program--which provided support to bolster
the physician workforce particularly focusing on rural and
underserved areas and communities. If we want to make true
progress for rural and underserved communities, we would mark
up and pass the Resident Physician Shortage Reduction Act.
Terri A. Sewell.
[all]