Minority Views
JURISDICTION AND FUNCTIONS OF THE COMMITTEE
The Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of
1974 established the Committees on the Budget of the House of
Representatives and the Senate. These Committees are
responsible for developing and reporting the annual concurrent
resolution on the budget (budget resolution), assembling and
reporting any reconciliation legislation required by the budget
resolution, and overseeing the congressional and statutory
budget process.
Once adopted, the budget resolution provides an overall
framework for Congressional consideration of spending, revenue,
and debt limit legislation. It sets a ceiling on total spending
and a floor on total revenues. It also provides an allocation
of spending authority to each committee of Congress, including
the appropriations committees and the various authorizing
committees. The House and Senate enforce the aggregate spending
and revenue levels as well as the committee allocations set by
the budget resolution, through points of order that govern the
consideration of legislation.
The budget resolution may also include the optional
reconciliation process, which directs authorizing committees to
revise programs under their jurisdiction in order to adjust
either projected spending or revenues by specified amounts. If
more than one authorizing committee receives reconciliation
instructions, the Committee on the Budget is responsible for
assembling the legislative policies and recommendations
submitted by the various authorizing committees without any
substantive revision for consideration on the House floor.
When the House of Representatives adopted Rules for the
104th Congress (House Resolution 6) on January 5, 1995, the
Committee on the Budget acquired legislative jurisdiction over
major elements of the congressional budget process and various
statutory controls over the Federal budget. In adopting the
Rules of the House of Representatives for the 105th Congress
(House Resolution 5) on January 7, 1997, the House extended the
Committee on the Budget's legislative jurisdiction to include
not only the congressional budget process but the budget
process in general. The Committee's jurisdictional statement,
clause 1(d) of rule X of the Rules of the House of
Representatives, now reads as follows:
(1) Concurrent resolutions on the budget (as defined
in section 3(4) of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974), other matters required to be referred to the
committee under titles III and IV of that Act, and
other measures setting forth appropriate levels of
budget totals for the United States Government.
(2) Budget process generally.
(3) Establishment, extension, and enforcement of
special controls over the Federal budget, including the
budgetary treatment of off-budget Federal agencies and
measures providing exemption from reduction under any
order issued under part C of the Balanced Budget and
Emergency Deficit Control Act of 1985.
Under its jurisdiction, the Committee on the Budget has
exclusive jurisdiction over both budgetary levels and budgetary
concepts. Under subparagraph (2), the Committee on the Budget
has primary jurisdiction over the budget process, as well as
secondary jurisdiction over purely procedural aspects of the
congressional budget process. Finally, under subparagraph (3),
the Committee on the Budget has exclusive jurisdiction over the
establishment, extension, and enforcement of direct and
discretionary spending limits, pay-go requirements, and other
special budgetary mechanisms to control spending, the deficit,
or the Federal budget, including the sequestration process.
In addition to its legislative duties, the Committee on the
Budget continues to have responsibilities for oversight and
studies. These responsibilities include oversight of the
Congressional Budget Office; study of the outlay effects of
existing and proposed legislation; study of off-budget
entities; study of tax expenditures; and study of proposals to
improve and facilitate the congressional budget process.
Summary of Activities
APPOINTMENT OF THE DIRECTOR OF THE CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
On July 27, 2023, Dr. Phillip Swagel was jointly appointed
by the Speaker of the House of Representatives and the
President pro tempore of the Senate as the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office for the term expiring January 3,
2027. The appointment can be found on page H4061 of the
Congressional Record.
FISCAL YEAR 2024 CONCURRENT RESOLUTION ON THE BUDGET
On September 20, 2023, the Committee on the Budget marked
up the Fiscal Year 2024 Concurrent Resolution on the Budget.
The Fiscal Year 2024 Concurrent Resolution on the Budget was
ordered reported on a vote of 20 ayes to 14 noes.
H.R. 5779, FISCAL COMMISSION ACT OF 2023
On January 18, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up
H.R. 5779, the Fiscal Commission Act of 2023. H.R. 5779
establishes a Fiscal Commission composed of 16 Members and
tasked with identifying policies to improve the United States'
fiscal situation in the medium term and attain a sustainable
debt-to-GDP ratio. The Committee adopted an amendment in the
nature of a substitute. H.R. 5779, as amended, was ordered
reported on a vote of 22 ayes to 12 noes.
H.R. 6952, FISCAL STATE OF THE NATION ACT
On January 18, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up
H.R. 6952, the Fiscal State of the Nation Act. H.R. 6952
requires the House of Representatives and the Senate to conduct
an annual joint meeting to receive a presentation from the
Comptroller General of the United States regarding the
Government Accountability Office's audit of the executive
branch's financial statement and the financial position and
condition of the Federal Government. H.R. 6952 also requires
the concurrent resolution on the budget to include a statement
of findings informed by the joint meeting. H.R. 6952 was
ordered reported by a voice vote.
H.R. 6957, DEBT TO GDP TRANSPARENCY STABILIZATION ACT
On January 18, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up
H.R. 6957, the Debt-to-GDP Transparency and Stabilization Act.
H.R. 6957 requires the President's annual budget submission and
the concurrent resolution on the budget to include the ratio of
the public debt to the estimated gross domestic product (GDP).
H.R. 6957 was ordered reported by a voice vote.
H.R. 766, DR. MICHAEL C. BURGESS PREVENTIVE HEALTH SAVINGS ACT
On February 6, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up
H.R. 766, the Dr. Michael C. Burgess Preventive Health Savings
Act. H.R. 766 requires the Congressional Budget Office (CBO),
upon congressional request, to estimate if proposed legislation
would reduce spending beyond the 10-year budget window through
the use of preventive health and preventive health services. If
CBO determines that the legislation would result in substantial
savings from the use of preventive health and preventive health
services, then CBO must include a description and estimate of
such savings in its projections. The Committee adopted two
amendments. The first was an amendment in the nature of a
substitute offered by Representative Burgess to implement
technical changes regarding who needs to be included on the
request, how the estimate can be used, and the definition of
``preventive health.'' The second amendment offered by Chairman
Arrington changes the short title of the bill. H.R. 766, as
amended, was ordered reported on a vote of 30 ayes to 0 noes.
The Committee on the Budget reported H.R. 766 on March 15,
2024. H.R. 766, as amended, passed the House of Representatives
by voice vote on March 19, 2024. H.R. 766 was received in the
Senate on March 20, 2024.
H.R. 7032, CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE DATA SHARING ACT
On February 6, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up
H.R. 7032, the Congressional Budget Office Data Sharing Act.
H.R. 7032 maintains confidentiality and provides much-needed
clarity to the Congressional Budget Office's (CBO) authority to
access and obtain data from executive branch agencies. H.R.
7032 also requires CBO to submit a report to Congress, one year
after enactment, outlining requests for information from
executive branch agencies and any challenges CBO faced in
accessing the requested information. H.R. 7032 was ordered
reported on a vote of 30 ayes to 0 noes.
The Committee on the Budget reported H.R. 7032 on April 29,
2024. H.R. 7032 passed the House of Representatives by voice
vote on April 29, 2024.
H.R. 7032 passed the Senate by unanimous consent on
September 10, 2024.
H.R. 7032 was signed by the President on September 30,
2024, and became Public Law No: 118-89.
H.R. 5301, ELIMINATE USELESS REPORTS ACT OF 2024
On February 6, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up
H.R. 5301, the Eliminate Useless Reports Act of 2024. H.R. 5301
requires federal agencies to identify outdated, duplicative, or
non-essential reports in their annual budget justifications.
H.R. 5301 also requires federal agencies, in consultation with
the Office of Management and Budget, to provide recommendations
for each listed report about whether it should be sunset,
modified, consolidated, or submitted less frequently in
addition to providing justification for each recommendation,
including the details about the resources used to prepare these
reports and their intended purpose. On February 6, 2024, the
Committee on the Budget ordered reported H.R. 5301 by a voice
vote.
On March 3, 2024, the Committee on Oversight and
Accountability ordered reported H.R. 5301, as amended, on a
vote of 40 ayes to 0 noes.
On November 12, 2024, the House of Representatives passed
H.R. 5301, as amended, by voice vote.
On December 11, 2024, the Senate passed H.R. 5301, without
amendment, by unanimous consent.
FISCAL YEAR 2025 CONCURRENT RESOLUTION ON THE BUDGET
On March 7, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up the
Fiscal Year 2025 Concurrent Resolution on the Budget, House
Concurrent Resolution 117 (118th Congress). The Fiscal Year
2025 Concurrent Resolution on the Budget was reported on a vote
of 19 ayes to 15 noes. The report accompanying House Concurrent
Resolution 117 (118th Congress), House Report 118-568, was
filed on June 27, 2024. This report established allocations of
spending authority to House committees and identified accounts
eligible for advance appropriations.
H.R. 8341, COST ESTIMATES IMPROVEMENT ACT
On May 16, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up H.R.
8341, the Cost Estimates Improvement Act. H.R. 8341 requires
all legislative cost estimates prepared by the Congressional
Budget Office (CBO) and the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT)
to include, to the extent practicable, the costs associated
with servicing the public debt. H.R. 8341 was ordered reported
on a vote of 17 ayes to 7 noes.
H.R. 8195, STRENGTHENING ADMINISTRATIVE PAYGO (SAP) ACT OF 2024
On May 16, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up H.R.
8195. H.R. 8195 strengthens congressional oversight of the
Administrative Pay-As-You-Go Act of 2023 by: (1) requiring the
Director of the Office of Management and Budget to submit any
waiver of Administrative Pay-As-You-Go requirements and an
estimate of the budgetary effects of the covered action to the
Committees on the Budget of the House of Representatives and
the Senate; (2) requiring the Director of the Office of
Management and Budget, for any exemption made, to submit to the
Committees on the Budget of the House of Representatives and
the Senate and the Comptroller General of the United States an
estimate of the budgetary effects of a covered action; (3)
ensuring that covered actions are budget neutral; (4)
clarifying that the threshold for covered actions of at least
$1 billion over ten years or $100 million annually is a
requirement and not an exemption; (5) terminating the sunset
date, making the Administrative Pay-As-You-Go Act of 2023 a
permanent provision; and (6) requiring the President's annual
budget request to include the number of waivers granted in the
prior fiscal year and first quarter of the current fiscal year
in addition to the number of determinations expected to be
submitted during the second, third, and fourth quarters of the
current fiscal year as well as the number of determinations
expected to be submitted in the fiscal year for which the
budget request is submitted. H.R. 8195 was ordered reported on
a vote of 16 ayes to 9 noes.
H.R. 8372, DEBT PER TAXPAYER INFORMATION ACT
On May 16, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up H.R.
8372. The Committee adopted one amendment offered by
Representative Omar. H.R. 8372, as amended, requires the
President's annual budget request and concurrent resolution on
the budget to include estimates per taxpayer of the public debt
and gross debt as well as Federal assets net liabilities and
Federal investment. H.R. 8372 also requires an employee's copy
of their W-2 form to include data on Federal revenues, outlays,
and the deficit in addition to the total gross debt and
estimated debt per taxpayer. H.R. 8372 was ordered reported, as
amended, on a vote of 21 ayes to 4 noes.
H.R. 8342, IMPROPER PAYMENTS TRANSPARENCY ACT
On May 16, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up H.R.
8342. H.R. 8342 requires the President's annual budget
submission to include key data regarding improper payments.
Specifically, H.R. 8342 requires the President's annual budget
submission to include: (1) a description of programs required
to submit improper payment reports; (2) a detailed explanation
of why any improper payments occurred; (3) trends on improper
payments over a three year period; (4) corrective actions
regarding improper payments that are incomplete; and (5) steps
agencies will take to address improper payment issues. H.R.
8342 was ordered reported on a vote of 18 ayes to 7 noes.
H.R. 8343, ENHANCING IMPROPER PAYMENT ACCOUNTABILITY ACT
On May 16, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked up H.R.
8343. H.R. 8343 would (1) designate all new federal spending
programs making more than $100 million in payments annually as
``susceptible to significant improper payments''; (2) subject
these programs to more timely reporting requirements; and (3)
reinstate the requirement that agencies report on antifraud
controls and fraud risk management efforts in annual reports to
Congress. H.R. 8343 would also address data gaps that currently
exist by requiring the President's annual budget submission to
include details on Federal agencies and specific programs that
are noncompliant with reporting requirements. H.R. 8343 was
ordered reported on a vote of 18 ayes to 7 noes.
H.R. 9716, INCREASING BASELINE UPDATES ACT
On September 25, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked
up H.R. 9716. H.R. 9716 would require the Congressional Budget
Office (CBO) to produce at least two baseline updates per year,
including at least one update with economic data. H.R. 9716
also requires the President to provide specific technical data
to Congress by February 1 of each calendar year, including up-
to-date estimates for current year and prior year data, and
credit re-estimates for the current year. H.R. 9716 was ordered
reported on a vote of 32 ayes to 0 noes.
The Committee on the Budget reported H.R. 9716 on December
11, 2024. H.R. 9716 passed the House of Representatives by a
vote of 407 ayes to 0 noes on December 11, 2024.
H.R. 9751, EXECUTIVE ACTION COST TRANSPARENCY ACT
On September 25, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked
up H.R. 9751. H.R. 9751 requires the Congressional Budget
Office (CBO), to the extent practicable, to include in the
baseline and any update to the baseline any judicial action and
any executive action (including any proposed rule, final rule,
executive order, or memorandum). H.R. 9751 also requires, to
the extent practicable, the baseline and any update to also
include a separate table of any judicial action and any
executive action (including any proposed rule, final rule,
executive order, or memorandum) issued on or after the last
baseline or any update with a total cost of at least $50
billion over the budget window. H.R. 9751 stipulates that any
proposed action shall be assumed final for purposes of
determining whether it is included in the separate table and
shall be included consistent with the scorekeeping guidelines
determined under the Balanced Budget and Emergency Deficit
Control Act of 1985. H.R. 9751 was ordered reported on a vote
of 20 ayes to 12 noes.
H.R. 9714, CBO OVERSIGHT ACT
On September 25, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked
up H.R. 9714. H.R. 9714 mandates, at the request of the
Chairman of the House or Senate Committee on the Budget, that
the Director of the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) testify
at least twice a year before both the House and Senate
Committees on the Budget. The hearings will be held at the
discretion of the Committees, but must take place before the
end of the calendar year, and may address any issue the
Committees deem appropriate, including a review of the accuracy
of baseline projections and estimates made by CBO during the
previous fiscal year. H.R. 9714 was ordered reported on a vote
of 21 ayes to 12 noes.
H.R. 9711, CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE SCHEDULING REFORM ACT
On September 25, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked
up H.R. 9711. H.R. 9711 requires that the Congressional Budget
Office (CBO) create a release schedule to be published no later
than December 31 annually, listing the estimated dates on which
CBO will make available major recurring reports, including at a
minimum the baseline for the budget year and subsequent
updates, the report on options to reduce the deficit, the
report on accuracy of budgetary projections for the most
recently completed fiscal year, and the report on programs or
activities with unauthorized appropriations. H.R. 9711 also
requires CBO to update the schedule as the Director deems
necessary. H.R. 9711 was ordered reported on a vote of 21 ayes
to 12 noes.
H.R. 8068, STOP THE BASELINE BLOAT ACT OF 2024
On September 25, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked
up H.R. 8068. H.R. 8068 excludes appropriations designated as
an ``emergency requirement'' or any resources provided under
supplemental appropriations laws from the Congressional Budget
Office's (CBO's) baseline projections. The Committee on the
Budget agreed to a technical amendment by unanimous consent,
which corrected a parenthetical reference in the introduced
bill. H.R. 8068, as amended, was ordered reported on a vote of
20 ayes to 13 noes.
H.R. 9686, HEALTH PANEL ACT
On September 25, 2024, the Committee on the Budget marked
up H.R. 9686. H.R. 9686 codifies the Panel of Health Advisors
within the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). H.R. 9686 also
outlines the duties and priority target areas of the Panel of
Health Advisors, stipulating the Panel shall provide technical
and functional expertise and recommendations to CBO to improve
the Office's studies, analysis, and cost estimates related to
health and health care issues and policies by meeting at least
once annually, issuing an annual report on the Panel's
recommendations to Congress, and outlining priority target
areas for the Panel to focus
Minority Views
----------
Summary Report
Chaos, confusion, and crisis have plagued the House ever
since the Republicans took the Majority in the 118th Congress.
The 118th Congress tumultuously began with the Republicans'
inability to govern, taking 15 votes to elect a Speaker, and
leaving the House Speakerless for four days, only to have that
Speaker ousted 269 days later. This level of inefficiency and
dysfunction has left the House Republican Majority in a league
of its own. Only Democratic defense of everyday Americans
prevented Republicans from making devastating cuts to
healthcare, education, and infrastructure.
House Democrats are focused on affordable health care,
improving the fiscal outlook, expanding access to education,
investing in children and families, supporting our veterans,
and tackling the climate crisis to move the country forward and
improve conditions for American families. Meanwhile Republicans
remain fixated on keeping promises to the wealthy, taking the
economy hostage and the country to the brink of default. Their
unpopular agenda to cut Social Security, Medicare, and other
vital programs while providing tax cuts for the rich and large
corporations stands in stark contrast to Democrats' commitment
to building an economy that works for everyone.
Democrats have shown that by investing in America--rather
than tearing it down--we can create a brighter, more prosperous
future for everyone. Republicans' proposals, on the other hand,
threaten to undermine decades of progress, all while enriching
the wealthiest individuals at the expense of working families.
Unfortunately, Republicans have chosen reckless
brinkmanship over responsible governance this Congress.
Republicans advocate for unpaid-for tax cuts that
overwhelmingly benefit the wealthy and would add trillions to
the national debt and further deprive our economy of critical
revenue. Then citing phony deficit concerns, Republicans demand
cuts to vital programs that keep our communities safe and
support American families. House Democrats remain steadfast in
their commitment to creating more jobs, lowering costs,
protecting Social Security and Medicare, and safeguarding
essential lifelines from Republican cuts.
IRRESPONSIBLE HYPOCRITICAL REPUBLICAN BUDGET POLICY
In addition to chaos, confusion, and crisis, fiscal
hypocrisy has plagued the House Republican Caucus. House
Resolution 5, ``Adopting the Rules of the House of
Representatives for the One Hundred Eighteenth Congress, and
for other purposes,'' eliminated the House Pay-As-You-Go
(PAYGO) rule, which requires spending increases or revenue cuts
to be offset. Instead, Republicans reverted to their backwards
Cut-As-You-Go (CUTGO) rule to allow deficit-financed tax cuts
and prohibit increased spending--even if it is deficit neutral.
By reinstituting CUTGO, the Republicans' fiscal hypocrisy is on
full display. While Republicans claim fiscal responsibility,
adopting CUTGO reinforces their loyalty to the wealthiest among
us by choosing to prioritize tax cuts over essential
investments in education, healthcare, and infrastructure that
benefit American families.
For the first time since the introduction of the
Congressional Budget Act, the House failed to have enforceable
budgetary levels for the entire Congress. The Republican House
failed to pass a budget resolution or even take the ministerial
act of filing levels in the Congressional Record, as required
by the Fiscal Responsibility Act.
REPUBLICANS FAILED TO FULFILL OVERSIGHT RESPONSIBILITIES
On February 9, 2023, the Committee held a business meeting
to consider and adopt Committee rules and an oversight plan for
the 118th Congress. Republicans disregarded their own Oversight
Plan, failing to hold some of the most basic hearings they
outlined in that plan. The Republicans' Oversight Plan outlined
hearings with the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), Treasury,
Health and Human Services (HHS), and Defense (DoD). This
blatant disregard began in the first session when Republicans
failed to invite the CBO Director to testify before the
Committee in 2023. This neglect continued when the Republicans
failed to hold hearings with Treasury, HHS, or DoD in 2023 or
2024.
The Republicans' Oversight Plan outlined committee activity
to hear testimony from Members on their priorities for the 2024
and 2025 budgets. In an attempt to score political points and
advance their own agenda, the Republicans held a ``Budget
Process Reform Member Day Hearing'' on December 6, 2023.
Unfortunately, the Republicans failed to follow their own
Oversight Plan to hold any Member Day hearings on priorities
for the 2024 or 2025 budgets, effectively freezing out Members
from offering their priorities before the Committee. The
Republicans did not hold any Member Day hearings in 2024. This
is in stark contrast to other years where the Republicans held
the majority. For example, on May 10, 2018, at the Members' Day
hearing, former Chairman Womack stated ``[e]ach year our
Members' Day hearing provides a forum for Members to weigh in
on their legislative priorities for their districts, states,
and, indeed for our country, and to suggest ideas for budget
savings as required by the Congressional Budget Act.'' And in
2017, former Chairman Black stated ``[w]e hold these Member Day
hearings to hear firsthand from our colleagues about their
ideas for the Federal budget, and we welcome those who come to
the committee. This hearing is required by section 301(e)(1) of
the Congressional Budget Act, and its intent is to provide a
forum in which Members can relay their priorities for their
district, their State, and, indeed, for our country.''
Breaching their own Oversight Plan, the Republicans took no
action in this Committee to strengthen Congress' Power of the
Purse. The Oversight Plan, which the Republicans largely
ignored, included a Budget Priorities section laying out plans
to examine Congress' Power of the Purse. While in the Majority,
Democrats held hearings on this important issue in the 116th
Congress (Hearing on Protecting Congress' Power of the Purse
and Rule of Law) and in the 117th Congress (Protecting Our
Democracy: Reasserting Congress' Power of the Purse).
Unfortunately, the Republicans failed to hold any hearings
during the 118th Congress to examine this key issue.
REPUBLICANS' DEVASTATING CUTS HARM AMERICAN FAMILIES
During the 118th Congress, Republicans have pursued an
agenda that would have disastrous consequences for millions of
Americans. Instead of investing in America's future, they are
pushing for massive, indiscriminate cuts to critical programs
that families depend on every day. The scale of these cuts
would be nothing short of devastating. Programs that support
health care, education, veterans' services, and economic
security would be slashed, all while Republicans prioritize
more tax breaks for the ultra-wealthy and big corporations.
The Republican agenda would weaken Social Security and
Medicare--vital programs that provide lifelines to a millions
of seniors--and strip away essential health coverage from
vulnerable families. Veterans' medical care, public education,
infrastructure, and social safety nets would be gutted.
Republicans are even willing to undermine law enforcement
funding, defund programs that protect Americans, and threaten
public safety. These are not just minor budget adjustments--
they are deep, harmful cuts that would leave working families
struggling to make ends meet.
By prioritizing tax handouts to the wealthiest Americans at
the expense of everyone else, Republicans are endangering the
economic security of our nation. Their proposals would worsen
inequality, undermine the middle class, and hollow out the
programs that keep American families strong. While Democrats
are committed to lifting up working families and ensuring that
everyone has a fair shot, Republicans continue to pursue
policies that enrich the wealthy few and abandon the millions
of Americans who rely on government services for their basic
needs.
H.R. 2811, REPUBLICANS' DANGEROUS DEFAULT ON AMERICA ACT
When the United States reached the debt limit, Republicans
recklessly endangered the full faith and credit of our nation
by holding the country hostage with their dangerous and
unpopular MAGA demands and threatening default on the national
debt if those demands were not met. Threatening to not pay
America's bills is not fiscal responsibility--it is a recipe
for economic disaster. The Republicans' dangerous Default on
America Act (DOA), which proposed ten years of destructive
spending caps and the largest single cut to non-defense
programs in American history, was dead on arrival. Budget
Committee Republicans failed to even hold a legislative hearing
or markup for this disastrous bill, exposing their failure to
govern responsibly.
The DOA Act represents one of the most dangerous pieces of
legislation in recent history. This proposal forces an
impossible choice: either Republicans cause the U.S. to default
on its obligations for the first time in history, triggering an
economic catastrophe, or they impose cruel, across-the-board
cuts that will devastate millions of American families. The DOA
Act would have enshrined these cuts into law with severe caps
on nondefense discretionary spending, locking in a decade of
underfunding for critical services that support families,
communities, and economic growth. Programs that Americans rely
on every day, including health care, education, and social
services, would be severely reduced, causing long-term harm to
our most vulnerable citizens.
Republicans used the threat of default as a bargaining
chip, effectively holding the American economy hostage. The
consequences of default would have been devastating--plunging
the economy into recession, causing widespread job losses, and
leading to higher interest rates that would hurt families
trying to buy homes or pay off student loans. The alternative--
Republicans' demanded cuts--would have been profoundly
destructive, leaving families without access to health care,
affordable education, and the support they need to stay afloat.
The cruelty of the DOA Act would not have been limited to
the immediate impact of these cuts. By capping future spending,
Republicans would have ensured that America's most vulnerable
will continue to suffer for years to come. This is not just an
irresponsible way to govern; it is a reckless and dangerous
assault on the wellbeing of American families, all in service
of giving tax breaks to the wealthiest individuals and
corporations.
REPUBLICAN SHUTDOWN THREATS, EXTREME CONTINUING RESOLUTION, AND HARMFUL
REPUBLICAN BUDGET RESOLUTIONS
Republican Failure to Pass Appropriations
As soon as the ink was dry on the bipartisan budget
agreement House Republicans reached with President Biden,
Republicans broke the agreement and catered to the extreme MAGA
wing of their caucus by moving appropriations bills that would
have made devastating cuts to non-defense spending. However,
Republicans spent months internally fighting over these bills
and barely came to any legislative agreements. For fiscal year
2024, Republicans only managed to send half of their individual
appropriations bills to the Senate. For fiscal year 2025,
Republicans somehow managed to do worse and only sent a third
of individual appropriations bills to the Senate.
Extreme Republican Continuing Resolution
Despite the looming debt limit crisis, Republicans pushed
an extreme continuing resolution that included steep cuts to
critical government programs. This extreme continuing
resolution was ultimately voted down. In a last minute
scramble, just hours before a shutdown, Republicans finally
conceded to what House Democrats, Senate Democrats, and Senate
Republicans had been advocating all along: passing a clean
continuing resolution to keep the government running. This
situation could have been avoided if Republicans honored the
bipartisan budget agreement they reached with President Biden
months earlier. Instead, they chose to gamble and go down-to-
the-wire forcing chaos on the entire nation, dragging the
country to the brink of default and risking a government
shutdown. Republicans have repeatedly shown they are willing to
jeopardize the welfare of all Americans to advance their
extreme agenda, proving their inability to govern responsibly.
Harmful 2024 Republican Study Committee Budget
The extreme 2024 Republican Study Committee Budget is a
direct attack on Social Security, Medicare, and critical
investments for hard-working Americans. This draconian budget,
supported by more than 80 percent of Republicans, calls for
raising the Social Security retirement age, increasing health
care costs for families, and slashing taxes for the wealthiest
Americans. Instead of working in a bipartisan way to find
solutions for Social Security solvency, Republicans have
neglected options that would support and contribute to
solvency. Republicans have continuously `pushed back' on
raising the $168,600 wage cap subject to payroll taxes.
Instead, they propose in the RSC budget to adjust calculation
for future payments that would result in lower benefit amounts
for future beneficiaries. These efforts reveal Republicans'
longstanding agenda to cut, privatize, and end Social Security
as we know it, leaving millions of Americans vulnerable.
2024 Harmful Republican Budget Resolution
Just ten days before a potential government shutdown,
Republicans marked up a budget resolution that included
hundreds of billions in Medicare cuts and drastic reductions to
Medicaid. Cuts of this magnitude would be devastating to
American families and strip away essential healthcare and
support services. During the markup, Democrats worked
tirelessly to restore budget levels to what was already agreed
upon in the bipartisan budget agreement. Democrats offered 15
amendments that would have protected funding for education,
health, and law enforcement, respecting the commitments made to
the American people. But Republicans rejected every one of
these reasonable amendments, choosing instead to press forward
with an extreme budget that prioritizes the wealthiest
Americans over working families.
This extreme 2024 Republican budget resolution reneged on
the bipartisan budget agreement, pushing America toward the
brink of a shutdown with reckless and harmful cuts. This budget
once again favored the wealthy at the expense of the middle
class and put American families at risk. Instead of addressing
immediate funding needs, Republicans wasted time, holding a
markup to simply check off a box, on a partisan budget scheme.
Republicans failed to file a committee report for this budget
resolution and the House never considered it on the floor,
confirming that this was a hollow exercise rather than a
genuine effort to budget and govern.
2025 Harmful Republican Budget Resolution
The 2025 Republican budget is an assault on core American
values, stripping critical funding for healthcare, education,
food assistance, and countless other programs that millions of
Americans rely on. This proposal slashes Medicaid, targets food
aid, and jeopardizes essential support programs--all while
paving the way to extend tax cuts primarily benefiting the top
1 percent. The budget prioritizes the wealthy at the expense of
working families and working individuals, neglecting real needs
for safe communities, affordable healthcare, and a quality
education. Demonstrating how unserious their budget was,
Republicans did not even wait for fiscal year 2024
appropriations to be finished before marking up the budget.
At the markup, Democrats offered 11 amendments to safeguard
crucial funding, preserve Social Security and Medicare, and
protect the climate investments made through the Inflation
Reduction Act. These amendments aimed to shield working
families from sweeping Republican cuts and prevent a rollback
on the progress made under President Biden's Administration.
Every single amendment was rejected by Republicans,
underscoring the extreme and partisan nature of their plan.
Even after trillions of dollars in cuts to programs helping
those most in need, the Republican budget still fails to
balance. To pretend to reduce the deficit, this budget relies
on inflated, unsound economic growth projections, conveniently
ignoring the nonpartisan forecasts from CBO. It also includes
gimmicks that pretend that trillions of dollars in tax cuts for
the rich will not have any cost (Democrats offered and
Republicans rejected an amendment that would have prevented any
new tax cuts that increase the deficit). The result is a
misguided fiscal vision that shifts the burden onto middle-
class families while favoring billionaires and corporations.
The contrast could not be starker. Democrats rejected this
backwards-looking budget and its misplaced priorities. More
than ever, Democrats remain committed to an agenda that invests
in American families, protects critical services, and builds on
the progress achieved over the last three years.
REPUBLICAN MICROMANAGEMENT AND POLITICALIZATION OF CBO
In the 118th Congress, Republicans have introduced a wave
of measures targeting CBO under the guise of ``reform.''
However, these proposals range from redundant to harmful,
collectively signaling an effort to politicize and micromanage
this vital, nonpartisan office. Rather than offering meaningful
solutions to improve budget accountability or address systemic
issues in the budgeting process, Republicans created a
``reform'' working group that only has Republican members and
has consistently put forth superficial reforms.
Despite claims to improve transparency, many of these so-
called reforms appear to serve partisan goals, pressuring CBO
to align more closely with Republican priorities. This approach
places undue restrictions on an institution that, by design,
serves in a nonpartisan role for Congress on budgetary matters.
By attempting to control CBO's functions and selectively
questioning its methodologies, Republicans are using bills to
manufacture problems where none exist, casting doubt on CBO's
objectivity without providing any substantial benefit to the
budget process.
In contrast, Democrats have consistently defended CBO's
independence and vital role in Congress. During the markup on
September 25, 2024, Democrats opposed these partisan bills,
underscoring the need for a nonpartisan CBO that provides
unbiased fiscal analysis and budget projections. Rather than
proposing unnecessary micromanagement, Democrats continue to
champion CBO's essential role as a neutral body and resist
attempts to politicize its functions, respecting its
independence and recognizing its longstanding tradition of
aiding Congress in a nonpartisan manner.
H.R. 8068, Stop the Baseline Bloat Act (Grothman (R-WI))
9/25/24, Reported out by roll call vote: 29-13
Democrats opposed H.R. 8068. We agree with Chairman
Arrington's comments during the markup that ``we should budget
for emergencies.'' This is precisely the purpose of emergency
spending in the baseline. Its treatment in the baseline is
specified in current law and is consistent with how other
discretionary appropriations are reflected. While specific
emergency needs