Minority Views
Introduction
The Committee on House Administration (``Committee'')
oversees the daily operations of the House of Representatives
and federal elections.
Per rule X, clause 1 of the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the Committee has the following jurisdiction:
(k) Committee on House Administration.
(1) Appropriations from accounts for committee
salaries and expenses (except for the Committee on
Appropriations); House Information Resources; and
allowance and expenses of Members, Delegates, the
Resident Commissioner, officers, and administrative
offices of the House.
(2) Auditing and settling of all accounts described
in subparagraph (1).
(3) Employment of persons by the House, including
staff for Members, Delegates, the Resident
Commissioner, and committees; and reporters of debates,
subject to rule VI.
(4) Except as provided in paragraph (r)(11), the
Library of Congress, including management thereof; the
House Library; statuary and pictures, acceptance or
purchase of works of art for the Capitol; the Botanic
Garden; and purchase of books and manuscripts.
(5) The Smithsonian Institution and the incorporation
of similar institutions (except as provided in
paragraph (r)(11)).
(6) Expenditure of accounts described in subparagraph
(1).
(7) House Communications Standards Commission.
(8) Printing and correction of the Congressional
Record.
(9) Accounts of the House generally.
(10) Assignment of office space for Members,
Delegates, the resident Commissioner, and committees.
(11) Disposition of useless executive papers.
(12) Election of the President, Vice President,
Members, Senators, Delegates, or the Resident
Commissioner; corrupt practices; contested elections;
credentials and qualifications; and Federal elections
generally.
(13) Services to the House, including the House
Restaurant, parking facilities, and administration of
the House Office Buildings and of the House wing of the
Capitol.
(14) Travel of Members, Delegates, and the Resident
Commissioner.
(15) Raising, reporting, and use of campaign
contributions for candidates for office of
Representative, of Delegate, and of Resident
Commissioner.
(16) Compensation, retirement, and other benefits of
Members, Delegates, the Resident Commissioner,
officers, and employees of Congress.
Membership and Organization of the Committee on House Administration
ONE HUNDRED EIGHTEENTH CONGRESS
COMMITTEE ON HOUSE ADMINISTRATION
(Ratio: 8-4)
Bryan Steil, Wisconsin, Chair
Barry Loudermilk, Georgia Joe Morelle, New York, Ranking
Morgan Griffith, Virginia Member
Greg Murphy, North Carolina Terri A. Sewell, Alabama
Stephanie Bice, Oklahoma Norma Torres, California
Mike Carey, Ohio Derek Kilmer, Washington
Anthony D'Esposito, New York
Laurel Lee, Florida
SUBCOMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP
SUBCOMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS
(Ratio: 4-2)
Laurel Lee, Florida, Chair
Barry Loudermilk, Georgia Terri A. Sewell, Alabama, Ranking
Stephanie Bice, Oklahoma Member
Anthony D'Esposito, New York Norma Torres, New York
SUBCOMMITTEE ON MODERNIZATION
(Ratio: 2-2)
Stephanie Bice, Oklahoma, Chair
Mike Carey, Ohio Derek Kilmer, Washington, Ranking
Member
Joe Morelle, New York
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT
(Ratio: 4-2)
Barry Loudermilk, Georgia, Chair
Morgan Griffith, Virginia Norma Torres, California, Ranking
Greg Murphy, North Carolina Member
Anthony D'Esposito, New York Derek Kilmer, Washington
Rules for the Committee on House Administration,
U.S. House of Representatives, 118th Congress
Rule 1--General Provisions
a. The Rules of the House of Representatives are the Rules
of the Committee so far as applicable and are incorporated by
reference as if set forth fully herein.
1. Should changes be adopted by the House of
Representatives to the Rules of the House of
Representatives, such new version of the Rules of the
House of Representatives shall immediately be
incorporated by reference without intervening Committee
action.
b. The Committee incorporates by reference all requirements
imposed on the Committee by statute as if set forth fully
herein.
1. Should new or amended statutory requirements
imposed on the Committee be adopted, such new or
amended requirements shall be immediately incorporated
by reference without intervening Committee action.
c. The following motions shall be privileged in the
Committee and shall be decided without debate.
1. A motion to recess from day to day, or to recess
subject to the call of the Chairman (within 24 hours),
shall be privileged; and
2. A motion to dispense with the first reading (in
full) of a bill or resolution shall be privileged if
printed copies are available.
d. Each subcommittee is a part of the Committee and is
subject to the authority and direction of the Committee and the
Committee Rules, so far as applicable.
e. The Committee shall hold at least one hearing during
each 120-day period following its organization on the topic of
waste, fraud, abuse, or mismanagement in Government programs
that it authorizes.
1. Such hearings shall include a focus on the most
egregious examples of waste, fraud, abuse, or
mismanagement as documented by any report the Committee
has received from a Federal Office of the Inspector
General or the Comptroller of the United States.
f. The Committee shall hold at least one hearing during any
session in which the Committee receives disclaimers of agency
financial statements of any Federal agency that it authorizes
or such disclaimers from representatives of any such agency.
g. The Committee shall hold at least one hearing on issues
raised by reports issued by the Comptroller of the United
States indicating that Federal programs or operations that the
Committee authorizes are at high risk of waste, fraud, abuse,
or mismanagement known as the ``high-risk list'' or the ``high-
risk series'''.
h. The committee is authorized at any time to conduct such
investigations and studies as it may consider necessary or
appropriate in the exercise of its responsibilities under House
rule X, and, subject to the adoption of expense resolutions as
required by rule X, clause 6 of the Rules of the House of
Representatives to incur expenses (including travel expenses)
in connection therewith.
i. A proposed investigative or oversight report shall be
considered as read in Committee if it has been available to the
members of the Committee for at least 24 hours (excluding
Saturdays, Sundays, or legal holidays except when the House is
in session on such a day).
j. A report of an investigation or study conducted jointly
by more than one committee may be filed jointly, provided that
each of the committees complies independently with all
requirements for approval and filing of the report.
k. After an adjournment sine die of the last regular
session of a Congress, an investigative or oversight report may
be filed with the Clerk of the House of Representatives at any
time, provided that a member who gives timely notice of
intention to file supplemental, minority, additional, or
dissenting views shall be entitled to not fewer than seven
calendar days in which to submit such views for inclusion in
the report.
l. The Committee is authorized to have printed and bound
testimony and other data presented at hearings held by the
committee or as otherwise determined by the Chairman, and to
make such information available to the public. All costs of
stenographic services and transcripts in connection with any
meeting, hearing, or other activity of the Committee shall be
paid from the applicable accounts of the House described in
clause 1(k)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of
Representatives.
m. The Committee shall submit to the House no later than
January 2 of each odd-numbered year a report on the activities
of the Committee pursuant to rules X and XI of the of the Rules
of the House of Representatives. Such report shall include:
1. Separate sections summarizing the legislative and
oversight activities of the Committee during the
Congress;
2. A summary of the authorization and oversight plans
submitted by the Committee under clause 2(d) of rule X
of the Rules of the House of Representatives;
3. A summary of the actions taken and recommendations
made with respect to the authorization and oversight
plans specified in subparagraph (2), above;
4. A summary of any additional oversight activities
undertaken by the Committee and any recommendations
made or actions taken thereon;
5. A delineation of any hearings held pursuant to
clauses 2(n), 2(o), or 2 (p) of rule XI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives; and
6. A list of hearings conducted with remote witness
participation.
7. After an adjournment sine die of the last regular
session of a Congress, or after December 15 of an even-
numbered year, whichever occurs first, the Chairman may
file this report with the Clerk of the House of
Representatives at any time and without approval of the
Committee, provided that
i. A copy of the report has been available to
each member of the Committee for at least seven
calendar days; and
ii. The report includes any supplemental,
minority, additional, or dissenting views
submitted by a member of the Committee.
n. The Committee's Rules shall be made publicly available
in electronic form and published in the Congressional Record
not later than 30 days after the Committee is organized in each
odd-numbered year.
o. Unless context clearly requires otherwise,
1. All words, phrases, and terms of art have the
meanings given them in the U.S. Constitution or the
Rules of the House of Representatives or, in the
alternative, their meanings in usual congressional or
parliamentary usage or daily usage.
2. ``Chairman'' means the member of the House of
Representatives appointed by the Speaker to lead the
Committee on House Administration or, when context
requires, the member of the Committee appointed by the
Chairman to lead a given subcommittee.
3. ``Clerk'' means the Clerk of the Committee.
References to the Clerk of the House will be express.
4. ``Committee'' means the Committee on House
Administration of the U.S. House of Representatives or,
when context requires, a subcommittee of the Committee.
5. ``Committee Rules'' mean this document, as may be
duly amended by the Committee.
6. ``House of Representatives'' or ``House'' means
the U.S. House of Representatives.
7. ``House Rules'' means the Rules of the House of
Representatives. When used in the singular, this refers
to a specific provision of the Rules of the House of
Representatives.
Rule 2--Regular and Special Meetings
a. The provisions of Rule 9 of these Committee Rules shall
apply as applicable to hearings except as described below in
this Rule 2.
b.
1. The regular meeting date of the Committee on House
Administration shall be the second Wednesday of every
month when the House is in session in accordance with
clause 2(b) of rule XI of the Rules of the House of
Representatives. If the House is not in session on the
second Wednesday of the month, the regular meeting date
shall be the third Wednesday of that month.
2. Additional meetings may be called by the Chairman
of the Committee as he deems necessary or at the
request of a majority of the members of the Committee
in accordance with clause 2(c) of rule XI of the Rules
of the House of Representatives.
3. The determination of the business to be considered
at each meeting shall be made by the Chairman in
accordance with clause 2(c) of rule XI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives. A regularly scheduled
meeting may be dispensed with, if, in the judgment of
the Chair, there is no need for the meeting.
4. To the extent practicable, the Chairman shall call
to order promptly all scheduled meetings.
c. If the Chairman is not present at any meeting of the
Committee, the ranking member of the majority party who is
present shall preside at the meeting.
1. The Chairman shall make public announcement of the
date, place, and subject matter of any meeting to be
conducted on any measure or matter. Such meetings shall
not commence earlier than the third calendar day
(excluding Saturdays, Sundays, or legal holidays except
when the House is in session on such a day) on which
members of the Committee have notice thereof.
2. If the Chairman, with the concurrence of the
ranking minority member, determines that there is good
cause to schedule or to begin sooner a meeting of the
Committee (or if the Committee so determines by
majority vote, a quorum being present), the Chair shall
make the announcement at the earliest possible date.
The announcement shall be made available publicly in
electronic form and published in the Daily Digest.
d. The Chairman shall make available publicly in electronic
form at least 24 hours before a meeting of the Committee the
text of any legislation, resolution, regulation, or other
document to be marked up, provided that the text of any
legislation, resolution, regulation, or other document to be
marked up at a hearing announced with fewer than 24 hours'
notice pursuant to pursuant to Paragraph (d), above, shall be
made available publicly with such announcement.
Rule 3--Open Meetings
a. As required by clause 2(g) of rule XI of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, each meeting for the transaction
of business, including for the mark-up of legislation by the
Committee, shall be open to the public except when the
Committee in open session and with a quorum present determines
by record vote that all or part of the remainder of the meeting
on that day shall be closed to the public because disclosure of
matters to be considered would endanger national security,
would compromise sensitive law enforcement information, would
tend to defame, degrade, or incriminate any person, or would
otherwise violate any relevant law or the Rules of the House of
Representatives.
b. No person other than members of the Committee and such
congressional staff and such other persons as the Committee may
authorize shall be present in any Committee meeting that has
been closed to the public.
c. The Committee may vote by the same procedure described
above in Paragraph (a) to close one subsequent day of hearing.
Rule 4--Records and Roll Calls
a.
1. A record vote shall be held if requested by any
member of the Committee.
2. The result of each record vote in any meeting of
the Committee shall be available for inspection by the
public at reasonable times at the Committee offices,
including a description of the amendment, motion,
order, or other proposition voted upon, the name of
each member voting for and against such proposition,
and a list of the members present but not voting.
3. The Chairman shall make available publicly in
electronic form the record of the votes on any question
on which a record vote is demanded not later than 48
hours after such vote is taken (excluding Saturdays,
Sundays, or legal holidays except when the House is in
session on such a day). Such record shall include a
description of the amendment, motion, order, or other
proposition voted upon, the name of each member voting
for and against such proposition, and a list of the
members present but not voting.
4. The Chairman shall make available publicly in
electronic form the text of any amendment to a measure
or matter adopted by the Committee not later than 24
hours after such amendment is adopted.
b.
1. Subject to subparagraph (2), below, the Chairman
may postpone further proceedings when a record vote is
ordered on the question of approving any measure or
matter or adopting an amendment. The Chair may resume
proceedings on a postponed request at any time.
2. In exercising postponement authority under
subparagraph (1), above, the Chairman shall take all
reasonable steps necessary to notify members of the
resumption of proceedings on any postponed record vote.
3. When proceedings resume on a postponed question,
notwithstanding any intervening order for the previous
question, an underlying proposition shall remain
subject to further debate or amendment to the same
extent as before the question was postponed.
c. All Committee hearings, records, data, and files shall
be kept separate and distinct from the congressional office
records of the Chairman and shall constitute property of the
House of Representatives and, pursuant to the Rules of the
House of Representatives, all members of the House of
Representatives shall have access thereto.
d. Committee records that are held at the National Archives
shall be made available pursuant to rule VII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives. The Chairman shall notify the
ranking minority member of any decision to withhold a record
pursuant to such Rule for disposition upon written request of
any Committee member.
e. To the maximum extent feasible, the Committee shall make
its publications available in electronic form, keeping in mind
the importance of accessibility standards and machine-readable
formats to the Committee's openness and transparency goals.
f. Unless the Chairman, in consultation with the ranking
minority member, deems it appropriate, the Committee shall not
conduct business by poll.
Rule 5--Proxies and Remote Participation
a. No vote by any member of the Committee may be cast other
than in person at the location where the Committee is sitting,
Minority Views
Legislative Branch Oversight
INTRODUCTION
The oversight and authorization activities of the Committee
on House Administration are key to the operations of the
Legislative Branch. During the 116th and 117th Congresses,
Committee Democrats guided the House through several
generational challenges, ensuring continuity of operations
during the COVID-19 pandemic and in the aftermath of the
January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol. Even in the face of
these historic obstacles, the Committee made unprecedented
improvements to House operations, particularly with respect to
human capital and institutional capacity.
According to Demand Progress, a nonpartisan, non-
governmental organization focused on strengthening democracy,
the House ``improve[d] the working conditions for its staff in
the 117th Congress than Congress has over the last three
decades combined.''\1\ These reforms improved the ability for
the House to recruit and retain top talent and provided Members
and staff with tools to perform their jobs more effectively,
strengthening the institution. Advances included, among others:
creating the House Office of Diversity and Inclusion and House
Office of Whistleblower Ombuds; imposing a $45,000.00 pay floor
for full-time House staff; decoupling of Member and staff pay;
raising the staff pay cap; increasing the lifetime maximum for
the Student Loan Repayment Program (SLRP) and exempting SLRP
payments from the pay cap; adoption of regulations recommended
by the nonpartisan Office of Congressional Workplace Rights
(OCWR) providing for unionization and collective bargaining for
House staff who choose to exercise such rights; adoption of
regulations recommended by OCWR relating to application of
rights under the Family and Medical Leave Act and Fair Labor
Standards Act for House staff; extending the House Paid
Internship Program to committees; raising the maximum allowable
compensation for interns; growing committee capacity by
increasing committee funding; expanding the Congressional Staff
Academy; launching the CAO Coach Program; creating the House
Human Resources Hub; and enlarging the House Child Care Center;
and increasing the capacity of the Office of Employee
Assistance.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Demand Progress, Statement on House Unionization Vote +
Establishment of Minimum Wage) May 7, 2022 https://demandprogress.org/
statement-on-house-unionization-vote-establishment-of-minimum-wage/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The accomplishments of Committee Democrats in the 116th and
117th Congresses led Axios to declare that the Committee,
``once seen as a bureaucratic backwater is now at the center of
some of the biggest policy fights in Congress.''\2\ In addition
to the reforms discussed above, Committee Democrats took a
leading role on issues related to election administration and
the assault on voting rights; disinformation surrounding U.S.
elections; both physical and cyber security; and the removal of
white supremacist and Confederate statuary and art from places
of honor in the Capitol. The Committee also drove the
authorization of two new Smithsonian museums: the National
Museum of the American Latino and American Women's History
Museum.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Lachlan Markay, Capitol Hill's Smallest Committee Takes Center
Stage, Axios (May 26, 2022), https://www.axios.com/2022/05/26/house-
administrative-committee-capitol-security.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee Minority looks forward to working with the
new Committee Majority to further strengthen the institution.
In particular, the Committee Minority appreciates the Committee
Majority's establishment of the Subcommittee on the
Modernization of Congress, and the fact that the Majority
agreed to an even split among Democratic and Republican
Members. The Select Committee on the Modernization of Congress,
established by House Rules packages in both the 116th and 117th
Congress made many recommendations to improve the institution,
and while the Committee implemented or partially implemented
more than 130 such recommendations in the previous Congresses,
additional implementation work remains.
The Committee Minority is committed to working in a
bipartisan fashion in its oversight of the Legislative Branch.
However, there will inevitably be matters in which the
Committee Minority will disagree with the Committee Majority.
For example, the Committee Minority is deeply troubled by
public reporting that the Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy
made a deal with Fox News personality Tucker Carlson, who has
referred to the January 6, 2021, attack as a ``false flag
operation''\3\ to provide him--and him alone--with ``unfettered
access''\4\ to tens of thousands of hours of security footage
of the Capitol related to the January 6, 2021, attack.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Meryl Kornfield and Jacqueline Alemany, McCarthy gives Tucker
Carlson exclusive access to Jan. 6 riot video, The Washington Post
(Feb. 21, 2023), http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/02/21/
tucker-carlson-kevin-mccarthy-jan-6-insurrection/.
\4\Id.
\5\Mike Allen, Exclusive: McCarthy gives Tucker Carlson access to
trove of Jan. 6 riot tape, Axios (February 20, 2023), https://
www.axios.com/2023/02/20/kevin-mccarthy-tucker-carlson-jan-6-riot-
footage.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
United States Capitol Police (USCP or Department)
leadership has repeatedly stressed the danger of publicly
releasing this footage, explaining that it puts the Capitol at
significant risk. For example, in July 2022, the USCP Acting
Assistant Chief of Police for Uniformed Operations said, in an
affidavit made as part of a federal prosecution, ``USCP
continues to consider any interior footage of the U.S. Capitol
to be highly sensitive information, and any access to it should
be strictly limited.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Declaration of Sean P. Gallagher, U.S. v. Egtvedt, No. 1:21-cr-
00177 (D.D.C.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As has been well publicized, in the runup to the January 6,
2021, attack, rioters attempted to gather information about the
interior of the Capitol, including tunnels and non-publicly
available floor plans. Providing access to hours of footage
will result in security vulnerabilities of the Capitol being
collected, exposed, and passed on to those who might wish to
attack the Capitol again. That the Capitol is open to the
public and that video footage of the January 6 attack is widely
available does not diminish the need to prevent large swaths of
unvetted security footage from being made public. According to
a federal judge who issued a protective order related to the
footage, ``Even if some information about the U.S. Capitol's
layout is available online, USCP's footage provides far more
detailed information, which could raise security concerns if
copied and publicized.''\7\ In addition, sophisticated foreign
and nonstate actors may be able to use the security camera
footage to identify weaknesses in Capitol security, such as
potential blind spots and Member evacuation routes. Moreover,
release of the footage would cause issues in the prosecutions
of January 6 defendants, whose attorneys only have access to
security camera footage under a protective order.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\7 U.S. v. Cudd, 534 F.Supp. 3d 48, 54 (D.D.C. 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The danger associated with these actions is even more
significant when considering the individual being provided the
footage. Mr. Carlson has a lengthy record of lying and
spreading disinformation about the January 6, 2021, attack on
his television show in an apparent attempt to rewrite history.
According to the Washington Post,
``Carlson promoted false and debunked claims about
government agents stoking the riot, from the wife of an
accused rioter (whom he later interviewed on his show
without comment) to elevating evidence-free and
obviously flimsy claims about a man named Ray Epps to a
national audience. He produced a widely debunked three-
part series aimed at reframing the Capitol riot in a
way that attributed responsibility to government
actors--and slotted the response to the riot in his
exhaustingly simplistic us-vs.-them narrative. When the
House select committee investigating the riot first
aired a hearing in prime time, 12 Carlson's show was an
ad-free hour of handing the microphone to riot
sympathizers and conspiracy theorists.''\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Kornfield, supra note 3.
Historically, Mr. Carlson's conspiracy theories and false
claims are so outrageous that attorneys for Fox News have
forced to concede in federal court that he should not be
considered an objective source of information.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\McDougal v. Fox News Network, LLC, 489 F.Supp. 174 (2020); see
also David Folkenflik, You Literally Can't Believe The Facts Tucker
Carlson Tells You. So Say Fox's Lawyers, NPR (September 29, 2020),
https://www.npr.org/2020/09/29/917747123/you-literally-cant-believe-
the-facts-tucker-carlson-tells-you-so-say-fox-s-lawye.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Any attempts by defenders of these actions to create a
false equivalence with the work of the Select Committee to
Investigate the January 6, 2021, Attack on the Capitol (Select
Committee) should be dismissed. During the course of its
investigation, the Select Committee worked directly with the
Department to ensure the security camera footage that was
ultimately released to the public did not pose a security
threat. The Select Committee was required to clear all footage
it released publicly with the Department. In some cases, the
Department did voice such objections, and the Select Committee
worked with the Department to address its concerns. In
addition, any individual that reviewed security footage signed
a user agreement, and their individual actions were tracked so
there was a record of who accessed what and when. No such
safeguards appear to be in place in the present case, and,
according to the New York Times, Mr. Carlson has explicitly
stated that ``he and a large team of staff members [are]
looking at the footage.''\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Luke Broadwater and Jonathan Swan, In Sharing Video With Fox
Host, McCarthy Hits Rewind on Jan. 6, N.Y. Times (Feb. 22, 2023),
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/22/us/politics/
tucker-carlson-jan-6-mccarthy.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee Minority intends to conduct robust oversight
on this issue and hopes that the Committee Majority will
rethink this decision, which, according to security
professionals, presents a significant security risk. Among the
unknowns the Minority intends to uncover are:
What footage has Tucker Carlson's
representatives already viewed?
What conditions did the Speaker's Office put
on the review of that footage?
Does the Speaker intend to physically
transfer video files to Tucker Carlson or anybody else?
What does Tucker Carlson intend to do with
the footage?
As part this Authorization and Oversight Plan, the Majority
says that it will ``empower security experts, not politicians,
to make security related decisions.'' Yet, the Department has
made clear that it views release of security footage as a
prodigious security threat.
HOUSE OFFICERS AND OPERATIONS, GENERALLY
The Committee Minority agrees with the Committee Majority
that the House should be accountable, open, accessible,
transparent, professional, modern and resilient. In particular,
the Minority shares the Majority's interest in ``facilitat[ing]
more opportunities for Americans to engage with Congress.'' The
Minority is therefore disappointed that the new House Majority
eliminated the option for hearing witnesses to provide
testimony remotely. Remote testimony allows individuals without
the financial means to travel to Washington, DC to engage
directly with Congress. It also makes it easier for individuals
with disabilities, rural Americans, and those with job
restrictions to engage with their elected representatives. When
Congress limits hearing witnesses to those with enough time,
money, child care and job flexibility to travel to Washington
for several days, it takes away the voice of millions of
Americans who deserve to heard.
The Committee Majority also expresses a desire to ``oversee
the coordination of services across the House entities to
ensure Committees may host field hearings across the country
and U.S. territories safely and effectively.'' With the
assistance of the House Recording Studio the Committee Minority
convened nine field hearings, two field roundtables and one
field listening session during the 116th and 117th Congresses.
The Minority looks forward to continuing to provide oversight
of the House Recording Studio's field hearing capabilities by
participating in additional proceedings outside Washington, DC.
CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER
The Committee Minority agrees with the Committee Majority's
oversight goals for the Chief Administrative Officer (CAO). In
addition, the Committee Minority intends to:
Provide vigorous oversight of services
provided to district offices, including the concept of
enterprise-wide district office WiFi.
Examine the House's relationship with the
General Services Administration (GSA) to ensure Members
can effectively serve their constituents through
district offices in GSA-owned buildings.
Review efforts to diversify the CAO
workforce, including oversight of CAO diversity working
groups and mentoring programs.
Continue efforts to improve customer service
and communications across all CAO functions and
business units.
Continue oversight of House technology
upgrades, including MyExpenses.
Review proposed reforms to the Office of
Finance and Payroll and Benefits, including potential
implementation of the Select Committee on the
Modernization of Congress recommendation to shift to
bimonthly pay periods.
Continue oversight of the Student Loan
Repayment Program.
Review and oversee information technology
services provided, maintained or hosted by House
Information Resources (HIR).
Continue oversight of failsafe procedures to
guarantee continuity of operations.
Continue oversight of House cybersecurity
practices, including network security and threat
prevention.
Provide oversight of the House Disaster
Recovery Program.
Oversee web services activities, including
new Member website development, with a focus on
accessibility.
Oversee the Technology Partner Program.
Oversee continued efforts to move toward
cloud computing.
HOUSE SERGEANT AT ARMS
The Committee Minority also agrees with the Committee
Majority's stated goal of independently empowering security
experts, not politicians, to make security related decisions.
Unfortunately, this stands in stark contrast with the decision
to provide a Fox News personality access to Capitol security
camera footage, in direct contravention of the wishes of
security experts within USCP.
In addition to many of the priorities noted by the
Majority, the Minority intends to:
Oversee continued implementation of the
Residential Security Program initiated during the 117th
Congress.
Continue to review the effectiveness of the
district office security center and law enforcement
coordinator program.
Review the HSAA role on the Capitol Police
Board and study potential reforms thereto.
Monitor implementation of security
recommendations made by various security experts in the
aftermath of the January 6, 2021, attack, including
those made by Lt. General Russel Honore's task force,
the USCP Office of Inspector General and Architect of
the Capitol Office of Inspector General.
Oversee efforts to improving emergency
preparedness training for Members and staff, both in
Washington, DC and in their respective districts.
Monitor efforts to appoint a permanent
Sergeant at Arms, including progress of any national
search.
CLERK OF THE HOUSE
The Committee Minority commends the Office of the Clerk for
its work during the protracted election for Speaker of the
House. The Minority intends to focus its Office of the Clerk-
related oversight on the following:
Review the Clerk's current IT configuration
and redundancy posture.
Oversee the House document repository.
Oversee lobbying disclosure process,
including ways to make data more easily accessible for
the general public.
Review standards for the electronic exchange
of legislative information among the chambers of
congress and Legislative Branch agencies.
Coordinate on matters under the jurisdiction
of the House Fine Arts Board and the Capitol
Preservation Board.
Continue review of functions and
administrative operations assigned to the Clerk.
Review of semi-annual financial and
operational status reports; recommend changes in
operations to improve services and increase
efficiencies.
Review the printing needs of the Clerk to
evaluate the potential for eliminating duplication.
Review the application programming interface
incorporated in the Clerk's website.
Oversee preparation of congressionally
authorized publications.
Oversee participation in the Congressional
Data Task Force.
Continued oversight of official reporter
participation in field hearings.
HOUSE OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
The Committee Minority agrees with the Committee Majority's
oversight priorities for the House Office of Inspector General
and looks forward to providing direction on audits management
advisories on a bipartisan basis.
ARCHITECT OF THE CAPITOL
The Committee Minority agrees with many of the Committee
Majority's oversight priorities for the Architect of the
Capitol (AOC). In addition to the priorities not
Hearings
The Looking Ahead Series: The Architect of the Capitol's Strategic Plan
for the 118th Congress
Full Committee
February 9, 2023
Witness:
The Honorable J. Brett Blanton, Architect of the Capitol
Part 1: Committee Funding for the 118th Congress
Full Committee
February 28, 2023
Part 2: Committee Funding for the 118th Congress
Full Committee
March 1, 2023
Member Day: Committee on House Administration
Full Committee
March 8, 2023
A View of House Modernization: Perspectives from the CAO
Subcommittee on Modernization
March 9, 2023
Witness:
Catherine Szpindor, Chief Administrative Officer
2022 Midterms Look Back Series: Successes in the 2022 Midterm Elections
Subcommittee on Elections
March 10, 2023
Witnesses:
The Honorable Kyle Ardoin, Louisiana Secretary of State;
The Honorable Chris Anderson, Supervisor of Elections, Seminole
County, Florida; The Honorable Frank LaRose, Ohio Secretary of
State; Damson Hewitt, President and Executive Director of the
Lawyers' Committee
2022 Midterms Look Back Series: Election Observer Access
Subcommittee on Elections
March 23, 2023
Witnesses:
Lynn Taylor, President of the Virginia Institute for Public
Policy; Josh Findlay, National Election Integrity Director at
the Republican National Committee; Michael Cunnington, Former
Congressional Observer; The Honorable Benjamin Hovland,
Commissioner at the U.S. Election Assistance Commission; Lisa
Lyons, County Clerk of Kent County, Michigan
Looking Ahead Series: Office of the Attending Physician
Subcommittee on Oversight
March 23, 2023
Witness:
Rear Admiral Brian P. Monahan MC USN, Attending Physician
of the United States Congress
2022 Midterms Look Back Series: Government Voter Suppression in Luzerne
County, Pennsylvania
Full Committee
March 28, 2023
Witnesses for Panel 1:
Jim Bognet, Former Congressional Candidate for PA-08; Darin
Gibbons, Counsel at the Republican National Committee; The
Honorable Donald Palmer, Commissioner at the U.S. Election
Assistance Commission; Alisha Hoffman-Mirilovich, Executive
Director at Action Together NEPA
Witnesses for Panel 2:
Theodore Fitzgerald, Citizen; Benjamin Herring, Citizen;
Jessica Morgan, Citizen; James Walsh, Citizen
Looking Ahead Series: House Sergeant at Arms' Strategic Plan for the
118th Congress
Full Committee
April 18, 2023
Witness:
William P. McFarland, Acting Sergeant at Arms
Data Breach at the D.C. Health Exchange
Subcommittee on Oversight; Subcommittee on Cybersecurity, Information
Technology, and Government Innovation
April 19, 2023
Witnesses:
The Honorable Catherine Szpindor, Chief Administrative
Officer; Mila Kofman, Executive Director of the DC Health
Benefit Exchange Authority
The Path Toward a More Modern and Effective Congressional Research
Service
Subcommittee on Modernization
April 26, 2023
Witness for Panel 1:
Dr. Mary B. Mazanec, Director of the Congressional Research
Service
Witnesses for Panel 2:
Joseph Dunne, Director of the European Parliament Liaison
Office in Washington, D.C., and formerly a Director in the
European Parliamentary Research Service; Richard Coffin, Chief
of Research and Advocacy at USA Facts; Kevin Kosar, Senior
Fellow of Legal and Constitutional Studies at American
Enterprise Institute
American Confidence in Elections: State Tools to Promote Voter
Confidence
Full Committee
April 27, 2023
Witnesses:
The Honorable Ken Cuccinelli, Chairman of the Election
Transparency Initiative; Joseph Paul Gloria, Chief Executive
Officer for Operations; The Honorable Donald Palmer,
Commissioner at the U.S. Election Assistance Commission; Hans
von Spakovsky, Manager of the Election Law Reform Initiative
and Senior Legal Fellow, on behalf of The Heritage Foundation;
The Honorable Mac Warner, Secretary of State of West Virginia
American Confidence in Elections: Protecting Political Speech
Full Committee
May 11, 2023
Witnesses:
Harmeet K. Dhilon, Managing Partner at Dhillon Law Group
Inc.; Audrey Perry Martin, Partner at The Gober Group; Justine
Reimer, Principal at Riemer Law, LLC; Bradley A. Smith,
Chairman and Founder of the Institute for Free Speech; Stephen
Spaulding, Vice President for Policy and External Affairs at
Common Cause
Looking Ahead Series: Oversight of the United States Capitol Police
Full Committee
May 16, 2023
Witness:
The Honorable J. Thomas Manger, Chief of Police of the
United States Capitol Police
American Confidence in Elections: Ensuring Every Eligible American has
the Opportunity to Vote--and for their Vote to Count According
to Law
Subcommittee on Elections
May 24, 2023
Witnesses:
Joseph Burns, Law Office of Joseph T. Burns, PLLC; Lisa
Dixon, Executive Director of the Lawyers Democracy Fund, Thor
Hearne, Founding Partner of True North Law, LLC; Deuel Ross,
Deputy Director of Litigation at the NAACP Legal Defense and
Education Fund, Inc.
American Confidence in Elections: The Path to Election Integrity in the
District of Columbia
Committee on House Administration; Committee on Oversight and
Accountability
June 7, 2023
Witnesses:
The Honorable Ken Cuccinelli, Chairman of the Election
Transparency Initiative; Monica Evans, Executive Director of
the DC Board of Elections; Charles Spies, Member of Dickinson
Wright, PLLC; Wendy R. Weiser, Vice President, Democracy,
Brennan Center for Justice
Oversight of the Office of Congressional Ethics
Subcommittee on Oversight
June 13, 2023
Witnesses:
Omar Ashmawy; Staff Director and Chief Counsel of the
Office of Congressional Ethics; The Honorable Michael Barnes,
Co-Chairman of the Office of Congressional Ethics; Paul
Vinovich, Chairman of the Office of Congressional Ethics
American Confidence in Elections: The Role of the Election Assistance
Commission in Free, Fair, and Secure Elections
Full Committee
June 14, 2023
Witness for Panel 1:
Brianna Schletz, Inspector General of the Election
Assistance Commission
Witnesses for Panel 2:
The Honorable Thomas Hicks, Commissioner at the Election
Assistance Commission; The Honorable Benjamin Hovland, Vice
Chairman at the Election Assistance Commission; The Honorable
Christy McCormick, Chairwoman at the Election Assistance
Commission; The Honorable Donald Palmer, Commissioner at the
Election Assistance Commission
American Confidence in Elections: The Path to Election Integrity Across
America
Full Committee--Field Hearing in Atlanta, Georgia
July 10, 2023
Witnesses:
Vernetta Keith Nuriddin, Elections Consultant, City of
Milton; Dr. Kathleen Ruth, Former Vice Chair of the Fulton
County Board of Registration and Elections; The Honorable Hans
von Spakovsky, Manager, Election Law Reform Initiative and
Senior Legal Fellow, The Heritage Foundation; Cathy Woolard,
Chair of the Fulton County Board of Registration and Elections
Oversight of the U.S. Capitol Police Office of Inspector General
Subcommittee on Oversight
July 19, 2023
Witness:
Ronald P. Russo, Inspector General of the United States
Capitol Police
Oversight of the Capitol Police Board
Committee on House Administration; Senate Committee on Rules and
Administration
July 26, 2023
Witnesses:
The Honorable Karen H. Gibson, Sergeant at Arms and
Doorkeeper of the Senate; J. Thomas Manger, Chief of the U.S.
Capitol Police; The Honorable William McFarland, Acting
Sergeant at Arms; Chere Rexroat, Acting Architect of the
Capitol
Oversight of United States Capitol Security: Assessing Security
Failures on January 6, 2021
Subcommittee on Oversight
September 19, 2023
Witness:
The Honorable Steven Sund, Former Chief of U.S. Capitol
Police
Oversight of the Federal Election Commission
Full Committee
September 20, 2023
Witnesses:
The Honorable Shana M. Broussard, Commissioner at the
Federal Election Commission; The Honorable Sean J. Cooksey,
Vice Chairman at the Federal Election Commission; The Honorable
Allen Dickerson, Commissioner at the Federal Election
Commission; The Honorable Dara Lindenbaum, Chair at the Federal
Election Commission; The Honorable James E. Trainor III,
Commissioner at the Federal Election Commission; The Honorable
Ellen L. Weintraub, Commissioner at the Federal Election
Commission; Christopher Skinner, Inspector General at the
Federal Election Commission
Legislative Branch Advancement: GAO Modernization
Subcommittee on Modernization
September 27, 2023
Witness for Panel 1:
The Honorable Gene Dodaro, Comptroller General at the U.S.
Government Accountability Office
Witnesses for Panel 2:
James-Christian Blockwood, Executive Vice President at the
Partnership for Public Service; Dan Lips, Head of Policy at the
Foundation for American Innovation; Dr. Tim Persons, Principal
at Pricewaterhouse Coopers LLP
Looking Ahead Series: Oversight of the Smithsonian Institution
Full Committee
December 12, 2023
Witness:
Lonnie G. Bunch III, Secretary of the Smithsonian
Institution
Artificial Intelligence (AI): Innovations within the Legislative Branch
Full Committee
January 30, 2024
Witnesses:
Take Ariga, Chief data Scientist and Director of Innovation
Lab, Science, Technology Assessment, and Analytics at the U.S.
Government Accountability Office; John Clocker, Deputy Chief
Administrative Officer of the Office of the Chief
Administrative Officer; Judith Conklin, Chief Information
Officer of the Library of Congress; The Honorable Hugh Halpern,
Director of the U.S. Government Publishing Office
American Confidence in Elections: Confronting Zuckerbucks, Private
Funding of Election Administration
Full Committee
February 7, 2024
Witnesses:
Dr. Will Flanders, Research Director at the Wisconsin
Institute for Law & Liberty, Mollie Hemingway, Journalist and
Author, Dr. Zachary Mohr, Associate Professor of Public
Budgeting and Financial Management School of Public Affairs and
Administration at The University of Kansas; Scott Walter,
President of the Capitol Research Center
Legislative Proposals to Support Modernizing the Congressional Research
Service and the Use of Federal Data
Subcommittee on Modernization
March 20, 2024
Witnesses:
Elise Bean, Director of the Washington Office at the Carl
Levin Center for Oversight and Democracy; Dr. Matthew Glassman,
Senior Fellow at the Government Affairs Institute at Georgetown
University; Dr. Nicholas Hart, President and CEO of the Data
Foundation; Robert Randolph Newlen, Interim Director of the
Congressional Research Service
Safety on Capitol Hill: DC Crime's Impact on Congressional Operations
and Visitors
Full Committee
March 21, 2024
Witnesses:
Gregg Pemberton, Chairman of the DC Police Union; Thomas
Manger, Chief of the United States Capitol Police; Raphael
Mangual, Nick Ohnell Fellow at The Manhattan Institute
Three Years Later: D.C. National Guard Whistleblowers Speak Out on
January 6 Delay
Subcommittee on Oversight
April 17, 2024
Witnesses:
Colonel Earl Matthews--Chief Legal Advisor, D.C. Army
National Guard; Command Sergeant Major Michael Brooks--Senior
Enlisted Officer, D.C. Army National Guard; Captain Timothy
Nick--Aide-de-camp, D.C. Army National Guard; Brigadier General
Aaron Dean--Adjutant General, D.C. Army National Guard
Looking Ahead Series: Oversight of the Office of the Clerk
Full Committee
May 8, 2024
Witness:
The Honorable Kevin F. McCumber, Acting Clerk of the U.S.
House of Representatives
American Confidence in Elections: Preventing Noncitizen Voting and
Other Foreign Interference
Full Committee
May 16, 2024
Witnesses:
Hans von Spakovsky, Manager, Election Law reform Initiative
and Senior Legal Fellow, Edwin Meese III Center for Legal and
Judicial Studies, The Heritage Foundation; Caitlin Sutherland,
Executive Director of American for Public Trust; J. Christian
Adams, President and General Counsel of the Public Interest
Legal Foundation; The Honorable Cord Byrd, Secretary of State
of Florida; Michael Waldman, President and CEO of the Brennan
Center for Justice at NYU Law School
The U.S. Copyright Office: Customers, Communities, and Modernization
Efforts
Full Committee
June 26, 2024
Witness:
Shira Perlmutter, Register of Copyrights and Director of
the U.S. Copyright Office
Oversight of the Library of Congress
Full Committee
July 10, 2024
Witness:
Dr. Carla Hayden, Librarian of Congress
Congress in a Post-Chevron World
Full Committee
July 23, 2024
Witnesses:
Wayne Crews, Fellow in Regulatory Studies at the
Competitive Enterprise Institute; Dr. Kevin Kosar, Resident
Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute; The
Honorable Paul Ray, Director of the Thomas A. Roe Institute for
Economic Policy at The Heritage Foundation; Satya Thallam,
Senior Vice President of Government Affairs at Americans for
Responsible Innovation; Professor Josh Chafetz, Agnes Williams
Sesquicentennial Professor of Law and Politics at Georgetown
University Law Center
American Confidence in Elections: Looking Ahead to the 2024 General
Election
Full Committee
September 11, 2024
Witnesses:
Cord Byrd--Florida Secretary of State; Jocelyn Benson--
Michigan Secretary of State; Frank LaRose--Ohio Secretary of
State; Mac Warner--West Virginia Secretary of State; Maggie
Toulouse-Oliver--New Mexico Secretary of State, Adrian Fontes--
Arizona Secretary of State
Continuity of Congress: Preparing for the Future by Learning from the
Past
Subcommittee on Modernization
September 18, 2024
Witness for Panel 1:
The Honorable Brad R. Wenstrup, Member of Congress
Witnesses for Panel 2:
Rebecca Gambler, Director of Homeland Security and Justice
at the U.S. Government Accountability Office; Eric Petersen,
Specialist in American National Government at the Congressional
Research Service; Thomas Wickham Jr., Private Citizen
American Confidence in Elections: Prohibiting Foreign Interference
Full Committee
December 18, 2024
Witnesses:
Matthew K. O'Neill, Co-Founder and Partner at 5OH
Consulting; Caitlin Sutherland, Executive Director of Americans
for Public Trust; Bradley Bowman, CMPP Senior Director at the
Foundation for Defense of Democracies; Derf Johnson, Deputy
Director of the Montana Environmental Information Center
MARKUPS
Markup of H.R. XX, American Confidence in Elections Act
Full Committee
July 13, 2023
Markup of Committee Resolution 118-22 Updates and modernizes the
Members Congressional Handbook; Committee Resolution 118-23
Updates and modernizes the Committee Handbook; Committee
Resolution 118-24 Updates and modernizes the Eligible
Congressional Member Organization (ECMO) Handbook; Committee
Resolution 118-21 To approve an additional Committee Consultant
Contract Agreement with the Committee on the Budget; H. Res.
XX--Updates House Rule 24 Clause 8 to clarify the Franking
blackout period is 60 days prior to an election in which the
members name will appear on a ballot to bring House Rules in
line with the statute; H.R. 3196--Architect of the Capitol
Appointment Act of 2023; H. Res. 458--Requiring foreign state
media outlets with credentialed members in the House news media
galleries to comply with the Foreign Agents Registration Act by
prohibiting the admission into such galleries of reporters and
correspondents who are representatives of such outlets who are
not in compliance with the requirements of such Act, and for
other purposes; H.R. XX--Extends the Federal Election
Commission's Administrative Fine Program by 10 years; H.R.
4474--Confirmation of Congressional Observer Access Act of 2023
(COCOA Act of 2023); H.R. 4460--NO VOTE for Non-Citizens Act
Full Committee
September 28, 2023
Markup of H.R. 4460--NO VOTE for Non-Citizens Act; H.R. 4396--American
Confidence in Elections: District of Columbia Citizen Voter
Act; H.R. 4316--Citizen Ballot Protection Act; H.R. 3162--
Protecting American Voters Act; H.R. 3229--Stop Foreign Funds
in Elections Act; H.R. 6513--Confirmation of Congressional
Observer Access Act of 2023 (COCOA Act of 2023); H.R. 4555--
Federal Election Audit Act; H.R. 6493--Safeguarding Electoral
Integrity Act of 2023
Full Committee
November 20, 2023
Markup of H.R. XX--End Zuckerbucks Act of 2024; H.R. XX--Electronic
Filing of Electioneering Communication Reports Act; H.R. 4486--
Hiring Preference for Veterans and Americans With Disabilities
Act
Full Committee
February 14, 2024
Markup of H.R. 7593: Modernizing the Congressional Research Service's
Access to Data Act; H.R. 7592: A bill to replace the
requirement for the Library of Congress to prepare hardbound
versions of the Constitution Annotated and supplements with a
requirement to instead prepare and publish digital versions
online.
Subcommittee on Modernization
April 11, 2024
Markup of H.R. 7592--A bill to replace the requirement for the Library
of Congress to prepare hardbound versions of the Constitution
Annotated and supplements with a requirement to instead prepare
and publish digital versions online; H.R. 7593--Modernizing the
Congressional Research Service's Access to Data Act; Committee
Resolution 118-33--Resolution to Approve Allocation from the
Paid House Committee Internship Program to Committees for 2024;
Committee Resolution 118-34--Resolution to Amend the Members'
Congressional Handbook (authorizing co-sponsored constituent
service events and making other Handbook revisions)
Full Committee
April 30, 2024
Markup of H.R. 8281--Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act (``SAVE''
Act); H.R. 8399--Preventing Foreign Interference in American
Elections Act; H.R. 7640--No Foreign Persons Administering Our
Elections Act; H.R. 4544--No Federal Funds for Ballot
Harvesting Act; H.R. 4317--To amend the National Voter
Registration Act of 1993 to require States to submit a report
to the Election Assistance Commission that includes information
with respect to the voter list maintenance activities of the
State, and for other purposes.
Full Committee
May 23, 2024
Markup of H.R. 9488--Secure Handling of Internet Electronic Donations
Act (SHIELD Act); H.R. 7764--Commission to Study the Potential
Transfer of the Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish
History to the Smithsonian Institution Act; H.R. 6394--
Semiquincentennial Congressional Time Capsule Act; H.R. 6969--
To direct the Joint Committee on the Library to procure a
statue of Benjamin Franklin for placement in the Capitol; H.R.
9489--To Sunset the Advisory Committee on the Records of
Congress, and for Other Purposes; H.R. 9487--To amend the
Legislative Reorganization Act of 1970 to authorize the
Legislative Counsel of the House of Representatives to
designate more than one of the attorneys of the Office of the
Legislative Counsel as a Deputy Legislative Counsel, and for
other purposes; H.R. 9490--To revise certain authorities of the
Government Publishing Office, and for other purposes.
Full Committee
September 11, 2024
Minority Views
FEDERAL ELECTIONS
During the 118th Congress, the Committee continued to
prioritize its historic role in conducting oversight of federal
elections, election administration, campaign finance, the
integrity and security of U.S. elections, and ensuring access
to the franchise for all Americans. Building upon the
Committee's extensive oversight and legislative work during the
117th Congress, in this Congress, Committee Democrats advocated
for our comprehensive democracy reform agenda and pushed back
on the Committee Republican pro-dark money, pro-voter
suppression agenda. During the 118th Congress, for example,
Committee Democrats opposed the Republican American Confidence
in Elections Act, a ``partisan power grab masquerading as a
defense of election integrity,''\1\ and SAVE Act, a measure so
extreme that most Americans would be unable to register to vote
using their driver's license or other state-provided
identification alone.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Editorial Board, Opinion: House GOP election bill expands dark
money and curtails D.C. autonomy, Wash. Post (July 11, 2023), https://
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/07/11/house-republican-confidence-
elections-dc/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When opportunities for bipartisan collaboration were
available, Committee Democrats worked diligently to revise and
improve legislation through Committee mark-ups and post-mark-up
amendments. We are proud of our efforts to dramatically improve
the H.R. 6513--COCOA Act of 2024 and to shepherd passage of
S.2747--A bill to amend the Federal Election Campaign Act of
1971 to extend the Administrative Fine Program for certain
reporting violations, which saved the Federal Election
Commission's (FEC) administrative fines program from
sunsetting.
Committee Democrats also conducted oversight over the two
federal agencies under our purview, the FEC and the Election
Assistance Commission (EAC), and administered an extensive
election observer program. For the November 2024 general
election, the Committee Minority trained nearly 200 staff, and
sent more than 70 congressional observers to monitor nearly 50
congressional races across 23 states.
Legislation
Democracy Reform Legislation
This Congress, Committee Democrats championed HR. 11, the
Freedom to Vote Act, and H.R. 14, the John R. Lewis Voting
Rights Advancement Act.
H.R. 11, the Freedom to Vote Act is comprehensive,
democracy reform legislation that will advance the democratic
promise by eliminating barriers to voting for all eligible
Americans, combatting dark money in politics, enhancing
transparency in campaign finance while empowering small donors,
and ending partisan. and H.R. 14, the John R. Lewis Voting
Rights Advancement Act, primarily sponsored by Subcommittee on
Elections Ranking Member Terri Sewell (AL), restores and
strengthens the Voting Rights Act.
H.R. 11, the Freedom to Vote Act
H.R. 11, the Freedom to Vote Act, was introduced during
118th Congress by Representative John P. Sarbanes of Maryland,
along with Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries of New York,
Ranking Member Joseph Morelle of New York, and Subcommittee of
Elections Ranking Member Terri Sewell of Alabama, on July 18,
2023. This legislation was supported by every member of the
House Democratic Caucus.
This comprehensive legislation to advance American
democracy is a collection of reforms introduced over the years
by various Members of Congress that would expand access to the
ballot box, protect the right to vote, bolster the integrity of
our democracy, and boost sorely needed confidence in self-
government. During the 117th Congress, a measure combining the
Freedom to Vote Act and the John R. Lewis Voting Rights
Advancement Act passed the House on July 13, 2022.
The Federalist No. 57 states:
Who are to be the electors of the federal
representatives? Not the rich, more than the poor; not
the learned, more than the ignorant; not the haughty
heirs of distinguished names, more than the humble sons
of obscurity and unpropitious fortune. The electors are
to be the great body of the people of the United
States.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\The Federalist No. 57, in THE FEDERALIST PAPERS, available at
https://guides.loc.gov/federalistpapers/text-51-60#s-lg-box-wrapper-
25493433. A series of 85 essays written by Alexander Hamilton, James
Madison, and John Jay, appeared anonymously in New York newspapers
under the pen name ``Publius.'' Federalist No. 57 is considered to be
the work of either Alexander Hamilton or James Madison.
H.R. 11 advances this bedrock principle of American
democratic self-governance. It is legislation for the ``great
body of the people'' to hold government accountable and to
protect the precious right to vote for all Americans.
Too many Americans feel shut out of the electoral process,
face barriers at the ballot box, or choose not to vote. Despite
the historically exceptional turnout in the 2020 general
election, the 2020 general election was fraught with long-
standing challenges in our electoral system: legal and
structural efforts to disenfranchise voters, especially
African-American, Native American, and Latino voters; extreme
partisan gerrymandering; outsized spending by wealthy special
interests; the continued proliferation of dark money; deceptive
practices; and disinformation campaigns about election results.
Further, following the 2020 general election, some states
rushed to enact voter restrictive laws, which were in effect
for the 2022 midterms, that restricted access to the ballot
box, such as by making it harder to vote by mail, requiring
documentary proof of citizenship to vote, establishing new ID
requirements, making it difficult for people who do not have
traditional addresses to vote, and imposing faulty voter
purges.
H.R. 11 combats these threats to our democracy. It includes
key provisions from the late Rep. John Lewis' ``Voter
Empowerment Act'' that would modernize voter registration
systems by implementing online voter registration, automatic
voter registration, and same-day voter registration, set
nationwide standards that expand access to absentee and early
voting, improve access to voting for individuals with
disabilities, prohibit deceptive practices, combat voter
intimidation, protect against faulty purges from voter
registration lists, and restore the federal voting rights of
Americans with felony convictions who are no longer
incarcerated. It would end partisan gerrymandering, and require
the disclosure of dark, undisclosed money so that Americans
know who is influencing their votes and their views.
H.R. 14, the John R. Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act
On September 19, 2023, National Voter Registration Day,
Subcommittee of Elections Ranking Member led every House
Democrat in introducing H.R. 14, the John R. Lewis Voting
Rights Advancement Act. The bill would protect the right to
vote and safeguard our democracy by restoring and modernizing
the full protections of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 (VRA).
Ten years ago, the Supreme Court gutted the VRA and unleashed a
wave of discriminatory state laws targeting voters and
restricting voting access. By restoring the VRA's authority,
the John R. Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act would prevent
such laws from taking effect in states and localities with a
recent history of voter discrimination.
Anti-Democracy Legislation
H.R. 4563--ACE Act
Republicans' American Confidence in Election Act (``ACE
Act'') would place extreme restrictions on voters and election
administrators, roll back access to proven voter registration
and voting methods, promote dark money in our politics, and
imposes Republicans' wish-list of restrictive voting laws on
the District of Columbia.
Committee Republicans invested a significant amount of time
on this legislation, holding numerous hearings and organizing a
six-hour markup of the bill's text. In addition to the time
spent, Committee Republicans expended tremendous taxpayer
resources in support of the ACE Act, including flying the full
Committee to Atlanta to announce the introduction of this bill.
But all of that appears to have been performative--the ACE Act
never even received consideration by the full House. House
Republicans likely abandoned the ACE Act because even they
realized what a flawed bill this is.
The following is a report, prepared by the Committee's
Democratic staff, illustrating the myriad flaws of the ACE Act.
It would have been released concurrent with the ACE Act's floor
debate, had House Republican leadership considered the bill a
priority.
CODIFYING THE BIG LIE: HOUSE REPUBLICANS' ANTI-DEMOCRACY ACE ACT
Introduction
In the 2020 presidential election, former Vice President
Joseph R. Biden defeated President Trump by roughly seven
million votes and 74 electoral votes. In the same election,
Republicans lost control of the Senate and failed to take
control of the House of Representatives.
Following months of false claims about the integrity of
United States elections and methods of voting, then-President
Trump--without evidence--claimed the election was stolen from
him. Republicans should have been prepared for these claims.
Not only is the former president known for repeated
mistruths,\3\ this was not the first time he had tried to
undermine the outcome of an American election. In 2016, then-
candidate Trump claimed that Senator Ted Cruz (R Texas)
``stole'' the Republican Iowa Caucuses.\4\ And he had indicated
that he might not accept the results of the 2016 presidential
election if Secretary Hillary Clinton prevailed.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Glenn Kessler, Salvador Rizzo, & Meg Kelly, Trump's false or
misleading claims total 30,573 over 4 years, Wash. Post (Jan. 24,
2021), https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/01/24/trumps-false-
or-misleading-claims-total-30573-over-four-years/.
\4\Amy Tennery, Trump accuses Cruz of stealing Iowa caucuses
through `fraud', Reuters (Feb. 3, 2016), https://www.reuters.com/
article/us-usa-election-trump-cruz/trump-accuses-cruz-of-
stealing-iowa-caucuses-through-fraud-idUSMTZSAPEC23ZBL9YS.
\5\Patrick Healy & Jonathan Martin, Donald Trump won't say if he'll
accept result of election, N.Y. Times (Oct. 19, 2016), https://
www.nytimes.com/2016/10/20/us/politics/presidential-
debate.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite the advance warning, when a defeated President
Trump claimed that the 2020 election was stolen, most House
Republicans ignored the oaths they swore to support and defend
the Constitution against all enemies, foreign and domestic;
they were either silent or endorsed President Trump's ``Big
Lie,'' and with it his effort to erode American democracy. In
fact, 126 House Republicans, led by now-Speaker Mike Johnson,
filed an amicus curiae brief with the Supreme Court forcefully
advocating for the votes of millions of citizens to be
discarded and their voices silenced, pushing the Court to
forsake the clear results of a free and fair American
election.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Andrew Solender, 126 House Republicans Now Support Lawsuit To
Overturn Election In Updated Brief, Forbes (Dec. 11, 2020), https://
www.forbes.com/sites/andrewsolender/2020/12/11/126-house-republicans-
now-support-lawsuit-to-overturn-election-in-updated-brief/?sh=
7daf8913e5db.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On January 6, 2021 (``January 6''), at the direct
instigation of President Trump and his allies, thousands of the
President's supporters attacked the United States Capitol in a
violent effort to stop the peaceful transition of power that is
the bedrock of our Republic.\7\ This insurrection claimed
multiple lives, and as of April 30, 2024, 14 individuals have
either pled guilty to, or been convicted of, seditious
conspiracy in relation to the attack. Hundreds more have been
convicted of other crimes, many of them for violent attacks on
law enforcement officers, and federal grand juries have
indicted over 1,000 people with crimes connected to the
insurrection.\8\ And, on August 1, 2023, a federal grand jury
indicted former President Trump with four felonies related to
his attempt to overturn the election.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\See Final Report, House Report 117-663, Select Committee to
Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States Capitol, 117th
Cong. (2nd Sess. 2022) [hereinafter, January 6th Select Committee Final
Report].
\8\Shawna Chen, Over 1,000 people now face charges in connection to
Jan. 6 riots, Axios (May 19, 2023), https://www.axios.com/2023/04/06/
jan6-riots-doj-charged.
\9\Tierney Sneed et al., Donald Trump has been indicted in special
counsel's 2020 election interference probe, CNN (Aug. 1, 2023), https:/
/www.cnn.com/2023/08/01/politics/donald-trump-indictment-grand-jury-
2020-election/index.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The worst assault on American democracy since the Civil
War, the January 6 attack was either ignored or glossed over by
most House Republicans--indeed, the large majority of the House
Republican Conference, including now-Speaker Johnson and then-
Republican Leader (and former Speaker) Kevin McCarthy, voted to
overturn the freely and fairly cast electoral votes of several
states the evening of January 6 once Congress was able to
safely return to the ransacked Capitol.
The evidence is clear--there was no widespread fraud in the
2020 election; Republicans know this.\10\ But the roots of
anti-democracy President Trump spread so easily throughout the
Republican Party predate his presidency and his candidacy.
While the disenfranchisement of wide swaths of Americans dates
to the founding of our country (when only land-holding white
men were legally entitled to vote), the last two centuries of
our history have been devoted to the expansion of suffrage. Not
so for the modern Republican Party, whose efforts to restrict
access to the ballot have grown markedly over the last two
decades.\11\ Attempts across the Union to disenfranchise voters
of color have increased dramatically--often pushed by
conservative groups like The Heritage Foundation--which rely on
dishonest, light-on-the-detail talking points about ``election
integrity'' when disseminating ghost-written anti-voter laws to
state lawmakers.\12\ In 2020, President Trump's baseless claims
of fraud fit neatly within a worldview that has been
crystalizing on the right for decades--that some voters,
despite being eligible American citizens, are suspect, and that
elections in which Democrats prevail are inherently
illegitimate.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\David Folkenflik, Off the air, Fox News stars blasted the
election fraud claims they peddled, NPR (Feb. 16, 2023), https://
www.npr.org/2023/02/16/1157558299/fox-news-stars-false-claims-trump-
election-2020; Michael Balsamo, Disputing Trump, Barr says no
widespread election fraud, AP (June 28, 2022), https://apnews.com/
article/barr-no-widespread-election-fraud-b1f148879 6c9a98c4b1a9061a
6c7f49d; Zach Schonfeld, Conservative group finds `absolutely no
evidence of widespread fraud' in 2020 election, The Hill (July 14,
2022), https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/3559758-conservative-
group-finds-absolutely-no-evidence-of-widespread-fraud-in-2020-
election/; Jan Wolfe, Factbox: Trump's false claims debunked: the 2020
election and Jan. 6 riot, Reuters (Jan. 6, 2022), https://
www.reuters.com/world/us/trumps-false-claims-debunked-2020-election-
jan-6-riot-2022-01-06/; Mike Emanuel & Sally Persons, Prominent
conservatives say election was lost, not stolen, Fox News (July 14,
2022), https://www.foxnews.com/politics/prominent-conservatives-
election-lost-not-stolen.
\11\See infra Part I. The Big Lie and Voter Suppression Efforts
Permeate the ACE Act.
\12\Ari Berman & Nick Surgey, Leaked Video: Dark Money Group Brags
About Writing GOP Voter Suppression Bills Across the Country, Mother
Jones (May 13, 2021), https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2021/05/
heritage-foundation-dark-money-voter-suppression-laws/.
\13\Jamelle Bouie, Opinion: The G.O.P has some voters it likes and
some it doesn't, N.Y. Times (Mar. 30, 2021), https://www.nytimes.com/
2021/03/30/opinion/voter-suppression.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This report details how the American Confidence in
Elections Act, a ``partisan power grab masquerading as a
defense of election integrity,''\14\ is just one more step in
House Republicans' ongoing strategy to undermine the rule of
law, the right to vote, and American democracy itself.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Editorial Board, Opinion: House GOP election bill expands dark
money and curtails D.C. autonomy, Wash. Post (July 11, 2023), https://
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/07/11/house-republican-confidence-
elections-dc/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part I. The Big Lie Permeates the ACE Act
Millions of Americans are concerned about the integrity of
American elections precisely because the Republican Party tells
them--repeatedly, emphatically--that our democracy is something
to fear. They are overwhelmed by false allegations of fraud,
panicked about fictional suitcases full of illegal ballots,\15\
distrusting of voting machines (and voting machine
manufacturers), and suspicious of election results from cities
like Atlanta, Detroit, Milwaukee, Philadelphia, and Phoenix--at
core, told by congressional Republicans to fear voters who
think and feel and look different.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Jane C. Timm, Georgia poll workers targeted by Trump are
cleared of false election fraud claims, NBC News (June 21, 2023),
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/elections/georgia-poll-workers-
targeted-trump-cleared-false-election-fraud-claim-rcna90350 (relaying
the results of the investigation by the Georgia State Election Board
clearing the Georgia election workers targeted by the former president
of any wrongdoing).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Using the cover of the Big Lie, which even President Trump
knows is entirely fabricated,\16\ House Republicans are using
their American Confidence in Elections Act (``ACE Act'')\17\ as
a vehicle to push their anti-democratic priorities. This
includes further restricting the ability of millions of
Americans--disproportionately voters of color--to participate
in our elections or fully exercise their democratic rights.
Republicans also hope this bill will increase the influence of
billionaire donors and dark money organizations that attempt to
hide in the shadows while propping up extreme candidates and
even more extreme policies.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Dissenting Views
PROCEDURAL CONCERNS IN COMMITTEE AND THEIR TROUBLING PRECEDENT
In addition to opposing H.R. 4563, as amended, on policy
grounds, we also take objection to some of the meeting's
procedural events, as the Committee Republicans established a
number of troubling precedents over the course of the markup to
avoid debate. Notably, the Chair ruled that an amendment
dealing primarily with early voting\293\ was not germane and
was instead within the Rule X jurisdiction of the Committee on
Education and the Workforce, merely because the amendment
incorporated definitions found in the Higher Education Act of
1965 (20 U.S.C. 1002).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\293\See Appendix I.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Republicans continued to undermine the
Committee's authority when they ruled out of order multiple
amendments aimed at ensuring candidates for Congress do not lie
to the public about their educational background, military
history, or employment history.\294\ These amendments were
introduced as a standalone bill on January 12, 2023, as H.R.
350: The SANTOS Act, which received a referral to the Committee
on House Administration as the only committee of
jurisdiction.\295\ Despite, this, Committee Republicans
insisted on a point of order that the provisions were outside
of the Committee's jurisdiction. The point of order was well
taken by the Chair and sustained on appeal, further muddying
our understanding of what Committee Republicans believe the
Committee has authority to act upon despite explicit guidance
from the Office of the Parliamentarian.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\294\See Appendix II.
\295\See Appendix III.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To be sure, the standing rules of the House task the
Committee on House Administration with jurisdiction over, inter
alia, the ``Election of the President, Vice President, Members,
Senators, Delegates, or the Resident Commissioner; corrupt
practices; contested elections; credentials and qualifications;
and Federal elections generally.\296\ Committee Democrats
strongly disagree with the ruling of the Chair severely
curtailing this Committee's jurisdiction. Even so, if Committee
Republicans insist on ceding this Committee's jurisdiction to
another committee, that is their prerogative (though the Rules
Committee is likely a more appropriate forum for that ill-
advised endeavor).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\296\House Rule X, clause 1(k)(12) (emphasis added); see also
Appendix IV.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In yet another procedural curiosity, Committee Republicans
attempted to object to consideration of an amendment that
simply affirmed President Joe Biden's victory because of the
contents of the title of the amendment.\297\ After the Chair
correctly proceeded to a vote on the germane amendment,
Committee Republicans struck it down, putting their position on
the outcome of the 2020 presidential election at odds with even
the most fringe right-wing witnesses they have invited to
testify before the Committee this Congress.\298\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\297\House Practice, Sec. 2 (``The scope of a measure is determined
by its provisions and not by the phraseology of its formal title.'').
\298\See Appendix V.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Even more puzzling, the amendment in the nature of a
substitute used, as base text for the proceeding, an amended
provision of the underlying bill--Section 413--which clearly
invokes the jurisdiction of the Committee on Homeland Security.
By the majority's own germaneness standard, the substitute
amendment should have been out of order.
Committee Democrats would have appreciated--and the
American people would have benefited from--a more fulsome
debate on the proposed amendments to the bill. Instead,
Committee Republicans refused to even consider many of
Committee Democrats' substantive amendments, and in the process
severely weakened the Committee's ability to make
jurisdictional claims over election policy in the future. The
committee room is not a vacuum, and those decisions will live
on long after the 118th Congress has dissolved.
Unfortunately, this kind of uneven and inconsistent
application of House and Committee rules and precedent is not
isolated to the markup of H.R. 4563. Indeed, Committee
Democrats have already objected to previous instances of
failure to treat the Committee's minority equitably, as is our
right. Although Committee Republicans ignored those objections,
we renew them here along with the objections outlined above. We
encourage the majority to return to regular order for the good
of this Committee and the House.
OBJECTIONS TO THE CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERSTANDING ADVANCED BY THE ACE ACT
Introduction
The policy grounds upon which Committee Democrats disagree
with this bill are legion.\299\ In this instance, however, we
limit our objection to the bill's findings regarding Article I,
Section 4, Clause 1 of the Constitution of the United States
(the ``Elections Clause''). Akin to our significant procedural
concerns, Committee Democrats strenuously object to the
majority's posture on Congress's constitutional authority
because of its dangerous precedential nature. We address this
in detail here because these misguided views--which conflict
with the plain meaning of the Elections Clause, congressional
practice, and Supreme Court precedent--threaten reverberating
consequences for Article I governance well into the future
should they be codified with the enactment of the ACE Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\299\Committee Democrats offered fifty thoughtful amendments during
the ACE Act mark-up, only one of which was adopted. The first amendment
offered, by Ranking Member Morelle, was an amendment in the nature of a
substitute with the text of the Freedom to Vote Act, as passed by the
House during the 117th Congress. The Freedom to Vote Act, unlike the
ACE Act, expands voter access and promotes transparency in political
spending.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In sum, the ACE Act misrepresents the Constitution and
Congress's role in regulating federal elections. The bill
asserts that ``[a]ccording to Article 1, Section 4 of the
Constitution of the United States, the States have the primary
role in establishing `(t)he Times, Places and Manners of
holding Elections for Senators and Representatives'', while
Congress has a purely secondary role in this space and must
restrain itself from acting improperly and
unconstitutionally.''\300\ Certainly, Congress must never act
``improperly or unconstitutionally.'' Committee Republicans,
however, have left a key element of the Elections Clause out of
their bill text, obfuscating the true authority of the
Elections Clause: ``the Congress may at any time by Law make or
alter such Regulations.''\301\ Implying that this language
provides a ``purely secondary'' role for Congress is to ignore
both the plain text and the history of the Constitution.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\300\H.R. 4563, 118th Cong. Sec. 3(1) (1st Sess., 2023) (as
amended).
\301\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 4, cl. 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Without a doubt, the intent of the framers of the
Constitution was that Congress would have plenary authority
over the election of its members. Indeed, eloquently arguing on
behalf of constitutional ratification, Alexander Hamilton made
quite clear the ``plain proposition, that every government
ought to contain in itself the means of its own
preservation.''\302\ In the 117th Congress, Stanford University
historian Jack Rakove testified that the adoption of the
Elections Clause, ``reflected the serious misgivings about the
state legislatures that many framers of the Constitution
shared,'' and that ``anyone concerned with the original meaning
of the [Elections] Clause, as it was understood in the late
1780s, needs to take this attitude into account.''\303\ The
drafters of the ACE Act, unfortunately, divert from this
original meaning of the Elections Clause.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\302\The Federalist No. 59 (Alexander Hamilton).
\303\The Elections Clause: Constitutional Interpretation and
Congressional Exercise: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on House Admin.,
117th Cong. 1-2 (2021) (written testimony of Jack Rakove). Professor
Rakove, a scholar of the origins of the American Revolution and
Constitution, the political practice and theory of James Madison, and
the role of historical knowledge in constitutional litigation, has won
the Delancey K. Jay Prize, the Fraunces Tavern Museum Book Award, the
Society of the Cincinnati Book Prize, and the Pulitzer Prize in
History.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Supreme Court has long upheld Congress's power under
the Elections Clause--since Ex Parte Siebold, 100 U.S. 371
(1879), the Supreme Court has repeatedly held that Congress's
power over congressional elections is ``paramount.''\304\ A
decade ago, the late Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of
the United States Antonin Scalia reaffirmed the ``broad'' and
``comprehensive'' scope of the Congress' authority under the
Elections Clause.\305\ In fact, Congress's powers pursuant to
the Elections Clause are even broader than those in other parts
of the Constitution. Article I, Section 4, Clause 1 of the
Constitution grants ``Congress . . . broad power under the
Elections Clause to regulate federal elections, unchecked by
the federalism concerns that have stymied'' other congressional
authorities based in different fonts of constitutional
power.\306\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\304\The Elections Clause: Constitutional Interpretation and
Congressional Exercise: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on House Admin.,
117th Cong. 1 (2021) (written testimony of Daniel P. Tokaji).
\305\Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, 570 U.S. 1, 5-6
(2013).
\306\Franita Tolson, The Elections Clause and the Underenforcement
of Federal Law, 129 YALE L. J. F. 171, 183 (2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
What is clear is this: The Constitution of the United
States grants explicit and broad authority to Congress to
regulate federal elections and to uphold our democratic
processes. If enacted, the ACE Act--by abdicating what is both
a legal prerogative and a constitutional responsibility--would
open the door to state-based anti-democratic and discriminatory
legislation across the United States. It would also set a
destructive precedent by surrendering Congress's Article I
authority against the express intentions of the Founders of
this Nation. Committee Democrats object.
The Background of the Elections Clause
In the wake of a stunning military victory over the British
crown, followed by eight years inefficiency and tumult under
the Articles of Confederation, by 1787 the American states
clambered for a system of government that would protect their
hard-won but nascent independence. An experiment in democratic
self-governance, the unsteady country demanded both liberty and
stability. A new governing document was needed, but debate over
what that document would be, and how it would be structured,
was spirited, attracting input from every corner on the
inchoate nation; it was, however, understood by all to be of
critical importance.\307\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\307\See Pauline Maier, Ratification: The People Debate the
Constitution, 1787-1788 (2010).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The immediate needs of the 13 states were chiefly economic
and military. Without a centralized power to direct the
collected efforts of the several state governments, the first
non-native independent American nation was in disarray. The
country could not pay its existing war debts, nor could it
finance its government. It had no centralized defense force;
threatening European powers loomed large, and ships that left
American ports of call were left undefended against
pirates.\308\ But in the eyes of many of the nation's leaders,
what clarified the need for a fundamental governmental overhaul
was the 1786-1787 Shays' Rebellion in which thousands of
western Massachusetts farmers--many of them veterans of the
Continental Army--protested in force a significant tax burden
and a rise in land foreclosures. The national army, under the
Articles of Confederation, was unable to subdue the rebellion,
and an appalled George Washington asked: ``What stronger
evidence can be given of the want of energy in our government
than these disorders?''\309\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\308\Ron Chernow, Washington: A Life 513-14 (2010).
\309\Id. at 517-19.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to this growing national crisis, delegates met
in Philadelphia during the summer of 1787 to debate, draft, and
submit to the several states for ratification a new
Constitution of the United States. The drafters and delegates
arrived at the Constitutional Convention with divergent
motivations and sometimes conflicting interests, but the
conclave had an overriding purpose--to secure the survival of
the fledgling nation. They had seen, during the course of the
1780s, the abject failure of the fatally feeble Articles of
Confederation and therefore insisted upon a stronger
centralization of power ``to secure the Blessings of
Liberty.''\310\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\310\U.S. Const. pmbl.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Elections Clause itself was heavily debated. Having
witnessed the states' prior refusal to support the confederal
government, the Constitution's drafters saw fit to give
Congress--rather than the state legislatures--final authority
over congressional elections out of a fear that the states
could fail to hold such elections at all.\311\ Convention
delegate Rufus King, of Massachusetts, believed that a
constitutional failure to provide congressional authority over
federal elections would be ``dangerous'' and ``fatal.''\312\
And James Madison, of Virginia, ``recognizing that state
lawmakers would abuse their power in ways that were impossible
to predict at the time, . . . warned that the Elections Clause
was needed to prevent self-interested partisans from twisting
election rules to benefit their faction.''\313\ Indeed, the
delegates rejected an attempt to altogether remove the phrase
``but [state legislature] provisions concerning [congressional
elections] may at any time be altered by the Legislature of the
United States'' from a draft of the Elections Clause--as
Committee Republicans have done in the text of their ACE
Act.\314\ The delegates eventually voted unanimously to adopt
Elections Clause as currently drafted--not as preferred by
Committee Republicans.\315\ Upon the signing and publication of
the full document on September 17, 1787, the Constitution was
transmitted to the states for ratification.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\311\Eliza Sweren-Becker & Michael Waldman, The Meaning, History,
and Importance of the Elections Clause, 96 Wash. L. Rev. 997, 1006
(2021).
\312\Id. at 1007.
\313\Id.
\314\Id. at 1006-08.
\315\Id. at 1008.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Debates over the structure and text of pending Constitution
were not confined to Independence Hall, nor was the
understanding of the rights and responsibilities contained
within the text restricted to lawyers' chambers and the various
state legislatures. The people of the United States were
acutely invested in the outcome of the convention and in the
ratification--or not--of the Constitution itself. In towns and
cities throughout the 13 states, people gathered, considered,
weighed, and decided.\316\ In newspapers across the nation,
essay after essay was published supporting or opposing,
explaining and critiquing, the document's text. Under the name
Publius, Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay
submitted to the people compelling and thoughtful arguments in
favor of constitutional ratification, but their voices were not
alone: Brutus, the Federal Farmer, and A Columbian Patriot\317\
were among the many who joined the national choir either for or
against ratification.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\316\Maier, supra note 307, at 45-67.
\317\Erick Trickey, The Woman Whose Words Inflamed the American
Revolution, Smithsonian Magazine (Jun. 20, 2017), https://
www.smithsonianmag.com/history/woman-whose-words-inflamed-american-
revolution-180963765/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To assume that every provision, clause, and word that found
its way into the final constitutional text was not heavily
analyzed and dissected is to betray a lack of knowledge about
the founding of our nation. That is why, to entirely ignore a
full section of the Elections Clause--indeed, one that provides
explicit preemptory congressional power over the preceding
state authority grant--betrays either a total ignorance of
American history in the Revolutionary period or an act of
legislative bad faith.
The Law of the Elections Clause
Committee Republicans, by omitting a key portion of this
text, may temporarily muddy the constitutional understanding of
a reader unfamiliar with the law or with American history, but
they do not change the Constitution itself. The plain text of
the Elections Clause should put to bed any notion that Congress
does not have foremost authority over congressional elections:
``The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for
Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State
by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by
Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of
chusing Senators.''\318\ So too should a thorough understanding
of the motivations of the Founders, and their actions during
the drafting and ratification of the Constitution. But if
neither this unaltered, clear language, nor this much needed
historical overview, is enough to convince a skeptic of the
genuine scope of the Elections Clause, perhaps nearly a century
and a half of Supreme Court precedent will persuade.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\318\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 4, cl. 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ex parte Siebold conc