Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
The Committee on Education and the Workforce began the
118th Congress with the goal of protecting the rights of
workers, job creators, students, and parents. The Committee
worked toward this goal through addressing the broken student
loan system for borrowers while protecting taxpayers,
strengthening workforce development programs, expanding access
to employer-sponsored health insurance, and protecting parents'
rights in schools.
The Committee also remained committed to its oversight
duties, considering seven Congressional Review Act resolutions
in Full Committee markups, sending letters to administration
officials, launching investigations into universities with
pervasive antisemitism on their campuses, issuing 29 subpoenas,
conducting four transcribed interviews and one deposition, and
holding multiple oversight hearings to review agencies'
policies and priorities.
Hearings Held by the Full Committee
February 8, 2023--Hearing titled ``American Education in Crisis.''
Purpose: To provide an overview of the main challenges
facing K-12 education, postsecondary education, and the
workforce development system.
Witnesses: Mrs. Virginia Gentles, Director, Education
Freedom Center, Independent Women's Forum, Arlington, VA; Dr.
Monty Sullivan, President, Louisiana Community and Technical
College System, Baton Rouge, LA; The Honorable Jared Polis,
Governor, State of Colorado, Denver, CO; and Mr. Scott
Pulsipher, President, Western Governors University, Salt Lake
City, UT.
March 28, 2023--Hearing titled ``Unleashing America's Opportunities for
Hiring and Employment.''
Purpose: To examine how the economic conditions created by
the COVID-19 pandemic, including high inflation, supply chain
disruptions, and labor shortages, have negatively impacted
workers and job creators.
Witnesses: Mr. Stephen Moore, Distinguished Fellow in
Economics, The Heritage Foundation, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Chris
Spear, President and Chief Executive Officer, American Trucking
Associations, Washington, D.C.; Dr. Heidi Shierholz, President,
Economic Policy Institute, Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Jerry
Akers, small business owner and franchisee, Palo, IA
(testifying on behalf of the International Franchise
Association).
May 16, 2023--Hearing titled ``Examining the Policies and Priorities of
the Department of Education.''
Purpose: To review the policies and priorities of the U.S.
Department of Education as conveyed in President Biden's Budget
for Fiscal Year 2024.
Witness: The Honorable Miguel Cardona, Secretary, U.S.
Department of Education, Washington, D.C.
June 7, 2023--Hearing titled ``Examining the Policies and Priorities of
the Department of Labor.''
Purpose: To review the policies and priorities of the U.S.
Department of Labor as conveyed in President Biden's Budget for
Fiscal Year 2024.
Witness: The Honorable Julie Su, Acting Secretary, U.S.
Department of Labor, Washington, D.C.
June 13, 2023--Hearing titled ``Examining the Policies and Priorities
of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.''
Purpose: To review the policies and priorities of the U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services as conveyed in
President Biden's Budget for Fiscal Year 2024.
Witness: The Honorable Xavier Becerra, Secretary, U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services.
June 22, 2023--Hearing titled ``Competencies Over Degrees:
Transitioning to a Skills-Based Economy.''
Purpose: To examine the rise of skills-based hiring and the
policies that can help broaden the talent pipeline for a more
competitive workforce in the 21st century economy.
Witnesses: Dr. Karin Kimbrough, Chief Economist, LinkedIn,
Sunnyvale, CA; Dr. Mark Smith, Director of HR Thought
Leadership, SHRM, Alexandria, VA; Dr. Papia Debroy, Senior Vice
President of Insights, Opportunity@Work, Washington, D.C.; and
Mr. Dan Healey, Head of People for Customer Success, SAP,
Newton Square, PA.
December 1, 2023--Hearing titled ``Member Day: Committee on Education
and the Workforce.''
Purpose: To provide an opportunity for non-Committee
Members to inform the Committee of their policy priorities
within the Committee's jurisdiction.
Witnesses: The Honorable Derek Kilmer, Member of Congress,
U.S. House of Representatives, Port Angeles, Washington; the
Honorable Joaquin Castro, Member of Congress, U.S. House of
Representatives, San Antonio, TX; the Honorable Brad Finstad,
Member of Congress, U.S. House of Representatives, Rochester,
MN; the Honorable Brian K. Fitzpatrick, Member of Congress,
U.S. House of Representatives, Doylestown, PA; the Honorable
Rudy Yakym, Member of Congress, U.S. House of Representatives,
South Bend, IN; and the Honorable Brad R. Wenstrup, Member of
Congress, U.S. House of Representatives, Cincinnati, OH.
December 5, 2023--Hearing titled ``Holding Campus Leaders Accountable
and Confronting Antisemitism.''
Purpose: To discuss the proliferation of antisemitism on
college campuses across the nation with university presidents,
and to examine how universities are addressing antisemitism.
Witnesses: Dr. Sally Kornbluth, President, Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA; Ms. Elizabeth Magill,
President, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA; Dr.
Pamela Nadell, Professor of History and Jewish Studies,
American University, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Claudine Gay,
President, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
April 17, 2024--Hearing titled ``Columbia in Crisis: Columbia
University's Response to Antisemitism.''
Purpose: To learn about antisemitism on Columbia's campus
that manifested through rule breaking, riots, and disruption
and about the University's response since October 7.
Witnesses: Dr. Nemat ``Minouche'' Shafik, President,
Columbia University, New York, New York; Professor David
Schizer, Harvey R. Miller Professor of Law and Economics and
Dean Emeritus, Columbia Law School, New York, NY; Ms. Claire
Shipman, Board of Trustees Co-Chair, Columbia University, New
York, NY; Mr. David Greenwald, Board of Trustees Co-Chair,
Columbia University, New York, NY.
May 1, 2024--Hearing titled ``Examining the Policies and Priorities of
the Department of Labor.''
Purpose: To review the Fiscal Year (FY) 2025 budget
priorities of the Department of Labor.
Witness: The Honorable Julie A. Su, Acting Secretary, U.S.
Department of Labor, Washington, D.C.
May 7, 2024--Hearing titled ``Examining the Education Department's
Policies, Priorities, and FY 2023 Financial Audit Failure.''
Purpose: To exercise oversight of the U.S. Department of
Education's (Department) operations, review the Department's
Fiscal Year 2025 budget priorities, review the Department's FY
2023 financial audit process, and examine related matters.
Witness: The Honorable Miguel Cardona, Secretary, U.S.
Department of Education, Washington, D.C.
May 15, 2024--Hearing titled ``Examining the Policies and Priorities of
the Department of Health and Human Services.''
Purpose: To review the Fiscal Year 2025 budget priorities
of the Department of Health and Human Services.
Witness: The Honorable Xavier Becerra, Secretary, U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, D.C.
May 23, 2024--Hearing titled ``Calling for Accountability: Stopping
Antisemitic College Chaos.''
Purpose: To examine antisemitism at Northwestern
University, Rutgers University, and the University of
California, Los Angeles (UCLA), including the establishment of
encampments and University leaders' responses.
Witnesses: Mr. Michael Schill, President, Northwestern
University, Evanston, IL; Dr. Jonathan Holloway, President,
Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ; Mr. Frederick M.
Lawrence, Secretary and CEO, The Phi Beta Kappa Society,
Washington, D.C.; Dr. Gene Block, Chancellor, UCLA, Los
Angeles, CA.
Markups and Other Business Meetings Held by the Full Committee
January 31, 2023--Full Committee Organizational Meeting to introduce
new Members of the Committee; adopt the rules of the Committee
on Education and the Workforce for the 118th Congress; approve
the Subcommittee Chairs and Ranking Members as well as approve
the assignment of Members to Subcommittees; and share the
Committee Oversight Plan for the 118th Congress.
March 8, 2023--Markup of H.R. 734, the Protection of Women and Girls in
Sports Act of 2023.
Sponsor: Rep. Gregory W. Steube (FL)
Disposition: H.R. 734 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 25 Yeas and 17 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-35 was filed on April
10, 2023.
March 8, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5, the Parents Bill of Rights Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Julia Letlow (LA)
Disposition: H.R. 5 was ordered to be favorably reported to
the House, as amended, by a vote of 25 Yeas and 17 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-9 was filed on March 14,
2023.
May 10, 2023--Markup of H.J. Res. 45, Providing for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the Department of Education relating to
``Waivers and Modifications of Federal Student Loans''.
Sponsor: Rep. Bob Good (VA)
Disposition: H.J. Res. 45 was ordered to be favorably
reported to the House, by a vote of 24 Yeas and 18 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-71 was filed on May 18,
2023.
June 6, 2023--Markup of H. Res. 461, Condemning the use of elementary
and secondary school facilities to provide shelter for aliens
who are not admitted to the United States.
Sponsor: Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks (IA)
Disposition: H. Res. 461 was ordered to be favorably
reported to the House, as amended, by a vote of 22 Yeas and 16
Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-113 was filed on June
14, 2023.
June 6, 2023--Markup of H.R. 1147, the Whole Milk for Healthy Kids Act
of 2023.
Sponsor: Rep. Glenn Thompson (PA)
Disposition: H.R. 1147 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 26 Yeas and 13 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-131 was filed on June
30, 2023.
June 6, 2023--Markup of H.R. 2813, the Self-Insurance Protection Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Bob Good (VA)
Disposition: H.R. 2813 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 24 Yeas and 18 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-114 was filed on June
20, 2023.
June 6, 2023--Markup of H.R. 2868, the Association Health Plans Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Tim Walberg (MI)
Disposition: H.R. 2868 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 18 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-112 was filed on June
14, 2023.
June 13, 2023--Markup of H.R. 824, the Telehealth Benefit Expansion for
Workers Act of 2023.
Sponsor: Rep. Tim Walberg (MI)
Disposition: H.R. 824 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 21 Yeas and 14 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-132 (Part I) was filed
on June 30, 2023.
June 13, 2023--Markup of H.R. 3941, the Schools Not Shelters Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Marcus Molinaro (NY)
Disposition: H.R. 3941 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 20 Yeas and 16 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-130 was filed on June
30, 2023.
July 12, 2023--Markup of H.R. 4509, the Transparency in Billing Act of
2023.
Sponsor: Rep. Virginia Foxx (NC)
Disposition: H.R. 4509 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 39 Yeas and 0 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-258 was filed on
November 1, 2023.
July 12, 2023--Markup of H.R. 4507, the Transparency in Coverage Act of
2023.
Sponsor: Rep. Bob Good (VA)
Disposition: H.R. 4507 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 38 Yeas and 1 Nay.
Committee Report: House Report 118-742 (Part I) was filed
on November 18, 2024.
July 12, 2023--Markup of H.R. 4527, the Health DATA Act of 2023.
Sponsor: Rep. Lori Chavez-DeRemer (OR)
Disposition: H.R. 4527 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 38 Yeas and 1 Nay.
Committee Report: House Report 118-260 was filed on
November 1, 2023.
July 12, 2023--Markup of H.R. 4508, the Hidden Fee Disclosure Act of
2023.
Sponsor: Rep. Joe Courtney (CT)
Disposition: H.R. 4508 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 39 Yeas and 1 Nay.
Committee Report: House Report 118-259 was filed on
November 1, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 4259, the Think Differently about
Education Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Marcus Molinaro (NY)
Disposition: H.R. 4259 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 39 Yeas and 0 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-252 was filed on October
25, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5349, the Crucial Communism Teaching
Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar (FL)
Disposition: H.R. 5349 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 33 Yeas and 9 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-255 was filed on October
25, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5110, the Protecting Hunting
Heritage and Education Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Mark Green (TN)
Disposition: H.R. 5110 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 42 Yeas and 0 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-207 was filed on
September 20, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.J. Res. 88, Providing for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the Department of Education relating to
``Improving Income Driven Repayment for the William D. Ford
Federal Direct Loan Program and the Federal Family Education
Loan (FFEL) Program''.
Sponsor: Rep. Lisa McClain (MI)
Disposition: H.J. Res. 88 was ordered to be favorably
reported to the House, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 19 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-253 was filed on October
25, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 4957, the Department of Labor
Succession Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Kevin Kiley (CA)
Disposition: H.R. 4957 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 19 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-254 was filed on October
25, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5339, the Roll back ESG To Increase
Retirement Earnings Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Rick Allen (GA)
Disposition: H.R. 5339 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 19 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-225 was filed on
September 26, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5337, the Retirement Proxy
Protection Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Erin Houchin (IN)
Disposition: H.R. 5337 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 19 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-227 was filed on
September 26, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5338, the No Discrimination in My
Benefits Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Bob Good (VA)
Disposition: H.R. 5338 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 19 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-226 was filed on
September 26, 2023.
September 14, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5340, the Providing Complete
Information to Retirement Investors Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Jim Banks (IN)
Disposition: H.R. 5340 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 19 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-224 was filed on
September 26, 2023.
November 8, 2023--Markup of H.R. 5933, the Defending Education
Transparency and Ending Rogue Regimes Engaging in Nefarious
Transactions Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Michelle Steel (CA)
Disposition: H.R. 5933 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 27 Yeas and 11 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-278 was filed on
November 24, 2023.
December 12, 2023--Markup of H.R. 6585, the Bipartisan Workforce Pell
Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Elise Stefanik (NY)
Disposition: H.R. 6585 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 37 Yeas and 8 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-337 was filed on
December 22, 2023.
December 12, 2023--Markup of H.R. 6655, A Stronger Workforce for
America Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Virginia Foxx (NC)
Disposition: H.R. 6655 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 44 Yeas and 1 Nay.
Committee Report: House Report 118-444 was filed on April
5, 2024.
December 12, 2023--Markup of H.J. Res. 98, Providing for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the National Labor Relations Board
relating to ``Standard for Determining Joint Employer Status''.
Sponsor: Rep. John James (MI)
Disposition: H.J. Res. 98 was ordered to be favorably
reported to the House, by a vote of 25 Yeas and 20 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-338 was filed on January
3, 2024.
December 12, 2023--Markup of H.R. 3400, the Small Businesses before
Bureaucrats Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Bob Good (VA)
Disposition: H.R. 3400 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 23 Yeas and 20 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-343 was filed on January
11, 2024.
January 10, 2024--Markup of H.R. 6914, the Pregnant Students' Rights
Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Ashley Hinson (IA)
Disposition: H.R. 6914 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 24 Yeas and 17 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-344 was filed on January
12, 2024.
January 10, 2024--Markup of H.R. 443, the Enhancing Detection of Human
Trafficking Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Tim Walberg (MI)
Disposition: H.R. 443 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 42 Yeas and 0 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-355 was filed on January
25, 2024.
January 31, 2024--Markup of H.R. 6951, the College Cost Reduction Act.
Sponsor: Rep. Virginia Foxx (NC)
Disposition: H.R. 6951 was ordered to be favorably reported
to the House, as amended, by a vote of 22 Yeas and 19 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-739 was filed on
November 18, 2024.
March 21, 2024--Markup of H.J. Res. 116, Providing for congressional
disapproval under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of
the rule submitted by the Department of the Labor relating to
``Employee or Independent Contractor Classification Under the
Fair Labor Standards Act''.
Sponsor: Rep. Kevin Kiley (CA)
Disposition: H.J. Res. 116 was ordered to be favorably
reported to the House, by a vote of 21 Yeas and 13 Nays.
Committee Report: House Report 118-445 was filed on April
5, 2024.
March 21, 2024--Markup of H.R. 6418, the Empower Charter School
Minority Views
Introduction
Representative Robert C. ``Bobby'' Scott (D-VA) is the
Ranking Member (Ranking Member Scott) of the U.S. House of
Representatives (House) Committee on Education and the
Workforce (Committee). Ranking Member Scott is committed to
building an America where everyone can succeed, not just the
wealthy few.
During the 118th Congress, the Committee's Democratic
Members (Committee Democrats)--led by Early Childhood,
Elementary, and Secondary Education (ECESE) Subcommittee
Ranking Member Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR) (ECESE Subcommittee
Ranking Member Bonamici); Higher Education and Workforce
Development (HEWD) Subcommittee Ranking Member Frederica Wilson
(D-FL) (HEWD Subcommittee Ranking Member Wilson); Health,
Employment, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Subcommittee Ranking
Member Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA) (HELP Subcommittee Ranking Member
DeSaulnier); and Workforce Protections (WP) Subcommittee
Ranking Member Alma Adams (D-NC) (WP Subcommittee Ranking
Member Adams)--relied on research and evidence to improve the
lives of children, students, workers, families, and retirees.
It is worth noting that upon taking the House Majority in
the 118th Congress, the Republicans eliminated the Committee's
Subcommittee on Civil Rights and Human Resources. The issues
that previously fell under that subcommittee's jurisdiction
remain with the Committee, and they have been doled out under
the rubric of the other subcommittees. However, considering the
number of civil rights issues within the Committee's
jurisdiction, and the number of civil rights-related offices
over which the Committee has oversight authority, it is an
unfortunate statement of priorities.
Over the last two years, Committee Democrats put people
over politics. They worked with the Biden Administration and
across the aisle to address longstanding inequities in
education and provide quality educational opportunities, expand
access to quality and affordable health care, and promote safe
and inclusive workplaces where workers can earn a living wage
and collectively bargain. Next Congress, Committee Democrats
will continue to champion policies that empower working
families and drive sustainable growth. The path forward is one
of opportunity, equity, and shared success for all.
EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION AND CHILD CARE
Research is clear on the short- and long-term positive
outcomes of quality preschool and child care programs. Quality
programs can help close achievement gaps in elementary and
secondary education and provide significant returns on
investment throughout a child's life. Access to affordable
child care enables families to more fully participate in the
labor market without jeopardizing their financial security.
Committee Democrats continued their commitment to improving
access to early childhood education during the 118th Congress.
On April 27, 2023, Ranking Member Scott, Representative
Susan Wild (D-PA), and other House and U.S. Senate (Senate)
colleagues introduced H.R. 2976 (S. 1354), the Child Care for
Working Families Act that would ensure that working families
pay no more than seven percent of their income for child care,
early childhood educators earn livable wages, and families have
more child care options in their communities. The legislation
would make high-quality child care affordable for families and
address the child care shortages that have made it difficult
for families to find an open child care slot. Committee
Republicans declined to mark up H.R. 2976.
On September 13, 2023, House Democratic Whip Katherine
Clark (D-MA), Senator Patty Murray (D-WA), Ranking Member
Scott, other House and Senate colleagues introduced H.R. 5433
(S. 2777), the Child Care Stabilization Act, which would
preserve vital childcare stabilization funding secured by
congressional Democrats in the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA).
The legislation would keep childcare providers afloat, preserve
child care slots for millions of children, and help ensure
access to quality and affordable child care for working
families before the funding expired on September 30, 2023.
Committee Republicans declined to mark up H.R. 5433. Inaction
on this bill will result in denying the child care sector an
additional $16 billion in child care funding annually over the
next five years.
K-12 EDUCATION
A strong K-12 education system is essential to ensuring our
children have the fundamental tools to grow into skillful,
productive members of society and maintaining U.S.
competitiveness. Every student should be able to succeed in a
safe, welcoming, and well-funded learning environment. This
Congress, Committee Democrats fought against the politicization
of classrooms and supported students, parents, educators, and
communities to ensure that schools provide an accurate and
high-quality education.
State of Education
On February 8, 2023, the Committee used its first hearing
this Congress to discuss the state of education in America.
Committee Democrats called Colorado Governor, and former
Committee Member, Jared Polis, as their witness. Throughout the
hearing, Gov. Polis and Committee Democrats countered
Republicans' extreme education agenda by contrasting House
Republicans' efforts to undermine public education, with House
Democrats' accomplishments for students, educators, and parents
over the previous Congresses.
Fighting Against Politics Over Parents
On March 8, 2023, the Committee's Republican Majority
(Committee Republicans) used their first markup to roll out
legislative attacks on our nation's public schools by
considering H.R. 5, the Parents Bill of Rights Act. Despite its
misleading name, H.R. 5 in actuality would facilitate efforts
to ban books, whitewash school curricula, and target school
board members, effectively politicizing schools rather than
making them inclusive and safe spaces for teaching and
learning. Moreover, the provisions of H.R. 5 that did not
incentivize such politicization were largely duplicative of
current law, would do little to actually address students'
well-being. Further, the provisions in the bill exemplified the
type of federal overreach congressional Republicans have long
claimed would harm children, teachers, and schools. Committee
Democrats offered 30 amendments to promote policies that would
help students and teachers succeed, 26 of which were rejected
by Committee Republicans. On March 23-24, 2023, Committee
Democrats opposed the bill during its consideration on the
House floor. During that debate, H.R. 5 was exposed as a
political stunt to undermine public education, compared to
ECESE Subcommittee Ranking Member Bonamici's substantive
alternative that would truly support parental engagement and
student success. House Democrats were unified in their
opposition to H.R. 5 and convinced five House Republicans to
oppose its passage, making H.R. 5's opposition bipartisan.
While H.R. 5 ultimately passed the House, it was not taken up
by the Senate.
Protecting Public Schools
On April 18, 2023, the ECESE Subcommittee held a hearing
during which Committee Republicans pressed for increased
parental school choice, advocating for programs that divert
funds from public education to subsidize tuition and fees at
private schools in various forms. Committee Democrats drew a
clear contrast between Republicans' support for low-quality
school choice programs that divert funds from public education,
lack accountability, provide unequal access to educational
opportunities, permit discrimination, potentially increase
racial and socioeconomic segregation, and fail to improve
student achievement, and Democrats' support for investments in
high-quality public schools that serve all students.
On June 6, 2023, Committee Republicans, as part of their
extreme anti-immigrant platform, marked up a non-binding
resolution, H. Res. 461, Condemning the use of elementary and
secondary school facilities to provide shelter for aliens who
are not admitted to the United States, which would condemn
schools for providing shelter for undocumented immigrants.
Committee Democrats highlighted the long history of schools
being used to shelter people, including in, but not limited to,
weather related emergencies. They also highlighted the U.S.
Supreme Court's decision in Plyler v. Doe, which held that
children who are not legally admitted to the country have the
right to a free public education under the Equal Protection
Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. On June 22, 2023, the
Majority brought H. Res. 461 to the House floor. Committee
Democrats emphasized that House Republicans were yet again
wasting floor time fostering culture wars and advocating
policies that would deny people in need even the most basic
physiological human needs.
On June 13, 2023, Committee Republicans took their
obsession with schools sheltering undocumented immigrants a
step further and marked up a bill, H.R. 3941, the Schools Not
Shelters Act. This bill would prohibit public schools and
institutions of higher education that receive federal financial
assistance from being used to provide shelter or housing for
undocumented immigrants as a condition of receiving such
financial assistance from the U.S. Department of Education
(ED). Committee Democrats denounced the Republicans'
politicization of schools and threats to remove vital funding
from public schools and institutions of higher education while
offering nothing to improve education. During the markup,
Representative Mark Takano (D-CA) offered an amendment to the
bill to affirm the U.S. Supreme Court's holding in Plyler v.
Doe. Committee Republicans rejected the amendment. On July 18-
19, 2023, the bill proceeded to the House floor. Curiously,
during the floor debate, there was no condemnation of schools
that have been used to house other populations of individuals
(e.g., prisoners) in the past. The absurdity of the bill was
further expressed when Ranking Member Scott pointed out the
bill only prohibited the use of schools as ``emergency''
shelters, leaving open the question of whether a school could
establish permanent, non-emergency shelter for undocumented
immigrants and retain federal funding. While the bill passed,
nearly 95% of House Democrats opposed its passage, and H.R.
3941 was not taken up by the Senate.
On March 6, 2024, the ECESE Subcommittee held a hearing
about charter schools that once again drew a contrast between
Committee Democrats' and Committee Republicans' views on public
education. Committee Democrats spoke about the importance of a
well-funded, well-regulated public school system and explained
their support for high-quality, equitable educational
opportunities for all students. This vision includes
accountable, non-profit charter schools as examples of quality
public school choice options. In contrast, Committee
Republicans expressed support for rapid and unchecked expansion
of charter schools as part of a broader school choice agenda.
This agenda includes allowing for-profit corporations to
operate publicly-funded charter schools and the conversion of
non-charter public schools to charter management. At the same
time, Committee Republicans dismiss concerns regarding the
adverse impact of choice policies on the public system's
ability to deliver a quality education to every child.
Following shortly after that hearing, on March 21, 2024,
Committee Republicans marked up H.R. 6418, the Empower Charter
School Educators to Lead Act. H.R. 6418 would permit the use of
federal charter school funding by charter school developers or
entities assisting charter school developers for pre-planning
grants to develop ideas for charter schools with the goal of
expanding school choice. While support for the bill was
bipartisan, the majority of Committee Democrats opposed the
legislation as an unnecessary expansion of current law, which
already permits planning grants when a developer is working
with a charter authorizer. They also expressed concerns about
the increased opportunities for waste, fraud, and abuse of
government funding H.R. 6418 could cause given that the bill
lacks necessary, relevant guardrails against such malfeasance.
While the bill was reported out of Committee favorably over
Democratic objections, Republican leadership declined to
consider H.R. 6418 on the House floor.
On June 4, 2024, the ECESE Subcommittee held a hearing in
which Committee Republicans attempted to scapegoat migrant
children for the chronic underfunding of K-12 schools. ECESE
Subcommittee Ranking Member Bonamici and Committee Democrats
used the hearing to remind Committee Republicans that access to
firearms is the greatest risk to school safety. They also
refuted arguments blaming migrant children for the underfunding
of K-12 schools, showing instead that Republican-backed voucher
programs are the biggest drain on public education funds.
Committee Democrats again decried efforts to undermine Plyler
v. Doe, the Supreme Court decision that affirmed access to
public education is a fundamental right, regardless of a
student's immigration status.
Addressing Foreign Influence While Combating Anti-Asian Rhetoric in K-
12 Education
On September 19, 2023, Committee Republicans continued
their politicization of public education, holding a hearing
whose title, Academic Freedom Under Attack: Loosening the CCP's
Grip on America's Classrooms, suggested that the People's
Republic of China controlled America's schools. Ranking Member
Scott, ECESE Subcommittee Ranking Member Bonamici, and other
Committee Democrats condemned Committee Republicans for holding
yet another culture war-focused hearing as part of their
extremist agenda. Committee Democrats reminded Committee
Republicans that Congress can raise legitimate security
concerns about the Chinese Communist Party without weaponizing
education or pursuing baseless conspiracy theories that result
in discrimination against Chinese and Chinese-American people
and fuel anti-Asian bias. Committee Democrats believe that our
nation's K-12 schools should embrace and celebrate the
diversity of their students, teachers, and staff. Committee
Democrats also highlighted that actual foreign security threats
are outside the jurisdiction of the Committee.
On June 13, 2024, Committee Republicans marked up H.R.
6816, the Promoting Responsible Oversight To Eliminate
Communist Teachings (PROTECT) for Our Kids Act. Committee
Republicans justified the bill's consideration by falling back
on their specious claims relating to Chinese influence and
interference in K-12 schools. Ranking Member Scott noted that
considering legislation likely to increase anti-Asian sentiment
while doing absolutely nothing to protect our children or
enhance learning outcomes in schools is a poor use of the
Committee's time. Ranking Member Scott then offered an
amendment that would give Committee Republicans an opportunity
to live up to their outsized claims, authorizing $300 million
in appropriations to fund this initiative they considered so
vital and necessary; however, Committee Republicans rejected
this amendment. While the bill was reported out of Committee
favorably over Democratic objections, Republican leadership
declined to consider H.R. 6816 on the House floor.
In that same June 13, 2024, markup, the Committee also
considered H.R. 5567, the Combating the Lies of Authoritarians
in School Systems (CLASS) Act. This bill would limit federal
funding for schools that receive more than $10,000 from foreign
sources in an effort to reduce foreign influence in K-12 public
schools. Committee Democrats unanimously opposed the
legislation as it would add another item to an already long to-
do list for elementary and secondary school administrators
without providing them any additional financial resources.
Ranking Member Scott offered an amendment that would authorize
$300 million in appropriations to fund this initiative;
however, Committee Republicans did not accept the amendment.
While the bill was reported out of Committee favorably over
Democratic objections, Republican leadership declined to
consider H.R. 5567 on the House floor.
The June 13, 2024, markup also included consideration of
H.R. 8649, the Transparency in Reporting of Adversarial
Contributions to Education (TRACE) Act. This bill would
establish numerous unnecessary and burdensome requirements
related to potential influence and espionage by foreign
adversaries. Under H.R. 8649, state and local educational
agencies would have to comply with these requirements in order
to receive federal education funds under the Elementary and
Secondary Education Act. Committee Democrats again condemned
the bill for feeding into Committee Republicans' culture wars
narrative without any credible evidence to support their
claims. If made into law, H.R. 8649 would create administrative
confusion for public schools, severely penalizing public
schools if they fail to meet the requirements of the bill
whether intentionally or accidentally. Taken with the other
bills marked up in this meeting, Committee Republicans
translated their extremist rhetoric into policies that would
have a chilling effect on states, districts, and schools
engaging in international and cultural exchange opportunities.
Ranking Member Scott, recognizing the administrative burden
public schools would face under H.R. 8649, offered an amendment
to provide funds to assist schools in complying with the bill;
Committee Republicans rejected the amendment on a party-line
vote. While the bill was reported out of Committee favorably
over Democratic objections, Republican leadership declined to
consider H.R. 8649 on the House floor.
School Discipline
On May 18, 2023, Ranking Member Scott joined Representative
Donald Beyer (D-VA) to reintroduce H.R. 3470, the Keeping All
Students Safe Act. This bill would help eliminate
discriminatory school discipline by prohibiting dangerous
seclusion and restraint practices in classrooms and help
schools adopt evidence-based practices to address student
behavior. Committee Republicans declined to mark up H.R. 3470.
Addressing Learning Recovery Post-Pandemic
On July 26, 2023, the ECESE Subcommittee held a hearing
during which Committee Republicans decried school closures
during the COVID-19 pandemic and expressed concerns about how
some schools used their COVID-19 relief funds. Committee
Democrats asserted that now is the time to look forward and
address the consequences of lost instructional time as well as
pre-existing achievement gaps and other challenges for our
nation's students that were exacerbated by the COVID-19
pandemic. They highlighted the historic investments in
education made by President Biden and congressional Democrats
that are currently aiding students, parents, and teachers in
addressing these issues. Committee Democrats also highlighted
the devastating cuts to critical education funding proposed by
congressional Republicans and the need to invest in public
education to enhance student success.
Establishing Commission to Study Indian Boarding Schools
On February 5, 2024, H.R. 7227, the Truth and Healing
Commission on Indian Boarding School Policies Act of 2024 was
introduced by Representatives Sharice Davids (D-KS) and Tom
Cole (R-OK). This bill establishes a Truth and Healing
Commission on Indian Boarding School Policies to investigate
and report on the history of Indian Boarding School abuses and
discriminatory policies and their