Dissenting Views
[GRAPHIC NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
January 2, 2025.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
__________
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
57-871 WASHINGTON : 2025
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
----------
House of Representatives,
Committee on Natural Resources,
Washington, DC, January 2, 2025.
Hon. Kevin F. McCumber,
Acting Clerk of the House of Representatives,
Washington, DC.
Dear Mr. McCumber: In accordance with rule XI l(d)(l) of
the House of Representatives, I hereby submit the Report on the
Activities of the Committee on Natural Resources for the 118th
Congress. This report summarizes the specific activities of the
Committee with respect to its legislative and oversight
responsibilities, and encompasses the period of January 3,
2023, through January 2, 2025.
Sincerely,
Bruce Westerman,
Chairman.
COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Full Committee Membership
(Ratio: 25 Republicans, 20 Democrats)
BRUCE WESTERMAN, Arkansas, Chairman
RAUL M. GRIJALVA, Arizona, Ranking Democratic Member
DOUG LAMBORN, Colorado GRACE F. NAPOLITANO, California
ROBERT J. WITTMAN, Virginia GREGORIO KILILI CAMACHO SABLAN,
TOM McCLINTOCK, California CNMI
PAUL A. GOSAR, Arizona JARED HUFFMAN, California
GARRET GRAVES, Louisiana RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona
AUMUA AMATA C. RADEWAGEN, JOE NEGUSE, Colorado
American Samoa MIKE LEVIN, California
DOUG LaMALFA, California KATIE PORTER, California
DANIEL WEBSTER, Florida TERESA LEGER FERNANDEZ, New Mexico
JENNIFFER GONZALEZ-COLON, MELANIE STANSBURY, New Mexico
Puerto Rico MARY PELTOLA, Alaska
RUSS FULCHER, Idaho ALEXANDRIA OCASIO-CORTEZ, New York
PETE STAUBER, Minnesota KEVIN MULLIN, California
JOHN R. CURTIS, Utah VAL HOYLE, OREGON
TOM TIFFANY, Wisconsin SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California
JERRY CARL, Alabama SETH MAGAZINER, Rhode Island
MATT ROSENDALE, Montana NYDIA VELAZQUEZ, New York
LAUREN BOEBERT, Colorado ED CASE, Hawaii
CLIFF BENTZ, Oregon DEBBIE DINGELL, Michigan
JEN KIGGANS, Virginia SUSIE LEE, Nevada
JIM MOYLAN, Guam
WESLEY P. HUNT, Texas
MIKE COLLINS, Georgia
ANNA PAULINA LUNA, Florida
JOHN DUARTE, California
HARRIET M. HAGEMAN, Wyoming
----------
On January 10, 2023, pursuant to H. Res. 14, Chairman Bruce Westerman
of Arkansas was elected to the Committee.
On January 10, 2023, pursuant to H. Res. 15, Ranking Member Raul M.
Grijalva of Arizona was elected to the Committee.
On January 31, 2023, pursuant to H. Res. 80, Majority (Republican)
Members (24) were elected to the Committee.
On January 31, 2023, pursuant to H. Res. 79, Minority (Democrat)
Members (19) were elected to the Committee.
On February 27, 2023, Rep. Jim Costa of California resigned from the
Committee. (Cong. Record Vol. 169, No. 37)
On February 27, 2023, pursuant to H. Res. 164, Rep. Susie Lee of Nevada
was elected to the Committee.
Vivian Moeglein, Staff Director
Chris Marklund, Deputy Staff Director
Thomas Connally, Chief Counsel
William David, Deputy Chief Counsel
Sophia Varnasidis, Director of Legislative Operations
Lora Snyder, Democratic Staff Director
Luis Urbina, Democratic Counsel
STANDING SUBCOMMITTEES OF THE COMMITTEE
ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Subcommittee on Energy and Mineral Resources
(Ratio: 14 Republicans, 12 Democrats)
PETE STAUBER, Minnesota, Chairman
ALEXANDRIA OCASIO-CORTEZ, New
York, Ranking Member
JARED HUFFMAN, California DOUG LAMBORN, Colorado
KEVIN MULLIN, California ROB WITTMAN, Virginia
SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California PAUL GOSAR, Arizona
SETH MAGAZINER, Rhode Island GARRET GRAVES, Louisiana
NYDIA M. VELAZQUEZ, New York DANIEL WEBSTER, Florida
DEBBIE DINGELL, Michigan RUSS FULCHER, Idaho
RAUL GRIJALVA, Arizona JOHN CURTIS, Utah
GRACE F. NAPOLITANO, California TOM TIFFANY, Wisconsin
SUSIE LEE, Nevada MATT ROSENDALE, Montana
Vacancy LAUREN BOEBERT, Colorado
Vacancy WESLEY P. HUNT, Texas, Vice-Chair
MIKE COLLINS, Georgia
JOHN DUARTE, California
BRUCE WESTERMAN, Arkansas, (Ex
officio)
Subcommittee on Federal Lands
(Ratio: 9 Republicans, 7 Democrats)
TOM TIFFANY, Wisconsin, Chairman
JOE NEGUSE, Colorado, Ranking
Member
KATIE PORTER, California DOUG LAMBORN, Colorado
SYDNEY KAMLAGER-DOVE, California TOM McCLINTOCK, California
GREGORIO KILILI CAMACHO SABLAN, CNMI RUSS FULCHER, Idaho
MIKE LEVIN, California PETE STAUBER, Minnesota
TERESA LEGER FERNANDEZ, New Mexico JOHN CURTIS, Utah, Vice-Chair
MARY PELTOLA, Alaska CLIFF BENTZ, Oregon
RAUL GRIJALVA, Arizona, (Ex officio) JEN KIGGANS, Virgina
JIM MOYLAN, Guam
BRUCE WESTERMAN, Arkansas, (Ex
officio)
Subcommittee on Indian and Insular Affairs
(Ratio: 6 Republicans, 5 Democrats)
HARRIET M. HAGEMAN, Wyoming, Chair
TERESA LEGER FERNANDEZ, New Mexico, Ranking Member
AUMUA AMATA COLEMAN RADEWAGEN, GREGORIO KILILI CAMACHO SABLAN,
American Samoa CNMI
DOUG LaMALFA, California RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona
JENNIFFER GONZALEZ-COLON, NYDIA M. VELAZQUEZ, New York
Puerto Rico, Vice-Chair ED CASE, Hawaii
JERRY CARL, Alabama RAUL GRIJALVA, Arizona, (Ex
JIM MOYLAN, Guam officio)
BRUCE WESTERMAN, Arkansas, (Ex
officio)
Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations
(Ratio: 5 Republicans, 4 Democrats)
PAUL GOSAR, Arizona, Chairman
MELANIE STANSBURY, New Mexico, Ranking Member
MATT ROSENDALE, Montana ED CASE, Hawaii
WESLEY P. HUNT, Texas RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona
MIKE COLLINS, Georgia, Vice-Chair SUSIE LEE, Nevada
ANNA PAULINA LUNA, Florida RAUL GRIJALVA, Arizona, (Ex
BRUCE WESTERMAN, Arkansas, (Ex officio)
officio)
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries
(Ratio: 14 Republicans, 12 Democrats)
CLIFF BENTZ, Oregon, Chairman
JARED HUFFMAN, California, Ranking Member
ROB WITTMAN, Virginia GRACE F. NAPOLITANO, California
TOM McCLINTOCK, California MIKE LEVIN, California
GARRET GRAVES, Louisiana MARY PELTOLA, Alaska
AUMUA AMATA COLEMAN RADEWAGEN, KEVIN MULLIN, California
American Samoa VAL HOYLE, Oregon
DOUG LaMALFA, California SETH MAGAZINER, Rhode Island
DANIEL WEBSTER, Florida DEBBIE DINGELL, Michigan
JENNIFFER GONZALEZ-COLON, RUBEN GALLEGO, Arizona
Puerto Rico JOE NEGUSE, Colorado
JERRY CARL, Alabama KATIE PORTER, California
LAUREN BOEBERT, Colorado ED CASE, Hawaii
JEN KIGGANS, Virginia, Vice-Chair RAUL GRIJALVA, Arizona, (Ex
ANNA PAULINA LUNA, Florida officio)
JOHN DUARTE, California
HARRIET M. HAGEMAN, Wyoming
BRUCE WESTERMAN, Arkansas, (Ex
officio)
STAFF ROSTER
Full Committee Staff
Majority
1324 Longworth HOB, (202) 225-2761
Vivian Moeglein, Staff Director
Chris Marklund, Deputy Staff Director
Tom Connally, Chief Counsel
William David, Deputy Counsel
Sophia Varnasidis, Director of Legislative Operations
Ilene Clauson, Director of Operations
Madeline Kelley, Director of Member Services
Rebekah Hoshiko, Communications Director
Bailey Mailloux, Digital Director and Deputy Communications Director
John Seibels, Press Secretary
Anna Mathis, Press Assistant
Jackson Renfro, Staff Assistant
David Demarco, Director of Information Technology
Janna Pinckney, Deputy Director of Information Technology
Darlene McDermott, GPO Detailee
Minority
1332 Longworth HOB, (202) 225-6065
Lora Snyder, Democratic Staff Director
Matthew Muirragui, Deputy Staff Director
Luis Urbina, Chief Counsel
Maria Oparil, Deputy Parliamentarian
Rachel Jones, Legislative Operations Manager
Carlos Martinez, Senior Executive Assistant
Marilyn Zepeda, Director of Outreach and Engagement
Christian Hollowell, Member Services Senior Associate
Lindsay Gressard, Communications Director
Jason Johnson, Communications Advisor
Sebastian Pons, Digital Manager
Subcommittee Staff
Subcommittee on Energy and Mineral Resources
1333 Longworth HOB, (202) 225-9297
Rob MacGregor, Staff Director
Jeanne Kuehl, Professional Staff
Will King, Professional Staff
Lonnie Smith, Legislative Assistant
Jacob Greenberg, Clerk
Sarina Weiss, Democratic Staff Director
Kelsey Hartman, Democratic Professional Staff
Subcommittee on Federal Lands
1329 Longworth HOB, (202) 226-7736
Aniela Butler, Staff Director
Brandon Miller, Professional Staff
Taylor Wiseman, Professional Staff
Jason Blore, Counsel
Colen Morrow, Legislative Assistant
Will Rodriguez, Clerk
Brandon Bragato, Democratic Staff Director
Rachel Lentz, Democratic Professional Staff
Qay-Liwh Ammon, Democratic Professional Staff
Subcommittee on Indian and Insular Affairs
1328 Longworth HOB, (202) 226-9725
Ken Degenfelder, Staff Director
Jocelyn Broman, Professional Staff
Justin Rhee, Professional Staff
Kirstin Liddell, Legislative Assistant
Ransom Fox, Legislative Assistant
Haig Kadian, Clerk
Bobby Ahern, Democratic Staff Director, Indian Affairs
Brian Modeste, Democratic Staff Director, Insular Affairs
Ivan Robles, Democratic Professional Staff
Qay-Liwh Ammon, Democratic Professional Staff
Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations
1331 Longworth HOB, (202) 225-2761
Michelle Lane, Staff Director
Lucas Drill, Counsel
James Lundquist, Professional Staff
Andrew Bambrick, Legislative Assistant
Cross Thompson, Clerk
Vic Edgerton, Democratic Staff Director
Ivan Robles, Democratic Professional Staff
Carolina Morgan, GAO Detailee
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries
1522 Longworth HOB, (202) 225-8331
Annick Miller, Staff Director
Doug Levine, Professional Staff
Kirby Struhar, Professional Staff
Thomas Shipman, Legislative Assistant
Lindsay Walton, Clerk
Rachel Gentile, Democratic Staff Director
Qay-Liwh Ammon, Democratic Professional Staff
C O N T E N T S
----------
Page
Letter of Transmittal............................................ III
Committee Organization........................................... IV
Staff Roster..................................................... VII
Jurisdiction of the Committee.................................... 1
Rules for the Committee.......................................... 2
Statistical Overview of Legislative and Oversight Activities..... 16
Legislative, Oversight and Roundtable Activities
Full Committee:
Business Meetings and Markups............................ 17
Legislative Activities................................... 30
Oversight Activities..................................... 31
Forums and Roundtables................................... 31
Subcommittee on Energy and Mineral Resources:
Legislative Activities................................... 32
Oversight Activities..................................... 35
Subcommittee on Federal Lands:
Legislative Activities................................... 36
Oversight Activities..................................... 45
Subcommittee on Indian and Insular Affairs:
Legislative Activities................................... 46
Oversight Activities..................................... 49
Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations:
Oversight Activities..................................... 50
Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries:
Legislative Activities................................... 51
Oversight Activities..................................... 59
Indo-Pacific Task Force:
Oversight Activities..................................... 60
Appendices:
I. Summary of Activities and Accomplishments.......................61
II. Printed Hearings................................................79
III. Committee Bill Reports Filed...................................111
IV. Legislation Passed the House...................................123
V. Public Laws Enacted............................................131
VI. Committee Prints...............................................135
VII. Dissenting Views...............................................137
Union Calendar No. 824
118th Congress, 2d Session----------------------HOUSE REPORT 118-977
======================================================================
REPORT ON THE ACTIVITIES OF THE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES 118TH
CONGRESS
_______
January 2, 2025.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
_______
Mr. Westerman of Arkansas, from the Committee on Natural Resources,
submitted the following
R E P O R T
together with
Dissenting Views
_______
Overview
The Committee on Natural Resources met on February 1, 2023,
for an organizational meeting of the 118th Congress under the
direction of Chairman Bruce Westerman. The Committee Membership
was 45 Members with 25 Republicans and 20 Democrats.
The Committee established five subcommittees: Energy and
Mineral Resources (Pete Stauber, Chairman); Federal Lands (Tom
Tiffany, Chairman); Indian and Insular Affairs (Harriet
Hageman, Chair); Oversight and Investigations (Paul Gosar,
Chairman); and Water, Wildlife and Fisheries (Cliff Bentz,
Chairman).
Jurisdiction
The jurisdiction of the Committee on Natural Resources, as
prescribed by clause (m)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House
is as follows:
(1) Fisheries and wildlife, including research,
restoration, refuges, and conservation.
(2) Forest reserves and national parks created from the
public domain.
(3) Forfeiture of land grants and alien ownership,
including alien ownership of mineral lands.
(4) Geological Survey.
(5) International fishing agreements.
(6) Interstate compacts relating to apportionment of waters
for irrigation purposes.
(7) Irrigation and reclamation, including water supply for
reclamation projects and easements of public lands for
irrigation projects; and acquisition of private lands when
necessary to complete irrigation projects.
(8) Native Americans generally, including the care and
allotment of Native American lands and general and special
measures relating to claims that are paid out of Native
American funds.
(9) Insular areas of the United States generally (except
those affecting the revenue and appropriations).
(10) Military parks and battlefields, national cemeteries
administered by the Secretary of the Interior, parks within the
District of Columbia, and the erection of monuments to the
memory of individuals.
(11) Mineral land laws and claims and entries thereunder.
(12) Mineral resources of public lands.
(13) Mining interests generally.
(14) Mining schools and experimental stations.
(15) Marine affairs, including coastal zone management
(except for measures relating to oil and other pollution of
navigable waters).
(16) Oceanography.
(17) Petroleum conservation on public lands and
conservation of the radium supply in the United States.
(18) Preservation of prehistoric ruins and objects of
interest on the public domain.
(19) Public lands generally, including entry, easements,
and the grazing thereon.
(20) Relations of the United States with Native Americans
and Native American tribes.
(21) Trans-Alaska Oil Pipeline (except ratemaking).
Rules for the Committee on Natural Resources
U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
118TH CONGRESS
Adopted February 1, 2023
RULE 1. RULES OF THE HOUSE; VICE CHAIRS
(a) Applicability of House Rules.
(1) The Rules of the House of Representatives, so far
as they are applicable, are the rules of the Committee
on Natural Resources (hereinafter in these rules
referred to as the ``Committee'') and its
Subcommittees.
(2) Each Subcommittee is part of the Committee and is
subject to the authority, direction and rules of the
Committee. References in these rules to ``Committee''
and ``Chair'' shall apply to each subcommittee and its
Chair wherever applicable.
(3) House Rule XI is incorporated and made a part of
the rules of the Committee to the extent applicable.
(b) Vice Chair.--Unless inconsistent with other rules, the
Chair shall designate a Vice Chair of the Committee and appoint
Vice Chairs of the Subcommittees. If the Chair of the Committee
or Subcommittee is not present at any meeting of the Committee
or Subcommittee, as the case may be, the Vice Chair shall
preside. If the Vice Chair is not present, the Ranking Member
of the Majority party on the Committee or Subcommittee who is
present, or the Chair's designee, shall preside at that
meeting.
RULE 2. MEETINGS IN GENERAL
(a) Scheduled Meetings.--The Committee shall meet at 10
a.m. the first Wednesday of each month when the House is in
session if so noticed by the Chair under Committee Rule 3(a).
The Committee shall also meet at the call of the Chair subject
to advance notice to all Members of the Committee. Special
meetings shall be called and convened by the Chair as provided
in clause 2(c)(1) of House Rule XI. Any Committee meeting or
hearing that conflicts with a party caucus, conference, or
similar party meeting shall be rescheduled at the discretion of
the Chair, in consultation with the Ranking Minority Member.
The Committee may not sit during a joint session of the House
and Senate or during a recess when a joint meeting of the House
and Senate is in progress.
(b) Open Meetings.--Each meeting for the transaction of
business, including the markup of legislation, and each hearing
of the Committee or a Subcommittee shall be open to the public,
except as provided by clause 2(g) and clause 2(k) of House Rule
XI.
(c) Broadcasting.--Whenever a meeting for the transaction
of business, including the markup of legislation, or a hearing
is open to the public, that meeting or hearing shall be open to
coverage by audio and visual recordings in accordance with
clauses 2(a)(1) and 4 of House Rule XI. The provisions of
clause 4(f) of House Rule XI are specifically made part of
these rules by reference. To the maximum extent practicable,
the Committee shall provide audio and visual coverage of each
hearing or meeting for the transaction of business in a manner
that allows the public to easily listen to and view the
proceedings, and maintain the recordings of such coverage in a
manner that is easily accessible to the public. Operation and
use of any Committee internet broadcast system shall be fair,
and nonpartisan, and in accordance with clause 4(b) of House
Rule XI and all other applicable rules of the Committee and the
House.
(d) Authorization and Oversight Plan.--No later than March
1 of the first session of each Congress, the Committee shall
prepare and submit its authorization and oversight plan for
that Congress in accordance with clause 2(d) of House Rule X.
RULE 3. MEETING AND HEARING PROCEDURES IN GENERAL
(a) Notice and Information for Members and the Public.
(1) The Chair shall publicly announce the date, place
and subject matter of a Committee hearing or meeting in
accordance with clause 2(g)(3) of House Rule XI.
(2) A hearing or meeting may begin sooner if the
Chair, with the concurrence of the Ranking Minority
Member, determines that there is good cause to begin
the meeting or hearing sooner, or if the Committee so
determines by majority vote. In these cases, the Chair
shall publicly announce the meeting or hearing at the
earliest possible time. The Committee shall promptly
notify the Daily Digest Clerk of the Congressional
Record and shall promptly make publicly available in
electronic form the appropriate information as soon as
possible after the public announcement is made.
(3) To the extent practicable, a background
memorandum prepared by the Majority staff summarizing
the major provisions of any bill being considered by
the Committee, including the need for the bill and its
effect on current law, will be available for the
Members of the Committee and the public no later than
48 hours before the meeting.
(b) Public Availability of Markup Text.--At least 24 hours
prior to the markup of any legislation (or at the time of an
announcement under paragraph (a)(2) above made within 24 hours
before such meeting), the Chair shall cause the text of such
legislation to be made publicly available in electronic form.
(c) Meetings and Hearings to Begin Promptly.--Each meeting
or hearing of the Committee shall begin promptly at the time
stipulated in the public announcement of the meeting or
hearing.
(d) Addressing the Committee.--A Committee Member may
address the Committee or a Subcommittee on any bill, motion, or
other matter under consideration or may question a witness at a
hearing only when recognized by the Chair for that purpose. The
time a Member may address the Committee or Subcommittee for any
purpose or to question a witness shall be limited to five
minutes, except as provided in Committee Rule 4(f), and except
that the Chair may extend this time period equally for the
majority and minority party for the purpose of Members
questioning a witness who requires an interpreter. In
recognizing Members to question witnesses, the Chair shall take
into consideration the ratio of the Majority to Minority
Members present and shall establish the order of recognition
for questioning in a manner so as not to disadvantage the
Members of the Majority or the Members of the Minority. Members
shall limit remarks to the subject matter under consideration.
(e) Quorums.
(1) A majority of the Members of the Committee shall
constitute a quorum for the reporting of any measure or
recommendation, the authorizing of a subpoena under
Committee Rule 4(d); the closing of any meeting or
hearing to the public under clause 2(g)(1), clause
2(g)(2)(A) and clause 2(k)(5)(B) of House Rule XI; and
the releasing of executive session materials under
clause 2(k)(7) of House Rule XI. Testimony and evidence
may be received at any hearing at which there are at
least two Members of the Committee present. For the
purpose of transacting all other business of the
Committee, one-third of the Members shall constitute a
quorum.
(2) When a call of the roll is required to ascertain
the presence of a quorum, the offices of all Members
shall be notified, and the Members shall have not less
than 15 minutes to prove their attendance. The Chair
shall have the discretion to waive this requirement
when a quorum is actually present or whenever a quorum
is secured and may direct the Director of Legislative
Operations or their designee to note the names of all
Members present within the 15-minute period.
(f) Participation of Members in Committee and
Subcommittees.
(1) Any Member of the Committee may sit with any
Subcommittee during any meeting or hearing, and by
unanimous consent of the Members of the Subcommittee
may participate in such meeting or hearing. However, a
Member who is not a Member of the Subcommittee may not
vote on any matter before the Subcommittee, be counted
for purposes of establishing a quorum, or raise points
of order.
(2) Any Member of the House who is not a Member of
the Committee may sit with the full Committee or any
Subcommittee during any meeting or hearing, and by
unanimous consent of the Members of the Committee or
Subcommittee may participate in such meeting or
hearing. Unless otherwise provided by unanimous
consent, such participation includes but is not limited
to the right to seek recognition, to submit materials
for the record as described in Committee Rule 3(o), and
to introduce a constituent witness as described in
Committee Rule 4(f)(1). However, a Member of the House
who is not a Member of the Committee may not vote on
any matter, be counted for purposes of establishing a
quorum, raise points of order, or offer motions.
(g) Proxies.--No vote in the Committee or its Subcommittees
may be cast by proxy.
(h) Recorded Votes.--Recorded votes shall be ordered on the
demand of one-fifth of the Members present, or by any Member in
the apparent absence of a quorum.
(i) Postponed Recorded Votes.
(1) Subject to paragraph (2), the Chair may, after
consultation with the Ranking Minority Member, postpone
further proceedings when a recorded vote is ordered on
the question of approving any measure or matter or
adopting an amendment. The Chair shall resume
proceedings on a postponed request at any time after
reasonable notice, but no later than the next meeting
day.
(2) Notwithstanding any intervening order for the
previous question, when proceedings resume on a
postponed question under paragraph (1), an underlying
proposition shall remain subject to further debate or
amendment to the same extent as when the question was
postponed.
(3) This rule shall apply to Subcommittee
proceedings.
(j) Privileged Motions.--A motion to recess from day to
day, a motion to recess subject to the call of the Chair
(within 24 hours), and a motion to dispense with the first
reading (in full) of a bill or resolution if printed or
electronic copies are available and have been properly
circulated by the Director of Legislative Operations or their
designee, are nondebatable motions of high privilege.
(k) Layover and Copy of Bill.--No measure or recommendation
reported by a Subcommittee shall be considered by the Committee
until two calendar days from the time of Subcommittee action.
No bill shall be considered by the Committee unless a copy has
been delivered to the office of each Member of the Committee
requesting a copy. These requirements may be waived by a
majority vote of the Committee at the time of consideration of
the measure or recommendation.
(l) Access to Dais and Conference Room.--Access to the
hearing rooms' daises (and to the conference rooms adjacent to
the Committee hearing rooms) shall be limited to Members of
Congress and employees of the Committee during a meeting or
hearing of the Committee, except that Committee Members'
personal staff may be present on the daises if their employing
Member is the author of a bill or amendment under consideration
by the Committee, but only during the time that the bill or
amendment is under active consideration by the Committee.
(m) Cellular Telephones and other Electronic Devices.--
During a meeting or hearing of the Committee, ringing or
audible sounds or conversational use of cellular telephones or
other electronic devices is prohibited on the Committee dais or
in the Committee hearing rooms.
(n) Motion to go to Conference with the Senate.--The Chair
may offer a motion under clause 1 of House Rule XXII whenever
the Chair considers it appropriate.
(o) Materials for Record.--Other than witness questions for
the hearing record, materials must be submitted within 10
business days following the last day of the hearing or meeting.
Witness questions for the hearing record must be submitted to
the Director of Legislative Operations or their designee within
3 business days following the last day of the hearing. The
materials submitted must address the subject matter of the
hearing or meeting. Only a Member of the Committee (including a
Member participating as provided in Committee Rule 3(f)) or an
invited witness may submit materials for inclusion in the
hearing or meeting record.
RULE 4. HEARING PROCEDURES
(a) Written Statement; Oral Testimony.--Witnesses who are
to appear before the Committee or a Subcommittee shall file
with the Director of Legislative Operations or their designee,
at least two business days before the day of their appearance,
a written statement of their proposed testimony, including to
the extent practicable English translations of any portions not
in English. Witnesses shall limit their oral presentation to a
five-minute summary of the written statement, unless the Chair,
in consultation with the Ranking Minority Member, extends this
time period. Subject to the approval of the Committee, the
Chair may waive oral testimony of any witness who has submitted
written testimony for the record. Any witness appearing before
the Committee shall remain available for questioning by the
Committee, unless excused by the Chair. In addition, a witness
appearing in a nongovernmental capacity shall file such
disclosure materials required by clause 2(g)(5) of House Rule
XI. Any witness appearing in a nongovernmental capacity shall
also disclose any current or pending litigation that involves
the Federal Government. Failure to comply with these disclosure
requirements may result in the exclusion of the written
testimony from the hearing record and/or the barring of an oral
presentation of the testimony. Disclosure materials may be
signed electronically.
(b) Minority Witnesses.--When any hearing is conducted by
the Committee or any Subcommittee upon any measure or matter,
the Minority party Members on the Committee or Subcommittee
shall be entitled, upon request to the Chair by a majority of
those Minority Members before the completion of the hearing, to
call witnesses selected by the Minority to testify with respect
to that measure or matter during at least one day of hearings
thereon.
(c) Information for Members.--After announcement of a
hearing, the Committee shall make available as soon as
practicable to all Members of the Committee a tentative witness
list and to the extent practicable the Majority staff shall
make publicly available a memorandum explaining the subject
matter of the hearing (including relevant legislative reports
and other necessary material). In addition, the Chair shall
make available to the Members of the Committee any official
reports from departments and agencies on the subject matter as
they are received.
(d) Subpoenas.
(1) The Chair of the Committee may authorize and
issue a subpoena under clause 2(m) of House Rule XI.
(2) The Committee may authorize and issue a subpoena
under clause 2(m) of House Rule XI if authorized by a
majority of the Members voting.
(3) Subpoenas shall be signed only by the Chair of
the Committee. Subpoenas may be served by any person
designated by the Chair.
(e) Oaths.--The Chair of the Committee, the Chairs of the
Subcommittees, or any Member designated by the Chair may
administer oaths to any witness before the Committee. All
witnesses appearing in hearings may be administered the
following oath by the Chair or his designee prior to receiving
the testimony: ``Do you solemnly swear or affirm, under penalty
of law, that the testimony that you are about to give is the
truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you
God?''
(f) Opening Statements; Questioning of Witnesses.
(1) Opening Statements may be made by the Chair and
the Ranking Member or their designee. Such Statements
shall be limited to five minutes in length. If a
witness scheduled to testify at any hearing of the
Committee is a constituent of a Member of the Committee
(including a Member participating under Committee Rule
3(f)), that Member may be recognized for up to 30
seconds to briefly introduce the witness at the
hearing.
(2) The questioning of witnesses in Committee and
Subcommittee hearings may be initiated by the Chair,
followed b
Dissenting Views
FULL COMMITTEE
During the 118th Congress, Committee Republicans failed to
address the most pressing challenges under the jurisdiction of
the House Committee on Natural Resources, including climate
change, the transition to clean energy, the protection of
endangered species, and the economic future of tribal, Native,
and Insular communities. Instead, Committee Republicans focused
their efforts on undercutting foundational environmental
protections and pursued a narrow, highly partisan agenda that
prioritized polluting industries over the public interest and
conservative ideology over science.
This Congress, Republicans renewed their support for
polluting industries under the guise of lowering energy costs
for American consumers. It is ironic then that in the face of
smoking-gun evidence of collusion between oil firms and OPEC to
raise gas prices for American consumers, Committee Republicans
focused mainly on advancing a fossil fuel wish list falsely
branded as ``permitting reform'' that continues a decades-old
effort to open our public lands and waters to irresponsible
development and fast-track unwise projects by gutting
environmental review and public input. If Republicans were
sincere in their calls for lower energy costs, perhaps they
should have focused their oversight efforts on polluting
industries' predatory practices, rather than giving additional
handouts to corporate polluters.
Nothing encapsulates Committee Republicans' priorities this
Congress more than H.R. 1, a shameless attempt to give massive
handouts to polluting industries and create new loopholes for
corporations to avoid accountability. Given that this
Republican-led House has been one of the most unproductive in
history, it is revealing that Republicans' signature piece of
legislation sought to put Americans in harm's way, gut our
bedrock environmental and public health laws, and ignore the
climate crisis. While Republicans wasted valuable time putting
polluters over people, Committee Democrats remain proud of our
significant accomplishments in the 117th Congress, including
delivering historic investments in climate action and clean
energy through the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). These
investments are creating jobs, cutting costs for working
families, and fighting climate change.
In addition to their partisan policy agenda, Republicans
allowed Committee events to spread hateful rhetoric. The
repeated amplification of white nationalist and anti-immigrant
rhetoric by the Committee is of significant concern, and
despite calls from Committee Democrats, Committee Republicans
have been unwilling to crack down on rhetoric that is connected
to acts of bigotry, intimidation, and violence. We hope that
Chairman Westerman will take an active stance to discourage
damaging and dangerous rhetoric in the Committee during the
119th Congress.
Below are our detailed Dissenting Views for the 118th
Congress Activities Report, which highlight these failures and
reflect our concern that Committee Republicans will continue to
prioritize polluters over people in the 119th Congress.
SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND MINERAL RESOURCES
Environmental Justice & Permitting
Throughout the 118th Congress, Republicans have pushed
their extreme deregulation agenda to weaken environmental
protections at the behest of polluting industries.
For over 50 years, the National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA) has ensured that federal projects and permitting are
well-informed and transparent. NEPA is designed to help the
federal government make informed decisions, encourage public
participation, and ensure government accountability. Public
participation is a central part of the NEPA process, allowing
agencies to directly obtain input from individuals who may be
affected by a federal action. NEPA and permit reviews conducted
under our environmental and public health laws protect
Americans against industry exploitation and dangerous
pollution, ensure a more responsible and accountable industry,
and prevent litigation down the road. NEPA reviews can help
mitigate a project's harmful environmental and community
impacts, improve project outcomes, and promote collaborative
planning and community buy-in on final decisions.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Never Eliminate Public Advice: NEPA Success Stories, Elly
Pepper, NRDC (Feb. 1, 2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This Congress, Committee Republicans have attacked NEPA
from all angles, from introducing a bill that uses the
Congressional Review Act to overturn the Council on
Environmental Quality NEPA Phase II regulations to extreme
legislation significantly weakening enforcement of nearly all
environmental and public health laws included in H.R. 1 and
later discussion drafts. When the federal government conducts
NEPA reviews incorrectly or does not consider essential impacts
and information, communities currently have six years after the
final action to sue for corrective action--Committee
Republicans have pushed to cut this to just 120 days.
Republicans claim that NEPA lawsuits and agency
inefficiencies delay projects, but it is permit applicants, not
federal agencies or lawsuits, that are most frequently the
cause of permit approval delays. The next most significant
cause of delays is insufficient funding. To address this,
Natural Resources Committee Democrats championed a historic
investment of more than $1 billion for federal permitting
offices at several federal agencies through the IRA. This
investment has already had a significant positive impact on
environmental reviews and will address legitimate, evidence-
based challenges faced in the environmental review process.
Despite the clear benefits of adequately funding our
agencies, Republicans want to continue slashing funding and
giving handouts to polluting industries while avoiding proper
analysis and community input.
Fossil Fuels
This Congress, Committee Republicans have pushed to
``unleash'' our energy potential by opening our public lands to
the oil and gas industry, even though the U.S. is already the
number one producer of oil and the number one producer and
exporter of gas in the world, and Americans don't see the
benefits. Rather than giving Americans lower energy prices, job
creation, or ``energy independence,'' we have high energy
prices and record-breaking profits for oil companies, declining
numbers of industry jobs, and public health and safety crises
concentrated primarily in environmental justice communities.
Between 2021 and 2023, the five largest U.S.-based oil
companies raked in more than $250 billion in profit, a 160
percent jump from 2017-2020,\2\ and are pumping those profits
into wealthy investors and executives. Big Oil also receives
hundreds of billions of dollars in taxpayer-funded subsidies
each year. According to the International Monetary Fund, in
2022, fossil fuel subsidies in the U.S. totaled $757 billion,
including health and environmental impacts.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Why oil companies are raking in record profits under Joe Biden,
CNN (June 11, 2024).
\3\International Monetary Fund, Fossil Fuel Subsidies (last visited
Dec. 4, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On top of the subsidy costs to taxpayers, Big Oil's price-
gouging may have cost individual Americans $500 per person per
year.\4\ In 2024, two FTC complaints and multiple class action
lawsuits alleged that Big Oil had been colluding with OPEC to
keep prices high, padding their profits at the expense of
American consumers.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Schumer and Senate Democrats call for Justice Department to
probe Big Oil for alleged collusion, CNN (May 30, 2024).
\5\House Committee on Natural Resources, Grijalva Statement on
Second Allegation of Big Oil Collusion with OPEC (Sept. 30, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many of the companies named in the class action lawsuits
hold federal oil and gas leases either onshore, offshore, or
both. Public lands and resources may have been purposefully
misused in the alleged collusion to price gouge Americans. In
July 2024, Committee Democrats sent a letter to the Department
of the Interior requesting information to confirm that if a
company was found civilly or criminally liable for the
allegations in the FTC complaint or lawsuit, it would be barred
from holding or obtaining federal leases. The letter also
inquired about more immediate steps DOI could take to protect
against corporate misuse of public lands and resources,
including pursuing suspension or debarment of irresponsible
companies. Since May 2024, Committee Democrats have been
repeatedly requesting for Committee Republicans to investigate
the allegations. Unfortunately, they have ignored the issue
completely.
Onshore Oil and Gas
This Congress, Committee Republicans have attempted to
overturn the Bureau of Land Management's new oil and gas
leasing rule, undo essential reforms from the IRA, and push oil
and gas destruction into sacred and sensitive areas like Chaco
Canyon and the Alaskan Arctic.
In April 2024, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM)
finalized a rule to modernize onshore oil and gas leasing,
implement reforms from the IRA, and update bonding requirements
to prevent taxpayers from bearing the cost of orphaned wells on
public land. Committee Republicans oppose the rule, arguing it
will increase costs and discourage investment, but recent state
experiences show otherwise. In Colorado and Texas, raising
royalty rates did not negatively impact production. Republicans
also misrepresent the orphan well issue, citing only 37 orphan
wells and 40 bond calls over the past decade, but this
overlooks the extensive time, resources, and staff required to
address non-producing wells, which pose increasing
environmental and public health risks the longer they are left
unplugged. The 2024 rule, which Republicans have sought to
overturn, strengthens tracking and enforcement to protect
communities from ongoing pollution by unplugged wells.
Throughout the 118th Congress, Committee Republicans have
pushed to expand oil and gas development in sensitive and
sacred areas. In New Mexico, the oil industry has caused
pollution and harmed Indigenous cultural sites, particularly in
the Chaco region. The Biden administration's withdrawal of
federal lands near Chaco Canyon, which Republicans
unsuccessfully tried to reverse, protects these sites and local
communities. In the Arctic, which is warming four times faster
than anywhere else on the globe due to the climate crisis,
Committee Republicans have pushed for more fossil fuel
development in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and the
repeal of essential ecosystem protections in the NPR-A,
accelerating climate change and exacerbating impacts.
Offshore Oil and Gas
As of September 2023, 2,249 active oil and gas leases were
on over 12 million acres of federal waters.\6\ Seventy-six
percent of these leases (1,710 leases) have never produced oil
or gas, and there are currently only three pending permits for
new wells in the Gulf of Mexico.7,8 The Outer
Continental Shelf Lands Act (OCSLA) directs the Secretary of
the Interior to establish a schedule for offshore oil and gas
lease sales every five years (Five-Year Plan). On September 29,
2023, the Biden administration released the 2024-2029 Five-Year
Plan, containing three lease sales in the Gulf of Mexico, the
minimum to sustain offshore wind leasing through 2030, under
the terms in the Inflation Reduction Act. This leasing plan is
consistent with President Biden's goals to reduce emissions by
50-52 percent of 2005 levels by 2050.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, GOM Lease Statistics
Interactive Dashboard (last accessed Sept. 21, 2023).
\7\Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Combined Leasing Report as of
September 1, 2023 (Sept. 2023).
\8\Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement, Status of Gulf
of Mexico Well Permits (accessed Sept. 9, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Republicans have proposed legislation to increase
the frequency of offshore oil and gas lease sales in the Gulf
and off the coast of Alaska and to deregulate the industry.
These efforts will not decrease energy costs for Americans but
will worsen the climate crisis and increase harm to
environmental justice communities, which bear the brunt of
associated dangerous and polluting onshore infrastructure and
refineries.
Federal Coal
In the U.S., coal is the largest and most carbon dioxide
intensive conventional fossil fuel resource. In recent years,
42 percent of the nation's annual coal production has come from
federal lands. Coal-fired power plants alone accounted for
nearly 60 percent of public lands' carbon emissions and 13
percent of total U.S. emissions.\9\ Due primarily to market
forces, U.S. coal production and consumption has declined
significantly, resulting in mine and power plant closures and
an increasing number of bankruptcies. Rather than addressing
these issues head-on, Committee Republicans have attempted to
prop up a declining coal industry, making false promises to
workers that coal will return, and have failed to address the
extreme environmental impacts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\U.S. Geological Survey, Federal Lands Greenhouse Gas Emissions
and Sequestration in the United States: Estimates for 2005-14 (2018)
(U.S. Geological Survey Scientific Investigations Report 2018-5131).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mining and Critical Minerals
Our transition to a clean energy economy requires critical
minerals, but mines create significant environmental harm. We
must use a whole supply chain approach that prioritizes smart-
from-the-start planning and emphasizes a circular economy to
reduce demand, prevent environmental and cultural harm, and
uphold Indigenous and labor rights. This approach includes more
efficient use of minerals, recycling and reusing minerals,
prolonging product life, developing substitutes, and partnering
with international allies.
Hardrock mining in the United States is still governed by
the antiquated Mining Law of 1872, which contains no
environmental or public health protections or tribal
consultation requirements and no royalty payments back to the
American people. The patchwork of other environmental laws and
regulations covering the impacts of mining leaves significant
gaps. According to the Environmental Protection Agency,
``mining and mineral processing facilities generate more toxic
and hazardous waste than any other industrial sector, costing
billions of dollars to address the public health and
environmental threats to communities.''\10\ Without
comprehensive mining reform, new domestic mining could risk
repeating environmental and human rights injustices, especially
as most untapped critical mineral resources are within 35 miles
of tribal lands.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, National Enforcement
Initiative: Reducing Pollution from Mineral Processing Operations (Dec.
2016).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition, many of the top companies mining in the U.S.
are foreign-owned--sometimes connected to our adversaries--and
have extracted publicly owned resources without paying any
royalties to American taxpayers or committing to support the
U.S. clean energy economy. Unlike coal, oil, and gas, mining
companies pay no royalties to the federal government for the
publicly owned minerals they extract. Multinational mining
companies have extracted more than $300 billion worth of
precious metals from public lands without paying a cent in
royalties to the American people.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Congress Must Establish a Hardrock Mining Royalty. Project on
Government Oversight (Oct. 28, 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Republicans have spent most of the 118th Congress
focused on the extraction and have refused to address massive
loopholes that provide handouts to foreign mining companies,
including those owned by foreign adversaries, looking to cut
corners and abuse public lands.
Renewable Energy
Renewable energy is safer, cleaner, and increasingly
cheaper than fossil fuel sources. In the 117th Congress,
Democrats made the most significant clean energy investments in
history through the Inflation Reduction Act. This investment
included extending and expanding key tax credits for wind,
solar, and other sustainable energies and funding for
permitting and transmission. Our public lands and waters are
some of the sunniest, windiest, and most geothermically active
places on the planet. Over the last several years, the Biden
administration has successfully advanced offshore wind, updated
onshore wind and solar regulations, and promoted transmission
for clean energy across federal land.12}13}14
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\House Committee on Natural Resources, Testimony of Dr. Walter
Cruickshank, Examining the Policies and Priorities of the Bureau of
Ocean Energy Management, the Bureau of Safety and Environmental
Enforcement, and the U.S. Geological Survey, 116th Cong. (March 6,
2019).
\13\Expanding Renewable Energy, Bureau of Land Management, U.S.
Department of the Interior (Last visited Dec. 4, 2024).
\14\Biden-Harris administration Celebrates Groundbreaking of New
Transmission Line, Delivering Clean, Reliable, Affordable Energy to
Millions of Americans, US Department of the Interior, Press Release,
(Jan. 20, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Republicans have deprioritized renewable energy
development in favor of fossil fuels and attempted to roll back
Democratic investments and actions. Republicans failed to mark
up even a pared-down version of the bipartisan Public Lands
Renewable Development Act, which would share revenue from
renewable energy development on public lands with local and
state governments.
This Congress, the Committee worked across the aisle to
pass a package of bipartisan bills that will promote geothermal
energy production and facilitate more efficient geothermal
permitting on federal lands. Unfortunately, Republicans also
introduced multiple bills that limit judicial review, introduce
categorical exclusions, or sidestep federal permitting entirely
for geothermal energy projects. Democrats believe that all
major projects, regardless of energy source, require sound
permitting, public input, and compliance with our environmental
regulations. Democrats will continue to advocate for these
protections to ensure that clean energy infrastructure planning
does not repeat the mistakes of the fossil fuel industry.
Abandoned Mines & Orphaned Wells
Mining, oil, and gas companies have long abandoned mines
and wells, burdening taxpayers with environm