Background and Need for Legislation
THE ORIGINS OF THE ELECTION LAW IN THE UNITED STATES
According to Article I, Section 4, Clause 1 of the
Constitution of the United States, commonly known as the
Elections Clause, states have the primary role in establishing
``[t]he Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for
Senators and Representatives,''\2\ while Congress has a purely
secondary role in this space and must work actively to restrain
itself from acting improperly and unconstitutionally.
Similarly, Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 provides that states
have the primary role in the appointment of presidential
electors.\3\ Thus, federal election administration legislation
should never be the first step and, in any event, must never
impose burdensome, unfunded federal mandates on state and local
election officials. When Congress does speak, it must devote
its efforts according to the direction of the Framers and only
to resolving highly significant and substantial deficiencies to
ensure the integrity of U.S. elections. Therefore, state
legislatures are the primary venues to establish rules for
governing elections.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\U.S. Const. art I, Sec. 4, cl. 1.
\3\U.S. Const. art II, Sec. 1, cl. 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Elections Clause
Congress's power in election administration is purely
secondary to the States' power and is to be employed only in
the most serious circumstances. This is confirmed by the
Framers' words, debates concerning ratification, the first
Congress convened under the Constitution, the writings of the
Supreme Court, and the Constitution itself. The Framing
Generation grappled with the failure of the Articles of
Confederation, which provided only for a weak national
government incapable of preserving the Union. Under the
Articles of Confederation, the States had exclusive authority
over federal elections held within their territory;\4\ but,
given the difficulties the national government experienced with
state cooperation (e.g., the failure of Rhode Island to send
delegates to the Confederation Congress),\5\ the Federalists,
including Alexander Hamilton, were concerned about the
possibility that states, in an effort to destroy the federal
government, simply might not hold elections or that an
emergency, such as an invasion or insurrection, might prevent
the operation of a state's government. This would leave
Congress without members and the federal government unable to
respond. The Constitution's Elections Clause was designed to
address these deficiencies.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ARTS. OF CONFED'N, Art. 5, Sec. 1.
\5\Robert G. Natelson, The Original Scope of the Congressional
Power to Regulate Elections, 13 U. PA. J. CONST. L. 1, 12 (Nov. 2010)
(citing to various historical documents).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Elections Clause did not swing the pendulum entirely
the other way toward the federal government but instead created
a system of state primacy with a very limited federal fail-
safe. Indeed, quite plainly, Alexander Hamilton, a leading
Federalist and proponent of the Constitution as enacted,
understood the Elections Clause as serving only as a sort of
emergency safeguard, not as an authority to nationalize the
U.S. election process. Writing as Publius to the people of New
York, Hamilton expounded on the true meaning of the Elections
Clause when he wrote, ``T[he] natural order of the subject
leads us to consider, in this place, that provision of the
Constitution which authorizes the national legislature to
regulate, in the last resort, the election of its own
members.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\The Federalist No. 59 (Alexander Hamilton) (emphasis added).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When questioned at states' constitutional ratifying
conventions about this provision, the Federalists confirmed
this understanding of a constitutionally limited, secondary
congressional power under the Elections Clause. Constitutional
scholar Robert Natelson, in his writings on congressional power
to regulate elections, summarized James McHenry, Maryland
convention delegate, to say that ``the risk to the federal
government [without a fail-safe provision] might not arise from
state malice: An insurrection or rebellion might prevent a
state legislature from administering an election.''\7\
Similarly, James Iredell at the North Carolina ratifying
convention said, ```[a]n occasion may arise when the exercise
of this ultimate power in Congress may be necessary . . . if a
state should be involved in war, and its legislature could not
assemble, (as was the case of South Carolina and occasionally
of some other states, during the [Revolutionary] war).'''\8\ In
Pennsylvania, Jasper Yeates said this to the ratifying
convention: ``Sir, let it be remembered that this power can
only operate in a case of necessity, after the factious or
listless disposition of a particular state has rendered an
interference essential to the salvation of the general
government.''\9\ John Jay made similar claims in New York.\10\
And, as Natelson notes,
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Natelson, supra note 5, at 37 (citing James McHenry, Speech
Before the Maryland State House of Delegates (Nov. 29, 1787), reprinted
in 14 DOCUMENTARY HISTORY).
\8\Natelson, supra note 4, at 12 (citing 4 ELLIOT'S DEBATES).
\9\Merril Jensen et al, THE DOCUMENTARY HISTORY OF THE RATIFICATION
OF THE CONSTITUTION 437 (1976). (reporting remarks by Jasper Yeates at
the Pennsylvania ratifying convention).
\10\Natelson, supra note 4, at 40 (citing 2 ELLIOT'S DEBATES).
[Representative] Alexander Contee Hanson, a member of
Congress whose pamphlet supporting the Constitution
proved popular, stated flatly that Congress would
exercise its times, places, and manner authority only
in cases of invasion, legislative neglect or obstinate
refusal to pass election laws [providing for the
election of Members of Congress], or if a state crafted
its election laws with a `sinister purpose' or to
injure the general government.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Natelson, supra note 4, at 39 (citing 4 ELLIOT'S DEBATES).
Cementing his point, Hanson went further to decree, ``[t]he
exercise of this power must at all times be so very invidious,
that congress will not venture upon it without some very cogent
and substantial reason.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Alexander Contee Hanson (writing as Astrides), Remarks on the
Proposed Plan: 31 January, reprinted in John P. Kaminski, Gaspare J.
Saladino, and Richard Leffler (eds.), 3 Commentaries on the
Constitution, public and private 18 December 1787 to 31 January 1788
522-26 (1984).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In fact, had the alternate view of the Elections Clause
been accepted at the time of the Constitution's drafting--that
is, that the clause offers Congress unfettered power over
federal elections--it is likely that the Constitution would not
have been ratified or that an amendment to this language would
have been required for the Union to prevail. Indeed, at least
seven of the original 13 states--enough to prevent the
Constitution from being ratified--expressed specific concerns
with the language of the Elections Clause giving Congress too
much power over election administration.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See 1 Annals of Cong. 799 (1789), Joseph Gales (ed.) 15 (1834).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, ``[l]eading Federalists . . . '' assured them
``that, even without amendment, the [Elections] Clause should
be construed as limited to emergencies.''\14\ Three States, New
York, North Carolina, and Rhode Island, made their ratification
of the Constitution contingent on this understanding being made
express:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Natelson, supra note 4, at 39.
New York: Under these impressions and declaring that
the rights aforesaid cannot be abridged or violated,
and that the Explanations aforesaid are consistent with
the said Constitution, And in confidence that the
Amendments which shall have been proposed to the said
Constitution will receive an early and mature
Consideration: We the said Delegates, in the Name and
in [sic] the behalf of the People of the State of New
York Do by these presents Assent to and Ratify the said
Constitution. In full Confidence . . . that the
Congress will not make or alter any Regulation in this
State respecting the times places and manner of holding
Elections for Senators or Representatives unless the
Legislature of this State shall neglect or refuse to
make Laws or regulations for the purpose, or from any
circumstance be incapable of making the same, and that
in those cases such power will only be exercised until
the Legislature of this State shall make provision in
the Premises . . . .\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Ratification of the Constitution by the State of New York (July
26, 1788).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
North Carolina: That Congress shall not alter,
modify, or interfere in the times, places, or manner of
holding elections for senators and representatives, or
either of them, except when the legislature of any
state shall neglect, refuse or be disabled by invasion
or rebellion, to prescribe the same.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Ratification of the Constitution by the State of North Carolina
(Nov. 21, 1789).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rhode Island: Under these impressions, and declaring,
that the rights aforesaid cannot be abridged or
violated, and that the explanations aforesaid, are
consistent with the said constitution, and in
confidence that the amendments hereafter mentioned,
will receive an early and mature consideration, and
conformably to the fifth article of said constitution,
speedily become a part thereof; We the said delegates,
in the name, and in [sic] the behalf of the People, of
the State of Rhode-Island and Providence-Plantations,
do by these Presents, assent to, and ratify the said
Constitution. In full confidence . . . That the
Congress will not make or alter any regulation in this
State, respecting the times, places and manner of
holding elections for senators and representatives,
unless the legislature of this state shall neglect, or
refuse to make laws or regulations for the purpose, or
from any circumstance be incapable of making the same;
and that [i]n those cases, such power will only be
exercised, until the legislature of this State shall
make provision in the Premises . . . .\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Ratification of the Constitution by the State of Rhode Island
(May 29, 1790).
This understanding of a limited Elections Clause was also
reinforced by debate during the first Congress that convened
under the Constitution when Representative Aedanus Burke (SC-
02) proposed a constitutional amendment to limit the Times,
Places and Manner Clause to emergencies.\18\ The amendment
appears to have failed because those on both sides of the Burke
amendment debate already understood the Elections Clause to
limit federal elections power to emergencies and therefore saw
no need for a constitutional amendment. Opponent Representative
Benjamin Goodhue (MA-02) voted against the amendment because he
understood the Elections Clause was intended to prevent state
governments from ``oppos[ing]'' and ``thwart[ing]'' the federal
government ``to such a degree as finally to overturn it.''\19\
Because Representative Goodhue believed the Elections Clause
already achieved Representative Burke's goal, he opposed
it.\20\ Similarly, proponent Representative William Smith (SC-
01) also believed the original text of the Elections Clause
already limited the federal government's power over federal
elections to emergencies and so thought there would be no harm
in supporting an amendment to make that language express.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\1 ANNALS OF CONG. 801 (1789) (Joseph Gales ed., 1834).
\19\Id.
\20\Id.
\21\Id. at 799.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Electors Clause
Just as the history and language of the Elections Clause
makes clear that the States have the primary authority to
administer elections, the same holds true for a state's power
to choose presidential electors under Article II of the
Constitution. The Electors Clause of Article II gives states
the power to ``appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature
thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole
Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may
be entitled in the Congress . . . .''\22\ As described in
detail below, today, nearly every state chooses its
presidential electors based on the presidential candidate that
won its popular vote.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\U.S. Const. art. II, Sec. 1, cl. 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Before adopting the Electors Clause, the Constitutional
Convention considered two different options--congressional
appointment or national direct simple majority vote.\23\ Under
the ``Virginia Plan'' drafted by James Madison and introduced
by Virginia Governor Edmund Randolph, the national legislature
would have chosen the nation's top executive.\24\ But this plan
was rejected as several of the Framers were concerned that this
practice existed in several revolutionary state constitutions
and proved unworkable.\25\ The Convention also rejected a
national direct simple majority vote in part out of concern
that the American people could not agree on a single
candidate.\26\ In all, four votes were taken rejecting
congressional appointment, and two votes were taken rejecting
direct election by the people.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Robert J. Delahunty and John Yoo, Who Counts?: The Twelfth
Amendment, the Vice President, and the Electoral Count, 73 Case W.
Rsrv. L. Rev. 27, 70 (2022).
\24\1 The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787, at 21. (Max
Farrand ed., 1911).
\25\See Gordon S. Wood, Power and Liberty: Constitutionalism in the
American Revolution at 129, 147 (2021).
\26\Delahunty & Yoo, supra note 23, at 70.
\27\1 The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787, at 21, 68-69,
80-81, 175-76, 230, 244 (Max Farrand ed., 1911); 2 id. at 29-32, 57-59,
63-64, 95, 99-106, 108-15, 118-21, 196-97, 401-04, 497, 499-502, 511-
15, 522-29.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As the Convention neared its end, there was no resolution
over how the nation's top executive would be chosen. The
Convention referred the controversy to the so-called
``Committee of Eleven'' to work out a solution.\28\ The
Committee of Eleven provided a proposal for the Electoral
College, which the full Convention accepted just two days later
with only a few small changes.\29\ That language makes up the
Electors Clause of Article II today.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\Chiafalo v. Washington, 140 S. Ct. 2316, 2320 (2020).
\29\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, the Convention also adopted language in Article II
outlining the procedures that electors were required to follow
that failed to foresee the rise of our current political
system.\30\ Originally, electors were to cast votes for two
candidates in the presidential field. The candidate that
achieved a majority would become president, the runner-up or
the losing presidential candidate would become vice president,
and, in general, the House of Representatives would decide the
winner if no candidate received a majority.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\U.S. Const. art. II, Sec. 1, cl. 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This problem became prevalent after the presidential
election of 1796. There, John Adams defeated political rival
Thomas Jefferson, but because Jefferson came in second, he
would serve as Adams' vice president.\31\ Unfortunately, things
got even more complicated following the presidential election
of 1800. There, when Thomas Jefferson and his running-mate
Aaron Burr ran as a ticket and won, every elector voted for
them both, resulting in a tie and throwing the election to the
House of Representatives.\32\ As a result of the presidential
elections of 1796 and 1800, the Twelfth Amendment was adopted
which permits electors to vote separately for president and
vice president.\33\ Nevertheless, the Electors Clause which
gives states the sole authority in choosing electors was not
amended.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Chiafalo, 140 S. Ct. at 2320.
\32\Id. at 2320-21.
\33\U.S. Const. amend. XII.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE SUPREME COURT HAS CONFIRMED THAT STATES HAVE PRIMARY AUTHORITY OVER
ELECTIONS IN THE UNITED STATES
Elections Clause
The Supreme Court also supports the understanding that the
Elections Clause limits federal power over the administration
of elections. In Smiley v. Holm, the Court held that Article I,
Section 4 reserved to the States the primary duty and
authority to provide a complete code for congressional
elections, not only as to times and places, but in
relation to notices, registration, supervision of
voting, protection of voters, prevention of fraud and
corrupt practices, counting of votes, duties of
inspectors and canvassers, and making and publication
of election returns; in short, to enact the numerous
requirements as to procedure and safeguards which
experience shows are necessary in order to enforce the
fundamental right involved. And these requirements
would be nugatory if they did not have appropriate
sanctions in the definition of offenses and
punishments. All this is comprised in the subject of
`times, places
Committee Action
118TH CONGRESS
Introduction and Referral
On July 10, 2023, amid the vintage ambiance of the iconic
Marietta Diner near Atlanta, Georgia, an emblematic location
symbolizing the everyday American experience, Representatives
Barry Loudermilk (GA-11), Stephanie Bice (OK-05), Mike Carey
(OH-15), and Laurel Lee (FL-15) surrounded Representative Bryan
Steil (WI-01), Chairman of the Committee on House
Administration, during his ceremonial signing of American
Confidence in Elections Act (``ACE Act'').
On July 11, 2023, Chairman Steil introduced ACE Act as H.R.
4563, which was referred to the Committee on House
Administration as well as the House Committee on the Judiciary,
the House Committee on Ways and Means, the House Committee on
Science, Space, and Technology, the House Permanent Select
Committee on Intelligence, the House Committee on Homeland
Security, the House Committee on Education and the Workforce,
the House Committee on Financial Services, the House Committee
on Oversight and Accountability, and the House Committee on
Rules.
Cosponsors
Cosponsors play a pivotal role in the legislative process,
serving as early indicators of a bill's support and momentum.
The 127 cosponsors behind the ACE Act underscore its broad
appeal and the widespread commitment among legislators to
fortify and instill confidence in the electoral process.
132 Members of the House of Representatives cosponsored ACE
Act in the 118th Congress. They include: Speaker Mike Johnson
(LA-04), Majority Leader Steve Scalise (LA-01), Republican
Conference Chair Elise Stefanik (NY-21), former Speaker Kevin
McCarthy (CA-20), Carlos Gimenez (FL-28), Claudia Tenney (NY-
24), Mike Carey (OH-15), Robert Wittman (VA-01), Thomas Tiffany
(WI-07), David Valadao (CA-22), Mike Bost (IL-12), Derrick Van
Orden (WI-03), Chris Smith (NJ-04), Garret Graves (LA-06),
Glenn Grothman (WI-06), Guy Reschenthaler (PA-14), Michael
Guest (MS-03), Jake Ellzey (TX-06), Ken Calvert (CA-41), Lauren
Boebert (CO-03), Alexander Mooney (WV-02), Jake LaTurner (KS-
02), Larry Bucshon (IN-08), Marjorie Taylor Greene (GA-14),
Mike Collins (GA-10), Michael Lawler (NY-17), Morgan Griffith
(VA-09), Russell Fry (SC-07), William Timmons (SC-04), Anthony
D'Esposito (NY-04), Ben Cline (VA-06), Dusty Johnson (SD-At
Large), Laurel Lee (FL-15), Mark Amodei (NV-02), Mike Johnson
(LA-04), Stephanie Bice (OK-05), Barry Loudermilk (GA-11),
Glenn Thompson (PA-15), Nathaniel Moran (TX-01), Richard Hudson
(NC-09), Vern Buchanan (FL-26), Ashley Hinson (IA-12), Buddy
Carter (GA-01), Chuck Edwards (NC-11), David Kustoff (TN-08),
Greg Murphy (NC-03), Robert Latta (OH-05), Scott DesJarlais
(TN-04), Erin Houchin (IN-09), James Moylan (GU-At Large), Nick
LaLota (NY-01), Pete Stauber (MN-08), Dan Crenshaw (TX-02),
John Moolenaar (MI-02), Mark Alford (MO-04), Nancy Mace (SC-
01), Ronny Jackson (TX-13), Sam Graves (MO-06), Scott Franklin
(FL-18), Virginia Foxx (NC-05), Aaron Bean (FL-04), Ann Wagner
(MO-02), August Pfluger (TX-11), Austin Scott (GA-08), Barry
Moore (AL-02), Brad Wenstrup (OH-02), Brian Babin (TX-36),
Bruce Westerman (AR-04), Carol Miller (WV-01), Cathy McMorris
Rodgers (WA-05), Chuck Fleischmann (TN-03), Cory Mills (FL-07),
Dale Strong (AL-05), Dan Newhouse (WA-04), David Rouzer (NC-
07), Diana Harshbarger (TN-01), Doug LaMalfa (CA-01), French
Hill (AR-02), Jerry Carl (AL-01), James Baird (IN-04), John
Carter (TX-31), Kay Granger (TX-12), Lance Gooden (TX-05), Lisa
McClain (MI-09), Lloyd Smucker (PA-11), Mariannette Miller-
Meeks (IA-01), Mary Miller (IL-15), Max Miller (OH-07),
Michelle Fischbach (MN-07), Mike Garcia (CA-27), Mike Kelly
(PA-16), Nicholas Langworthy (NY-23), Randy Feenstra (IA-04),
Rick Crawford (AR-01), Robert Aderholt (AL-04), Roger Williams
(TX-25), Ryan Zinke (MT-01), Tom Cole (OK-04), Tom McClintock
(CA-05), Tony Gonzales (TX-23), Troy Balderson (OH-12), Adrian
Smith (NE-03), Andy Barr (KY-06), Brad Finstad (MN-01), John
James (MI-10), John Rose (TN-06), Mike Flood (NE-01), Monica De
La Cruz (TX-15), Morgan Luttrell (TX-08), Rudy Yakym (IN-02),
Patrick McHenry (NC-10), Trent Kelly (MS-01), Gregory Steube
(FL-17), Nicole Malliotakis (NY-11), Daniel Meuser (PA-09), Kat
Cammack (FL-03), Mark Green (TN-07), Gus Bilirakis (FL-12),
Michael Waltz (FL-06), Mike Ezell (MS-04), Tim Walberg (MI-05),
Rich McCormick (GA-06), Pat Fallon (TX-04), Neal Dunn (FL-02),
George Santos (NY-03), Bill Huizenga (MI-04), Darin LaHood (IL-
16), Randy K. Weber, Sr. (TX-14), Jack Bergman (MI-01), Brandon
Williams (NY-22), Doug Lamborn (CO-05), Harriet Hageman (WY-At
Large), and Troy Nehls (TX-22)
Stakeholder Endorsements
ACE Act represents years of hard work with key stakeholders
and outside groups working to improve election integrity so
voters can have confidence in our elections. Below are listed
the various stakeholders who have been integral to the creation
of ACE Act. Some statements of support are featured.
Full Support
49 organizations endorse the ACE Act in its entirety and
support its passage. They include: America First Policy
Institute, Heritage Action, Republican National Lawyers
Association, AMAC Action, People United for Privacy, Election
Transparency Initiative, Election Integrity Network, Concerned
Women for America, Americans for Citizen Voting, West Virginia
Secretary of State, Louisiana Secretary of State, Restoring
Integrity and Trust in Elections, Fair Lines America, American
Commitment, Voter Reference Foundation, America Project,
National Defense Committee, RI Center for Freedom & Prosperity,
Middle Resolution Policy Foundation, Illinois Conservative
Union, Florida Fair Elections, Michigan Fair Elections, Pure
Integrity for Michigan, TN Fair Elections, North Carolina
Election Integrity Team (NCEIT), Fairfax GOP EIT, EIWG Fairfax
County, Lanier Tea Party, VoterGA, GA Election Integrity
Coalition, TPPA, Tea Party Patriots770, Eagle Forum of GA,
GoReclaimGeorgia, Convention of States, Gary Meyers Realty,
Inc., Law Office of John Fogarty, Jr., Music by Debra, Alliance
for Wise Energy Decisions (AWED), William & Saylor Co.
Free Speech and Citizen Privacy Provisions Support
69 organizations specifically endorse the constitutional
protections of free speech and privacy included in the ACE Act
and support the passage of those provisions. They include:
People United for Privacy, ALEC Action, 60 Plus Association,
Advancing American Freedom, Alaska Policy Forum, AMAC Action,
Americans for Tax Reform, Philanthropy Roundtable, American
Commitment, American Energy Alliance, American Juris Link,
American Target Advertising, American Values, Americans for
Limited Government, The Buckeye Institute, Capital Research
Center, Catholics Count, Center for Freedom and Prosperity,
Coalition for Policy Reform, Commonwealth Foundation,
Conservative Victory Fund, DonorsTrust, Empire Center for
Public Policy, Empower Mississippi Foundation, Family
Foundation of Virginia, Freedom Foundation, Freedom Foundation
of Minnesota, Georgia Center for Opportunity, Goldwater
Institute, Gun Owners of America, Heartland Institute, Hispanic
Leadership Fund, Idaho Freedom Action, Illinois Policy
Institute, Independence Institute, Independent Women's Voice,
Institute for Liberty, Iowans for Tax Relief, James Madison
Institute, John Locke Foundation, John K. MacIver Institute for
Public Policy, Leadership Institute, Less Government, Libertas
Institute, Log Cabin Republicans, Louisiana Family Forum,
Mackinac Center for Public Policy, Maine Policy Institute,
Mountain States Legal Foundation, National Committee for
Religious Freedom, Nevada Policy Research Institute, North
Carolina Election Integrity Team, Former State of Ohio
Treasurer, Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs, Opportunity
Solutions Project, Palmetto Promise Institute, Pelican
Institute for Public Policy, R Street Institute, The Rainey
Center Freedom Project, Rhode Island Center for Freedom and
Prosperity, Rio Grande Foundation, Save Our States, State
Policy Network, Students for Life of America, Students for Life
Action, Tea Party Patriots Action, Thomas Jefferson Institute
for Public Policy, Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty,
Yankee Institute, Yorktown Foundation for Public Policy, Young
America's Foundation.
What They Are Saying
Americans for Public Trust Executive Director Caitlin
Sutherland: ``With the introduction of the ACE Act,
Chairman Steil is taking a crucial step to safeguard
our political system by closing the foreign influence
loophole that has allowed hundreds of millions of
dollars to flow into organizations supporting leftwing
causes and politicians. A single foreign billionaire
has set up nonprofits that have poured over $265
million to groups in the Arabella Advisors network, a
dark money hub comprised of multiple nonprofits that
support radical environmentalism, sweeping changes to
U.S. election laws, defunding the police, packing the
Supreme Court, K-12 indoctrination, and more. Americans
for Public Trust encourages all Members of Congress to
join Chairman Steil in ending any and all foreign
meddling in our elections.''\669\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\669\Press Release, Committee on House Administration, What They
Are Saying: Support for the American Confidence in Elections Act (July
24, 2023), https://cha.house.gov/press-
releases?ID=E8068684-DAA0-4926-BA82-67D2D1D0F54C.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Election Integrity Network Deputy Director Ned Jones:
``We say it all the time, `If we don't fix our broken
election system, nothing else matters.' The informative
hearings, that your committee has held in the past few
months, have exposed many of the concerns with that
system, and the ACE Act addresses those concerns.
Several of these concerns are covered in Title I, lack
of voter confidence, election integrity, an alarming
trend with localities allowing non-citizens to vote,
the lack of list maintenance, the lack of photo ID to
vote, and getting the outside funding and influence in
our election system. I strongly support the ACE Act and
the great work that your committee is doing to help fix
our broken election system. Americans, who want fair,
honest, and transparent elections appreciate your
efforts.''\670\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\670\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
America First Policy Institute Center for Election
Integrity Chair Hon. J. Kenneth Blackwell and Vice-
Chair Hogan Gidley: ``The comprehensive work that has
gone into this legislation, by listening to people who
are part of the election system around the country, has
resulted in a bill that is balanced and fair. It would
provide the transparency needed to improve Americans'
confidence in their election system. CEI is proud to
stand with you in support of this legislation.''\671\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\671\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Republican National Lawyers Association President
Marc Ellinger and Chair Harmeet K. Dhillon: ``One of
the missions of our 6,000 lawyer and law student
members is to advance open, fair, and honest elections.
The ACE Act does just that. The ACE Act provides a
stark contrast to the election legislation that
dominated the last two Congresses, H.R. 1 and H.R. 4 .
. . In comparison, the ACE Act promotes confidence in
elections by increasing transparency, clarifying the
limited role of the federal government in election
administration, and promoting the freedom of Americans
to express political viewpoints.''\672\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\672\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
West Virginia Secretary of State Mac Warner: ``I
fully endorse The America Confidence in Elections (ACE)
Act and encourage the U.S. Congress to pass the bill.
ACE provides states with tools to improve ballot
delivery, conduct signature verification, use voter ID,
provide observer access, maintain voter lists, conduct
post-election audits, and much more. ACE engaging the
Election Assistance Commission to create voluntary
guidelines for non-voting equipment is a magnificent
path to increase integrity in the elections process.
Sharing federal information with states for voter
registration list maintenance will also allow cleaner
elections. I also applaud the use of federal resources
to empower decision-making at the state and local level
while removing the authority of overreaching federal
programs. I continue urging the repeal of Biden's EO
#14019, a prime example of federal overreach. Passing
ACE will help restore confidence in elections
throughout the United States.''\673\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\673\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Voter Reference Foundation Executive Director Gina
Swoboda: ``This election integrity bill is sorely
needed to restore confidence to the American people
that our elections processes and systems are both
transparent and secure . . . The Voter Reference
Foundation applauds the tremendous work done on the
American Confidence in Elections Act and is proud to
support this bill.''\674\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\674\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Voters Organized for Trusted Election Results in
Georgia Co-Founder Garland Favorito: ``We are grateful
to Chairman Steil and the CHA for adopting non-partisan
transparency provisions we recommended for Georgia and
American voters. New provisions of the `ACE Act' will
make public all materials essential to conducting post-
election audits throughout the 22-month federal record
retention period. These include ballots, ballot images,
cast vote records, chain of custody documents, logic
and accuracy test results and equipment certifications.
Both Democrats and Republicans have favored these
transparency provisions for years. Publicly available
ballots are needed to verify questionable election
results and detect counterfeits previously seen in
Georgia. Once the `ACE Act' becomes law, Americans will
no longer be forced to suffer through secretly counted,
unverifiable elections that divide the country because
no one really knows who won. That will help restore
American confidence.''\675\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\675\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tennessee Free and Fair Elections Co-Director Kathy
Harms: ``We in Tennessee, and around the country, are
grateful for the exceptional work that has been done on
this legislation. Protecting and ensuring integrity in
the electoral process is a foundational principle that
should engender bi-partisan support. Specifically, this
legislation emphasizes the need for each State to be
able to develop methods and interventions to secure our
elections with less Federal Government and/or partisan
political intrusions. We support the ACE Act and are
grateful to all who have shared the vision for
Confidence to be returned to the American people that
their vote is more rigorously being protected.''\676\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\676\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Coalition Letter Signed by Over 70 Nonprofit
Organizations, led by People United For Privacy: ``The
free speech provisions in the American Confidence in
Elections Act would defend the vital role nonprofit
organizations serve in encouraging free speech and the
free exchange of ideas. Privately supporting causes--
and the organizations advancing those causes--is a
fundamental freedom protected by the First
Amendment.''\677\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\677\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hearings and Roundtables
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
in the 118th Congress, the Committee held nine hearings--six
full committee hearings and three subcommittee hearings, as
well as two subcommittee roundtables to develop the ACE Act. In
contrast, large election bills reported out of the Committee in
the 116th and 117th Congresses received two hearings.\678\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\678\See For the People: Our American Democracy, Before the
Committee on House Administration, 116th Cong. (2019); Strengthening
American Democracy, Before the Committee on House Administration, 117th
Cong. (2021). Committee Democrats believe an additional seventeen
hearings in the 116th Congress also support H.R. 1. This is false.
Unlike the hearings cited above, in the Committee Report for H.R. 1 in
the 117th Congress, Committee Democrats refused to identify the subject
or witnesses at any of the seventeen hearings in stark contrast to how
they detailed the other two hearings. This was not an accident; it was
done because those seventeen hearings did not support the legislation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. On March 10, 2023, the Committee held an elections
subcommittee hearing titled, ``2022 Midterms Look Back Series:
Successes in the 2022 Midterm Elections.'' The hearing focused
on the strengths and weaknesses of the 2022 federal midterm
election, lessons learned from newly implemented and
administered State election laws, and how ACE Act can be
strengthened based on new data from the midterm election.
Witnesses included: The Honorable Kyle Ardoin, Louisiana
Secretary of State, The Honorable Chris Anderson, Supervisor of
Elections, Seminole County, Florida, The Honorable Frank
LaRose, Ohio Secretary of State, and Damon Hewitt, President
and Executive Director of the Lawyers' Committee.\679\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\679\2022 Midterms Look Back Series: Successes in the 2022 Midterm
Elections: Hearing Before the Subcomm. On Elections of the H. Comm. On
Admin., 118th Cong. (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. On March 23, 2023, the Committee held an elections
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following roll call votes occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 4563:
1. Vote on Amendment #1 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by
Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 2 ayes and 6 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T. Noes: Steil, B.,
Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L.
2. Amendment #2 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Mr.
Morelle, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 6 ayes and 2 noes. Ayes:
Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M.,
D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Noes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T.
3. Amendment #3 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Mr.
Morelle, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 6 ayes and 3 noes. Ayes:
Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M.,
D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Noes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T.,
Kilmer, D.
4. Amendment #4 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Ms.
Sewell, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 5 ayes and 3 noes. Ayes:
Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L. Noes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D.
5. Amendment #5 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Ms.
Sewell, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 5 ayes and 3 noes. Ayes:
Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L. Noes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D.
6. Vote on Amendment #6 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by
Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 5 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M.,
D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
7. Vote on Amendment #7 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by
Mr. Kilmer, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 5 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L.
8. Vote on Amendment #8 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by
Mr. Kilmer, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 5 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L.
9. Vote on Amendment #9 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by
Mr. Kilmer, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 5 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L.
10. Vote on Amendment #10 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Kilmer, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 5 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L.
11. Vote on Amendment #11 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 2 ayes and 6 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T. Noes: Steil, B.,
Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A.,
Lee, L.
12. Vote on Amendment #12 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 1 aye and 6 noes.
Ayes: Sewell, T. Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B.,
Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
13. Vote on Amendment #13 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 1 aye and 6 noes.
Ayes: Sewell, T. Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B.,
Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
14. Vote on Amendment #14 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 1 aye and 6 noes.
Ayes: Sewell, T. Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B.,
Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
15. Vote on Amendment #15 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 1 aye and 6 noes.
Ayes: Sewell, T. Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B.,
Murphy, G., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
16. Vote on Amendment #16 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 3 ayes and 7 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Kilmer, D., Torres, N. Noes: Steil,
B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S., Carey, M.,
D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
17. Vote on Amendment #17 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 3 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N. Noes: Steil,
B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
18. Vote on Amendment #18 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
19. Vote on Amendment #19 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
20. Vote on Amendment #20 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
21. Vote on Amendment #21 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes's: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
22. Vote on Amendment #22 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
23. Vote on Amendment #74 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Kilmer, adopted by a vote of 12 ayes and 0 noes.
Ayes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.,
Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
24. Vote on Amendment #23 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D., Torres, N.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
25. Vote on Amendment #24 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 7 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
26. Vote on Amendment #25 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 7 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
27. Amendment #26 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Mr.
Morelle, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 7 ayes and 4 noes. Ayes:
Steil, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S., Carey,
M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Noes: Morelle, J., Sewell,
T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
28. Vote on Amendment #27 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
29. Vote on Amendment #28 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
30. Vote on Amendment #29 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
31. Vote on Amendment #30 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Sewell, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 7 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
32. Vote on Amendment #31 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
33. Vote on Amendment #32 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
34. Amendment #33 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Ms.
Torres, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 8 ayes and 4 noes. Ayes:
Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G.,
Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Noes:
Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
35. Amendment #34 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Ms.
Torres, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 7 ayes and 4 noes. Ayes:
Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Noes: Morelle, J.,
Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
36. Vote on Amendment #35 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
37. Vote on Amendment #36 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
38. Vote on Amendment #37 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
39. Vote on Amendment #38 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Ms. Torres, failed by a vote of 3 ayes and 7 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Kilmer, D., Torres, N. Noes: Steil,
B., Loudermilk, B., Murphy, G., Bice, S., Carey, M.,
D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
40. Amendment #39 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered by Mr.
Morelle, ruled non-germane, motion to table appeal to
ruling, passed by a vote of 8 ayes and 3 noes. Ayes:
Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G.,
Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Noes:
Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D.
41. Vote on Amendment #40 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 3 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D. Noes: Steil,
B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
42. Vote on Amendment #41 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 3 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Kilmer, D. Noes: Steil,
B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
43. Vote on Amendment #42 to H.R. 4563 ANS, offered
by Mr. Morelle, failed by a vote of 4 ayes and 8 noes.
Ayes: Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy,
G., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L.
44. Vote to favorably report H.R. 4563 ANS, as
amended, with the recommendation that the amendment be
agreed to and the bill pass, offered by Ms. Lee, passed
by a vote of 8 ayes and 4 noes. Ayes: Steil, B.,
Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M., Murphy, G., Bice, S.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Noes: Morelle, J.,
Sewell, T., Torres, N., Kilmer, D.
Statement of Constitutional Authority
Congress has the power to enact this legislation pursuant
to the following:
Article I, Section 4, Clause 1--informs the
Congress that the primary authority to set election law
and to administer federal elections rests with the
States and not with the Congress.
First Amendment--``Congress shall make no
law respecting an establishment of religion, or
prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the
freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the
people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the
Government for a redress of grievances.''
Article I, Section 8, Clause 17--``To
exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever,
over such District (not exceeding ten Miles square) as
may, by Cession of particular States, and the
Acceptance of Congress, become the Seat of Government
of the United States[.]''
Fourteenth Amendment--``All citizens born or
naturalized in the United States, and subject to the
jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United
States[.]''
Fifteenth, Nineteenth, Twenty-Fourth, and
Twenty-sixth Amendments--``The right of citizens of the
United States to vote . . .''
Tenth Amendment--confirms that the
Constitution assigns only enumerated powers to the
Congress and that the States and the people retain the
remainder.
Article I, Section 8, Clause 7--``To
establish Post Offices and post Roads[.]''
Article I, Section 5, Clause 1--``Each House
shall be the Judge of the Elections, Returns and
Qualifications of its own Members[.]''
Sixteenth Amendment--``The Congress shall
have the power to lay and collect taxes on incomes,''
Article I, Section 8, Clause 3--``To
regulate Commerce with . . . the Indian Tribes[.]''
Article I, Section 8, Clause 12--``To raise
and support Armies[.]''
Article I, Section 8, Clause 13--``To
provide and maintain a Navy[.]''
Article I, Section 8, Clause 14--``To make
Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and
naval Forces[.]''
Article I, Section 8, Clause 18--``To make
all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for
carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all
other Powers vested by this Constitution in the
Government of the United States, or in any Department
or Officer thereof.''
Response to the Minority Views on Procedural Concerns
Committee markups are important for several reasons--
arguably the most important of which is to allow the minority
party to express its views and vote on its amendments. But when
a committee refuses to hold markups, and instead regularly
sends legislation referred to it directly to the floor, the
minority party loses its only ability to force the majority to
vote on controversial amendments. What is more, a committee
that continually waives jurisdiction over primary referrals
weakens its ability to make strong jurisdictional arguments
when other referrals arise. That is because it creates a bad
precedent that the committee is willing to waive jurisdiction
when it otherwise would have an opportunity to have its views
on a subject known. This is also problematic for another reason
in that, Members and committee staff with knowledge on these
issues will lose an opportunity to engage on them.
In the 116th and 117th Congresses, Committee Democrats
failed in their responsibility to hold markups on election
bills that passed the House in which the Committee on House
Administration held primary jurisdiction. In the 116th
Congress, five major election bills passed out of the House,
yet Committee Democrats held a markup on only three of
them.\799\ In the 117th Congress, there were four major
election bills that passed out of the House, and Committee
Democrats failed to hold a single markup.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\799\See H.R. 1623, Help America Run Act, 116th Cong. Sec. 1
(2019); H.R. 4990, Election Technology Research Act of 2020, 116th
Cong. Sec. 1 (2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In fact, Committee Democrats did not hold a markup on any
bill for the entire 117th Congress.\800\ In contrast, in H.R.
4563's markup, Committee Democrats offered forty-five minority
amendments whereas in the entire 117th Congress, Committee
Republicans in the minority were unable to offer an amendment
to any bill. In comparison, during our markup, a Democrat
amendment was adopted. Based on these circumstances, for
Committee Democrats to accuse Committee Republicans of setting
a ``[t]roubling [p]recedent''\801\ because of disagreement on a
few germaneness questions cannot possibly be taken seriously.
What does set a ``[t]roubling [p]recedent'', however, is
refusing to hold a markup for an entire Congress. Republicans
are committed to transparency and regular order, which better
serves the American people.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\800\Committee on House Administration, Markups, 117th Congress,
https://cha.house.gov/com
mittee-activity/markups/
all?field_evo_congress_number_target_id=4&field_evo_subcommittees_
target_id=All. (Noting that there are three markups listed, two on a
contested election contest, one for amounts provided to House
committees, and zero markups featuring a bill with an H.R. number).
\801\Minority Views at 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After failing to hold a single markup during the previous
Congress, it is understandable that Committee Democrats would
be confused over how the germaneness rules apply. According to
the Deschler-Brown Precedents, for a germane relationship to
exist between an amendment and the underlying legislation, an
amendment