Minority Views
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
January 3, 2025.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
57-894 WASHINGTON : 2025
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
COMMITTEE ON RULES
Michael C. Burgess, Texas, Chair
Guy Reschenthaler, Pennsylvania, James P. McGovern, Massachusetts,
Vice Chair Ranking Member
Michelle Fischbach, Minnesota Mary Gay Scanlon, Pennsylvania
Thomas Massie, Kentucky Joe Neguse, Colorado
Ralph Norman, South Carolina Teresa Leger Fernandez, New Mexico
Chip Roy, Texas
Erin Houchin, Indiana
Nicholas A. Langworthy, New York
Austin Scott, Georgia
Jennifer Belair, Staff Director
Donald C. Sisson, Minority Staff Director
Steve Waskiewicz, Deputy Staff Director
Caroline Donlon, Legislative Clerk
______
SUBCOMMITTEE ON RULES AND ORGANIZATION OF THE HOUSE
Guy Reschenthaler, Pennsylvania, Chair
Erin Houchin, Indiana, Mary Gay Scanlon, Pennsylvania,
Vice Chair Ranking Member
Michael C. Burgess, Texas James P. McGovern, Massachusetts
Thomas Massie, Kentucky
Austin Scott, Georgia
______
SUBCOMMITTEE ON LEGISLATIVE AND BUDGET PROCESS
Michelle Fischbach, Minnesota, Chair
Ralph Norman, South Carolina, Teresa Leger Fernandez, New
Vice Chair Mexico,
Michael C. Burgess, Texas Ranking Member
Chip Roy, Texas Joe Neguse, Colorado
Nicholas A. Langworthy, New York
______
*Tom Cole of Oklahoma was elected to the Committee on Rules on January
10, 2023 and served as Chair of the Committee until he resigned on
April 11, 2024 to serve as the Chair of the Committee on
Appropriations. Michael Burgess of Texas, Vice Chair, was elected as
Chair of the Committee on Rules on April 11, 2024. On the same date,
Austin Scott of Georgia was elected to serve as a Member of the
Committee.
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
----------
House of Representatives,
Committee on Rules,
Washington, DC, January 3, 2025.
Kevin F. McCumber,
Acting Clerk, House of Representatives,
Washington, DC.
Dear Mister Clerk: Pursuant to clause 1(d) of rule XI of
the Rules of the House of Representatives for the 118th
Congress, I transmit herewith a report entitled ``Survey of
Activities of the House Committee on Rules for the 118th
Congress.''
Sincerely,
Michael C. Burgess, M.D.,
Chair.
C O N T E N T S
----------
Page
I. History, Function, and Organization of the Committee on Rules. 1
A. Introduction................................................ 1
B. History and Function........................................ 2
C. Committee Organization During the 118th Congress............ 6
D. Information Transparency and Technology for the Rules
Committee.................................................... 7
E. Rules of the Committee on Rules for the 118th Congress...... 9
II. House Rules Changes Adopted at the Beginning of the 118th
Congress....................................................... 17
A. Introduction................................................ 17
B. Summary of Substantive Changes Contained in H. Res. 5,
Adopting House Rules for the 118th Congress.................. 18
III. Committee Jurisdiction and Activities....................... 26
A. Introduction................................................ 26
B. Special Orders or Rules..................................... 27
1. Rule Requests............................................. 27
2. Hearings.................................................. 28
3. Special Orders or Rules................................... 29
a. Background.............................................. 29
b. Categories of Rules Granted with Amendment Structures... 29
c. Categories of Rules Granted with Certain Floor
Management Tools......................................... 30
d. Categories of Rules Granted to Resolve Differences Among
and Responding to the Legislative Actions of Committees.. 31
e. Categories of Rules Granted Dealing with House-Senate
Relations................................................ 32
f. Categories of Rules Granted with Certain Housekeeping
Tools.................................................... 33
4. Floor Consideration of a Special Rule..................... 33
5. Rules Rejected, Tabled, or Pending........................ 34
6. Explanation of Waivers of All Points of Order............. 35
7. Waivers of House Rules.................................... 35
8. Waivers of Budget Enforcement............................. 41
C. Original Jurisdiction Matter................................ 43
1. Committee Consideration of Original Jurisdiction Measures. 43
2. Original Jurisdiction Full Committee Hearings............. 43
3. Original Jurisdiction Measures Reported................... 45
IV. Activities of the Subcommittees.............................. 51
A. Activities of the Subcommittee on Rules and Organization of
the House.................................................... 51
1. Jurisdiction and Purpose.................................. 51
2. Summary of Activities in the 118th Congress............... 51
3. Legislation Referred to the Subcommittee on Rules and
Organization of the House.................................. 52
B. Activities of the Subcommittee on Legislative and Budget
Process...................................................... 52
1. Jurisdiction and Purpose.................................. 52
2. Summary of Activities in the 118th Congress............... 52
3. Legislation Referred to the Subcommittee on Legislative
and Budget Process......................................... 52
V. Statistical Profile of the Committee on Rules in the 118th
Congress....................................................... 53
VI. Publications................................................. 55
VII. Appendices.................................................. 57
VIII. Minority Views............................................. 114
Union Calendar No. 826
118th Congress }
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
2d Session } { Rept.118-979
=====================================================================
SURVEY OF ACTIVITIES OF THE HOUSE COMMITTEE
ON RULES FOR THE 118TH CONGRESS
SURVEY OF ACTIVITIES OF THE HOUSE COMMITTEE ON RULES FOR THE 118TH
CONGRESS
_______
January 3, 2025.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
_______
Mr. Burgess, from the Committee on Rules,
submitted the following
R E P O R T
together with
Minority Views
Pursuant to clause 1(d) of rule XI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee on Rules transmits
herewith its Survey of Activities for the 118th Congress.
I. HISTORY, FUNCTION, AND ORGANIZATION OF THE COMMITTEE ON RULES
A. Introduction
In the 118th Congress, the Committee on Rules returned to
its traditional two-subcommittee structure and retained its
purpose in the House of Representatives. Its size and super
majority ratio remained the same as in previous Congresses,
under both Republican and Democratic control. The Committee's
central function continued to be setting the conditions under
which major legislation is considered on the House floor,
particularly regarding the terms of debate and the process for
consideration of amendments.
The Committee has been described by various scholars and
Members as a ``legislative traffic cop,'' ``gatekeeper,''
``field commander,'' as well as ``the Speaker's Committee.''
All of these terms highlight the critical role the Committee
plays in the conduct of legislative business in the House.
While the primary responsibility of the Committee is to be the
scheduling arm of the majority leadership, it also exercises
``original jurisdiction'' over the rules of the House, joint
rules of the House and Senate, the order of business in the
House, and the budget process. Although the principal purpose
of this report is to summarize the activities of the Rules
Committee in the 118th Congress, its secondary purpose is to
view these activities in the context of the evolution of the
Committee and the House of Representatives since the First
Congress in 1789.
B. History and Function
The 118th Congress of the United States has created new
areas of precedent, challenging the traditional function of the
Committee on Rules--and its relationship with the Speaker of
the House--in exceptional ways. Chief among these challenges
was the razor-thin majority, which allowed a small, determined
group of members to stymie the will of the Speaker and in many
cases, the will of the majority of the Majority. But to fully
appreciate the drastic shift in the 118th Congress, it is
important to place the role of the Committee in context.
The history of the Committee on Rules roughly parallels the
evolution of the House over the past 235 years. The first Rules
Committee was established as a select committee of the House on
the second day of the First Congress, April 2, 1789, pursuant
to the Constitutional mandate in Article I, section 5, clause 2
that, ``Each House may determine the rules of its proceedings .
. .''. The House order creating the Committee stated that ``a
committee be appointed to prepare and report such standing
rules and order of proceeding as may be proper to be observed
in this House . . .''.
The Members serving on the Rules Committee have included
some of the most prominent Members of the House. Of the first
11 Members on the Committee, several were Founding Fathers of
the nation. These included: (1) Representative James Madison of
Virginia, the ``Father of the Constitution'' and future
President of the United States; (2) Representative Roger
Sherman of Connecticut, the only one of the Founding Fathers to
help prepare and sign all four of the most important documents
of the early nation: the Articles of Association, the Articles
of Confederation, the Declaration of Independence, and the
Constitution; (3) Representative Elias Boudinot of New Jersey,
President of the Continental Congress from November 1782 to
November 1783; and (4) Representative Elbridge Gerry of
Massachusetts, a future Vice President of the United States and
a signer of both the Declaration of Independence and the
Articles of Confederation.
Five days after its appointment, the first Select Committee
on Rules began exercising its responsibilities. It reported
four rules on: (1) the duties of the Speaker, (2) decorum and
debate, (3) the disposition of bills, and (4) the operations of
the Committee of the Whole. Six days later, on April 13, 1789,
the Select Committee reported an additional eight rules dealing
with such matters as the service of Members on committees,
Members' attendance during floor proceedings, the creation of a
standing Committee on Elections, the duties of the Clerk, and
the duties of the Sergeant at Arms. Following the adoption of
these rules by the House, the Select Committee was dissolved.
During the first 90 years of the House, this pattern
continued. At the beginning of each Congress, the House would
establish a Select Committee on Rules, which would report any
recommended revisions in the standing rules of the House from
those of the previous, and then dissolve. In some Congresses,
the House did not appoint a Select Committee on Rules and
instead operated under the rules adopted in the preceding
Congress.
Although in its early years the House relied primarily on
select committees to draft legislation, by the mid-nineteenth
century this system evolved to include 34 standing committees,
which assumed such responsibilities. The House briefly
converted the Rules Committee into a standing committee between
1849 and 1853. In 1880, the House permanently converted the
Rules Committee into a standing committee chaired by the
Speaker of the House. It was this Speaker-Chair position,
combined with the newly-emerging role of the Committee to
report rules managing consideration of legislation on the
floor, that cement the Committee's place in legislative
history.
In 1883, the modern Rules Committee began to emerge when
the House upheld the right of the Committee to issue ``special
orders of business'' or ``special rules'' providing for the
consideration of legislation from other committees. By 1890,
this new role had become the exclusive prerogative of the Rules
Committee.
Special rules, which were and are House resolutions, also
known as simple resolutions reported from the Rules Committee,
were important because they required only a majority vote of
the House to provide for the consideration of bills out of the
order in which they appeared on the floor Calendar. This is
notable because, until the use of special rules, a two-thirds
vote was required to suspend the rules and consider a bill out
of order. A simple majority could now accomplish what
previously required a super-majority. Special rules gained
importance because they gave the House flexibility in its
legislative agenda, which in turn, allowed for House leadership
to respond to changing judgments about the nation's needs at
any given time, and to do so with increased certainty as to the
outcome of their legislative agenda.
The individual most responsible for recognizing and
utilizing the full potential of the combined powers of the
Speaker and Rules Committee chair was Representative Thomas
Brackett Reed of Maine, who served in those two roles between
1889-91 and l895-99.
Not only did he use his authority as Speaker to make
rulings from the Chair that outlawed certain obstructionist
tactics on the House floor; he also proceeded to codify these
rulings, known as ``Reed's Rules,'' in the standing rules of
the House through his capacity as Rules Committee Chairman.
Speaker Reed also made regular use of the Rules Committee to
report special rules, enabling him to schedule bills to be
considered on the floor when he wished and under his terms of
debate and amendment.
It was not until 1910 that this powerful Speaker-Chair
combination was broken up by a revolt against Speaker Joseph
Cannon of Illinois, who had served as Speaker and Rules
Committee chair since 1903. A group of progressive Republican
insurgents joined with the Democratic minority to bypass the
Rules Committee and directly amend the House Rules from the
floor. When Speaker Cannon upheld a point of order that only
the Rules Committee could recommend changes in House Rules, the
group voted to overturn the ruling. They were then able to
amend the rules of the House, stripping the Speaker of his
chairmanship and membership on the Rules Committee, as well as
his power to appoint Members to the Committee.
They also voted to enlarge the Committee from five to 10
members elected by the House. The following year, a new
Democratic majority completed the revolution by taking away the
Speaker's power to appoint Members to all of the other
committees of the House. Since then, the House has elected all
Members to standing committees.
This revolt had far-reaching and long-lasting consequences.
The standing committees became independent power centers, no
longer directly accountable to the Speaker. While the Rules
Committee continued to serve as the scheduling arm of the
Leadership, it illustrated its independence when reaction set
in against the New Deal in 1937.
From that time until 1961, the Committee was dominated by a
conservative coalition of Southern Democrats and Republicans
who sometimes would refuse to report rules on bills that the
majority leadership wanted on the floor, or they would report
such rules only under their own terms and timing. A successful
effort by Speaker Sam Rayburn of Texas and President John F.
Kennedy in 1961 to enlarge the Committee from 12 to 15 Members,
including two more liberal Democrats, did not resolve this
problem.
It was not until the mid-1970s, with a large influx of new
Democratic Members, that the Rules Committee was fully restored
as an arm of the majority leadership.
This reform movement, with the emergence of more
independent Members and the proliferation of semi-autonomous
subcommittees, furthered the decentralization of power in the
House. This decentralization soon led to pressures to give the
majority leadership, in particular the Speaker acting through
the Rules Committee, more authority to direct the business of
the House.
In 1975, the Democratic Speaker was given authority under
Caucus rules to appoint all Rules Committee Democrats, subject
to Caucus ratification. In 1989, the Republican Conference gave
the minority leader the same authority to appoint all Rules
Committee Republicans. The slates of appointees recommended by
both Leaders are still subject to approval by the whole House
in the form of a simple resolution. This practice continues
today. In the 118th Congress, all of the Republican Members
were appointed to the Rules Committee through the adoption of
H. Res. 14 and H. Res. 1133. The Democratic Members of the
Committee were appointed through the adoption of H. Res. 15.
Overall, the Rules Committee continues its role of
facilitating the deliberation and amendment of major
legislation in the House. However, the 118th Congress was not
without its challenges. As previously mentioned, a razor-thin
majority--the smallest in our nation's history--contributed to
a nearly unprecedented seven defeated special rules reported
out of the Rules Committee. Only the 93rd Congress, just over
50 years ago, had more special rules defeated. In addition, the
118th Congress saw the first successful resolution to vacate
the office of the Speaker and the consideration of an
additional unsuccessful resolution of the same nature. Finally,
a procedural vote on a motion to recommit H.R. 2925 was
successful, a success unseen in the previous Congress.
In these ways, the 118th Congress explored a new era of
tradition and practice over the institutional procedures of
old. Yet even with these dynamics, the institution saw success
in broadening the voices heard of those elected, from the
highest of rank to the rank-and-file. H. Res. 5 reversed a
variety of ``reforms''' enacted in previous Congresses with the
intent to restore a more robust legislative process that
broadened the voices influencing its outcome. The resolution
repealed COVID-era rules imposed under then-Speaker Nancy
Pelosi that consolidated legislative decision-making to the
Speaker's chamber. Such rules included the use of proxy voting
and the prolific use of en bloc amendment consideration to pre-
determine amendments outcomes and ultimately protect members of
the Democratic majority from taking any difficult votes.
Considering this intent, the 118th Congress has proved to
be an unmitigated success. The resulting process dramatically
increased the legislative activity of the chamber which more
accurately reflected the democratic norms the Founding Fathers
envisioned. In the 118th Congress, House Republicans provided a
more than 40 percent increase in the number of rules with
amendments as compared to either of the previous two Congresses
under Democrat control, considered more amendments on the floor
than the previous four years combined, and considered a
modified-open rule for the first time in over three Congresses.
Nearly 1,600 amendments were offered to a single bill, a
massive increase from any other bill in recent memory. While
outcomes of such efforts were at times relatively mixed in
comparison to previous years, the process restored the ability
of all Members to have a voice in the legislative process, a
stark contrast to the top-down leadership-driven approach in
previous years. Certainly those who applaud the outcomes of the
previous Democratic majority should take heed that such certain
outcomes often come at the expense of allowing robust Member
participation and more open processes.
While the most high-profile role of the Rules Committee is
to direct legislative traffic to the House floor, the Committee
is also responsible for other important business. For instance,
as part of its gate-keeping work, the Committee must help
resolve jurisdictional disputes between other standing
committees. As is often the case, committees will report
legislation with amendments that impact the jurisdiction of
other committees. When legislation with such cross-
jurisdictional language comes to the Rules Committee, the
Committee must resolve these disputes to ensure that
legislation reaches the floor without controversy between House
committees.
Finally, with the aid of the Office of the Parliamentarian,
the Committee plays a role in ensuring compliance with the
House Rules. Authorizing and appropriating committees often
seek guidance in how to conduct their oversight and legislative
responsibilities in accordance with the Rules, and when
questions arise regarding the propriety of certain courses of
action, they turn to the Rules Committee or the Parliamentarian
for the answer.
Overall, and notwithstanding changes in majority control,
the Rules Committee continues its role of facilitating the
deliberation and amending of legislation in the House, all the
while balancing the legislative agenda of the majority
leadership with preserving institutional norms and promoting
civility in discourse and debate.
C. Committee Organization During the 118th Congress
At the beginning of the 94th Congress, the Committee
membership was increased from 15 Members (10 Democrats and five
Republicans) to 16 Members (11 Democrats and five Republicans).
This ratio remained until the 98th Congress, when the
membership was reduced to 13 Members (nine Democrats and four
Republicans). The membership has remained at 13 for the 118th
Congress. The ratio of majority party Members to minority party
Members also has remained the same. As in the 112th through the
115th Congresses, Republicans comprised the majority, with
Democrats in the minority. During the 116th and 117th
Congresses, Democrats were in the majority.
Seven of the 13 members of the Rules Committee in the 118th
Congress served on the Committee during the previous Congress.
The returning Republican Representatives were Tom Cole of
Oklahoma, Michael Burgess of Texas, Guy Reschenthaler of
Pennsylvania, and Michelle Fischbach of Minnesota. The new
Republican Representatives on the Committee for the 118th
Congress were Thomas Massie of Kentucky, Ralph Norman of South
Carolina, Chip Roy of Texas, Erin Houchin of Indiana, and
Nicholas Langworthy of New York. Tom Cole of Oklahoma was
elected as Chair of the Committee on January 10, 2023, and
served as Chair until he resigned from the Committee on April
11, 2024, and was subsequently elected Chair of the Committee
on Appropriations. On the same date, Michael Burgess of Texas
was elected as Chair of the Rules Committee and Austin Scott of
Georgia was elected as a Member of the Committee. The returning
Democratic Representatives were James McGovern of
Massachusetts, Mary Gay Scanlon of Pennsylvania, and Joe Neguse
of Colorado. The new Democratic Representative on the Committee
for the 118th Congress was Teresa Leger Fernandez of New
Mexico.
The Committee held its organizational meeting on January
30, 2023. Chair Tom Cole of Oklahoma opened the meeting and
welcomed all the Committee Members.
Chair Cole announced that the proposed Rules Committee
rules would be considered as read and open for amendment at any
point. He explained that the proposal called for the adoption
of the Committee's rules which remained the same as the
previous Congress with one proposed change, reducing the number
of subcommittees from three to two. The Committee retained the
Subcommittee on Rules and Organization of the House and the
Subcommittee on Legislative and Budget Process.
Mr. Burgess offered a motion that the Committee adopt the
proposed Committee rules for the 118th Congress. Four
amendments were considered. Amendment #1, offered by Mr.
McGovern, would have extended the existing requirement that the
text of bills the Committee meets on be made available for 24
hours by including Rules Committee Prints in what must be
provided, and was not agreed to by a voice vote. Amendment #2,
offered by Mr. McGovern, would have required a two-thirds vote
instead of a simple majority to report a rule that waives the
72-hour rule, and was not agreed to by a record vote of 4 to 8.
Amendment #3, offered by Mr. McGovern, would have required a
committee vote before beginning testimony on any emergency
measure, and was not agreed to by a record vote of 4 to 9.
Amendment #4, offered by Ms. Scanlon, would have required the
chair to allow nongovernment minority witnesses to testify
before the Rules Committee if the ranking member certifies that
circumstances necessitate remote testimony, and was not agreed
to by a voice vote. Mr. Burgess's motion to adopt the Committee
rules was agreed to by voice vote.
Pursuant to clause 2(d) of rule XI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, Chair Cole designated Michael Burgess
as the Vice Chair of the Rules Committee to act on the Chair's
behalf during a temporary absence of the Chair.
Mr. Burgess offered a motion that pursuant to rule 5(c) of
the Committee on Rules, the Subcommittee on Rules and
Organization of the House and the Subcommittee on Legislative
and Budget Process continued to be composed of five majority
and two minority Members, identical to the ratio used in recent
Congresses. Mr. Burgess's motion was agreed to by voice vote.
Chair Cole asked unanimous consent that any appointments to the
subcommittees be postponed until the chair and ranking member
had time to consult with committee members and each other.
Finally, the majority and minority staff of the Committee
on Rules was approved and the committee staff was authorized to
make technical and conforming changes to rules reported by the
Committee for the duration of the 118th Congress.