Purpose and Summary
S. 2256, the Federal Cybersecurity Workforce Expansion Act, would establish two new pilot programs related to the cybersecurity workforce. It would create a five-year cybersecurity apprenticeship pilot program within the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). Up to 25 apprentices could participate in this program each year and enter into service agreements with the federal government upon completion of the program. The bill also directs DHS, in coordination with the Department of Veterans Affairs, to establish a five-year pilot program to provide cybersecurity training at no cost to veterans and military spouses. Under the bill, DHS would submit annual reports to Congress on each of these pilot programs, and the Government Accountability Office (GAO) would conduct an assessment of each program within four years after it is established. Finally, the bill would extend from 2022 to 2027 the requirement that federal agencies submit an annual report to the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) identifying cyber- related work roles in the agency's workforce.\1\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\On November 3, 2021, the Committee approved S. 2274, the Federal Cybersecurity Workforce Expansion Act. That bill, as reported, is substantially similar to S. 2256. Accordingly, this committee report is, in many respects, similar to the committee report for S. 2274. See S. Rept. 117-131. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- II. Background and Need for the Legislation There is a national shortage of qualified cybersecurity personnel. According to CyberSeek, a project supported by the National Initiative for Cybersecurity Education (NICE) at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), there are over 660,000 cybersecurity job openings in the United States, including over 8,000 at the federal level, as of August 2023.\2\ A September 2022 State of the Federal Cyber Workforce report by the Federal Cyber Workforce Management and Coordinating Working Groups noted that ``[s]ystemic changes to the development of our cyber workforce are vital for our nation to sufficiently govern and maintain our critical infrastructures and data security.'' The report also found that ``increasing cyber attacks and a heightened talent shortage serves as a wake-up call that the federal government must reenergize and promote how it is a premier place of employment for cyber professionals.''\3\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\Cyberseek, Interactive Map (www.cyberseek.org/heatmap.html) (accessed Aug. 9, 2023). \3\Cyber Workforce Management and Coordinating Working Group, State of the Federal Cyber Workforce: A Call for Collective Action (Sept. 2022) (digital.va.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/State-of-the-Federal- Cyber-Workforce-Report_2022.pdf). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The consistent shortage of cybersecurity personnel represents a high risk to national security. Federal cyber workforce management challenges have been on the GAO High-Risk List since 2003.\4\ In that report, GAO stated: --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\Government Accountability Office, High-Risk Series: Protecting Information Systems Supporting the Federal Government and the Nation's Critical Infrastructures (GAO-03-121) (Jan. 2003) (www.gao.gov/assets/ gao-03-121.pdf). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- [A]gencies must have the technical expertise they need to select, implement, and maintain controls that protect their information systems. Similarly, the federal government must maximize the value of its technical staff by sharing expertise and information. . . . [T]he availability of adequate technical and audit expertise is a continuing concern to agencies.\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \5\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Since 2003, the need for a developed and expansive cyber workforce has continued to intensify. As GAO Director of Information Security Issues, Gregory C. Wilshusen, stated in March 2018 testimony before the House Committee on Homeland Security Subcommittees on Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Protection and Oversight and Management Efficiency during a hearing examining the cybersecurity workforce: The Office of Management and Budget has noted that the federal government and private industry face a persistent shortage of cybersecurity and IT talent to implement and oversee information security protections. This shortage may leave federal IT systems vulnerable to malicious attacks. Experienced and qualified cybersecurity professionals are essential in performing DHS's work to mitigate vulnerabilities in its own and other agencies' computer systems and to defend against cyber threats.\6\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\Government Accountability Office, Cybersecurity Workforce: DHS Needs to Take Urgent Action to Identify Its Position and Critical Skills Requirements (GAO-18-430T) (Mar. 2018) (www.gao.gov/assets/gao- 18-430t.pdf). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In the April 2023 High-Risk Series report, GAO recommended that federal agencies ``take additional actions to address the federal cybersecurity workforce shortage'' and that the Office of Management and Budget develop a governmentwide workforce plan to address the issues facing the cyber workforce.\7\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \7\Government Accountability Office, High-Risk Series: Efforts Made to Achieve Progress Need to Be Maintained and Expanded to Fully Address All Areas (GAO-23-106203) (Apr. 2023) (www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23- 106203.pdf). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The problem of cybersecurity workforce shortages has taken on increased urgency as the United States faces escalating threats from hostile cyber actors. In 2021, multiple high- profile cybersecurity incidents, including SolarWinds, Microsoft Exchange, and Colonial Pipeline, prompted President Biden to issue an Executive Order aimed at improving the nation's cybersecurity preparedness systems.\8\ Furthermore, critical infrastructure, such as healthcare systems, face an ever-growing threat from cyber incidents that affect operations and patient care, illustrated by recent attacks in early 2023 on Tallahassee Memorial HealthCare in Florida and the University of Michigan Health System.\9\ These cyber attacks further underscore the urgent need to advance skills of the nation's cybersecurity workforce. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\Executive Order No. 14,028, 86 Fed. Reg. 26,633 (May 12, 2021). \9\Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Opening Statement of Chairman Gary Peters, Hearing on In Need of a Checkup: Examining the Cybersecurity Risks to the Healthcare Sector, 118th Cong. (Mar. 16, 2023) (S. Hrg. 118-XX). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs has held multiple hearings in the wake of cybersecurity attacks to address the government's preparedness, response, and recovery efforts.\10\ During a hearing on September 23, 2021, entitled National Cybersecurity Strategy: Protection of Federal and Critical Infrastructure Systems, Senator Margaret Wood Hassan (D-NH) asked Jen Easterly, Director of the Cyber and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), if an apprenticeship program would help address workforce challenges at CISA. Director Easterly said, ``We've already started talking about how we could implement apprenticeships at CISA. . . . I think we need to be as creative as possible in all our approaches to deal with the deficit that we have across the country and then across the federal cyber workforce.'' Fellow witness Chris Inglis, National Cyber Director in the Executive Office of the President, agreed with Director Easterly's remarks and added that ``apprenticeships are essential, not simply because they provide experience for its own sake, but they bridge the gap between aspiration that is often supported by training and education and the real experience that employers need or want when you show up at that door.''\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \10\See Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Hearing on Prevention, Response and Recovery: Improving Federal Cybersecurity Post-SolarWinds, 117th Cong. (May 11, 2021) (S. Hrg. 117-XX); Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Hearing on Threats to Critical Infrastructure: Examining the Colonial Pipeline Cyber Attack, 117th Cong. (June 8, 2021) (S. Hrg. 117-429); Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Hearing on National Cybersecurity Strategy: Protection of Federal and Critical Infrastructure Systems, 117th Cong. (Sep. 23, 2021) (S. Hrg. 117-266); and Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Hearing on In Need of a Checkup: Examining the Cybersecurity Risks to the Healthcare Sector, 118th Cong. (Mar. 16, 2023) (S. Hrg. 118-XX). \11\Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Transcript, Hearing on National Cybersecurity Strategy: Protection of Federal and Critical Infrastructure Systems, 117th Cong. (Sep. 23, 2021) (S. Hrg. 117-266) (https://plus.cq.com/doc/ congressionaltranscripts-6351036?4&searchId=9Svfjbqf). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In March 2023, the Biden Administration continued efforts to expand the cyber workforce through the release of a National Cybersecurity Strategy. The strategy recognized ``the need for cybersecurity expertise across all sectors of the economy'' and seeks to ``strengthen and diversify the Federal cyber workforce, addressing the unique challenges the public sector faces in recruiting, retaining, and developing the talent and capacity needed to protect Federal data and IT infrastructure.''\12\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\The White House, National Cybersecurity Strategy (Mar. 2023) (www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/National-Cybersecurity- Strategy-2023.pdf). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In July 2023, the White House published an additional strategy document focused on strengthening cyber education and training opportunities. The National Cyber Workforce and Education Strategy highlights the importance of skills-based approaches like apprenticeship programs: Integrated education and training models that include work-based learning, paid internships, externships, pre-apprenticeships, or registered apprenticeships have proven to be effective. Through these and other work- based learning opportunities, cyber workers can earn a wage as they gain hands-on experience and develop their skills. The Federal Cybersecurity Workforce Expansion Act aims to strengthen the cybersecurity talent pipeline within the federal government by establishing a registered apprenticeship pilot program at DHS in which participants receive on-the-job cybersecurity training. Upon successful completion of the program, participants may be appointed to cybersecurity- specific positions within a federal agency. The appointed program graduates would enter into a service agreement, in which they commit to working in the federal government for a period of service equal to the length of the apprenticeship. Under the bill, DHS and the Department of Veterans Affairs also would establish a pilot program to provide cybersecurity training at no cost to veterans and military spouses. This pilot program would incorporate coursework, virtual learning, and work-based learning opportunities and lead to a recognized postsecondary credential. This bill incorporates recommendations from a report published by the Cyberspace Solarium Commission in March 2020. The report recommended that the federal government ``develop work-based learning programs and apprenticeships to supplement classroom learning'' as a step to improve cyber-oriented education.\13\ Another recommendation called for designing ``cybersecurity-specific upskilling and transition assistance programs for veterans and transitioning military service members to move into federal civilian cybersecurity jobs.''\14\ The Federal Cybersecurity Workforce Expansion Act reflects these recommendations and would augment cybersecurity workforce development pathways. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\Cyberspace Solarium Commission, A Warning From Tomorrow (Mar. 2020) (drive.google.com/file/d/1ryMCIL_dZ30QyjFqFkkf10MxIXJGT4yv/view). \14\Id. at 44. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- III. Legislative History Senator Hassan (D-NH) introduced S. 2256, the Federal Cybersecurity Workforce Expansion Act, on July 12, 2023, with Senator John Cornyn (R-TX) as an original cosponsor. The bill was referred to the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs. The Committee considered S. 2256 at a business meeting on July 26, 2023. During the business meeting, S. 2256 was ordered reported favorably by roll call vote of 7 yeas to 1 nay, with Senators Peters, Hassan, Sinema, Rosen, Ossoff, Lankford, and Scott voting in the affirmative and Senator Paul voting in the negative. Senators Carper, Padilla, Blumenthal, Johnson, Romney, Hawley, and Marshall voted yea by proxy, for the record only. IV. Section-by-Section Analysis of the Bill, as Reported Section 1. Short title This section establishes the short title of the bill as the ``Federal Cybersecurity Workforce Expansion Act.'' Section 2. Findings This section includes findings indicating the need for additional federal cybersecurity professionals. Section 3. Definitions This section defines the terms ``Department,'' ``institution of higher education,'' and ``Secretary'' for the purposes of this bill. Section 4. Cybersecurity apprenticeship pilot program Subsection (a) defines the terms ``area career and technical education school,'' ``community college,'' ``competitive service,'' ``cyber workforce position,'' ``early college high school; educational service agency; local educational agency; secondary school; state educational agency,'' ``education and training provider,'' ``eligible entity,'' ``excepted service,'' ``local workforce development board,'' ``minority-serving institution,'' ``nonprofit organization,'' ``provider of adult education,'' ``qualified intermediary,'' ``related instruction,'' ``sponsor,'' ``state,'' ``state apprenticeship agency,'' ``state workforce development board,'' and additional terms from the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act for the purposes of this section. Subsection (b) directs the Secretary of Homeland Security to establish an apprenticeship pilot program within three years of the bill's enactment. DHS would employ up to 25 apprentices in cyber workforce positions during each year of the program. The pilot program would offer learning opportunities based on the NICE Workforce Framework for Cybersecurity, or a successor framework, and prepare the participants for cyber workforce positions within federal agencies. DHS or an eligible entity receiving a contract, cooperative agreement, or grant would sponsor the registered apprenticeship program and veterans would be able to use their educational assistance toward the program. Subsection (c) directs the Secretary of Homeland Security to consult with the Secretary of Labor, the Director of NIST, the Secretary of Defense, the Director of the National Science Foundation, and the Director of OPM when developing the apprenticeship pilot program. Subsection (d) outlines options available to DHS for entering into a contract or cooperative agreement with or a making a grant to an eligible entity for assistance sponsoring the apprenticeship program. The entity chosen to sponsor the program must have demonstrated experience in implementing apprenticeship programs, have knowledge of cybersecurity workforce development, be able to provide participants with one or more recognized postsecondary credentials, use instruction that is specifically aligned with the needs of federal agencies, and have demonstrated success in connecting apprenticeship participants with careers relevant to the pilot program. Subsection (e) requires any entity seeking a contract, cooperative agreement, or grant under subsection (d) to submit an application to DHS with such information as the Secretary may require. Subsection (f) allows DHS to prioritize an eligible entity in the context of subsection (d) if the entity: (1) is a member of an industry or sector partnership that sponsors or participates in an apprenticeship program; (2) provides related instruction for a registered apprenticeship program; (3) works to transition members of the military and veterans to apprenticeship programs in a relevant sector; (4) plans to carry out the apprenticeship program with an entity that receives state funding or is operated by a state agency; (5) has successfully increased the representation of women, minorities, and individuals from other underrepresented communities in cybersecurity; or (6) focuses on recruiting women, minorities, and individuals from other underrepresented communities. Subsection (g) directs DHS to provide technical assistance to eligible entities selected under subsection (d) to leverage any existing and relevant federal job training and education programs. Subsection (h) requires pilot program participants to enter into a service agreement in which they agree to serve in a cyber workforce position within a federal agency, if offered such a position after completion of the apprenticeship program, for a length of time equal to the length of the apprenticeship program. If an individual does not satisfy the requirements of the service agreement, they would need to repay the cost of the education and training provided, reduced by an amount factoring in the period of service they completed. The Secretary may waive the service or repayment requirements in certain circumstances, such as if compliance would involve hardship to the individual. Subsection (i) specifies that participants in the apprenticeship program may be appointed to cybersecurity positions in the excepted service. Subsection (j) specifies that individuals who successfully complete the apprenticeship program may be appointed to cybersecurity positions in the excepted service. Subsecti