Background
Pueblos of Jemez and Zia. The Pueblos are located on two separate Reservations within their respective ancestral territories, approximately 40 miles northwest of Albuquerque in central New Mexico. The Pueblo of Jemez includes over 89,000 acres of land and has 3,400 Tribal members;\1\ and the Pueblo of Zia is comprised of more than 170,000 acres of land and has over 900 Tribal members.\2\ For centuries, both Pueblos have functioned as agricultural communities and irrigated to farm corn, squash, and other crops, as well as support of livestock.\3\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\Legislative Hearing on Tule River Tribe Reserved Water Rights Settlement Act of 2022, S. 4896, Pueblos of Jemez and Zia Water Rights Settlement Act of 2022, and S. 4898 Pueblos of Acoma and Laguna Water Rights Settlement Act of 2022 Before the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, 117th Cong. (2022) (written testimony of the Honorable Raymond Loretto, DVM, Governor of the Pueblo of Jemez). \2\Application for Treatment in a Similar Manner as a State Under Clean Air Act 2018, page 5 at https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/ 2018-07/documents/pueblo-zia-tas-application-supporting- documentation.pdf. \3\See supra, note 1. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Jemez River flows through the boundaries of both Pueblos, providing water for irrigation and recharging the alluvial aquifers that supply the Pueblos' drinking water.\4\ The river also supplies water throughout the Jemez River Basin for domestic, municipal, commercial, agricultural and environmental purposes, and it supports sacred and culturally significant Pueblo resources that rely on the River and related groundwater for survival.\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\Id. \5\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Despite their proximity to the river, the Pueblos have consistently struggled to meet the modern water and wastewater needs of their Reservation populations due to lack of water pressure, water quality concerns, insufficient storage capacity, and outdated infrastructure.\6\ Without intervention, these issues will continue to worsen as the populations and economic activities of Pueblos continue to expand.\7\ Accordingly, for the past 40 years, the Pueblos have been actively seeking remedies in and out of court to improve the dependability and quality of their water supply, as well as their drinking water and wastewater systems. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\Id. The Pueblos' drinking water infrastructure was built in the 1960s, and the Pueblos' wastewater treatment needs are currently served by non-discharging evaporation lagoons rather than modern and scalable forms of sewer treatment and discharge. \7\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- S. 595 would fully and finally settle the Pueblos' outstanding legal claims by authorizing, ratifying, and confirming the 2022 Agreement that resolves the matter through a fund-based settlement that supports: completion of a water and wastewater feasibility study; construction of new water and wastewater systems; improvement and augmentation of existing irrigation systems; establishment of a Pueblo Water Resources Department; quantification of the Pueblos' additional domestic, commercial, municipal, and industrial water rights; rehabilitation and new construction of livestock watering facilities; acquisition of land and water rights adjacent to the Pueblo ditches and around the Jemez River stream restoration projects; and construction of a water pipeline. Pueblos of Acoma and Laguna. The Pueblos are located in the river basin of the Rio San Jose, west of Albuquerque along Route 66. The Pueblo of Acoma includes approximately 450,000 acres of land\8\ and has over 6,000 enrolled members;\9\ the Pueblo of Laguna is comprised of approximately 500,000 acres of land and has over 7,800 enrolled members.\10\ The Pueblos' economies historically relied on irrigated agriculture, including subsistence style farming and trade, and they designed and built vast systems of irrigation ditches and massive reservoirs before first contact with the Spanish and Pueblo people.\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\Pueblo of Acoma Land Holdings at https://www.puebloofacoma.org/ wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Acoma-Landholdings_Final.pdf. \9\Raymond Concho Jr. & Arvind Patel, Enhancement of Pueblo of Acoma Utility Authority, presentation to the United States Department of Energy, Office of Indian Energy (2017) at https://www.energy.gov/ sites/prod/files/2017/11/f46/48-acoma-pueblo.pdf. \10\Laguna Department of Education, Pueblo of Laguna, at https:// www.lagunaed.net/ pueblolaguna#::text=Laguna%20Pueblo%20is%20one%20of,over%207%2C800 %20enrolled %20tribal%20members. \11\Legislative Hearing on Tule River Tribe Reserved Water Rights Settlement Act of 2022, S. 4896, Pueblos of Jemez and Zia Water Rights Settlement Act of 2022, and S. 4898 Pueblos of Acoma and Laguna Water Rights Settlement Act of 2022 Before the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, 117th Cong. (2022) (written testimony of the Honorable Martin Kowemy, Jr., Governor of the Pueblo of Laguna). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Pueblos historically irrigated thousands of acres of agricultural fields along the Rio San Jose, until late 19th Century diversions on the mainstem of the river began depriving both Pueblos of surface water.\12\ Since then, over a century of diversions by junior water users have resulted in irreversible damage to the Pueblos' water supply, including loss of most of the flow from Rio San Jose.\13\ This water loss has affected the Pueblos by substantially reducing agriculture, limiting flow to the riparian zone that nurtures native plants, and preventing important cultural ceremonies that require a flowing river.\14\ The loss is so significant that, even if all junior users immediately ceased use, historical flows could not be restored to the Pueblos for decades, if at all.\15\ As such, the Pueblos have spent 40 years in litigation and eight years in negotiations attempting to find a solution to their water crisis. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\Id. \13\Id. \14\Id. \15\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- NEED FOR LEGISLATION This bill would fully and finally settle the Pueblos' outstanding claims by authorizing, ratifying, and confirming the Rio San Jose Agreement, providing for a fund-based settlement, and supporting administration of Pueblo Water Rights on Pueblo lands under a Pueblo Water Code, similar to the manner in which water rights are administered by the New Mexico State Engineer on non-Indian lands. SUMMARY OF S. 595 AS ORDERED REPORTED S. 595 authorizes, ratifies, and confirms the Rio San Jose Agreement, as amended; requires the Pueblo Water Rights to be held in trust by the United States; makes certain authorizations and prohibitions regarding the Pueblo Water Rights; establishes Settlement Trust Funds for the Pueblos of Acoma, Laguna, Jemez, and Zia; authorizes mandatory appropriations for the Settlement Trust Funds and other purposes; and places certain requirements on the Secretary of the Interior. LEGISLATIVE HISTORY Senators Heinrich (D-NM) and Lujan (D-NM) introduced S. 595 on March 1, 2023. It was referred to the Committee on the same day. On March 29, 2023, the Committee met at a duly convened business meeting to consider S. 595 with three other bills. The Committee passed three of the four bills, including S. 595, en bloc by voice vote without amendment, and ordered the bills to be reported favorably. Representatives Leger Fernandez (D-NM), Stansbury (D-NM), and Vasquez (D-NM), introduced H.R. 1304, an identical companion bill, on March 1, 2023. On the same day, it was referred to the House Committee on Natural Resources. On March 22, 2023, the bill was further referred to the Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife, and Fisheries. To date, the House has taken no further action on H.R. 1304. 117th Congress. Senator Heinrich (D-NM) introduced S. 4898, a bill substantially similar to Title I of S. 595 (Pueblos of Acoma and Lugan Water Rights Settlement), and S. 4896, a bill substantially similar to Title II of S. 595 (Pueblos of Jemez and Zia Water Rights Settlement), in the Senate on September 20, 2022. Both bills were referred to the Committee on Indian Affairs. The Committee held a hearing on the bills on November 16, 2022. The Committee took no further action on the bills before the conclusion of the 117th Congress. Representative Leger Fernandez (D-NM) introduced H.R. 8920, a companion bill to S. 4898, and H.R. 8921, a companion bill to S. 4896, in the House on September 20, 2022. On the same day, H.R. 8920 and H.R. 8921 were referred to the House Committee on Natural Resources. The House took no further action on the bills before the conclusion of the 117th Congress. SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF S. 595 AS ORDERED REPORTED Section 1--Short title; Table of Contents This section sets forth the short title as the ``Rio San Jose and Rio Jemez Water Settlements Act of 2023,'' and includes a table of contents. TITLE I--PUEBLOS OF ACOMA AND LAGUNA WATER RIGHTS SETTLEMENT Section 101--Purposes This section sets forth the purposes of the bill to: resolve the water rights claims of the Pueblo of Acoma, the Pueblo of Laguna, and the United States as their trustee, in the adjudication titled ``State of New Mexico, ex rel. State Engineer v. Kerr- McGee, et al.''; authorize, ratify, and confirm the Agreement entered into by the Pueblos, the State, and various other parties; authorize the Secretary to execute and modify the Agreement; and authorize funding to implement the Agreement. Section 102--Definitions This section provides definitions for various terms used throughout the bill. Section 103--Ratification of agreement This section authorizes, ratifies, and confirms the Agreement and conforming amendments; directs the Secretary to execute the Agreement, and authorizes the Secretary to make modifications consistent with congressional approval requirements and federal law. This section also requires the Secretary and the Pueblos to comply with federal environmental laws as applicable, affirms that execution of the Rio San Jose Agreement does not constitute a major federal action under the National Environmental Policy Act, and provides for the Pueblos' costs for related compliance activities to be paid from the Pueblo Trust Funds. Section 104--Pueblo Water Rights This section requires the Pueblo Water Rights to be held in trust by the United States; protects the rights from loss through non-use, forfeiture, abandonment, or other operation of law; preserves after-acquired state-law based water rights; and clarifies that the rights do not include water uses or water rights claims on an allotment. This section also authorizes the Pueblos to allocate, distribute, and lease the rights on and off Pueblo lands; requires the Pueblos to recognize, and not object to, allottee water rights in any general stream adjudication, including the Adjudication; prohibits alienation and forfeiture of the Pueblo Water Rights; provides that authorizations of the Act satisfy the requirements for federal authorization of purchases or grants of land from Indians; and clarifies that non-use of all or any portion of the Pueblo Water Rights by any water user shall not result in forfeiture of those rights. Section 105--Settlement Trust Funds This section establishes the Pueblo of Acoma Settlement Trust Fund, the Pueblo of Laguna Settlement Trust Fund, and the joint Acomita Reservoir Works Trust Fund. It also requires the Secretary to: manage the Pueblo Trust Funds in accordance with the American Indian Trust Fund Management Reform Act of 1994 and other federal laws governing the deposit and investment of Tribal funds; invest the funds with earnings accruing to the Pueblos; and make most funds available to the Pueblos on the enforceability date, with certain specified funds made available upon deposit. This section permits withdrawals from the Pueblo Trust Funds for certain specified purposes pursuant to a Tribal management plan in accordance with the American Indian Trust Fund Management Reform Act of 1994, or expenditure plans approved and enforced by the Secretary; withdrawals from the Acomita Reservoir Works Trust Fund may be submitted to the Secretary through a joint expenditure plan and subject to certain requirements. A right of judicial review of the Secretary's determination with respect to any of these plans is not allowed other than through the Administrative Procedures Act. This section also limits the uses for each of the Pueblos' accounts and Acomita Reservoir Works Trust Fund; requires annual reporting regarding withdrawals, and limits federal liability for expenditures and investments made by the Pueblos after withdrawal. It also prohibits per capita distribution of any portion of the Pueblo Trust Funds; confirms the Pueblo or Pueblos will retain title, control, and operation of any project constructed with trust funds; and makes the Pueblos responsible for the operation, maintenance, and replacement costs of such projects. Section 106--Funding This section authorizes mandatory appropriations for: the Pueblo of Acoma Settlement Trust Fund, including: $296,000,000 for the Water Rights Settlement Account, $14,000,000 for the Water Infrastructure Operations and Maintenance Account, and $1,750,000 for the Feasibility Studies Settlement Account. the Pueblo of Laguna Settlement Trust Fund, including: $464,000,000 for the Water Rights Settlement Account, $26,000,000 for the Water Infrastructure Operations and Maintenance Account, and $3,250,000 for the Feasibility Studies Settlement Account; and the Acomita Reservoir Works Trust Fund, in the amount of $45,000,000. This section also provides for adjustments of the Pueblo Trust Funds to address cost fluctuation and market volatility, and requires the State of New Mexico to contribute a cost share of $36,000,000. Section 107--Enforceability date This section requires the Secretary of the Interior to publish a statement of findings in the Federal Register to render the settlement agreement enforceable. Section 108--Waivers and releases of claims This section requires the parties to execute waivers and releases of claims related to the Pueblos' water rights, while reserving certain rights and retaining certain claims. This section also preserves the sovereignty and jurisdiction of the government entities; preserves the United States' authority to fulfill its trust responsibilities and enforce its laws, including environmental and jurisdictional laws; clarifies that the Act does not waive claims relating to quality of water and the environment under various federal laws or individual Tribal member claims; preserves claims relating to hunting, fishing, gathering, or cultural rights; and states that the Act does not confer jurisdiction on any state court to interpret federal health, safety, or environmental laws or determine the duties of any party thereunder, or conduct judicial review of any federal agency action. This section further provides for tolling of claims and defenses between the enactment and enforceability dates, and provides for termination of the agreement if the Secretary's statement of findings is not issued by July 1, 2030, or a later date mutually agreed upon by the Pueblos and the United States with notice to the State. This section also provides for the consequences of such termination. Section 109--Satisfaction of claims This section provides that benefits realized under the Act shall serve as full satisfaction of any claim of the Pueblos against the United States that the Pueblos waive and release under the Act. Section 110--Consent of United States to jurisdiction for judicial review of a Pueblo Water Right permit decision This section provides the United States' consent to the limited jurisdiction of the District Court for the Thirteenth Judicial District of the State of New Mexico, the New Mexico Court of Appeals, and the New Mexico Supreme Court to provide judicial review in an action appealing a Pueblo Water Right Permit decision under the Agreement, and sets standards for such review. Section 111--Miscellaneous provisions This section affirms the federal government's sovereign immunity is not waived, states that the land and water rights of allottees and other Tribes are not quantified or diminished, and confirms that the Act does not affect laws or regulations in effect prior to enactment regarding pre-enforcement review of federal environmental enforcement actions. This section also provides that the Act controls over the Agreement in the event of a conflict. Section 112--Antideficiency This section states that the United States shall not be liable for failure to perform if adequate appropriations are not provided by Congress. TITLE II--PUEBLOS OF JEMEZ AND ZIA WATER RIGHTS SETTLEMENT Section 201--Purposes This section sets forth the 4-fold purpose of the bill to: (1) resolve the water rights claims of the Pueblo of Jemez, the Pueblo of Zia, and the United States as their trustee, in the Jemez River Stream System; (2) authorize, ratify, and confirm the Agreement entered into by the Pueblos, the State, and various other parties; (3) authorize the Secretary to execute and carry out the Agreement; and (4) authorize funding to implement the Agreement. Section 202--Definitions This section provides definitions for various terms used throughout the bill. Section 203--Ratification of Agreement This section authorizes, ratifies, and confirms the Agreement and conforming amendments; directs the Secretary to execute the Agreement, and authorizes the Secretary to make modifications consistent with congressional approval requirements and federal law. This section also requires the Secretary and the Pueblos to comply with federal environmental laws as applicable, affirms that execution of the Agreement does not constitute a major federal action under the National Environmental Policy Act, and provides for the Pueblos' costs for related compliance activities to be paid from the Pueblo Trust Funds. Section 204--Pueblo Water Rights This section requires the Pueblo Water Rights to be held in trust by the United States; protects the rights from loss through non-use, forfeiture, abandonment, or other operation of law; preserves after-acquired state-law bas