Skip to content

senate · Committee report

S. Rept. 118-132

NORTH DAKOTA TRUST LANDS COMPLETION ACT OF 2023

2023-12-12

Committees

Associated legislation

Text

Section-by-Section Analysis

Section 1. Short title Section 1 provides the short title of the bill, the ``North Dakota Trust Lands Completion Act of 2023.'' Section 2. Definitions Section 2 defines key terms used in the bill. Section 3. Relinquishment and selection; Conveyance Subsection (a) states that the Secretary of the Interior (Secretary) may authorize the State of North Dakota (State) to relinquish certain State land grant parcels located wholly or partially within the boundaries of any Indian Reservation in the State, and in lieu of the relinquished land select one or more parcels of unappropriated Federal land of substantially equal value, not later than 180 days on the date in which the State makes a selection. The subsection clarifies that nothing in this subsection precludes the Secretary from conducting an environmental review of any proposed parcel relinquishment. Subsection (b) requires the Secretary to initiate the conveyance of unappropriated Federal land selected by the State within 60 days after the date the Secretary approves the selection, by patent or deed in a form acceptable to the Secretary and the State. The subsection also requires the State to concurrently relinquish and convey title to the State land grant parcels, free and clear of any financial claims, liabilities, or other financial encumbrances. Subsection (c) states that each party to which land is conveyed under this Act shall succeed to the rights and obligations of the conveying party with respect to any lease, right-of-way, permit, or other valid existing right to which the land is subject. Subsection (d) states that, on request from the applicable Tribe, any parcel relinquished by the State that is located wholly or partially within the boundary of an Indian reservation, shall be taken into trust by the Secretary on behalf of the Tribe and be considered to be part of the reservation. The subsection also requires that prior to any land conveyance, the State and the Secretary consult with the affected Indian Tribe. Subsection (e) withdraws, subject to valid existing rights, all unappropriated Federal land selected by the State for conveyance from public land laws, mining laws, and mineral, material, and geothermal leasing laws. Section 4. Valuation Subsection (a) requires that any State and Federal land parcel subject to conveyance be of substantially equal value and if not equal, the party conveying the less valued parcel equalize the value by payment and record the imbalance on a ledger account. Subsection (b) requires an appraisal of the land parcels subject to conveyance to be conducted by one or more independent appraisers selected jointly by the Secretary and the State, and that such appraisals shall be subject to the Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions or the Uniform Standards for Professional Appraisal Practice. Subsection (c) requires that any cash equalization payments may not exceed 25 percent of the total value of the parcel of unappropriated Federal land. Subsection (d) authorizes the Secretary to use mass appraisals, a summary appraisal, or a statement of value by a qualified appraiser carried out in accordance with the Uniform Standards for Professional Appraisal Practice, rather than appraisal practices of Federal Land Acquisitions if the parcel of Federal land is less than $500,000 and less than $500 per acre. Subsection (e) authorizes the Secretary and the State, if land parcels are not of equal value, to agree to use a ledger account to equalize the overall value of land. The subsection also authorizes the State and the Secretary to assume costs or other requirements for conveying land that could be borne by the other party and is authorized to adjust the value of unappropriated Federal land parcels to properly compensate each party. Lastly, the subsection requires that if any parcel's value is selected due to the presence of minerals, that the value of the parcel be reduced by applicable revenue sharing obligations under the Mineral Leasing Act. Section 5. Miscellaneous Subsection (a) clarifies that any land or minerals conveyed under this Act be subject to all applicable Federal, State, and Tribal law. Subsection (b) provides that nothing contained in the bill affects any treaty-reserved rights or other rights of any Indian Tribe. It also states that nothing contained in the bill will affect land or minerals held in trust by the United States, or any individual Indian allotment. Subsection (c) requires the Secretary and the State to make available any record relating to hazardous materials on land to be conveyed. It also requires that a hazardous materials inspection and certification be conducted on Federal and State land prior to completing any conveyance. Subsection (d) authorizes the continuance of any grazing permit or lease on conveyed land for the remainder of its term. The subsection clarifies that nothing in this Act prevents the Secretary or the State from canceling or modifying a grazing permit if the land is conveyed. Section 6. Saving clause Section 6 provides a savings clause that states that nothing in this Act applies to or affects litigation or disputes on the date of enactment regarding ownership of any land or mineral resources located in the State. COST AND BUDGETARY CONSIDERATIONS The Committee has requested, but has not yet received, the Congressional Budget Office's estimate of the cost of S. 1088 as ordered reported. When the Congressional Budget Office completes its cost estimate, it will be posted on the Internet at www.cbo.gov. REGULATORY IMPACT EVALUATION In compliance with paragraph 11(b) of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate, the Committee makes the following evaluation of the regulatory impact which would be incurred in carrying out S. 1088. The bill is not a regulatory measure in the sense of imposing Government-established standards or significant economic responsibilities on private individuals and businesses. No personal information would be collected in administering the program. Therefore, there would be no impact on personal privacy. Little, if any, additional paperwork would result from the enactment of S. 1088, as ordered reported. CONGRESSIONALLY DIRECTED SPENDING S. 1088, as ordered reported, does not contain any congressionally directed spending items, limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in rule XLIV of the Standing Rules of the Senate. EXECUTIVE COMMUNICATIONS The testimony provided by the Bureau of Land Management at the Subcommittee on Public Lands, Forests, and Mining July 12, 2023, hearing on S. 1088, follows: Statement of Thomas Heinlein Assistant Director for National Conservation Lands & Community Partnerships, Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Department of the Interior s. 1088, north dakota trust lands completion act S. 1088 would authorize the State of North Dakota to relinquish to the Secretary of the Interior certain lands and mineral estates that are located partially or wholly within the boundaries of four Tribal reservations in the state, to the extent such lands or mineral estates were conveyed to the state at statehood. The bill would apply to up to approximately 37,000 surface acres and 186,000 total mineral acres. If the State elects to relinquish a parcel, the bill authorizes the State to select one or more parcels of BLM-managed public land or mineral estate of substantially equivalent value within the State of North Dakota. The bill further directs the Secretary to, upon request of a Tribe, take into trust relinquished lands or mineral estates within the boundaries of a reservation. The BLM generally supports the conveyance of public lands when such conveyances are in the public interest and consistent with publicly approved land use plans. In addition, the BLM is committed to managing public lands and minerals in a manner that seeks to protect the treaty, religious, subsistence, and cultural interests of Federally recognized Tribes, consistent with the BLM's mission and applicable law. By placing lands into trust status through the Department, Tribes are able to reacquire lands within or near their reservations, establish a land base for Tribal communities, and clarify jurisdiction over their lands. The BLM supports the Sponsor's goal of addressing the patchwork of inholdings within existing reservation boundaries. The BLM would like to work with the Sponsor to clarify the intent of several of the bill's provisions and the mechanisms outlined in the bill for effectuating the proposed conveyances. Analysis The North Dakota Enabling Act, enacted in 1889, provided for the division of what was then known as Dakota into two states--North Dakota and South Dakota. It also enabled the people of North Dakota and South Dakota, as well as the states of Montana and Washington, to form constitutions and state governments. The Act granted, with certain exceptions, sections 16 and 36 in every township to the new states to support schools. Under the Act, the State of North Dakota was granted lands and minerals totaling more than 2.5 million acres. Many of the land grant parcels are located within Tribal reservation boundaries. Specifically, 3,612 surface acres and 74,888 total subsurface acres are located within the Fort Berthold Indian Reservation; 24,179 surface acres and 74,717 total subsurface acres are located within the Standing Rock Indian Reservation; 9,379 surface acres and 36,338 total subsurface acres are located within the Fort Totten Indian Reservation; and 72 surface acres and 639 total subsurface acres are located within the Sisseton-Wahpeton Indian Reservation. There are no state land grant parcels located within the Turtle Mountain Indian Reservation. In total, there are approximately 37,000 surface acres and 186,000 total mineral acres located within the boundaries of the five Tribal reservations in the state. The BLM notes that it manages only approximately 58,000 surface acres in North Dakota, which would constrain the BLM's ability under the bill to convey surface acres should the State select surface acres in exchange for relinquishing state land grant parcels. Should the State focus on obtaining Federal minerals via selection of subsurface lands, the BLM notes that a large majority of the Federal oil and gas minerals in North Dakota are leased, and thus are encumbered by valid existing rights. We would like to work with the Sponsor to clarify which Federal mineral estate would be eligible for transfer and whether any additional exclusions should be included in the bill. We also recommend further coordination with the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) particularly if surface management of the National Forest System lands might be affected. Parcel Selection Process S. 1088 authorizes the State of North Dakota to select one or more parcels of BLM-managed public land of substantially equivalent value within the State in exchange for relinquishing to the Department all right, title, and interest of a state land grant parcel located wholly or partially within the boundaries of any Tribal reservation. Under the bill, the Secretary must approve or reject the State's selection within 90 days, and if approved, must initiate the process of conveying the selected parcel to the State within 60 days. The bill stipulates that the conveyance shall not be considered a sale, exchange, or conveyance under section 203, 205, 206, or 209 of FLPMA. After selection and approval, the bill requires that relinquished state land grant parcels located within the boundaries of a Tribal reservation be taken into trust by the Secretary for the benefit of that Tribe, upon the request of the Tribe. Prior to the conveyance of such a parcel, the State and the Secretary are required to consult with the Tribe that has the subject land grant parcel within its reservation boundaries. The BLM notes that although the bill stipulates that the conveyances would not be considered a sale, exchange, or conveyance under FLPMA, there are necessary procedures and compliance actions required to convey ownership. While the BLM recognizes the Sponsor's intent to simplify the conveyance process for the purposes of the bill, the BLM would like to work with the Sponsor to ensure any lands selected by North Dakota go through an appropriate review process. In addition, the BLM would like to work with the Sponsor to include all affected Tribes in the Tribal consultation process, and not limit consultation to only the Tribe with the state land grant inholding to be conveyed, as Tribal consultation is an important process that should involve Tribes impacted by a Federal action, consistent with applicable law and regulation. Existing Uses The bill permits the State to select, and the Secretary to convey, BLM-managed public lands that are subject to a mineral lease or permit issued under the Mineral Leasing Act or in a producing or producible status during the 10-year period following enactment. The State would also be authorized to select BLM-managed land that is ``mineral in character,'' on the condition that, if subject to an existing lease or permit, the Secretary shall reserve an overriding interest in the portion of the mineral estate that is subject to a mineral lease, and such a selection shall not include any portion of the mineral lease or permit. The bill allows the conveyance of the Federal surface interest of land subject to a mineral lease but requires all Federal mining claims to be converted to State leases and provides that the State will assume all authority over any authorizations or obligations applicable to a relinquished Federal mining claim. Under the bill, all BLM- managed parcels selected by the State for conveyance would be withdrawn from operation of the public land laws, mining laws, and mineral leasing laws, with the withdrawal ending on the date the land is conveyed to the State or the date that the selection is rejected. Regarding all existing uses, section 4(c) of the bill states that each party to an exchange shall, to the fullest extent allowable under Federal and state law, assume the rights and obligations of the conveying party with respect to any lease, right-of-way, permit, or other valid existing rights. The bill specifically provides for continuance of Federal grazing permits by requiring the Secretary and the State to allow the grazing to continue for the remainder of the permit or lease term. Further, the bill stipulates that if a parcel conveyed by the State is used to meet the base property requirements for a Federal grazing permit or lease, the land shall continue to qualify as a base property for the remainder of the term of the permit or lease, as well as for the term of any renewal or extension. The BLM notes that while several of the bill's provisions refer to ``Federal mining claims,'' there are currently no Federal locatable mining claims in North Dakota. The BLM recommends the Sponsor clarify the intent of these provisions. In addition, it is unclear what would constitute the ``overriding interest'' reserved by the Secretary in mineral estate subject to a lease. The BLM recommends that the Sponsor further define what is considered an overriding interest, as well as the mechanism for its reservation. Further, the BLM recommends the Sponsor clarify whether the overriding interest reserved by the Secretary would supersede the bill's direction that each party is to succeed to the rights and obligations of the conveying party with respect to any lease, right-of-way, permit, or other valid existing right to which the land is subject--particularly given other provisions directing conversion of all Federal mining claims to state leases. The BLM appreciates the Sponsor's attention to the disposition of existing grazing operations in the bill. The BLM notes that it may still be required to comply with regulations requiring two years notice of lease cancellation, and cooperative range improvements may also require refunds based on valuation and depreciation schedules. The Department also recommends that the Sponsor work with the Bureau of Indian Affairs to clarify future management of state grazing leases on the lands to be held in trust for the benefit of a Tribe. Lastly, the BLM notes that the savings clause in section 7 of the bill states that ``nothing in this Act applies to or impacts the ownership of any land or mineral resources.'' The BLM recommends that the Sponsor clarify the intent of the savings clause, given the conveyances of ownership of land and mineral resources directed by the bill. Valuation of Parcels Under the bill, state land grant parcels conveyed for a parcel of Federal land must be ``substantially equal in value.'' The bill requires the Secretary to determine the values of both the state land grant parcel and the BLM-managed parcel to be conveyed through an appraisal completed in accordance with the Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions. The bill further authorizes the Secretary, with the consent of the State, to use mass appraisals, a summary appraisal, or a statement of value made by a qualified appraiser to determine the value of a parcel using the Uniform Standards for Professional Appraisal Practice, if both parties agree that the market value of the parcel is less than $500,000 and less than $500 per acre. For the value of a Federal parcel that is attributed to the existence of a mineral lease and the lease is to be conveyed, the bill requires that the value of the parcel be reduced by the amount that represents the likely Federal revenue sharing obligation under the Mineral Leasing Act. The bill stipulates that such an adjustment is not to be considered as a property right of the State. If the overall value of the parcels to be conveyed is not equal, the bill requires the party conveying the parcel of lesser value to equalize the value by payment of funds to the other party. The bill also allows the party conveying the parcel of lesser value to enter the imbalance in value in a ledger account established by the bill. The ledger account must reflect imbalances in value to be reconciled in a subsequent transaction, balanced not later than three years after the date on which the ledger account is established, and closed not later than five years after the date of the last conveyance of land under the bill. Regarding costs and other requirements of conveyance, the bill authorizes the State or the Secretary to assume costs, responsibilities, or requirements for conveying land under the bill that are ordinarily borne by the other party. The parties are directed to make adjustments to the value of the Federal parcel to be conveyed to compensate the State or the Secretary, as applicable. The BLM notes that the bill does not include any mechanism for protesting or appealing land valuations by any party. The BLM recommends that the Sponsor consider their intent to as to how such protests or appeals would be addressed. In addition, the BLM notes that it is typical for the party requesting the purchase to cover the costs of conveyance outright and recommends amending the provisions requiring adjustments to the value of the Federal land to be conveyed to the State accordingly.

Source: https://api.congress.gov/v3/committee-report/118/srpt/132