Skip to content

senate · Committee report

S. Rept. 118-153

UTAH SCHOOL AND INSTITUTIONAL TRUST LANDS ADMINISTRATION EXCHANGE ACT OF 2023

2024-01-09

Committees

Associated legislation

Text

Section-by-Section Analysis

Section 1. Short title Section 1 provides the short title for the bill, the ``Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration Exchange Act of 2023.'' Section 2. Definitions Section 2 defines key terms used in the bill. Section 3. Ratification of Agreement between the Administration, the State of Utah, and the Secretary of the Interior Subsection (a) ratifies the Memorandum of Understanding agreed to between the Bureau of Land Management, the Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration, and the State of Utah on March 17, 2023 (Agreement). The text of the Agreement is printed in the Appendix to this report. Subsection (b) directs the Secretary of the Interior (Secretary) to implement the Agreement. Section 4. Conveyances Subsection (a) states that the land exchange outlined in the Agreement is in the public interest. Subsection (b) authorizes the conveyances of land described in the Agreement and requires that the conveyances be completed not later than 45 days after the date of enactment of the Act. The subsection also requires the conveyances of land in the Agreement be equalized if the Federal and State land are not equal in value. Subsection (c) requires that the map and legal descriptions be on file and available for public inspection and authorizes the Secretary to make technical corrections to the map and legal description. It also clarifies that if there is any conflict between the map and legal descriptions, the legal descriptions will control. Subsection (d) requires that any conveyance of land under the Act comply with applicable land use plans under section 202 of the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 (FLPMA; 43 U.S.C. 1712). Section 5. Equalization of the exchange Subsection (a)(1) requires that not later than 18 months after the date of execution of the land exchange, the total value of the land exchange shall be determined by an appraisal in accordance with paragraph (5), based on land and mineral values present, be in accordance with FLPMA, and use nationally recognized appraisal standards. Paragraph (2) authorizes an appraisal to take into account reports of mineral deposits in the land being exchanged, and that if any mining claims apply, that they be appraised according to the Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisition. It also clarifies that the United States is not required to conduct a mineral examination for any mining claim on lands conveyed under the Agreement. Paragraph (3) provides for the adjustment of the land value if there is the presence of minerals to reflect applicable revenue-sharing obligations under the Mineral Leasing Act. It also provides that any appraisals approved by the Secretary shall remain valid for 3 years after the date on which the appraisal is approved. Lastly, the subsection provides for a dispute resolution process if the Secretary and SITLA do not agree to accept the findings of an appraisal. Subsection (b) requires that if the Federal land and State land subject to conveyance are not equal in value, the values shall be equalized and the conveyance of any equalization parcels shall occur not later than 45 days after the date of the identification of the appraisal to ensure that the exchange is of equal value. Section 6. Withdrawals Subsection (a) withdraws, subject to valid existing rights, the Federal land subject to exchange from mineral location, entry, and patent under the mining laws. Subsection (b) permanently withdraws, subject to valid existing rights, any State land subject to exchange from all forms of appropriation and disposal under the public land laws, including the mining and mineral leasing laws, and the Geothermal Steam Act of 1970. Subsection (c) authorizes the revocation of withdrawal of any Federal land to be conveyed to the State from appropriation or disposal under a public land law to the extent necessary to permit the conveyance of Federal land to the State. Section 7. Sunnyside, Utah, water supply provisions Section 7 excludes any land being conveyed under this Act from the Act of January 7, 1921, which sets aside certain land in Utah for a water supply reserve for Sunnyside, Utah. Cost and Budgetary Considerations The cost estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office for S. 1405 follows: S. 1405 would ratify and direct the Department of the Interior (DOI) to implement, within 45 days of enactment, an agreement with the state of Utah. Under the agreement, DOI and the state would exchange about 170,000 acres of land of approximately equal value. Under the bill, any state land conveyed to the federal government would be withdrawn from mining, mineral, and geothermal leasing laws, subject to valid existing rights. The bill would require the exchanged land to be appraised within 18 months of the exchange and for the state and DOI to equalize any disparity in the value of the land exchanged by conveying additional land, as necessary. The cost of the appraisal would be shared by DOI and the state. CBO estimates DOI also would incur administrative costs to facilitate the land transfer. Using information from DOI, CBO estimates that the federal costs to complete the exchange would not exceed $500,000; that spending would be subject to the availability of appropriated funds. Using information from DOI, CBO estimates that some state and federal land that would be exchanged currently generates receipts from various land uses. Under current law, CBO estimates the state land will generate about $2,000 annually and the federal land about $5,000 annually over the 2024-2033 period. Under the bill, payments formerly due to Utah or the United States would be payable by the leaseholder to the respective new landowner after the exchange. Since the amounts currently collected from the federal land are greater than receipts earned from the state land, CBO expects that conveying the land would result in the federal government receiving less receipts than under current law. Those receipts are recorded in the budget as a reduction in direct spending. Thus, CBO estimates that enacting the bill would increase direct spending by an insignificant amount over the 2024-2033 period. On November 21, 2023, CBO transmitted a cost estimate for H.R. 3049, the Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration Exchange Act of 2023, as ordered reported by the House Committee on Natural Resources on July 26, 2023. The two bills are similar and CBO's estimates of their budgetary effects are the same. The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Lilia Ledezma. The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss, Deputy Director of Budget Analysis. Phillip L. Swagel, Director, Congressional Budget Office. Regulatory Impact Evaluation In compliance with paragraph 11(b) of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate, the Committee makes the following evaluation of the regulatory impact which would be incurred in carrying out S. 1405. The bill is not a regulatory measure in the sense of imposing Government-established standards or significant economic responsibilities on private individuals and businesses. No personal information would be collected in administering the program. Therefore, there would be no impact on personal privacy. Little, if any, additional paperwork would result from the enactment of S. 1405, as ordered reported. Congressionally Directed Spending S. 1405, as ordered reported, does not contain any congressionally directed spending items, limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in rule XLIV of the Standing Rules of the Senate. Executive Communications The testimony provided by the Bureau of Land Management and the Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration at the Subcommittee on Public Lands, Forests, and Mining hearing on S. 1405 on July 12, 2023, follows: Statement of Thomas Heinlein, Assistant Director for National Conservation Lands & Community Partnerships, Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Department of the Interior s. 1405, utah school & institutional trust lands administration exchange act S. 1405 would ratify a land exchange between the Department and the Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration (SITLA). Under the bill, the BLM would acquire approximately 162,000 acres of lands, and interests in lands, managed by SITLA that are located largely within the Bears Ears National Monument (the Monument), in exchange for a roughly equivalent amount of public land and interests in land managed by the BLM across the State of Utah. The bill includes a post- conveyance appraisal and equalization process to ensure that the exchanged lands, and interests in land, would be of equal value. The bill is consistent with President Obama's 2016 Proclamation establishing the Monument and President Biden's 2021 Proclamation restoring the boundaries and management conditions of the Monument. Both proclamations direct the Secretary of the Interior to explore entering into a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the State of Utah that would set terms to exchange land owned by the State and administered by SITLA within the boundary of the Monument for land of approximately equal value managed by the BLM outside the Monument. The BLM supports S. 1405 as it would promote conservation and appropriate resource management, including the protection of invaluable cultural resources and sacred sites within Bears Ears National Monument. The Bears Ears National Monument is located in San Juan County, Utah, and is comprised of approximately 1.36 million acres of public land administered by the BLM as part of the National Landscape Conservation System and National Forest lands administered by the USFS. The Monument lands contain evidence of more than 13,000 years of occupation by indigenous peoples, including petroglyphs and pictographs, large villages, ancient cliff dwellings, ceremonial sites, and countless other objects that provide an extraordinary archaeological and cultural record. These archaeological and cultural resources were seminal to the passage of the Antiquities Act more than a century ago. The lands of the monument are profoundly sacred to many Tribal Nations, including the Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, Navajo Nation, Ute Indian Tribe of the Uintah and Ouray Reservation, Hopi Nation, and the Pueblo of Zuni, who continue to rely on these lands for religious, traditional, and ceremonial uses. The Monument contains several geologic marvels including deep sandstone canyons, desert mesas, the renowned Valley of the Gods, and the namesake Bears Ears Buttes, as well as a rich paleontological history that is only recently beginning to be understood. Areas within the Monument are also used by local communities and Tribal members for firewood gathering and livestock grazing. Beyond the vast cultural and natural resources found within the Monument, the area is also meaningful to recreationists who visit the Bears Ears region to backpack, rock climb, and river raft, among other recreational activities. Proclamation 10285, issued by President Biden on October 8, 2021, directed the Secretary of the Interior to explore entering into an MOU with the State of Utah to exchange land administered by SITLA within the boundary of the Monument for land of approximately equal value managed by the BLM outside the boundary of the Monument in order to further the protective purposes of the Monument. On March 17, 2023, after more than a year of working closely to develop an agreement, the Department, the State of Utah, and SITLA entered into the ``Memorandum of Understanding--Exchange of Lands.'' The MOU sets forth the terms of a broad land exchange that is designed to promote conservation and appropriate resource management by exchanging SITLA inholdings within BLM- administered public lands, including the Monument, for other BLM-administered public lands that are more suitable for revenue generation located in 20 counties within Utah that would further SITLA's statutory duties to benefit schoolchildren and other trust beneficiaries in the state. The BLM-administered public lands identified by SITLA for conveyance to SITLA were identified to maximize the potential for revenue generation (per the applicable statutory requirement) while avoiding management conflicts from significant wildlife resources; endangered species habitat; significant archaeological, cultural, and historic resources; areas that are sacred or are traditionally, spiritually, or religiously significant to Tribal Nations; lands within the boundaries of Indian reservations; areas of critical environmental concern; coal resources requiring surface mining; wilderness study areas; and significant recreation areas; and to promote the objectives and legal mandates of both the BLM and SITLA. Analysis S. 1405 would ratify the terms of the MOU between the Department, SITLA, and the State of Utah, thereby facilitating the exchange of state-owned land, the majority of which is located within or proximate to the Monument, for BLM- administered public lands throughout Utah. Under the bill, the BLM would acquire approximately 162,510 acres of lands administered by SITLA, including State inholdings within the Fish Creek Canyon, Road Canyon, Butler Wash, Mancos Mesa, and Bridger Jack Wilderness Study Areas. In return, SITLA would acquire approximately 167,012 acres of public lands currently managed by the BLM outside the Monument. The bill requires that the exchange outlined in the MOU take place within 45 days following enactment. To ensure that the exchange is of equal value, the legislation further requires that SITLA and the Department complete an appraisal of the exchanged lands within 18 months of the exchange, using nationally recognized appraisal standards. If the appraisal identifies a disparity in the total value of the exchange, the value would be equalized through the conveyance of specific state or Federal land, as appropriate. These ``equalization parcels'' are generally identified within the MOU. The land exchange contemplated in the MOU would allow the BLM to acquire lands containing important or sensitive resources, mostly within or adjacent to the Monument, while transferring public lands into State ownership for revenue generation that would further SITLA's statutory duties to provide a benefit for Utah schoolchildren and other trust beneficiaries. S. 1405 provides that the exchange of these lands is in the public interest, and that the values of the lands, as determined by the appraisal, are to be equal, consistent with land exchanges that would occur under Section 206 of FLPMA. Like FLPMA, the land exchange provides options for equalizing the value including adding or removing parcels from the exchange. ---------- -- -------- Testimony of Michelle McConkie, Director, Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration My name is Michelle McConkie, and I am the Director of the Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration (``SITLA''), an independent state agency that manages state trust lands granted by Congress at statehood for the financial support of public education and other state institutions. In addition to public schools, beneficiaries of Utah's trust lands grants include the University of Utah, Utah State University, a hospital that provides healthcare to disabled miners, and the state schools for the blind and deaf. SITLA manages approximately 3.3 million acres of state trust lands, along with an additional million acres of severed mineral estate. Revenue from school trust lands--derived from oil and gas, mining, real estate development, and other activities, is deposited in the Utah Permanent School Fund, a perpetual endowment supporting public schools. The Utah Permanent School Fund has a balance of approximately $3.2 billion. Proceeds from the fund are distributed annually to every public school in the state to help with each school's most pressing academic needs. I encourage the Subcommittee, and Congress, to act favorably on S. 1405, the Utah School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration Exchange Act of 2023. This legislation would ratify, and provide authority to implement, a March 17, 2023 land exchange agreement between SITLA, Utah Governor Spencer Cox, and Secretary of the Interior Deb Haaland. That agreement is the product of over a year and a half of discussions between the State, federal land managers, local governments, and other interested stakeholders. The proposed exchange is supported by rural county governments, various stakeholder groups, Governor Cox and the Utah legislature. We have worked hard to put together an exchange that will be fair and transparent financially, workable in implementation, and conducive to more effective land management by both the state and federal governments. We believe this legislation meets all these goals. Management Conflicts Created by Federal Designations Surrounding State Land Inholdings The fundamental problem addressed by this legislation is the issue of scattered state land inholdings embedded within federal conservation areas such as national monuments and other designations, and associated land management conflicts. The designation of the Bears Ears National Monument captured more than 200 scattered tracts of state trust land within its outer boundaries, totaling over 126,000 acres. The State has been charged by Congress and the Utah legislature with managing these school trust lands for the financial benefit of Utah's public education system. This is accomplished through mineral and real estate development and other revenue-generation activities. But restrictions on the use of surrounding federal lands, through establishment of the Monument, will limit the utility of the inheld state trust lands for economic development. And development of school trust lands within national monuments and other designations is directly at odds with the conservation purposes for which the surrounding federal lands were set aside. These conflicting mandates, and the checkerboard pattern of state trust lands inholdings, will make effective management of both state trust lands and the Monument itself very difficult if not impossible. While the declaration of the Monument, and its large geographic scope, are matters of significant controversy, and litigation, between the State of Utah and United States, both governments agree that trading out state land inholdings is in everyone's best interest. The History of Land Exchanges as an Effective Solution Land exchanges are an effective solution to the management conflicts associated with inholdings. Exchanges can allow each government to manage consolidated lands as each party's land managers deem most advisable, without interference. In the last twenty-five years the State of Utah and the United States have worked successfully to complete a series of large congressionally-authorized land exchanges. These have included congressionally-mandated exchanges in 1998 concerning the Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument, in 2000 concerning federal wilderness in Uta

Source: https://api.congress.gov/v3/committee-report/118/srpt/153