Hearings
The Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense began hearings
on April 9, 2024 and concluded them on July 18, 2024, after
eight separate sessions. The subcommittee heard testimony from
representatives of the Department of Defense and the
Intelligence Community.
Summary of the Bill
The Committee recommendation of $852,179,000,000 includes
funding to develop, maintain, and equip the military forces of
the United States and for other purposes, including
$514,000,000 in mandatory spending and $20,800,000,000 in
emergency funding.
The fiscal year 2025 budget request for activities funded
in the Department of Defense appropriations bill totals
$833,415,121,000 in new budget authority, including
$514,000,000 in mandatory spending.
In fiscal year 2024, the Congress appropriated
$892,059,545,000 for activities funded in this bill. This
amount included $824,999,000,000 in base appropriations of
which $514,000,000 was mandatory spending. Additionally, the
Congress appropriated $67,060,545,000 in emergency
appropriations for fiscal year 2024 in Public Law 118-50.
The Committee recommendation in this bill is $6,380,000,000
above the amount provided in fiscal year 2024, excluding all
emergency funding, and $18,763,879,000 above the amount
requested for fiscal year 2025 including emergency funding.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
The following table displays the recommendations for each
title:
[In thousands of dollars]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fiscal year
Account Fiscal year 2025 Committee
2024 enacted estimate Recommendation
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title I--Military Personnel 176,244,339 181,880,539 180,667,384
(inlcudes emergency).......
Title II--Operation and 287,190,915 296,334,504 300,599,339
Maintenance (inlcudes
emergency).................
Title III--Procurement 172,029,494 166,770,761 175,222,313
(inlcudes emergency).......
Title IV--Research, 148,320,479 143,156,590 145,118,045
Development, Test and
Evaluation (inlcudes
emergency).................
Title V--Revolving and 1,786,779 1,720,550 1,840,550
Management Funds...........
Title VI--Other Department 42,696,094 42,498,177 43,033,177
of Defense Programs........
Title VII--Related Agencies. 1,139,419 1,164,000 1,129,507
Title VIII--General -4,438,519 -150,000 4,528,685
Provisions (includes
emergency).................
Fiscal Year 2024 National 67,060,545 ............ ..............
Security Supplemental
Appropriations Act (Public
Law 118-50)................
-------------------------------------------
Net grand total....... 892,029,545 833,375,121 852,139,000
===========================================
Total mandatory and 892,059,545 831,379,000 852,179,000
discretionary (incl.
scorekeeping
adjustments).........
------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee has displayed recommended adjustments in
tables presented under each appropriation account.
These adjustments reflect the following Committee actions:
removal of funds excess to need based on contract award savings
or changes to a program's acquisition strategy; elimination of
funds requested for programs which are lower priority,
duplicative, or not supported by firm requirements with out-
year development or procurement appropriations; deletion of
excess funds based on program delays or slow execution;
addition of funds to reflect congressional priorities, to
include executable unfunded requirements, and to rectify
shortfalls in the budget estimate; and implementation of
recommendations in S.4638, the National Defense Authorization
Act for Fiscal Year 2025, as reported by the Senate Armed
Services Committee.
CLASSIFIED PROGRAM ADJUSTMENTS
The Committee recommends adjustments to certain classified
programs, as explained in the classified annex to the
Committee's report.
Definition of Program, Project and Activity
The terms ``program, project, and activity'' for
appropriations contained in this act shall be defined as the
most specific level of budget items identified in the
Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2025, the related
classified annexes and Committee report, and P-1 and R-1 budget
justification documents as subsequently modified by
congressional action.
The following exception to the above definition shall
apply: the military personnel and the operation and maintenance
accounts, for which the term ``program, project, and activity''
is defined as the appropriations accounts contained in the
Department of Defense Appropriations Act.
At the time the President submits the budget request for
fiscal year 2026, the Secretary of Defense is directed to
transmit to the congressional defense committees budget
justification documents to be known as the ``M-1'' and ``O-1''
which shall identify, at the budget activity, activity group,
and sub-activity group level, the amounts requested by the
President to be appropriated to the Department of Defense for
military personnel and operation and maintenance in any budget
request, or amended budget request, for fiscal year 2026.
Reprogramming Guidance
The Secretary of Defense is directed to continue to follow
the reprogramming guidance for acquisition accounts as
specified in the report accompanying the House version of the
Department of Defense appropriations bill for fiscal year 2008
(House Report 110-279). The dollar threshold for reprogramming
funds shall be $15,000,000 for military personnel; $15,000,000
for operation and maintenance; $15,000,000 procurement; and
$15,000,000 research, development, test and evaluation.
Also, the Under Secretary of Defense (Comptroller) is
directed to continue to provide the congressional defense
committees annual DD Form 1416 reports for titles I and II and
quarterly, spreadsheet-based DD Form 1416 reports for service
and defense-wide accounts in titles III and IV of this act.
Reports for titles III and IV shall comply with guidance
specified in the explanatory statement accompanying the
Department of Defense Appropriations Act for Fiscal Year 2006.
The Department shall continue to follow the limitation that
prior approval reprogrammings are set at either the specified
dollar threshold or 20 percent of the procurement or research,
development, test and evaluation line, whichever is less. These
thresholds are cumulative from the base for reprogramming value
as modified by any adjustments. Therefore, if the combined
value of transfers into or out of a military personnel (M-1),
an operation and maintenance (O-1), a procurement (P-1), or a
research, development, test and evaluation (R-1) line exceeds
the identified threshold, the Secretary of Defense must submit
a prior approval reprogramming to the congressional defense
committees. In addition, guidelines on the application of prior
approval reprogramming procedures for congressional special
interest items are established elsewhere in this report.
Funding Increases
The funding increases outlined in the tables accompanying
each appropriation account shall be provided only for the
specific purposes indicated in the tables of Committee
Recommended Adjustments. The Committee directs that funding
increases shall be competitively awarded, or provided to
programs that have received competitive awards in the past.
Congressional Special Interest Items
Items for which additional funds have been recommended or
items for which funding is specifically reduced as shown in the
tables detailing Committee Recommended Adjustments or in
paragraphs using the phrase ``only for'' or ``only to'' are
congressional special interest items for the purpose of the
Base for Reprogramming (DD Form 1414). Each of these items must
be carried on the DD Form 1414 at the stated amount, as
specifically addressed elsewhere in this report. In addition,
section 8006 of this act provides direction on the treatment of
increases which appear in the tables of the Committee
Recommended Adjustments, including certain limitations on the
use of reprogramming authority in relation to these items.
Committee Initiatives
The Committee is pleased that the fiscal year 2025
President's budget request continues to prioritize investments
that resource the priorities identified in the 2022 National
Defense Strategy. The Committee's recommendation builds on
those proposals, and recommends increases that expand the
Department of Defense's capability and capacity to confront the
evolving global threat environment. This includes additional
funding to improve quality of life for military personnel and
their families; enhance military training and operational
readiness; strengthen recruiting, retention and training of the
Department of Defense acquisition workforce; sustain weapons
production lines identified by the military services as
critical; and invest in future critical technologies. Funds are
delineated in the tables of Committee Recommended Adjustments
and designated as congressional special interest items for the
purpose of the Base for Reprogramming (DD Form 1414).
ADDITIONAL EMERGENCY APPROPRIATIONS
The Committee recommendation includes $20,800,000,000 in
additional emergency appropriations, as detailed in the tables
of Committee Recommended Adjustments, to address significant
Department of Defense shortfalls. The Committee has worked
closely with the Department of Defense, its military
components, and the Combatant Commands in developing its
recommendation. Many of the recommended additional funds
address unfunded requirements identified by the commanders of
the Combatant Commands and chiefs of the military services.
Other recommendations address emerging national security
requirements that were not known to the Department of Defense
at the time of the delivery of the fiscal year 2025 President's
budget request. These funding priorities include:
--$2,727,800,000 to address the unfunded priorities of the
Commander of U.S. Indo-Pacific Command and for other
capabilities relevant to near-peer competition,
including $450,000,000 to accelerate offensive space
control efforts of the Space Development Agency;
--$1,755,000,000 for the sustainment of operational and force
protection activities in the U.S. Central Command past
September 30, 2024, and for other readiness
investments;
--$1,172,057,000 to address anticipated fuel funding
shortfalls in fiscal year 2025;
--$3,445,446,000 to make an additional 500 Air Force aircraft
available than would otherwise be available at the
requested funding level;
--$838,660,000 to increase and accelerate the fielding of
counter unmanned aerial system capabilities to address
the growing and rapidly evolving threat posed by drones
to U.S. forces;
--$781,447,000 for quality of life initiatives for service
members and their families, including to accelerate the
U.S. Army's implementation of operational deployment
pay to recognize the rigors of overseas deployments and
to accelerate modernization of Marine Corps barracks to
improve the quality of unaccompanied housing for
service members;
--$2,153,500,000 for Navy shipbuilding for select acquisition
of battle force ships, including advance procurement
funding for a four-ship amphibious ship procurement, as
agreed to by the Navy and the shipbuilding industry
that will lead to cost savings of approximately
$900,000,000 versus buying the ships individually;
--$2,720,307,000 to revitalize the U.S. defense industrial
base, including expansion of solid rocket motor
production, raw materials purchases for critical
weapons systems, and modernization of Army ammunition
plants and Navy shipyards;
--$1,218,895,000 for air defense, missiles, and other
munitions;
--$478,488,000 for counterterrorism activities, including
increases intelligence, surveillance, and
reconnaissance and addressing worldwide force
protection requirements; and
--$3,508,400,000 for other targeted investments in air, land,
cyber, and space military capabilities.
The Committee believes that inclusion of these funds is
necessary in the Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2025
for the Armed Forces to have the proper resources to counter
Russia, deter the People's Republic of China, and continue to
address threats from Iran and terrorist groups against U.S.
forces and our allies and partners, consistent with the 2022
National Defense Strategy.
Readiness
The Committee recommends an additional $2,000,000,000 in
title VIII of this act to be transferred to the operation and
maintenance accounts and be divided proportionately among the
services and the National Guard and reserve components to
address shortfalls in weapons sustainment, training, and
operations for which funding was not requested in the fiscal
year 2025 President's budget request. The funding provided is a
congressional special interest item. The Secretary of Defense
and the Service Secretaries are directed to submit a detailed
spending plan by sub-activity group to the Committees on
Appropriations of the House of Representatives and the Senate
not less than 30 days prior to the obligation of these funds.
These transfers may be implemented 30 days after congressional
notification unless an objection is received from either the
House or Senate Appropriations Committees.
Innovation
The Department of Defense [DOD] remains rightly focused on
driving innovation into its acquisition programs and internal
processes. During the past fiscal year, innovation at the
Departmental-level has taken on new forms, to include the
initiation of the Replicator program, the expansion of the
Defense Innovation Unit [DIU], and further maturation of the
Rapid Defense Experimentation Reserve [RDER]. The Committee
continues to view the end goal of defense innovation as
fielding the most advanced capabilities to operational units at
scale, thereby strengthening our National defense.
While innovation within acquisition programs requires
understanding a range of threats and potential concepts to
defeat them, the Committee believes that the importance of a
rigorous understanding of the technical maturity and
manufacturability of potential material solutions must also be
key considerations when deciding how to allocate limited
resources. Similarly, innovation should not create additional
layers of bureaucratic review, but must instead empower the
end-users the military services are responsible for manning,
training, and equipping. In fiscal year 2025, the Committee
again recommends substantial DOD resources for flexible,
innovation-focused spending, including more than $2,179,364,000
in Department-wide and Service funding for the prototyping and
maturation of promising, early-stage, and commercial
capabilities. While the Department has made progress in
coordinating enterprise-wide efforts with the establishment of
the Defense Innovation Working Group and the Defense Innovation
Community of Entities, the Committee believes additional action
is warranted to maximize the impact of the totality of
Department ``innovation-tagged'' resources, which are managed
by numerous entities with disparate reporting chains, and which
may or may not include the Department's acquisition executives.
In particular, the Committee believes that the DOD's RDER
initiative could be better positioned to support rapid
experimentation. The Department characterizes RDER as a process
through which the Undersecretary of Defense (Research and
Engineering) assesses military services prototypes' operational
relevance to the Joint Force through field experimentation.
Following these experiments, DOD stakeholders then analyze
collected data to, in part, inform future budgetary decisions.
However, the Committee notes that RDER has to date not resulted
in accelerated fielding outcomes. For example, less than one-
third of RDER programs funded in fiscal year 2023 have
``graduated'' from the program and formally transitioned into
the Services. Additionally, the majority of these projects will
lack dedicated Service funding in the fiscal year 2025
enactment due to lack of transition to the Services. While the
Committee is supportive of data-driven joint experimentation,
it is unaware of significant operational improvements derived
from the RDER funding construct to date. Therefore, the
Committee recommends slowing the rate of growth requested for
RDER and other adjustments, as detailed in the tables of
Committee Recommended Adjustments.
The Committee recommends full funding for Replicator funds
requested in the fiscal year 2025 President's budget request.
During fiscal year 2024, senior Department officials engaged
extensively with the Committee on the Replicator initiative. In
response to reporting requirements in the Department of Defense
Appropriations Act, 2024 (Public Law 118-47), the Department is
reviewing Replicator system selections to account for the
doctrine, organization, training, materiel, leadership,
personnel, facilities, and policy [DOTMLPF-P] considerations
associated with the initiative. The Committee believes that
this comprehensive understanding and plan to address the
DOTMLPF-P implications are critical to the initiative's success
and has apparently not yet occurred in full. Additionally, the
Committee believes that selected programs would benefit from
the development of robust test and evaluation master plans
[TEMP] or similar test and evaluation (T&E] plans to ensure
that concepts as envisioned are technically capable of meeting
stated objectives. The Committee directs the Director of the
Defense Innovation Unit to engage with the Department's and
respective Services' technical leadership as well as the
Director, Operational Test and Evaluation, to ensure that
developed T&E plans are adequate, as well as fully resourced.
Not later than 60 days after the enactment of this act, the
Deputy Secretary of Defense and the Vice Chairman of the Joint
Chiefs of Staff shall provide a briefing to the congressional
defense committees on the DOTMLPF-P and T&E plans for each
selected Replicator system.
Additionally, the Committee understands that Replicator
Tranche Two selections are forthcoming, and that the Department
may seek congressional action to ensure additional funding for
Tranche Two systems is included in the Department of Defense
Appropriations Act, 2025. In anticipation of these emerging
requirements, and in light of the Committee's substantive
concerns about the lack of results of RDER, the Committee
recommends reallocating RDER resources into a Rapid Defense
Innovation Reserve. The intent of this reallocation