Background
The TFPA authorizes the Department to enter into a contract or agreement with Tribes to carry out projects to protect Indian forest land or rangeland, including proposals to restore Federal land that borders on or is adjacent to Indian forest land or rangeland. The statute defines ``Indian forest land or rangeland'' as ``land that . . . is held in trust by, or with a restriction against alienation by, the United States for an Indian tribe or a member of an Indian tribe,'' and is ``forest land . . . ; or . . . has a cover of grasses, brush, or any similar vegetation; or . . . formerly had a forest cover or vegetative cover that is capable of restoration.'' Covered projects must meet certain criteria, including that the BLM- managed lands involved must be adjacent to the Tribe's trust or restricted fee lands; those lands must be under the jurisdiction of the Tribe; pose a fire, disease, or other threat to those trust lands or be in need of land restoration activities; and present or involve a feature or circumstance unique to that Tribe (including treaty rights or biological, archaeological, historical, or cultural circumstances). The TFPA requires that the Department respond to such projects within 120 days of receiving a proposal. If the Department denies a Tribe's request to enter into an agreement, the TFPA requires the agency to provide the Tribe with an explanation for its decision, and to propose consultation with the Tribe. Under the TFPA, Tribes and the Department have engaged in mutually beneficial work to improve forest and grassland conditions and protect Tribal lands and communities from risks. Projects proposed by a Tribe under the TFPA may be carried out through an Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (ISDEAA) funding agreement. Like the ISDEAA, the TFPA may extend to ANCs as well as federally recognized Tribes--although the reference to trust or restricted lands, and the requirement that the lands be under the jurisdiction of the Tribe, means that ANCs are practically excluded from participation under the statute. Analysis S. 4370 would expand the definition of ``Indian forest land or rangeland'' to include land in the state of Alaska that is held by an ANC under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (43 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.) or has ``a special geographic, historical, or cultural significance to the Indian tribe.'' The bill also removes the requirement that projects occur on Federal lands managed by the BLM or the USDA Forest Service that are adjacent to Tribal lands. Rather, S. 4370 requires Federal lands present or involve a special geographic, historic, or cultural significance to the Tribe. Expanding the definition of ``Indian forest land or rangeland'' provides clarity for the use of TFPA by ANCs. Further, removing the requirement that projects occur on Federal lands bordering or adjacent to Tribal lands removes ambiguity pertaining to proximity. The BLM supports these amendments to reduce the threats to Tribal forest lands and rangeland, trust resources, and values. S. 4370 also expands the lands on which Tribes may carry out land management activities to include Indian forest land or rangeland; requires the Department to submit to Congress a report describing the Tribal requests received and agreements or contracts that have been entered into; and authorizes the appropriation of $15 million per year from 2025 through 2030 to carry out the Act. The TFPA has been successfully used to address management of lands administered by the BLM and USDA Forest Service that are a priority to Tribes due to their associated risks to Tribal forest land resources. The Department notes that without more specificity in the proposed bill's definition, there is a risk that expanding the TFPA to include Tribal lands could potentially result in duplicate efforts and the comingling of trustee obligations by the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), USDA Forest Service, and the BLM, as the BIA administers programs including forest management and wildfire fuels reduction on lands held in trust for Tribes. However, in any format, this proposal would further Tribal ability to protect and restore forest lands across boundaries as threats to and the overall health of these lands do not stop at the boundaries of Tribal and Federal lands. S. 4370 could allow for a TFPA project to occur in part or in whole on trust lands managed under the authority of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA). We would welcome the opportunity to work with the Sponsor and the Committee on revisions to clearly define the role of the BIA for such projects. Finally, the Department would welcome the opportunity to work with the Sponsor on revisions that clarify agency financial responsibility for cross-jurisdictional projects. The Department would welcome the opportunity to work with the Sponsor and the Committee to ensure that the expansion of the TFPA to apply to Tribal lands results in complementary, rather than duplicative, efforts. EXECUTIVE COMMUNICATIONS The Committee has received no communications from the Executive Branch regarding S. 4370 or its reported version. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW On February 9, 2023, the Committee unanimously approved a motion to waive subsection 12 of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate. In the opinion of the Committee, it is necessary to dispense with subsection 12 of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate to expedite the business of the Senate. [all]