Background
The Settlement Act authorized $460 million, indexed to inflation, for the Bureau of Reclamation to plan, design and construct two major projects on the Crow Reservation: (1) the rehabilitation and improvement of the Crow Irrigation Project (CIP), and (2) the design and construction of a Municipal, Rural, and Industrial (MR&I) water system. Both projects were to be designed and constructed as generally described in detailed engineering reports prepared by consultants to the Tribe and cited in the Settlement Act. In addition, the Settlement Act gave the Tribe a 15-year exclusive right to construct hydropower facilities at the Yellowtail Afterbay Dam, a Bureau of Reclamation facility. That exclusive right expires in 2025. Proposed Amendment S. 4442 would amend the Settlement Act by establishing a non-trust fund account to allow the Bureau of Reclamation to continue work on rehabilitation of the CIP and a new MR&I projects trust fund to be used by the Tribe for (i) planning, permitting, designing, engineering, constructing, reconstructing, replacing, rehabilitating, operating, or repairing water production, treatment, or delivery infrastructure, including for domestic and municipal use or wastewater infrastructure; (ii) purchasing on-Reservation land with water rights; and (iii) complying with applicable environmental laws. The amendments do not increase the funding for the Settlement Act but merely change the way some funds are held and expended. If enacted as written, it is our interpretation that while the Amendment would repeal Section 406 in its entirety, funding for the MR&I projects trust fund would not exceed $246,381,000, as indexed, as provided in section 414(b) of the Settlement Act (which would be redesignated as 415(b) pursuant to S. 4442). When the Settlement Act was enacted, it did not provide for the creation of a non-trust interest bearing account for funds appropriated for project construction. Subsequent Indian water rights settlements have provided for such accounts to allow funds to accrue interest while projects are being planned, designed, and constructed. Because the Settlement Act did not provide this authorization, the Department and the Tribe instead opened a joint-signature account with a private bank for the investment of settlement funds. While this has allowed the funding to earn interest, it has come with costs associated with maintaining a private bank account. The Tribe now seeks to establish a non-trust interest-bearing account in Treasury so it can enjoy the benefits of earning interest without having to pay management fees to a private banking institution. S. 4442 would authorize the establishment of a non-trust interest- bearing account in Treasury to receive the funds already appropriated and yet to be appropriated for CIP rehabilitation. Reclamation would continue to be the lead agency responsible for the planning, design, and construction of CIP rehabilitation features. With respect to the MR&I system, S. 4442 would convert this portion of the Settlement Act from an infrastructure-based settlement to a trust fund-based settlement. S. 4442 would direct the Secretary to establish in the existing Crow Tribe Water Rights Settlement Trust Fund a new ``MR&I Projects''' account. The Tribe could then use funds from this account for several authorized purposes: plan, design, and construct MR&I systems; plan, design, and construct wastewater treatment facilities; and purchase on-Reservation land with water rights. S. 4442 would provide the Tribe with flexibility and discretion to plan, design, and construct the MR&I and wastewater systems that it believes will best serve communities on its Reservation. Finally, S. 4442 would extend by five years the period during which the Tribe has the exclusive right to develop hydropower at the Yellowtail Afterbay Dam, to 2030. The Department supports S. 4442. Allowing the Tribe to use the funding authorized for a large, centralized MR&I system to instead build smaller MR&I projects will allow it to make decisions regarding how, when, and where to develop water infrastructure on the Reservation. This approach is consistent with Tribal sovereignty and self-determination. We would like to work with the Tribe and the Committee, however, to include language in S. 4442 to ensure that trust fund expenditures prioritize providing clean drinking water over land acquisitions. The expansion of the authorized uses from a single use (MR&I) to multiple uses, including wastewater projects and purchases of land with water rights, will necessarily reduce the amount of funding available for badly needed drinking water systems on the Reservation. Provisions prioritizing funding for MR&I would ensure safe, reliable drinking water for the Tribe. Conclusion Chairman Schatz, Vice Chairman Murkowski, and members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity to provide the Department's views. EXECUTIVE COMMUNICATIONS The Committee has received no communications from the Executive Branch regarding S. 4442. CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW On February 9, 2023, the Committee unanimously approved a motion to waive subsection 12 of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate. In the opinion of the Committee, it is necessary to dispense with subsection 12 of rule XXVI of the Standing Rules of the Senate to expedite the business of the Senate. [all]