Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title; Table of contents
Section 1 establishes the short title of the bill as
``America's Outdoor Recreation Act of 2023'' and a table of
contents.
Sec. 2. Definitions
Section 2 establishes definitions for the bill.
Title I--Outdoor Recreation and Infrastructure
SUBTITLE A--DECLARATION OF POLICY
Sec. 111. Declaration of policy
This section declares that it is the policy of the Federal
Government to foster and encourage recreation on Federal land,
consistent with relevant agencies' multiple use missions and
the laws applicable to specific areas of Federal land.
SUBTITLE B--PUBLIC RECREATION ON FEDERAL RECREATIONAL LANDS AND WATERS
Sec. 121. Biking on long-distance trails
This section directs Federal land management agencies to
identify not fewer than 10 long-distance bike trails (i.e.,
bike trails with at least 80 miles in total length on Federal
land), and 10 areas where there is an opportunity to develop or
complete long-distance bike trails. For any existing trails
identified, the Secretaries may publish and distribute maps,
install signage, and issue promotional materials. Prior to any
trail identification, the Secretaries are required to ensure
that identification would not conflict with an existing use of
a trail or road, including horseback riding. This section
further requires the Secretaries to issue a report that lists
the trails identified under this section.
Sec. 122. Climbing guidance
This section directs the Forest Service and agencies within
the Department of the Interior, within 18 months and after a
notice and comment period, to issue guidance on climbing
management on Federal lands, including within designated
wilderness areas. Such guidance must recognize that
recreational climbing is an appropriate use within wilderness
areas when undertaken in accordance with applicable laws and
subject to terms and conditions that the relevant agency
determines are appropriate. The guidance must describe any
requirements for the placement and maintenance of fixed anchors
and associated routes in wilderness areas and must include
direction providing for the continued use and maintenance of
existing recreational climbing routes.
Sec. 123. Designated target shooting ranges
This section requires the Forest Service and the Bureau of
Land Management (BLM) to seek to ensure that each National
Forest and BLM district has at least one target shooting range
that is open to the public and does not require a user fee.
Specifically, agencies are to identify whether each National
Forest and BLM district has such a target shooting range; and
for each National Forest and BLM district that does not,
agencies are to determine whether applicable laws or plans
prevent their establishment. If a determination is made that
applicable laws or plans do not preclude the establishment of a
target shooting range on a forest or district, the Forest
Service and BLM are to (in coordination with non-federal
stakeholders and partners) identify an appropriate location for
a target shooting range, and, within five years of enactment,
to either: construct a new or modify an existing target
shooting range to conform with this section; or enter into an
agreement with a non-federal stakeholder or partner that will
establish or maintain a target shooting range. Agencies may
coordinate with non-Federal entities, and explore opportunities
to leverage funding to maximize non-Federal investments in the
construction, operation, and maintenance of target shooting
ranges. This section allows a target shooting range located on
land transferred pursuant to the Recreation and Public Purposes
Act to qualify as a target shooting range under this section.
SUBTITLE C--IMPROVING RECREATION INFRASTRUCTURE
Sec. 131. Broadband internet connectivity at recreation sites
This section directs the Forest Service and BLM to publish
a list of high-priority developed Federal recreation sites that
lack broadband internet and to estimate the cost to equip those
sites with broadband. This section also directs agencies to
partner with the Department of Commerce to foster the
installation of broadband internet infrastructure at developed
recreation sites.
Sec. 132. Extension of seasonal recreation opportunities
This section directs the Department of the Interior (DOI)
and the Forest Service to better understand visitor trends, the
effect of seasonal closures of Federal land on adjacent
businesses and local tax revenue, and opportunities to extend
the period of time Federal land is open to the public during
seasonal closures to increase associated revenues for
businesses and local governments. This section directs the
agencies to make efforts to minimize seasonal closures on lands
where such closures prevent recreational activities that
provide economic benefits.
Sec. 133. Gateway communities
This section directs DOI and the Forest Service to
collaborate with State and local governments, housing
authorities, trade associations, and nonprofits to identify
needs and economic impacts in gateway communities. Further,
this section directs the Secretary of Agriculture, in
coordination with the Secretaries of the Interior and Commerce,
to provide information regarding financial and technical
assistance opportunities to gateway communities (adjacent to
recreation destinations, including non-Federal recreation
destinations) to support economic opportunities through
tourism.
Sec. 134. Parking opportunities for Federal recreational lands and
waters
This section directs DOI and the Forest Service to seek to
increase parking opportunities for people recreating on their
lands. In order to help minimize any potential increases in the
deferred maintenance backlog, this section allows the agencies
to enter into public-private partnerships and lease non-Federal
land for parking opportunities.
Sec. 135. Travel management
This section directs the BLM and Forest Service to seek to
have maps available to the public depicting where vehicles are
allowed and where they are prohibited, as well as to update
them periodically to ensure the maps do not become outdated. In
carrying out this section, agencies are required to increase
opportunities for motorized and non-motorized access and
experiences on Federal land.
Sec. 136. Public-private partnerships to modernize Federally-owned
campgrounds, resorts, cabins, and visitor centers on Federal
recreational lands and waters
This section directs DOI and the Forest Service to
establish a pilot program for public-private partnership
agreements to modernize campgrounds and buildings on Forest
Service and BLM land. Agreements are not to exceed 30 years and
must include certain capital expenditure and maintenance
requirements. At least one agreement would be required for each
region of the National Forest System and for five States in
which the BLM administers land.
Sec. 137. Forest Service Pay-For-Performance Partnerships
This section establishes a pilot program to formally
authorize financing partnerships on National Forest service
lands for recreation projects. This section allows the agency
to enter into project agreements with private sector partners
that agree to pay for all or part of projects on Forest Service
lands as a long-term investment, using an innovative funding
model where investments are paid in full when specified
recreation-related outcomes are met. Project agreements cannot
be longer than 20 years or exceed $15 million.
SUBTITLE D--ENGAGEMENT
Sec. 141. Identifying opportunities for recreation
Consistent with the direction provided in Federal Land
Policy and Management Act (FLPMA) and the Outdoor Recreation
Act of 1963, this section requires the Federal land management
agencies to conduct an inventory and assessment of current
recreation resources, to identify any trends relating to use,
and consider future recreation needs. After identifying
underutilized locations, the agencies must consider the
suitability for developing, expanding, or enhancing these
recreation resources. After, the agencies are to select high-
value recreation resources at which to expand and encourage
recreation use. To avoid duplicative efforts, the agencies may
use existing work already completed or in progress for similar
inventories required under FLPMA. This section does not affect
land management plans, but actions undertaken pursuant this
section are to be consistent with any applicable existing
management plans.
Subsection (e) of this section repeals subsection (d) of
section 200103 of title 54, United States Code, relating to the
formulation and maintenance of a comprehensive nationwide
outdoor recreation plan.
Sec. 142. Federal Interagency Council on outdoor recreation
This section establishes a Federal Interagency Council on
Outdoor Recreation (FICOR) to help coordinate the
implementation of this Act across multiple Federal departments
and agencies, and applicable State and local agencies and
offices.
Sec. 143. Informing the public of access closures
This section requires relevant land management agencies to
post on their website notifications of any temporary closures
of roads and trails on the respective unit.
Sec. 144. Improved recreation visitation data
This section directs the Forest Service and certain
agencies within the DOI to establish a single visitation data
system to collect, model, and report accurate annual visitation
data, categorizing the data to capture estimates of different
recreation activities. This section also establishes the Real-
time Data Pilot Program to make available to the public real-
time or predictive visitation data for Federal lands. The pilot
program is only to be carried out in areas where gateway
communities are supportive, and in coordination with community
partners and third-party providers, such as technology and data
companies.
Sec. 145. Monitoring for improved recreation decisionmaking
This section requires relevant land management agencies to
pilot the use of new techniques to try to count visitors that
participate in forms of visitation that have been historically
difficult to track.
Sec. 146. Access for servicemembers and veterans
This section encourages the Secretaries of Agriculture and
of the Interior to work with the Secretaries of Defense and
Veterans Affairs to ensure servicemembers and veterans have
access to outdoor recreation and outdoor-related volunteer
wellness programs.
Sec. 147. Increasing youth recreation visits to Federal land
This section requires the Department of Agriculture and DOI
to develop a national strategy to increase youth recreation on
Federal lands.
Title II--Amendments to the Federal Lands Recreation Enhancement Act
Sec. 201. Short title
This section amends section 801 of the Federal Lands
Recreation Enhancement Act (FLREA) to eliminate the table
contents in section 801(b).
Sec. 202. Definitions
This section amends section 802 of FLREA to place the
definitions in alphabetical order and add new definitions for
the terms ``recreation service provider'' and ``special
recreation permit.''
Sec. 203. Special recreation permits and fees
This section amends section 803 of FLREA to include special
recreation permits and fees. Specifically, this section
codifies direction to land management agencies to develop and
make special recreation permit applications available to the
public. Upon receipt of such applications, the agencies may
issue special recreation permits to applicants (which may
include an authorization for incidental sales).
As amended by this section, section 803 allows land
management agencies to charge a special recreation permit fee
for the issuance of a special recreation permit. Specifically,
it allows the agency to charge fees one of several different
ways: a predetermined fee based on visitor-use days or a flat
rate, or one of two calculations based on gross receipts. In
most of these cases, the permittee chooses the fee regime that
will apply for their permit. This section does not affect
commercial use authorizations or cost recovery.
This section relocates existing provisions of law
pertaining to the disclosure of fees to section 803 of FLREA,
including the requirement to post entrance fee requirements.
Additionally, this section requires the agencies to disclose,
at the point of collection, how much money is being collected
annually and how the money is being spent. This section allows
a recreation service provider to inform its customers of any
fees charged by agencies under FLREA.
Subsection (b) is a conforming amendment that strikes
section 804(e) of FLREA.
Sec. 204. Online collection of certain recreation fees
Section 204 adds a new subsection (j) to section 803 of
FLREA to allow Federal land management agencies to collect
online payment for entrance fees, standard and expanded amenity
recreation fees, and special recreation permit fees.
Sec. 205. Online purchases and establishment of a digital version of
America the Beautiful--the National Parks and Federal
Recreational Passes
Section 205 amends section 805(a) of FLREA to direct DOI
and the Forest Service to sell the America the Beautiful--the
National Parks and Federal Recreational Lands Pass online, in
addition to in-person sale locations currently authorized under
law. In addition, this section directs DOI and Forest Service
to create a digital version of the pass to be used by the
public.
Sec. 206. Availability of Federal, State, and Local Recreation Passes
Section 206 amends section 806 of FLREA to allow Federal
land management agencies, on the request of a State or country,
to sell State or county entrance or recreational passes. The
Federal agencies may collect fees flowing from such sales, and
are required to transfer any collected funds to the applicable
State or county.
Sec. 207. Use of special recreation permit fee revenue
Section 207 amends section 808 of FLREA to allow fee
revenues currently retained at the site of collection to be
used to improve the special recreation permitting program (in
addition to all current allowable expenditures).
Sec. 208. Permanent authorization
Section 208 permanently authorizes FLREA by repealing the
sunset provision in section 810 of FLREA.
Title III--Special Recreation Permits for Outfitting and Guiding
SUBTITLE A--ADMINISTRATION OF SPECIAL RECREATION PERMITS FOR OUTFITTING
AND GUIDING
Sec. 311. Permit administration
This section requires land management agencies to publish
on their websites when certain additional permit opportunities
are available to outfitting and guiding businesses. Further,
this section directs them to provide email subscriptions for
potential applicants, notifying them of permit availability.
Finally, this section requires agencies to respond to an
applicant within 60 days of receipt of an application for a
special recreation permit.
Sec. 312. Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management transitional
special recreation permits for outfitting and guiding
This section directs relevant land management agencies to
implement a program to issue special recreation permits that
are for terms of two years that have the ability to be
converted to 5 or 10-year terms, provided that certain
requirements are met.
Sec. 313. Surrender of unused visitor-use days
This section specifies that a recreation service provider
may notify relevant agencies of its inability to use the days
allocated to them under their permit, and to surrender those
days for temporary reassignment to other outdoor recreation
service providers and the unguided public.
Sec. 314. Reviews for transitional permits and long-term permits
This section requires agencies to periodically review the
performance of recreation service providers with longer-term,
outfitter and guide-related special recreation permits. It also
requires the Forest Service and allows DOI agencies to review
whether all of the days made available to recreation service
providers under their permit are being used. In making the
latter determination, this section allows for recreation
service providers to not be penalized for not using days if
conditions exist beyond a recreation service provider's
control. In addition, this section incentivizes recreation
service providers to make available to others any days that
they were allocated but not able use.
Sec. 315. Adjustment of allocated visitor-use days
This section establishes a framework that agencies may use
to adjust the number of days available under longer-term
permits after reviews required under section 314 are completed.
Further, this section allows agencies to assign additional
visitor-use days to special recreation permits.
SUBTITLE B--ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS RELATING TO SPECIAL RECREATION
PERMITS
Sec. 321. Permitting process improvements
This section directs agencies to evaluate the current
permitting process and to identify opportunities to decrease
duplicative processes, costs, and permitting times in order to
simplify the special recreation permitting process. In
addition, this section directs the agencies to evaluate the
wording and terms of their existing categorical exclusions to
ensure consistency with this Act and to revise them as
necessary.
This section prohibits agencies from conducting a needs
assessment as a condition of issuing a special recreation
permit, unless specifically required under the Wilderness Act.
This section also requires agencies to make permit applications
available online. Lastly, this section specifies when agencies
are to issue special recreation permits and when they are not
required because the activities to be undertaken only would
have nominal effects on resources and programs.
Sec. 322. Service First Initiative and multijurisdictional trips
Section 322 reauthorizes the ``Service First Initiative''
first established by section 330 of the Department of the
Interior and Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2001, and
subsequently reauthorized, expanded, and made permanent in
subsequent appropriations acts. Subsection (a) repeals the
current statutory authorization for the Service First
Initiative. Subsection (b) provides permanent authorization for
the Initiative. Subsection (c) directs the Secretaries of the
Interior and Agriculture to establish a pilot program that
authorizes their agencies to issue a single joint special
recreation permit for recreation activities that cross multiple
agency boundaries. Subsection (c) requires agencies to issue at
least 10 joint special recreation permits through at least 4
different offices under the pilot, and to designate a lead
agency for issuing and administering each permit under the
pilot. Subsection (c)(4) requires that agencies retain their
own respective authorities for permit issuance and enforcement,
and does not prohibit any person or entity from applying for
separate special recreation permits.
Sec. 323. Permit flexibility
This section directs agencies to establish guidelines to
allow permit holders to engage in new activities that are
substantially similar to those authorized in their current
permits without the issuance of entirely new and separate
permits.
Sec. 324. Liability
This section clarifies when relevant land management
agencies may require a commercial general liability insurance
policy as a condition of receiving a specia
Background
Federal land management agencies oversee approximately 640
million surface acres. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) is
responsible for approximately 245 million of those acres while
the Forest Service manages another 193 million. Most other
Federal land is managed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
(FWS), with over 92 million acres, and the National Park
Service (NPS), with approximately 80 million acres. The Bureau
of Reclamation (Reclamation) and the Army Corps of Engineers
also manage Federal lands used for recreation.
The Department's bureaus contribute to its overall
recreation mission and to the Secretary's recreation and
equitable access priorities. The National Park System, which
preserves some of our most important national treasures, hosts
over 300 million visitors every year. The public lands managed
by the BLM host a remarkable variety of recreational
activities, and BLM lands supported more than 73 million
recreational visits last year--an increase of three million
from 2019. The National Wildlife Refuge System provides world-
renowned places to see iconic wildlife and partake in a variety
of outdoor activities, such as hiking, bird-watching, canoeing
and hunting. The water projects of Reclamation, which is the
largest wholesale water supplier in the nation, are among
America's most popular sites for water-based outdoor
recreation.
The Federal Lands Recreation and Enhancement Act (FLREA)
authorizes the following four Interior Department agencies to
collect fees on Federal lands and waters: the BLM, Reclamation,
FWS, and NPS. FLREA also provides the Forest Service in the
Department of Agriculture authority to collect recreation fees.
Revenues collected under FLREA allow the Federal government to
implement projects that benefit visitors, such as improving
accessibility, maintaining recreation sites, and building
informational exhibits. FLREA also authorizes agencies to issue
SRPs, which include authorizations for commercial, competitive
event, and group recreation uses of the public lands and
waters. These permits are issued to manage visitor use, protect
recreational and natural resources, and provide for the health
and safety of visitors. The BLM administers approximately 4,700
SRPs per year. Other Interior bureaus use different authorities
in addition to FLREA to manage recreation and collect
associated fees: the FWS issues special use permits;
Reclamation issues use authorizations; and NPS issues
commercial use authorizations (CUAs) and special use permits.
S. 3266, Outdoor Recreation Act
S. 3266 proposes to modernize and improve outdoor
recreation on Federal lands by addressing permitting processes,
land management planning, broadband connectivity at recreation
sites, visitation data analysis, travel management, and public-
private partnerships to renovate campgrounds on Federal lands,
among other provisions.
Title I
Title I of S. 3266 aims to increase outdoor recreation
opportunities by directing a study on permitting challenges
that hinder youth groups' ability to access and recreate on
Federal land and easing permit requirements for outfitters and
guides serving fewer than 40 clients at picnic areas. Title I
also outlines additional requirements for the BLM and Forest
Service land use planning process by requiring recreation
resource inventories and consideration of future recreation
needs in developing land use plans. Finally, Title I requires
at least one designated shooting range to be established in
each National Forest and BLM district.
Regarding designated shooting ranges in Section 104 of the
bill, the BLM notes that it currently manages only six
designated shooting ranges, with plans to open four more in BLM
Arizona's Phoenix District in the near future. To determine
whether to establish such ranges, the BLM works with the local
communities to assess the demand and viability. While the BLM
recognizes the sponsors' interest in increasing access to
designated shooting ranges, we note that significant resources
are required to develop and maintain shooting ranges, including
removal of lead ammunition, clean-up of hazardous materials,
and berm management. The BLM further notes that, given the many
uses of the public lands that compete for resources, it would
be challenging to manage such a large number of designated
shooting ranges, as envisioned in the bill, without the ability
to charge a user fee, which the bill currently prohibits.
Finally, the BLM notes that over 99 percent of public lands are
open to recreational shooting and the BLM works with local
communities and our partners to provide access for these
opportunities. Currently, there are over 20 shooting ranges on
public lands that are administered by non-Federal entities
through a Recreational & Public Purpose (R&PP) Act lease, and
over 50 shooting ranges that have been patented and conveyed
under the R&PP Act.
Title II
Title II of the bill seeks to modernize and improve
recreation on public land by requiring the Department and the
Forest Service to publish a list of high priority Federal
recreation sites that lack broadband access and estimate the
cost of facilitating that access. The bill directs the
Department and the Forest Service to partner with the
Department of Agriculture's Rural Utilities Service to
construct broadband infrastructure at recreation sites. Title
II also establishes a competitive grant program to enable non-
Federal partners to help with inspection and decontamination of
watercraft at reservoirs managed by the Department to prevent
the introduction and spread of aquatic invasive species.
Title II requires collection and publication of real-time
visitation data on a single interagency system and directs the
Forest Service and BLM to prioritize completion of travel
management plans. Section 204 of Title II requires the BLM to
develop a ground transportation linear feature or motor vehicle
and over-snow vehicle use map for each BLM district in a GIS-
compliant format within five years of enactment. The bill also
requires the BLM to update any travel management plan that is
fifteen years or older.
The BLM recognizes how important visitation data is to
enhancing recreational opportunities and experiences for
visitors while protecting natural and cultural resources. Most
recreational opportunities on BLM-managed public lands are not
directly tied to developed sites and facilities. Due to the
dispersed nature of these recreational activities, it would be
challenging for the BLM to provide the real-time, site-specific
visitation data required by the bill, and thus we are concerned
that the provision could not be implemented as currently
drafted. The Department would like to work with the Committee
and bill sponsors to address technical issues in order to
achieve the sponsors' goals.
Additionally, to date, the BLM has incorporated 90,000
miles of roads and trail routes into its transportation system
through completion of 153 travel plans, but there are an
estimated 400,000 miles of routes remaining that would need to
be inventoried, evaluated, and incorporated into the
transportation system as appropriate. Given the sheer volume of
roads and trails on BLM lands and the process required to
complete each travel plan, it may not be feasible to obtain the
required road and trail information for the linear feature
within five years of enactment. The BLM further recognizes that
it must balance the need for public access with protecting
natural and cultural resources through upholding the long-
standing minimization criteria for travel management planning
when designating travel and trail routes.
Title III
Title III seeks to encourage economic growth by providing
for financial and technical assistance to develop visitation
infrastructure in rural communities adjacent to recreation
destinations. Specifically, Title III directs the Department
and the Forest Service to explore extending recreation shoulder
season opportunities and establishes a pilot program for
public-private partnership agreements to modernize campgrounds
on Forest Service and BLM-managed lands. In addition, Section
304 of the bill requires the BLM to enter into at least 1
public-private partnership agreement to modernize campgrounds
in no fewer than 5 states in which the BLM administers public
lands.
The BLM appreciates the sponsors' interest in finding
innovative ways to modernize recreation facilities and meet the
growing demand for outdoor recreation opportunities. The BLM
notes that it does not currently have the authority to enter
into concessions agreements, and the pilot program established
in section 304 gives the BLM a similar authority for
modernizing campgrounds covered by the pilot program. Finally,
section 304 only allows the Secretaries to enter into
agreements for modernizing campgrounds with private entities.
Since the BLM currently engages with non-profit groups and
local, state, and Tribal governments to cooperatively manage
sites, the BLM recommends that the sponsors consider expanding
this pilot program to include those entities, as they may also
benefit from participating.
S. 1229, SOAR Act
S. 1229 authorizes single joint SRPs for multi-
jurisdictional trips across Federal lands and makes various
amendments to FLREA aimed at improving the process and reducing
the cost of applying for and administering SRPs.
Single Joint SRPs for Multi-Jurisdictional Trips
Section 7 of S. 1229 authorizes agencies to issue single
joint SRPs for trips crossing jurisdictional boundaries of more
than one Federal land managing agency. When a single joint SRP
for a multi-jurisdictional trip is proposed, the bill
authorizes each of the land management agencies to identify a
lead agency for the SRP. This designation is determined by the
relative length of the portions of the proposed trip, the land
use designations of the areas to be accessed during the trip,
the relative ability of each agency to properly administer the
single joint SRP, and any other considerations. Under the bill,
the agencies would not be permitted to recover the costs of
this coordination. S. 1229 also authorizes agencies to delegate
their respective enforcement authorities to the designated lead
agency.
The Department supports efforts to improve the permitting
process for trips that cross jurisdictional boundaries and
would like to continue to work with the sponsors on certain
modifications. For example, the Department supports delegating
enforcement authorities among agencies, but would like to
ensure these delegations conform with the statutory authorities
for each agency. In addition, the Department would like some
clarity on how an environmental analysis would be handled by
the identified lead agency to ensure compliance with standards
for other agencies. Specifically, the Department is concerned
that the use of categorical exclusions authorized by the lead
agency and applied to a single joint SRP for a multi-
jurisdictional trip could result in conflicts with another
agency's established National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)
processes.
Although the Department appreciates the bill's option for
agencies to withdraw from single joint SRPs, the Department
feels the requirements to issue substantially similar permits
with no new application may cause processing issues and other
limitations that could impact the timeliness of the permitting
process. If an agency needs to withdraw from a single joint
SRP, presumably it is because the agency needs to issue a
permit under terms different from the single joint SRP, whether
due to differing management concerns or other circumstances.
Lastly, the Department would like to continue to work with the
sponsors to determine appropriate cost recovery options.
Alignment of Permitting Authorities & Fees
Section 3 of S. 1229 defines each land management agency's
recreation permitting instruments as SRPs under FLREA and lays
out a formula for the fees associated with SRPs, including
alternative fees. NPS is excluded from these fee-setting
provisions in the bill; however, the Department is concerned
that these provisions, coupled with the limited cost-recovery
provided in the bill, would severely limit the NPS's ability to
fund the program.
The Department generally supports expanding FLREA to
coordinate recreation permitting across agencies. However, the
Department believes the bill, as currently written, could
create conflicts with existing statutory authorities. For
example, the NPS issues CUAs (for activities included in the
definition of SRPs under the bill) under the authority of the
National Park Service Concessions Management Improvement Act of
1998, not under FLREA. Additionally, the NPS issues special use
permits and recovers associated costs under 54 U.S.C. 103104
for many of the activities that would be permitted under SRPs.
The Department would like to continue to work with the sponsors
and Committee on modifications to these provisions.
Expedited Permitting
S. 1229 provides authority for agencies to improve
recreation permitting processes. This includes the expanded use
of categorical exclusions, programmatic NEPA, and expedited
rulemaking. The bill also directs agencies to make online
permit applications available. The Department supports these
efforts as we continue to pursue opportunities to facilitate
increased recreational access for all Americans, especially
underserved communities. The BLM has already taken significant
steps to develop online access to recreation information and
permits, most recently through its launch of the pilot
Recreation and Permit Tracking Online Reporting (RAPTOR)
system. RAPTOR allows users to apply for and renew SRPs online.
The BLM piloted RAPTOR in seven field offices during fiscal
year 2021, and successfully issued 38 permits through the
system. An additional 17 field offices will be added to the
RAPTOR pilot in 2022.
S. 1229 authorizes permittees to voluntarily return unused
service days to be available for other permittees. The bill
also authorizes use of temporary SRPs and conversion of
temporary permits to long-term permits. In addition, the bill
includes provisions directing agencies to establish a permit
administration protocol to automatically authorize permittees
to engage in activities substantially similar to those for
which they have a permit. The Department supports efforts to
simplify the permitting process for applicants.
Permit Notifications
Section 6 of S. 1229 requires agencies to make
notifications of permit opportunities available online. The
Department supports these efforts and would welcome the
opportunity to work further with the sponsors and the Committee
on necessary modifications to these provisions. For example,
the Department is concerned that providing notification of all
potential recreation permit opportunities could result in a
speculative market for the most profitable ones. Additionally,
recreation activities are generally proposed by the public, and
bureaus then determine whether they require permits under
Federal land management laws and regulations.
Liability & Cost Recovery
Section 9 of S. 1229 determines the terms under which
agencies require permittees to waive the liability of the
United States for permitted recreation activities. Section 10
also requires agencies to amend the cost recovery process for
issuing and renewing SRPs. This section would exempt the first
50 hours of work from cost recovery in issuing and monitoring
these permits. Under the bill, the exemption would be applied
to multiple permit applications for similar services in the
same area. The agencies would be required to determine the
share of the aggregate amount to be allocated to each
application on an equal or prorated basis. While the Department
supports the goal of simplifying processes when they are overly
burdensome, we would like to continue to work with the sponsors
and the Committee to determine appropriate cost recovery
options for the agencies. For example, limiting full cost
recovery on larger, more complex applications could
unintentionally prevent the effective administration of all
SRPs.
S. 1874, Recreation Not Red Tape Act
Title I of S. 1874 contains substantially similar
provisions authorizing single joint SRPs for multi-
jurisdictional trips across Federal lands to the language in S.
1229 discussed above. Like S. 1229, Title I of S. 1874 also
makes various amendments to FLREA aimed at improving the
process and reducing the cost of applying for and administering
SRPs. Titles II through IV of S. 1874 address access to public
lands for recreation, job opportunities for veterans at Federal
land management agencies, and establishment of a National
Recreation Area System and interagency trail management
program, among other provisions.
Title I
Title I of S. 1874 contains two sections that are not
included in S. 1229. Sections 111 and 112 of S. 1874 encourage
the agencies to work with states to allow a purchaser to buy a
Federal recreation pass and state recreation pass in the same
transaction and requires the Secretaries to sell the Federal
America the Beautiful passes through the website of each
Federal land management agency. The Department supports
improvements in the retail of recreation passes for the
recreating public and would like to work with the sponsors to
ensure the Department has the ability to perform revenue
transfers across multiple entities. We note the Federal America
the Beautiful passes are currently available online through the
USGS Store, including the free Annual Military Pass for Gold
Star Families and Veterans. Further, since Veteran's Day 2020,
Gold Star Families and U.S. military veterans are eligible to
receive free access to more than 2,000 Federal recreation
areas, including national parks, wildlife refuges, and forests.
The free access program is a way to thank America's veterans,
Gold Star Families, and current military and their dependents
for their support of our country and to encourage them to
explore recreational opportunities on their public lands and
waters.
Title II
Title II of S. 1874 directs agencies to work with branches
of the military to improve veterans' and service members'
opportunities to engage in outdoor recreation, and to hire
veterans at Federal land management agencies. The Department is
working diligently to expand recreation access for our military
families and veterans, and strongly supports these provisions.
Titles III & IV
Title III establishes a National Recreation Area System
composed of existing Forest Service and BLM National Recreation
Areas and any future areas designated by Congress. It includes
provisions to protect valid existing rights within the National
Recreation Areas, as well as livestock grazing units, state and
Tribal jurisdiction over fish and wildlife, water rights, and
ski area land. Further, the title requires agencies to develop
comprehensive management plans associated with each National
Recreation Area. Title III also directs agencies to develop
appropriate recreation performance metrics for evaluating
public land managers and adds recreation to the missions of
other Federal agencies. Title IV promotes the use of volunteers
to support the stewardship of public lands and directs agencies
to establish an interagency trail management plan.
The Department appreciates these efforts to highlight and
support the incredible recreation values of our public lands
and generally supports the goals of these provisions. We would
like