Hearings
The Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense began hearings
on March 28, 2023 and concluded them on June 20, 2023, after
six separate sessions. The subcommittee heard testimony from
representatives of the Department of Defense and the
Intelligence Community.
Summary of the Bill
The Committee recommendation of $831,781,268,000 includes
funding to develop, maintain, and equip the military forces of
the United States and for other purposes, including
$514,000,000 in mandatory spending and $8,000,000,000 in
emergency funding.
The fiscal year 2024 budget request for activities funded
in the Department of Defense appropriations bill totals
$826,678,377,000 in new budget authority, including
$514,000,000 in mandatory spending.
In fiscal year 2023, the Congress appropriated
$834,034,228,000 for activities funded in this bill. This
amount included $798,249,750,000 in base appropriations of
which $514,000,000 was mandatory spending. Additionally, the
Congress appropriated $35,784,478,000 in emergency
appropriations for fiscal year 2023 in Public Law 117-180 and
Public Law 117-328.
The Committee recommendation in this bill is
$25,531,518,000 above the amount provided in fiscal year 2023,
excluding all emergency funding, and $5,102,891,000 above the
amount requested for fiscal year 2024 including emergency
funding.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
The following table displays the recommendations for each
title:
[In thousands of dollars]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fiscal year
Account Fiscal year 2024 Committee
2023 enacted estimate Recommendation
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title I--Military Personnel. 172,708,964 178,875,510 176,538,766
Title II--Operation and 278,075,177 290,071,993 289,919,031
Maintenance................
Title III--Procurement...... 162,241,330 169,056,946 169,446,717
Title IV--Research, 139,760,526 144,879,625 143,382,724
Development, Test and
Evaluation.................
Title V--Revolving and 1,654,710 1,682,708 1,795,079
Management Funds...........
Title VI--Other Department 41,751,419 40,917,595 41,696,900
of Defense Programs........
Title VII--Related Agencies. 1,076,265 1,164,000 1,115,442
Title VIII--General 941,359 ............ 7,856,609
Provisions (Includes
emergency).................
Ukraine Supplemental 7,810,497 ............ ..............
Appropriations Act, 2023
(Public Law 117-180).......
Additional Ukraine 27,867,748 ............ ..............
Supplemental Appropriations
Act, 2023 (Public Law 117-
328).......................
Disaster Relief Supplemental 106,233 ............ ..............
Appropriations Act, 2023
(Public Law 117-328).......
-------------------------------------------
Net grand total....... 833,994,228 826,648,377 831,751,268
===========================================
Total mandatory and 834,034,228 826,678,377 831,781,268
discretionary (incl.
scorekeeping
adjustments).........
------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee has displayed recommended adjustments in
tables presented under each appropriation account.
These adjustments reflect the following Committee actions:
removal of funds excess to need based on contract award savings
or changes to a program's acquisition strategy; elimination of
funds requested for programs which are lower priority,
duplicative, or not supported by firm requirements with out-
year development or procurement appropriations; deletion of
excess funds based on program delays or slow execution;
addition of funds to reflect congressional priorities, to
include executable unfunded requirements, and to rectify
shortfalls in the budget estimate; and implementation of
recommendations in S.2226, the National Defense Authorization
Act for Fiscal Year 2024, as reported by the Senate Armed
Services Committee.
CLASSIFIED PROGRAM ADJUSTMENTS
The Committee recommends adjustments to certain classified
programs, as explained in the classified annex to the
Committee's report.
Definition of Program, Project and Activity
The terms ``program, project, and activity'' for
appropriations contained in this act shall be defined as the
most specific level of budget items identified in the
Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2024, the related
classified annexes and Committee report, and P-1 and R-1 budget
justification documents as subsequently modified by
congressional action.
The following exception to the above definition shall
apply: the military personnel and the operation and maintenance
accounts, for which the term ``program, project, and activity''
is defined as the appropriations accounts contained in the
Department of Defense Appropriations Act.
At the time the President submits the budget request for
fiscal year 2025, the Secretary of Defense is directed to
transmit to the congressional defense committees budget
justification documents to be known as the ``M-1'' and ``O-1''
which shall identify, at the budget activity, activity group,
and sub-activity group level, the amounts requested by the
President to be appropriated to the Department of Defense for
military personnel and operation and maintenance in any budget
request, or amended budget request, for fiscal year 2025.
Reprogramming Guidance
The Secretary of Defense is directed to continue to follow
the reprogramming guidance for acquisition accounts as
specified in the report accompanying the House version of the
Department of Defense appropriations bill for fiscal year 2008
(House Report 110-279). The dollar threshold for reprogramming
funds shall be $10,000,000 for military personnel; $15,000,000
for operation and maintenance; $15,000,000 procurement; and
$15,000,000 research, development, test and evaluation.
Also, the Under Secretary of Defense (Comptroller) is
directed to continue to provide the congressional defense
committees annual DD Form 1416 reports for titles I and II and
quarterly, spreadsheet-based DD Form 1416 reports for service
and defense-wide accounts in titles III and IV of this act.
Reports for titles III and IV shall comply with guidance
specified in the explanatory statement accompanying the
Department of Defense Appropriations Act for Fiscal Year 2006.
The Department shall continue to follow the limitation that
prior approval reprogrammings are set at either the specified
dollar threshold or 20 percent of the procurement or research,
development, test and evaluation line, whichever is less. These
thresholds are cumulative from the base for reprogramming value
as modified by any adjustments. Therefore, if the combined
value of transfers into or out of a military personnel (M-1),
an operation and maintenance (O-1), a procurement (P-1), or a
research, development, test and evaluation (R-1) line exceeds
the identified threshold, the Secretary of Defense must submit
a prior approval reprogramming to the congressional defense
committees. In addition, guidelines on the application of prior
approval reprogramming procedures for congressional special
interest items are established elsewhere in this report.
Funding Increases
The funding increases outlined in the tables accompanying
each appropriation account shall be provided only for the
specific purposes indicated in the tables of Committee
Recommended Adjustments. The Committee directs that funding
increases shall be competitively awarded, or provided to
programs that have received competitive awards in the past.
Congressional Special Interest Items
Items for which additional funds have been recommended or
items for which funding is specifically reduced as shown in the
tables detailing Committee Recommended Adjustments or in
paragraphs using the phrase ``only for'' or ``only to'' are
congressional special interest items for the purpose of the
Base for Reprogramming (DD Form 1414). Each of these items must
be carried on the DD Form 1414 at the stated amount, as
specifically addressed elsewhere in this report. In addition,
section 8006 of this act provides direction on the treatment of
increases which appear in the tables of the Committee
Recommended Adjustments, including certain limitations on the
use of reprogramming authority in relation to these items.
Committee Initiatives
The Committee reaffirms the importance of resourcing the
U.S. defense strategy, military capabilities, and the defense
industrial base to meet the increased challenge of strategic
competition with China, as outlined in the 2022 National
Defense Strategy and its predecessor, the 2018 National Defense
Strategy. The Committee is encouraged to see continued
investments in modern capabilities appropriately tailored for
the changing nature of warfare. Further, many investments
designed to bolster the United States' ability to compete with
China support broader strategic objectives, including
reassuring allies and partners and enhancing deterrence vis-a-
vis Russia.
In its review of the budget request, the Committee
recommends fully funding those programs and initiatives that
support the efforts outlined above, to include multi-year
procurement acquisitions of weapons and nuclear modernization
programs. Further, the Committee identified and recommends
targeted increases for key areas of investment, both at
combatant commands, as well as in support of the Department's
enabling capabilities that are integral to equipping and
managing a more capable force. As detailed elsewhere in this
report, these congressional special interest items include, but
are not limited to:
--$534,000,000 to improve deterrence posture in INDOPACOM;
--$293,500,000 to improve domain awareness for U.S. homeland
defense and U.S. Northern Command;
--$400,000,000 for the United States Africa Command and the
United States Southern Command to expand cooperation,
share information, to train and ultimately improve the
abilities of our partner nations in their specific
areas of responsibility;
--$200,000,000 to increase domestic defense manufacturing
readiness;
--$200,000,000 for the U.S. National Defense Stockpile;
--$141,000,000 to implement the recommendation of the
National Security Commission on Artificial
Intelligence;
--$90,000,000 to accelerate cybersecurity enhancements
through the implementation of Zero Trust Architecture
on DOD networks;
--$200,000,000 to improve defense acquisition oversight,
contracting and execution;
--$145,000,000 to expand military service recruiting
initiatives to address end-strength shortfalls;
--$129,000,000 for National Guard counter-drug activities,
including efforts to counter the scourge of fentanyl;
--$10,000,000 to improve insider threat detection; and
--$1,700,000,000 to address facility infrastructure repairs
and upgrades across the military services.
ADDITIONAL EMERGENCY APPROPRIATIONS
The Committee recommendation includes $8,000,000,000 in
additional emergency appropriations to address further,
pressing national security challenges and shortfalls in
military preparedness, including: $2,000,000,000 for unfunded
requirements of the military services and Combatant Commands,
as detailed elsewhere in this report; $1,900,000,000 to
increase military readiness, as detailed elsewhere in this
report; $1,500,000,000 to address increased acquisition program
costs stemming from inflation or other changes in economic
assumptions; $1,100,000,000 to replace Department of Defense
stocks upon the exercise of Presidential Drawdown Authority for
Taiwan authorized in the James M. Inhofe National Defense
Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023 (Public Law 117-263);
$1,000,000,000 to address high priority defense industrial base
capacity shortfalls and promote resilience in associated supply
chains and workforces; and $500,000,000 to address anticipated
fuel funding shortfalls in fiscal year 2024.
The Committee notes that recommending these funds for
inclusion in the Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2024
does not preclude the Committee from making additional
emergency supplemental recommendations at a later time based on
the Department's needs, particularly as relates to continuing
support for Ukraine and Taiwan.
Multi-year Procurement Contracts for Critical Munitions
In fiscal year 2023, the Committee urged the Department of
Defense to exercise greater use of multi-year procurement
contracts for critical munitions in order to increase the
Department's stocks of such munitions, improve warfighting
readiness, provide the defense industrial base with predictable
production opportunities and firm contractual commitments,
ensure consistent funding across the Department's Future Years
Defense Program, increase and expand defense industrial
capacity, and coordinate the timing and funding for capital
expenditures with defense contractors. The Committee notes that
the fiscal year 2024 President's budget requests this authority
for seven weapons programs. The Committee recommends providing
this authority for all requested programs with sufficient
funding to allow the Department to negotiate those proposed
agreements and associated economic order quantities to ensure
timely delivery of weapons at reduced costs. However, the
Committee notes that in some cases, the Department is
requesting funding to increase production capacity well above
what is required by the proposed multi-year contract without
firm private sector co-investment commitments. The Committee
notes that this is inconsistent with other long-term
acquisition programs.
The Committee believes that greater and more consistent
industry co-investment is warranted to more equitably share
both the costs and benefits of stable, multi-year procurement
contracts. The Committee notes that one of the production lines
for which multi-year procurement authority is requested
established its current capacity entirely with private industry
investment, another was established through a fifty-fifty cost
share, and another had no industry investment. Accordingly, in
light of such disparities in funding strategies, and to
encourage greater industry co-investment, the Committee
recommends adjustments to facilitization investments.
The Committee directs the Department to negotiate multi-
year procurement contracts which yield unit cost savings
commensurate with the stabilizing effect of economic order
quantities, and industry commitments in facilitization with a
particular focus on subcontractors in line with best practices
including the ongoing approach to the VIRGINIA and COLUMBIA-
class, as well as other shipbuilding programs. The Committee
further directs the Secretary of Defense to provide reports on
each munitions multi-year procurement award on a semi-annual
basis until all such munitions have been delivered, to include
projected and realized cost savings; impact of government and
industry investment on capacity and associated supply chain,
identifying potential risks and weaknesses; and analysis of
whether the multi-year procurement has created stability in the
supply chain.
Homeland Defense Capability Acceleration
As detailed at a Committee briefing on February 9, 2023,
the Committee is concerned by the incursion into U.S. airspace
of a high altitude surveillance balloon from the People's
Republic of China in January and February 2023. It is
imperative to ensure homeland defense systems are fully capable
to provide situational awareness so similar incidents do not
occur in the future. Recognizing the critical role of the Over-
the-Horizon Radar [OTHR] program in detecting airborne and
surface targets of interest, the Committee recommends an
additional $55,000,000 over the fiscal year 2024 President's
budget request to procure a testbed to integrate OTHR with
space-based sensors. The Committee also recommends an
additional $211,500,000 over the fiscal year 2024 President's
budget request to acquire three additional radars for the
Three-Dimensional Expeditionary Long Range Radar program.
Finally, the Committee recommends a total of $27,000,000 for
the ARCHER program. These additions fully fund the top three
unfunded priorities of U.S. Northern Command. The Committee
encourages the Department to act expeditiously in executing
these improvements to homeland defense networks.
Artificial Intelligence
The Committee is supportive of efforts by the Department of
Defense [DOD] to develop clear policies and governance
structures for the ethical use of artificial intelligence, to
strengthen its internal technical expertise, and to leverage
the benefits of artificial intelligence for more effective
outcomes in support of the National defense. The Committee
notes that the Department of Defense established the Chief
Digital and Artificial Intelligence Office [CDAO] in February
2022 to break down stovepipes within the DOD, and provide a
common policy and technical foundation for the Office of the
Secretary of Defense, the military services, combatant
commands, and defense agencies. The Committee remains
supportive of the CDAO and sees its maturation as a key enabler
to further adoption of artificial intelligence throughout the
Department of Defense.
The Committee makes two recommendations to accelerate the
Department's artificial intelligence work in fiscal year 2024
and transparently structure spending within the CDAO. First,
the Committee recommends the creation of a new Program Element,
Alpha-1, accelerating the CDAO's development of a new
enterprise capability that enables DOD entities to responsibly
develop and deploy AI/ML capabilities. Recognizing that the
development of artificial intelligence capabilities across the
Department is an inherently decentralized task requiring
implementation within the military services, combatant
commands, and other DOD entities, Alpha-1 is intended to
centrally offer best-of-breed capabilities through an
enterprise pipeline, empowering DOD users to better utilize
existing data and reduce technical risk.
Therefore, the Committee recommends the realignment of
$172,723,000 of requested CDAO resources to support the
creation of Alpha-1, and recommends an increase of $50,000,000
to create an autonomy enterprise platform. Additionally, as a
component of the creation of a new Program Element for Joint
All-Domain Command and Control [JADC2], the Committee
recommends the realignment of $235,287,000 of resources
requested by the CDAO for the purposes of JADC2 to the JADC2
Program Element. The Committee notes the inclusion of
additional language on this matter elsewhere in this report.
Further, the Committee recommends an additional $141,000,000
for implementation of National Security Commission on
Artificial Intelligence recommendations at DARPA, as well as
other targeted increases elsewhere in the Department.